ML20081B558
| ML20081B558 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Wolf Creek  |
| Issue date: | 03/06/1984 |
| From: | Koester G KANSAS GAS & ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| KMLNRC-84-026, KMLNRC-84-26, NUDOCS 8403090225 | |
| Download: ML20081B558 (5) | |
Text
KANSAS GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
+
THE ELECTFMC COMPANY CLENN L NOESTER v<t PerssIOENT - touCLE AR March 6, 1984 Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 KMLNRC 84-026 Re:
Docket No. STN 50-482 Subj: Operating Shift Experience
Dear Mr. Denton:
The Utility Group on Operating Shift Experience met with the NRC Commissioners and Staff on February 24, 1984, to propose a method for evaluating the shift experience base at a nuclear power plant.
Attached for your information are two sets of experience tables for the Wolf Creek Generating Station that were developed using the experience categories, weighting factors and maximum time credits proposed by the Utility Group. The first set of tables contains the experience base as of today and the second set contains what is expected at the time of fuel load in August, 1984.
Yours very truly, f//$
GLK :bb Attach cc: HThompson, w/a PO'Connor (2), w/a WSchum, w/a JCollins, w/a 8403090221. 840306 PDRADOCK05000g
,i v
\\
\\
201 N. Market - W7ctita, Kansas - Mah Address: RO. Box 208 I Wichita, Kansas 67201 - Telephone:la sa Code (316) 261-6451
.Y.
e.
L t.
l{-
DATE 3/6/84 PLANT NAME Wolf Creek Generatirvi Station OPrRATitr. Stif rT EXPrRIFMT tfTi ttTy 1(ansas Gas & Electric Co.
(As of 3-1-84)
. inn Tirs.r i Control Room Operators O*b* D^IE NLICLEAR PrWI:ll Pl. ANT FXPERIFNCE FOR Ort:RATINri SillFT crtSILinn1_(HerrE,ll FNTFD tiATA:
MONTilS/Mnatttts X trErcitTgggg; FACTOR 3
NEtCHilNG MAXfpHiM TYPE OF EXPERIT9;CE F Ae 'Te tH CDI fil T 1
2 3
4 S
O 1
0 9
- 3. SAME TYPE Creett.RCFTL SRO l.04 Nel f.lMlf i
I
SAffE TYPE COMMERCI AL 90 1.00 NO ( tttt?
~
- 4. OTIIER COMMFRCIAL PO H.7%
Nrt L1 HIT S. NAVY (MILITARY) NtfCLF.AR M Mritt11t'l e
(RO. ens. tooN, rPNS) n.so et/as {
~
1/8k 4*/a s (OTHER:
61,g3.3 3 /s3 52/s3 si/g j ss/s}
u./q p g,
. 2s is 4 12 rewarisS 1, *4 1 4 A. SIMutATnR a
(405t'RFNCE PLANT)
- e. G S (12 tWWTHS)
~
A /21
$!8 I
I 1.80 (9 Mitslie' )
3l/1 I} [i 3'
j
/q 3 /g 3 [g
/j 3f[9 e
( S I MI t.A R) 4
+
- 7. NUCLFAR Pt.Ar37 EXPERIFNCE fill $fifFT (tWN Pl.ANF) 24 Mrtliff'i gjg g/9
[g/g (28 3 %
II!S II!$
'/s II/1 (LESS TffAN I 1/2 YEAFS PRIOR TO F.I..)
R 7%
(12 t*W1HS) l (MORE THAN I t/7 YEARS PRf nR TfD f.L.)
- 89. '.0 (Il etwirlf t)
g ee/g 14/is 11 /1 1/4 e, g
3 g
L l
- 4. LICF.NSED CLASSROnM TRAINING AND EXAM H.54 9 TWWITH%
j (OWre PLANT) 3 Th[)
!I)
"I E
9 PARTICIPATION AT DPERATING Pl. ANT p. V.
12 PWWTit*1 10 OTIIER NtrLEAR P!, ANT EXPERIFHCE N,2%
] 2 P9 t# Tit'l 18.CONDtib!NGLICEN$ETRAINING 0.25 9 MelN TftS
- 12. DECREE (ENGINEERING. APPLIED SCIENCE OR I
4 E3titVALENT) 12 twelTHS (RACitrLORS DrGREE) 412 twir.lifS)
( ASSnCI ATES ( EGRFE) 16 PWWlHS)
TOTAL NtCLEAR PLANT EXf* Ell! DICE:
)Wd84 3 4 Pa. N.M
$ yrf'. pg, (1,4j 34 JVr 3f se.2fr 6 M. Jy 34 es.
- :- = = - _
tro? PAnTICIPATiaW EXPERe f:NCE TIME
- 20t PNR/pr#R (NKS)
STARTUP & SHUTDONN (VES/NO) 4 PEONTilS,0N SIfIFT 4
t NOTC la SEE *It4STRI)CTIONS FOR USE OF NtM*f. EAR INWrR Pt.ArtT f KrEntr.NCE FACTORS l'stR OPERATING SitIFT PnSIT! rwa $ (e s[, APPL.f RANT $l' g.ITFCK ONE OF TifE FOI.it1NING:
Q)
NOTE 2s INCt.UDE AI.L SillFT StfrERVISORS (SS). 8HIFT SPO'S, REACTOR Ort.TsATnRS (Rn)
Shi f t salvisors must be used to satisf y the
- hot participatiort a.
AND SilIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA).
carwrlence" reqntrements of the utility plan.
i O6 shirt advi=or=-ilterobab!r be re9= ired. =t lea== ror so
=hirt=-
O c.
Ihn not plan to use whi f t aAlgors unless noma unforeseeve circ ~.-
7
= e n.
+ i s 6 e.
, ~
7
.DATJ 3/6/84 OPrmina Sunn Eure 2IENCE PLANT NAME unt e Naate r:anariting Station (AS cf 3-1-04) tFTILITT h s Gas & Electric CC,.
JOR TIT 3.Es Khlft hym i e^--
O.L. DATE 8/84 (NOTE 2)
NUCLE &ll PONER PLANT EXPE21FNCE Fct OrERAtl*F. SHIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1)
FMTER DATAs MONTHS / MONTHS X 88EIGt!TIid FACTOR Nf;IGitTING MAXIMitM
,_TTFE OF EXPERIrNCE FACTom s'Rf~DIT I
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
IS a
.75 Nil LIN!*'
- 1. SANE TYPE CUMMEstCIAL 80 1.00 NO LIMIT
- 4. OtllER COMMERCIAL 90 0.75 NO LlHIT i
S. NAVY (MILITARY) NUCLF.AR 36 MOprTIIS g
gg,f 3(,
44)J4
( ftO, EWS, ECON, PrdS) 0.50 378g &
I s
(OTNER:
0.25 va /#e n As
" 4
[g{
1 [j {
{ [2f f /I 6 SIMULATOR 12 W WTHS 3
I e
e 1
1 1 3 (RIFERENCE PLANT) 5.00 (17 MINATifS) g !2 g I!I a
a.
L S
~q/1 aj/1 3 /1 31 /1 31/1 31 1 (S rMIi.AR) n.oo (9 anmiS) 3;/q 3J[/q iz L2/g sa/9 62/1 12 / 9
- 24 ar/t 81/ 9 84/1
- 3. NUCLEAR PLAtaT EXrERIENCE On siirrT (ONN PLANr) 24 MONTHS 32,q (LESS THAN I 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO r.L.)
n.75
( 3 2 runniS i
1 2r/st M/tt 54-41 M43-(MORE THAN I 1/2 VEARS PRica TO r.L.)
s.50 (12 m WTrict lis /st 2 /1 M 2 u a n1 23/n L (ONia PLANTI
. - - - -7f[3)
Ik[3h 7ffI 7 }
7 /3
'1 !
T !3 7 !3 3'1/8 }
3 !i
- 0. LICENSED CLASSROnpl TRAINING AND EXAM 0.50 9 PWWTHS 8
8 1
l{/s)
I!/sj li/l!
1/4, l' /fl li/3I t/8 i{/s
- . PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT 0.75 12 MP4 Tits I
s 25/6f lo/nL
- 10. UTilgit UCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 P'ONTit3 II. CONDU TING LICENSE TRAININC 0.25 9 MONTilS
- 12. DECREE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVA11NT) 12 MrwrrHS
- 1 f l.
81 I 2.
82-33.
(BACHELORS DEGREE)
(12 PawatH3) 11 II
~
(ASSnCIATES DEGREE)
(6 MnNttlS) fN.
4*'h 6IF 3 k
3 T* 0"*
'Y'i 30*
TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 8 8
4W (80.
6Ve SV7jaa.
4 w 6'ges. 6W s1N. $* 6 3 f007 PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME
- 23% PNR/fyin (NKS) n STARTUP & SHUTDONN (VES/NO)
MONTHS,0N SHIFT 4
NOTE 13 SEE *INSTP9CTIONS 7.3R USE OF NUCLEAR Pf MER PIANT EXPEfitr* ICE FACTORS Fent OPERATING SalIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLICANTS)*
CitECK ONE OF THE FOLIONINGs NOTE 23 INCLUDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), SilIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) ric c r'
i ese t he y
a AND SHIFT TECilNICAL ADVISORS (STA).
b.
Shif t advisors w111 probably be required, at least for some shif ts.
O e-Oo aat Piaa to== =ha re advisore vale== so-e oaror...e. es re- -
n e aere at 4 wn.
e 4
i, ATE 3/1/02 OPr"ATInG Sisirt rX ncirNCE tLawT #AME~ M f C-8 2nerating Str. tion Elsetric Co.
- (As of 3-lf,g, Senior Reactor Oper*tOrm ursLITY r--*=
m-o.L. r> ATE 8/84 trarrE 2)
. Nticorsa rc.rR reaNT rurER rrect:
FOR Ol'E"ATINC Gl*l FT PMI TIONS (NOTE 1)
FNTrn tiATA: '
MnNTHS/MrWTitS X WEICHTING FACTOR Wi'II:llT i Ni' MAX 5 Mt'M TY M OF EXPERIFtWE FAtmtN t'WI l.tl 7 8'
2 3
4 S
0 7
'I I
- l. SAME TVPE CrW9MLRCIAL SRO l.00 NO Ltnt? -
.?. OTRER COMMTRCI AL SRO 75 NO Lint?
1 SArtE TVPE COMME:RCI AL NO
!.00 NO LIN'T
~
- 4. OTHER COMMERCIAL RO S.7%
NO Lift lT (n0. Ews, toow, erwS) n.s0 gq/gt g/g3 13/Q 5 /28
%. NAVT (MILITART) NtM*LF.A R 34 MreirHS 6
s (OTilER) 0.2%
4/N 57/84k 67 +
(RFfERFNCE PLANT) 4.00 (12 P9 tirHS)
I I I' / 1 l/zi t/2{
/2(
1/2i.
- a. SIMuLrtOR 12 evnmis gp$
Ig/q y
Jg[q. 3l[1 Jh/T (S IMi TAR) 1.04 (9 meirHS)
JJ
- 7. NuCtrAR PLANT EXPERIFNCE Off SilIFT (UNN l*f ANT) 24 MtWITfl3 g2 /q
$2/j gg/q ft/j I2[I II!T str.SS THAN 1 1/2 vrARS PalnN TO r.s )
R.7%
(12 tuerrHS) eMORE THAN 1 1/2 YEARS l'RIOR 70 F.L.)
s.%0 (12 PettiII:1) li /%'/s 26/l1
~
M/l' 2sh O
II
- e. LICENsto CLASSR0 tut TRAINIt0G AND EXAM n.50 9 theeIIIS 11 3 7hf3
[3 7k!3 I
(OHN PLANT)
^
- ~
il4t
>! A t si/it it/sk 'i Ura p f5 5' 18 8
- 9. PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PLANT R.7%
12 PRINTitS b
e
- 10. OTHEll UCLEAR PLANT EXPEll!rtiCE 0.2%
3 2 Me ttrttG
- 11. CON ING LICENSE TRAINING 0.2%
9 Niem15
- 12. DEGREE (ENCINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALFNT)
B7 PtWITHS (BACtlELORS DEGREE)
(!J PkWa rilS)
(ASSOf'I ATES DEflREE)
(6 PhWITilS) h 49,3 g g, gy,2{g. 45 f ee. ($l p4, 4yr ${M.
41,6 g, TOTAL Nt! CLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE:
1807 PAlt?ICIPATifte F.XPERIFNCE TIME o 204 PwR/greR (NKS)
STARTUP & SHttrDOWN (VES/NO)
MONTNS,000 SNIFT 4
NOTE 1:
SEE *IndSTRUCTIONS FOR USE OF NUCtJ.AR PetfER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR OPERATING Sil!FT POSITIONS (OL APPLICANTS)*
CHFCK ONE OF Tite FOLLOWING leoTE 2s INCLUDE ALL SalIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR UPERATORS (RO) h t Participation e
1 t
u an AND Sil1FT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA).
O b.
Shif t advisors will probably be required, at least for some shif ts.
O c.
I1o not P.lan to use shif t advisors unless some unforeseen cirrwe t e am a. 4 :ce.
.h
--""*e t*Tr. W '
reEnTrrR: retr 7 rXPentrNcE rt. ANT HnME m1 F tvaak cenersting Station UTIS. TT Kansa, Gan 6 Electric Co.
gg,og 3.g_g43
.lius TITLE: Control HoOm Op1r.ators r
0.L. ItATE M4 Nik t#AR BYM:R Pl. ANT EXPERirtP'f:
FOR tur.RATtra sisitT revstTfDNS (fMtf(M
$~NTlR GMTA:
MilNTHS/91rPITitS X WEICitTING FACTOR NEIr.H rItR: MAKIetUN TVTE (W l'XPERitrt*E rAr70M' CP1'blT 3
2 3
4' 0
7 8
I 30
,m I. SAME TYPE CretPtt.RCI AL SRO I.00 NO LittlT
.?.
. 75' NO t.Its t ?
1 sat 1E TYPE CletMERCI AL 110 1.00 NO LIMIT
- 4. OTHEli COMMrHCI AL P) 0.7S HO LittlT
~
- 4. NAVT (MILITARV) NtN' LEAR 16 DNelTttS 13/h as/uf ula
=
t wo. ENS, rixas. PPNS) e.s0 68/fs 08j,I
,,j,p 4 A +3
}g/15 n/Xi
- As)
(OTilER) 0.2%
$s[123 4
g a
4 SIMULATOR 12 PWWITttS f[l h
. hk
~
1 $b
- f. fy }
kg Ijgt g jg g/q 3}/i 3
3IA 3$ A 3
($
8
)
(9
- 1. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE Ota Sitil? (ONN Pl.ANF) 24 PktITilS ggfq gg/q j}/g l@
l}$
12h M
N M,
(LESS TilAN I 1/2 YEARS PRIOR 70 F.I..)
A.75 (12 fitHTilS) 1/9L W
(MORE THAN I 3/2 TEARS PRIOR TO F.L.)
R.$0
( 3 2 MiWTilS) 1
,/
gg/q {
4
- 4. LICENSED CLASSROtsi TRAINING AND EXAM e.50 9 ftwritS 7 /$
7([3f Ifbh --Ik/Q IkN ' Ik!IL U4
{ /J 7L/J (OWN PLANT)
-~
tVsi Uk
- 9. PARTICIPATitel AT OPERATING PIANT R.75 12 MiWITitS
- 13. OTilER NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIF.rV.E O. 2 *e 12 MatlTilG 1
- 31. CONDilb71NG LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MinfilS
- 32. DECREE (ENGINEERING. APPLIED SCIENCE ON
. E QU I V AI.ENT )
l 2 pu ntilS (BACHELORS DEGREE)
(12 PWeerlist (ASStiCIATES DrChrEl (6 DtWTHS) i j
TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIt'.NCEI lu kk Me 4% %h. (Ye 3]ed. j f $f H. 4VrOfM. 24 No.lNh 4 *$ pe.
Syr 4*
3)' 3 W IlOT PAkTICIPATitW ;:XPERilNft 4
TIME
- 20% PNR/rPtR (NRS) y STARTUP & SitUTDONN (YES/NO)
MONTHS ON SiltFT NOTE la SEC 'll4STRUCTIONS FOR USE OF NirlEAR IMMER r!.AJJT EXPEHirNCE FACTORS rtH4
{
OPERATING $1lIr? POSITIONS (OL APPL.IrANTS)*
CitFCK ONE OF Tile For.trWINGs MOTE 2 INCLUDE ALL SaltFT SUPERVISORS (SS), SillFT SRO's, REACTOR Ol'ERATORS (RO) t(e c
i 3
e.t t AND SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA).
y an O
b.
$ntee.a.i.or..iiipro Lir L. requir.a..t
!...t ror.o
.nsee..
O c.
Do not Pt.n t a uso.tilf t.(visor. unles. some unforeseen circee-4 ne aww ar lw i
4 h
5 1
1
-