ML20078E133
| ML20078E133 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 09/28/1983 |
| From: | Lubbock D PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | CALIFORNIA, STATE OF |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8310050396 | |
| Download: ML20078E133 (66) | |
Text
.
4 u, _..
---, 7.- -
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 73
.s. -, 5 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
4 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD 5
6 7
In the Matter of
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-275 8
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
)
50-323
)
9 (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power
)
(Reopened Hearing --
Plant, Units No. 1 and 2)
)
Design Quality 10
)
Assurance) 11 12 13 LICENSEE PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY'S FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO 14 GOVERNOR DEUKMEJIAN'S THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES 15 16 17 INTERROGATORY 26 18 (b)
See also PGandE letter to the NRC, dated August 30, 19 1983 (Enclosure 2, Attachment 13).
20 INTERROGATORY 46 21 (b)
See also PGandE letter to the NRC, dated August 30, 22 1983 (Enclosure 2, ), and ITR-55, Rev. O, 23 Section 4.2.12.
24 INTERROGATORY 48 25 (b)
The documents pertinent to this matter are identified 26 in our response to Number 48(a) above.
See also PGandE i
8310050396 830928
{DRADOCK 05000275
~
q 1
1 letter to the NRC, dated June 15, 1983 (ref. EOI 8014).
2 See also FSAR Update Change Notices for EOIs 8028, 3
8029, 8030, 8031, 8049, 8051, 8055, and 8059.
4 5
CONTENTION 4(e) 6 Contention 4(e) should be changed as follows:
Rev.
"D" 7
to Rev.
"O".
8 9
INTERROGATORY 56 10 (b)(17)(f)
PGandE Audit 83170S; September 14, 1983; 1
i l
11 signed by G. W.
- Heggli, A. Ozeroff, 12 C. Kesinger, and S. M.
Skidmore; to J. O.
13 Schuyler.
14 INTERROGATORY 61 15 See Attachment A.
16
///
17
///
'l l
18
///
i 19 20 21 22 l
23 24 25 26. _ _
a 1
1 2
Respectfully submitted, 3
ROBERT OHLBACH PHILIP A. CRANE, JR.
4 RICHARD F.
LOCKE i
Pacific Gas and Electric Company 5
P.O. Box 7442 3
San Francisco, California 94120 6
(415) 781-4211 7
ARTHUR C. GEHR Snell & Wilmer 8
3100 Valley Center Phoenix, Arizona 85073 9
(602) 257-7288 i
10 BRUCE NORTON Norton, Burke, Berry & French, P.C.
4 11 P.O. Box 10569 Phoenix, Arizona 85064 12 (602) 955-2446 13 Attorneys for Pacific Gas and Electric Company 14 15 16 By t
4 Dan G.
Lubbock 17 18 DATED:
September 28, 1983.
19 20 21 22 f
i 23 24 25 26 --
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD 4
5 In the Matter of
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-275 6
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
)
50-323
)
7 (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power
)
(Reopened Hearing --
Plant, Units No. 1 and 2)
)~
Design Quality 8
)
Assurance) 9 CERTIFICATION 10 I, Dan G.
Lubbock, hereby certify:
11 1.
I am one of the attorneys for Licensee 12 Pacific Gas and Electric Company in the above-entitled 13 matter and, as such, am authorized to execute this 14 certification.
15 2.
I have read the foregoing Supplement of 16 Licensee Pacific Gas and Electric Company to Answers to 17 Governor's First and Third Set of Interrogatories, and know 18 the contents thereof.
19 3.
I am informed and believe the answers to said 20 interrogatories to be true and correct.
21 I certify under penalty of perjury that the 22 foregoing is true and correct.
23 Executed at. San Francisco, California, on l
24 September 28, 1983.
l 25 26 DAN G.
LUBBOCK
o ATTACHMENT A ATTACHMENT A IS THE SUPPLEMENTATION OF ATTACHMENT C TO PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY'S ANSWERS TO GOVERNOR DEUKMEJIAN'S THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES I
i l
l l
LINCOLN E. MALIK (f) i)
Docket #50-275 _____
i l
Lincoln E. Malik eeruceura2 engineering earthquake engineering probability analysis soils engineering l
EDUCATION University of California, Berkeley:
Ph.D. Structural Engineering, 1976 l
Stanford University:
Degree of Engineer,1970 Stanford University:
M.S. Civil Engineering, 1969 Universi ty of California, Berkeley:
B.S. Civil Engineering, 1964 PROFESSIONAL HISTORY URS/ John A. Blume & Associates, Engineers, San Francisco, California, Man-ager of Structures Department, 1979 present; Project Engineer, 1976-1979 University of California, Berkeley, Department of Civil Engineering, Re-search Assistant, 1971-1976 l
Sargent and Lundy Consulting Engineers, Chicago, Illinois, Design Engi-i neer, 1965-1968 Westenhoff and Novak Consulting Engineers, Chicago, 111Inois, Design Engi-neer, 1964 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Dr. Malik has had extensive experience in structural engineering, risk analysis, and soils engineering.
His experience includes the seismic anal-ysis of nuclear power plants, high-rise buildings, and buried structures; design of reinforced concrete and steel structures; assessment of earth-quake damage; risk analysis of nuclear-related equipment and structures; foundation design; and slope-stability analysis.
He is also a member of selected professional committees engaged in establishing state-of-the-art procedures for the seismic analysis of nuclear facilities.
Among other major projects, Dr. Malik supervised the seismic reanalysis and design of modifications for the Connecticut Yankee nuclear power plant in i
response to the Systematic Evaluation Program (SEP) initiated by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC).
He directed the effort to develop the struc-tural criteria and the technical approach to model, analyze, and design the modifications for the entire plant.
He'also supervised the development of project-specific computer programs and preliminary parametric studies and the preparation of responses to NRC staff questions.
Dr. Malik was also responsible for supervising the analysis, evaluation, and design of modifications of safety-related masonry walls in response to IE Bulletin 80-11.
For this project, criteria documents were developed for three nuclear plants, and a full evaluation and design of modifications was completed for the masonry walls at the Connecticut Yankee plant.
He also participated in the owners group that developed generic criteria for use in all plants.
1.-.
i LINCOLN E. MAllK PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE (Continued)
His supervision of the seismic evaluation and risk analysis of the Purex l
facility structures at the Hanford reservation in Washington included over-seeing the nonlinear analyses of several structures.
Also involved, in association with a subcontractor, was a risk analysis to develop fragility curves for the structures at the facility.
In connection with the seismic review of the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant for a postulated earthquake on the Hosgri fault, Dr. Malik supervised the reevaluation of the containment and auxiliary structures, providing such work as development of seismic criteria, mathematical modeling, soil-structure interaction analysis, dynamic analysis, and assistance in the development of the seismic sections of the PSAR and FSAR documents.
In this work, he of ten met with NRC staff and clients to resolve problems and of-fered expert testimony at hearings before the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards and the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board.
He also coordinated a seismic research program for Pacific Gas and Electric Company involving i
several engineering and scientific firms.
His nuclear experience has also included structural analyses and design of structures at the Quad Cities Nuclear Power Plant, seismic analysis of buried nuclear waste storage tanks at the Hanford facility, and SEP work for the Dresden 2 and Oyster Creek nuclear power plants.
Dr. Malik's probability analysis experience includes supervision of a proJ-ect to assess both the reliability of industrial cranes and added rella-i bility resulting from redundancies along the crane's loading path.
Soils engineering, which was one of Dr. Malik's minors in his doctoral studies, is another area of his professional expertise.
He was responsible for the analysis and design of the crusher building at the River Rouge Plant in Michigan, which was sunk as a caisson in very soft clay.
He also directed projects requiring the design of foundations at several power plants and slope-stability analyses under gravity and seismic loads.
In addition, Dr. Malik has performed static and dynamic analyses to inves-tigate the response of the Olive View Medical Center in Los Angeles to the 1971 San Fernando earthquake.
He also investigated the contribution of floor systems to the dynamic characteristics of buildings.
AFFILIATIONS ASCE Seismic Analysis of Safety Class Structures Standards Committee, Nuclear Standards Committee
t 5
a i
i l
R. C. ANDERSON i
4 i
(f) i)
Docket #
1.
50-344 2.
50-263 i
ii)
Case #
1.
Trojan 1
2.
Monticello 1 '
I I
(g) i)
Date:
1.
1978 - 1980 2.
1971 i
1 l
ii)
Yes 4
{
iii)
No iv)
No 4
i 1-k.
w 1
l 1
)
i i
+
a h
4 a,.
-.. - =..
l l
l PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF RICHARD C. ANDERSCN i
My nme is Richard C. Anderson.
I am the Engineering Manager in the Diablo Canyon integrated project organization consisting of Pacific Gas and Electric Company and Bechtel Power Corporation employees.
I am a Registered Mechanical and Nuclear Engineer in the State of California.
I hold a BS l
degree in Mechanical Engineering fr m the University of California at Berkeley.
I have been with Bechtel for more than 24 years and for the past five years have been assigned as an Engineering Manager in Bechtel's San Francisco Division, responsible for all engineering work in the Pacific Northwest and Japan.
I have been assigned since March, 1982, specifically to the Diablo Canyon Project to act as Project Engineering Manager. Prior to these Engineering Manager assigments, I was the Chief Nuclear /Enviromental Engineer for Bechtel's San Francisco Power Division, involved in nuclear power plant design, safety, and operation.
Prior to that, I was assigned as an Assistant Project Engineer on a proposed nuclear power plant project for PGandE and as Mechanical Supervisor and later Project Engineer on another large nuclear power plant project in the United States. 'Jhese assignments included supervision and coordination of design, specification, procurement, and quality control activities.
I also served as Senior Mechanical Engineer for various other nuclear power facility projects in the United States and abroad, which included work in systems, safety and equipment engineering.
I have been an instructor in Bechtel's power plant courses for over 10 years and have given numerous talks and lectures in California on nuclear power and energy issues. 4248a
W. H. WHITE (f) i)
50-344 ii)
Trojan (g) i)
Date:
1978 - 1980 ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No s
e s
i N
s 1
k r
.,~ 6 -
\\
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF IR. WILLIAM H.1GiITE My name is William H. White.
I am an Assistant Project Engineer in the Diablo Canyon integrated organization consisting of Pacific Gas and Electric Ocupany and Bechtel Power Corporation enployees. My responsibilities include supervision and direction of seismic-related engineering analyses for the Diablo Canyon Unit 1 Project Engineering Organization.
I am a Registered Professional Engineer and menter of the American Society of Civil Engineers.
My educational background includes:
BS, Civil Engineering, University of Idaho; MS, Civil Engineering, University of Colorado; PhD, Civil Engineering, University of mlorado.
For the past five years, I have been an engineering specialist with Bechtel's San Francisco Power Division working with the Q11ef Civil Engineer's staff in the area of seismic analysis for several Bechtel projects.
Earlier, I was a Structural Engineer with the Tennessee Valley Authority where I was responsible for seismic analysis of all Category I structures for a twin-unit nuclear power plant, including seismic iriput for the design of the nuclear stem supply system.
I was en Assistant Professor at Oregon State University where I taught undergraduate and graduate courses in structural mechanics and analysis and camputer applications.
I performed a special study for Bechtel on soil-structure interaction for the proposed Mendocino nuclear power plant while teaching at Oregon State University.
While enplayed at the Bettis Atomic Power Laboratory, I was a Senior Engineer working on shock analysis of nuclear reactors aboard subnarines and was involved in programs to assess the shock resistance of reactor internals subjected to long-term irradiation danage. 4248a i
e ese ei e-e4 e6e-6 e
4 S. M.
SKIDMORE ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No l
o l
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICNFICIE &
STEVEN M. SKINGE My name is Steven M. Skidmore.
I have been the Manager of Quality Assurance in the Nuclear Power Generation Department in the Pacific Gas and Electric Ctspany since May,1983.
I am responsible for the quality assurance of Diablo Canyon Power Plant construction and engineering. Prior to that, I was the Assistant Project Manager to the Diablo Canyon Project, between February,1982 and May,1983, where I was responsible for managenent of the Diablo Canyon Construction Quality Assurance Evaluation, as well as other l
.i functions.
Between 1972 and 1982, I was employed by Pacific Gas and Electric Ocupany as an engineer in various capacities, including engineer in the Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering Department, Assistant to the Eclear Projects Engineer, hchnical Assistant to the Vice President of Nuclear Power Generation, and Supervising Personnel and Environmental Safety Engineer.
In these positions, my responsibilities included analyses of reactor physics and fuel cycle evaluations for Diablo Canyon, and the management and coordination of development of the emergency plans for Diablo Canyon.
l Between 1967 and 1971, I was enployed as a Research Assistant in the Department, of Mechanical Engineering at Stanford University, where I wui enrolled as a graduate student of nuclear engineering.
Between 1962 and 1967, I was employed by the General Electric Oonpany, both at the Hanford Atomic Products Operations Office and at the mclear Energy Division. My responsibilities included engineering work in pile physics, and the analyses of reactor physics for reactor fuel manufacturers and a plutonium production laboratory.
I am a Registered Professional Nuclear Engineer in the State of California.
I have a MS degree in Nuclear Engineering from Stanford thiversity in 1969, and a BS degree in Physics fra Oregon State University in 1962.
4248a
6 O
G M. J. JACOBSON (g) i)
2.
1974 I
1 l
l l
.x
.;.a
~.....
PROPESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF MICHAEL J. JAODBSON My name is Michael J. Jacobson.
I am the Project Quality Assurance (QA)
Engineer for the Diablo Canyon Project consisting of the integrated organization of Bechtel Power Corporation and Pacific Gas and Electric (bnpany.
I am a Registered Professional Quality Engineer in the State of California.
My educational background is as follows: BS in Civil Engineering, Sacramento State Cbliege, 1970; Business Management Certificate in Management, Golden Gate University, 1979.
I joined Bechtel Power Corporation in 1970 as a Quality Assurance Engineer responsible for various aspects of design phase quality assurance on a nuclear power plant project.
I was subsequently responsible for performing structural design and seismic analysis activities on the project. Later, I was assigned as Project Quality Assurance Engineer responsible for supervising project QA activities, including direction of quality audits of construction activities.
Subsequently, I was assigned Project QA !!Ngineer on various other nuclear power plants, where I was responsible for directing project QA programs.
I was responsible for ensuring that project construction and site activities, as well as quality control aspects, met applicable QA and regulatory requirements.
I was assigned to the Diablo Canyon project in 1982 to direct and control the QA program for this project. 4248a
C. W. DICK 11)
No iii)
No iv)
No PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF CHARLES W. DICK My name is Charles W. Dick.
I am a Project Manager and a member of the project management team of the Diablo Canyon Project consisting of the integrated organiM 51 of Bechtel Power Corporation and Pacific Gas and Electric Conpany, and with responsibilities which include quality assurance.
I am a Licensed Professional Engineer in the states of Onlifornia, New York, and Pennsylvania.
My educational background is as follows: BS in Electrical Engineering, California Institute of 'Iechnology,1946; MS in Electrical Engineering, Stanford University, 1948.
I have also had additional training through Advanced Engineering Programs in Business Administration and fr a various technical and business courses.
Prior to my recent assignment to the Diablo Canyon Project, I was Manager of Division Quality Assurance Division at the Bechtel Power (brporation fra 1980 to 1982. My responsibilities included formulating the QA programs for inplementing such programs, and training QA personnel for some 14 nuclear projects.
I joined Bechtel Power Corporation in 1965 and worked as a Project Engineer on various nuclear and fossil-fuel projects. I was responsible for project ergineering work for a number of different types of pwer projects and studies, for nuclear standards development and for licensing. Beginning in 1973, I became an Engineering Manager and subsequently Manager of Engineering, with overall management responsibility for the project engineering work on more than 20 power plant projects.
Prior to my enployment at Bechtel, I was engaged as an engineer with the General Electric (bnpany beginning in 1948. During that time, I was involved in marketing and application engineering related to nuclear power facilities.
Prior to that I was assigned as an electric utility applications engineer and provided consultation services involving heavy electrical apparatus.
I am a senior menber of IEEE and a menber of the American Society for Quality control.
I was also a menber of the industry working group for development of ANSI Standard N45.2.ll (Quality Assurance Standards for Design h
w
- c. H. MOORE (f)
None (g) i)
N/A ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF j
GARY H. MOORE My name is Gary H. Moore.
I am the Unit 1 Project Engineer of the Diablo Canyon Project consisting of the integrated organization of Pacific Gas and Electric Company and Bechtel Power Corporation.
I have held this position since January, 1982.
I am responsible for the project engineering work related to the design and analysis of Diablo Canyon Power Plant Unit 1.
I am a Registered Professional Engineer in Mechanical and Control Systems in the State of California.
My educational background is as follows: BS in Mechanical Engineering, San Jose State University, 1968; MS in Mechanical Engineering, San Jose State University, 1969.
I joined PGand E in 1969 as a Mechanical Engineer in the Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering Department, designing instrumentation and control (I&C) systems for conventional fossil plants.
In 1977, I was named a Senior Mechanical Engineer supervising the I&C Group assigned to the Potrero Unit 7 Project.
In 1979, I was named Supervising Mecha{tical Engineer, supervising the Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering Department's entire I&C Group, including responsibility for the IEC design of the Diablo Canyon Power Plant.
I have completed the following formal training courses: Simulator Training, Westinghouse Nuclear Training Center, Zion, Illinois: Westinghouse PWR Information Course.
4248a _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
DR.
S. KAPLAN (f) i)
Docket #
1) 50-247, 50-286 2) 50-320 3)
LA-80-001-AK 4)
CP76-96 ii)
Case #
1)
Consolidated Edison's Indian Point Plant, Units 2 and 3 2)
Metropolitan Edison Co. - TMI Unit 2 3)
Northern States Power Co.
Prairie Island 4)
USA Fed. Power Comm., Canadian Artic Gas Pipeline (g) i)
Date:
1)
January 24, 1983 2)
March 20, 1979 3)
May 29,.1980 4)
August 20, 1976 ii)
Yes iii)
No iv)
No f.
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATICNS OF DR. STANLEY KAPLAN EDL.ATION:
Senior Post-Doctoral Fellowship, University of Southern California, 1967-1969.
Ph.D., Mechanical Engineering and Applied Mathematics, University of Pittsburgh, 1960. Post-doctoral courses in mathematics at the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Institute of Tecnnology, 1960-1965.
M.S., Mechanical Engineering, University of Pittsburgh, 1958.
Graduate of the Oak Ridge School of Reactor Technology, 1955.
B.S., Civil Engineering, City College of New York, 1954.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE:
)
i General Sumary 1
i Mathematician and engineer well known for contributicms to risk analysis and reliability theory, reactor physics, kinetics, and couputational technique.
Specializes in probabilistic methodology; decision theory; risk analysis; and, particularly, applications of Bayes' theorem. In this connection, has worked specifically and recently on developing probabilistic and decision theoretic treatments of various phases of the energy business.
Included here are PRA analyses of several existing nuclear plants, hazardous material transportation and storage, spent fuel pools, aircraft inpact, offshore oil drill (environmental risk), underground oil storage, pipelines, and tarsands projects (business and construction risk). Developer of the DPD method for probabilistic calculations, the two-stage Bayesian technique for data analysis, the " set of triplets," " probability of frequency," 'cause table,"
and " environmental table" concepts in risk analysis. Originator of the Matrix
'Iheory of Event Trees and DPD approach to seismic risk analysis.
Chronological Sumary l
l 1977 - Present President, Kaplan & Associates, Inc., a consulting firm specializing in risk analysis and applied decision theory.
Cbncurrently Adjunct Professor, Department of Chemical, tax: lear and 'Ibermal Engineering, University of California, Ice Angeles, and Associate Consultant, Pickard, Iowe and Garrickg_Inc.,_
1975-1977 Private consultant specializing in risk analysis and decision theory.
1972-1975 Holmes & Harver, Inc., Anaheim, California Director, Advanced 'Mchnology Division; Director, Systems Sciences Division
'Mchnical Director, kclear & Systems Science Group 1971-1972 Director of Software Development, CDMARC Design Systems, Inc.,
San Francisco, California.
1969-1971 Product Manager and Senior Staff Member, Conputer Sciences Corporation, Ios Angeles, California.
1967-1969 Special Research Fellow, U.S. Public Health Service at i
University of Southern California, Ios Angeles.
1955-1967 Westinghouse Bettis Atomic Power Laboratory, West Mifflin, Pennsylvania.
Experimentalist, Experimentalist in Charge, Scientist, Senior Scientist, Fellow Scientist, Advisory Scientist.
1954 Incturer, Department of Civil Engineering, City College of New York.
1962-1967 Concurrently Adjunct Professor of Mechanical Engineering, University of Pittsburgh; Lecturer, Department of Mathematics, Carnegie Institute of Technology.
MEMBERSHIPS, PAST CR PRESENT:
American Society of Civil Engineers American melear Society Society of Industrial and Applied Mathematics New York Acadent( of Sciences l
4248a. _. _.
LIST OF PUBLICATIONS OF DR. STANLEY KAPLAN Kaplan, S., "On a 'Two-Stage' Bayesian Procedure for Determining Failure Rates from Experiential Data." PLG-0191, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol PAS-102, No. 1, January 1983.
Garrick, B. J., and S. Kaplan, Chapter 2.7, " Electric Power " High Risk Safety Technology, A.E. Green, Editory, John Wiley & Sons,1.td.,1982.
Kaplan, S., "On Safety Goals and Related Questions " Reliability Engineering, Vol. 3. No. 4, July 1982, 267-277.
Kaplan, S., "A Matrix Theory Formalism for Event Tree Analysis," Risk Analysis, Vol 2. No. 1, March 1982.
Kaplan, S., B.J. Garrick, and P.P. Bieniarz, "On the Use of Bayes' Theorem in Assessing the Frequency of Anticipated Transients," Nuclear Engineering and Design, Vol. 06S. ISS., 23-32 (1981).
l
- W ee e.
g%
0 t
9 )
j
- = -
l Kaplan, S., "On the Method of Discrete Probability Distributions in Risk and Reliability Calculations - Application to Seismic Risk Assessment,"
Risk Analysis, Vol.1. No. 3, September 1981.
Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, "On the Quantitative Definition of Risk,"
Risk Analysis,1,1 May 1981. -, -.
~-
Apostolakis, G., and S. Kaplan, " Pitfalls of Risk Calculations,"
Reliability Engineering, 2,, 2,135-145, April 1981.
Kaplan, S., B. J. Garrick, and G. Apostolakis, " Advances in Quantitative Risk Assessment - The Maturing of a Discipline," IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, HS-28, No.1, February 1981.
- Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, "Some Misconceptions About Misconceptions," Letter to the Editor, Risk Analysis, Vol.1, No. 4, December 1981.
Apostolakis, G., S. Kaplan, B. J. Garrick, and R. J. Duphily, " Data Specialization for Plant Specific Risk Studies," Nuclear Engineering and Design, Vol. 56, 321-239 (1980).
Kennedy, R. P., A. C. Cornell, R. D. Campbell, S. Kaplan, and H. F. Perla, "Probabilistic Seismic Safety Study of an Existing Nuclear Power Plant," Nuclear Engineering and Design. 59, 2 August 1980.
- Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, "Try Probabilistic Thinking to Improve Power Plant Reliability," Power, March 1980.
Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, "On the Use of Bayesian Reasoning in Safety and Reliability Decisions - Three Examples," Nuclear Technology, jjl,231-245(1979).
Apostolakis, G., S. Kaplan, B. J. Garrick, and W. Dickter, " Assessment of the Frequency of Failure To Scram in Light Water Reactors," Nuclear Safety, Vol. 20, No. 6, November-December 1979.
Kaplan, S., "On a Probabilistic Approach to Project Cost Estimating,"
Consulting Engineer, February 1976.
Garrick, B. J., and S. Kaplan, " Reliability Technology and Nuclear Power," IEEE Transactions on Reliability, S)ecial Issue on Nuclear Systems Reliability and Safety, Vol. R-25, No. 3, August 1976.
l l l
L Kaplan, S., "On a Bayesian Type Methodology for liaking Accept / Reject i
Decisions on Offshore Lease Bids," Journal of Petroleum Technology, 4?
March 1976.
Kaplan, S., and D. Trujillo, " Numerical Studies of the Partial Differential Equations Governing Nerve Impulse Conduction-I, the Significance of Lieberstein's Inductance Term," Journal of Mathematical '
Biosciences, 7_, 379-404 (1970).
Kaplan, S., " Variational Methods in Nuclear Engineering," Advances in Nuclear Science and Technology, Vol. Y, P. R. Greebler, editor, Academic Press (1909).
Kaplan, S., A. J. McNabb, J. K. Siemsen, and D. Trujillo, "The Inverse Problem of Radioisotope Diagnosis - A Computational Model for Determining the Size and Location of Tumors," Journal of Mathematical Biosciences, 5, 29-35 (1969).
Yasinsky, J.
B., and S. Kaplan, "On the Use of Dual Variational Principles for the Estimation of Error in Approximate Solutions of 3_1,, 80-90 (1968).
1 Diffusion of Problems," Nuclear Science and Engineering, Kaplan, S., " Canonical and Involutory Transformations of Yariational Problems Involving Higher Derivatives," Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 2_2_, 1, 45-53 (1968).
Yasinsky, J. B., and S. Kaplan, " Anomalies Arising from the Use of i
Adjoint Weighting in a Collapsed Group Space Synthesis Model," Nuclear l
Science and Engineering, 31_, 2, 354 (1968).
Kaplan, S., A. J. McNabb, and M. B. Wolf, " Input-Output Relations for.a Counter Current Dialyzer by the tiethod of Invariant Imbedding," Journal of Mathematical Biosciences, 3_, 3, 289-293 (1968).
Kaplan, S., "A New Derivation of Discrete Ordinate Approximations,"
Nuclear Science and Engineering, 3, 1, 76 (1968).
(
Yasinsky, J.
B., and S. Kaplan, " Synthesis of Three-Dimensional Flux l
Shapes Using Discontinuous Sets of Trail Functions," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 28,, 426-437 (1967).
Kaplan, S., and J. A. Davis, " Canonical and Involutory Transformations of the Variational Principles of Transport Theory," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 28,, 2, 166-176 (1967).
Kaplan, S., J. A. Davis, and M. Natelson, " Space-Angle Synthesis - An
, Approach to Transport Approximations," Nuclear Science and Engineering, j
28,364-375,(1967). _
Kaplan, S., " Properties of the Relaxation Lengths in P1-Double-P1 and Angle-Space Synthesis Type Approximations," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 28, 450-463 (1967).
Kaplan, S., and J. B. Yasinski, "Na'tural Modes of the Xenon Problem with j
Flow Feedback - An Example," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 25, 430-438 (1966).
Gelbard, E. M., and S. Kaplan, " Reality of Relaxation Lengths in Various Approximate Forms of the Slab Transport Equation," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 26, 4, 569 (1966).
1
~
- Kaplan, S., " Synthesis Methods in Reactor Theory," Advances in Nuclear Science, Vol.111, Academic Press, June 1966.
l Kaplan, S., "An Analogy Between the Variational Principles of Reactor Theory and Those of Classical Mechanics," Nuclear Science and j
Engineering, 23_, 3, 234 (1965).
Kaplan, S., E. M. Gelbard, " Invariant Imbedding and the Integration Techniques of Reactor Theory," Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications,1_1,, No.1-3, 538-547, (1965).
,1 Henry, A. F., and S. Kaplan, "Some Applications of a Multimode Generalization of the Inhour Formula," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 2_2,,4,479-486,(1965).
Kaplan, S., O. J. Marlowe, and"J. A. Bewick, " Application of Synthesis Techniques to Problems Involving Time Dependence," Nuclear Science and Engineering, g, 163-176 (1964).
-~Kaplan, S., "The Use"of the' R~ayleight'-Ritz Method 'in~ Nsn'-Self' A'dj6 tnt
~
Problems," IEEE Transactions, MIT-12, 2 (1964).
Kaplan, S., Editor and Contributor, Section 5.5, " Space-Time Kinetics,"
Naval Reactors Handbook, Vol.1.
Kaplan, S., A. F. Henry, S. G. Margolis, and J. J. Taylor, " Space-Time Reactor Dynamics," Proceedings, Third United Nations International Conference on the Peaceful Uses of Atomic Energy, Geneva (1964).
Kaplan, S., "Some New Methods of Flux Synthesis," Nuclear Science and Engineering, E, 1, 22-31 (1962).
Kaplan, S., "The Property of Finality and the Analysis of Problems in Reactor Space-Time Kinetics by Various Model Expansions," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 9,, 3, 375 (1961).
t Kaplan, S., and G. Sonnemann, "The Methods of Finite Integral Transforms in Heat Transfer Problems," Proceedings of the International Heat _
Transfer Conference, Boulder, Colorado (1961).
Kaplan, S., and S. G. Margolis, " Delayed Neutron Effects During Flux Tilt Transients," Nuclear Science and Engineering, 7,, 3, 276 (1960).
Kaplan, S., and G. Sonnemann, "A Generalization of the Finite Integral Transform Technique and Tables of Special Cases," Proceedings of Mid-Western Conference on Solid and Fluid Mechanics, Austin, Texas (1959).
Goldsmith, M., T. T. Jones, T. M. Ryan, S. Kaplan, and A. D. Vorhis.
" Theoretical Analysis of Highly Enriched Light Water Moderated Critical Assemblies," Proceedings. Second United Nations International Conference on the Peaceful Uses of Atomic Energy, Pager P/2376 (1958).
REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS Kaplan, S., " Bayesian Methods in PRA " presented at the American Nuclear Society Topical Meeting:
Advances in Reactor Computations, PLG-0265, March 28-31, 1983.
"Seabrook Probabilistic Safety Assessment," Public Service Company of New Hampshire, to be published in 1983.
Kaplan, S., M. T. L. Ma, J. C. Wang, and C. P. Purohit, "Probabilistic Risk and Decision Analysis of General Electric Turbine Cracking Problem,"
PLG-0246, September 1982.
Kaplan, S., H. F. Perla, and D. C. Bley, "A Methodology for Seismic Safety Analysis of Nuclear Power Plants," presented at the International Meeting on Thermal Nuclear Reactor Safety, Chicago, Illinois, August 29-September 2, 1982.
Bley, D. C., S. Kaplan, and B. J. Garrick, " Assembling and Decomposing PRA Results:
A Matrix Formalism," presented at the International Meeting on Thermal Nuclear Reactor Safety, Chicago, Illinois, August 29-September 2, 1982.
Fleming, K. N., S. Kaplan, and B. J. Garrick, "Seabrook Probabilistic Safety Assessment Management Plan,"PLG-0239, June 1982.
Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, D. C. Iden, E. B. Cleveland, H. F. Perla, D.
C. Bley, D. W. Stillwell, H. Y. Schneider, and G. Apostolakis, " Power Plant Availability Engineering:
Methods of Analysis, Program Planning, and Applications," EPRI NP-2168, PLG-0165, May 1982.
" Indian Point 2 and 3 Probabilistic Safety Study," Power Authority of the State of New York and Consolidated Edison Company of New York. Inc.,
March 1982. -
Lin, J. C., and S. Kaglan, "SEIS3: A Computer Program for Seismic and Wind Risk Assessment, PLG-0222, March 1982.
" Zion Probabilistic Safety Study," Commonwealth Edison Company, September 1981.
Kaplan, S., "The Bayesian Approach to Data Reduction in Probabilistic Risk Analysis," PLG-0205 prepared as input to the NRC/ANS Probabilistic Risk Assessment Procedures Guide, September 1981.
Stillwell, D. W., B. J. Garrick, D. R. Buttemer, G. Apostolakis, J. C. Lin, and S. Kaplan, " Analysis of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station Reactor Protection System," PLG-0195, July 1981.
- Kaplan, S., " Matrix Format for PRA and Its P'ossible Usefulness in Licensing," presented to the ACRS Subcommittee on Reliability and Probabilistic Risk Assessment, Los Angeles, California, July 28, 1981.
Kaplan, S., G. Apostolakis, B. J. Garrick, D. C. Bley, and K. Woodard,
" Methodology for Probabilistic Risk Assessment of Nuclear Power Plants,"
~
PLG-0209, June 1981.
Kaplan, S., " Scarce Data Analysis Techniques," ANS 1981 Annual Meeting, Transactions, Miami, Florida, June 7-11, 1981.
Mulvihill, R. J., and B. J. Garrick, R. S. Hanson, S. Kaplan, Y. G. Mody, D. A. Reny, L. H. Riechers, and H. V. Schneider.," Comparative Evaluation of Boiler Availability for Intermountain Power Project," PLG-0169, April 1981.
_Garr.ick, B. J., S., Kaplan,..and N. 0..Siu,-.". Definition of Bounding ----
Physical Tests Representative of Transport Accidents - Rail and Truck,"
PLG-0164, March 1981.
Kaplan, S., L. H. Reichers, and B. J. Garrick, " Histogram Convolution Program (HICOP)," PLG-0157, December 1980.
Hanson. R. S., J. C. Lin, D. M. Wheeler, S. Kaplan, B. J. Garrick, D. C.
Iden W. B. Holder, and L. G. H. Sarmanian, "An Assessment of the Reliability of Turbine-Generators," PLG-0155, November 1980.
Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, D. C. Iden, E. B. Cleveland, H. F. Perla, D. C. Bley, and D. W. Stillwell, " Power Plant Availability Engineering, Methods of Analysis - Program Planning - Applications," 2 Yols.,
PLG-0148. October 1980.
Kaplan, S., R. S. Hanson, B. J. Garrick, and J. W. Stetkar, "A Strategic Plan for a National Data System for Electric Power Plants," PLG-0144, July 1980..
l
~..... - -.
l,'.
e Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, G. Apostolakis, D. C. Iden, K. Woodard, and T. E. Potter, " Seminar: Probabilistic Risk Assessment of Nuclear Power Plants," PLG-0141, July 1980.
~
Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, and D. C. Bley, " Seminar:
Power Plant Probabilistic Risk Assessment and Reliability," PLG-0127, May 1980. __
i Garrick, B. J., and S. Kaplan, "A Conceptual Plan for a National Data System for Electric Power Plants," PLG-0131 April 1980.
Garrick, B. J., and'S. Kaplan, "0yster Creek Probabilistic Safety Anal-ysis (OPSA)," presented at the AHS-ENS Topical Meeting on Thermal Reactor Safety, Knoxville, Tennessee, April 8-11, 1980.
Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, "A Strategic Plan for a National Reliability Data System," PLG-0125. March 1980.
Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, G. Apostolakis, D. C. Bley, and T. E. Potter.
" Seminar:
Probabilistic Risk Assessment as Applied to Nuclear Power Plants," PLG-0124, March 1980.
Kaplan, S., B. J. Garrick, and D. C. Bley, " Notes on Risk, Probability, and Decision," PLG-0113, November 1979.
Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, and S. Ahmed, "A Reliability Prediction Technique for Selected Thennomechanical Components of Gas Turbine Combined Cycle Plants," PLG-0109, September 1979.
Garrick, B. J., S. Kaplan, P. P. Bientarz, Ko Woodard, D. C. Iden, H. F. Perla, W. Dicter, C. L. Cate. T. E. Potter, R. J. Duphily, T. R. Robbins, D. C. Bley, and S. Ahmed, "0PSA, Oyster Creek
- ~~
Probabilistic Safety Analysis," (Executive Summary, Main Report, Appendixes), PLG-0100 DRAFT, August 1979.
Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, " Notes on Prediction of Reliability,"
PLG-0117, June 1979.
Kaplan, S., and B. J. Garrick, " Notes for a Workshop on Risk, Reliability, and Decision Under Uncertainty," presented at Battelle Northwest Laboratory, June 1979.
Garrick, B. J., P. P. Bientarz, and S. Kaplan, " Risk Analysis of Transporting Oconee Spent Nuclear Fuel to the McGuire Nuclear Station,"
PLG-0102, June 1979.
Garrick, B. J., and S. Kaplan,'" Training Engineers to be Reliability Practitioners," Sixth Annual Reliability _ Engineering Conference for the
, Electric Power Industry, Proceedings _, Miami Beach, Florida, April 19-20,1979..
_________________________---___________________________J
I i
Kaplan, S., J. M. Vallance, and C. L. Cate, " Prediction of Frequency of Aircraft Crashes at the Three Mile Island Site," October 1978.
Kaplan, S., " Description of OPTSWU-1, a Program for Computing the Optimum Amounts of Separative Work to be Contracted for," November 1976.
Kaplan, S., " Notes on> Pooling, Meaning of, Types of, and Advantages of..-.---,.,....
Also Hotes on a Bookkeeping Concept for Equitable and Visible Management of a Nuclear Pool " September 1976.
- Kaplan, S., " Notes on the Concept of Inventory as it Relates to Uranium Procurement Planning," September 1976.
Kaplan, S., "UPLAN, A Decision Theoretic Tool for Uranium Procureme'nt Planning," May 1976.
- Kaplan, S., and J. M. Vallance, " Notes on a Model for Evaluation and Optimization of Uranium Procurement Strategies for the CAPCO Companies,"
January 1976.
Garrick, B. J., and S. Kaplan, " Reliability Technology and Nuclear Power," 1975.
Garrick, 8. J., S. Kaplan, "A Method for Evaluating Nuclear Plant Siting Concepts," presented before the Joint Committee on Atomic Development and Space, California Legislature, Sacramento, May 19, 1972.
Garrick, B. J., S. Xaplan, and D. C. Baldonado, "On a Decison Theory Formalism for Nuclear Power Plant Siting," presented to the Conference on Unique Siting Concepts for Nuclear Power Plants, Joint Committee on Atomic Development and Space, Sacramento, California, May 9,1972.
e e,
8 e
L. E. SHIPLEY RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
Seismic (c)
See attached qualifications of L. E. Shipley.
(d)
None (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f) 1.
i)
Docket # 50-344 ii)
Case #:
Trojan Seismic Reevaluaton 2.
i)
Docket # 50-352 ii)
Case #:
Limerick Construction License Hearing 3.
ACRS - Bechtel Presentation on Industrial Problem (g) i)
Date:
1.
1978-1979 2.
1972 3.
1975-1976 ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No l -
Name:
L.E. SillPLEY Position:
Assistant Chief Engineer (Plant Design)
('
Technical Consultant to Diablo Canyon Education:
BS, Mechanical Engineering, US Merchant Marine Academy, Kings Point, NY Registered Professional, Mechanical Engineer in Professional Data:
o California o Member of ASME Member of ASME/ ANSI Task Force t,o Define Vibration o
Monitoring Requirements for Piping (Past) o Member ANS Committee for Protection Against Postu-lated Effects of Pipe Rupture.
Member of Industry Advisory Committee to a DOE pro-o gram for Structural Energy Absorbing Restrainers.
o Chairman on several ASME Technical Sessions at the ASME Piping and Pressure Vessel Conferences.
Su=ary:
o Present - Assistant Chief Engineer o
1 year Technical Consultant to Diablo Canyon gU Y.**.!
o 115 years Assistant Project Engineer (Nuclear Plant)
)
4 years Supervisor of Piping Stress Analysis for o
San Francisco Power Division.
o 9 years various positions of increasing responsi-bility in Engineering 2 years Engineering officer, US Merchant Marines.
o Experience:
Mr. Shipley has recently assumed the position of Assis-tant Chief Engineer for Plant Design in the San Francisco Power Division. The scope of responsibility of the Chief's office requires technical direction of over 900 professional engineers and draftsmen working on 15 projects worldwide.
Scope of services includes equipment location, piping layout, piping stress analy-sis, pipe support design, material specification, velding and NDE.
Projects include nuclear, fossil and, co-generation power plants. He is the chairman of an interdivisional technical steering committee for com-puter program applications.
In addition, he is the corporat'e sponsor for over 10 computer programs includ-ing the most widely used piping program.
(..
-=
Experience For over a year, Mr. Shipicy has been assigned to the (continued):
Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant in San Luis Obispo, (i/.)
Ca. as a Technical Consultant to the piping program.
He was instrumental in the development and review of the Corrective Action Program whose intent was to re-view all piping systems to licensing commitments and newly developed seismic criteria. During the course of the assignment, constant communication was required with the independent verification team and the con-struction forces at the jobsite.
Previously, he was Assistant Project Engineer on the Susquehanca Steam Electric Station in Berwick, Pennsylvania for 1 yrs.
He was responsible for en-gineering in the civil-structural, architectural and piping / plant design areas.
He directed the efforts of 350 engineers and draf tsmen in a variety of engineering tasks including:
structural analysis review of all seismic category o
I buildings.
i o Preparation of as-built response spectra curves.
Piping / Stress analysis and pipe support design, o
o Valve Qualification fh i
o Material Specification o Welding and NDE The final 2 months before fuel-load were spent at the jobsite coordinating the final as-built reconciliation for pipe hangers. This phase of the work required extensive construction / engineering interface for which he was the focal point. The job responsibilities also included budget, schedule and manpower planning as-pects.
Technical direction was given in the areas of stress analysis, pipe support design, materials selection and qualification, valve qualification, welding and NDE.
Previously, Mr. Shipley worked in' the field of piping stress analysis for 13 years and was responsible for technical direction and personnel administration of 150 engineers and technicians. Projects under his supervision include nuclear and fossil power plants, as well as liquid-metal fast breeder plants.
O,
~
He h.1s been directly involved in the design of the fol-Er.perience (continued):
lowing nucicar plants:
Monticello, Pilgrim 1. Peach 30ttom, and Duand Arnold. He has had supervisory re-(*,
sponsibilities for Arkansas Units 1 and 2, and Trojan,
(./
Limerick,1 & 2, Susquehanna,1 & 2, Pilgrim 2, Skagit.
Tossil plants include:
Jim Bridger and Colstrip.
TFIF was the breeder plant.
Hr. Shipley was responsible for the dynamic analysis of piping as it relates to abnormal events, such as pipe rupture and building response to dynamic loads. Analy-sLs includes both linear and non-linear, as well as elasto-plastic evaluations using time history and direct integration computer codes. Mr. Shipley was also re-sponsible for ASME - required stress reports including Ilfe cycle evaluation of thermal transients as well as other cyclic phenomenon. He was responsible for the analysis of piping on fossil projects, including cold springing of the major piping systems.
Corporate Standards and Guides were written under his supervision.
Mr. Shipley has visited all of the jobsites mentioned above, primarily in a trouble-shooting capacity, and has conducted the pipe support field review on Monti-cello.
He was responsible for the Bechtel Topical
- report,
" Seismic Analysis of Piping Systems." He has served on ASME Annual Meetings for Pressure Vessels and Piping
.3 as a session chairman for seismic analysis of piping and equipment.
He has testified at several hearings on various piping issues.
N;.
- l
f DR. H. BOLTON SEED (a)
Yes (b)
Soils and Seismic (c)
See attached Professional Qualifications (d)
Will supplement (e)
To be provided during testimony (f) 1.
50-275, 50-323 2.
Diable Canyon Seismic Safety Hearings (g)
(i) 1.
12/16/78 2.
12/20/78 3.
12/21/78 (ii)
Yes (iii)
Yes (iv)
No
. l
_A
,u 1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 7.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 2
i
(
3 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOARD 4
In the Matter of
)
Docket Nos. 50-275
)
50-323 5
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC _ COMPANY
)
)
Applicants Ex..No. 7 6
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power
)
Plant, Units No. I and 2)
)
December 1978 7
8 PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF WITNESSES FOR 9
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 10 71 Name: %
Dr. H. Bolton Seed 12 Title or Position:
{ -ofessor of Civil Engineering, Geo-p 13 technical Engineering, Department of Civil 14 Engineering, University of California, Berkeley 15 Degrees:
B.S. Kings College, London University 1944; 26 S.M. Harvard University 1947; Th.D Kings College,
..., ~
27 London University 1948 18 Profescional Experience:
Dr. H. Bolten Seed is a member of 19 the faculty of the Department of Civil Engineering, l
l 20 University of California, Berkeley, since 1950 and l
21 has been engaged in research and instruction in soil mechanics, seism 5.c' gro~und mothon, Eoil lique-2,2 23 faction under seismic excitation, soil-structure
~.
( j.1, 24 interaction analyses for se'ismic response, seismic
,v I
25 design of large civil engineering structures, etc..
(,.
l~~
26
.. _. a ;. + :... e.. v,;. x-..,... ?. e,...,-~.
l
- u. g <..%.
...+.% -c
..v.
>f % 'f gf g nf.y[ f.{c' g $..?,j g Q ife,'j.
f f
4,.;,. ; 7
-,:. _{.
mj.
. _?..zs;Q. Y :'f.; 32h,.'. 35g.lJ.;,-- A.g ~s.~. & c4..,6 Jg.,~_. Q q ~},3;'*,.:.13
.. : h;.
y.i.c-tys..;-q.
.Qy.. -; ; -
=
... = _.....
,r 1
Dr. Seed was chair==n of the Department of 2
Civil Engineering, U.C. Berkeley, 1965-1971.
g
(.
^
3 Foundation Engineer, Thomas Worcester Inc.,
4 Consulting Engineers, Boston, 1949-50.
5 Since 1953, Consultant on soil merhanics 6
problems and seismic design problems to:
7 U.S. Army Corp of Engineers 8
U.S. Bureau of Reclamation
~
9 U.S. Geological Survey 10 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11 U.S. Navy 12 U.S. Veterans Administratioil
~
C.'
13 National Aeronautucs and Space Administration 14 Oakridge National Laboratory 15 State of California Department of Water Resources 16 San Francisco. Bay Conservation and Development a.
- f.,
17 Commission J-18 Bechtel Corporation, Consulting Engineers 19 Kaiser Engineers, Consulting Engineers 20 Stone and Webster, consulting Engineers A[sphalt Institute 21
.22 Shell. Development company. ey,f-g- > 7
= -
-....--..~..... ~ -
23 J. B. Simons Company, Consulting Civil ' Engineers...,,,
~24
... '.... ;. 9...
._..a._
f..
John A. Blume and Associates, Consulting Structural s
25 Engineers
~ ~~~ '
~
(
26 v
, =, s.f <*.:te e * *
- g % e6.*,.o L' rt f**. ?>.,' t %*
'1 '. :
~.
g'-
'. *
- 5 **
e
.*s.
~.'
= - --..s +r ~ +.
.h.
~
- a,.,. ; w a s>. p a,.: g w. '. . h.l;6Y~:-Q1:5. yin' '5.'.M: e.m:9~:,.c.Nt,j'i. \\.e
.."i
.? p. M ~:.t C.'.G.&.
....r.
- ,.
- - z...
., c
'4.i..
w :...,.
.y u..: :
tea,.u 1 L x e n u x ~%. -o:.nu.m...,.;...was k p A...
e.s 9rs:
. r ?: :... ~;%'-2: :.>,_,cr4 ; z.- :. L -
s b.
ens
I m
t.
w 1
H. J.,Sarton.and Associates, Consulting Structural 2
h@ ms
(
3 Agbabian-Jacobsen and Associates 4
R. E. Davis, consulting Civil Engineer 5
Woodward-Clyde consultants, consul' ting Soil 6
Engineers 7
Dames and Moore, Consulting Soil Engineers 8
Shannon and Wilson, Consulting Soil Engineers 9
Law Engineering Co., Consulting Soil Engineers 10 Abbot A. Hanks,' Consulting Soil Engine'rs e
11 Compania Shell de Venezuel'a-e 12 et.::.
13 consultant during past year on seismic design 14 problems to:
' ~'
15 World Bank 16 U. 5. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 17 Atomic Energy organizrtion of Iran 18 U. S. Army Corp of Engineers 19 State Rivers & Water Supply Commission, Victoria,
\\
20 Australia 21 State of California Department of Water Resources
.22 State of California, Division of iiighways 23 State of California, Division of.Minam & Geology,.,
.s..
24
.Bechtel Corporatio.
... ~-
~~.-.."...
n t-25 Woodward-Clyde.connultants-
- ~
f' 26 Los Angeles Department of Water and Power q
3 s.Q.
. ~j% n..b..u s W ~. "~~..* ** - \\ ' ' * * * ' Y ' = - -
$.: M,.% +.i.:<y W'..bm..,*s
..<.e,
?v e.1.:".J. %..37s M..
- g. ;. v = :
. U.i~
1'i
?r+'Mw a.C'$p' +
s
.2,.. 'I
& b.; 'y :.'},bC} h: 'Q.,iWgc.,,'.T.s.l n.~'.gy.,,,,.).fMDM.,%.".9~fE.?
,6'. '.
,:u.
4,,
1.,.., ;..,, l
.w
..f.*i.-nC.n.f.w{i.%w$
&T T
.i.. ;.......
m= = : -.=....
p.
c 1(
1 Br1.za Engineering Company, Chicago 2
Tippets-Abbot-McCarthy-Stratton, New York
(
3 Ministry. of Planning, Nicaragua 4
East Bay Municipal Utility' District 5
Motor Columbus, Switzerland 6
Tehran-Berkeley /Pandam, Iran 7
United Engineers and Constructors 8
Metropolitan Water District of Los Angeles 9
Fugro, Long Beach 10 Pacific Gas and Electric Con:pany, San Francisco 11 Westinghouse-Hanford Company 12 Department of Interior - Panel to Investigate 13 Failure of Teton Dam 14 15 16 3y 18 19 20 21
.=
32
.o
..: u :
23
.....,, ~ ~. ~...,.
2.y. 7. s.= :, e. n. 9. 5.;;.=.;.9.;...
...n
.a..
. ~.
y4 l
25 l
1 l
26 m.
- .g r
.. =;.... s, yi _m * > = 's..* ?s
- n.
..s;u:.cf S,*.';d.: -
. a.....
.. 2...,.
... a.:: >
.. x.... ',.2...,y.9., :.s./.., :..,
..n l.i.. : F.VWy~M. M: s.. %..f:,4..'4]':.p.x (W~..
'..~.... < a ;..,. i.
"' e,% r
.?--
. q~ ~,.
'.I-[_s_tk'.'Z.Y ih dadiY... N.. N Ifi-M, u. 3.e a
ddd~f/AfS.$NdbYN; :. -
- l lib -
o.
- M
.(
.r iG 3'
Y__ e
J. K. McCALL RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
Seismic (c)
See attached qualifications of J. K. McCall.
(d)
None (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f)
None (g) i)
N/A ii)
N/A iii)
N/A iv)
N/A i.
= ~'= "-
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATICMS &
JmN K. McCALL My name is John K. McCall. My work experience is described in the " Work History" sunmary attached.
PROFESSIONAL LICDISES AND SOCIETIES:
Registered Civil Engineer, California Registered Professional Engineer, Florida EDUCATION AND PERSONNEL DEVEIDPMENT PROGRAMS:
B.S., University of California, Berkeley, Civil Engineer, 1966.
M.S., University of California, Berkeley, Structural Eagineer,1968.
4248a
NAME John K. McCn11 WORK HISTORY DATES COMPANY, OlVISION OR POSITION HELD,
SUMMARY
OF DEPARTMENT.
RESPONSIBILITIES AND l
FROM TO LOCATION AND SUPERIOR SIGNIFICANT ACCOMPLISHMENTS 3/1968 6/1971 Kaiser Engineers, Engineer -
Civil / Structural Oakland, CA Preparing structural drawings, calcula-tions, and specifications for commer-Superior: Mr. D. Mauser, cial and industrial buildings.
6/1971 12/1971 Self-enployed Design and construct single family, residence.
12/1971 7/1973 Bechtel Corporation Senior Engineer -
Civil Structural-SFHO San Francisco, CA On Chief Engineer's staff, responsible for planning, executing, and reporting Superior:
Mr. H. Wahl post-tensioning tendon surveillance program for 5 PWR containments; assiste<1 in preparing division civil / structural criteria.
1/1974 11/1977 Bechtel Corporation Senior Engineer -
Civil Structural-SFPC San Francisco, CA Assigned to Hope Creek project, pre-pared project civil / structural design Superior: Mr. G. Katanics criteria; participated in conceptual and final design of all buildings; responsible for coordination execution and review of seismic analysis and design; performed confirmatory seismic analysis; assistant to project engineer as engineering. planner.
11/1977 6/1979 Bechtel Corporation Engineering Supervisor -
Civil Structural-SFPD San Francisco, CA Assigned to Hope Creek project field as Lead Resident Engineer; approved changes Superior: Mr. G. Katanics and deviations from plans and specifica-tions; interpreted design requirements; participated in constructibility improve -
ment program; initiated numerous design changes to simplify construction; elim-insted construction delays due to docu-mentation interface.
-38<
l NAME John K. McCall WORK HISTORY DATES COMPANY, OlVISION OR POSITION HELD.
SUMMARY
OF DEPARTMENT.
RESPONSIBILITIES AND l
l LOCATION AND SUPERIOR FROM TO SIGNIFICANT ACCOMPLISHMENTS 6/1979 2/1981 Bechtel Corporation Engineering Supervisor -
Civil Structural-SFPD San Francisco, CA Assigned to Hope Creek project as Group Leader; direct supervision of Superior: Mr. K. Buchert 20 to 25 engineers and designers responsible for generating design and contract documents, and related coor-dination.for Reactor Building (2 units),
natural draft cooling towers, and service water intake structure; resolved technical problems and initiated con-struction of intake structure and cooling towers; continued finalization of Reactor Building design and supporteil construction activities.
2/1981 3/1982 Bechtel Corporation Civil Structural-SFPD Engineering Specialist -
San Francisco, CA Assigned to Hope Creek as Deputy Civil Superiors:
Group Supervisor; technical supervision Mr. K. Buchert and of 70 to 80 engineers and designers Mr. B. Pusheck responsible for generating design and contract documents, and related coor-dination, for all civil and structural work on project; continued finalization of design and support of construction activities, prepared draft sections of FSAR.
3/1982 5/1982 Bechtel Corporation Engineering Specialist -
Civil Structural-SFPD San Francisco, CA f
Superior: Mr. B. Pusheck Assigned to PSE&G General Service Agreement as project engineer for l
remodeling existing warehouse to a combined office building and warehouse;,
supervision of approximately 10 engineers and designers of all disciplines, gener-sting design and construction documents, supervision of consultant activities, assisting in generation of project schedules and budgets, coordination with client personnel at project manager level; initiated project, including engineering staffing and procedure, led negotiations with both client and vendors for both consultant and general contractor agree-ments, supported start of erection of structural steel and pile driving in field approximately 5 veeks after client direction to start project.
o
NAME John K. McCall WORK HISTORY l
COMPANY, DIVISION OR POSITION HELD.
SUMMARY
OF DATES DEPARTMENT; RESPONSIBILITIES AND FROM TO LOCATION AND SUPERIOR SIGNIFICANT ACCOMPLISHMENT 3 5/1982 Present Bechtel Corporation Engineering Supervisor -
Civil Structural-SFFD I
San Francisco, CA Assigned to Diablo Canyon Project as Unit #1 Civil Group Supervisor; super-Superior: Mr. B. Pusheck vision of 350 engineers and designers responsible for verifying, evaluating, and designing civil / structural items, coordination, planning and scoping group efforts, controlling associated consultant efforts, initiated group and developed organization and pro-cedures, developed various sources, working with chief engineer, to staff group, performed review, analysis and design for plant structures and race-vays/HVAC supports, supported field conctruction of modifications required, designed major revision of water supply and sanitary systems, prepared required licensing documents, interfaced with independent verification program con-sultants.
b 9
-4 0-
l E. R. KAHLER RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
QA (c)
See attached professional qualifications of E. R.
Kahler.
(d)
None (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f)
Previous testimony:
None (g) i)
Not Applicable ii)
Not Applicable iii)
Not Applicable iv)
Not Applicable i
N**
Edwin Roy Kahler RESUME WORK EXPERIENCE:
MAY 1982 - PRESENT Project Quality Engineer - Unit 1, Diablo' Canyon' Project'(PGsI'-
~
Bechtel) - Supervisor, responsible for quality engineering function for the project. Duties include monitoring the quality of engineering design,,
resolution of engineering concerns and problems in the area of procedures and quality assurance, developing quality assurance requirements for contracts and purchasing with the engineer, preparing responses for and interfacing with the NRC and various independent verifications consultants in the area of quality and quality assurance.
OCTOBER 1980 - MAY 1982 SeniorEngineers0aervising'the'ProiramSection'of'Eniineerini'Q0a1Ity control - Responsi)ilities included directing EQC auditing of power generation projects for compliance with the Engineering Manual, including the general responsibilities listed above.
JUNE 1977 - OCTOBER 1980 Engineer, Electrical Engineering Department - Responsible engineer for electrical desing on Los Medanos Gas Storage. Project, Geysers H 5 2
abatement systems Units 1-8 including DER systems and the pilot project at Unit 8, conceptual design for Montezuma Coal Project switchyard system, switchyard modifications at Martinez Power Plant, providing interface design for matching a Toshiba generator to 1950 design GE turbine, excitation and cwitchyard system.
JUNE 1972 - JULY 1977 Field Engineer on loan to Electrical Engineering Department - Responsible engineer for the seismic and regulatory requirement upgrade for Humbolt Bay Nuclear Unit 3.
Responsibilities included redesign of old systems, design of new systems to meet regulatory requirements, seismic qualification of old equipment or purchase of qualified new equipment. -.
__________n__
(
ERK Resume Page 2 DECEllBER 1974 - JUNE 1976 a
Field Engineer,' Superintendent's'0ffide','DIabi6'Cany6n - Responsible for
'Tiaison between construction and engineering, vendor representative contracts, and part-time as a start-up engineer at the plant.
JULY 1974 - DECEliBER 1974 Field Engineer - Responsible for electrical construction and start-up of Geysers Units 9, 10 and 11. Responsibilities included writing and performing start-up tests from loop tests through commerical operation of the plant.
8 PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS:
Washington State University - June, 1973 s
Registered Professional Electrical Engineer (California) No. E10110 _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
BIMAL SARKAR RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
Seismic (c)
See attached qualifications of Bimal Sarkar.
(d)
None (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f) i)
Docket No. 50-344 ii)
Case No. Trojan ASLB Hearing (g) i)
Date:
1978-1980 ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No 4
i I
I 1
i
, L
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF BIMAL SARKAR PRESENT POSITION:
Engineering Supervisor, Bechtel Power Corporation EDUCATION:
B.Sc.(Eng.), Civil Engineering, University of Bihar, India M.E., Civil Engineering, University of Calcutta, Irdia M.S., Civil Engineering, University of California, Berkeley PROFESSIONAL DATA:
Registered Professional Engineer, California e
SUMMARY
5 years: Engineering Supevisor 3 years: Senior Engineer 2 years: lihgineer 2 years: Structural Analyst 4 years: Civil Engineering Specialist 3 years: Design Engineer 2 years: Imeturer in Civil Engineering EXPERIEM2:
Mr. Sarkar is the Engineering Supervisor in Bechtel's San Francisco Power Division. Presently, he is the deputy group supervisor ir. the Civil / Structural group of the Diablo Canyon Project.
In his present position, he controls the group's licensing activities as well as coordination with the IDVP.
Earlier, he performed design, analysis and supervisory work in the design of Nuclear Power Plants.
4248a... _ - -
Prior to joining Bechtel, Mr. Sarkar worked as a Structural Analyst with I
URS/ John Blume and Associates, where he was involved primarily with evaluation of nulti-story buildings which were affected by the 1971 San Fernando Earthquake.
Frun 1966 to 1970, Mr. Sarkar was a Civil Engineering Specialist with the 1
Ministry of Planning and Ministry of Industry, Government of Libya.
In this capacity, Mr. Sarkar was responsible for review of the engineering design of major civil engineering projects in Libya which were being designed by consulting engineering firms of Europe and the United States.
Mr. Sarkar worked as a Design Engineer with M/S Ballardie, 'Ihoupson &
Matthews, a structural engineering firm in Calcutta, India, for two years.
Mr. Sarkar designed multi-story buildings, auditoriums, and other structures both of reinforced concrete and structural steel.
Fran 1961 to 1963, Mr. Sarkar was a lecturer in Civil Engineering at the Calcutta University in India, where he taught undergraduate courses in structural mechanics and analysis.
4248a -.
n.
G. V. CRANSTON 4
RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
General (c)
See attached qualifications of G. V. Cranston.
(d)
Publications:
Author of Bechtel Nuclear Topical Report, NB-TOP-1,
" Testing Criteria for Integrated Leakage Rate Testing of Primary Containment Structures for Nuclear Power Plant, November, 1972, which has been approved by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Participated in writing the ANSI /ANS-56.6 - 1978 (N277)
Standard, "American National Standard on PWR Containment Ventilation System," November 8, 1978.
Participated in writing the ANSI /ANS-56.8 - 1981 (N274)
Standard, " Containment System Leakage Testing Requirement,"
February 19, 1981.
(e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f) i)
None ii)
None (g) i)
N/A ii)
N/A iii)
N/A iv)
N/A
- l
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATICHS OF GRECORY V. CRANS' ION My n m e is Gregory V. Cranston.
I am the Unit 2 Project Engineer of the Diablo Canyon Project, consisting of the integrated organization of Pacific Gas and Electric Company and Bechtel Power Corporation personnel.
I have held this position since May, 1982.
I am responsible for the project engineering work related to the design and analysis of the Diablo Canyon Power Plant Unit 2.
I am a Registered Professional Engineer in Mechanical and NL1 clear in the State of California.
I hold a BS degree from the United States Naval Acadeny at Annapolis, Maryland, with a major in Nuclear Science.
I also attended and graduated from the U. S. Navy Nuclear Power Program, which included six months education on Nuclear Power Plant 'Ibeory and Operations at the U. S. Navy Nuclear Power School, Mare Island, California, and six months of practical training and qualifications as an Engineering Officer of the Watch on a nuclear reactor prototype at the U. S. Naval Nuclear Power Training Unit, located at the National Reactor Testing Facility in Idaho.
I have been with Bechtel for more than 13 years. Prior to my assignnent on Diablo Canyon, I was assigned as the Resident Engineer on a two-unit nuclear power plant in Pennsylvania. Prior to that, I was assigned as an Assistant Resident Project Engineer and Mechanical Group Supervisor. 'Jhese assignments included supervision and coordination of design, specification and quality control activities.
I also served as Senior Mechanical Engineer for various other nuclear power plant projects in the United States and abroad.
From 1972 to 1979, I served as Test Director for all Bechtel offices for Primary Reactor Integrated leakage Rate '14 sting, supervising test preparation and testing at various nuclear power plant projects in the United States and abroad.
Prior to working for Bechtel, I was a Lieutenant in the U. S. Navy and a qualified Engineering Officer of the Watch on a nuclear-powered autunarine that went through new construction, initial startup and criticality, and sea trials, l
4248a -.
MICHAEL R. TRESLER RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
Seismic (c)
See attached qualifications of Michael R.
Tresler.
(d)
None (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f) i)
Docket No. 50-275, 50-323 ii)
Case No. Diablo Canyon Seismic Reevaluation Hearing (g) i)
Date:
1978-1979 ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No 4..
................_1.____---------
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF MICHAEL R. '5P_CPA My name is Michael R. Tresler. From 1981 to the present, I have been enployed as a Piping Design Cbordinator at PGandE. My responsibilities include supervision, coordination, and direction of the piping and pipe support analysis and design for Diablo Canyon Power Plant.
From 1980 to 1981, I was enployed as a Supervising Project Cbntrol Engineer in PGandE's Nuclear Projects Department with responsibility to develop, imple ent, and maintain a project control system for Diablo Canyon Power Plant.
Fran 1964 to 1980, I was enployed in various positions as an engineer and superintendent in PGandE's Engineering Department and General Construction Department. During that time, I held the positions of Engineer, Resident Mechanical Engineer, Project Superintendent, and Assistant Station Construction Superintendent. My responsibilities included engineering, analysis, design, field engineering services, and supervision and management activities related to large fossil-fired units and the Diablo Canyon Power Plant.
In particular, from 1966 to 1970, I prepared startup procedures and supervised startup activities related to fossil and nuclear power plants.
My educational background includes a BS degree in Mechanical Engineering from the California Polytechnic State University, 1964.
I have coupleted the following formal training courses:
Westinghouse Reactor Operator Training School, 1969.
Westinghouse Design Imeture Series specific to Diablo Canyon, system and caponents design,1971.
Stat-A-Matrix course covering the establishment of a QA program and personnel training, 1973.
Westinghouse PWR Inforation Course, 1980.
Westinghouse Simulator Training, 1980 J
4248a
-50
N. J. TUHOLSKI RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
Seismic (c)
See attached qualifications of N. J. Tuholski.
(d)
Publications:
i)
SIT Reports ii)
Tendon Surveilance Reports (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f)
None (g) i)
N/A ii)
N/A iii)
N/A iv)
N/A
I
= ~ - - - -
y t
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIOtE OF N. J. 'IUBOLSKI My name is Neil J. niholski. My work experience is described in the
- Work History' sumary t ttached.
PROFESSIONAL ACHIEVD4ElfIS:
/
1.
Participation in ASME Code Comnittee.
2.
Participation in the Subgroup on Wsting and Protection Against Overpressure (SC-3C) 3.
Past Member of the Working Group on Concrete Pressure Canponents (SC-XI)
PROFESSIONAL LICDiSES AND SOCILTIES:
Licenses: Civil Registration California C-022053 Structural Registration California S-2260 Societies:
Tau Beta PI ASME SESA SGME (Inactive)
EDUCATION AND PERSONNEL DEVEIDPMENT PROGRAMS:
BSCE, University of California, Berkeley, 1963. Major: Civil Engineering MSCE, University of California, Berkeley, 1972. Major: SESM (Structural Engineering.
United States Navy, Airborne Crew (Officer Training Avionics Navigation, etc.)
University of Maryland, Graduate Courses in Plates / Shells /'Ibraion Bechtel, BOC, Materials Engineering.
4248a
-s2-q
f I
~
rAME Neil J. Tuholski WORK HISTORY DATES COMPANY, DIVISION OR POSITION HELD.
SUMMARY
OF DEPARTMENT; RESPONSIBILITIES AND FROM TO LOCATION AND SUPERIOR SIGNIFICANT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Sum =ers 1960-62 Calif. Division of Surveying on Interstate System.
Soils Highways - District 11 testing in field (compaction, gradation _,
clay equivalents, etc.)
10/63 4/64 Shasta County Junior Civil Engineer.
Bridge Inspection, Design of 225' R.C. Box Cirder Bridge.
Some highway design.
4/64 8/68 U.S. Navy Commissioned Officer (Ensign - Lt.) -
Airborne Tactical Coordinator -
Several duties including:
1.
Sqd.
Air Intelligence Officer - Briefing & De-briefing air-crews; 2. Tactical Coordina-tor in C.O.'s air-crew; 3.
Air Frames Branch Officer.
(Two tours in Viet Nam).
3/69 10/73 U.S. Naval Ship Research Research Structural Engineer, engaged in
& Development Center structural analysis in support of Trident Carderock, MD program. Principal role in tasks which involved structural analysis, scale steel model design & instrumentation, stability analysis, parametric studies of struc-tural configurations, & writing reports on the results of comparisons of analysis
& model tests.
Member of Submarine D,eep Dive Group.
10/73 4/75 Ann Arbor Power Division Senior Engineer on the Midland Nuclear Office - Bechtel Power Project at the Ann Arbor office of Bechtel Power.
Responsible for finite element analysis & design of the contain-ment structure & steam generator supports Additional assignments included safety analysis report preparation, liner plate design & piping penetration design &
analysis.
4/75 10f77 Bechtel Mining & Metals -
Facility Engineer for the Mining & Metals San Francisco Division. Responsible for the steel &
concrete design & analysis of major struc<
tures for large concentration plants.
Duties: Coordinating, checking, & issuing extensive structural drawings &
calculations.
Proj ects:
1.
Hurricane Creek 2.
Tilden Mine 3.
Pala Bora 1 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
1 NAME Neil J. Tuholski WORK HISTORY DATES COMPANY. DIVISION OR POSITION HELD.
SUMMARY
OF DEPARTMENT; RESPONSIBILITIES AND FROM TO LOCATION AND SUPERIOR SIGNIFICANT ACCOMPLISHMENTS 10/77 12/79 Bechtel Research &
Testing activity leader with Bechtel's Engineering Research & Engineering Operation in the Applications Engineering Group.
Engaged in the planning, field implementation,
& report writing of structural integrity tests, tendon surveillance programs, and other tests for nuclear containments.
Projects: 1.
Arkansas Nuclear One 2.
Point Beach 3.
Palisades 4.
Farley 5.
Trojan 6.
SONGS 7.
ASCO 8.
Lemonitz 9.
Koushe,ng Also development of designs and studies in support of Photovoltaic Power Stations 12/79 9/82 Bechtel - San Francisco Group Leader on Limerick Plant for Con-Power Division tainment & Adjacent Structure Analysis &
Assessment of Mark II Bydrodynamic Loads.
Group Leader of Civil Equipment Qualification Group.
9/82 PRESENT Bechtel - SFPD Civil Deputy Group Supervisor -
Supervisor for Containment Group and Field Coordination Activities.
h 4
6 54-
e PAT CHANG-LO RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
Seismic (c)
See attached qualifications of Pat Chang-Lo.
(d)
Publications:
SMIRT-4 Conference, " Containment Line Plate Anchors and Steel Embedment Test Results, 1977."
ASCE, " Design of Nuclear Power Plant Structures."
Bechtel Topical Report, BC-TOP-5, " Prestressed Concrete Nuclear Reactor Containment Structures."
(e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f) i)
Docket No. 50-344 ii)
Case No. Trojan ASLB Hearing (g) i)
Date:
1978-1980 ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No I
y.
~^
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATICES OF PATRICK L.C. GA)G-ID POSITION:
Project Engineer EDUCATION:
BSCE, Civil Engineering, Virginia Military Institute MSCE, Civil Engineering, San Jose State College PROFESSIONAL DATA:
Registered Civil Engineer in California
SUMMARY
5 years: Project Engineer 3 years: Group Supervisor 3 years: Group Imader 1 year:
Senior Engineer 3 years: Engineer 2 years:
Intermediate Engineer EXPERIENCE:
Mr. Oiang-Io is presently a consultant to the civil / structural group supervisor and the sponsor, responsible for management of the Diablo Canyon project turbine building structural verification program.
Mr. mang-In is also the Project Engineering Manager on the Bechtel/MHI
'I4chnology and Services Contract.
In this capacity, he has overall responsibility for the transfer of engineering technology relating to the design of IWR nuclear power plants and aawiated engineering services.
Mr. mang-Io was the Project Engineer on the Trojan tbclear Project. In this capacity, he had overall responsibility for the civil / structural design and analysis of the proposed modifications to the Trojan control Building.
4248a -----------------_--o
Previously, Mr. mang-Io was the Project Ergineer on the 'Dsuruga No. 2 Power Station.
In this capacity, he had overall responsibility for the project, which included the civil / structural design of the reactor building and review and ccmnent services relating to plant and equipnent arrangement in the reactor and the auxiliary buildings.
}
Mr. mang-Io was the civil / structural supervisor on the TEPCO turbine plant reference design project and the Kashiwazaki design review. He was also the civil and structural group supervisor on the Japan Atcznic Power Cturpany BWR feasibility study. He was responsible for the seismic and structural analysis and design of the reactor building consisting of the auxiliary, fuel, diesel generator, and control buildings.
Previously, Mr. Gang-Io was group leader for the Puget Sound Power &
Light reactor building.
In this capacity, he was responsible for all civil and structural activities pertaining to the reactor building. As group leader in the special structures group,'he was responsible for the development of design guides, topical reports, and structural analyses of the concrete nuclear containment structures.
Previously, Mr. Gang-Io worked as senior engineer for the Arkansas Nuclear One, Units 1 and 2 reactor building. As lead engineer he was responsible for design, analysis, and preparation of specifications and engineering drawings. He also participated in the design of the Northern States Power Canpany's Monticello reactor building and was responsible for the design and analysis of equipment supports, structural steel, and concrete walls and clabs.
l l
4248a
-57'-
J. B. HOCH RESPONSE TO INT. 61:
(a)
Yes (b)
General (c)
See attached qualifications of J. B. Hoch.
(d)
None (e)
To be provided during testimony.
(f) i)
Docket # 50-323, 50-275 ii)
Case:
Diablo Canyon Project (g) i)
- Date:
ii)
No iii)
No iv)
No i
I l i
= --
_4 TxR
,... y,.gtp.
.. ~ %%..'
PRMESSIONAL GIALIFICXfM OF JGDI B. EXE My name is John B. Boch. Since January, 1982, I have been esployed as Project Manager of the Diablo Canyon Project organization at PGandE. %
7
. N.=
- responsibilities include managerial and supervisory duties, and providing
- 9. '
coordination and direction of the Diablo Canyon Project ory nimation.
Prcan 1980 to 1982, I was employed as Manager of the helear Projects Department at PGandE. My responsibilities include unnagerial and supervisory duties, and providing coordination and direction of the m elear Projects Departnent in matters related to PGandE's nuclear power plants.
From 1959 to 1980, I was employed as an Engineer in various disciplines in PGandE's Engineering Departner.t. W responsibilities included engineering, design, analysis work, activities related to M C licensing, and engineering management for PGandE's Diablo Qinyon Power Plant.
My educational background includes a BS degree in Mechanical Engineering from the University of Idaho, 1959, and graduate studies in Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, 1961 to 1962.
I am a Registered Professional Engineer (Mechanical and Mclear) in the State of California.
l 4248a _
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
)
3 PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-275
~3 R2 :37
)
Docket No. 50-323 Dicblo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, )
)
Unita 1 and 2
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The foregoing document (s) of Pacific Gas and Electric Company has (hevo) been served today on the following by deposit in the United States mail, properly stamped and addressed:
Judge John F. Wolf Mrs. Sandra A.
Silver Chairman 1760 Alisal Street Atomic Safety and Licensing Board San Luis Obispo CA 93401 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington DC 20555 Mr. Gordon Silver 1760 Alisal Street Judga Glenn O.
Bright San Luis Obispo CA 93401 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board US Nuclear Regulatory Commission John Phillips, Esq.
Wuchington DC 20555 Joel Reynolds, Esq.
Center for Law in the Public Interest Judga Jerry R.
Kline 10951 W. Pico Blvd. - Suite 300 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Los Angeles CA 90064 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington DC 20555 David F. Fleischaker, Esq.
P. O. Box 1178 Mrc. Elizabeth Apfelberg Oklahoma City OK 73101 c/o Cetsy Umhoffer 1493 Southwood Arthur C. Gehr, Esq.
Scn Luis Obispo CA 93401 Snell & Wilmer 3100 Valley Bank Center Jcnice E.
Kerr, Esq.
Phoenix AZ 85073 Public Utilities Commission State of California Bruce Norton, Esq.
5246 State Building Norton, Burke, Berry & French, P.C.
350 McAllister Street P. O. Box 10569 Scn Francisco CA 94102 Phoenix AZ 85064 Mrs. Raye Fleming Chairman 1920 Mattie Road Atomic Safety and Licensing i
Shall Beach CA 93449 Board Panel US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mr. Frederick Eissler Washington DC 20555 Sc nic Shoreline Preservation
[
Canference, Inc.
4623 More Mesa Drive Scnta Barbara CA 93105 nno
__ _ _ _ ' _~ T Z E_*' 7pM M16% E
.4l: 1.' ' '
} [,.,.. -
Chairman Judge Thomas S. Moore Atomic Safety and Licensing Chairman Appeal Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing ' 7g.y,
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Appeal Board gf:-
Washington DC 20555 US Nuc19ar Regulatory Commissi. g{i
}
Washingon DC 20555 Sacratary US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Judge W. Reed Johnson Washington DC 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Attn:
Docketing and Service US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Section Washington DC 20555 L wrence J. Chandler, Esq.
Judge John H. Buck H2nry J. McGurren Atomic Safety and Licensing US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Appeal Board Office of Executive Legal Director US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Waohington DC 20555 Washington DC 20555 Mr. Richard B. Hubbard Michael J. Strur:wasser, Esq.
MHB Technical Associates Susan L. Durbin, Esq.
1723 Hamilton Avenue Suite K Peter H. Kaufman, Esq.
San Jose CA 95125 3580 Wilshire Blvd.
Suite 800 Los Angeles CA 90010 Mr. Carl Neiberger Talogram Tribune Maurice Axelrad, Esq.
P. O. Box 112 Lowenstein, Newman, Reis, and Sen Luis Obispo CA 93402 Axelrad, P.C.
1025 Connecticut Ave NW Washington DC 20036 e
D3to:
September 23, 1983 Dan'G. Lubbock
~
__---------------___-.__.-----J