ML20080G212
| ML20080G212 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 02/08/1984 |
| From: | Churchill B METROPOLITAN EDISON CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE |
| To: | Wolfe S Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| 83-491-04-OLA, 83-491-4-OLA, ISSUANCES-OLA, NUDOCS 8402130305 | |
| Download: ML20080G212 (11) | |
Text
A SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE
.3 w. - O a pas *wensw.e or maort.sionat Cceaometions r.
isoQ heSTREET N.W.
wAsMiNGTON. D. C. 20036 e-a
....m
. mae,J.a edM tQ.ae
(
^
e savsteL 1 e
ea=sa+ o mo.v's. e.C Jo** thoto.ec.
O*'*"'a"a=t=stao s 's wa nt s. a **=a C.
- c. v=oma s =.Cas us. e c.
sco**
a t==o tt= = = %. E a e co=or e voowenioot. p C.
C=aastsa ta=an *C-C
- s tu. a % c re s at=ot u= a
==et
, ' =,,, g"Yo', n Y. " '
ggTfg"a "g,U."
E C o m'E m e e,"gmo e,
oC C a Pr. a g et ai?*o*f L'i""o.'?".<".0"t.'?.O.'s"TilE?'
- "E;,R.*. a'J'E.... C' t'at'!.?, o"*rx. v.e.c trem
- z24o * * * *za 4*
- o st== mooca
.a A. - e o ~. s-n o ot==tsg.p g
-ost t.. E c
.oot
..... e r*ED a v mos Sataka eacC = a *v e? - * -
==*
- >C = amo== e mom toma6 e
so== a amentgas ote, o g af t,t #7 8. moses 8sS.
- C OtLissa a 8'oGway STE *= t = a = t.am a%es t m as twca s,
- C.
b VCE w. C=wmCassw p C.
oav'o ma mu st am att p=. 8C mapiras soo a t== t t= s =awtneam
- tances t newsCa o!sa s e[sek =s.
C' (20 2 822so72
[ot NCE et eSYN Ie se c. mma"$
vs E E **e as sa= a 17'JJ"o's "fa."~o "Wi"J'I?6.n***2""
"*"t"a'.i! Te' *
- 2;':'i.iti n 'C" **
C tammama a.
mosso'TI.
- C.
s e rr t ** 6 ' A S6om.
- C eskt= a retcru sawat =CE
- Co=t=
222.'t";*oll.:'"
~7 tit
."."c.
te??%5!.* n*1 " " '
f."!3a".i:,"ro" "a-C a
C
" " lit!E** **7t"t o' %. e it'!'?LE. "ait."isi?"
- ***-)
T:,7a3,"E L".'lrt, it','? f "J.*/'E' C.,
6 anna,.t Carta t 'a y t e. =
ovaw Lg o,g.
g o est em awotwouCm.
- C
'= Coma S a= game eseC o mm eC" Caekt Saaw6aw' g = pggge am g
ga ga.e teent s'os. Swant. Ja. S C.
g w% sam 86 Cas a as o s wo.T S
,C.a.o=t'. ae a so,m.E S
- C.
. E A.ms.t S m.eo m.o.mf.aMGt to.a.ae a
.C,B e.w o,o =.'a.4 4..'=u a.,
o o.amot.t a.
ow.
a man E.
C.
a a
t t
a t %=E'= a....c sA=t s = Synot e # C somm 6 Came.,e so=N r otak'*
amontw o Ebus
- - d
,,.o., a
- "^"? t c',^. "C". t. s.
3.:.'.'o'".i..'at"?a'*"
i,"! ?. 2.' "C i!P.v.'e
- "3M".! "^o"e!'e.
s.Co,ew.,E. s.
ea..a..s o.or.
C
......o ea
. m..
.=owa.st-ma commit 5 co'vL'et a=am arvt m,, s.onE 6u
.*C-te Cowattu aromana e C=amo a a stCate S'E vt as 6. *s t w?2E"C.
olam o awvCn. *
=owamo a Saar
=tgg wes e t e t wa se=.=o'o% u
' a.o* ao.ee s = a e February 8, 1984
...r.....te
.a
.,, eae (202) 822-1051 Sheldon J. Wolfe Administrative Judae
,pOM DCMT NUMBER Chairman, Atomic Safety and Pr OD t UTIL FAC.,... ;... 4-Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 In the Matter of Metropolitan Edison Co., et al.
(Three Mile Island Nuclear Station, Unit No.1)
Docket No. 50-200 OLA (Steam Generator Repair) 1
Dear Judge Wolfe,
We received a call from your office today informing us that Reference Documents 27, 34, 42, 47, 48, 49 and the proprietary version of Topical Report 008, Re v. 3 had not been included with the documents submitted for in camera review on f
l February 6, 1984.
We apologize for any inconvenience caused by this oversight and enclose the aforementioned documents herein.
In addition, Reference Document 18 (GPUN TDR-007) and Topical Report 008, Rev. 3 were previously submitted to the l
N.R.C. with attached letters requesting that portions of those i
documents be considered proprietary.
These requests were l
I subsequently approved by the N.R.C.
Fo r the Boa rd ' s in fo r-a.a we are including copies of Licensee's request letters and o f - -
8402130305 840'208 PDR ADOOK 05000289 D
0 PDR l
9 SHAW. PITTMAN. PoTTs & TRowCAIDGE
.we
...o,..e,c
.,et..o.ms~.
Sheldon J. Wolfe February 8, 1984 Page Tao N.R.C.'s corresponding result letters approving those requests.
Copies of these documents will also be delivered to all parties on the service list.
Finally, please note that Reference Document 34 was mistakenly included in the " List of Proprietary Reference Docilments" attached as Appendix I to the Protective Order submitted by Licensee on February 6, 1984.
This document was previously reclassified as non-proprietary.
Therefore, this document was not submitted along with the proprietary documents; and we now request the Board to delete document 34 from the List of Proprietary Documents.
Respectfully 7 submitted,
,.Me Churchill Counsel for Licensee BWC/ lcm Enclosure cc:
Service List (w/o enclosures) i y
I 9
a q
~
i d
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Saf3t7 and Licensing Board In the Matter of
)
)
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY, ET AL. )
Docket No. 50-289-OLA
~~ ~~
)
ASLBP 83-491-04-OLA (Three Mile-Island Nuclear
)
(Steam Generator Repair)
Statica, Unit No. 1)
)
SERVICE LIST Sheldon J. Wolfe Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Chairman, Atomic Safety and U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Licensing Board Washington, D.C.
20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Docketing and Service Section (3)
Washington, D.C.
20555 office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Dr. David L.
Hetrick Washington, D.C.
20555 Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Joanne Doroshow, Esq.
Professor of Nuclear Engineering Louise Bradford University of Arizona Three Mile Island Alert, Inc.
Tucson, Arizona 85271 315 Paffer Street Harrisburg, Pennsylvania l?;32 Dr. James C.
Lamb, III Adr.inistrative Judge Jane Lee Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 183 Valley Road 313 Woodhaven Road Etters, Pennsylvania 1 3;9 Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27514 Norman Aamodt L
Richard J. Rawson, Esq.
R.
D.
5, Box 428 Mary E. Wagner, Esq.
Coatesville, Pennsylvania
. ;i:3
{
Office of Executive Legal Director i
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l
Washington, D.C.
20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal j
Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Washington, D.C.
20555 i
i
Y s
GFU Nuclear Corporation
[r QJ NUCI63r
"" "'" sc =
- nocte 441 South Midcletcwn. Pennsylvania 17C!
717 944 7621 TELEX 64 2386 Writer's Direct Dial Nurnber:
Of!- 1 otstribution Sep: ember 14, 1983 AIf doML 5:11-83-256 subget:
OT5G1 TR.w-5 j0ffice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Assisn;d to: !Nks.t-
!A :n:
J. F. S:ol.:, Chief iOperating Reac: ors Branch No. 4
,ou,03:2 Division of Licensing U.S. Nuclear Regulato:7 Co= ission Washing:en, D.C.
20555 tse.
c A ins-Parsts.
w Hukill-T rl.122 X
,7x a,,g.4,,
.R. Wilesn-Parsip S t r te n-Assiin.
3:tiste-Trt.t 5 x
t Three lille Irland Nuclear Station, Uni: 1 (OfI-1)
/
cx11t
.cl.14 t
Operating License No. DPR-50 Finfrtck-Parstp.
cis nsi-T r t. 67 Docke: No. 50-289 Heward-Tarsio.
Topical Repor: 008, Rev. 3 Ku-hn-Sev.Bidt, Y.a :In s-Parsip.
X
{
Inclosed is GPUN's Topical Repor: 008, Rev. 3, " Assessment of ~MI-l Plant Newt:o-Tr:ining
'FC'7-Par 819-Safe:y for Return to Service After Steam Generator Repair",
as t_
y y
L;viNTel.197 N ]1 son-T ri. i t. 5 2.
As with Revision 2 submitted earlier, portions of this docu ent are considered Hurd-Trl.8R X
proprietary to CPUN's consul: ants.
Under :he provisions of 10 CTR
.790, we i
zee.r-Aireert request tha: you cat.tinue :o protec: :.ne proprie:a:/ sections :.ron pu lic dis-P.e s s.s rv. sie s.
crinebu ce r.eir s t closure in accordance with the affidavi: signed by J. H. Tay" or,1:anager, 3%'
g..hich was subritted with !cpical Rep::: 008, Rev. :.
? ages, para-sl:5r-Parst;.
X Liegngin$d figures containing such inic-*
d--
have been marked "- prietarv" b.
graphs a lT s
x t
w:t iora -rars t e.
x x
in the :ex: ef :he d:cu=en:.
Cross-references showing tha rel?:a-ice cf VIsh-Parsio.
prcpri'.:arv material in Revision 3 frc: tha: sh:v. in Exhibi: I cf :he Revisic.
i
~
$$'M[
N
- affidavi: is attached:
A nenproprie:ary.ers ce of Topical Ee; :: 005. Rev.
3 has a'se been enclosed fer your use'in :ublic distribu: ice.
cattns x
x EDPC-Chstrr Hill x x
overste.it ec.
- e-a
~ ~4 * ~ e ' ~ '
Arnold-Irl.118
!{#
B;rtnof f Pars a;.
s Charrv-Parsip.
g I
./
Dicckr.mp-Parsio.
Kuhns-Parstp.
\\-
'w f -
J'
~W----
i v : r re c h i- > mt.
.mirec:o r, 01: '.
% ?
' ~
.: D. \\.,. _. v.,.j e
~
n:lesures s
b.u.).MVk
[
T.rRFW#tm nP3 K.[ T&
,5 fU j oi. T ne 9-/6-fr cou Nuciear corporasn is a su:siciary c: tne Ger e abouci.: utiwes c: : at:en s
i 9
Preprietary Secticns of Topical Report OCE, P.ev. 3
?
TR. 008, Rev. 2 Affidavit TT.. OCE, Rev. 3 Section Page Se: tion Page Figere 1 A Figure 1-4 l
Section III. D & E 25-28 Section III. D 25-27 Section V.A.2 34-35 Section V.A.2 34-35 Section V.C.1 38-42 Sec-ion V.C.1 38-42 Section V.C.2 42-43 Section V.C.2 42 Section V.D.2 45-47 Section V.D.2 45 47 Section VI.C 52-53 Section VI.C
.52 i
e
- 5 8
' 6L fo a
/
'g UNITED STATES Str 0 g
NUCLEAR PEGULATORY COMMISSION s
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 October 11, 1983 Docket No. 50-289 g
21985 Mr. Henry D. Hukill Vice President GPU Nuclear Corporation P. O. Box 480 Middletown, Pennsylvania 17057
Dear Mr. Hukill:
SUBJECT:
APPLICATION FOR WITHHOLDING INFORMATION FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE By letter dated September 14, 1983, you submitted the " Assessment of TMI-l Plant Safety for Return to Service Af ter Steam Generator Repair", Topical Report 008, Revision 3.
You have requested that the infomation in certain sections and figures of the report be withheld from public disclosure pursuant to 10 CFR Section 2.790.
The withholding request is supported by affidavit signed by Mr. James H. Taylor of B&W dated March 7,1983.
Your requests to withhold earlier revisions of this report from public inspection were previously granted by HRC letter dated August 9,1983.
B&W maintains that the document contains infomation of the type customarily held in confidence by them and that such infomation is not available in open literature and is not known by potential competitors of B&W.
B&W believes that disclosure of this infomation would reduce the expenditure l
of their competitors and, tous, would harm their competitive position.
We have reviewed the application and related material based on the require-ments and criteria of 10 CFR 2.790 and have detemined that this report contains proprietary commercial infomation.
We have also found at this time that the right of the public to be fully apprised as to the bases for and effects of the proposed action does not outweigh the demonstrated concern for protection of 94W's competitive position. Accordingly, we have detemined that the applicable information should be withheld fran public disclosure.
We, therefore, approve the request for withholding pursuant to Section 2.790 of 10 CFR Part 2 and are withholding from public inspection the above mentioned document.
Withholding from public inspection shall not affect the right, if any, of persons properly and directly concerned to inspect the document. If the need arises, we may send copies of this infomation te our consult-ants working in this area. We will, of course, assure that the consult-ants have signed the appropriate agresu nts for handling proprietary data.
$~f[J fI/[
//
Mr. Henry D. Hukill If the basis for withholding this inforTaation from public inspection should change in the future such that the information could then be made available for public insp2ction, you or BAW should promptly notify the NRC.
Sincerely,
]
Ydet[
ohn/F.Stolz, Chief pefating Reactors Branch f4 OWision of Licensing ec:
See next page i
4 e
I S
J l
l l
1
~,- >
g W
my n
}g -
.?
m44 TAPR is 1983 G DU Nuclear Corporat.:r s
u- -
(d
[hj
@ jME'
..o.m
- ...c~ esc' tan'0
~
- Eie.:
A::::e::v.+..C -.s, visa -
t
- a e.
ca t,.1st s 0
ELEX $4 2365
. e s.cre:t 3.r '.. :e A ::i' 20,1953 33,3 cistributten
-3211 83-122 3#
- %tM d.
,s3ecY,*1m61 l V[.
's.k s.A baur had n
)
1 toffice of Nuclear Rcac ct Regulations iAttn:
John F. Stolz, Chief
- ""*d "*'
' Operating Reactors Branch No. 4 U. S.. Nuclear Regulatory Cc==ission
.-jp
'a n'te' Washington, D.C.
20555 t,'
i,
" ^
",ii s i s.?r t. i t :.
Dear Sir:
in g-e.1 rs t e.
s x K' vi l ex-r.ir n i r.
Three Mile Island Nuclear Station. 'Jni: A (U!!-1) r:4n-Ad:In.
Opere. ting License "o.
D?R-30 c.Infr i
Decke: No. 50-189 inrrne..r,rstp.
n2-1 Steam Generator r.epair,n,e;:::
1.w. -trt.Af (G?UN-TDR-007 Rev.1/Eli. 17 0 Rev.')
ev..ra-rarsin.
. r II x
II Enclosed for use in your revie.V of :he nn-1 S:ea. Genera::: Mpair is ptei..r.sia'""
Revision 1 cf the "Once :hrough Stes: Genera:cr Repair Kine:ie I<pansien i
x g.Techr.ical Report." Revision 0 of this reper: dated:jeve:bar1982vas
$"r'ni. N7'
- l. vin-tl.197
% $:. :sen: to you by letter dated January 20,19E: (5.1-E -Ca).
i.. l s..n-f r t.14
!...". N,5 Se:e of the inf or:a: ion in :his sub=1:tal is censidered reprie:ary te 4.s r v. s i.t.:
362 and their subcentractor Foster t.teeler Inergy /.pplica:1 ens,
.ne..
.n i...r.i r m r. i' as sucrn by J. H. Tayle.r, Manager, 367 Licensini. in his af fidan,:
'.'l.',l.N,.
presented eith Revision 0.
Pages, paragraphs, : ables and fi;uras cc:'-
m-S n. fi t 'u..
!. {
taining such info =atien have been marked ";reprie:ary in :,.e ten c,
, *...3.r.irip.
the document.
Cross-references sheving the releca:Len Of prerrie:ar7 x
l ' I'l$'N.":'n material in F.evision 1 fran *ha: isrecues:ef:;:a: 30ftheIMif^0-.
shevn in hhi 1:
. t,.
...,m.
.t-e.
for Revisien 0 is attached.
1:
- .s:.n:c=M.-.c....v(.
'" ".'::... n i i i
{
protected frc: pu'r'.ic disclesure under :he
- "M i~ns r:
3:-
x rg k
/ (
bin *Ii
~
tr. uti 1 * ". t r '* l '.
/
t L.---l.It.il.',
lsll.?r IN.~
C 7,-
LL d2.8 U
.' }.
, #.*... p. N r a i t..
()
in
'*/3(. i Y.ur'.11 j
Iete..l ifsaa.
. "... i. e. n:e. '
Iirac:e, !::I-1 HDE:'UO:vjf b-- -
Inciosures cc:
J. Yt.n " lie:
i l'V l l'. d'Lt l
I.Y u' 3:)?.
.u.. I:1. r
.Ey.g,s;.-u l
f
~
Origir.a1 Version
.evision 1 Hone Page vii Pages 1-5 through 1-10 Fages 1-5 through 1-10 Figures 1-2 and,,-8 through 1-13 Figures 1-2 and 1-8 tr.rc.;.-
1 1-10 and 1-13 Pages 2-1, 2-3 through 2-5, Pages 2-3 through 2-5, 2 '.i -hrou;h 2-11 through 2-13, 2-15 through 2-18, 2-13, 2-18, 2-20, 2-22, 2-25, 2-29.
2-20, 2-27, 2-29, 2-34 through 2-39, 2-35 thrcush 2-43, 2-4; :nr: ugh'2-!
2-41, 2-45, 2-47 through 2-49, 2-51, 2-54, 2-57, 2-58 througn 2-61, 2-53, 2-54 2-63 through 2-69 Tabla 2-4 Tables 2-4 through 2-9 Figures 2-2 through 2-12, 2-14 through Figures 2-2, 2-3, 2-5 tr.r:-gn 2 '.2, 2-17a, 2-19, 2-45, 2-46, 2-475 2 14 through 2-17, 2-175, 2-19, through 2-47f 2 44c through 2-46, 2-49 Pages 3-1 and 3-2 Pages 3-1 and 3-2 Pages 4-2 and 4-3 Page 4-2 Page 5-3 Fage 5-3
,.,_/
Page 6-2 None. '
I 1
1 4
s.
4 l
0
'O
.?
l c
\\
i
\\/
i l
l
- / '.
h{p.e.,,.'c, UNITED STATES
~
4 7
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Q
WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555
.t.
-I
,y August 9, 1983 C
J Docket No 50-289 m -t Distribution Au AjoAJA Mr. Henry D. Hukill O TS c,
- Vice President p \\g suhbsee
'GPU Nuclear Corporation
--4g p
P. O. Box 480 Middletown, Pennsylvania 17057 A;.tsnu coqAM
Dear Mr. Hukill:
Dua Dato:
SUBJECT:
APPLICATION FOR WITHHOLDING INFORMATION FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Disc.
C A
'a n s-P e rs t p.
By letter dated January 20, 1983, you submitted the "TMI-l Once-Through Steam "NffsN$...' t,
Generator Repair Xinetic Expansion Technical Report". You have requested n
s:rt:n-A a tn.
that infomation in certain sections and figures of the report be withheld from public disclosure pursuant to 10 CFR Section 2.790.
The withholding nit.re-Trt. tis x
x A
NIci'SNp.
request is supported by affidavit signed by Mr. James H. Taylor of B&W dated cienst-Trt.67 J anuary 13, 1983.
Subsequently, you submitted a revision to this report
% W -Parsip.
by letter dated April 20, 1983, supported by the same affidavit.
Kuuhn-srv.81dg.
K:::nss-P rsip.
X x
.n=cee-Training B&W maintains that the document contains infomation of the type customarily tae.--Parsio.
held in confidence by them and that such information is not available in
[',,[,i'%
open literature and is not known by potential competitors of B&W.
B&W nissn-Trt.no believes that disclosure of this infomation would reduce the expenditure Hurd-Trl.8S of their Competitors and, thus, would ham the competitive position of B&W EU'.'s^r* 'll'e *,.
and its subcontractor, Foster Wheeler.
Cre n;bst re e h rs t, We h8Ve reviewed the a# plication and related naterial based on the slear-P rsip.
x X
NC-s Ib.
requirements and criteria of 10 CFR 2.790 and have detemined that this x
x report contains proprietary commercial infomation.
sie.
x Lx.
I Vcish-Parstp.
l*$["l$[;,27 We have also found at this time that the right of the public to be fully apprised as to the bases for and effects of the proposed action c.u t as x
x does not outweigh the demonstrated concern for protection of B&o's nce-c serv wilt x x
n
!' $$$1]
competitive position.
Accordingly, we have detemined that the applicable information should be withheld from public disclosure.
', cherry-Farste.
car:nort ears e.
. ' $c'UEe.'$1p.
We, therefore, approve the request for withholding pursuant to Section 2.790 of 10 CFR Part 2 and are withholding from public inspection 9e u ns-r.esta.
verre-ht->cPst above mentioned document.
Withholding from public inspection shall not af fect the right, if a*s, cf persons properly and directly concerned to inspect the document.
I' tne need arises, we may send copies of this information to our consultaa.:s xrctrus:Q, working in this area.
We will, of course, assure that the consultaats have signed the accropriate agreements for handling croprietary cata.
m.
x
- m. : f-# - g 3 D. i jyu
p:f-s Mr. Henry D. Hekill,
If the bast or withholding this infomation from public inspection should change in
. future such that the information could then be made available for public irispection, you or B&W should promptly notify the NRC.
Sincerely, r
- j ff 7
oh F. Stolz, Chief
)
Ope ating Reactors BrancK#4 ising of Licensing cc:
See next page r
i l
r
[
e l
-