ML20080M852
| ML20080M852 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 09/28/1983 |
| From: | Strumwasser M CALIFORNIA, STATE OF |
| To: | PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC CO. |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-OL, NUDOCS 8310040288 | |
| Download: ML20080M852 (26) | |
Text
.
- f UNITED STATES OF AMERICA t NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Ogc ED BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL B_OARD . , , ,
- 83 OCT -3 All :14
)
In the Matter of ) f ~ '
) ~
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-275 ' O.L.
) 50-323 0.L.
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power ) l-Plant, Units 1 and 2) ) t
} pMED C0F2 Esp 0NDE' ICE ---
l -
GOVERNOR DEUKMEJIAN'S FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO APPLICANT'S THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES Governor George Deukmejian hereby supplements his answers to the third. set of interrogatories propounded to him by Applicant Pacific Gas and Electric Company.
INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
Identify each and every person you intend to or may call as a witness during these proceedings. As to each such witness, state:
(a) Name, occupation, occupational address and telephone number.
l (b) Whether the witness will render expert testimony.
(c) If the witness will render expert testimony,
! please list each sp+c12ic subject matter about which the witness will bo N 7c' ?d to testify.
(d) At the. tsttness will be called to give expert testimony, please list the specific qualifications of the witness that you contend would qualify the witness to give 1.
8310040288 830928 PDR ADOCK 05000 O __ -......;- - . . .
h5O3
opinion toetimony on occh cpscific cubject aatter Ebout which the witness will testify.
(e) List each and every professional article, book, or the like, if any, the witness has authored or co-authored concerning each specific subject matter set forth in your answer to 1(c) .
(f) Identify each and every document the witness will rely on to reach any opinion testimony and specifically corollate each such document (by page and paragraph number) to each specific subject matter on which the witness will render an opinic'.
(g) As to each specific subject matter identified in your answer to 1(c), identify by docket number and case name each Nuclear Regulatory Commission licensing proceeding where the witness has previously given expert testimony concerning each specific subject matter.
(h) As to each proceeding identified in your answer to 1 (g ) , please state:
(i) The date(s) the expert testimony was given.
l (ii) Whether you have a copy of the testimony given.
(iii) Whether you have a copy of the transcript covering any or all of the witness' examination and/or cross-examination for each such proceeding.
(iv) Whether you have a copy of any notes which the witness made in preparation for, or utilized during, the witness' examinatiori or cross-examination in each such proceeding.
2.
(1) As to each specific subject matter identified in your answer to 1(c), identify by docket number and court name each legal proceeding where the witness has previously given expert testimony concerning each specific subject matter.
(j) As to each proceeding identified in your answer to 1(i), please state:
(i) The date(s) the expert testimony was given.
(ii) Whether you have a copy of the transcript covering any or all of the witness' examination and/or cross-examination for each such proceeding.
(iii) Whether you have a copy of any notes which the witness made in preparation for, or utilizededuring, the witness' examination or cross-examination in each such proceeding.
(k) As to each specific subject matter identified in your answer to 1(c), iGantify committees and organizations where the witness has previously given testimony concerning each specific subject matter.
(1) As to each committee or organization identified in 1(k), please state:
(i) The date(s) the expert testimony was given.
(ii) Whether you have a copy of the testimony given.
(iii) Whether you have a copy of the transcript covering any or all of the witness' examination and/or cross-examination for each such proceeding.
(iv) Whether you have a copy of any notes which the witness made in preparation for, or utilized during, the 3.
- m. ..-.-. - _ _ _ ..
witnson' oxtmination and/cr crogo-excmination in etch such
' proceeding.
ANSWER TO INTERROGATORY NO. 1:
- 1. Richard B. Hubbard.
(a) 1723 Hamilton Avenue, Suite K, San Jose, CA 95125; (408)266-2716.
(b) Yes.
(c) General, quality assurance.
(d) See Exhibit A.
(e) See Exhibit A.
(f) To be provided in testimony.
(g) To be provided in a supplemental answer.
(h) There are copies. There are no notes.
(i) To be provided in a supplemental answer.
(j) There are copies. There are no notes.
(k) None other than those already identified.
(1) Not applicable.
- 2. George Apostolakis.
l (a) 3493 Stoner Avenue, Los Angeles 90066; (213) 825-1300.
(b) Yes.
(c) Statistics (d). See Exhibit B.
(e) See Exhibit B.
l (f) To be provided in testimony.
l l
l 4.
7-. __
(g) -Nona.
(h) Not applicable.
(i) None.
(j) Not applicable.
(k) None.
(1) Not applicable.
DATED: September 28, 1983 JOHN K. VAN DE KAMP, Attorney General of the State of California ANDREA SHERIDAN ORDIN, Chief Assistant Attorney General MICHAEL J. STRUMWASSER, Special Counsel to the Attorney General SUSAN L. DURBIN, PETER H. KAUFMAN, Deputy Attorneys General
/ -
By a Ih / M -
// MI 2iA3L J. STRUT?S.SSER Attorneys for Governor George Deukmejian
' 3580 Wilshire Boulevard Suite 800 Los Angeles, California 90010 (213) 736-2102 l
l l
5.
l
- . . . . . . . .e. . . - . . , . ~ . . . . . . . . . - . .
3..-.
. - _ - , .w , . :~. - - . . . , - - - - - - - . - . . - . , - . - . - - - - . , - - - - . . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ - - - ~ - - - - ~ - - - - - -
4 4 8 f
k EXHIBIT A 4 - - . *n . 4 * **<-. . = = .., , e ~ - - m y ~. - _ _ - -.n
_ _ - - - -n.- ..n.- . . . . . _,. ,_ __,,_ _ , , ,_ __ _____
- 9 PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF RICHARD B . HUB B ARD
. RICHARD B. H UBB ARD MHB Technical Associates 1723 Hamilton Avenue Suite K San Jose, California 95125
.(408) 266-2716 E XPE RIEN CE :
9/76 - PRESENT Vice-President - MHB Technical Associates, San Jose, California.
Founder, and Vice-President of technical consulting firm. Special-ists in independent energy assessments.for government agencies, i
particularly technical and economic evaluation of nuclear power facilities. Consultant in this capacity to. Oklahoma and Illinois Attorney Generals, Minnesota Pollution' Control Agency, German Ministry for Research and Technology, Governor of Colorado, Swedish l Energy Commission, Swedish Nuclear Inspectorate, and the U.S.
Department of Energy. Also provided s tudies and testimony for various public interes t groups including the Center for Law in the Public Interest, Los Angeles; Pu blic Law Utility Group, Baton Rouge, Louisiana; Friends of the Earth (F0E), Italy; and the Union of Concerned Scien tis ts , Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Provided testimony to the U.S. Senate / House Joint Committee on Atomic Energy, the U.S. House Committee on In terior and Insular Affairs, the California Assembly, Land Use, and Energy Committee, the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards, and the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board. Performed comprehensive risk analysis of the accident probabilities and consequence's at the Barseback Nuclear Plant for the Swedish Energy Commission and edited, as well as contributed to, the Union of Concerned Scientis t's technical review of the NRC's Reactor Saf ety S tudy (WASH-1400).
2/76 - 9/76 Consultant, Project Survival, Palo Alto, California.
Volunteer work on Nuclear Saf eguards Initiative campaigns in Cali-fornia, Oregon, Washington, Arizona, and Colorado. Numerous presentations on nuclear power and alternative energy options to civic, government, and college groups. Also 'res ource person f or public service presentations on radio and television.
=
1
- j. -
..m---.___. _ _. .. ,._... . , ,
a.we
5/75 - 1/76 Manager - Quality Assurance Section. Nuclear Energy Control and Instrumentation De p a r tma n t , General Electric Company, San Jose, California.
Report to the Department General Manager. Develop and' implement quality plans, programs, methods, and equipment which assure that products produced by the Department meet quality requirements as defined in NRC regulation 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, ASME B oiler and Pressure %ssel Code, customer contracts, and GE Corporate policies and procedures. Product areas include radiation sensors, reactor vessel internals, fuel handling and servicing tools, nuclear plant control and protection instrumentation systems, and nuclear steam
' supply and Balance of Plant control room panels. Responsible for approximately 45 exempt personnel, 22 non-exempt personnel, and 129 h surly personnel with an expense budget of nearly 4 million dollt.rs and equipment inves tment budget of approximately 1.2 million dollars.
11/71 -
5/75 Manager - Quality Assurance S'ubsection, Manufacturing Section of Atomic Power Equipment Department, General Electric Company, San Jose, California.
Report to the Manager of Manufacturing. Same functional and product responsibilities as in Engagement #1, except at a lower organizational' report level. Developed a quality system which received NRC certification in 1975. The system was also success-fully surveyed for ASME "N" and "NPT" symbol authorization in 1972 and 1975, plus ASME "U" and "S" symbol authorizations in 1975..
Responsible for from 23 to 39 exempt personnel, 7 to 14 non-exempt personnel, and 53 to 97 hourly personnel.
3/70 - 11/71 Manager - Application Engineering Subsection, Nuclear Ins trumen-tation Department, General Electric Company, San Jose, California.
- Responsible for the post order technical interface with architect engineers and power plant owners to define and schedule the instru-mentation and control sys tems for the Nuclear S team Supply and Balance of Plant portion of nuclear power generating stations.
Responsibilities included preparation of the plant instrument list with approximate-location, review of interf ace drawings to-define functional design requirements, and release of functional require-ments for detailed equipment designs. Personnel supervised included 17 engineers and 5 non-exempt personnel.
.n o . , . . . , - . , . , , . - ~ - . . . , - - ,
12/69 - 3/70 Chairman - Equipment Room Task Force, Nuclear Instrumentation Department, General Electric Company, San Jose, California.
Responsible for a special task force reporting to the Department General Manager to define methods to improve the quality and reduce the installation time and cost.of nuclear power' plant control rooms . Study resulted in the conception of a factory-fabricated control room consisting of signal conditioning and operator control panels mounted on modular floor sections which are completely assembled in the factory and thoroughly tested for proper operation of interacting devices. Personnel supervised included 10 exempt personnel.
12/65 - 12/69 Manager - Proposal Engineering Subsection, Nuclear Instrumentation Department, General Electric Company, San Jose, California.
Responsible for the application of instrumentation systems for nuclear power reactors during the proposal and pre-order period.
Responsible for technical review of bid specifications, preparation of technical bid clarifications and exceptions, definition of material list for cos t estimating, and the "as sold" review of contracts prior to turnover to Application Engineering. Personnel supervised varied from 2 to 9 engineers.
8/64 - 12/65 Sales Engineer, Nuclear Electronics B us ine s s Section of Atomic j
Power Equipment Department, General Electric Company, San Jose, California.
Responsible for the bid review, contract negotiation, and sale of ins trumentation sys tems and components for nuclear power plants, test reactors,-and radiation hot cells. Also responsible for j industrial sales of radiation sensing systems for measurement of chemical properties, level, and density.
10/61 - 8/64 Application Engineer, Low Voltage Switchgear Department, General Electric Company, Philadelphia, P ennsy lv ani a .
Responsible for the application and design of advanced diode and silicon-controlled rectifier constant voltage DC power systems and variable voltage DC power systems for indus trial applications .
Designed, followed manuf acturing and personally tested an advanced SCR power supply for product introduction at the Iron and S teel Show'.
P ro j ec't Engineer for a DC power system for an aluminum pot line sold to Anaconda beginning at the 161KV switchyard and encompassing all
- the equipment to convert the power to 700 volts DC at 160,000 amperes.
i l
t -- _~.
7.,. , , _
9/60 - 10/61 CE Rotational Training Program t
Four-3-month assignments on the CE Rotational Training Program for. college technical graduates as follows:
- a. Installation and Service Eng. - Detroit, Michigan.
Installation and startup testing of the world's largest automated hot s trip s teel mill.
- b. Tester - Industry Control - Roanoke, Virginia.
Factory testing of control panels for control of steel, paper, pulp, and utility mills and power plants.
- c. Engineer - Light Military Electronics - Johnson City, New York.
Design of ground support equipment for testing the auto pilo ts on the F-105.
- d. Sales Engineer - Morrison, Illin o is .
Sale of appliance controls including range timers and refrigerator cold controls.
EDUCATION:
Bachelor of Science Electrical Engineering, University of Arizona, 1960.
Mas ter of Business Administration, University of Santa Clara, 1969.
PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATION:
l Regis tered Quality Engineer, License No. QU805, S tate of California.
L Member of Subcommittee 8 of the Nuclear Power Engineering Committee j of the IEEE Power Engineering Society responsible for the prepara-tion and revision of the following 3 national Q. A. Standards:
- a. IEEE 498 ( ANSI N4 5.2.16) : Requirements for the Calibration and Control of Measuring And Test Equipment used in the Construction and Maintenance of Nuclear Power Generating S tations .
L
._g----. . . . _
, _ . - , . - _ _ ~ . . _ ~ _ _ _ . , . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . __ _ . _ _ _ , ,,_ _ , , ,_ ._, .. . _ _ _ . , _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _
, PROFESSIONAL AFFILI ATION: ( Con td)
- b. IEEE 336 (ANSI N45.2.4): Installation, Inspection, and Testing Requirements for Class lE Instrumentation and Electric Equipment at Nuclear Power Generating S tations.
t
- c. IEEE 467 : Quality Assurance Program Requirements for the Design and Manufacture of Class 1
-IE Instrumentation and lectric Equipment for Nuclear
- Po'wer Generating S tations .
I am currently a member of the IEEE Ad hoc Committee which recommended the issues to be addressed in the development of a
! standard relating to the selection and utilization of replace-I ment parts for Class IE equipment during the construction and operation phase. I am also a member of the work group which will prepare this proposed standard.
PERS ONAL DATA:
Birth Date: 7/08/37 Married; three children Health: Excellent I
P UBLI C ATIONS AND TESTIMONY:
! 1. In-Core System Provides Continuous Flux Map of Reactor Cores, R .B . Hubba rd and C.E. Foreman, Power, November, 1967.
I j 2. Quality Assurance: Providing It, Proving It, R .B . Hubbard, p Power, May, 1972.
- 3. Tes timony o f R.B . Hubbard, D.G. B ridenbaugh, and G.C. Minor before the United S tates Congress, Joint Committee on Atomic Energy, February 18, 1976, Washington, DC. (Published by the Union of Concerned S cientis ts , Cambridge, Massachusetts.)
Excerpts from testimony published in Quote Without Comment, Chemtech, May, 1976.
4 Tes timony of R.B . Hubbard, D.G. B ridenbaugh, and G.C. Minor to the California S tate Assembly Committee on Resources, Land Use, and Energy, Sacramento, California, March 8, 1976.
l
~
S. Testimony of R. B. Hubbard and G.C. Minor before California S tate Senate Committee on Public Utilities, Transit, and Energy, Sacramento, California, March 23, 1976.
- 6. Tes timony or R.B . Hubbard and G.C. Minor, Jddicial Hearings Regarding Grafenrheinfeld Nuclear Plant, March 16 & 17, 1977, Wurzburg, Germany.
l
= ee i----4,+g-- %.,3= * - ~ ~
6
9 PUBLICATIONS AND TESTIMONY : (Contd)
- 17. Tes timony Hof R.B . Hubbard to United States House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Energy and the Environ-ment, June 30, 1977, Washington, DC, entitled, Effectiveness of NRC Regulations - Modifications to Diablo Canyon Nuclear Units.
- 8. Testimony of R.B. Hubbard to the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards, August 12, 1977, Washington, DC, entitled, Risk Uncertainty Due to Deficiencies in Diablo Canyon Quality Assurance Program and Failure to Implement Current NRC Practices.
- 9. The Risks of Nuclear Power Reactors: A Review of the NRC Reactor Safety Study WASH-1400, Kendall, et al, edited by R.B.
Hubbard and G.C. Minor for the Union of Concerned Scientis ts, August, 1977.
- 10. Swedish Reactor Saf ety Study: BarsebEck Risk Assessment, MHB Technicel Associates, January 1978 (Published by Swedish Depart-ment of Industry as Document DSI 1978:1).
- 11. Testimony of R.B. Hubbard before the Energy Facility Siting Council, March 31, 1978, in the matter of Pebble Springs Nuclear Power Plant, Risk Assessment: Pebble Springs Nuclear Plant, Portland, Oregon.
- 12. - Presen ta tion by R.B . Hubbard before the Federal Ministry for Research and Technology (BMFT), August 31 and September 1, 1978, Meeting on Reactor Safety Research, Risk Analysis, Bonn, Germany.
- 13. Testimony by R.B. Hubbard, D.G. Bridenbaugh, and G.C. Minor before the Atomic Saf ety and Licensing Board, September 25, 1978, in the matter of the Black Fox Nuclear Power S tation Cons truction Permit hearings, Tulsa, Oklahoma.
l l 14. Testimony of R.B. Hubbard before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, November 17, 1978, in the matter of Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant Operating License Hearings, Operating Basis Earth-quake and Seismic Reanalysis of Structures, Systems, and Com-ponents, Avila Beach, California.
- 15. Testimony of R.B. Hubbard and D.G. Bridenbaugh befor( he Louisiana Public Service Commission, November 19, 197t, Nuclear Plant and Power Generation Costs, Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
- 16. Testimony of R.B. Hubbard before the California Legislature, Subcommittee on Energy, Los Angeles, April 12, 1979.
l l
< _. ,___m_ -. _ - - - ~. - - ~ " ' "
l PUBLICATIONS AND TESTIMONY: (Contd)
- 17. Testimony of R.B. Hubbard and G.C. Minor before the Federal Trade Commission, on behalf of the Union of Concerned S cien tis ts , Standards and Certification Proposed Rule 16 CFR Part 457, May 18, 1979.
- 18. ALO-62, Improving the Safety of LWR Power Plants, MF.B Technical
, Associates, prepared for U.S. Department of Energy, Sandia i
National Laboratories, September, 1979, available from NTIS.
- 19. Tes timony by R.B . Hubbard before the Arizona State Legislature, Special Inter 2m House Committee on Atomic Energy, Overview of
' Nuclear Safety, Phoenix, AZ, September 20, 1979.
I i 20. "The Role of the Technical Consultant," Practising Law lesti-tuterprogram on " Nuclear Litigation," New York City and Chicago, November, 1979. Available from PLI, New Yo,rk City.
- 21. Uncertainty in Nuclear Risk Aasessment Methodology, NHB Technical Associates, January, 1980, prepared for and available from the l Swedish Nuclear Power Inspectc rate, Stockholm, Sweden.
+
- 22. Italian Reactor Safety Study: Caorso Risk Assessment, NHB Technical Associates, March, 1980, prepared for and available from Friends of the Earth, Rome, I t aly .
- 23. Development of S tudy Plans: Safety Assessment of Monticello and Prairie Island Nuclear S tations , MHB Technical Associates, August, 1980, prepared for and available from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.
- 24. Affidavit of Richard B. Hubbard and Gregory C. Minor before the Illinois Commerce Commission, In the Matter of an Investi-gation of the Plant Construction Program of the Commonwealth Edison Company, prepared for the League of Woman Voters of Rockford, Illinois, November 12, 1980, ICC Case No. 78-0646.
- 25. Systems Interaction and Single Failure Criterion, MHB Tech-nical 1981 pre for and from Associates, the Swedish Januaryfower inspeSared il Nuclear to ra t e, S tock$olm,able Sweden.
26.- Summary'of~ Emergency Response Planning Criteria for Regional and Local Authorities Near Nuclear Electric Cenerating Stations, MHB Technical Associates, June, 1981, prepared for and available 1
from Friends of the Earth, Rome, Italy.
- 27. Economic Assessment: Ownership Interest In Palo Verde Nuclear Station, September 11, 1981, prepared for and available from the City of Riverside, California.
g , *
, _ [ U 1171 *'
,
- 15 T ^~ . - - . , * - . , _ . - . - . - - , . - ~ , . - . ~ . . - - .
+ . .
PUBLICATIONS AND TESTIMONY: (Contd)
~
- 28. Systems Interaction and Single Failure Criterion: Phase II Report, MHB Technical Associates, December, 1981, prepared for and available from the Swedish Nuclear Power Inspectorate, Stockholm, Sweden.
- 29. Testimony of Richard Hubbard and Gregory Minor on Emergency Response Planning, Diablo Canyon operating license hearings before ASLB, January 11, 1982.
. 30. Statement of Richard Hubbard before the U .S . House Sub-committee on Energy and Environment concerning QA program breakdowns, November 19, 1981.
- 31. Testimony of Richard Hubbard on Quality Assurance, South
. Texas operating-license hearing before ASLB, prefiled June, 1981.
[ 32. Testimony of R. B. Hubbard, G. C. Minor, M.W. Goldsmith, S. J. Harwood on behalf of Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding Contention 7B, Systems Classification and Interaction,
' April 13, 1982.
l 33. Testimony of R. B=. Hubbard and D. G. Bridenbaugh, in the
- matter of Jersey Central Power and Light Company For An Increase in Rates for Electrical Service, on behalf of
, New Jersey Department of the Public Advocate, Div is io n of Rate Counsel, Three Mile Island Units 1 & 2, Cleanup and Modification Programs, May, 1982.
- 34. Testimony of R. B. Hubbard and G. C. Minor on behalf of
, Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and Licensing i
Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1,.regarding __ Suffolk County Contention 27 and SOC Contention 3, Post-Accident Monitoring, May 25, 1982.
l 35. Testimony of R. B. Hubbard on behalf of Suffolk County, before
~
the ' Atomic Saf ety and Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit'1, -
regarding Suffolk County Contentions 12, 13, 14, and 15, Quality Assurance / Quality Control, June 29, 1982.
5 t
i 4
,,~-[ _
, , . , , , ,,p. , _ . . , . , -,,,,m_._r,mm.. ., ,%,,s ,, ,.-,yy,,,,p,,, .,,,.y., _ . , . , ,
f O
e i.
O 1
I r
t h
EXHIBIT B
- ~ - - - - - - . . . _ *"
' * - - - ' ~ , _
" '"i g
-v v 3
P I
i CURRICULUM VITAE CEORGE APOSTOLAKIS Date of Birth: April 7, 1946 Place of Birth: Greece Citizenship: USA Address: 5532 Boelter Hall University of California Los Angeles, CA 90024 Tel: ( 213) 825-1300 (213) 825-2792 EDUCATION Diploma, Electrical Engineering National Technical University Athens, Greece, June, 1969 M.S., Engineering Science California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California June 1970 Ph.D., Engineering Science California Institute of Technology, and Applied Mathematics Pasadena, California June 1973
- 1. .
e m P -- , , , ~ - - . , _ . , . . . _ . _-
POSITIONSjiEI.!J Postdoctoral Scholar June 1973 - 1974 Assistant Professor July 1974 - June 1979 Associate Professor July 1979 - June 1983 Professor July 1983 - Present Scheol of Engineering and Applied Science Ur,versity of California, Los Angeles
_ HONORS AND SPECIAL RECOGNITION RECEIVED Mark Mills Award, American Nuclear Society 1974 Effective. Teaching Award, School of Engineering and Applied Science, UCLA 1977 Listed in Who's Who in the West 1980 MEMBERSHIP J.N SCHOLARLY SOCIETIES American Nuclear Society Society of Risk AncIysis CONSULTING ACTIVITIES U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Member of Research Review (1977-1978): Group, Probabilistic Analysis Staff.
Lawrence Livermore National Seismic Safety Margins Laboratory (1978-1982): Research Program.
Sandia National Laboratories Risk Methodology for (1979-1980): Geologic Disposal of Radioactive Waste.
Bechtel Power Corporation Probabilistic Risk (1980-present): Analysis USNRC/ Lawrence Livermore Member, Peer Review Panel.
National Laboratory Load Combination Program (1980-1982):
2.
- _ ~ .. . _.
Pickard, Love and Garrick, Inc. Probabilistic Risk Analysis (1977-present): of the Oyster Creek.
Zion, Indian Point, Browns Ferry and Midland Nuclear Generating Stations; Principal Responsibilities:
methodology, data analysis and fire risk assessment; Indian Point Hearings; Member of the Technical Review Board, Seabrook Probabilistic Safety Study.
CONFERENCES AND SHORT COURSES Assistant Technical Program 1978 Chairman, International Topical Meeting on Probabilistic Nuclear Reactor Safety, Newport Beach, California George Washington University, 1977-1981 Short Course on " Applications of Risk Analysis", Washington, D.C. ,
Berlin, Buenos Aires Short Course on Reliability, 1978
! Electric Power Research Institute I Advanced Seminar on Risk from 1978-1979 Industrial at: ivities, Euratom Nuclear Research Center, Ispra, Italy Pickard, Love and Garrick, Inc. , 1979-1980 Short Courses on Probabilistic Risk Analysis, Southern Company Services, Boston Edison Co.
Panelist, Panel Discussion on 1983 Probabilistic Risk Assessment, 7th International Conference on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology, Chicago, IL l
3.
EDITORIAL SERVICES R SCHOLARLY PUBLICATIONS Reviewer:
Nuclear Safety 1977 - Present Nuclear Science and Engineering 1979 - Present IEEE Transactions on Reliability 1980 - Present AIchE Journal 1977 - Present Book Review, " Reliability of 1977 Nuclear Power Plants" for Nuclear Technology Risk Analysis 1981 - Present .
Reliability Engineering 1982 - Present BOOKS C. Apostolakis, S. Carribba and G. Volta, Editors, Synthesis and Analysis Methods fcy; Safety and Reliability Studies, Plenum Press, 1980.
C. Apostolskis, " Bayesian Methods in Risk Assessment", in: Advances igt Nuclear Science and Technology, J. Lewins and M. Becker, Editors, Volume 13, Plenum Press, 1981.
PAPERS Apostolakis, George E. , "An Analytical Estimate of the Error in Conven-tional Point Kinetics Reactivity Due to Spatial Effects", Nuclear Sci-l ence and Engineerina, 53:141-152, February 1974.
Hsich, T., Okrent, D., and Apostolakis, C.E., "On the Average Probabil-ity Distribution of Peak Ground Acceleration in the U.S. Continent Due to Strong Earthquakes", Annals pf Nuclear _Eneray, 2:615-624, December 1975.
Apostolakis, George E. , "The Effect of a Certain Class of Potential Com-
- mon Mode Failures on the Reliability of Redundant Systems", Nuclear i Engineering Jgy! Design, 36
- 123-133, January 1976. _
Apostolakis, George, and Lee, Yum Tong, " Methods for the Estimation of Confidence Bounds for the Top-Event Unavailability of Fault Trees, Nuclear _ Engineering and Desita, 41:411-419, May 1977.
j- .
4.
. . , . - $ -- - r g,.__..-.p___.-- - ,,,-.,,-.a-.cm_,__- _,.r. , , . . . ~ , , , _ , . * ...,,_, - , - - _ . _ , - . , _ _ . , , .
Wu, J.S. , Salem, S.L. , and Apostolakis, C.E. , "The Use of Decision l Tables in the Systematic Construction of Fault Trees", International Conference set Nuclear Systems, Reliability Engineering and Risk Assess-ggql, Gatlinburg, Tennessee, June 20-24, 1977.
Apostolakis,- C'.E. , and Bansal, P.P. , "Effect of Human Error on the Avai-1 ability of Periodically Inspected Redundant Systems", _IEEE Transactions
, En Reliability 1-26: 220-225, August 1977.
l Salem, S.L. , Apostolakis, C.E. , and Okrent, D. , "A New Methodology for the Computer-Aided Construction of Fault Trees", Annals 30[ Nuclear Enerav, 4:417-433, 1977.
Kazarians, M., and Apostolakis, G., "On the Fire Hazard in Nuclear Power '
l Plants", Nuclear Engineering jug [ Desian, 47:157-158, May 1978.
l Apostolakis, George, " Probability and Risk Assessment: The Subjectivis- '
tic Viewpoint and Some Suggestions", Nuclear Safety, 19:305-315, May-June 1978.
Apostolakis, George, and Mosleh, Ali, "A Study on the Quantification of Judgment", American Nuclear Society Topical Meeting on Probabilistic Analysis gf Nuclear Reactor Safety, Newport Beach, California, May 8-10, 1978.
Lee, Y.T. , Okrent, D. , and Apostolakis , G. , "An Evaluation of the Incre-
- mental Seismic Risk Due to the Presence of Nuclear Power Plants", Ameri-can Nuclear _ Society Topical Meeting est Probabilistic Analysis 31 Nuclear Reactor Safety, Newport Beach, California, May 8-10, 1978.
4 Chun, J., and Apostolakis, G., "On the Probability of Loss of de Power Following ac Failure in a Nuclear Power Plant", Nuclear Technolony, 40:149-158, September 1978.
Salem, S.L. , Wu, J.S. , and Apostolakis, G. , " Decision Table Development and Application to the Construction of Fault Trees", Nuclear Technolony 42:51-64, January 1979.
Apostolakis, G., and Mosleh, A., " Expert Opinion and Statistical Evi-dence: An Application to Reactor Core Melt F'equency", Nuclear Science and Entineerina, 70:135-149, May 1979.
Lee, T.Y., Okrent, D., and Apostolakis, G., "A Comparison of Background Seismic Risks and the Incremental Seismic hisk Due to Nuclear Power Plants", Nuclear Engineering apf Design, 53:141-154, June 1979.
Apos tolakis, G. , Kaplan, S. , Garrick, B.J. , and Dickter, W. , "Aseessment of the Frequency of Failure to Scram in Light Water Reactora", Nuclear safety, 20:690-705, Nov.-Dec. 1979.
Apostolakis, G. , Kaplan, S. , Garrick, B.J. , and Duphily, J.R. , " Data Specialization for Plant Specific Risk Studies", Nuclear Engineering and Design, 56:321-329, 1980.
5.
_.m.. . . _ _ _ - _ . . . .
. . - . - _ - ~- .
I Apostolakis, G., and Kazarians, M. , "The Frequency of Fires in Light Water Reactor Compartments", A,NS_/ ENS Tonical Meetina jut Thermal Reactor Safety, Knoxville, Tennessee, April 7-11, 1980.
Apostolakis, G., and Chu, T.L. , "The Unavailability of Systems under Periodic Test and Maintenance", Nuclear Techno1ory, 50:5-15, Mid-August, 1980.
Chu, T.L. , and Apostolakis, G., "Nethods for Probabilistic Analysis of l Noncoherent Fault Trees", IEEE Transactions jgt Reliability, R-29:354-l 360, December 1980.
Wu-Chien, J.S. , and Apostolakis, G. , "On Risk Aversion in Risk Accep-tance Criteria", Reliability Engineerina, 2:45-52, Jan.-March 1981.
Kaplan, S., Garrick, B.J., and Apostolakis, G., " Advances in Quantita-tive Risk Assessment: The Maturing of a Discipline", IEEE Transactions sgt Nuclear Science, NS-28:944-946, February 1981.
Apostolakis, G. , and Kaplan, S. , " Pitfalls in Risk Calculations", Relia-bility Engineerine, 2:135-145, April-June 1981.
Moieni, P., Apostolakis, G., Cummings, C.E., "On Random and Systematic Failures", Reliability Engineerinn, 2:199-219 July 1981.
Mosleh, A., Apostolakis, G., "Some Properties of Distributions Useful in the Study of Rare Events", IEEE Transactions 2n Reliability, R-31:87-94, April 1982.
Siu, N.O., Apostolskis, G., "Probabilistic Models for Cable Tray Fires".
Reliability Engineerina, 3:213-227, May 1982.
Kazarians, M., and Apostolakis, G., "Modeling Rare Events: The Frequen-cies of Fires in Nuclear Power Plants", presented at the workshop on l low-probability /high consequence risk analysis, Society for Risk Analysis, Arlington, Virginia, June 15-17, 1982.
i l Mosleh, A., and Apostolakis, G., "Models for the Usc of Expert Opin-ions", presented at the workshop on low-probability /high consequence i
risk analysis, Society for Risk Analysis, Arlington, Virginia, June 15-l 17, 1982.
Apostolakis, G., Bayesian vs. Classical Methods in Probabilistic Risk Analysis", presented at-the Symposium on Quantification oJ[ Risks:
Reducing the Uncertainties, Annual Meeting, Pacific Division, American i Association for the Advancement of Science, Section P. Industrial Sci-ence, Santa Barbara, California, June 21-22, 1982.
Apostolakis, G. , Kazarians, M. , and Bley, D.C. , " Methodology for Assess-ing the Risk from Cable Fires", Nuclear Safety, 23:391-407,' July-August, 1982.
6.
-:~ m .. , + ~ .- =w - - -
_ . = := . a .- - - - . - . - - _ - - - - . _
Apostolakis, G. , " Data Analysis in Risk Assessments", Nuclear EnRineer-ing and Desian, 71:375-381, August 1982.
Apostolakis, G., " Time-Dependent Accident Sequences", presented at the U.S.-German Joint Seminar on Structural Risk Analysis, Columbia Univer-sity, New York, May 18-20, 1983.
Mosleh, A., and Apostolakis, G., "A Method for Estimating Fragility Curves Using Expert Opinions", Paper M3/4, JtA t International Conference An Structural Mechanics ja Reactor Technolony, Chicago, Illinois, August 22-26, 1983.
Madrid, A., Apostolakis, G., and Conn, R.W., "On the Development of Accident Sequences Involving Tokamak Impurity Control Systems", Nuclear Technolofv/ Fusion, 4:1135-1140, September 1983.
e 7.
. _ . 72 L: z ... . - . :: _z:: :-.-_ . :m _ . _ _ . - . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 00CMETED-USNRC BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD 13007 -3 All :14
)
, In the Matter of ) 0Fricc 0F SECRETAe '
) DCCKLTING & Sgg<yg7g' PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-28Wd.
) 50-32 3 0.L.
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power )
Plant, Units 1 and 2) )
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this date I caused copies of the foregoing GOVERNOR DEUKMEJIAN'S FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS i TO APPLICANT'S THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES served on the following by U.S. Mail, first class (except for those persons marked with an asterisk ("*"), to whom the envelope was posted Express Mail), postage prepaid.
- Hon. Nunzio Palladino, Chairman U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H S treet, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20555 Hon. Victor Gilinsky, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H S treet, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20555 Hon. Thomas Roberts, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H S treet, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20555 i
1.
- .J =. : ::."::.:C::= * .' -. :L.. -.. :.- - ~ ..- - . - - - ,
l .
l Hon. Jemes Asselstine, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H S treet, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20555 Hon. Frederick M. Bernthal, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H S treet, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Hon. Thomas S. Moore, Chairman *
- - Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Hon. W. Reed Johnson
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washing ton, D.C. 20555 Hon. John H. Buck
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Judge ~ John F. Wolf, Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Judge Glenn O. Bright Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Judge Jerry R. Kline Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Harold Denton Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Leonard Bickwit, Esq.
Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 2.
Lawrence Chandler, Esq.
- Henry J. McGurren, Esq.
Office of Executive Legal Director BETH 042 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Attention: Docketing and Service Section Mrs. Elizabeth Apfelberg 1415 Cozadero San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 Janice E. Kerr, Esq.
Public Utilities Commission 5246 State Building 350 McAllister Street San Francisco, CA 94102 Mrs. Raye Fleming 1920 Mattie Road Shell Beach, CA 93449 Mr. Frederick Eissler Scenic Shoreline Preservation Conference, Inc.
4623 More Mesa Drive Santa Barbara, CA 93105 Gordon Silver Sandra A. Silver 1760 Alisal Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 Joel R. Reynolds, Esq.
Eric Havian, Esq.
John Phillips, Esq.
Center for Law in the Public Interest 10951 West Pico Boulevard, Third Floor Los Angeles, CA 90064 Bruce Norton, Esq.
- Norton, Burke, Berry & French 2002 East Osborn Phoenix, AZ 85064 Philip A. Crane, Jr. , Esq.
- Richard F. Locke, Esq.
Pacific Gas and Electric Company 77 Beale Street, Room 3135 l
San Francisco, CA 94106 1
3.
David S. Fleischaker, Egq.
P. O. Box 1178 Oklahoma City, OK 73101 Arthur C. Gehr, Esq.
Snell & Wilmer '
3100 Valley Bank Center Phoenix, AZ 85073 Mr. Richard B. Hubbard MHB Technical Associates 1723 Hamilton Avenue, Suite K San Jose, CA 95125 Mr. Carl Neiberger Telegram Tribune P. O. Box 112 San Luis Obispo, CA 93402 Virginia and Gordon Bruno Pecho Ranch P.O. Box 6289 Los Osos, CA 93402 Nancy Culver 192 Luneta San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 Maurice Axelrad, Esq.
- Lowenstein, Newman, Reis, & Axelrad 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036 DATED: September 28, 1983 JOHN K. VAN DE KAMP, Attorney General of the State of Cclifornia ANDREA SHERIDAN ORDIN, Chief Assistant Attorney General MICHAEL J. STRUMWASSER, Special Counsel to the Attorney General SUSAN L. DURBIN, PETER H. KAUFMAN, Deputy Attorneys General r
l l
By [ MfM$L
'l
- CHAEL J. STRUMWASSER
! Attorneys for Governor George Deukmejian 3580 Wilshire Boulevard Suite 800 Los Angeles, California 90010 (213) 736-2105
! 4.
l
.. _ : T;::r - - - : - s - ~ : - - .~; :a -- ~ - - -- . ::: - ~ T : - = . . _ . _ - - - _ . _ . - . .