ML20077D862

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards New Hampshire Yankee Objection to Certain Data Requests, from Nelkens to State of Nh Nuclear Decommisioning Financing Committee
ML20077D862
Person / Time
Site: Seabrook NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 05/31/1991
From: Haffer E
SHEEHAN, PHINNEY, BASS & GREEN, P.A.
To: Smukler L
NEW HAMPSHIRE, STATE OF
References
NUDOCS 9106050237
Download: ML20077D862 (9)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:_.__--.mma . . ~ . _ _ _ _ , - . _ _ _ . . - . . - . . ._-..m., .- .#--, 

                                                                                                                 -...- .m 24... _  .m._  . _ . . ~ . . . - - - - - i..- . -

a # . lk k hlkN 

      )                                                heNNar UAl$ +

Grit N N,0 ME'\ 4; A N*.':47 '. .% 

                          'A1TORNI.% AT LAN May 31, 1991 1Mittu ttutt PO. Ikn 3701 Ma w aistik Ni w il AuP6Hikt 0,1105 3701       Larry Smukler, Chairman I A u.n.,r.mt            Nuclear Decommissioning eaa,s.e3:n          '

Financing Committee N.H. Public Utilities Commission 111u M a l' tac t 8 Old Suncook Road gni 3:5 Concord, New Hampshire 03301 Permmnu Naw firuronu RE NDFC 91-1 0%a13m nus uun -

Dear Mr. Smukler:

                                                  "* NI" I enclose the original and 15 copies of New Hampshire Yankee's objection to certain Data Requests.

Sincerely, Edward A. Haffer EAHtd1 Enclosures CC w/enct Service List l l 9106050237 910531 

                                        -PDR                 ADOCK 05000443                                                       -N    j-o                              .PDR                                                                              .-

STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE NUCLEAR DECOMMISSIONING FINANCING COMMITTEE In Re Seabrook Station - Unit 1 Docket NDFC 01-1 NEW RAMPS 11J.BF YANKEE'S OBJECTION TO CERTAIN DATA RE0 yip _TE New Hampshire Yankee objects to certain Data Roquests of Ms. ( Nelkens, saying:

1. Attachment 1 hereto is a copy of Data Requests dated May 29, 1991 from Ms. Nelkens.
2. Although New Hampshire Yankee is proceeding '.o answer the great majority of those Requests, Requests 2a-d. 3, 4, and 11 are neither relevant to the present proceeding nor reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.

(Although Request 2e could arguably be characterized also as neither relevant nor reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, New Hampshire Yankee will nevertheless attempt to provide an answer to it, since it at least is directed to the approximate time of decommissioning). THEREUPON, New Hampshiro Yankee respectfully requests an order of the Committee that it need not answer Nelkens Data Requests 2a-d, 3, 4, and 11, and that it be granted such other relief as is just. Respectfully submitted, NEW HAMPSHIRE YANKEE By Its Attorneys, SHEEHAN, PHINNEY, BASS & GREEN PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION DATED: May 31, 1991 By:_  % . (Edward A./h affer 

                                                                  ~

1000 Ely Street Manchester, NH 03105 (603) 627-8115 

                                                        .2-CERTIFICATE OF BERVICE I hereby certify that copies of this Objection were sent to the persons sh)wn on the attached Service List.
                                                        ,/                  ~,

Edward A. Ha for 't ] 

                  '                                                         NDFC SFRVICE LIST Senstbr Cle'sson J. BIsisdell    Larry H. Smukler, Chairinan-     Alexandar Kalinski, Esquire Senate Finance Comittee         N 11. Public Utilities Com.       PO Box 1136 s Room 120 - State Houve              8 Old Suncook Road               Manchester, NH _03105 (Concord, MI 03303               Concord    Ntl-- 03301 Rep. Elizabeth Hager            Mr. Robert Cushing, Jr.           Director of Nuclear Chairvoman, Appropriatiens Com. 395 Winnacunnet Road              Reactor Regulation Roon 100 - State House          Hampton, NH 03842                 Nuclear Regulatory Com.

Concord, NH 03301 Washington, D.C. 20555 l h. I Georgie 'Ihomas Mr. John Arnold- James Volz Esquire

State Treasurer Attorney General Verinont Dept. of- Pub. Se rv.
Room 121 - State House Annex State House Annex 120 State Street i Concord, NH 03301 Concord, NH 03301; ' Hentpelier. VT 050 Y.

4 Harry H. Bird, M.D. Mary K. Hetcalf Sen. Beverly b Fe2U : worth

Commissioner Campaign for Ratepayers' Rights State House

. Health & Welfare Dept. One Glassford Lane Concord, NH ~0D0' [ Hczen Drive Durham, NH 03824 Concord, N!! 03301 l ! R erd H. Flynn, comissioner Seabrook Selectmen's Office. Robert _A. Backus, Esquire Dr artment of Safety Seabrook Town Office 116 Lowell Street James H. Hayes Bldg.-Hazen Dr. Seabrook, NH 03874 PO Box _516-p Concord, NH 03301 -Manchester, NH- 03105-i, . .Lt.-Col.-Willard F. Boyle Mr. Robert Patnaude_ 'Audrey Zibelman,-Esquire i 463 New Zealand Road- 5 Sunset Avenue: N. H. ' Public. Utilities Com.- i 'Se brook, NH 03874 Derry, NH- 03038L 8 Old Suncook Road L -Concord, NH. 03301-- i i l Mr. Robert W.'Romer Guy Chichester Ddvid J. Draiterinan, Esquire- , N. H. Yankee Corporation- . League of Towns- , Myers, z Jordan- &l Duffy ~! ! Serbrook Station - PO Box 300 - 556 Washington Street 4 Park Street  ; , Seabrook, NH 03874- Rye, NH .03870--- Concord, NH ~03301: 1 i G. _, . 

                   '                    s
         -{tr. Dennis D. Raca                 Mrs. Barbara Bowler                 Michael Holmes, Esquire Public Service Co. of N.H.          RR J. Box 131                       N. H. Public Utilities Com.

PO Box 330 Diamond Ledge Road 8 Old Suncook Road Manchester, NH 03105 Ctr. Sandwich, NH 03277 ConcoM. NH 03301 Edwart! Haffer, Esquire Mr. Winslow Melvin Stephen J. Hartman, Jr. , Mgr. Sheehan law Firu 88 Pleasant Street EBTS - Marketing 1000 Elm Street Concord, NH 03301 Marine Midland Bank, N.A. Manchester, NH 03101 250 Park Ave. - 2nd Floor ' New York, NY 10177 4 Mary Beth Gentleman Stephen G. Wrd, Esquire David M.:Rosenbaum, President Mass. Executive Office Public Advocate's Office Technical Analysis Corp. of Energy Resources State House Station 112 6723 Whittier Ave. - Suite 202 l 100 Cambridge St.-Suite 1500 Augusta, ME 04333 McLean,.VA 22101  ; Boston, MA 02202 j James B. Walker Mrs. Barbarc C. French Ms. Aileen Katz Box 86B - R.F.D. I 17 Fairvisa Avenue LeaFue of Women Voters Laconia, M1 03246 Henniker, NH 03242 3 Pleasant Street - Room 3 Concord, Mi 03301  ; 4 1 d Rep. Susan Spear Campaign for Ratepayers' Rights Frederick Coolbroth, Esquire

47 Probate Street P.O. Box 563 Devine, Millimet & Branch i Keene, NH 03431 -Concord, NH 03301 -111. Amherst Street - Box 719 Manchester, NH 03105 1

4 Ms. Karen Briskie Mr. Ian Wilson .Mr. John Rohrbach Deputy State Treasuzer . Business & Industry Association . Office of Consumer' Advocate { Stato House Annex - Room 121 122 No. Main Street N. H. Public Utilities Com.  ! 

        . Concortl, ' NH 03301               Concerti, . NH 03301                8 Old Suncook Road Concord, NH 03301 t

d I me

c . 4 e 

      ,'       John G. Tut'aill
  • l P.O. Box 7d IAmpster,1NH 03606 i
- Mary Metcalf
Seabrook Anti-Pollution League c 5 Market Street l Portsmouth, NH- 03801
Robert Backus, Esquire.
Backus, Meyer & Solomon 116 Lowell Street Box 516
,             Manchester, NH              03105 3

! Shelley Nelkens

Box 164 -

Antrim, NH- 03440 Harold Judd, Assistant Attorney General Department of Attorney General

25 Capitol Street-
Concord, NH 0.1301-6397 i
Wynn Arnold, Executive Director and Secretary N.H. Public Utilities comm.

8 Old Suncook Road Concord, NH 03301-e Victoria Turner i ' f124 - Box 253 Bennington, NH 03442 1 i 

                                                                                                         ?

5 I e k i e 

                                                       -   ,n                +.<r  ,      w- g - -n m -q

__ . --_m._.m .__.____ -- _.._ ._ ___ -. -- - I 

         *                          $                                                                                                                                                                          i d

q l l i 3 h s a  : 1 I 5 I ' l a 1 t ) s I i I ATTACID1ENT 1  ; i i l l. i l a l i  : I _( a i E aI l i I t. I s 9 ( 

                                                                                                                                                                                                              +

4 i i 1 l 9 

       ., . - _ _ . ~ . . . . . _ . . . . . _ _ - . . . _ _ _ _ . . _ . _ . . .                        _..   .  . _ - . . . . . . . . . . . ~ . _ . . _ . , _ . _ . . . _ , _ _ . _ . . _ . .   .m.___. _J

_d6.i s a a 4 A.e ,iw .-.44- s___-A,4.1--,+a.su+,. ra4.--d_.,_h-k. __,J422  :.~__A+-a ,m. ,6m+,_ _ug._S,aA.,4-,-44.A Wa.uSJ-*-+w A 4,4.',*w-A-*u_a-d-,-ud4* 24h,,-iF--JMa- 4 *ay,e p A d-ma g Yc> 'ib N %C. M c u yp eny] g ( 

   ->                                 CCce4                                                                                                                                           ' M for cle a l y g I                           res h ( r diea.efiv;ty c.viteka_ g.oc ,
M lasss and e,4e u.ch es n r e i n a d e p 4 << 2"1+*kdecoMcm,q U"ce heads o+ 'Buchet ca+s 'on mtes A g,i w ,c, ** "fe7o .

d *W ~~3 g ( ~7 ' WI gg l i- h't" 44or *d ato Ludjdayy cfec.'isions for Sec4too h decordg 4e 't k N 8C. 3 " cey.ledecy eew4eols [of deWH bekoder. 3rd f(c[ e4 cer % r dWeJWes n ue q de pi % n ,n & 6cdy) w ec.>%e tc6""i b io as in a be- to r.ed ds ;nssu mphs ',' C fr,e s. - c o- c.< j m,1x *,,w g rp p,se. r,ae o .. ws o+ .n t=' 6 ' ^ t w+ys id ' p*, *'t-cu *ieD % o.ec. @pepa+Iy e n si+e , @ poi ec'W - l ico ymt o9 entAdtM @ ten yeo.4 , b WC^k YCAAT $' l 5+44 C 4 A~'S'PS $ 

                    @fle c3 9.oldh & At cec. car to W coreaicel j                                   en                      an     isofor.es                     mea +iord ia r e s perse. tv da+a. re 3 v o i- Q )

4 .+/4 g p c,9 cage 6g'g -f,g gc, . h Plegg.e g g,w e44 ! ASSociaied wM cod me&d A deceumissieg 9 9 't/w foY'ofcost ' 1550c'laitd drid. +hese- odlmee ts C.iaciude huo in c ~v Cos, lo# ! Iob codv, e4c} 

                                                                                                            *1                                                             M cu'n te % + desly s
                     $ Re ,' Mw prlSel                                                                                                         presed ly OT W.l.l' 9 ease. i4eun.                                                                                                                                                             te.kad&d l                                           -               o.4 cita.hreio...rf s                                                 e O w ken tAisd b co                               1 e'

dee.ed55iodij ** g k.ueobe ti's co3ts assediated .di or. i nsteded fo 

                                                                                                               ' +he;, a.s+ @ cc0 # of keAds b M'Y i 13 h.c Aa_+                                           o.c e.

demot(.3L s, s h & max',% N of >( 0 + s y w eV f - m, u .. m s.a , , ,,.se , q c , a , 4 ! & How w'iti +kis c.oc+ ha. mg C was4e, ne coveaud by 2cc's /w;p/kog ! N'% s" d~" $ O d a4 I " > c. tass 

                                                                                                          >,0           +ue s;,e,,at atwasa.

84 a. e,e.to n pcc my 

                                                                                                                                                                                                          , t..a.w w4 v
  • coes i5 not o p.ew 3 a e ([D u m <

eoc.L c u % sor- g i. e .i /c+ = ae / w cu,3 c a.te uf ,4. e + 4a. tatal deceu.ssM ccds' 

                             @ d 6l                            cote.tucM - Pleass                                                                                                   Lu h5 (*Ho o^y %eds" 34ti; q * " % vs.g ireo.ies, ra                                                                          ch4       eskartg ' hip '+tws .

su us% es s u,4eek .Sf A baris we.u, p.d l' b Appt46c 6-l @on a i.o Lof 

                                                                                                         - aa-u.a es e aae                                                                                             m #&60 Slitf95
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    *ucl' ew.a 1                                                                             ce.k mlelf p64;ts' ot.                                       'oTh on Pless e. ! bo, spec.i S4 c. ' os. -fo                                                         7 iss'ruecf ord eka'tAcA., ibY S^*  -

dec,, Srtofis4 - p htSP.Atly II S'l(N't 4 6 'rk. process .4 beu3 Cohsid44GCf "cleoa" h6,4 e,g psyds e6 SeabAcolt eyte rt a aa,,,,u.,s._ j 'Pc^d Q t e seses'"'t **n-codo?aM? Ie 4 S,oe _

N Y Mt- NCL-  %"'L As an L. 6f ( o , E N Cod h t' d w.a mm*tst W ar e. d & A cf w k . * "' N"I,IT % *A., t k w 'tk o.neu,d sef aside Sor. %-t putye:c , h ' * *,"6ll d e4 4 d i u b % e W u be d '7 

  & Rsl La.Wgg                          y                . .i .

b Please, .'aiam'ise, na. tw-l& pop gjD eG mafeM Al ' O:Lt ca.n be li SECod*.mbated io le ,h i.is c ele u g,,, cu, cIcon sc.rnp (P3 g t. % y-6) 

               " ""' S PW CEC defa'iled Assessec4 ef pg.c ne g, top, e,( pe (,fi 4eg
                 ' " ' 'ItfL'il     o. tai ds k y     n a.ssoc w J,4 pog ,,opu p T* P'^+ #r ual     sie g Q.       Q3 li  g b o et,   17, lh M \5          Yk'-     baslS       Sob ~ M                     ti        f tAda$$4 w yp               ,l Gael % a. dq s,%e.7 C.Piiabnesump on o M         soeulb. 4. do~llah \9ad o^ d*Wisdc3 L c. 'rE & Pes uq%

to g is kwus.d} h Please prov.da. o bAcaldawn cA +k m aac.*T tea.wt. I( o. AcciM4m ws e aa.1 - " 

                                                  ! w .- w, p e e-s,a e uqw v se
       @c93.s,%s.:i)

Pleass pado %ose. .po@m M AWl9 esp-ou M fvM n-i r 3 Airpaw-co9 sr W da" rk< ceino+~c~f u aas r os a.c--., mace 

                                                                                                  '8           8' Ad h e sis, a.ss. dais.d IC'c levCI 4ASYe Soc II%/

Why It tkt p Mc.'i g sYrn4.Y PS for o- Be4 will an unk,# cpg M,:!!We (7) . Ple.ae comm Mt en Any 'r ## elaune or ~ . o,. ros ue a sas is s w i-,,e

  • e .

tease p p s, & e. .sact, s, Pado & P"S=nc ^* % 9'* Haoa u Pe&%fub,WS 9tk).h. ; +*-Ao O t5ecY ss OS Jcu~ l '933 wen m . w . w . > u w co st a a m ,-ise m 7 u 

       @ tr, gifpgfedo so O xp % @ 'it                                     m nor 'in + *cce ,tt         W Ns
       @ A:r.jd AM66 Ah. wucA                                                         sM 6e            h e e s e m ~ .r a                                  = ~ i,- m 3 wwo.

b% Wed) hto @ cost 84 deco.*Mc819' Cl"*Mt- **P W f

  • d "' M I
       @ told \upo.tf dell d'A -To eg gI l#}76 mile 8'Iwt f^c8AhSF I" Expb.eu et % a'* *
  • d%,

g ge,,,, n. ) .sg+ eos,,@esst c sp.yge r -* "H r't^cludt- 

                                                          .?    C    Please.
  • co* d ace'ws *4-1 wuest d8* SAM 0ll ,w:e m ,,
  ,, g               g    -

h , ,gp ,,' wrkeoss ~ c,och a a.esso M e,n(Ja.itc9 g r - me to'itk nuo MM8pc'84I sno m am " ob >%* ha tp tto.as9er casks % de ploA p*cime.#c"? h elcase, grroutsg Ti.dgs ft#, 7-/3 n, p g-f , cy,3-t_ , cv 3.; g ,rg);npo coo.ya % 4 r sept W/D44 f a 

                                 %s v. pore,gui ie% ,. %, 3ppc:, roawh wid .r a.scl ret AndWghl PaofedtM ' C'inlud3                           .tla radi@oe, easie              M radio & co.rra i.na % g
  ., odi EI) V e k m q ,}}
Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20077D862&oldid=2765338"