ML20069H567

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Response to Licensee Motion to Compel Under Commission Question 6.Resources Unavailable to Develop Study on Health Effects.Parents Concerned About Indian Point Does Not Bear Burden of Proof.W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence
ML20069H567
Person / Time
Site: Indian Point  
Issue date: 03/24/1983
From: Rodriguez P
PARENTS CONCERNED ABOUT INDIAN POINT
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20069H571 List:
References
ISSUANCES-SP, NUDOCS 8304060253
Download: ML20069H567 (4)


Text

--

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA RELATED CORRESPONDENC3 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATCMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

~

Before Administrative Judges:

James P.

Gleason, Chairman

'g3 [53 -l P2M Frederick J.

Shon Dr. Oscar H.

Paris

.c

..; !. w

__--_____________-____________-_-_______x

)

In the Matter of

)

Docket Nos. 50-247-SP

)

50-236-SP CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK )

4 INC. (Indian Point, Unit No. 2)

)

)

March 24, 1983 POWER AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF NEW

)

YORK (Indian Point, Unit No. 3)

)

)

-_---__-...----_-_--_----____-__-___--_-_x PARETs RI; CURI TO LICIFSIIS' "CTICM TO CC"?EL U' TOE 7 C7""I95ICN O'IE9TIO'T 6 In resoonse to interrocatory 121, PARI ns croceses to cresent twe follevir.c witnesses:

John 3. I crnborougi,.th.D.

Testimony, references and pertinent h

inf ar=ation submitted with this response.

T. Herry 3raselton, :I.D.

Resume and bibliography already subsitted under Concission Question 3 References relating to Question 6 will be provided at later data.

Arthur B. Zelman, M. D.

Testimony submitted under Question 3 Refsrences relating to I.uestion 6 will be provided at a later date.

R c'c e r t Porits%v, D.D.S.,

is an orthodontist and nut: itionis t with cractise in Peekskill, New York.

He is associated with the Institute for C-raduate Dentists, New York Cit", and Alheri Einstein 7 ental Division of edical 9chool, Bronx. "ew York.

Or. ?crinskv vill testify on chanoinc attitudes t wards x-rays in the dental co-unity in the cast 40 vears.

8304060253 830324

(

PDR ADOCK 05000247 D

l 0

PDR L

O..* 9 ? T* :.. 1 4. a=

e 9 %. a.

1 i r

  • -,. S. s,,, v m..,
4.,.,. e a..w= v.. e. a 3 w. /

1a.

T.T

.a

.3 a

..a

.:, 5

~. p..

,..,,,,3,...

3.

4..1...

.a.

,,a

..-o.,.

.f 4

... c. 3.,

.-.,,--.4..t..

...:..~.

,,,,, o. a.

.~u

e. 4..v.u,

-,-.Av,

, _ 21. _ a. 2.

v..<..., a.. o_ s.

wy 4

v

.s w

.,3,a., n :w,,

a - g.

e.

1.,.a. 4. 3.

o 1

s

2. 0.,...

.. ~. ~

a...,n v

4-o,,

c, _, a _ =. 2.

... w.2

...e

" con Ei Leses Its Ficht on Dismissinc ~4crker", H

m. e. m o e,

,_1..,_o.2.

E-all ite~ becinnine," A -an worline at Con Ed"s nuclear cower plant To l.JT, 5 -d 'i":..

3111 Falk. " co-ias", suburbia Todav, 6-6-32.

'*ilton R.

3enja-in, " Nuclear 9tudv Raises Esti-ate of Accident Tolls", Nashincton Post, 11-1-92.

Jon Craig, "Incian.oint 2 Nuke Flant Rateci Below Average in Safety", Citizen Rerister, 8-19-82.

Susan Jaffe, "Sloa D,ath At Indian Point", Villace Voice,12-2h-79 On 12-18-32 articles on worker exposure to radiation appeared in both the "ew Ycrk Ti=es anci Citizen Register. Exact titles not available at present n=e.

? n.o s u.- o, ". va.1' " w..

.o..~...

= c oc'.e, " ^ c.. u r. = ' _'.. = _1

..a A.4 a

_4.

v 7..L., te 71. f,,

.1, r-6

...,,, 3.1 3...,

1.T 3,u s.e

.O. o... m e,.

Aucust 1932.

a r

.,k a.,. n.s -.,.,,.,. a

_4

.,a.1 R ae4 4 3.

i,,.,,n

.r,. s u 2.

o-me

.y-m cial 'Tuclear Power Reactors 1920," US T3.C Report 7CRIG-0713, 7el.

2, Oece-ber 1991.

vsteratic Assess ent of Licensee Perfor ance Review

.,'--=_aa-.- e *.~.," "s., "...

o.. m ~. ". ". 't'.z.r. ". - 0 : ' a,

-r au o, " "R. ". ? 4 c. o.. =. ' a aa Aucust 1951.

3.G.

Brooks, "Occucational Radiation Excesure at Co--ercial "uclear Pcwer Reactors 1979," US:'RC Recort BJRIG-0713, '/cl. 1,

" arch 1981.

'J. S.17.R.C., ""inth Annual Cccucational Radiation Excosure

'a.~^...

l o 7 '., " "_ _:."t.r

o. o..~- r *. "U o. ? "-C ' 2 2,

^c'+.,ba..-

l o. ', ~,.

~' J. F u r u k.v, et al, " 'ccuptional Radiation 2nposure at

? 4 r...a+a c..c o.l s_ A.

t,wa..- '. o. a r.,. -., ' o 6 0_

1' 0. 7 c, " ", "o..

J. a_ r a.- *.

-, w +.

ym

.-~..- _n~,c.,

At,.....

1. c. v s..

in 3.3.

3 rocks, " Reve n '-.innual :ccupational o.adi=. tion 2n-pesura Recort, 19 7a, " C 3-o.C a.e cor

'7.JRIG-7 5 /10 9, "ove-ber 1975.

T.D.

ur phy,

C.i.

Hinson, "Occucational Radiation Exposure at Lickt Nater Occled Power Reactors, 1969-1974," Us"RC Recort :"CREG 75/032,, une 1975.

F. aims' response to interrogato:7 21 is that they do not have the rescurces to develop a studf accut healt: effects, bu*,.

in ligh:

of tr.a accepta:re of tM contenti:n, would rge the 3ce: :o ta'.<e 4

measures to ensure that a 0::::plete record is develope: in this investi-gator 7 procaeding. P.Cli:C3 does not her the burden of proof.

o

+

.h7111s Ro rigue:

?? rents Concerned foout Indian Point J

k

I J

4 4

e 4

i 4

f 4

i j

e-

f e.

o C * '".,I,R.

-.. - - ~-.,,..

Js.

.n

\\.*.J

.)

\\,

.~. i,n

+ eL %=.~W

.,r.%%

3.vi....,,.n

%.s.1gl.v....;O.We

- ~

e o

e o, n e f n-

,s, e-,

e-u D f

=r=.p,q.4,u _s+e..es v.)

I i

n D O.O"s." *.* ? %..t.jfra ae-a _-../

ee

- s A.._ ae

.~

p..

%.. _...a,..

3,:

)

ucc_:._, _..~.

. w,

%.s.a yaw.m e.-

.s, m -~

.,_.xw -.g

.e....

i

.e:

x c.

z_

u..

Ci' 'E".V Y^RK (Indian hin-C.i-2 )

)

~

)

p n p.q A G,.v =...-.y m.=.~=..=.

f. -

. u sc.V 1

.. ~

)

n..,

  • ~

C.e tL::,eV v.c.=.v r Ind.4 a. m..,_.. - %.._- _a t

s i

I h m bv certify that I have served cocies of dan n s f

  • J.:.WW 7M

.d'tM 27vn. A 'c r m w c.

Q,,y'K= u

.qr, v e,=.%.

< m v.

w.Mc, v c to cne service list below on

^

M. :c6 e,

.!.5=J tv deccsitinc it in the United States

, a

-all, first class, excect these marked bv an asterisk which were delivered by hand on 1993.

4 j,4 f,

je /*

3r. Jesar e. serte er. presortes J. sum

.. ef f,

,f 5

me.m= sage,s, ameo megenerestee ammessaresase desse ease.e-2 so.e e e.ese seine e sy r y ( p,p /j., y, a=

aemette noor

.ses==ee amare

_ f f. -

.e

e.. me.

ee e. eye mestae

  1. g s.,

. =e

==.ee=e. LC. Jewt aeeen, a.s.

se99s enes.e n. fee, ses.f e eb v eemeias here[ **.*%

Sammesas ese Beretes amessee e,

f D%we

/

erfsee of me amore r,

p e.3. em6ser teceaetere Commuteenes 5.3. esseer eseesseere Causamente emptestas. L6.

30999 septestee. 8.C.

.e999 Sere.. Ate 46e. Ese.

enerou S. esffe. Cae.

Leetrem'esease. Ese.

ens 'we lease sessmens

.mtse S. %ere. $30.8 asmae 1efets ame 68emates here aumeg mgesene,re messee

  • ere stese"moneetsee heroom elot eteese. of 22ee aumene f. eesse&&. tae.

s.s. seesey es.

eswees em ementactas. 8.E.

emere J. esti.a'esec. Eme.

g 99 Genere&'s Wftee esempesse %eenre f. keesse Wftee of tes uttee 6ates 3bremser egense 1 state ene.6eemosee ameneg se ear 6e kese Caesar nemmer et tee Geest asetsteSere e.$. eusser euemeenart Causesses seere pomeg ese 8ere, of 'esef 3.eney sometastas. LC.

N999 J.3. enmaser esseseeare "messee Lausse Mftee hen & stag es sse Besteen. Steenterha. ore Stese testetee6ee6 este Mesas, of stee9 enestnestas. S.C.

2-99g mrose e. ;

.. toe.ee acessmens Gmeures :omment song F.

egaresta. Ese.e**

faereense 7.-

Grous Lesene e. %rry. Ese.

Gemeessessee Geseen Genest of

.eesem J. usete.

.r..

Eat.

Emetre state Mese

=ftse of ammeras Conset seur est&etas. GEGIB 'Y90 Feeerse faamreammet tesegement messeep een %re..me, ones44 4. enroestS. *ee.

a&ameh of ?22]?

eee g arest. S.e.

e Lestee Meme 3ertes enream. Jr.

Lae.

somasense 3.3.

Jee*3 ese *ere, of 'ese) e.ergen asemessees. Dorteres 58"mwe F. C"aele. Rae.

Le 8 98 s* E8e*

99e k Street, e.e.

Me Steerg e. "ees. Est.

Some ese Geense

'Sertoe G. frase. tae.

esensactes. S.C.

2Se's acessees "seest, genes meet seemse itsenso 6 emme. Ete.

emner esseertst of ese Ehese esser Caeree F. ame s,

!*e sessene evene esees, georgene

o 'ere. of 'esif esse ?se of ese omre ettiase of -

it feeeres 81eas e'e Cetmee Chrete

  1. ?e *ese teamme ese ",re of

'S2'e um ters. of Mto he. of

'9918 i

(,.,.

,.-e hw6ee a. Soneteer. ".e=3iesremrene A Femaepe Massey e. E14asere. Lee.

eeonensesor % esse's est6ee tuur fare Stees mette Suretes asseres sammeo6 he64t

  • me.

" messes ese aere Rees (eergy Xf'ee b I* 88 &es.

  • s0.

?biree h Stege Mese I hassefe4&W Steee 8 tees.

II8888 **

U"*

80*

elease. af 82233

&&sesp. of ? 2,32) wer9e $sammen este Metas, of 'seet 8pteuse of tee Carte. lme.

ISO '88E s

eIS *sE86. Esse e8e fore. 'ef9EO E#"H Derlee J. estatm. (ae.

aere 6 # Wets. Eme.

'es

+e besse > tee Erte iteress.,Est.

h.6t&e84&ee eletenee

  • reene seasassee. 99 -5929

'9us eart ansamerste of aus

  • 4eas estereo
  • detta Estater. Lauretteler Fere ese eue acrese "seese of hes&ame ame earle frece Caster

+1 ese emeseems see$

Geeeeene C486este rer *sfe {perty

$&egeren $. Ple6mer ese C'e enestees,ame Is '

meet paese Genospuestes asemenettee ese fare. ef ' esse ese C4et of 'es%e tty, of '9998 est been elete asas he 4& tee of 'e998 speurette suas me0eteger S& free 8. But ee4&e emmene of ese Caessa of tee esseenesser Caett Laseesgos esmee 3emmerts. Eme.

me.

8 e6 Seeste. lat.

46945 Ga&etere. keff astersee 8

C459 e( eue tare

4grte essere. (es.

.merene S.

Sumere t. Cae,

,een ett. #=epost 3treeter elaertet 8e se aeretas assee

  • ergeret huet, (se.

ese *ere %e6&e "eterest C&tt emel 4tte Please. of 'seeg ene tere. of 'Seef hasse. semes. Smear e eartesore temwee Graus. Ise.

230 pare seemen g aweet Strees eus Iers. sf 'eise ese *ye. of leGef 2eene e. Reeff

  • rene laatse. Ese.

seenseessar seesse*e eastem entsames Leersene? Caett

% estates.

  • .me.
.sewetoe Commessee 299 ".rous street

"'4 esf9.e aseem. suste **3 atte 81este, of ' Sect ese '. ore. of *este

.meo 8.."Leesse. tae.

3sarese ee. eaa. emeterftete. (ee.

cf.ee e. sta. tae.

ese 'ere aseerotte.se Seasse ameree, estre es se emoeten a.smes enseesarossee enmee

?e :eue e

  • 21 eessereast es6.

aseste safest one,h6eemesas amare tomar* mete til 46Lamre art *

,ew C6te. ;s ?22ee

+e.seentestem ee ere, et os'2 5tteer aartes, se 49est

.een at tes eeser ese fore meest ee leerst "s,6

meten anses Laneenneter 3
aen e.

se.en. ltreeter ta= ?are case am.nes.se net e

esos fire 3erset, base "eZe ese 'ere steerette ese ere. of Se's at st.c esent street ese *ere. of 0001 files o. mt se. (ae.

eti ts as S.

.ePem.

!I, Eme.

neeen 1. 'Jto6 4 9 ates of Whrerose So4884 tete esfees eue estos

  • fe f itreet. e e.. $stee See

ae 44empetteet evenue. 9. e, bate 99 deshtsg haB. $. $.

JeMe gest egten. I.6 j*1le W"

-