ML20080T928

Forwards Answer to City of Philadelphia Interrogatories on Sys Interaction,Designated Discovery 28.W/exception of Three Listed Documents,Documentary Matl Responsive to Request Will Be Made Available for Insp.Related Correspondence

ML20080T928
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	02/29/1984
From:	Wetterhahn M CONNER & WETTERHAHN
To:	Bush M PHILADELPHIA, PA
Shared Package
ML20080T931	List: ML20080T928 ML20080T950
References
NUDOCS 8403020099
Download: ML20080T928 (6)

Text

fr - ,.

a'v ,7 I; L HEtJJED C0;iRESPONDENC(

3 LAW OFFICES COLKETED '

GONNER Se WETTERHAHN. P.G.

1747 PENNSYLVANI A AVEN U E. N. W.

[(,*, "j, $,"y"j[g# ,,

tonant M. M ADSB

",* WAS HINGTON. D. C. 20006 'gj {gg .j gjj l}@

INONID W.OLSOFI i- ^ 5 % ,^i * " ",*i " "

. Lf fl.E OF SEtntin -

. o , e.e ..a DOCK E TINGP*EtWP"

%, . .m. v. o . Febiuary 29, 1984 g CL, _,

Martha'W. Bush, Esq.

~

City.of Philadelphia Municipal Services Building  :

15th and JFK Boulevard  !

Philadelphia, PA 19107 In the Matter of Philadelphia Electric Company (Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 and 2)

Docket Nos. 50-352 and 50-353

-Det.r Ms. Busht Enclosed are " Applicant's Answers to the City of Philadelphia Interrogatories on Systems Interaction." This request has'been designated . Discovery 28. A copy of the answers- was made available in Philadelphia on Monday, February:27, 1984.

Three of the documents identified in response to this request are proorietary to the General Electric Company. I have enclosed a form.of " Agreement Regarding Disclcsure of Confidential . Commercial Information'," satisfactory to it which must be . executed before these documents are made available to you or your representative. If you have any questions _ regarding this proposed proprietary agreement, please give me a call.

'With the exception of these three documents, the documentary material responsive to your request will be made available for_your inspection during normal business days from - 9 :00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. at a room near Philadelphis Electric Company's headquarters. Please call Edwald Cullen, Esq. at 215/841-4273 to make specific arrangements at least one day in advance in order to gain access to the documents.

Any. copies that you wish made of this material as the result 8400020099'840229

PM 9 ADOCK 05000352 pg

+ r.-

h& Mnrthn W.sBu:ih, Ecq..

7 Fcbruary 29,.1984~ -

Page 2 i of your review should be marked and copies will be made at

~

commercial rates.

p3 Sincerely, Mark J. Wetterhahn ,

Counsel for the Applicant Enclosures i

k ';

p '-

j:

V h

(

. .u, -ita c

d

> -- m e w -, mea-, .wwe,, , .- .-,+em, ,~.e.- ,-n ,,mv- e- , +p~ry, , ,.w ..,. ,- nm,,pe.--r,-- ,-ee-- --n

v -

-r3! ,

-4 RELATED CC?.RESPONDENCE i.L ;4- t~

.-Y' UNIT'ED STATES OF M9 ERICA DOCKETED USHRC

[ ~ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSISN 4e .

'84 MR -1 A11 :38

'In~the Matteriof.

LFFICE n; gc PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY , Docket Nos. 50-362ChEl

NG'{cgg 77_ .3ggyg 7' Jd N  : 50-353 BRANCH Yx  ;-(Limer'idh- Generating Station,  :

Units l'and 2).  :

AGREEMENT REGARDING DISCLOSURE OF CONFIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INFORM ATION i

A...Phyllis A. Zitzer, (hereinafter "Signator") is the representative of Limerick Ecology Action, a' party to'the e.bove-ccptioned proceeding.

-B. Ph'iladelphia Electric Company (PECo) .has angaged General Electric Company.(GE),~a non-party:in this proceeding, to supply the nuclear steam

supply system for the Limesick Generating Station, Unit 1 and 2.

.C.  ; Philadelphia Electric Company has requested that Signator be permitted

-:to have access .to the following information:

~

1)~ -Assessment'of BWR Mitigation of ATWS,1 Volumes 1 and II,.NEDE "24222,,G.G'. Sherwood, S.L. Mather'(December, 1979).-

2) Engineering Topical Report, Scram System Reliability Analysis,

.'N2DE.21514-II and -2,'W.P. Sullivan,'T.Y. Fukushima, L.R. Youngborg (Tecember, fi976). 4

3) -Design Analysis and SAR Inputs for ATWS Performence and Standby-'

i.

Liquid Control System, Limerick l' and 2 Plants, NEDE 22042, REV. 1. G.C.

Y '

Storey,;(February,'1982).

r y- ' '

G n ",

= 4 )-

Relisbility Analysis of Alternate 3A Design for Mitigation of

~

Pr ,

pg c; , ' Anticipated Transients Without' Scram (ATWS) Events for BWR Plants,~NEDE-22157, L class 2,: S. ;Viswesyaran,' P. Tan ~(June, 1982) .-

, :t -

Y .~

p u -

w w 4

--.c -we. . ,- ~,g.,.. -, _. _

r7 ,e

Gr y

O N- '

- 'D. _GE'will make the information available to signator to inspect,

provided *.ha't tho information (hereinafter "information") will be used for-the y

limited purposes and will'be-treated in a confidential manner as provided

- below.

'i .

. E. -In consideration of tha disclosure of the information by GE,.the

^

SignatorTagrees as follows.

(1) -Signator will. inspect'the information in strict confidence and secrecy.

-(2) Signator will use the information only for preparation of testimony in connection with the existing intervenor contentions in the r

~'

above-captioned proceeding,'in cross-examinatien, and for other legitimate

.evidertiary purposes in connection with existing intervenor contentions and.

-Board questions. The information, if used :n whole or in part for any of the

above purposes - preparation of. testimony, cross-examination, and other legitimate evidentiary purposes -- shall.be subject-to paragraphs (3) anf. (4) 4

..'elow b and.sha'11 be presented only during in camera hearing ~ sessions that

. provide: protection against non-disclosure equivalent to that provided under this: Agreement.

(3). Signator will not; photocopy,-transcribe, reproduce, or discinee i-

'the information'to'any other person.or entity who has not executed this 1 Agreement..

(4): Signator will ssfeguard and hold in strict confidence the

.information.'

p % r' i.

'l!;c 1

~ *-e. -- .2 _e. .gg .

-n w-y lv

- S.

\

'-gl '.

' l(5)', Restrictions <nt disclosure contained'herein shall not apply to

'any'information or material:

. Ja. -which can be shown to have been known or used by Signator.

s.

prior to theLdate of disclosure to Signator by GE, or-i 'b. 'which either;before or--after-the date of disclosure to g Signator by Gr is lawfully disclosed to Signator by an independent third party without restriction on disc.osure v'

on behalf'of GE, or

c. which either before or after the date of the disclosure to .

Signator by.GE becomes available to the public through no

/

fault-of Signator.

Nothing in this Agreement-shall be construed as permitting Signator to

unfairly obtain.the right to use information that becomes publically known-

< through 'ari improper act or omission on their part.

-(6), Signator may not' assign this Agreement

~(7) iSignator-makes no admission an to.whether the information

-disclosed ' tar GE is, . in f act, . confidential commercial .information, but Signator In the event any tsc

~w ill. treat the:information on a. confidential basis.

regulation, rule,'or ASLB order, other administrative order,'or' judicial-ruling requires-the disclosure of the information without providing the equivalent protection accorded under this agreement, GE will have the'right to Jimmediately withdraw the.information from'Signator upon request, and Signator 1

. will promptlyl abide' by. that request.

n' .

,f'  ;$ , ,

I N

-e--.p- . q, y ay

P, -

(9) Signator will return to GE all the information at the conclesion of her use, but in no event later than the termination of har representation of Limerick Ecology Action, or uhe conclusion of the above-captioned proceeding, whichever occurs first.

e e

Date Signator CONSENTED TO:

GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY

/

BY

_