ML20070M067

Third Set of Interrogatories & Request to Produce Documents. Svc List Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20070M067
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	01/07/1983
From:	Backus R BACKUS, MEYER & SOLOMON, SEACOAST ANTI-POLLUTION LEAGUE
To:	NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD)
References
ISSUANCES-OL, NUDOCS 8301120253
Download: ML20070M067 (3)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:, m,,; y s. ,a og corEESPONDENCR ,3:

g -

- 4

.( ef ec Lv s e,.; _....

.,,L f Q ~-: n g) '?.:# c /i UNITED STATES OF AMERICA f NUCLEAR REGULNIDRY COlmilSSION Uh1ETED ~ "7 \\' g zn u.y h. .._ ' y N ' BEFORE THE A'IDMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD -g g -{ & '83 JAN 10 ~ P2:13 = .a 21 In:the: matter of: Cr~iG ;f SLMTAukv w.. [hUBLICSEkVICECOMPANYOF Docket Nos.50Nk h jC. E .; n CNEW' HAMPSHIRE, et al-50-444 OL 7 -* y 7:: 3;; c, N S h (S.eabrookiStation, Units 1 and 2)

• y + ; ;OHy E e p.

c;. ,~ _. $,,[,l '9 SAPL'S THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES r@Fe AND RQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS N'..;.f n M ~-

• 2.e C

.t;O 'ID THE. NUCLEAR REGULATORY OOhMISSION STAFF .i h; *dWh5 2a#.~in. :.Ws5E ergs

--Ths Seacoast Antipollution League ("SAPL") hereby requests the av

3

.NRC S t a f f..- p u r s u a n t to 10 C.F.R. 62.740(b) and 62.741, answer

W separately and fully, in writing under oath or affirmation, the

..l-following interrogatories and produce and permit inspection and ~ l' copyin~g~of the original or best copy of all documents identified in ,ZE the responses to. Interrogatories below, and that subsequent to filing l"- answe r s Eto these Interrogatories and producing documents therein "'~ identified, the NRC Staff file supplemental responses and produce fj:.; additional documents as required by 10 C.F.R. 42.740(e). - 2.":' - y, = l. Describe in detail the basis for the Staf f's conclusion that .d5 ' - M he database for assessing the probabili1 ties of events more ~ , severe than the,de,sJgn. basis for natural. phenomenon or sabotage a.:c W nevents is beyo'id.,the. s t a t e-o f-the-ar t. o f : p robab i l i s t i c risk

• "E mas'sessment.

.j u... . L. a. w. lW-. 2. ...:Wh'at is the basis for the Staf f's conclusion that the additional +1dE , 4 !!s k from severe accidents initiated by natural events or

d

1

, ~sabo t a ge i s wi t h i n t h e unce r t.a i r).t y o f r i s k s p r e s en ted f o r the !91 Accident sequences considered,,in the DES and FES? s r4tf f k. ~_......

k 3.

kfease provide copies of al5 staf f memoranda prepared in TC 'islation to the development of the Commission's Statement of . Interim Policy published June 13, 1980. ^ i mm 4. tStste wi th particulari ty all numerical values assigned to the I un'dertainties of distributions of individual dose impacts set C, .forth in(Figures 5.4 through 5.7 and included in the sununary ch impact table 5.10 oT'The DES. V$tb with particularity the basis for the Staf f's conclusion FF" 5. I ~' d ~~that-the uncertainty bounds for probabilistic and risk assessment analyses in the FES could be well over a f actor of 10, but are not likely to be as large as a factor of 100. Are the uncertainty bounds equal with respect to all ca tego r i es ,j ,v 8301120253 830107 PDA ADOCK 05000443 C PDR

.~-? q;- - 'q-1 p. 1 r .~. ,p% 4 '..t eg ~ ~.5 .U.~~. ,v... k,. y.h. t .- r L... ; - 9.-..I e q c .1 4-p . g.. ~ waq q re. - g w ,of risk, including early. fatalities, early injuries, and/or .c 7 latent cancer fatalities? ~If they are. not equal, please ~., g. 4 7 ju.. J. 3 Indicate with specificity the uncertainty bounds for each 2$.J **~ feategory of risk enumerated above. L:W 6.. Will the Staf f: produce as a witness in the proceedings any of - .the. authors or contributors to Sandia NUREG/CR-2239? If so, 2 31 ~P ease, state.their names and mailing addresses. l .;:y:.:7... c.,3;.;.. - nW ~t7.

. : Wh a t ~. l~s ' the basis for the Staf f's~ decision not to perform' CZ,,T -j ja'ecident;, consquence

, analyses using several seasonal .&,. meteorological ^ databases in f avor of mean meteorological data? y.p:7 73 c-

__[

8..

State -wi th particularity the meteorological data used in consequence analysis for accidents occurring between May 30th 7::! +l"~ii k and. September-1, during periods of high population density. 7 '~ .: a... " ;., 1 w;a : n-crre 4 M!;W-9.I 't. Provide the most up-to-date data available used in the analysis L +i l. 'of< worst case accident consequences and probabilistic risk 7.b ' '

assessments.

m. '

~10I lPiease provide copies of the following documents: a)' NUREG/CR-2239 with all appendices. 3 b)~ NUREG/CR-1659. ~ ~ '

c)

NUREG-0737. ( 4 d) NUREG-0340, Overview of the Reactor . Safety Study ".r. Consequence Model, I.B. Wall, et al,.U.S. NRC, October, .w 1.

1977, se)

NUREG-0348, Demographic Statistics Pertaining to Nuclear ..eme- - Power Reactor Sites, U.S. NRC, October, 1979. . ~ ~f. ' .get p ::.

11. 6ePlease describe in detail the loca'ti'on of all moni toring devices 7g.,

.: 1used to gather meteorological ' data -ssed in the worst case '1 ~.- ace'ident analysis and probabilistic risk analysis in both the

DES and FES.

s T u;;; 3 Respectfully submitted, = _.. ~ fili. ~- ~ SEAOOAST ANTI-POLLUTION LEAGUE

t fr -

By Its Attorneys,- ~. p ' ,, ;7 BACKUS, SHEA & MEYER f T 'i f& BEttT M ACKUS i P. O. Box 516 y h. Manchester, NH 03105 9 (603)668-7272 January 7, 1983 i l (

~ n . }. p y_ g. ~ f

y.-}

~ .% 4 v mw v --'- z. // r m.. n 3 j\\ f 5.* ~-'T.Y. ^ * * ' * '~~'s ~ ~ i' 9 ^ r_zr.rmp 3,F- '.,_f.',,' 4'm,m,,.sn n:, ; s e ~ ' o ~ :-;5. &, 4L. ,n. ~.;.. SERVICR,. LIST s : ';. c; - - g;. 21 00'LKETED ' f'a L.z,, :.L:]#; L ~

r USHi3C-

..:& 2 er Hoyt, Char Thon.as G. Dignan, Esq. 'Ad.r..in.2 Judge @ n n $ opes and. Gray g3 &aMONP2M AtomictSafetirk lic. Ap. 225 Franklin' Street p B ard: 'UJSMNRC, ? J.x x..Ecston,.MA 02110 + 9 N6shingtori7DCW20555A. t CFFICE u.-.. C gy DOCKETiw"& S%ER ~ ...c. a

w.. _ -

r .Dr. Jerrt Harbour / Docket:ing and Service Sec. 3R,\\NCH

Admin.iGudge.952W C'

- At~6mi64afetiy'"kLic/ Ap. Office ofsthe Secretary U. S. NRQ 'Boafd;- E U-7 ,Washindon.SQNRC$DC N 0555 , ' ~, Washington, DC-20555 + 5;G:=-. 4Q2T ^ ~' Roy 95-Lessy.;QJr., Esqi GOffice of,Exdeutive ' Royert L. Chiesa, Esq;.. w 3 y ~ ~~zLegalcDir..ectorx. 95 Market Street' ^ EU5'Su.NRC ' $P r Manc q wr, E. 03101 ,s 7 ashingtdn',TDCT20555 -,~ ... - ~ p-g - a yy. m

Phill;Lp Ahrensis-Esq.

^ Jazie Doughty- ' Asst. Atty.TGeneral Field Directd.r " State House,GStatior #6 SAPL i [Aiigusta,_ ME ZO4333 ',' 5 Market Street >~ ,., 5, ~.m. -,.. Portsinouth, NH 03801 J Wilfred 'L. c Sanders, Esq.

(Sanders h.McDdrmott T.1pper Kinder, Esq.

A08 LafaydttsSoad ' 0 - Attorney Gencral's Ciffite 038 State of New Hampshire Hampton,"NH 7.y;w.y W. ~,' - 2 w. .vy ^ Concord., NR 03301s gy -

$ ~'I.

\\ . M.. . - J T.3 M JDrP Emraeth ^ASuebke David R. Lewis. - 4 " Admin. Jtidgeg?8i~Lic. Ap. Atomic' Sai'ety a Lic. Brd. ~ E. fat'omic' Safety U. S. NRC - Fri. E/N-439 '. Board 'U.S$,NRC, Washington, DC. 20555-- . Washington,t_^DCR20555 m ^ 2 3e s JJ.o ; Ann ' Shots.iElT, Asst. AG' 3.One Ashburtongla ce, 19th -m 7 Floor-W,J+

< Boston, MAi202108 q5;g.

. y;- .. William S. Jordan, II, Esq. ~ Ellyn R..,WeiMF E'sq.

17.25 I StreetwR.W.

Suite'506 W r-a Was u.gton, DCT.20006 ' g;X:,,. .WMW 9 .n .mn Edward J. McDercot,t, Esq. Sacrs -and McDern;ott 408 Lrdayet.teload 'Hampton, NU OQ8M mtme s r ,L i . ~.- y air,.. c m.. .}}