ML20080D334
| ML20080D334 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 05200001 |
| Issue date: | 12/22/1994 |
| From: | Quirk J GENERAL ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | Borchardt R NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM), Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20080D338 | List: |
| References | |
| MFN-163-94, NUDOCS 9412280096 | |
| Download: ML20080D334 (83) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:, 167. p
- r
) a GE Nucle:r Energy Generalilectoc Corrparv US Curtner Avenue, San Jose. CA 95125 December 22,1994 MFN No.163-94 Docket No. 52-001 Document Control Desk U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Attention: R.W. Borchardt, Director Standardization Project Directorate Associate Directorate for Advanced Reactors and License Renewal Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Subject:
Submittal of Revision 1 to the ABWR Design Control Document
References:
(1) R.W. Borchardt to Mr. Joseph Quirk, dated December 8,1994. (2) J.F. Quirk te Mr. Dennis Crutchfield, Submittal of Final ABWR Design Control Document, MFN No.134-94, dated October 28,1994. Enclosed is one (1) copy of the replacement pages to the subject document for the Docket Control Desk and one (1) copy for the Public Document Room. Further, in accordance with direction of NRR project staff, General Electric Nuclear Energy (GE-NE) is prmiding thirteen (13) copies of the replacement pages to the NRR recipients listed on Attachment 1. This is being done to accelerate the distribution process and ensure timely staff receipt. As requested by the Reference 1, this revision of the DCD is accompanied by a list of the currently effective pages. This list is provided as Attachment 2. Reference 1 also requested that tables of Attachment 3 of Reference 2, that submitted DCD Revision 0 for review, be updated to reflect the staffs comments and any other changes, and be resubmitted as DCD Revision 1. In addition, Reference 2 requested that GE refer to information which was removed from the DCD because it represents detailed PRA information as " Industry Initiative" as opposed to "NRC DCD Guidance". This is also provided in this transmittal as. To better keep track of the updates and other changes pertaining to Resision 0 and Revision 1, inserts into the existing table as a result of i Revision 1 have been inserted as item numbers (L11 entry) with a lettered suffix (e.g.16a). When the entry is affected by both Revision 0 and Revision 1, a combined number and number with lettered sufIix (e.g.16/16a) is used. 9412280096 941222 [g PDR ADOCK 0520 1 g gr 10A0(GA t I
-p j., O E Finally, Reference 1 requested that GE reverify all building figures in Tier 1 Sections 2.15 and 3.2 for divisional, fire, flood, and radiological boundaries at the appropriate elevations.- This reverification has been completed and, where necessary, the Tier 1 figures have been realigned consistent with the Certified Design Material. Three Tier 1 figures were upgraded. All of the DCD Revision 1 replacement changes are identified in the Page Change Instructions (Attachment 4). Sincerelyg d Joseph F. Q ' r - t Attachments cc: with enclosure w/o enclosure w/o enclosure A.J. Beard (GE) S.M. Franks (DOE) F.J. Miraglia(NRC) N.D. Fletcher (DOE) T.H. Boyce(NRC) W.H. Rasin(NEI) S.P. Frantz(Newman, S.A. Hucik(GE) R.L. Simard(NEI) i Bouknight & Edgar) F.A. Ross(DOE) R.J. Bell (NEI) M. A. Rowden(Fded, i Frank...) N.T. Patel(GE) J.N. Fox (GE) L i i i l
' i. ATI'ACHMENT 1 DIRECT SHIPMENT OF DCD REPLACEMENT PAGES TO NRR RECIPIENTS OUANITY RECIPIENT ORGANIZATION 3 RICHARD W. BORCIIARDT NRR/ADAR/PDST 1 GOUTAM BAGCHI NRR/ADT/DE/ECGB 1 CARL BERLINGER NRR/ADT/DE/EELB 1 CONRAD E. McCRACKEN NRR/ADT/DSSA/SPLB 1 ROBERTC. JONES NRR/ADT/DSSA/SRXB 1 RICIIARD J. BARRE'IT NRR/ADT/DSSA/SCSB 1 EDWARD J. BUTCHER NRR/ADT/DSSn/SPSB 1 MATTHEW CIllRAMAL NRR/ADT/DRCII/IIICB 1 MARYLEE M. SLOSSON NRR/ADT/DRCH/lillFB 1 R. LEE SPESSARD NRR/ADT/ DOTS 1 JANICE E. MOORE OGC I l l
s ATTACHMENT 2 Effective Pages of DCD as of Dec.1994 ALL PAGES IN THE DCD ARE REV. 0 EXCEPT FOR THOSE LISTED BELOW: Introduction Section 2.8.4 2.15.12-10 1 TOC 2.8.41 1 Section 3.2 i/ii 1 Section 2.12.14 3.2-2 1 LOT 2.12.14-3 1 3.2-3 1 iii/iv 1 Section 2.15.5 3.2-4 1 Section 1.0 2.15.5-15 1 3.2-6 1 1.0-5 1 Section 2.15.10 3.2-7 1 1.0-6 1 2.15.10-3 1 3.2-8 1 1.0-7 1 2.15.10-5 1 3.2-9 1 1.0-9 1 2.15.10-6 1 3.2-10 1 1.0-10 1 2.15.10-8 1 3.2-11 1 1.0-11 1 2.15.10-9 1 3.2-12 I 1.0-12 1 i 2.15.10-10 1 3.2-13 I i 1.0-13/14 1 2.15.10 11 1 3.2-15 1 2.15.10-12 1 3.2-22 1 Tier 1 i 2.15.10-13 1 Section 5.0 Section 2.7.1 2.15.10-14 1 5.0-2 1 2.7.1-3 1 2.15.10-15 1 Tier 2 2.7.1-4 1 2.15.10-16 1 TOC Section 2.8.1 Section 2.15.12 i I 2.8.11/2 1 2.15.12 3 1 ii I Section 2.8.3 2.15.12-5 I IV l 2.8.3-1/2 1 2.15.12-6 1 Chapter 1 TOC 2.15.I2-9 1 1.0- i 1 Page1 i
r Effective Pages of DCD as of Dec.1994 ALL PAGES IN THE DCD ARE REV. 0 EXCEPT FOR THOSE LISTED BELOW: Section 1.1 Section 3.3 3H.2-6 1 1.1-3 1 3.3-3 1 3H.2-12 1 Section 1.8 Section 3.7 3H.2-30 1 1.8-29 1 3.7-39 1 Section 3H.3 1.8-34.1 1 Section 3.8 3H.3-2 1 i 1.8-35 1 3.8-42 1 SH.3-5 1 1.8-38 1 3.8-60 1 Appendix 3K 1.8-39 1 Section 3.9 SK-1 1 l.8-40 1 3.9-29 1 SK-2 1 1.8-41 1 3.9-30 1 SK-3 1 1.8-42 1 3.9-31 1 SK-4 1 1.8-43 1 3.9-36 1 SK-5 1 1.8-44 1 3.9-56 1 SK-6 1 1.8-45 1 3.9-84 1 Section 4.2 1.8-46 1 3.9-87 1 4.2-6 1 1.8-47 1 3.9-121 1 4.2-7 1 1.8-51 1 Section 3H.1 Section 5.2 Section 2.0 3H.1-4 1 5.2-41 1 2.0-2 1 SH.1-5 1 5.2-44 1 Section 2.3 311.1-7 1 5.2-45 1 2.3 1 1 311.1-13 1 5.2-53 1 2.3-6 1 311.1-16 1 Section 6.2 Chapter 3 TOC Section 3H.2 6.2-81 1 iii/iv 1 311.2-2 1 6.2-82 1 Page2
7--. s e Effective Pages of DCD as of Dec.1994 ALL PAGES IN THE DCD ARE REV. O EXCEPT FOR THOSE LISTED BELOW: 6.2-83 1 7A-5 1 Section 11.5 6.2-84 1 7A-7 1 11.5-23 1 6.2-85 1 7A-8 1 Section 12.2 6.246 1 7A-9 1 12.2-32 1 6.2-87 1 Appendix 7B 12.2-33 1 Section 6.3 7B-1 1 12.2-66 1 6.3-30 1 71k4 1 Section 12.3 Section 6.7 7B-5 1 12.3-26 1 6.71 1 Chapter 9 LOF Chapter 14 TOC 6.7-2 1 viii 1 iv 1 Appendix 6C Section 9.2 Section 14.2 6C-5 1 9.2-12 1 14.2-140 1 Section 7.1 9.2-58 1 Section 14.3 7.1-2 1 Section 9.3 '14.3-1 1 7.1-4 1 9.3-9 1 14.3-2 1 Section 7.2 9.3-18 1 14.S3 1 7.2-55 1 9.3-21 1 14.3-4 1 i Section 7.3 9.3-24 1 14.3-5 1 7.S96 1 9.3-36 1 14.3-6 1 Section 7.6 9.4-54 1 14.S7 1 7.6-7 1 Appendix 9B 14.3-8 1 7.7-49 1 9Ikl5/16 1 14.3-9 1 Appendix 7 A Section 10.2 14.3-10 1 7A-4 1 10.2-11 1 14.3-11 1 Pages
l Effective Pages of DCD as of Dec.1994 ALL PAGES IN THE DCD ARE REV. 0 EXCEPT FOR THOSE LISTED BELOW: 14.S12 1 14.3-36 1 Section 15.4 14.S13 1 14.S37 1 15.4-7 1 i 14.3-14 1 14.S38 1 Section 15.6 14.Sl5 1 14.3-39 1 15.67 1 14.S16 1 14.S40 1 15.6-26 1 14.3-17 1 14.3-41 1 15.6-27 1 14.3-18 1 14.S42 1 15.6-30 1 14.S19 1 14.3-43 1 Chapter 16 14.S20 1 14.3-44 1 Section 3.3 l4.3-21 1 14.S45 1 3.3-1 1 14.3-22 1 14.3-46 1 3.S2 1 14.S23 1 14.S47 1 3.S3 1 14.3-24 1 14.S48 1 3.3-5 1 i 14.3-25 1 14.3-49 1 3.3-6 1 14.3-26 1 14.3-50 1 3.Sl8 1 14.S27 1 14.3-51 1 3.3-19 1 14.S28 1 14.3-52 1 3.3-21 1 ( l 4.S29 1 14.S53 1 3.S28 1 14.3-30 1 14.3-54 1 3.S29 1 14.S 31 1 14.3-55 1 3.S42 1 14.S32 1 14.3-56 1 3.3-47 1 14.S 33 1 14.3-57 1 3.S48 1 1 14.S 34 1 14.3-58 1 3.S53 1 14.3-35 1 14.3-59/60 1 3.S 68 1 Paged i i
g '. Effective Pages of DCD as of Dec.1994 ALL PAGES IN THE DCD ARE REV. O EXCEPT FOR THOSE LISTED BELOW: 3.3-69 1 Appendix 18E Section 3.5 18E-1 1 3.5-2 1 18E-23 1 Section 3.6 Appendix 18F 3.6-41 1 18F-5 1 6 Section 3.7 18F-6 1 3.7-4 1 18F-7 1 Section B3.3 18F 10 1 i B3.3-61 1 18F-12 1 B3.3-62 1 Section 19.8 B3.3-63 1 19.8-35 1 i B3.S-64 1 9EA Section B3.5 19EA-33 1 B3.5-9 1 Appendix 19M i B3.5-10 1 19M-1 1 Chapter 17 TOC i 1 Appendix 19P Section 17.3 19P-1/2 1 ) 17.3-6 1 Appendix 19R Appendix 18A 19R-33 1 18A-1/2 1 Chapter 21 Section 18A.6 21 543 1 18A.6e 1 21-544 1 21-545 1 Page5
] ATTACIIMENT 3 DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DCD AND SSAR/CDM ] AND CHANGES TO DCD INTRODUCTION LEGEND Catenary Description ] 1 NRC Comment 2 NRC DCD Guidance a. Tier 2* b. Proprietary Information c. Not Used d. Safeguards Information e. Internal Consistency (Tier 1/CDM and Tier 2/SSAR) 3 GE Intiated Change for Clarification, Completeness, or Elimination of Disconnects 4 DCD Improvements over the SSAR or CDM of Significant Value. Improvements of Lesser j Value and not Specifically Recorded are: Minor Improvements in Format Correction of Spelling Inclusion of Scanned / Redrafted Figures Corrections to Table of Contents Replacement of " Deleted" with "Not Used" Commesurate with a New Document 5 Removal of Detailed PRA Information-Industry Initiative 1 i
Changes to DCD Introduction I Item DCU DCD j No. Pages Section Change Cat. Reason l 1 1.0-5 3.8 Added New Section 3.8 1 NRC Comment l 2 1.0-6 Table 1 Changed " Delineation" to " Designated". 1 NRC Comment j Replaced "None" with "First Full Power" for j Table 5 and next to entries. Added " Table i 1.8-21" to next to last entry. Clarified Note 1. l 3 1.0-7 Table 3 Added "3.8.1.2.2" and "3.8.4.1.5.2" 1 NRC Comment 4 1.0-7 Table 4 Added "3.8.4.5.1.2" and corrected "3H.4.2.1" 1 NRC Comment to "3H.2.4.1" 5 1.0-9 Table 6 Relocated "3.9-2" two places ; changed 1 NRC Comment " delineated" to " designated"; added "the" 4 i before the word "second" in note (1); added "1.8-20" in last column. 6 1.0-10 Table 7 . Added " Table 1.8-20", "Ref. 3.9-11" and 1 NRC Comment i "Ref. 3.9-9". Referenced drawing notes 29 I and 32. Added section reference for thermal ) oscillations. Added second reference for seismic anchor motion. Added " Table 3.9-1". Replaced " Tables 3.9-1,3.9-2" with " Table i 1.8-21". Changed " Earthquake Design Load" j to " Earthquake Cycles". I 7 1.0-11 Table 7 Added " Table 1.8-20." Removed " Table 1.8-1 NRC Comment l 21." Added clarifying note (3). Added "(Ref. l 3.9-10)" 8 1.0-12 Table 8 Extensively revised 1 NRC Comment 9 1.0-13/14 Table 10 Added "(except Section 7A.4)". 1 NRC Comment i 4 INTRO-1 l l
Changes to DCD Introduction DCD DCD ltem Pages Section Change Cat. Reason No. 10 1.0-13/14 Table 11 Added superscript (1) to title. Deleted "(a)" 1 NRC Comment from 78.1,78.2 abd 78.3. 11 1.0-13/14 Table 11 Added "7A.2(4)" and "7A.2(10)" 3 Completeness 1 INTRO-2 Y
Differences Between ABWR DCD and CDM Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason l 1 v/vi Table of Contents Added footnote "* section number in 4 Lost in a rollover parentheses-section, under which the subject is covered." 1a 2.7.1-3 and Table 2.7.1a Changed "SGTS(A)" to "SGTS(B)", 3 Inconsistent with P&lDs i 2.7.1 -4 "SGTS(B)" to "SGTS(C)", "FCS(A)" to i "FCS(B)", and "FCS(B)" to "FCS(C)". l 1b 2.8.1-1/2 2.8.1 Added "to" following the word predicted 1 NRC Comment l l under item (1). 1c 2.8.3-1/2 2.8.3 Replaced " dual" with "the in first sentence. 1 NRC Comment Added "s" to control rod in first sentence of item (4). Added "(associated with a given accumulator)" after stuck rod in item (4). 1d 2.8.4-1 2.8.4 Added "s" to component and event in fourth 1 NRC Comment paragraph. I 2 2.12.1-1 2.12.1 Inserted "at least" before "a UAT or a RAT" 3 Clarification in second line of next to last paragraph. 3 2.14.6-5/6 Table 2.14.6 Changed "7.34 kg/cm2" to "0.72 MPa" under 4 incomplete units conversion item 8. 4/4a 2.12.14-1 2.12.14 and Deleted "is a voltage regulating device and" 3 Clarification and Figure 2.12.14 in front of "The attemate power supply" at t 2.12.14-3 the end of the fourth paragraph and replaced " VOLTAGE REGULATING DEVICE" with " ALTERNATE POWER SUPPLY" in figure. In Revision 1, updated figure to be consistent with CDM. CDM-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and CDM lte m DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 5 2.15.5-7 2.15.5 Changed "45*C" to "50 C". 3 Max room temperature lower than maximum outside air. See Chapter 9 changes. Sa Mult. Section 2.15.5, Realigned DCD figures consistent with CDM. 1 NRC Comment 2.15.10' DCD Figure 2.15.10h upgraded to show solid lines around RSS (A) area. DCD Figure 2.15.12, 2.15.10h upgraded to show secondary 3.2 containment barrier for R/B. Figure 2.15.10j upgraded to remove and extraneous dotted line in the vicinity of column R3/RB. There are no other differences between the DCD and CDM building figures. 6 2.15.5-23 Figure 2.15.5j Reversed HWH inlet to outlet and HNCW 3 Clarification outlet to inlet. 7 5.0-2 Table 5.0 Changed "26.6 C' to "26.7 C' under 1% 3 Rounding error exceedance values. 8 5.0-2 Table 5.0 Changed "717.85 kPa" to "718.20 kPa' 3 Conversion error under minimum static bearing capacity. 8a 5.0-2 Table 5.0 Changed "2.35 kPa" to "2.394 kPa* under 1 NRC Comment maximum snow load and "13.8 kPaD" to 13.827 kPaD" under Maximum pressure drop. e CDM-2 A
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 1 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 1.1-1 1.1.1 Replaced " Advanced Boiling Water Standard 2e NRC DCD Guidance Safety Analysis Report" with " Tier 2" in first paragraph. 2 1.1-1 1.1.1 Replaced "SSAR" with " Tier 2" in second 2e NRC DCD Guidance paragraph. 2a 1.1-3 1.1.5 Removed " Final design approval (FDA) and" 3 Consistency with the from section application of the DCD 3 1.2-24 1.2.2.10.1.3 Removed last sentence. 4 Last two sentences the same. 4 1.6-1 1.6 Replaced section title and introductory 4 Clarification sentence 5 1.6-2 Table 1.6-1 Changed "SSAR" to " Tier 2" in right-hand 2e NRC DCD Guidance thru 1.6-6 column. 6 1.7-1 1.7.1 Replaced "...the ABWR SSAR" with " Tier 2" 2e NRC DCD Guidance in second line. 7 1.7-23 Table 1.7-2 Under item 2D changed explanation of 4 Clarification function from " Output exists if and only if all specified inputs exist" to " Output exists if specified number of inputs exist." 8 1.7-24 Table 1.7-2 in truth table for item 3C changed "1" to "0" 4 Correction in right-hand bottom comer. 9 1.8-12, Table 1.8-19 Italicized SRP 3.5.3,3.8.1 and 4.2 2a NRC DCD Guidance i 1.8-13 Appendices, and added 2 fooaotes tn page 1.8-24. 10 1.8-27 Table 1.8-20 Corrected title of Reg. Guide 1.43. 4 Correction 1-1 i
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 1 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 11 1.8-27 Table 1.8-20 Italicized Reg. Guide 1.47 and referenced 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote 4. 12 1.8-29 Table 1.8-20 Italicized Reg. Guide 1.75 and referenced 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote 4. 12a 1.8-29 Table 1.8-20 Italicized Reg. Guide 1.84 and referenced 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote 1. 13 1.8-30 Table 1.8-20 Italicized Reg. Guides 1.92 and 1.100 and 2a NRC DCD Guidance referenced footnotes 1 and 2, respectively. 14 1.8-31 Table 1.8-20 Italicized Reg. Guide 1.105 and referenced 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote 3. 15 1.8-34 Table 1.8-20 Italicized Reg. Guides 1.152 and 1.153 and 2a NRC DCD Guidance referenced footnote 4. 16/16a 1.8-34.1 Table 1.8-20 Added notes (1) thru (4). Clarified note (1). 2a NRC DCD Guidance /Cornment 17 1.8-35 Table 1.8-21 Changed "1983" to "1989' under ACI 318 3 UBC references ACI 318-entry.1 1989. Changed forinternal consistency. Returned ACI 349 to 1980 Edition in Revision 1. There is no longer a difference between DCD and SSAR pertaining to ACI 349. 1 1-2
b Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 1 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 18/18a 1.8-35 Table 1.8-21 Italicized the following codes and standards:2 2a NRC DCD Guidance. Also thru ACl 349 IEEE 845 added MIL-HDBK-217 and 1.8-87 AISC N690 IEEE 1012 IEC 801-2 for consistency ANS 7-4.3.2 IEEE 1023 with text. ANS 57.5 ANS 58.2 IEEE 1042 ANSI /HFS-100 IEEE 1228 (Draft) DOD 5000.2 ANSI /NOA-2a DOD AD/A223168 ASTM C776 DOE AR602-1 ASTM C934 DOE DI-HFAC-80740 IEEE C37.90.2 DOE ESD-TR-86-278 IEEE C62.41 DOE HDBK-761 A IEEE C62.45 DOE HDBK-763 IEEE C63.12 DOE-STD-2167A IEEE 279 DOD TOP 1-2-610 lEEE 323 MIL-H-46855B IEEE 338 MIL-HDBK-217 IEEE 344 MIL-HDBK-251 IEEE 384 MIL-HDBK-759A IEEE 603 MIL-STD-461C IEEE 730 MIL-STD-462 IEEE 802.2 MIL-STD-1472D lEEE 802.5 MIL-STD-1478 IEEE 828 IEC 801-2 IEEE 829 IEC 880 IEEE 830 IEC 964 and added the corresponding nine notes to page 1.8-47. 2 Removed Italics from ANSI N101.4 in Revision 1. Now same as SSAR. 1-3
4 Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR 4 1 Chapter 1(Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 19 1.8-36 Table 1.8-21 Revised title of ANSI A58.1. 4 Cleanup 19a 1.8-39 Table 1.8-21 Added and italicized "ASME NOA-2a" and 1 NRC Comment referenced footnotes (3) and (4). l 19b 1.8-40 Table 1.8-21 Added and italicized " ANSI X3.139", " ANSI 1 NRC Comment i X.143", " ANSI X3.166" and "X3T9.5/84-49" and referenced footnotes (3) and (4). 19c 1.8-42 Table 1.8-21 Added number for IEEE 7-4.3.2. 3 Missing Number 19d 1.8-42 Table 1.8-21 Referenced footnote (9) under lEEE 338 and 3 Incomplete added fccinote (9) to page 1.8-47. 19e 1.8-43 Table 1.8-21 Added and italicized IEEE 518 and 1 NRC Comment referenced footnotes (3) and (4). f 19f 1.8-51 Table 1.8-21 Replaced IEEE 1033 with IEEE 1050 and 1/3 IEEE 1033 canceled referenced footnotes (3) and (4). 20 1.8-46 Table 1.8-21 Added ASCE 71988 under"others". 4 Missing reference l 20a 1.8-51 Table 1.8-22 Added IE Bulletin 79-02 1 NRC Comment 21 1.9-1 1.9 Replaced "SSAR" with " Tier 2" 3 places. 2e NRC DCD Guidance i 22 1 A-11 1 A.2.9 Italicized " Plant-specific SRV models - with 2a NRC DCD Guidance j NUREG-0737 requirements" 23 1 AA-2 1AA.2(3) Changed "3.87E-6 c/kgh" to "1.5E-4 Gy/h" 4 Correct units and "1.29E-4 c/kgh" to "5.0E-3 Gy/h". 24 1 AA-3 1 AA-3.1 In first paragraph replaced "SSAR" with 2e NRC DCD Guidance " Tier 2". 25 1 AA-6 1 AA.4.3 in second paragraph replaced "0.983" with 5 Industry initiative " estimated to be very high" i l 1-4 i
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 2 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 2.0-2 Table 2.0-1 Changed "26.6 C" to "26.7 C" under 1% 4 Rounding error Exceedance Value for Ambient Design Temperature. 2 2.0-2 Table 2.0-1 Changed '717.85 kPa" to "718.20 kPa" 4 Conversion error under Minimum Static Bearing Capacity. 2a 2.0-2 Table 2.0-1 Changed "2.354kPa" to '2.394 kPa" under 1 NRC Comment maximum snow load. 2b 2.3-1 2.3.1.2 Changed "717.85 kPa" to "717.20 kPa". 3 Conversion error 2c 2.3-6 2.3.2.33 Changed "717.85 kPa" to "718.20 kPa". 1 NRC Comment 2-1
w Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 3.2-8 3.2.5.3(3) Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 2 3.2-8, 3.2.5.3(4) Italicized (a) and (b), added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.2-9 3.2-9. 3 3.2-9 3.2.5.3 Italicized last paragraph, using footnote of 2a NRC DCD Guidance item 2. 4 3.2-63 Table 3.2-3 Six places, italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 4a 3.3-3 3.3.4 Deleted date from ASCE 7 4 Cleanup 5 3.4-15 3.4.2 Second paragraph, first line: rep! aced 1 incorrect acronym; NRC "ABWER" with "ABWR". comment 6 3.5-8 3.5.1.1.2.2(4) Equation (3.5-3): Removed small dashes 4 Consistency with Figure from top of "f". 3.5-1 definition f 7 3.6-12 3.6.2.1.4.1 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 8 3.6-12 3.6.2.1.4.2 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.6-14. 9 3.6-14 3.6.2.1.4.3 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.6-15. 10 3.6-15 3.6.2.1.4.4 Italicized text, using item 9 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 11 3.6-15 3.6.2.1.4.5 Italicized text, using item 9 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 12 3.6-16 3.6.2.1.5.2 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance - 13 3.6-17 3.6.2.1.5.3.1 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 14 3.6-17 3.6.2.1.5.3.2 Italicized text, using item 13 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 15 3.6-22 3.6.2.3.1 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 3.6-25. 3.6-25 16 3.6-25 3.6.2.3.2.1 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 17 3.6-26 3.6.2.3.2.2 Italicized text, using item 16 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 18 3.6-29 3.6.3 Changed "this SSAR" to " Tier 2" in second 2e NRC DCD Guidance paragraph. 19 3.7-8, 3.7.2.1.4 Italicized text, added footnote on page 3.7-9. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-9 20 3.7-21 3.7.3.1 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 21 3.7-22 3.7.3.2 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 22 3.7-23 3.7.3.3.1.2 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 23 3.7-23 3.7.3.3.1.3(1) Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 24 3.7-24 3.7.3.3.1.4 Changed "the SSAR" to " Tier 2" in first 2e NRC DCD Guidance paragraph 25 3.7-25 3.7.3.3.1.4(2) Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 26 3.7-25 3.7.3.3.1.6 Italicized text, using item 25 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 27 3.7-25 3.7.3.3.1.7 Italicized text, using item 25 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 28 3.7-25, 3.7.3.3.1.8 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-26 3.7-26. 29 3.7-27 3.7.3.3.4 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 30 3.7-28, 3.7.3.6 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-29 3.7-29. 3-2
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 31 3.7-29 3.7.3.7.1 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 3.7-31. 3.7-31 32 3.7-31 3.7.3.7.2 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 3.7-33. 3.7-33 33 3.7-35, 3.7.3.8.1.6 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-36 3.7-36. 34 3.7-36, 3.7.3.8.1.7 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-37 3.7-37. 35 3.7-37 3.7.3.8.1.8 Italicized text, using footnote of item 34. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 36 3.7-38, 3.7.3.8.1.9 Italicized text two places, added footnote on 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-39 page 3.7-39. 36a 3.7-39 3.7.3.8.1.9 Changed "lV" to "Ill' in last sentence. 1 NRC Comment 37 3.7-39 3.7.3.8.1.10 Italicized text, using footnote of item 36. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 38 3.7-40, 3.7.3.13 Italicizeo text two places, added footnote on 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.7-41 page 3.7-41. 39 3.8-2 3.8.1.1.1 Added an italicized paragraph with footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 40 3.8-3 3.8.1.22 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 41 3.8-20 3.8.2.2.3 Italicized first paragraph, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 42 3.8-22 3.8.2.4.1.4' Italicized second paragraph, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 43 3.8-27 3.8.3.2 Added an italicized paragraph with footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 44 3.8-28 3.8.3.2 Added an italicized paragraph with footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3-3
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 45 3.8-30 3.8.3.5.1 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 46 3.8-30 3.8.3.5.2 Italicized text, using item 45 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 47 3.8-35 3.8.4.2.1(1) Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 48 3.8-36 3.8.4.2.1(2) Italicized text, added footnote, and changed 2a NRC DCD Guidance " Table 3.8-10" to " Table 3.8-9". 49 3.8-37 3.8.4.2.1(9) Removed "88" from ANSI /ASCI 7 4 Date is applied by Table 1.8-21 l 50 3.8-38 3.8.4.2.2 Italicized first sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 51 3.8-38 3.8.4.2.3 Changed "AISC" to " ANSI /AISC-N690" and 2a NRC DCD Guidance italicized first sentence, using item 47 footnote. 51a 3.8-60 3.8.4.3.2 Changed "1.96 kPa" to "19.61 kPa" 1 NRC Comment 52 3.8-44 3.8.4.4.1 Italicized first sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 53 3.8-46 3.8.4.5.1.2 Changed title from "Materic's Criteria" to 2a NRC DCD Guidance " Structural and Materials Criteria" and added italicized sentence. 54 3.8-46 3.8.4.5.2 Italicized first sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 55 3.8-46 3.8.4.5.3 Italicized first sentence, using item 54 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote. 56 3.8-47 3.8.5.2 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 57 3.8-54, Table 3.8-4 Italicized References 13,14 and 15, added 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.8-55 footnotes on page 3.8-55. 58 3.8-54 Table 3.8-54 Changed " Table 3.9-10" to " Table 3.9-9" in 4 Correction Reference 15 3-4 m w-n
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 59 3.8-55 Table 3.8-4 Removed Note 1. 1 NRC comment 60/60a 3.8-60 Table 3.8-9 Italicized text (1) thru (6), added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 60b 3.8-60 3.8.4.3.2 Added "with" following the word accordance 4 Cleanup in item (7)(c). 61 3.8-61, Table 3.8-10 Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.8-62 3.8-62. 62 3.9-1 3.9.1.2 Italicized last paragraph, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 63 3.9-7 3.9.1.7 Created a new Subsection 3.9.1.7 with an 2a NRC DCD Guidance italicized paragraph and footnote. 64 3.9-14 3.9.2.2.1 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 65 3.9-28 3.9.3.1 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 65a 3.9-29 3.9.3.1 Added paragraph summarizing supplement 3 1 NRC Comment to Bulletin 88-08 and how ABWR addresses. 66 3.9-29 3.9.3.1 Italicized text two places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 67 3.9-32 3.9.3.1.1.7 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 67a 3.9-36 3.9.3.1.19 Added reference to Table 3.9-1 1 NRC Comment 68 3.9-36 3.9.3.1.20 Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 69 3.9-36 3.9.3.1.21 Italicized text, using item 68 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 70 3.9-36 3.9.3.1.22 Italicized text, using item 68 footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 71 3.9-37 3.9.3.2.1.1 Italicized a last portion of first paragraph, 2a NRC DCD Guidance added footnote. 72 3.9-41 3.9.3.2.3.1.4 Italicized a sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3-5
MMmmm Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 73 3.9-42 3.9.3.2.3.1.4 ltalicized text two places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 74 3.9-45 3.9.3.2.5.1.2 Italicized a sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 75 3.9-50 3.9.3.4 Italicized last three sentences, added 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote. 76 3.9-50 3.9.3.4.1 Italicized text three places, using item 75 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote. 77 3.9-51 3.9.3.4.1 Italicized text two places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 78 3.9-51, 3.9.3.4.1 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.9-52 79 3.9-53 3.9.3.4.1 Italicized text one place, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 80 3.9-53, 3.9.3.4.1 Italicized text two places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.9-54 81 3.9-55 3.9.3.4.1(5) Italicized a sentence in first paragraph, 2a NRC DCD Guidance added footnote. 82 3.9-56 3.9.3.4.1(6) Italicized text two places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 82a 3.9-56 3.9.3.4.1 Added R.G.1.94 to italicized portion of 1 NRC Comment paragraph (a). 83 3.9-77 3.9.6.2.2 Added an italicized paragraph at top with 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote. 84 3.9-77 3.9.6.2.2(1) Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 85 3.9-77, 3.9.6.2.2(2) Italicized text, added footnote on page 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3.9-78 3.9-78 86 3.9-84 3.9.8 Italicized Reference 3.9-6, added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance - l 3-6 ,.s
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 87/87a 3.9-84 3.9.8 Italicized References 3.9-7,3.9-9,3.9-10, 2a/1 NRC DCD and 3.9-11 and added footnote. Added date Guidance / Comment to Reference 3.9-11 88 3.9-86 Table 3.9-1 Italicized Event 12, added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance 89 3.9-87 Table 3.9-2 Italicized Event 3', added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance 90 3.9-88 Table 3.9-2 Italicized Notes 7 and 9, added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance 91 3.9-88 Table 3.9-2 Italicized Note 12, added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance 91a 3.9-121 Table 3.9-8 Added reference for K17 Radwaste System 1 NRC Comment Valves (Tier 2 figures). 92 3.9-139 Table 3.9-8 Deleted "SSAR" under notes (a) and (d) 2e NRC DCD Guidance 93 3.10-1 3.10 Added an italicized paragraph with footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 94 3.10-2 3.10.1.1 Italicized text three places, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 95 3.10-3 3.10.1.3 Italicized last sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 96 3.10-3 3.10.2.1 Italicizea last sentence using ite" 89 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote. 97 3.13-11 3.13.4.5 Changed "SSAR" to " Tier 2" 2e NRC DCD Guidance 3.13.4.6 3.13.4.7 98 3.13-14 3.13.5.2 Replaced "are less than 1% of" with "is a 2b NRC DCD Guidance very small percentage of the" in the last , paragraph
- Moved RH bracket inside superscript to satisy NRC Comment.
3-7
EMMmmm Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 99 3.11-5 3.11.7 Italicized reference 3.11-2 and added 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote 99a 3A-3 3A.3.2 NRC comment that Equation 3A-1 is missing 1 NRC Comment a factor of 70. The equation is dimensionless and therefore requires no coefficient (factor). Same as SSAR. 100 3A-85 Figure 3A-17 Provided correct figure for elevation 4 incorrect figure in SSAR -10.95 m 101 3A-295 and Figures 3A-227 Reversed these figures 4 incorrect in SSAR 3A-296 and 3A-228 102 3B-24 thru Tables 3B-2 thru Changed "provided under separate cover" 2b NRC DCD Guidance 3B-39 38-9 to "not part of DCD (Refer to SSAR Appendix 3B" 38-41 and Figure 3B-2 and 38-42 3B-3 3B-47 thru Figure 3B-8 thru o 3B-49 38-10 38-53 thru Figures 38-14 thru 3B-59 3B-20 3B-61 thru Figures 3B-22 thru 3B-64 38-25 3B-66 and Figures 38-27 3B-68 and 3B-29 3B-70 thru Figures 3B-31 3B-73/74 thru 3B-34 3-8
l l l l Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR ~ Chapter 3(Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 103 3B-27 38.4.4.1 Removed "SSAR" in third line of first 2e NRC DCD Guidance paragraph. 104 3E-43 Figure 3E-6 Removed duplicate title in body of figure. 4 Cleanup - l 105 3G-14 Figure 3G-7 Replaced Figure 3G-7 [AP LOAD (MS 4 Correction NOZZLE BREAK) CASE AP2, NODE: 81, i HORIZONTAL] with Figure 3G-7 [AP LOAD j (MS NOZZLE BREAK) CASE APA2, NODE: l 33, HORIZONTAL] l l 106 3H.1 -3 3H.1.4.1.1 Italicized codes (1), (3) and (5) and added 2a NRC DCD Guidance footno'.es l 107/107a 3H.1-3 thru 3H.1.4.2 Revised parameters to be consistent with 4/1 Cleanup /NRC Comment 3H.1-5 Table 2.0-1 and deleted date from ASCE 7. 108/108a 3H.1-7 3H.1.4.3.1.3 Revised snow load to agree with 4 Cleanup _ Table 2.0-1. I 108b 3H.1-13 3H.1.5.2 Revised shearwave velocity to agree with 1 NRC Commer:t Table 2.0-1 108c 3H.1-16 3H.1.5.5.2.1 5 4 Changed "9.90x10 kPa" to "9.67x10 kPa." 1 NRC Comment 109/109a 3H.2-2 thru 3H.2.4 Revised parameters to be consistent with 4/1 Cleanup /NRC Comment 3H.2-6 Table 2.0-1 and deleted date from ASCE 7. 110 3H.2-2 and 3H.2.4.1, and Italicized ACl349 and ANSI /AISC-N690 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3H.3-2 3H.3.4.1 110a 3H.2-12 3H.2.5.2 Deleted date from ASCE 7 4 Cleanup 110b 3H.2-30 Figure 3H.2-19 Replaced " psi" with " psf". -1 NRC Comment 111/111a 3H.3-2 thru 3H.3.4 Revised parameters to be consistent witn 4 Cleanup { 3H.3-5 Table 2.0-1 and deleted date from ASCE 7. 3-9
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 3 (continued) Item i DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 112 3H.3-29 Figure 3H.3-1 Changed "0.15 ksf" with "7.18 kPa" and 4 Units conversion "4.48 ksf" with "215 kPa" in vertical center of table. 113 31-7 Table 31-4 Deleted footnote 2 and changed "40" to "50" 3 Must cool with outside air for diesel generator room. as high as 46.1 C 114/114a 3K-1 thru 3K Added entire appendix" 2a/1 NRC DCD Guidance / 3K-6 Comment 115 3L-1 and Figures 3L-8 Removed duplicate title in body of figures. 4 Cleanup 3L-2 and 3L-9 116 3M-6 3M.7(1) Removed "in the SSAR" from third line of 2e NRC DCD Guidance first paragraph. i 117 3M-7 3M.8 Replaced "SSAR" with " Tier 2",2 places 2e NRC DCD Guidance 118 3MA-19 3MA.5.2 Changed "SSAR" to " Tier 2" 2e NRC DCD Guidance i " Modified phrase "NRC Approval" to "NRC Staff Approval" two places on page 3K-1 for Revision 1. Also, replaced 7he reference in Subsection 4.2.2(c)(3)" with "lEEE-344" in section 3K.6 on page 3K-4 for Revision 1. 3-10
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 4 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 4.2-1 4.2 Added italicized paragraph with footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 2 4.2-1 4.2 Added italicized sentences with footnote. 2a NRC comment 3 4.2-3 thru 4.2.2.1 and Italicized text, added footnote on page 4.2-5. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 4.2-5 4.2.2.2 4 4.2-5 thru 4.2.3.1.1 Italicized text, added footnote on page 4.2-6.t 2a NRC DCD Guidance 4.2-6 5 4.2-6 4.2.3.1.2 Italicized text using a Section 4.2 footnote.t 2a NRC DCD Guidance 5a 4.2-7 4.2.3.1.2, 4.2.4 Changed " Subsection 4.2-3' to " Reference 3 Clarification 4.2-3" a^d italicized second sentence of Section 4.2.4 Sb 4.2-7 4.2.5 Added date for NEDE-31152P 1 NRC Comment 6 4.2-7 4.2.5 Italicized references, added footnote.tt 2a NRC DCD Guidance 7 4.2-8 Figure 4.2-1 Italicized title, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 8 4.2-9/10 Figure 4.2-2 Italicized title, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance. 9 4.3-2 4.3.2.1 Italicized a sentence, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 10 4.3-8 Figure 4.3-1 Italicized title, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 11 4A-1 4A.1, 4 A.2, Italicized text, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 4A.3 12 4B-1 4B.1 Italicized sentences, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance t For Revision 1, extended paragraph (2) italics to Section 4.2.3.2. tt For Revision 1, italicized Reference 4.2-3. 4-1
Differ inces Between ABWH DCD and SSAR Chapter 4 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Sec: ion Difference Cat. Reason 13 48-1 4B.2 Replaced proprietary SSAR Sections 48.2 2b NRC DCD Guidance through 48-16 with Reference AB-1, italicized the reference using item 12 foctnote. 14 4C-1 4C.1 Italicized sentences, added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 15 4C-1, 4C.2, Italicized, added footnote on page 4C-2. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 4C-2 4C.3 16 4D-1 4D Removed proprietary information, referenced 2b NRC DCD Guidance SSAR. 4-2 r -e
.ww,. 1 Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 5 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 5.2-30 5.2.4.3.2.1 Added " Appendix 5A demonstrates 4 Ties appendix to text. compliance with Regulatory Guide 1.150." at bottom of section.. 1a 5.2-41 5.2.5.2.1 Removed last paragraph 3 Redundant to Section 5.2.5.2.3 1b 5.2-41 5.2.5.2.2 Added "RHR" in front of " Shutdown Cooling 1 NRC Comment System" in third line of item (2). 2 5.2-44 5.2.5.2.2(11) Replaced "RCU" with "RCW" in middle of 1 incorrect acronym; NRC paragraph. comment. 2a 5.2-44 5.2.5.2.2(11) Added period after " variable" in third to last 1 NRC Comment line. 2b 5.2-45 5.2.5.4.2 Changed " Pickings" to " Packings" in fourth 1 NRC Comment line. 3 5.2-51 thru Table 5.2-1 Added code case N-476 and italicized code 2c NRC DCD Guidance 5.2-53 cases N-71-15 through N-430 and N-476. 4 5.3-13 5.3.3.1.1.1 Added " located between the two seal rings. 4 Should be part of SSAR. A monitor line is attached to the tap to " Lost" in a rollover. provide an indication of leakage from the inner seal-ring seal." to the bottom of the page. 5 5.4-16 5.4.5.4 Replaced " sections" with "s" in second 4 " sections" should be sentence of second paragraph. " seconds" and abbreviated as "s". 6 5.4-29 5.4.7.1 Added " pressure" in front of " design" in ~4 Missing werd. four1h to last line of subsection. 5-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 5 (Continued) 7 5.4-66 Table 5.4-4 Changed "32.6 C" to "37.8 C". 3 See reason for item 2 of Chapter 9. i e 5-2
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 6 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 6.2-14 6.2.1.1.3.5 Removed subsection 6.2.1.1.3.5. 3 Not required with UHS of 35 C. 2 6.2-26 6.2.1.1.5.5 Added " sense a gap between the disk and 4 Lost in SSAR amendment the seating surface. If the gap is less than rollover. 9 mm," following the third line of the third paragraph. 3 6.2-61 6.2.4.2 Added " containment isolation" before 1 NRC comment " signals" in the seventh paragraph of Section 6.2.4.2. 4 6.2-62 6.2.4.2.6 Added "of GDC 54" in front of "that no active 1 NRC comment failure..." in the first paragraph of the section. 5 6.2-63 6.2.4.2.6 Added " power operated" in front of " isolation 1 NRC comment valve arrangements..." in fifth paragraph of the section. 6 6.2-63 6.2.4.2.6 Replaced "nonpowered" with " manual" in 1 NRC comment front of " isolation valves is maintained..." in the last paragraph of the section. 6a 6.2-81 6.2.5.2.6.2 Replaced numerical values with word values 1 NRC Comment thru 6.2.5.2.6.3 for consistency with Appendix 19E. 6.2-87 6.2.5.2.6.4 6.2.5.2.6.6 6.2.5.2.6.9 7 6.2-126 Table 6.2-7 Changed "SSAR" to " Tier 2". 2e NRC DCD Guidance thru 6.2-167 6-1 .. ~.. ~.
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 6 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 7a 6.3-30 Table 6.3-4 Changed " Subsection 5.3.3.7.8" to 3 Correction " Subsection 6.3.3.7.8". No longer different from SSAR. 8 6.3-44 Table 6.3-15 in third line of second column changed "PFL' 4 incorrect acronym to "LPFL". 9 6.3-32 and Tables 6.3-6 and Changed "[ Proprietary information provided 2b NRC DCD Guidance 6.3-50 Figures 6.3-10 under separate cover)" to "[ Proprietary thru 6.3-29 information not part of DCD (Refer to SSAR 6.3-87/88 Section 6.3)]". 10 6.4-7 6.4.2.5.1 Changed "2.7%" to "25d in the third column 1 NRC comment of the table under " halogens". 11 6.4-9 6.4.4.2 Removed "... with portable air analyzers 4 Sentence repeated due to indicate the need to do so. However, the rollover. operator is allowed..." from the top of the page. 11a 6.7-1 6.7.1 Added "providing nitrogen for." at end of first 1 NRC Comment sentence of second paragraph. 11b 6.7-2 6.7.3 Changed " safety portion" to " safety-related 1 NRC Comment portion' in first line of paragraph. 12 6A-12 6A Added " activated carbon is greater than two 4 Originally in SSAR, lost in a inches deep, each representative" to top of rollover. the page. 12a 6C-5 6C.5 Changed "130m3/h" to "1130m3/h" in next to 3 SSAR incorrect last line. 6-2 l
-4 Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 7 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 7.1-7 thru 7.1.2.1.6 Italicized text, added footnote on 2a NRC DCD Guidance 7.1-11 page 7.1-11. 1a 7.1-4 7.1.1.4.2 Replaced "SLC System" with "SLCS" in last 1 NRC Comment line. 2 7.1-31 7.1.2.10.9 Added Italicized paragraph with footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3 7.2-32 7.2.2.2.1(6) Italicized " Regulatory Guide 1.105" and 2a NRC DCD Guidance added footnote. 3a 7.2-55 Figure 7.2-6 Removed "NOT"in four places 1 NRC Comment 4 7.3-72 7.3.2.1.2(3)(f) Italicized RG1.105 and Reference 7.3-2 and 2a NRC DCD Guidance added footnote. 5/5a 7.3-96 7.3.4 Italicized Reference 7.3-2 and added 2a NRC DCD footnote. In Revision 1, changed " November" Guidance / Comment to " October" under Reference 7.3-2. 6 7.4-24 7.4.2.3.2(3)(f), Italicized RG1.105 and added footnote. 2c NRC DCD Guidance 7.6-23 7.6.2.1.2(3)(f), 7.6-30 7.6.2.6.2(3)(f) 7 7.5-24 thru Tables 7.5-4, Changed " Safety Analysis" to " Tier 2" in third 2e NRC DCD Guidance 7.5-27 7.5-5 and 7.5-6 column. 8 7.5-28 Table 7.5-8 Replaced "S" with "T" in right hand column 2e NRC DCD Guidance and "S=SSAR" with "T= Tier 2" in footnote. 9 7.6-3 7.6.1.1.1(4) Changed "nv" to " neutron /cm2= four places. 4 incomplete units conversion 9a 7.6-7 7.6.1.1.2.1(9) Changed "84.37 kg/cm2 " to 8.27 MPaG." 3 Incomplete units change g 10 7.6-27 7.6.2.3 Replaced "SSAR" with Tier 2 2e NRC DCD Guidance 11 7.6-30 7.6.2.6.2(3) Italicized RG 1.105. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 7-1
~ Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 7 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 12 7.6-47 Figure 7.6-9 Removed duplicate title in body of figure. 4 Cleanup Replaced "of the SSAR" with " Tier 2" in first 2a NRC DCD Guidance 13 7.7-77 7.7.1.11 line. 14 7A-1 7A.1 Added two italicized paragraphs with 2a NRC DCD Guidance footnote 15/15a 7A-2 7A.2 Italicized all of Section 7A.2. In Revision 1, 2a/1 NRC DCD thru 7A-12 added reference to IEEE 518 and 1050 Guidance / Comment under item (4) on page 7A-4 with footnote and modified reference to ANSI FDDI under item (10) on page 7A-7. 16 7A-7 7A.2 Changed "the SSAR" to " Tier 2" in 2e NRC DCD Guidance Response (11) 16a 7A-9 7A.2 Replaced "lEEE-1033" with "lEEE-1042". 3 IEEE-1033 canceled 17 7A-12 7A.3 Italicized all of Section 7A.3 and added 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 7A-15 footnote } 18 7A-16 7A.5 thru 7A.7 Italicized Sections 7A.5 through 7A.7 and 2a NRC DCD Guidance 9 thru 7A-20 added footnote 19 78-1 78.1 Changed "lEEE (draft H)* to "lEEE 1228 4 Reference Update (draft)" under item (1)(a)(iv). 20 78-1 7B.1 thru 7B.3 Italicized Sections 78.1 througi; 78.3 and 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 7B-7/8 added footnotes 21 7C-2 7C.2 and 7C.3 Italicized Section 7C.2 and added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 7C-5 22 7C-5 7C.4 in first paragraph changed "less than 10E-6" 5 Industry initiative j to " extremely low." 7-2
l i1 ll1 llIi 11 Ij e gna e h c n c na o s s t d a n u i i e u R G e D te C lp D mo C c R In N t a a 4 C 2 R .e A t S r o S e n t d o d n o n u f a d C" e D )d d C e 4 d D u 0 a n e 2 R it c d 1 W n n n o e r h a B C e i 5 3 t A w 7-( ff C i n 7 D P 7 e r e e n 0 o t w p 0 it t a e 2 c h B 2 e 2 C s 9 S d 9 d e e c 1 e c n aE iz e lpN c r i e eU la f i RJ I f t D n Do 4 5 i Ctc C C De 7 7 S 3 1 s 1 - De 7-1C Cg C C 7 Da 7 u P 7r h t m.o 3 4 eN 2 2 t I l ll
i Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR i Chapter 8 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 8 2-15 Table 8.2-1 "SSAR" changed to " Tier 2' on first line. 2e NRC DCD Guidance - I 4 2. 4 4 8-1
0-f Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR ~ Chapter 9 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference. Cat. Reason 1 9.1-6 9.1.2.1.3 Changed "1361 kg" to "13.35 kN" under 4 Incomplete unit conversion. item 6. 2 9.2-6 9.2.5.1(1) Changed "37.8 C" to "35 C average" at end 3 During the course of the of item (1). stafi review, GE changed from 95 F (35*C) to 100 F (37.8 C) and the FDA ver-sion of the SSAR ended at the 100 F value. Page 2-11 of the FSER shows a 95 F l value for the UHS (Emer-gency Cooling Water inlet). As part of the FOAKE. program, the systems cooled by the UHS were evaluated and it was determined that the federally mandated phase out of several commonly used refrigerants would require lowering the UHS temperature to 95 F (35 C). FOAKE also found that plate type heat exchangers would be much more suitable. Finally, itis prudent to allow the use of both screw-type and centrifugal-type chillers. 4 9-1 i m
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 9 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 2a 9.2-12 9.2.8.3.1 Deleted second "wc!!" in first line of 1 NRC Comment paragraph. 3 9.2-20 9.2.11.1.1(1) Changed "37.8 " to "(i.e.,35 C average)" in 3 See reason for item 2 second line of second paragraph. above. 4 9.2-21 9.2.11.2 Inserted the following paragraph: 3 See reason for item 2 above. "The Control and Service Building general arrangement drawings, Figures 1.2-14 through 17 (and companion Fire Protection drawings, Figures 9A.4-11 through 13, and Radiation Protection drawings, Figures 12.3-42,43,48 and 64) show the location of the RCW pumps and heat exchangers. (Note: The heat exchangers are depicted as shell-and-tube type; however, the attemate plate-type can be accommodated in the same area of the Control Building in a horizontal arrangement at elevation -8200mm, the same elevation as the pumps)." 5 9.2-22 9.2.11.2 Removed "due to tube plugging" in 3 See reason for item 2 paragraph beginning with "The above above. analysis shews..." 6 9.2-25 9.2.11.3.2 Removed "the tubing side" from paragraph 3 See reason for item 2 beginning with " System components and above. piping materials..." 7 9.2-27 9.2.11.4 Replaced " tube plugging" with " leakage" in 3 See reason for item 2 next to last sentence in first paragraph. above. 9-2
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 9 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 8 9.2-27 9.2.11.4 Replaced last word " fouling" in second 3 See reason foritem 2 paragraph with " refurbishing". above. s 9 9.2-27 9.2.11.5 Replaced "a tube leak" with " leakage" in the 3 See reason foritem 2 next to the last paragraph. above. 10 9.2-31 9.2.13.2 Deleted " centrifugal" in front of compressor 3 See reason for item 2 in the third sentence of the second above. paragraph. 11 9.2-34 9.2.13.5 Changed last sentence of third paragraph to 4 Consistency with P&lDs read "two-way valve based on refrigerant compressor discharge pressure". 12 9.2-50 Table 9.2-4a Changed "54.01" to "127.24" in the fourth 1 NRC comment column of the totalload entry. 13/13a 9.2-58 Table 9.2-8 Removed " type-centrifugal hermetic" in 3 See reason for item 2 Revision 1 above. 14 9.3-5 9.3.2.3.4 Changed " Reactor" to " Turbine" in front of 4 Correction " Building Sample Station" 14a 9.3-9 9.3.3.1.3 Replaced "This" with "That" in second 1 NRC Comment paragraph 14b 9.3-9 9.3.3.2 Replaced "in with "is" in the third line of 1 NRC Comment paragraph 15 9.3-9 9.3.3.2 Removed "(Subsection 9.3.2.1)" from the 1 NRC comment first line. 16 9.3-9 9.3.3.2.1 Changed "is" to "are". 1 NRC comment 9-3
l Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR i Chapter 9 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 17 9.3-13 9.3.5.2 Changed item (a) from "High RPV pressure 4 Modified to reflect SRNM (7.76 MPaG) and average power range monitor (APRM) not downscale for 3 minutes, or" to "High RPV pressure 1 (7.76 MPaG) and startup range neutron monitor (SRNM) not downscale for 3 minutes, or " l 17a 9.3-18 9.3.6.2 Removed "which" following " isolation 1 NRC Comment 9.3-21 9.3.7.2 valves". 18 9.3-22 9.3.7.2 Added last paragraph "outside primary 4 Paragraph lost in an containment a manually-operated valve is Amendment 34 rollover kept closed and locked during normal plant i operation. During refueling, the valve is opened to provide air inside containment. A check valve is provided inside the containment." 18a 9.3-24 9.3.8.2.1 Removed "and system" in second line of first 1 NRC Comment paragraph. 19 9.3-34 Table 9.3-1 Changed "85.8" to "8.41" in next to last 4 Correction of unit column under Pump Discharge to injection conversion Valve inlet entry. 20 9.4-8 9.4.1.2.3.3(6) Removed "at E1.7200 in C/B" from end of 4-Wrong elevation sentence. i 9-4 ---.v-ve+< m.--w , w -- ---- - - n
1 Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 9 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 21 9.4-18 9.4.5.1.3 Added "On a smoke alarm in a division of 4 Lines lost on a Amendment the secondary containment HVAC system, 34 rollover. the HVAC system shall be put into smoke removal mode. To remove smoke from the secondary "to top of paragraph beginning with containment, the exhaust filter..." 22 9.4-24 9.4.5.4.1.2 in second paragraph changed "46 C" to 4 46.1*C consistent with Tier "46.1*C", changed "45*C" to "50*C" in two 1 Table 5.0 and Tier 2 places. Table 2.0-1. 45 C/50*C temperature allows cooling from outside air. 23 9.4-27 9.4.5.5.5 Changed "45 C" to "50 C" 4 See reason foritem 22 above 23a 9.4-54 Figure 9.4-2c Changed " AUX" to " HOUSE" and " GAS" to 3 Inconsistency " COMBUSTION". This aligns the DCD with the SSAR (no difference). 24 9.5-24 9.5.1.3.9 Replaced last sentence with " Fire detection 4 Consistency with Tier 1 and alarm systems are supplied with power from a non-Class 1E uninterruptible power supply." 25 9.5-59 9.5.12.3.3 Removed probabilities at end of first 2c NRC DCD Guidance-paragraph. 26 9A.2-8 and Table 9A.2-1 Changed "SAR" to " Tier 2" at top of fifth 2e NRC DCD Guidance 9A.2-9 column and in note 13. 27 9A.4-53 9A.4.1.1.37(f) Changed "RCWU" to CUW 4 incorrect acronym 9-5 u___
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 9 (Continued) Item ! Pages DCD DCD No. Section Difference Cat. Reason 28 9A.4-48 9A.4.3.2-6(5)(c) Changed "with No. 2 fuel c 1 with min. flash 1 NRC comment point of 377 C" to "with minimum flash of 37.8 C". 29 9A.5-16 9A.5.7 Removed "of the SSAR" in 2 places 2e 29a 9B-15/16 Figure 9B-1 Replaced DCD Figure with SSAR Figure. No 3 inconsistency difference between DCD and SSAR. 9-6
t Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR i Chapter 10 l Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 4 1a 10.2-11 10.2.3.1 Replaced " ASTM A-170" with " ASTM A-370' 1 NRC Comment 4 4 a 4 10-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 11 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 11.2-1 11.2.1.2 At end of second sentence from bottom, 1 NRC comment " receiver tank" changed to " sample tank" and "LCW" inserted in front of " sample tanks". 2 11.2-5 11.2.3.1 Changed second line to read: "... effluent 1 NRC comment from the LCW sample tank or the hot shower i drain sample tanks as indicated...". 3 11.5-3 11.5.1.2 The middle paragraph - sentence changed 1 NRC comment "10CFR20.6" to "10CFR20.1302" and " Amendments 1 and 2" to " Attachments 1 and 2". 4 11.5-20 Table 11.5-1 In fifth column under main streamline tunnel 1 NRC comment area deleted "10-13 o 10-6 Amps". t In fifth column under reactor building vent exhaust deleted "10-2 o 102 mR/h". t In fifth column under drywc!! sump discharge deleted "10-13 o 10-6 Amps". t In fifth column under offgas pretreatment changed "10-2 to 104 Mgy/h" to "10-2 o t 104 mGy/h". 11-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 11 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 5 11.5-22 Table 11.5-2 in fourth column under plant stack discharge 1 NRC comment (normal range) changed "3.51 x 10-9 cpm per MBq/cm3" to "3.51 x 108 cpm per M B q/c m 3, in fifth column under plant stack discharge (normal range) changed "3.7 x 104" to 3.7 x 103 MBq/cm3" to "3.7 x 10-9 o 3.7 x 10-3 t MBq/cm3". l 6 11.5-23 Table 11.5-2 !a fifth column under radwaste building 1 NRC comment ventilation exhaust changed "3.7 x 10-7 o t 3.7 x 10-2 MBq/cm3" to "3.7 x 10-9 o 3.7 x t 10-3 MBq/cm3". 7/7a 11.5-23 Table 11.5-2 Designated footnote in fifth column under 1 NRC comment Standby Gas Treatment System Exhaust - Inline Configuration (added footnote to page 11.5-24). Removed designated footnote to l Offline configuration. 8 11.5-23 Table 11.5-2 In fourth and fifth column under gland 1 NRC comment seal condenser exhaust discharge changed "3.6 x 106" to "1.33 x 109" and "3.7 x 10-7 o 3.7 x 10-2" to "3.7 x 10-9 to t 3.7 x 10-3", respectively. 9 11.5-23 Table 11.5-2 in fourth column under standby gas 1 NRC comment treatment exhaust changed "3.6 x 106" to "1.33 x 109". 9a 11.5-23 Table 11.5-2 Changed " Main" to " Plant" in first entry in 1 NRC Comment fifth column of fifth entry. 11-2
r ~h Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 11 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 10 11.5-24 Table 11.5-2 Added footnote "This dynamic range reflects 1 MRC comment. post-accident conditions; the entry for expected activity in this row is for the expected normal activity, i.e. non-accident." 11 11.5-25 Table 11.5-3 In fourth column.under reactor building 1 NRC comment cooling water intersystem leakage changed from "3.7 x 10-1 to 3.7 x 10-2 MBq/cm3" to "3.7 x 10-7 o 3.7 x 10-2 MBq/cm3". t i i l 1 l w 11-3
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 12 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 12.0-x List of Figures Added "(Gy/h)" to end of title for 1 NRC comment Figure 12.3-74. la 12.2-32 Table 12.2-8 Added "" to "8.9E-1" figure and added 3 Erroneously omitted in 12.2-33 footnote " Multiply by 6 if Hydrogen Water SSAR Chemistry is in use". 1b 12.2-66 Table 12.2-21 "Nanotesla" changed to " Gamma" under Part 3 SSAR Unit conversion A incomplete 2. 12.3-23 12.3.3.1 In first paragraph replaced " Certified Design 2e To make referencing Material (GE document 25A5447)" with consistent " Tier 1". 2a 12.3-26 12.3.4 Replaced "DAC3.7b" with " Table 3.2b of Tier 3 Updated designation 1" 3 12.4-9/10 Table 12.4-1 In second column replaced "SSAR" with 2e NRC Guidance " Tier 2". 12-1
i Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 13 ltem DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason None L 13-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 14 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 14.3-1 thru 14.3 Relabeling consistent with change from 2e NRC DCD Guidance 14.3-23 CDM/SSAR to Tier 1/ Tier 2. 1a 14.2-140 14.2.12.2.9(4) Changed "62.2*C" to "80*C" under level 1. 3 Incorrect conversion 2 14.3-1 1 14.3 Changed last sentence from "... basis for 3 To more closely follow the NRC authorization to load fuel per the language of Part 52. provisions of 10 CFR Part 52.103." to "... basis for the NRC finding under CFR Part 52.103(g)." 2a 14.4-1 14.3 Modified first paragraph to better reflect the 1 NRC Comment Tier 1 information. 2b 14.3-9 14.3 Changed " Table 19.2-1" to " Table 19.8-1 1 NRC Comment and " Table 19.2-7" to Table 19.8-7" at end of first paragraph on page 14.3-9. This change aligns the DCD with the SSAR (No difference). 3 14.3-12 14.3.2.2 Changed first sentence of item (3) from "As 3 To more closely follow the required by 10CFRS2.103, the inspections, language of Part 52. tests, and analyses must be completed..." to "The inspections, tests, and analyses are to be completed...". 3a 14.3-23,24, Tables 14.3-Incorporated editorial comments 1 NRC Comment 26,28,29, 1,2,3,10,11 30,50,58 3b 14.3-59/60 Table 14.3-12 Changed " safety" to " safe" and "RSS design 1 NRC Comment basis " with "as seisrnic". 14-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 14 (Continued)_ _ ltem DCD DCD i L _ _No.! Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason i __t 4 14.3-24 Tables 14.3-1 Right-hand column labeled 'SSAR Value" to 2e NRC DCD Guidance thru thru 14.3-10 " Tier 2 Value". I 14.3-58 L__ __L u- 'I O 14-2 w e e --m
.= Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 15 l Item j DCD l DCD l No. Pages l Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 15.1-5 15.1.2.1.2.2 Replaced "less than once per 10,000 years. 5 Industry initiative It". with "so low that it." 2 15.1-8 15.1.3.1.1 Removed "(less than 7x10-5 failure per 5 Industry Initiative reactor year)" in next to last sentence. 3 15.1-8 15.1.3.1.2.1 Replaced "less than 0.0088 times a year" 5 Industry initiative with "very low frequency". 4 15.1-8 15.1.3.1.2.2 Replaced "less than once per 10,000 years" 5 Industry initiative ~ with " extremely low". 5 15.2-1 15.2.1.1.1 Deleted "less than 7 x 310-5 failures per 5 industry initiative reactor year)" from last, sentence. 6 15.2-1 15.2.1.1.2.1 Deleted "(0.0088 failu s per reactor year)". 5 Industry Initiative - 7 15.2-2 15.2.1.1.2.2 Replaced "less than 7 10-5 per year" with 5 Industry Initiative " extremely low". 8 15.2-5 15.2.2.1.1-Deleted "(less tha one failure every 11 5 Industry initiative years)" from ne to last sentence. 9 15.2-5 15.2.2.1.2.3 Removed pr ability numbers (4 places) 5 industry initiative 10 15.2-9 15.2.3.1.2.3 Modified parbgraph and removed probability 5 Industry initiative numbers (4 gees) 11 15.3-5 15.3.2.1.1 Replaced "(less n 7 x 10-5 failures per 5 Industry initiative year)" with "very lo " in second paragraph. 12 15.3-5 15.3.2.1.2.1 Replaced "about 0.00 failures per reactor 5 Industry initiative year" with "very low" A 15-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 15 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 13 15.3-8 15.4.5.1.1 Replaced "(less than 7 x 10-5 failures per 5 Industry initiative reactor year)" with "very low". 14 15.3-8 15.4.5.1.2.1 Replaced "about 0.0088 failure per reactor 5 Industry initiative year" with "very low". 15 15.4-11 15.4.7.1.2 Rep! aced numerical value of probability with 5 Industry initiative " expected frequency is low". 16 15.4-13 15.4.8.1.2 Removed probability numbers (3 places) 5 Industry initiative 16a 15.6-7 15.6.4.5.1.2 Changed "12,868 kg" to "12,870kg" and 1 NRC Comment, "21,949 kg" with "21,953". inconsistent with Table 15.6-5. 16b 15.6-26 Table 15.6-4 Changed "s5" to "s5.5". 1 NRC Comment, inconsistent with text and Table 15.6-5. 17/17a 15.6-27 Table 15.6-5 Changed "5.Os" to "5.5s" under isolation 4/1 inconsistency with text /NRC valve closure time. Changed " Isolation valve Comment closure time" to "MSIV closure time (break time until fully closed)" under Revision 1. 18/18a 15.6-30 Table 15.6-8 Changed "12" to "2" under item lE 4/1 Correction /NRC Comment particulate. Changed "6.1 Umin" to "66.1 Umin" under item IIA in Revision 1. 19 15B-17 thru 158.4 Rewrote introduction to more firmly, 5 Industry initiative 158-20 and reference chapter 19 and detected 15B-41/42 subsections 15B.4.1 through 158.4.4.2 and Figure 15B-8. 20 15D-2 15D.3.1 Removed "(processor failure rate = 10-5/h)" 5 Industry initiative from the end of item (4) 15-2 2 t m --nn, s,-- ~ v.- ,r e ~ --
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 15 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 21 15D-2 15D.3-2 and Revised text to eliminate probability. 5 Industry initiative 15D.4 22 15D-3 Table 15D-1 and Eliminated figure / table contents and referred 5 Industry Initiative 15D-5 thru Figures 15D-2 thru to SSAR. 15D-8 15D-5 23 1EE-15 Tables 1.CE-12 Replaced "kg/cm2g" with "MPaG" all places. 4 SSAR unit conversion thru 15E-15 incomplete. 15-3 w
l l Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR i Chapter 16 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 Mult Mult The header and footer on each page are 1 NRC comment changed as follows: The GE document number in the header from the SSAR, i 23A6100 Rev. x,is deleted. The SSAR amendment number in the footer is replaced i with "Rev. O Design Control Document / Tier 2" 2 1 = 2 M utt l M utt Where the phrase "of the SSAR"is used to 1 NRC comment describe information in the SSAR, it 'is replaced with the phrase "of the DCD Tier 2". 3 Mult 4.0 Where the phrase "of the SSAR"is used to 2e DCD NRC Guidance 5.0 describe the applicant's SSAR, it is replaced with the phrase "of the FSAR". 4 M utt Mult Where the phrase "in the SSAR, Chapter (or 2 NRC comment Section) x" is used to point to the section of the SSAR, it is replaced with the phrase "in DCD Tier 2. Chapter (or Section) x". _ ). p 5 Mutt Mutt Where the phrase "ABWR SSAR analysis" is 1 DCD intemal consistency used to describe the safety analyses in the SSAR, it is replaced with the phrase "ABWR safety analysis". 4 6 Mult Mult Where the phrase " transient or accident 1 DCD intemal consistency j analysis in the ABWR SSAR"is used with no l specific chapter or section reference, it is replaced with the phrase " transient or 3 accident analysis for the ABWR". 16-1 i -,-,.n. .~ ~ - - + - -. - - s
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR 1 Chapter 16 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section - Difference Cat. Reason 7 Mult B 3.8 Where the phrase " described in the SSAR" 2e NRC DCD Guidance is used to refer to Chapter 8 of the SSAR, it is replaced with the phrase " described in l DCD Tier 2, Chapter 8". 8 Mult Mult V!here the phrase " requirement of Section x 2e NRC DCD Guidance of the SSAR" is used to refer to certain requirement specified in the SSAR, it is replaced with the phrase " requirements of DCD Tier 2, Section x". 8a* 3.3-1, 3.3 Numbering of Required Action for Condition 1 Renumbering was 3.3-2, A of LCO 3.3.1.1 "A.2.1" changed to necessary to reflect the B3.3-61 "A.2.1.1", "A.2.2" changed to "A.2.1.2", proper use of Logical through "A.2.3" changed to "A.2.2.1", and "A.2.4" Connectors. B3.3-64 changed to "A.2.2.2". 8b* 3.3-1, 3.3 The Logical Connectors (AND, OR) were 1 Proper indentation of logical 3.3-2, aligned to be consistent with the convention connectors. 3.3-3, defined in Section 1.2, Logical Connectu 3.3-6, 3.3-6, 3.3-18, 3.3-19, 3.3-21, 3.3-28, 3.3-29, 3.3-47, 3.3-48, 3.3-53, 3.3-68, 3.3-69 e . 2 -w-w- ~.--ae ,-s,- -,,,--<.-wnwe.-e,--,-wwwm n .w,,-.-e-, ,--x-e. e-~, -w---w,-- ~,. ---~,-,~~-=<,--i-
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 16 (Continued) 1 Item DCD DCD 4 l No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 8c' 3.3-42 3.3 Changed unit of SR 3.3.2.1.3 from "HZ" to 3 Inconsistent unit. " Cps l " cps". used here is neutron counts per second, not cycles per j second. 8d* 3.5-2, 3.5 Numbering of Required Action for Condition 1 Renumbering was B3.5-9, C of LCO 3.5.1 was changed from "C.1.1" to necessary to reflect the I B3.5-10 "C.1.1.1", "C.1.2" changed to "C.1.1.2, "C.2" proper use of Logical changed to "C.1.2", and "C.3" changed to Connectors. "C.2". i 8e* 3.6-41 3.6 Logical connector AND in Required Action 3 Proper indentation of logical for Condition D of LCO 3.6.4.3 was re-connectors. aligned. 8f' 3.7-4 3.7 Loaical AND for Required Action for 3 Logical connector was l Cc Jition B of LCO 3.7.2 was added. missing. 9 3.7-3, 3.7.1.3, 3.7.2.3, Changed UHS temperature from "37.8 C" to 3 UHS temperature of 3.7-4, 3.7.3.3, and "35 C". subsection 9.2.5 changed 3.7-8, and B3.7.1 from 37.8 C to 35 C. l B3.7-4 10 B 3.3-51 B 3.3.1.1 in item 19, Main Steam Pressure-Low, 3 Inconsistent unit Applicable Safety Analyses, LCO, and l Applicability, the use of the term "100 F/ hour"is changed to "55 C/h"; the use of the term "785 psig" is changed to "5.41 MPaG". In item 22, Main Steam 1 Tunnel Temperature-High, the term "25 gpm" is changed to "95 ilmin".
- Includes FAXs from C. Tang (GE) to N Giles (NRC) dated November 22 and 23.1994.
I 16-3 l . ~ -. - ~... . ~.. - -. - -
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 16 (Continued)_ _ lte m DCD i DCD i No. j Pages j Section Difference Cat. Reason L. 11 B3.3-146 B3.3.2.1 From third line in last paragraph removed 4 Correction "one bypassed channel in each division and one" l 12 B 3.3-167 B 3.3.4.1 in item 3, SB&PC Reactor Steam Dome 3 Inconsistent unit ~ Pressure-High, Applicable Safety Analysis, LCO, and Applicability, the term "1500 psig" is changed to "10.34 MPaG". I 13 8 3.3-237 B 3.3.8.2 In Background section, the term "135 psig" is 3 Inconsistent unit changed to "0.93 MPaG" l 16-4 ,.n..
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 17 3-. r-l No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason I 1 17.0-1 17.0 Deleted "of this Standard Safety Analysis 2e NRC DCD Guidance Report" from first sentence. i~ la l 17.3-6 17.3.11.1 Changed '8.6 MPa" to '8.6 MPaG" 1 NRC Comment 17-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR 1 Chapter 18 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1/1a 18E-1 18E.1 Added italicized second paragraph and 2a/3 NRC DCD Guidance / footnote. Added " Staff" after "NRC" in third Clarification l line of second paragraph in Revision 1. J 2 18E-1 18E.2 and 18E.3 Italicized entire sections and added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 18E-5 3 18E-7 Table 18E-1 Italicized entire table and added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance thru 18E-28 3a 18E-23 Table 18E-1 Added item xiii(NUREG-0800) 1 NRC Comment 4 18E-29 to Italicized entire attachment and added 2a NRC DCD Guidance { thru 18E-35 Table 18E-1 footnote j 5 18E-36 thru Table 18E-2 Italicized entire tables and added footnote 2a NRC DCD Guidance l 18E-40 thru Table 18E-4 5a 18A.6-8 Table 1 Changed "SGTS(A)' to SGTS(B)*, 3 Inconsistent with P&lDs i i 18F-5 Table 18F "SGTS(B)* to "SGTS(C)", "FCS(A)" to r i 18F-6 "FCS(B)", and "FCS(B)" to "FCS(C)" i 18F-7 18F-10 18F-12 i I I: ) 18-1 =. -
-o Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 Ite m DCD j DCD No. Pages { Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 15.1-2 19.1.2 Deleted numerical probabilities (4 places). 5 Industry initiative Substituted word values (2 places). 2 19.2-1 and 19.2.2 and Replaced this SSAR" with " Tier 2" 2e NRC DCD Guidance 19.2-2 19.2.3.1 3 19.3-1 19.3.1.1 Removed "two events per year. This total 5 Industry initiative consists of one planned reactor shutdown and one transient which results in reactor scram. The expected number of planned shutdowns is" from the second paragraph. l Removed "are the same as those used in -{ the GESSARll PRA (Reference 19.3.3) and" l from the third paragraph 4 19.3-1 19.3.1.2 Deleted Subsections 19.3.1.2.1 through 5 Industry Initiative 19.3.1.2.3 and inserted statement "not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 5 19.3-12 19.3.1.5 Eliminated probability values in first 5 Indust.y Initiative paragraph. 6 19.3-18 19.3.2.6 Replaced "no more than 10%" with "a small 5 Industry Initiative percentage" in last paragraph. 7 19.3-20 19.3.2.12 Replaced "of 1.6E-7 per year" with "is 5 Industry initiative extremely small". 8 19.3-23, Tables 19.3-1, Deleted frequencies and added footnote 'S Industry Initiative 19.3-29 19.3-4 thru 19.3-6 referring to SSAR. thru 19.3-31 9 19.3-33 Figure 19.3-2 Deleted body of figure and added footnote 5 Industry initiative referring to SSAR. 19-1
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR I Chapter 19 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 10 19.4-3 19.4.2 Removed probabilities in three placed and 5 Industry initiative inserted word values in two places. t 11 19.4-5 19.4.3.1.1 Removed "of the SSAR" two places. 2e Industry Initiative 12 19.4-11 19.4.4 Removed last two sentences of second 5 Industry Initiative paragraph. 13 19.4-12 19.4.4 Eliminated two probability values in last 5 Industry initiative paragraph. 14 19.4-12 and 19.4.5 Eliminated six probability values. 5 Industry Initiative 19.4-13 15 19.4-13 19.4-6 Replaced "10-7 per year" with "very small". 5 Industry initiative 15a 19.5-1 19.5-1 Replaced "LPCl" with "RHR". 4 Industry initiative 15b 19.5-3/4 19.5.3 Deleted " Examining the data in Table 19.3-6, the CCFP Pi is 0.007. Therefore," from the fourth paragraph. 16 19.6-1 19.6.2 and 19.6.3 Eliminated probability values in 5 places. 5 Industry initiative 17 19.6-3 19.6.5 Eliminated probability values in 2 places in 5 Industry initiative the next to last paragraph. 18 19.6-4 thru 19.6.7, Eliminated prebability values in ten places. 5 Industry initiative 19.6-5 19.6.8, 19.6.8.1, 19.6.8.3, and 19.6.9 19 19.7-1 19.7.3 Replaced two numerical probabilities with 5 Industry initiative word values. 19-2
0 Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 20 19.8-1 19.8 Replaced "the Certified Design Material 2e NRC DCD Guidance (Section 14.3)" with " Tier 1". Inserted "important" in front of " features are addressed by ITAAC...". Modified last sentence of second paragraph. 21 19.8-2 thru 19.8 Eliminated all probability values 5 Industry initiative 19.8-24 22 19.8-24 19.8.7 Changed "Section" to " Attachment" and 2e NRC DCD Guidance deleted "of the ABWR SSAR" under vessel depressurization". 23/23a 19.8-35 Table 19.8-4 Change "(2.15.210)" to "(2.15.10" under 4/1 Correction /NRC Comment blowout panels. 24 19.8-41/42 Table 19.8-7 Changed "2% per 100 F" to "2% per 55.6 C" 4 Conversion 25 19.9-7 9.9.10 Replaced "(i.e., less than one foot) and also 4 Clarification prevent accumulation in one area flowing to "with in" under item (3) (b). 26 19.9-7 19.9.11(8) Removed "with an unavailability of 1E-3 per 5 Industry initiative demand or less". 27 19.10-3 19.10.5 Deleted second sentence. 5 Industry initiative 28 19.10-3 and 19.10.7 Deleted "as 0.99" in second sentence, and 5 Industry initiative 19.10-4 deleted from third sentence on. 29 19.13-3 19.3.5 Deleted second sentence in first paragraph. 5 Industry initiative 30 19A-1 19A.1 Replaced "SSAR" with " Tier 2" in 2 places. 2e NRC DCD Guidance 19-3
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason { 31 13A-21 thru Table 19A-1 Changed "SSAR" to " Tier 2" in right hand 2e NRC DCD Guidance i 19A-23/24 column 32 19B-1 thru Safety issues Changed "SSAR" to " Tier 2" in right hand 2e NRC DCD Guidance 19B-7 Index column. 33 198-8, 198.2.2 and Replaced "SSAR" with " Tier 2" 2e incomplete units cor> version 198-11 19B.2.45 198-80, 198-83 34 198-77 19.B.2.43 Changed "2.3E+0lKg (23 ionnes) to 3 3RC DCD Guidance "2.26+05 N". 35 198-119 19B.2.68 Removed "For the SSAR" 2e NRC DCD Guidance 36 19C-1/2 19C Replaced " Safeguards information provided 2d NRC DCD Guidance under separate cover" with "This section is not part of the DCD (refer to SSAR)." 37 19D-1/2 19D Removed entire Appendix 19D and replaced. 5 Industry initiative with "This section not part of the DCD (refer to SSAR)." 38 19E.1-1/2 19E.1 Deleted "primarily" in front of the word 5 Industry initiative deterministic in the first line 39 19E.2-11 19E.2.1.2.3, Modified statement pertaining to 5 Industry initiative thru 19E.2.1.2.3.1.1, probabilities. 19.E.2-13 19E.2.1.2.3.1.2 19E.2.1.2.3.1.3 40 19E.2-15 19E.2.1.2.3.2.1 Replaced "LPCl* with "LPFL". 4 Correction 19E.2-19 19E.2.1.2.3.3 19-4 e-ev ,y=-.-e.. ~4+-ww-4 ..m-- ,,, -. - +. - - - -
- er$~.r-
+ e -.m-w~e
==.c---- s w.e---.w ,-.--.w-i e ..-== ---
.,..d Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR ~ Chapter 19 (Continued) l Item DCD j DCD
- No.
Pages l Section Difference Cat. Reason u 41 19E.2-19 19E.2.1.2.3.3(2) Deleted "of the SSAR* 2e NRC DCD Guidance 42 19.E.2-22 19E.2.1.2.3.3(10) Added " exceed" in front of "0.46 MPa". 4 Correction i 43 19E.2-25 19E.2.1.3.3 Modified second sentence to eliminate 5 Industry initiative failure rate and melded the second and third sentence for clarification. r_ - 44 19E.2-32 19E.2.1.5.2.7, Eliminated probability values and replaced - 5 Industry Initiative j thru 19E.2.1.5.2.13, them with word values. 19E.2-36 19E.2.1.5.3.1, 19E.2.1.5.3.2, l 19E.2.1.5.3.3 f 45 19E-36 19E.2.2 Eliminated probability values and replaced 5 Industry initiative 19E-37 19E.2 2.1 them with word values. l 19E-44 19E.2.2.2 19E-46 19E-48 19E-49 46 19E-52 19E.2.2.3 Replaced probability values with word 5 Industry initiative 19E-54 19E.2.2.5 values. 19E-55 19E.2.2.6 19E-56 19E.2.2.8 19E-57 19E-60 19E-61 47 19E.2-73 19E.2.3.3.1 Replaced numerical values of probability - 5 Industry initiative l 19E.2-77 with word values I 19-5 1
) Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) i item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 48 19E.2-82 19E.2.3.3.3(2) Eliminated numerical probabilities in items 5 Industry initiative 19E.2-83 (a), (b), (e), (f), (g), (h), (i), and (k). 19E.2-84 49 19E.2-85 19E.2.3.3.3(4) Modified first paragraph to eliminate 5 Industry Initiative - probabilities. 50 19E.2-86 19E.2.3.3.4 Modified items (1) and (2) to eliminate 5 Industry initiative 19E.2-87 probabilities. 19E.2-88 19E.2-89 51 19E.2-101 19E.2.3.5.3.4 Deleted "the ABWR SSAR" from the first 2e NRC DCD Guidance f sentence. 52 19E.2-105 19E.2.3.6.1 Replaced numerical values of probability 5 Industry initiative 19E.2.107 19E.2.3.6.4 with word values. 53 19E.2-108 19E.2.4 Replaced "no" with "early" in second 4 Clarification sentence. l 54 19E.2-128 19E.2.6.5.2 Replaced numerical values of probabilities 5 Industry Initiative 19E.2-129 19E.2.6.7 with word values. 19E.2-131 19E.2.6.9 19E.2-132 19E.2.6.10 19E.2-137 19.E.2.7.2 i 19E.2-138 19E.2.7.3 19E.2-140 19E.2.8.1 19E.2-141 19E.2.8.1.1 i I 19-6
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 54 19E.2-142 19E.2.8.1.2 (cont) 19E.2-143 19E.2.8.1.4 19E.2-144 19 E.2.8.1.7 i 19E.2-146 19E.2.8.2.7 19E.2-152 19E.2-153 55 19E.2-174 Table 19E.2-20 Eliminated probabilities and added note 5 Industry Initiative 19E.2-175 19E.2-21 " probabilities not part of DCD (refer to 19E.2-184 19E.2-26 SSAR)". 19E.2-185 19E.2-27 19E.2-28 56 19E.3-259 Figures 19E.2-19a Removed information from body of figures 5 Industry initiative thru thru 19E.2-22 and added note "Not part of DCD (refer to 19E.2-274 SSAR)". 57 19E.3-1 19E.3.1.1 Replaced "98.6%" with "a very large 5 Industry initiative percentage" in second paragraph. 58 19E.3-3 19E.3.2.2 Replaced "the SSAR" with " Tier 2" in first 2e NRC DCD Guidance paragraph. 59 19E.3-6 Table 19E.3-1, Removed probabilities and added note 2c Industry initiative 19E.3-9 19E.3-6 and " Probabilities not part of DCD (refer to 19E.3-10 19E.3-7 SSAR)". 60 19E.3-11 Figure 19E.3-1 Removed body of figure and added note 5 Industry initiative " Figure is not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 19-7 h ummmme
j Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued)__ l Ite:n : DCD DCD {No. ] Pages
- Sectior, Difference Cat.
Reason 61 19EA-5 19EA.2.1.3 Removed numerical probabilities and, where 5 Industry initiative 19EA-7 19EA.2.1.5 applicable, replaced with word values. 19EA-9 19EA.2.1 G 19EA-10 4 19EA-11 62 19EA-24 19EA.3.S.2 Removed numerical probabilities and, where 5 Industry Initiative 19EA-27 19EA-4.1 applicable, replaced with word values. 19EA-28 19EA-4.2 19EA-4.2.1 63 19EA-32 Figures 19EA-1 Deleted body of figures and added note 5/1 Industry Initiative /NRC DCD thru thru 19EA-6, " Figures not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". Guidance 4 "d (included deleting body of Figure 19EA-2 in i 19EA-39 19E -9 Revision 1). 19EA-40 19EA-14 } 19EA-45 19EA-15 19EA-46 2 l 64 19EB-2 19EB.1.1 Replaced numerical probabilities with word 5 Industry initiative 19EB-3 values. l 65 19EC-4 19EC.2.1.1 Removed probabilities and added note 5 Industry Initiative i " Probabilities not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 4 t 19-8 c. -m- ,,.,w-..-~,--*e. -,,,v,-,,-..w .,,-ew--... vv--~~--r- --._,,-,.-,3-, e --.,_w,, y. v.
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) item ! DCD DCD l No. l Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason i 66 19EC-5 19EC.2.1.2 Removed numerical probabilities and, where 5 Industry Initiative thru 19EC.2.1.3 applicable, replaced with word values. 19EC-14 19EC.2.1.5 19EC.2.1.6 i 19EC.2.1.7 l 19EC.2.2.2 l 19EC.2.2.3 19EC.2.2.4 19EC.2.2.5 67 19EC-29 Figures 19EC-1 Removed body of figures and added note 5 Industry initiative i 19EC-30 19EC-2 " Probabilities not part of DCD (refer to 19EC-36 18EC-8 SSAR)". } 68 18EE-3 19EE.2.1 Removed vacuum breaker related 5 Industry Initiative 19EE-5 19EE.2.2 probabilities 19EE-6 19EE.2.3 l 69 l 19EE-11 19 EE.4.1 Replaced numerical probabilities with word 5 Industry initiative 19EE-12 19EE.4.4 values. 19EE-13 19EE.5 70 19EE-17 Table 19EE-2 Removed probabilities and added note 5 Industry initiative " Probabilities not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 71 19EE-16 Figures 19EE-1 Removed body of figures and added note 5 Industry Initiative 19EE-17/18 and 19EE-2 " Probabilities not part of DCD (Refer to SSAR)". 72 19FA-1/2 19FA Removed attachment 19FA and added note 5 Industry initiative "This attachment is not part of the DCD (refer to SSAR)." 19-9
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 73 19H-14 19H.3.3 Deleted last sentence of first paragraph. 5 Industry initiative 74 19H-15 19H.4.2 Deleted last sentence of last paragraph and 5 Industry initiative last sentence of fourth to last paragraph. 75 19H-17 19H.5.1 Changed "the SSAR" to " Tier 2" and 2e Industry Initiative "lTAAC" to " Tier 1". 76 19H-23 Table 19H-1 Changed " probability" to " fragility" in footnote 5 Industry initiative 1 and modified footnote 5 eliminate specific values. 77 19H-24 Table 19H-2 Removed fragilities and added note " Fragility 5 Industry Initiative thru thru 19H-10 not part of DCD. Refer to SSAR". 19H-32 78 1 91-2 1 91.2 Removed fragilities and corresponding 5 Industry Initiative 1 91-3 1 91.3.2 probabilities. 19I-4 1 91.3.3 1 91-5 1 91.4 1 91-8 1 91.5.2 1 91-9 1 91.6 191-10 1 91.7 79 191-11 Table 191-1 Removed fragilities and HCLPF values from 5 Industry initiative 191-12 table and extended note to read " Fragilities 191-13 and HCLPF values are not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 80 191-14 Table 191-2 Remove body of tables and added note 5 Industry initiative "This table is not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 19-10
O Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 81 191-15 Table 191-3 Fragilities and HCLPF values deleted from 5 Industry Initiative table and added note " Fragilities and HCLPF values are not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)." 82 191-16 Table 191-4 Body of table deleted and added note "This 5 adustry initiative table is not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 83 191-17/18 Figures 191-1 Deleted figures and added note " Figures 5 Industry initiative thru 191-25 191-1 through 191-25 are not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 84 19K-2 19K.3 Replaced numerical probability valves with 5 Industry initiative 19K-5 19K.5 word valves. 19K-8 19K.11.1 19K-12 19K.11.5 19K-17 19K.11.14 85 19K-19 Tables 19K-1, Removed numerical values from tables and 5 Industry initiative thru 19K-2 and 19K-3 added note "Not part of DCD (refer to 19K-21 SSAR)* 86 19K-22 thru Table 19K-4 Removed numerical values in right hand 5 Industry initiative 19K-31/32 column and added note "Not part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 87 19L-1 19L.3 Replaced 'the ABWR Safety Analysis Report 2e Industry initiative (SSAR)" with " Tier 2". 88 19L-2 189L.3 Replaced numerical probability value with 5 Industry initiative word value. 89 19L-3 19L.4.2 Removed 'SSAR". 2e NRC DCD Guidance 90 19L-8 19L.5.3 Removed last sentence from item (3). 4 Clarification / correction 19-11
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued) 6 Item DCD DCD l l No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason ___e._____ i 91 19L-8 19L.5.3 Removed probability statement in last 5 Industry initiative paragraph. f ~ 92 19L-8 15L.5.4 Changed " third" to "second" in first item (1). 4 Correction 93 19L-20 19L.7.3 Changed "one" to "two" diesel generations at 4 Correction end of first paragraph and deleted "one" t under item (b). i 94 19L-21 19L.7.3 Deleted probabilities in second paragraphs. 5 Industry Initiative 95 19L-21/22 19L.8.2 Deleted "SSAR*. 2e NRC DCD Guidance 19L.8.3 96 19L-23 19L.8.4 Replaced numerical values of probabilities 5 Industry initiative 19L-24 19L.9.2 with word values. 97 19M-1 19M.1 Replaced numerical probability values with 5 Industry Initiative 19M-2 19M.3 word values. 19M-3 19M.4.1.1 19M-7 19M.4.2.5 19M-8 97a 19M-1 19M.1 Changed "small marg:n" to " small criterion" 1-NRC Comment in Revision 1 98 19M-9 19M.5.2 Removed frequencies and added note "Not 5 Industry Initiative 19M-10 part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 99 19M-10 19M.6.2 Replaced numerical values of probabilities 5 Industry initiative 19M-11 with word values. 19M-12 1 1 19-12 1 ,nm-n.-,-.,-,,a-n.- e - - - - ~. ..,ne+~,.. ,,~--,-,m-- .-w . - - - - = -.,. m.--,,-, . > -. - + , -.,, - +, ,.w <. -. - - - ~-, ,,v..rr,. --.+---,--.~m.- w,,
l i i i Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Continued)_ _____ _ I Item DCD DCD l No. j Pages l Section Difference Cat. Reason s ___ _ i j j 100 19M-13 Table 19M-1 Removed frequencies and added note "Not 5 Industry initiative j 19M-33 19M-11 part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 1 I thru 19M-12 19M-35 19M-13 i 19M-14 i t_ 101 19M-16 Table 19M-3 Deleted body of tables and added note "Not. 5 Industry initiative thru thru part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". j 19M-33 Table 19M-5 w i 102 19M-38 Figure 19M-3 ' Deleted body of figures and added note "Not 5 Industry initiative thru thru 19M-13 a part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". i 19M-48 i 103 19N-1 19N.1 Removed numerical probabilities. 5 Industry Initiative i 19N-12 19N.5.1 l 19N-13 r 104 19N-15 19N.5.4.2 Replaced numerical probabilities with word 5 Industry initiative 19N-17 19N.6 values. 19N-18 19N.7 l i l105/105a' 19P-1/2 19P Removed Appendix 19P in its entirety and 5 Industry initiative added note "This section is not part of the j DCD (Refer to Attachment A of the Technical j Support Document for the ABWR). Attachment A of the Technical Support j Document for the ABWR is not incorporated by reference in the DCD." ) 106 190-2 190.2 In last paragraph replaced "the SSAR* with 2e NRC DCD Guidance i " Tier 2" and replaced "the inspections, Test, Analysis, and Acceptance Criteria (ITAAC Requirement)" with " Tier 1*. l l 19-13 l
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR 8 Chapter 19 (Cont.) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 4 107 190-3 190.3 Replaced numerical probability values w?th 5 lodustry initiative 190-4 word values. i 108 190-21 190.6 Replaced numerical probability values with 5 Industry Initiative 190-23 190.7.2 word values. I 190-25 190.7.3 190-26 190.7.5 190-31 190.7.9.1 190-33 190.7.9.3 190.7.9.4 190.7.9.5 l 109 190-45 190.12.4 Removed unavailability values from table 5 Industry initiative and added note "Not a part of DCD (refer to SSAR)." 1 l 110 190-57 Figures 190-1 Removed all figures and replaced with note 5 Industry initiative thru thru 190-19 " Figures 190-1 through 190-19 are not part i 190-75/76 of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 111 190A-1 Figures 190A-1a Removed all figures and replaced with note 5 Industry Initiative i thru thru 190A-20 ck " Figures 19A-la through 190A-20 ck are not 190A-412 part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 112 1908-5 Tables 190B-3 Removed probabilities and added note "Not 5 Industry initiative 190B-6 190B-4 part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 113 190C-29 Table 1900-2 Removed "ABWR" in fifth column under 4 Correction Susquehanna 1 entry. 114 19R-1 19R.1 Replaced numerical values of probability 5 Industry initiative 19R-2 with word values. 19R-3 l 19-14 ,-~r., ,--,,,-.w--- -,, - - ~ e
u-,
~ Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 19 (Cont.) Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 115 19R-4 19R4.4 Replaced "SSAR" with " Tier 2". 5 Industry Initiative l 19R-24 19.R.S.4.2 l 116 19R-9 19R.4.3 Replaced "2 hours" with "several hours" in 5 Industry Initiative fourth paragraph. 117 19R-21 19R.5.3 Replaced numerical probabilities with word 5 Industry Initiative 19R-22 19R.5.4.1 values. 19R-25 19R.5.4.2 19R-27 19R.5.5.1 19R-28 19R.5.5.2 19R-29 19R.6.1 19R-30 19R.6.4 19R-31 19R.6.6 118 19R-31 19R.6.5 Deleted reliability goals and added note "Not 5 Industry Initiative a part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". i 118a 19R-33 Table 19R-1 Changed"(200,00 gal)" to "(200,000 gal)" 1 NRC Comment under feedwater. 119 19R-35 Tables 19R-3 Frequency / probability deleted and added 5 Industry Initiative thru 19R-37 thru 19R-6 note "Not a part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 120 19R-47 thru Figures 19R-7 thru Removed body of figures and added note 5 Industry initiative 19R-53/54 19R-13 " Note a part of DCD (refer to SSAR)". 4 a N 19-15
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 20 item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 20.1-1 20.0 Added new paragraph on relationship of 2e NRC DCO Guidance SSAR and Tier 2 " names" in Chapter 20. 2 20.3.8-37 Response 420.69 Italicized item (1) and added footnote. 2a NRC DCD Guidance 3 20.3.8-51 Response 420.92 Italicized third and last paragraphs of 2a NRC DCD Guidance and response and added footnotes. 20.3.8-52 h 4 20.3.12-5 Response 725.66 Removed event / frequency table from end of 5 Industry initiative response. 5 20.3.15-37 Responses 910.17 Changed notation " Response to this 2d NRC DCD Guidance thru thru 910.15 question is provided under separate cover" 20.3.15-39 to " Safeguards Information not part of DCD 1 (see SSAR Subsection 20.3.15)". 6 20.3.9-1 Responses 725.1 Deleted responses and added " Response to 5 Industry initiative thru thru 725.61 Chapter 19" questions not part of DCD (see 20.3.9-SSAR Subsection 20.3.9)". 15/16 7 20.3.11-10 Responses Deleted responses and added " Response to 5 Industry initiative thru 420.131 thru Chapter 19 questions not part of DCD" (See 20.3.11-420.135 SSAR Subsystem 20.3.11). 11/12 8 20.3.12-1 Responses 725.62 Deleted responses and added " Response to 5 Industry initiative i thru thru 725.94 Chapter 19 questions not part of DCD" (see l 20.3.12-SSAR Subsection 20.3.12). 9/10 9 20.3.14-29 Responses 621.1 Deleted responses and added " Response to 5 Industry Initiative thru through 621.11 Chapter 19 questions not part of DCD" (see 20.3.14-32 SSAR Subsection 20.3.14). 20-1 l -e ,a., .--n n. ..e-- n
Differences Between ABWR DCD and SSAR Chapter 21 Item DCD DCD No. Pages Section Difference Cat. Reason 1 21-35 and Figures 1.2-25, Changed figure to show 3 TCW heat 3 Figure 1.2-25 inconsistent 21-26 1.2-26 exchangers and pumps. with text and Figure 9.2-6a. 2 21-103 and Figures 5.4-10 Italicized note 32 and 29, respectively and 2a NRC DCD Guidance 21-127 (Sheet 1) and added footnotes. 6.3-7 (Sheet 1) 3 21-516 Figure 9.2-1 Removed RCW from lower right-hand of 3 Conflicting figures show Sheet 9 figure. TGSC cooled by both RWC system and condensate feedwater system. Traditionalis with condensate feedwater system and agrees with URD requirements. 3a 21-543 Figure 9.4-4 Replaced " Essential" with " Safety-Related" 1 NRC Comment 21-544 Sheets 1,2 and 3 in title. 21-545 21-1
y .{ A'ITACHMENT 4 ' i ABWR Design Control Document Revision 1. Page Change Instruction The following pages have been changed, please make the changes in your copy of the Design Control Document. Pages are listed below as page pairs (front and back), except Chapter 16, which is single-sided pages only. Remove Pares Add Pares Remove Pares Add Pages Replace the cover sheet in each volume [ 1.8 29,30 1.8-29,30 Introduction 1.8-34.1 1.8-34.1 1.8-35 thru 1.8-35 thru 1.(ki/ii 1.0-i/ii 1.8-48 1.8-48 1.0-iii/iv 1.8-51,52 1.8-51,52 1.(L5 thni 1.0-5 thni 1.0-13/14 1.0-13/14 Chapter 2 2.0-1, 2 2.0-1, 2 Tier i 2.S1, 2 2.S1, 2 i 2.7.1-3, 4 2.7.13,4 2.S5, 6 2.S5, 6 2.8.11/2 2.8.11/2 2.8.Sl/2 2.8.3-1/2 Chapter 3 2.8.4-1, 2 2.8.4-1, 2 3,o_;;;fiv 3,o_;;;fjy - -l 2.I2.14 3,4 2.I2.14-3,4 l 2.I5.5-15,16 2.15.5-15, I fi 3,33,4 3,g3, 4
- 2. 5.lfh3 thni 2.15.10-3 thru 2.15.10-16 2.15.10-16 3.7 39,40 3.7-39,40
- 2. I n 12-3, 4 2.15.12-3,4 '
t 2.15.12 5,6 2.15.12-5, 6 3 M 1,42 SM1,42 2.15.12 9,10 2.15.12 9,10 3.W59,60 3.8-59,60 3.21 thiu 3.2-1 thni 3.2. I 6 3.2-16 'I 3.9 29,30 3.9-29,30 S tL1,2 5.01,2 3.9-31,32 3.9-31,32 3.9-35,36 3.9-35,36 l Tici 2 3.ib55,56 3.9-55,56 l Replace the Tier 2 Table ofuntents pages in 3.!b83,84 3.9-83,84 l solunies 3 through 25 3.9-87,88 3.9-87,88 l 3.9-121,122 3.9-121,122 TOC
- i. ii i, ii 311.1-3, 4 311.1 3, 4 m.w m.w 311.1 5, fi 311.1-5, 6 t
311.1 1, 8 311,1-7, 8 Chapter I i 311.1 13, 14 311.1-13,14 l l m...,n 1.(b...i, n 311,1 15, 16 311.1-15,16 i I 1.13.I 1.13,4 1 t (II 4
if, e ABWR Design Control Document Revision 1. Page Change Instruction The following pages have been changed, please make the changes in your copy of the Design Control Document. Pages are listed below as page pairs (front and back), except Chapter 16, which is single-sided pages only. l Remove Pares Add Pages Remove Pares Add Pages 31-I.2 1, 2 311.2-1, 2 7.2 55,56 7.2-55,56' Si1.2-5, 6 311.2-5, 6 j SI1.2-11,12 311.2-11,12 7.S95,96 7.S95,96 311.2-29,30 Sil.2-29, 30 l 7.G7,8 7.67,8 Sil.S1,2 Sil.S1,2 311.S 5, 6 311.3-5, 6 7.7-49,50 7.7-49,50 SK-1 thm SK-1 thnt 7A-3 thnt 7A 3 thru 3K-6 SK-6 7A.10 7A-10 Chapter 4 71kl thn 71k1 thru 4.2-5, 6 4.25,6 71k6 71L6 4.2-7, 8 4.2-7, 8 { Chapter 9 Chapter 5 9.0-vii/viii. 9.0-vil/viii 5.2 41,42 5.2-41,42 5.2 43,44 5.2-43,44 9.2 11,12 9.2-11,12 5.2-45,46 5.2-45,46 9.2-57,58 9.2-57,58 5.2-53,54 5.2 53,54 9.S9,10 9.S9,10 i Chanter 6 9.S17,18 9.S-17,18 6.2-81,82 6.2-81,82 9.321,22 9.S21,22 6.2-83,84 6.2 83,84 9.S23,24 9.S23,24 6.245,86 6.245,86 9.S35,36 9.S35,30 9.S53,54 9.S53,54 6.S29,30 6.S29,30 91bl5/16 91kl5/16 6.71,2 6.71,2 Chapter 10 l 6C 5,6 6C 5, 6 10.2 11,12 10.2-11,12 Chapter 7 Chapter 1I i 7.11,2 7.11,2 Section 11.2 is being reissued as Rev. O, due to an i 7.1-3, 4 7.13,4 assembly error in the presious revision. l -=
, <eo ABWR Design Control Document Revision I-Page Change Instmetion The following pages have been changed, please make the changes in your copy of the Design Control Document. Pages are listed below as page pairs (front and back), except Chapter 16, which is single-sided pages only. Remme Paces Add Pacen Remove Paces Add Paces Tier 2(Cont.) 3.S21 3.S21 11.21 thru 11.21 thru 3.S28 3.3-28 11.2-12 11.2 12 3.S29 3.S29 3.S-12 3.S42 11.5-23,24 11.5-23,24 3.3-47 3.S47 3.S48 3.3-48 Chapter 12 3.S53 3.3-53 12.2 31, 32 12.2 31,32 3.%H 3.%8 12.2 33, 34 12.2 33,34 3 %9 3.%9 12.2-65,66 12.2-65,66 3.5-2 3.5-2 12.3-25,26 12.S25,26 3 6-41 3.441 Chapter 14 1 l 0-iii, iv 14.0-iii, iv 3.7 I 3.7-4 l l l 2-139,140 14.2 139.140 113 SGI 113.3-61 11 3. % 2 11 3. % 2 14.Sl thru 14 Sl thru 153 %3 113.163 1-1 S59/60 14.S59/60 [g3 g; ig3,g.g Chapter 15 113.5-9 B3.5-9 15 4-7, H 15.4-7, M B3.5-10 B3.5-10 15 (L7, H 15.6-7, H Chapter 17 15 425,26 15IL25,26 17.0-i, ii 17.0-i, ii 15iL27,28 15.6-27,28 1;eL29,30 15.429,30 17.3-5,6 17.3-5,6 Chapter 16 Chapter 18 3 Siibiu 3.Sl thru 18A l/2 18A 1/2 1MA 6-7,H 18A.47,8 333 3 33 3 S5 3 S5 l H E-1, 2 18E 1,2 3w 3y lHE 23,24 18E-23,24 3 3ig 3 y;g 3 Sl9 3 S19 (3)
,s.* i ABWR Design Control Document Revision 1. Page Change Instnaction The following pages have been changed, please make the changes in your copy of the Design Control Document. Pages are listed below as page pairs (front and back), except Chapter 16, which is single-sided pages only. l ' Remove Pares Add Pares Remove Pares Add Pages Tier 2 (Cont.) 18F-5 thru 18F-5 thru 18F 12 18F12 Chapter 19 19.8-35,36 19.8-35,36 19FA-33, 34 19FA 33,34 i 19M1,2 19M 1,2 19P-1/2 19P-1/2 i 19R-33, 34 19R 33,34 i Chapter 20 The following chapter 20 pages are being reissued f as Rev. O because of an assembly error in the i prenous revision. 20.2.9-29 thru 20.2.9-29 thru 20.2.9-34 20.2.9-34 i Chapter 21 Drawines f Replace the TOC page in volumes 26 through 31 1 TOC pg 4 TOC pg 4 21-543 21-543 21-544 21 544 21 545 21-545 i (4) _.}}