ML20071D012
| ML20071D012 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Zimmer |
| Issue date: | 02/21/1983 |
| From: | Borgmann E CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20071D008 | List: |
| References | |
| EAB-SOL-27, NUDOCS 8303090101 | |
| Download: ML20071D012 (1) | |
Text
_
(
ii e
-(lk,$~ll "=m$ #
1 THE CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY is
~ ~
CINCINN ATI,OMIO 45201 February 21, 1983 EAB-SOL-27 scIoYv. cs.*c^s"o",
PRINCIPAL S{A1 :
t/9A _/wENF D/RA SCSVo 71,f 3 U.
S.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION A/RA PA10 h
Region III DFRP SLO 799 Roosevelt Road GWA RC Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 GNSF DP ML Attention:
Mr.
J.
G.
Keppler OL
- FILEDF, Regional Administrator s
RE:
Wm.
H.
Zimmer Nuclear Power Station - Unit 1 CONCURRENCE OF NON-CONSTRUCTION ITEMS UNDER SHOW CAUSE ORDER OF NOVEMBER 12, 1982, Docket No. 50-358 Construction Permit No. CPPR-88 W.
O.
57300 Job E-5590 File 957 Gentlemen:
The intent of this letter is to clarify Item 11 of your November 30, 1982 letter (attached) to Mr.
E.
A.
Borgmann.
Item 11 covered the physical movement of mechanical equipment, provided it does not enhance Construction.
The NRC reply to this work' request was that it did not contain sufficient information to permit blanket approval and that CG&E should request approval of such work by Region III on a case by case basis.
The following is offered as a clarification to Item 11.
This Item is intended to mean that where Permanent Plant Material is in the Power Plant, Fab Shops or Warehouse, it can be moved to secure locations or locations for inventory purposes, so long as movement is not for permanent installation.
A prompt reply to this request would be appreciated.
Very truly yours, THE CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC CO.
By E.
A.
Borgmann Senior Vice President JCH: rem cc: NRC Office of Inspection and Enforcement Washington, D.
C.
20555 NRC Senior Resident Inspector Attention:
W.
F.
Christianson 8303090101 830303 PDR ADOCK 05000350 A
PDR FEB 2 5 E63
r -
..m s.
s.
a UNITED STATCO If M4g*V,
- MJCJEAR RECULATORY CO?.".*lO0 ION
(
m c ano n ass M
W p,tcEIVED t
s veo noossvet.T AoAo t
o u = u.vu.iu.m oi.m er a
E%* coo
- go(Yn
- ~~g y
NOV 10 E~.2 g-
,==="" DE0 01g
&- -Decknt No. 50-358 g
file
=
" - ^ =ad=aati Gas and Elactric 3.w..a u W any AIIN: Mr. Ecr1 A. Em w.n Senior Vice Precident Incinacring Servines and Qcetric Production
~
3.39 5.ast 4th Streat
. N="4aae ti, 03 45201
.c.,,--
.Scntle=en:
"Ihis is in respdasa to your letter (QI.-2110) dcced Kovc=.ber 10. 1902 med revised on Novanhe.r 22.1982 (copicis enclosed).
ToterequestforNRCconcurrencepriortoperhor=ingthe16cetivitica
~
... Murd in your Novc=bar 16, 1902 letter is not, ccncidercd to be c rcquccc to reicx the order as provided for in pcrcgrcPh IV.E.(3) of j
the 2:ovechcr 12. 1982 Order to show ccuco cad Order Its:.dictcly L
Euspending Conceruction.
Enther. it to concidtrc.d to be, a requc;t for L
mlar4 Netion of the scop..of the ccrivitics r.ucptnded by the order.
l l
As discussed in the nnatina vic'n you cn r,ov-^cr 17, 1982 thn Enc l
Tcquested thct activities which c:icht be concidered to be. covered by
._4he ordcr be cub =itted to Region III for revicv sad cyprovcl.
1hsring tele. phono convercationc on Kavcd _r 19, 1902, T.III perr:an-ci infort;d CG;I: that itcan 9. velhdc= cf c:n.ca isl cycccr c, ct.d 15.
docu= nt revicuo, of the Novc=ber IG, 1552 1ctecr ecro clearly not prohibited by the order und that th:/ could continue.
CGC.E'c rcviced letran A-red November 22 deleted thoco two itc=s.
Tha following activitico cre not concidcred to be safety-eclated conctruction activition uus, pended by tbc order, snd they ecy bo l
co=tinued within your c>.irting e. neceracnt controlc cnd your cccchliched l
qialdry accurence progracio.
Tho itc= nur-Scru licted bclow correcpond
-:2 the naccrc contained in your 1:ovc.ber 22, 1902 letter, tV L
i y
l 1
I i
.y
~
2 9-/ 2 /
- 3 O
/
3 0 Sa2 Cincinnati cao and Elcetric,
i Coupspy 1
1.
Re:noval of paints and coatings necesesry to inspect valds, not to infringe on the metablished corrective action system and tha verification program and not to include grinding, cutring, etc.
I 2
Re noval of fireproofing and in=ulation to inspect valds and hast mmher traceability.
Grindir; and cutting steel are not permitted.
3.
Removal of hangers or parts of hangcra looking for beat nu=her traccability, not to include cutting, chipping, grinding. burning, etc.
4.
EssenHn1 EVt.C sir flow tanting sad brlevin;.
5.
Routino v.ciatenance of eascatini cocponcats such as lubricccion.
cicening, changing filters. etc. cs H71.C. t:otors, etc.
8.
Eccciving of asacarial cataricl; however, the issue or rcissue I
of assentici acterials for essential application is not to be performed except in support of ite:n 5 above and the varification pro;;r =.
9.
conduct evcluccieno of existin; ecccacici continco staich rcquira tchina sn=ples cud conducting tceto.
Ec:gica etc to be li=1ted in cire cuch cs pcint chips and the cuthoricction doco not include 4
cutting seccl, grinding. etc.
4 4
13.
Eydrostatic cnd pneucstic ecuting and TDE cetivities.
Tha folleging ite=n did not conscin sufficient information to permit bienket approval.
L*c believe such work chould be requested by CG6E cnd cpproved by EEC Regica III on a cccc by ccca bccis.
- 11. Tho phyr.Leci covczent of r.cc*ncaicc1 cquip-t, provided it dono l
not c'*henr*C construction.
- 12. ino cpplication of fire barricro c1cccified es importent to scfety i
not listed as essential.
l The follo ing activitics may not continuo at thic tico:
6.
Shipecct of ccsential racerict offsite to vcadors for fabrication.
Tcis is concidered to be scfcty-rolsted ccaccructica work.
7.
Crinding activitics to prepero cascattel v.:.lds for UDE cxentnntions.
Grinding on enecntial r.aterial.s is concidersd tc be a safety-related construction activity.
-n-
,. Cincinn;tB G2a M Elcctric gy Coorpany f
- 10. ' Electrical testing of cables and logic testing. Although testing lLs not specifically prohibited by this order, the proposed testing involves deterr-innting and terminating iceds sixich 2.s norm =lly 4
cocaidated to be a construction r.ctivity.
Ecgion III in not
^
prepared to issuo blanket approval for electrical testing of cables and logic testin;;. but vill consider approval of such testing on a specific case basis.
14.
Installation of mirror inculation on the EPV vossci is not approved since it would cover areas that cry require inepcetion.
Va vill gledly diccuco any quections you hevo concerning thin c tter.
l Bioccrcly, D
s Jee s G. Ecpp Regics 1 Id 'Metrctor Encloaurca:
As stated cc w/ltro dtd 11/16; 11/22/62:
E:U/Docrrr. nc Control D.:ch MT Resident Innpcetor, EIII Enrold W. Cohn, Peccr Sicing Co iccion Citizenc /<citust a Ecdiocctivo Environ =cnt Helen W. Evenc, Ctcta of C*aio Robert M. Quillin, Ohio Deparecent of Eccith Tho=cs Applc;cto Thonss Dcvine, Accocicte Dirceter, Institute for l
Policy Studies Dave Martin, Offico of Attorney Cencral 3%rh Wetterhchn, Ecq.
Jeroz.e A. Vcnne enn, Esq.
e
_ ~. - -..........
- =.. - -.
-w.-.
m q.
- THE CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY E
- "U N ZIMMER NUCLEAR POWER STATION, P.O. BOE 201, MDSCOW, 03 45153 movember 18, 1982 QA-2118 Revised Nov. 22, 1982 u,,.
me neo e.x ns.es e
\\
U.S. Euclear Regulatory Cornission Region III 799 Rooscvelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Attention:
Mr. J. c. rapplcr Regions.1 Administrator RE:
WN. H. ZIE:ER NUCLEAR PO*n'En CT1.TIO.:. U:!II 1 CO:"CtEEE';CE OF EOM-COMCTT.COTION ITa:S UCDI'R SEDW CAUSE 01DE?. OF 1;GVDC'?. 12, 1902 DOCKER K0. 50-358, CONSTnUOTIO: PEm:IT EO.
_CPPR-88, V.O.
57303, JOU E-55C3, FILG l'.C-3 Gentic=ca:
I hio 1ctecr in a revicion to our letter Q*.-2110 of rove her 18, SS2.
he r:. vision required the re sysl of ite== to. O cnd No.15 fecn ths cricin 1 lettor i
brecuso they do not constituto physicci conotruction as coverad by your Show Cause Order cud therefore should not hcvc bcen included.
l n ia revicion confires the exchence of infern: tion in a telephona conversation l
betvecn !! ccrc. D. Eenter of ycur etaff c:ad D. K. Culver on Noveder 19, 1982.
r Tieferc.cc ic :::do to the c:: tin; h Id ir. Cir.cinnnti, 0"nio.Eeve6cr 17.1902 in l
Ifr. DicLhen r'c office.
We vica to cc:.c:. u:: cerrt.in cetivitico which vc believe do not violccc the spirit of tha Novc.S:.r 12, 1902 Chou Ccuco r.nd Order of Ic_ dir.ce--
Suspcucica of Eccentici conceruction.
Ecrsver, wo vich concurrence on thoco itc=.:
prior to their perfomece l
1.
Recoval of peints end contince noccccery to inspeer veldo. Repainting to protect valdo.
In thic percitted?
(
2.
Rensval of fircproofing cud incult.tica to incpect valde and heat nu=her I
trceocbility.
Ccn thio be donc?
l l
3.
Eccaval of hangor or pcrec cf h:.ncer looking for hect nucer tracecbility.
Is.this pert:itted?
4.
tecontial IWAC is recdy for cir tec: cud belt.ncing.
Mr.y va proceed?
5.
It is necessary to perform routine z. intenance on esssatial cocponents such as lubricstion, cleaninc cf.cncing filters, oce., on UV/C,
- tors, etc.
Will this be pctnittcf.7 s.,
,y
~
7 l
..e i-o J. C. Emppler QA2118 Novesber 18. 1982 Pep 2 HJK would like to sh'ip essential saterial off site to vendors for 6.
fabrication.
i 7.
Grinding is required in oor.= cases to prepare essential welds for EDE an -f nation.
Is this per=itted?
Are we prohibit 2d from receiving e.nd reis:,uing occcatici catorial to 8.
contractors on site provided they cre not eced in construction?
We would like to continue walkdo a of oc::catini systees both for 9.
engineering, inspection and tracc:.bility.
I We would' like to conduct ev 1uction= of c=icting ensential coatings 10.
wh1eb require taking surples cnd ccaduating tests.
We would like to continue cinctricci 5ccting of cables and logic testing.
~
11.
Is this pernicccd7 Is it permitted to physicc11y covo t.cchcnicel cquips:nt provided it
^
12.
does not enhc=co conctruccics?
Are va percitted to continue applicction of fire barriers classified 17 es impsetent to safety not licted no cacenti 17 l
14.
May va proceed with hydroct tic, pncuc. tic testing and EDET Ecvicv cnd ceceptance of qu lity-rciated docu:.: tation - may it proceed?
15.
16.
Insta11stion of mirror inculctica en the 15V veccol.
Ecy it proceed?
A prompt comique in responce to our requcc eculd bn cypreciated.
Vcry cruly yours, TEE CICCIlT.!!.TI CAS & ELECTRIC COM'!M 1--
gy C
E. /.. E37.C.LU:22 5 1:10'.; VICE PRESIDC;T RPE:jas cct NaC Office of Inspection
& Enforcement Washington D.C. 20555 NRC Senior Resident Inspector Attn: W. F. Christiencon T,1rm r Project Inspector Region III
,,,n
,.--,-n
, - - - - - - -, _., - - - -, -