ML20073R755

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Supplemental Surrebuttal Testimony of J Doyle Re Severe Minor & Offsetting Errors in Computer Analysis.Certificate of Svc Encl
ML20073R755
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 04/28/1983
From: Doyle J
Citizens Association for Sound Energy
To:
References
NUDOCS 8305040535
Download: ML20073R755 (8)
v • d • e


Text

7' i

e nLcATE!T_tstouE*omQ. s CASE EXHIBIT 762

'~

T/2853 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSI0li

%*3 llAy BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSItiG BOARD g 80 35 In the Matter of APPLICATION OF TEXAS UTILITIES I

Docket Nos. 50-445 I'

and 50-446 GfNERATING COMPANY, ET AL. FOR AN OPERATING LICENSE FOR

~

f.

COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECT.RIC STATION UNITS #1 AND #2 I

(CPSES)

I

+

l-SUPPLEMENTARY SURREBUTTAL TESTIMONY OF JACK D0YLE, WITNESS FOR INTERVENOR CASE 1

Q: Mr. -Doyle, was there additional information~which you wish to supply

~

~

2-regardingthedocuments.forwarde' don 4/26/83(CA.SE.EXHIB.IT761,your,_

3 SurrebuttalTestimony)?

4 A:

Yes.

First of all, on page 8 of. CASE Exhj6it.761C, last sentence,,

~

5 should read:

"The force in-ther. beam varies little wRh varying stiffness 6

of the stiffer beam."

Then, the computer. output con'tained sNeraT minor and generally 7

8 offsetting errors.

(This is CASE Exhibit 761 A.) - The information received g

by phone was misinterpretted in t'hree areas:

(1). Young s modulus was in-10 terpretted as 27,450,000; the correct value_for the Gibbs and Hil-1 drawing 11 is 27,650,000.

(2) The.CT'E (Coefficient of Thermal Expansion) was inter-12 pretted as 7E-6;' the correct value for the Gibbs and Hill drawing is 6.623E-6.

.D 13 (3) The temperature, was interpr,etted as 210 F; the correct figure as used l

14 by Gibbs and Hill is 220 F.

A revised com1[ uter run is attached (CASE Ex. 762A).

l 15 Q: Are there drawings already in 'the iecord which dyal with'tlie upper

~

16 lateral support or the moment resisting support?

~

8305040535 830428

~

PDR ADOCK 05000445 T

pop

j 2.

1 A: With regard to the upper lateral support, there'are none of which 2

I am aware. With regard' to the moment resisting supp'ott,' th'ere are several '

3 drawings in the record of this and another moment resisting restraint, but 4

the^particular restraint in question is thi configuration that existed until 5

at least the last day I worked at the site and thhrefore does not contain-

^

6 the kicker or brace as depicted in the Gibbs and Hill analysis. For the 7

drawing in question, they can be found in CASE Exhibit 669B (attachments to 8

' Jack Doyle deposition / testimony),'pages 9Q, 9R, 95,.and 9T.

9 Another moment restraint which was not analyzed can be found 10 in. CASE Exhibit'6698, pages 9U,.9V, and 9W. The bla'nned. configuration of the 11

.unanalyzed beam is in the lower left-hand corne'r of 9W.

~

12 Q:

Is there anything further you would like.~tn add regarding this 13 matter?

14

'A: Not at this time.

~

15

~

16 e

13

'19 i

20 21 g

sp

( 23 24 25 p

. ~

f l

^

N

~

'4/27/G3 - 11:50: 44 CASE EXHIBIT 762A 2**

SYSTEMS PROFESSIONAL STRESS - PROGRAM NO. 16.1 REV-201C. M

    • x x x *
  • xx t * * *
  • x x * * * * * * * * * * * *
  • x * * * * * * ** * * * * * * *
  • x x x x t * * * * * * * * * * *
  • x
  • x t * *
  • x t * *
  • 4 STRUCTURE - UPPER-LAT RES. 44)PPERLAT.-BM.).

TYPE PLANE FRAME NUMBER OF JOINTS 4

$ STATISTICS

$ TRACE NUMBER OF MEMBERS 3-LIST MEMBER PROPER. TIES IN INCHES NUMBER

  • OF LOADINGS 1

- NUMBER OF SUPRORTS 2..

1 UNITS KIPS INCH

~

TABULATE REACTIONS FORCES DI5 PLACEMENTS'

-. JOJNT. COORDIN ATES---- -

-. -. [

^

1 0 0 S $ 2 10 0 $ 3 172 0 $ 4 182 0 S-UNITS KIPS INCHES

.---- M E MB. PROP PR IS AX-357-.12-1,. *--SM.--.--

2

{

~~

MEMB PROP.PRIS AX 14.82 IZ 1.

  • WALL B

- -. _.1 -

~ ~

MEMB PROP PRIS AX 2.83 IZ 1.

  • WALL A 3

N MEMBER. INCIDENCES-- -

~

m p 3. 2 $ 223$ 3 3'4 ~

~~ ~

~

UNITS KIPS INCHES CONS TA NT.S-E.-27650.-- ALL --.

UNITS NIPS INCH

- - ~

~~ # ~

LOADING NO. 1

-.--ME MBER.. TEMP-- CH ANGE S.00000462.L,

~~

2 220

~

SOLVE

.-_ RROBLEM C055<ECTLL SRECIFIED, EXECUTION TO PP h.-_. --.-..

N w

ew.e..

e..

.e.,

e.

m-=

g

.e e

a. -
  • ^

m P

o.-

7 m

w

_- 3 _, - -

- ~

  • g

- 6ee -

.ee6, -.m

,,,,,g

STRUCTURE - UPPER LAT RES ( UPPERLAT.BM )

=============================

=============================u

( UNITS IN INCHES AND KIPS )

MEMBER PROPERTIES ~

.h MEMBER LENGTH X-AXIS Y-AXIS Z-AXIS X-AXIS Y-AXIS Z-AXIS E

.-..e 1

10.00 1.5E-1 0.0E O

1.OE O 2.8E 4.

2 *162 00 3 6E 2 0.0E O

1.0E O 2.8E 4

-...__ 1. O E O

2.. B E. 4..

_ 3 _.

. 10. 00_ 2. 8 E___0. OmDE O

a 4

me r.,

.-s aus. e y

e 6..e.

..e,..e-ee e p

4 O

~*-*M---

3.....,

-m e>

.e

.g zen g

8 9

A

'W pp Mg.

.e.em m.

m.

.&4 aw

-. e e

d e

I a

.- = w... e -

ab e

W 9

M-M M

M e

=

.4 gd>

M-6 N

=

h e

h

' e 4-E**

no.

wm p

an

  • y w.

..o.e 4

e==-

. es w.

a w

..M N -m

  • w..

4

  • 4

.~

N

s STRUCTURE - UPPER LAT RES ( UPPERLAT.BM >

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = _ =. = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = - = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =. = = = = = = = = = - = = = =

( UNITS IN INCHES AND-KIPS h- --- -

LOADING NO. 1

=================;.======================_=====.--======-.=====

w MEMBER FORCES MEMBER JOINT AXIAL FORCE SHEAR. FORCE-MOMENT 1

1 1399.930 0.000 0.00

-439 9.930_-----

0.000' 0.00 - - -.

2 2

1399.930 0.000 0.00 3

-1399.930 0.000

+

0.00

~~

.... - _ 3..._ --. 2.__ __43 9 9_ 90 0

~

-.c.000

_ 0.00

~

4

-1399.920 0.000.

0.00

. - -. 7.-

A P-P.L IE It_JCI N T.- L O A DS.,_

F REG-JOIM.T S-JOINT FORCE X FORCE Y

~

MOMENT Z

-0.001 0.000

-0.00-3

-0.002 0.000 0.00

-. - - - - - - REACT.I ONSAPPLIEb-_ LOADS-- SUPPDRT_ JOINTS,- - - - -.. - --.-

JOINT FORCE X FORCE Y MOMENT Z -

1.. --. 139.9_. 9 3 0 0.000 0 00-_...__

4

-1399.920 0.000 0.00 SUM 0.003 0. 0 0'O

~

___ ----- _EREE -JOIN T-CISRLAC EM E NT S--_.

JOINT X-DISPLACEMENT Y-DISPLACEMENT ROTATION

- - - - - - -. - _.2.-- -- _---- -4. 0342 0_0000 0J0000 3

0.1789 0.0000 0.0000 e

ew.

.e-p_

e as e

ww&

-g.g,..e

-.N-N

-we.

.wa.-

e e

6 2.----.

a g

ub e

m 4

. aim..

-.-.. "--m--

.==

s

..e

&=

m 6

SYSTEM P:GFESSIONAL STRESS 4/27/03 RTRUCTURE - UPPER LAT RES ( UPPERLAT.BM )

                                                                                                                                        • a***

PLANE FRAME 4

3 MEMBERS._.

4 JOINTS 1 LOADINGS 27 LINES INPUT..

55.E<ECORDS USEfr O.8 MINUTES RUNTIME O

e.m.

.._eem

. +.

.e.

w.

13..

.=.

m.m e.ew...

e 7

1%

~

e 6

._.. *_i_._.._

g 4

e a

  1. g

.Y...~.e....

. _ O. 2M L

-o m #

w

.e en se

-e*e

.w...

- ee e-

.g.

-- me e

.-6mMG o og-

-e en e

=

w s.

w.*

..e.._.-

e.

. = =.

e..

l

~

l L

1

~

c O

~

l I

g O

    • N W

W e6

..N.e-W ee e-m 6

/

6me W. e 4> 6 6 ee.

m e

et

  • 8" l**.e#=.*>.

a.m.

e -e-e.

m q.

e_

.wem.

e.

m.

S y

. O si.

.w e.

w.

.e me

-.g

..m.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Y*

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 83 IIM -2 MO:36 In the Matter of l

l

.o

..i APPLICATION OF TEXAS. UTILITIES Q

Em 1

GENERATING COMPANY,'ET'AL. FOR l

. Dockel Nos. 50-445 AN OPERATING LICENSE FOR 9

and 50-446 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC l

~

STATION UNITS #1 AND #2 (CPSES) '

I CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE By my signature below, I h.ereby certify that true ind' correct copies of Supplemental Surrebuttal TestimcIny of Jack Doyle, Witness for Intervenor.

CASE (CASE Exhibit 762 and Attachment 762A)

- have been sent to the names listed below this 2Bthday of Apr.il -

, 198 _,

3 by: Express Mail where indicated by

  • and First _ Class Mail elsewhere.

j l

  • Administrative Judge Peter B. Bloch Alan S.-Rosenthal, Esq., Chainnan-t U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=nission Atomic Safe.ty and Licensing Appeal Board 4350 East / West Highway, 4th Floo P. ~

U. S. Nucpar Regulatory Comission Bethesda, Maryland 20014 Washington, D. C.

20555

  • Dr. i(enneth A. McCollom,' Dean Dr. W. Reed Johnson, Member

~

Division of Engineering, Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Architecture and Technology U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Oklahoma State Univers.ity

.Stillwater, Oklahoma 74074.

Washington, D. C..

20555

-Thomas -S. Moore, Esq., Member

  • Dr. Walter H. Jordan Atomic. Safety and Licensing Appeal Board 881 W. Outer Drive U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Oak Ridge,~ Tennessee 37830 Washington, D. C.

20555 l

  • Nicholas S. Reynolds, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Panel l

Debevoise & Liberman U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l

1200 - 17th St., N. W.

2 Washington, D..C.

.20036

~

-Washington, D. C.

20555 -

i

. Docketing and Service.Section..

i

  • Marjorie Ulman Rothschild, Esq.

Office ~ of the Secretary Office of Executive Legal Directoi ;USNRC -.11. S. Nuclear Regulato,ry fomission l

Maryland National Bank Building Washington, D.jC.

20555 7735 Old Georgetown Road - Room 10105. -

Bethesda, Maryland' 20814

  • Ms. Lucinda Minton, Law Clerk

-Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board

._ 4350 East / West Highway,' 4th Floor Panel

.. - Bethesda, Maryland 20014-U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Washington, D. C.

20555

~

l s.

_, ~ _

Certificate of Service Page 2

  • David J. Preister, Esq.

Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Division Supreme Court Building Austin, Texas

,78711

.+

John Collins Regional Administrator, Region IV U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Conmission 611 Ryan Plaza Dr., Suite 1000 Arlington, Texas 76011 Mr. R. J. Gary

. Executive Vice President and General Manager Texas Utilities Generating Company

~

~ ~

2001 Bryan Tower Dallas, Texas 75,201

~

{anny Alan Sinkin "c

~~ ~

838 East Magnolia Avenue San Antonio, Texas 78212 e

u.

=

t

[h 2

-gCASE TCitizens Associat' ion for Sound Energ rs.) Juanita Ellis, President

~

l 1426. 3. Polk rDallas, Texas 75224-

~

~

2,14/946-9'446 6

es m

s 2

4 y

6 4

m

~

s O

m N

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20073R755&oldid=4403515"