ML20070N845
| ML20070N845 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Hatch, Calvert Cliffs, Palo Verde, Grand Gulf, Arkansas Nuclear, River Bend, Vogtle, Waterford  |
| Issue date: | 04/25/1994 |
| From: | Correia R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Zech G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20070N848 | List: |
| References | |
| REF-GTECI-B-56, REF-GTECI-EL NUDOCS 9405100117 | |
| Download: ML20070N845 (6) | |
Text
.-
p na
.7Y UNITED STATES i
[ )Zl[t]
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20666 0001 s..w.,.. j April 25,1994 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Gary G. Zech, Chief.
Performance and Quality Evaluation Branch Division of Licensee Performance and Quality Evaluation, NRR FROM:
Richard P. Correia, Chief Maintenance and Reliability Section Performance and Quality Evaluation Branch Division of Licensee Performance and Quality Evaluation, NRR
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- MARCH 31, 1994, NRC MAINTENANCE INSPECTION PROCEDURE WORKSHOP The subject workshop was held at the Holiday Inn Crowne Plaza in Rockville, Maryland. This was the second public workshop on NRC "Results f-L Based" maintenance inspection procedures.
The list of pre-registered
(
attendees is provided as Enclosure 1, a transcript of the meeting as l, the workshop handout as Enclosure 3, and submitted written l
comments as Enclosure 4.
The purpose of the workshop was to provide the public an opportunity to comment on the NRC draft maintenance inspection procedure which will be used by NRC inspectors to verify the implementation of the Maintenance Rule (10 CFR 50.65). Workshop presentations included an overview of the NRC inspection program, the maintenance rule and the NUMARC 93-01. industry guidance, the contents of the draft maintenance inspection procedure, and preliminary maintenance rule enforcement information.
Headquarters maintenance rule staff and NRC regional inspection representatives participated in the discussions.
As stated in the Federal Registrar Notice published on February 4,1994, the written comments received through April 14, 1994, will be considered for incorporation, as appropriate, into the next revision to the inspection procedure. Written comments were received by mail from the Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI), Winston & Strawn, Brookhaven National Laboratories and nine utilities. Most of the items-included in the written comments were also l
discussed at the workshop, and many comments received from the utilities were included in those received from NEI.
O 9405100117 940425
[
PDR REVGP ERONUNRC-PDR t\\ \\
/
, /pp ~,7--MfM4/(d NC L
/
O
( y ',,, 9 M 4-/, p7. 50 -kda"
,t 0
24-In f _.y MC RE CENTEfi COPY
l
=.,
Gary G. Zech i Following revision to the draft procedure, the staff plans to perform several site visits during the latter part of 1994 to verify and validate the draft procedt.re.
Lessons learned from the site visits and the revisions to the inspection procedure will be the subject of a public workshop in the Spring l
of 1995.
J WA Richard P. Correia, Chief Maintenance and Reliability Section Performance and Quality Evaluation Branch Division of Licensee Performance 1
and Quality Evaluation, NRR l
Enclosures:
As stated
~
cc w/o enclosures l
C. Rossi R. Wessman i
i l
DISTRIBUTION:
Central, Files
- PDR (w/ enclosures)
RPEB R.F.
l SEND RPES:DRll SC:RPEB DRIL OFC NAME TO TFoley:Jp RPCorreia [O DATE PDR7 k/I,(/94 dr] Q /94
/
/94
/
/94
/
/94 COPY?
s No /
Yes No
{
Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes No i
"0FFICI ALNt&GORD COPY DCtNMEHff NAMEt St\\RPEBDOCS\\SECTION.S\\ WORKSHOP.MEM l
I i ',
PRE-REGISTARED ATTENDEES i
MAINTENANCE PROCEDURE WORKSHOP MARCH 31, 1994 i
1 Dwight Johnson Entergy 2
John Wilson Entergy 3
Tom Thurman Grand Gulf 4
Ron Moomaw Grand Gulf 5
Sam Mooney Grand Gulf i
i 6
'Monika Pigon Commonwealth Edison i
7 Don Goldsmith Commonwealth Edison i
8 Kent Engelmann Niagara Mohawk 9-Ken Johnson Niagara Mohawk i
10 Bob Magnant Niagara Mohawk 11 Dan Strong Niagara Mohawk 12 Preston Swafford Niagara Mohawk 2
13 Bob Williams Duquesne Light Co.
14-Paul Smith Duquesne Light Co.
15 Charlene Sabol Duquesne Light Co.
i 16 Alan Abrahamovich Yankee Atomic Electric Co.
L 17 Patrick Donnelly Yankee Atomic Electric Co.
18 Liz Thompson Florida Power & Light i
19 Katharen Lauver Florida Power & Light 20 Bob Dawson Florida Power & Light 21 Greg Lareau Duke Power Co.
i 22 Mary Birch Duke Power Co.
l 23 Neal McCraw Duke Power Co.
24 Terry Pedersen Duke Power Co.
3 25 Robert Knoerr Duke Power Co.
i 26 David Franklin Southern California Edison 27 Lou Cash Southern California Edison 4F 28 Jiggs Travis Southern California Edison 29 Ken Brown Southern California Edison 30 G.L Plumlee Southern California Edison 31 Kevin Hastings Northeast Utilities 32 Robert Flanagan Northeast Utilities 33 John Wilaon Northeast Utilities 34 Ted Nichols Northeast Utilities 35 Phil Baumann Northeast Utilities 4
36 Paul Parulis Northeast Utilities 37 Tom Galloway Northeast Utilities i
38
-Bill Temple Northeast Utilities j -39 Jerry Van Noordennen Northeast Utilities 40 Bill Simmons IES Utilities 41 Ken Putmas IES Utilities 42 Mark Reis Washington Public Power Supply l
43 Dick Telander Washington Public Power Supply I
44 Jeff McGuire Centerior Energy 1
45 Todd Henderson Centerior Energy 46
-Terry Doerscher Illinois Power 47 Edward Bader Illinois Power 48.
Bill Heysek General Public Utilities 49 George Belchik Union Electric 50 Doug Gaynor Consolidated 2dison
j..
1,,
51 Mike Yergeau North Atlantic Energy 52 Eric Zumwalt Baltimore Gas & Electric i
53 Eric Teffany Consumers Power Co.
~
j 54 Don Burke Virginia Power i
55 Ed J. Fisher Rochester Gas & Electric 56 Brent Smith New York Power Authority 57 Steven Swearngin OPPD Ft. Calhoun 1
58 William W. Williams Pennsylvania Power & Light 59 Mark Forsyth South Texas Project 60 Vic Whaley TVA 61 Richard Favraeu TVA 62 Ted Koser South Texas Project
]
63 C. W. Crawford.
Carolina Power & Light
]
64 Wesley Sparkman Southern Nuclear Operating Co.
65 Wayne Colonnello Detroit Edison 1
66 Carol. Jilek Wisconsin Electric 67 Jeff Irwin Arizona Public Service 1
68 Roy Linthicum Arizona Public Service Co.
69 Ted Dillard Florida Power & Light i-70-Mark Varno Carolina Power & Light i
71 Vince Kelly Pennsylvania Power & Light 72 Dale Roth Pennsylvania Power & Light j
73 Don Gandenberger Pennsylvania Power & Light-i 74 Bill Williams
. Pennsylvania Power & Light l
75 Bill Dupuis Commonwealth Edison j
76 Chuck Sibley Commonwealth Edison 77 Allen Mc Allister Toledo Edison 78 Aryl Clason Wolf Creek Nuclear Operating Copr.
}
79 David Kapinus Commonwealth Edison 80 John Wallace Wisconsin Public Service 81 Ron Gaston Centerior
}
82 Randell Herring Duke Power 83 Bill Zemo American Electric Power 84 Ana Anuje Baltimore Gas & Electric 1
85 Rick Branch Baltimore Gas & Electric B6 Al Broch Baltimore Gas & Electric 87 Jim Lippold Baltimore Gas & Electric 88 Tim Lupold Baltimore Gas & Electric 89 John Osborne Baltimore Gas & Electric i
j 90 Steven Siebenaler Vectra Technologies a
91 David Army QES 92 Donald Burgy Axiom Technology Corp.
j 93 Lothar Schroeder
- Axiom Technology Corp.
[
94 David Van State of New Jersey 95 Thomas Kolesnik State of New Jersey 96 Al Paglia South Carolina Electric & Gas 97 Roger Miller Gilbert Commonwealth 98 Fred Lobbin General Physics 99 Michael P. Ferrante American Nuclear Insurers 100 Ray Smith Martin Marrietta 101 Owen Rothberg INEL 4
102 Patrick Daily DOE Oakridge 4
103 Raj Gopal Indus Technologies
\\
i
. - ~
..u
...---e
~.
-,,,.-.m
..cyou--v..,
m,-
_. - - ~
7 104 Harry E) stein Devon-Roe
'105 Jeffry.otz Devon-Roe 106 James Jenson Devon-Roe Wes'inghouse 107 Mark Beaumont t
108 Chris Peta Westinghouse 109 Steve Fowler Westinghouse 110 Jim Raleigh Southern Technical Services 111 Bob Sweeny Southern Technical Services 112 Frank Berte Tetra Cnsti 113 Michael Grim Enercon Services 114 Bob Barkonic Pa. Dept. of Environmental Ser.
115 Bob Meyers Pa. Dept. of Environmental Ser.
116 Vienin Graney Bechtel 117 Eric Blocher Gilbert Commonwealth 118 Danial Lehnert Ogden Environmental 119 Frank E. Gregor Ogden 120 Bill ligget DOE - Energy Inform. Adm.
121 Dave Andress DOE - Energy Inform. Adm.
122 Tim Mathews Neuman Bauknight 123 Robert Helfrich Winston & Strawn 124 Daniel Stenger Winston & Strawn 125 Anthony Fresco Brookhaven National Lab.
126 Warren Hall NUMARC 127 Dan Rains NUMARC 128 Ray NG NUMARC 129 Alex Marion NUMARC 130 Doug Walters NUMARC 131 Mel Gmyrek NUMARC 132 Gene Kurtz Vectra 133 Steve Mondrowski Vectra i
134 Bill Miggett NUS Corporation 135 Earl Hill NUS Corporation 136 Charles Willbanks NUS Corporation 137 Bob Borsum B&W Technologies 138 David Ste11 fox McGraw Hill 139 Walt Smith Sargent & Lundy 140 Pamla Ellis EPH l
141 Dr. Armand Lakner Viking Systems Int'l l
142 John Conklin B & W Technologies 1
143 Fred Schofer Tenera l
144 Mark Doyle SAIC 145 Wayne Johnson EPRI 146 Art Killinger MPR 147 Jim Danahy Grove Engineering 148 Santiago Alvarez Westinghouse 149 Jim Riccio Public Citizen Critical Mass 150 Bob Christie Performance and Reliability 151 John Gurtner Irwin Engineering 152 Ray Smith Martin Harrietta l
a--
d
}
)',
a i
k i
t 153 Angel Coello Spanish Nuclear Safety Council
- 154 Joaquin Echeverria Endesa l155 3
Juan Manuel Martinez Nuclenor 156 Miguelangelo Chimeno Iberdrola 157 Ernie Rossi Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- 158 Gary Zech Nuclear Regulatory Commission
. 159 Rich Correia Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2 160 Tom Foley Nuclear Regulatory Commission i 161 Chuck Petrone Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- 1. 162 Frederick Shoun Nuclear Regulatory Commission 4
163 Dave A11 sop Nuclear Regulatory Commission i 164 Mike Webb Nuclear Regulatory Commission l 165 Jeff Sharkey Nuclear Regulatory Commission j 166 Steve Reynolds Nuclear Regulatory Commission 167 Frank Akstulewicz Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- 168 Pat O' Reilly-Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- 169 Tim Polich Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- 170 Steve Hoffman Nuclear Regulatory Commission i 171 Scott Newberry Nuclear Regulatory Commission i 172 Tom Hiltz Nuclear Regulatory Commission l 173 Pat O'Reilly Nuclear Regulatory Commission 174 John Boardman Nuclear Regulatory Commission 175 Cornie Holden Nuclear Regulatory Commission 176 Paul Shemanski Nuclear Regulatory Commission 177 David Fisher Nuclear Regulatory Commission
! 178 Donna Skay Nuclear Regulatory Commission j 179 Peter Koltay Nuclear Regulatory Commission i
)
i l
4 i
4 h
1 4
i L
4 4
4 4
. ~,
- _ -.. -,.... ~
l 1
\\
accandw/ur nats...,l y !9Pt oi Transcript NRC Public Workshop on the Maintenance Rule Inspection Procedure March 31,1994 4
(
_