ML20077P650

Discusses Util Application to Suspend Antitrust License Conditions for Plant & Forwards City of Cleveland Arguments Respecting Commission Lack of Authority to Grant Relief Requested by Applicants

ML20077P650
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	07/30/1991
From:	Goldberg R CLEVELAND, OH, GOLDBERG, FIELDMAN & HJELMFELT
To:	Bechhoefer C, Bollwerk G, Mark Miller Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20077P653	List: ML20077P650 ML20077P657 ML20077P673
References
CON-#391-12078 A, NUDOCS 9108190060
Download: ML20077P650 (3)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _

1

/5078 l

...n..... . ,,

1 coLoncRG, FIELDM AN & LCTHAM, P. Ce' [,,,'[ + f s to o , se t t t ht M B f a t t i, N. w l CtVDt4OOLCptmo w AS'tlN ot ON. D C. 70006 AmMOLD ,it(DuaN

• GL E N6d W 4tfMAM g .j { fg ttitPMoht

)

l' C6eakkiko D.SimO9mtm,sa. '808' 488 8800 sO6Mua L. Wthtt e 8thhtfM M A49 tat t i t t COPit a

1. - t July 30, 1991 ,

i, O e . . a 30.

DAVID C. .eJT Lwf I Lt I

Hon. Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 1920 South Creek Fly-In Daytona Beach, Florida 32124 Hon. Charles Bechhoefer Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Room E-413 Bethesda, Maryland 20014 Hon. G. Paul Bollwerk, III Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 4350 East-West Highvay Room E-522 Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Ret Applications of Ohio Edison Company, and Cleveland Electric Illuminating Companf and Toledo Edison Company to Suspend Anti-trust License Conditions -- Perry Nuclear Power Power Plant Unit 1 and Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Unit 1 -- NRC Docket Hos.

50-440A, et al.

Gentlement In a Memorandum and Order of June 19, 1991, the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board-acknowledged receipt of copies of Ohio Edison Company's application to suspend the anti-trust license conditions of the Perry operating license, of which Ohio Edison is a co-owner licensee, insofar as they apply to Ohio Edison.

In that same Memorandum and Order, the Board directed Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and Toledo Edison Com-pany, to supply the Board with copies of their application to 9100190060 910730 PDR ADDCK 05000440 '

N PDR u,

GOLDDERG, FIELDM AN & LETH AM, P, C, Hon. Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Hon. Charles Bechhoofer Hon. G. Paul Dollwerk, III .

July 30, 1991 Page 2 suspend as to them the same anti-trust license conditions of the Perry operating license and, additionally, the anti-trust licenso conditions of the Davis-Besse operating license.

Further, the Board directed the NRC Staff to provide it with copies of the Department of Justice's letter to the Commis-sion, dated June 13, 1990, and the Commission's letter to the Licenseos, dated April 24, 1991.

The City of Cleveland, a vital party to the anti-trust review proceedings that culminated in the issuance of the afore-mentioned Operating Licenses, and a vital party to the present phase of the proceedings initiated by Ohio Edison's application to suspend the anti-trust license conditions, believes that the Board should also have before it copies of the following filings made by the City of Cleveland in opposition to the applications:

1. Answer of City of Cleveland, Ohio, in opposition to Chio Edison Company's Application for Suspension of Perry Cperating License Anti-trust Conditions, dated February 19, 1988,

2. Comments of City of Cleveland, Ohio in Opposition to Application of Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and the Toledo Edison Company for Suspension of Operat-ing License Ant.1-trust Conditions, dated September 13, 1908.

3. Letter dated Aug at 21, 1990, to Thomas E. Murley, Director, Office'#.bf Nuclear Reactor Regulation, from counsel for the Clty of Cleveland, Ohio, responding to a letter of July 24, 1990, from counsel for Ohio Edison Company to Mr. Murley.

These documents are incorporated by reference in the city of Cleveland'c " opposition to a Hearing with respect to the Denial of Applications to Suspend Anti-Trust License Conditions and Petition to Intervene in the Event Hearing is Requested and Granted" filed May 31, 1991, at pp. 7-8. These documents, inter Alla, present the City of Cleveland's arguments respecting the commission's lack of authority to grant the relief requested by

l GOLDDERG, FIELDM AN & LETH AM. P C.

Hon. Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Hon. Charles Bechhoofer Hon. G. Paul Bollwerk, III July 30, 1991 Page 3 the applicants. The decision of April 26, 1991, did not address this lack of authority in light of the denial of the applications (p. 13, n. 18).

Reppoctfully submitted, Nh nj /td N' '

a-.',

" {ht-s '.

~

35{144% , jf Reuben Goldberg channing D. Strother, Jr.

Attorneys for the i.f.ty of Cleveland, Ohio Enclosures cc: (with enclosures)

Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary /'

cc: (without enclosures)

Joseph Rutberg, Esq.

Sherwin E. Turk, Esq.

Steven R. Hom, Esq.

Gerald Charnoff, Esq.

James P. Hurphy, Esq.

Mark C. Schector, Esq.

Roger W. Fones, Esq.

Janet Urban, Esq.

D. Biard MacGuineas, Esq.

David R. Straus, Esq.

Kenneth L. Hegemann, P.E.

__---m.m