ML20065D000
| ML20065D000 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry  |
| Issue date: | 09/13/1990 |
| From: | Lyster M CENTERIOR ENERGY |
| To: | ARMY, DEPT. OF, CORPS OF ENGINEERS |
| References | |
| PY-CEI-ACOE, PY-CEI-ACOE-000, NUDOCS 9009200040 | |
| Download: ML20065D000 (10) | |
Text
.
I'*
PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT Mal Address.
10 CENTER POAD P.O. BOX 97 Michael D. Lyster PEMY, OHIO 44081 PEMY, OHIO 44081 Vce Prescent Nuclear (216)259 3737 September 13, 1990 PY-CEl/AC0E-0007L Crumander, Buffalo District U.S. Army Corp of Engineers 1776 Niagara Street Buffalo, New York 14207-3199 Commande r,
Enclosed is an Application for Depar'. ment of the Army Permit to allow a temporary hose to be routed from the Lake Erie shoreline on the.2agsg. Power Plant site to the, offshore intake cribs. The hose will be in place f rom October 10 - 19, 1990, and will be used on October 17-to deliver a chemical (Betz blocide Clam-Trol CT-1) to plant water' systems to treat for zebra mussels.
The chemical tanks and pumps will be located in a dike on shorc. The hose will be reighted and routed along the lake bottom to the two intake cribs, located approximately 2630 feet offshore. The Pose will branch to each intake crib and will be inserted cpproximee-ly five feet into each structure.
It will be secured to supports around'the intake ports..The hose will be inspected by scuba divers prior to and periodically during the chemical injection.
The hose is standard EPDM tubing with:3/8 inch thick walls. It is rated for 150 psi; the operating pressure for this use will be approximately 50 psi. The four lengths of hose, each 700' long, will be joined with senders that will be clasped in place. The connections will be pressure tested before chemical is pumped through.
The chemical treatment program was approved by the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency cn June 15, 1990. The first treatment was applied on July 25, 1990. At that time. a boat was used to carry the chemical tanks to the' intake cribs. Due to the increased possibility of inclement weather in October, the use of-a temporary hose instead of a boat will help ensure the safety of workers and decrease the likelihood of an offshore spill.
In addition to the application, drawings, maps, md a copy of the approval letter from l~
the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency are enclosed. Please notify us of the results of your review of this application at your earliest possible convenience.
Please call i
Louise Barton, (216) 259-3737 ext. 6723, if you have any questions or need any further information.
.Since e 9009200040 900913 PDR ADOCK 05000440
/
P PDC Michael D. Ly ter 4
I Enclosure MDL:LKB njc cc: USNRC Document Control Center ye3 NRR Project Manager TO Sr. Resident Inspector QS>
Operonng Urnts-Cleveland Electre mummchng
( QQg p,,,mToledo Edison R ].
APPL.lCATION FOR DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY PERMIT oass APPA0 VAL ML 0F02 0034 (33 CFR 325)
Espires 30 June lett Puenc esparano tasoon lor sus acescaan as marmenon a asemame e average 6 nees per reasones a me mesemy of cases mchang me see lor reneums enspungene, seenpung summg dem sowage, gesienng an$ meNesung Ste GM neeWd. 848 compleERg arte seWWWWie sie consomen of sisareressort Anchossene tar nesger or mese compen anunca, or mese a sonaguessy Summe asas, as tese longer. Sans commons segmeng Wue thoden esenses or any amor assent of gue onessaan of visormenon, vuemang ter seeems eue tween, a Waeungen Hessennere Saraces, Osecamese lor intermanen Operases ane Resorm, tats Jesterson Done Magnuoy, tapa, Asengen. VA 222024302; ans e to Omos at nearmosan and Regidesary ANors, Omm d Idemgement and Budget, Wasnnglon, DC 20AGL The Deparenant of to Army somet program e aumented try Semen 10 of me Rnese sie Herenre Act of lege, Secean 404 of M Clean waar Act and Secton 103 of va admirtow Prosecuan, Reseason sul Senceaeres Act T)ese name senere permes assionseig acenese e or afteceng neugests wesere el pie Uruled Steens, me theenerge of dredged or te messed suo sedere el ste Umged Steses, and me penspanagan of esages mesenal tar pie purpose of mampeg d meo ocean mesers ineormenon proused on ene tem edi to imod a eveneeng she aspecamen lor a gemut Insormenon at run aconcesan a mese a meest as putec recore pseupt eeuence of a putec nocos. Ducsomse of sta sidemane seesselse a wohetery, nomover, te ones reassesse are necoseery a arcar to commwucess met see appacent and to evouses Ste perfeut asgensoort if necesemy snormenon a not previosa, te gemet aaree=t cervet be processed nor can a gemet to emastL i
Ocip est of onqpnei dremmes or good reprochacete copes ufuen enour Wie IDCaton and Character of pie proposed acewwy must te anached 40 me angmenenng (see samoso creeuwigs and snaarucsons) and tuo suenused a to Duence Engneer normg pansecuan over to irw =armi of vie proposed acevity. An aarme=mann E.st O riot compeeled m lue wie tus renametL i'
- t AP8UCAT10N M mam84 (To to seesgneer Dr Carmel 1 NAME, ADDRESS, ANo TTTLE OF AUTHOnt2ED AGENT N/A famenene na esmo nummene naure
- 2. Nawa ANo AcoREs8 OF APouCANT The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co.
l
]""""
Perry Nuclear Power Plant 10 Center Road mensmens et Aumenemmer i nereer assenese ene summus Perry, Ohio 44081 io en e my femonone na asme niemene news emme as u, some a me pesemame se m. semn semameen ene is 8Issuh, usan seemet mastumeness enemuseman m assert et ins asettamart Ac(
)
N/A (nasemen someATumE OF APWUCANT oATE
.ac 121(s 259-3737 tommes 4 osTAsuio osacaprnoN or paaposso ActwTv 4s ACTMTY m....
.w.
l To route a temporary hose from the Laka Erie shoreline on the Perry Power Plant site to the of fshore inta'* i cribe, "approximately"2650r. ' The hose will be in place fron'octose
~
10 to 19, 1990, and will be used October -17.
Hy e
<a pumpose The hose will be used to deliver a chemical (Betz Blocide Clam-Trol CT-1) to the plant water intake to creat water systems for Zebra massels.
Note that the chemical treatment program has been approved by the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency.
(See attached letter, dated 6/15/90) l l
4c, cecHAmos op onsooso on Fitt uafumiAL Not applicable ENG FORM 4345, Aug 89 ^
sornou op Apn se a oesa.gyt no.
cccw-om
l' 1,
5 ANo Aoomasets op CJomano PeoremTv ommens, Lasses, ETC, wm8E PsioPERTv ALso AoJones THE wifetway l
To the West:- Nef f Perkins Co., 3715 Perely Road, Perry, Ohio 44081 J
1 l
To the East: Mrs. Allen Daniels, P.O. Box 144, Cates Mills, Ohio 44040 -
9 l
L j
t L
e wATuneoor Ano LocAnow on wATensoor wiens Acnverr easts on a peopcm,ao 1!
Leke Erie on the Perry Power Plant site (see enclosed maps).
i J
(
l F Location UN LANo wkERE ACTMTv casts oR S PRoPoeSo e
i
COUNTY StAft M CCM North Perry Village i
tocAL oovensano ecov s summocnon ovanerra a = m.,e.
as me mi,ser = =a mune..
e a.nemme a vus a no is ans.or e ves y sessman, mean me veer en asamy was emmemma inemass em esses een as me esames
'2
.~
5 d
F p.
(
- o. Lw as esemens er omreassesse sus esmans memes seem one seemet eemanen amme iseessonnene ser serseesemen amenuman emessene ese -
)
- essenen amamese a one seemenem
-, y, seuse Acancy Twe Appatwat mawiricATionna oats op AssucAnow onuop apanovas, omis astcassa, t
i f'
Ohio EPA Director's final N/A 3/.L/90 6/.15 /90.. _.;,.,..J/A,.._
findings and.
W
., orders.
h g,
.._.-~--!.
{
to Accomanen is huseov mean ter a asema er ammune is sumanse me acesus esamens haems -i onresy mas i em temmear men ene asennesen ennemass m me
, anus ines no me eens es n.y womameen ene nemme cuan messammen e som emmensam ano esasesa I heuer eeresy man I sensmen me aumener is vnmereene me graseous assusmus or i em assues as eso shey massensus am as me esonennt 1
l 11
}
O NlA I
saGRATUHE OF A i-e
@ ATE sionAfung op AggNT OATE The soonca ori must be ssonoQ by me Derson uno cessres a enecertene me prooosen acawy tacekcants or se naar be segreegt by a ordy Jueserved agent at me stasement sn blocA 3 has been Aged our must asgeesL 18 U.S.C. Secean 1001 prowka e.sc whoever, e any menner seen sie pasensen of any eenerseens or egency of The Uness Sasses knamangly and wisedy laishes, concmege, or covere is by any vice, aceums, or emuco a masenet lent as menee muy team, bcensusor haiestese staammenes or representagone or makes or uses any seses unen0 er escasman knouang name to castemt any leise teessusor steumanna simienent or envy, snas ne knee not mese men sto.com or snonsense not rnare men ime veere, or east
- A**ms er ame somm nota e& GIM 81W eEM emt.en as
.-..,...,.,.-m..
.e
.,.-.m.,.,cm..,
m,-
r-..
w
.-...~-..,--,e
.1 I
YOU CAN SAVE TIME AND HINIMIZE DELAYS IN THE EVALUATION OF YOUR l
PERHIT APPLICATION BY TAKING A
FEW MOMENTS TO FROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION:
1.
Please give us the name of any
- agent, consultht or
- l contractor that is - involved in the work you would like t'o have permitted:
Hame:M DhlSon 0 bl ( & thol Address: 2593 tonGrd 8% iW
- m. tes scwiava pn i s age, Telephone 412 ' N so90 2.
We also will need the names and addresses of landowners that own property adjacent to your planned workeite.
There may be nore than two adjacent property owners, and if there are, you chould include their names and addresses on the back of this sheet:
Hameif LCC Puksas Co Address sm s 6 m W es.
Rux ono 'ug m Telephone i
Hame: WS Auca M (5 Address: Po dos my cc:tn eutu m wweuo Telephone 3.
The address of the postmaster that delivers the mail at your planned workeite is also needed:
Address: kur-v ksT CEcc l
34/ Ce de-Rd Pe r. -
Oh.c Wo si
.l 4.
Please provi'e the address of the Town or City. Clerk where d
the proposed work is located:
Address: V' IIA e d Ner O kerrv PerfV b d f W'4 9 Lc.el uce-l Kck D '73G IM. K rloc Kc) Sude 930
- Pe<rv. Os:c unosi pa:neu;Ile ch40 mp 7rj Telephone / 0
- v) J N - '/9 '/ '/
I4 'O 3 6'2 '-66 VD 5.
Please provide the address of the office responsible for the issuance of building permits and land use zoning decisions at your project site:
Address: Ln) e CeA IM bal Yilla a e e$ Nor h ferry'.
sn Wnd on oet cla l
Quou Town s,ne Rel.
Pa mew. ne Ch.c wa m i
M n, son, Dh ;O %OS7 Telephone : /2 0 'r % %
/
G 8U 45 9 - 4 2 35~
/
YOUR COOPERATION IN PROVIDING THIS INFORMATION IS APPRECIATED
SHWY mee er one. ame. -.mem==== n==r jy,gg1g0 e
P.O. Box 1040,1800 Watermark Dr. -
Coluneus Ohio 43206 0140 ido8'sall'. casese esionier (614) 844 3020 Paz (014) 644-2320 1
June 15, 1990 Re: Director's Final Findings and Orders CEI - Per.=y Nuclear Power Plant i
l Mr. Joseph C. Szwejkowski Centerior Energy P.O. Box 94661 Cleveland, Ohio 44101-4661
. Transmitted herewith is one copy of the Director's Final Findings and Orders in the referenced matter.
g You are hereby notified that this action of the Director is final and may be appealed to the Environmental Board of Review pursuant to Section 3745.04 of the Ohio Revised Code. The appeal must be in writing and set forth the action complained of and the grounds upon which the appeal is based. 'It must be filed with the Environmental Board of Review within thirty (30) days after notice of the Director's action.
A copy of the appeal must be served on the Director of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency and the Environmental Law Division of the Office of the Attorney General within three (3) days of filing with the Board.
An appeal may be filed with the Environmental Board of Review at the following address:
Environmental Board of Review 236 East Town Street, Room 300 Columbus, Ohio 43215
'tobert E. Phelps, P.E.
er Permit Administration Section Division of Water Pollution Control PEP /mmt Certified Mail cc:
Don Schregardus, Director's Office Andrew Turner, DWPC Heidi Sorin, DWPC John Morrison, DWPC Kelvin Rogers, DWPC-NEDO A. Franks /C. Porter, PIC Joseph Sommer, Director, 00NR Bill Kurey, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Jeff Wilson, Betz Laboratories Journal Room File
. an-.
D3te Issued June 15. 1990 Date Effective June 15, 1990 BEFORE THE OHIC ENVIRORMENTAL PROTECTION AIENCY i
)
In the matter of:
i Cooling Water Additive Request Director's Final'Findines j
and Orders 6
g Pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 6111.03(H), the Director of the Ohio -
Environmental Protection Agency (Ohio EPA) hereby makes the following Findings t
and issues the following orders:.
l FINDINGS i
1.
Centerior Energy, owns and operates the CEI - Perry Nuclear Power Plant, hereinafter referred to as."CEI - Perry Plant",
North Perry, Ohio.
located at 10 Center Road, 2.
The CEI - Perry Plant discharges pollutants to Lake Erie.
g 3.
CEI - Perry Plant currently. holds an effective NPOES permit (No. 3IS00016#CD, OH0063461) for the aforementioned discharge.
4 Part II, Other Requirements B., of the aforementioned NPOES ' permit requires that, "In the event that the permittee's operation shall require the use of cooling water treatment additive, written permission must be obtained from the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency. The permittee shall demonstrate that the use of the additive in the concent.7tions espected will. not be harmful or inimical to aquatic life as determined by acute static bioassays".
5.
On March 1, 1990, CEI - Perry Plant applied to the Ohio EPA to receive written permission for the use of Clas Trol CT-1 cooling water treatment additive for the control of zebra mussels.
6.
The use of this cooling water additive requires the addition of bentonite clay in the effluent to detosify the active chemical before it is discharged to Lake Erie.
7.
The proposed discharge concentratien of active Clam Trol CT-1. contained in the final effluent entering Lake Erie is 0.0_ing/1.
9.
The Director believes the issuance of these Orders is furthering the intent of i
the general assembly, that the Environmental Protection Agency will prevent and i
abate pollution of the environment for the health, safety, welfare, and property of the people of the state.
9.
The Director has given consideration to, and based his determination on, evidence relating to the technical feasibility and economic reasonableness of 1
complying with these Orders and to evidence relating to conditions calculated to result from compliance with these Orders, and its relation to the benefits to the people of the State to be derived from such compiggo,gccomplishing the purposes of Chapter 6111 of the. Revised Code.
0001z JUN 15 90 t c. my tni.
- 5. a..
- c. v a
.....,y d th e EllTERED OlRECTOR'S JOURNAL t hidat d;;ument ac f!kd in tN racurcs of tne Ct:io Environmental Protection Agency.
By:0 i WDate p !/3~/9D
mm
,)
- 1. The use of the Clas Trol CT-1 cooling water additive at the CEI - Perry Plant for
. the control of zebra mussels is subject to compliance with all applicable lenis, rules, regulations,; standards and the conditions. contained herein.-
a
[
implementation of the proposed treatment applications. The spill prevention plan.
-]
L shall document all precautionary procedures that will be followed to minimize. the possibility of an accidental' discharge or spill of the Clas Trol CT-1.
In addition, the spill prevention plan shall document' steps that would be taken in'-
the event that an accidental release of the' Clan Trol CT-1 into tho' environment.
would occur.
Any back-up or auxiliary methods. to feed the bentonite clay should l
also be described ~in case of mechanical failure during the treatment, application.
- 3. A report containing the monitoring and toxicity data obtained during the
. treatment applications-must be submitted '; +'he Ohio EPA for review. This report:
i shall-include the following and'must be ergm.tted no later.than one (1) month e
after each Clas Trol CT-1 application.
j l
~
- a. During each Clam Trol CT-l' treatment application, a grab sample of the-effluent shall-be taken at a minimum of every two (2) hours. Thegrabsamp$e-should be taken at a point located downstream of the detonification site.
These grab samples'will be used for analysis to measure the concentration of active Clan Trol-CT-1 that is being discharge into Lake Erie.-
- b. A composite-sample of the effluent shall be collected throughout each Clas r
Trol CT-1 application at a point located along the discharge pipe downstream.
of the detonification site and used to conduct acute tonicity tests.-- A-t 48-hour static acute toxicity test using Ceriodashnia (gMg or M m and a 96-hour static acute fathead minnow (Pimeshales oromelas) toxicity test i
shall be conducted each time Clan Tr91 CT-1 is applied.
These toxicity tests-shall be definitive acute tests using only 100f. effluent (i.e no dilutions).
A receiving water control shall be. collected as a grab sample.near the intake.-
structure immediately prior to the Clan Trol CT-1 applicati:,n.. A second-control shall also be obtained as'a grab sample;immediately prior to the Clam Trol ~ CT-1 application at a point along', the discharge pipe. The toxicity tests shall be run on these samples at full strength (i.e. no dilutions are necessary). The results of these tests will be judged on'a pass / fail basis.
A test shall be considered a failure if mortality,.or a~ combination of 1
mortality plus other adverse effects, is shown to be at a ' statistically significant level.
All toxicity tents shall be conducted using _ the procedures specified in the Ohio EPA Quali., Assurance Manual (or current revisions) i q
and/or standar1d' operating procedures promulgated by the U.S. EPA.
OHIO E.P.A.
JUN 15 90 1
1 certtfy this to be a true and accurate copy of the ENTERED OlRECTOR'S JOURHAL official docume.at as filed in the records of the Ottio Environmental Protection Agency.
By M
Date
=.
939D,1 (Cont.)
_4.
Sy January 1,1991, the following chronic toxicity tests must be' comp 1.eted and
.a the' data-submitted to the Ohio EPA in order to maintain approvsl for the use of
- the Clan Trol CT-1 beyond this year.. This data will be used 'to develop a chronic criterion for the Clas Trol CT-1 in orWor to further evaluate any long-term effects.
A twenty-one (21) day flow-through chronic toxicity test with gggglig
~
m and a twenty-eight (20) day flow-through; chronic toxicity test with rathead minnows Lplaanhplag oronelas)'shall be completed using the Clan Trol CT-1.
The-tests shall be Performed using American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) procedures for conducting toxicity tests in a flow-thro @ system. ' Resu),ts to be.
(
reported for these chronic tests include the lowest observed effect concentration l
~
(Lotc) and the no observed effect concentration (NDEC).
Also, acute _ endpoints
't (median lethal concentrations (LC50) and/or median effective concentrations i.
(IC50)) shall be.ecorded.
i 5.
Annual reports muet be submitted by 7anuary 1, of each year to the Ohio EPA, as to the progress being made.in the areas of research specified in 5.a. - e.
below. The annual reports should contain the results of all monitoring and*
toxicity testing dona during the application of Clas Trol CT-1 and the results obtained during the.3 -ified research program.- The reports should also contain 1
any anticipated research.'s the future,' any problems encountered, and any-additional information that ay be useful in evaluating the products perfomance. If Ohio EPA de'
- s that the above specified data is not being generated, these findings are
, 3rs approving the use of Clas Trol CT-1 at the CEI - Perry Plant will be revoked. CEI - Perry Plant shall continue research to deteristne:
I if the Clas Trol CT-1, the detonification material or a combination of, the a.
two have the. potential to cause chronic effects in the receiving water at-,
representative concentrations.
b.
the degradation and fate of the Clas Trol CT-1, the detoxification material and a combination of the two in the receiving water.
if the Clan Trol CT-1 and the detoxification material combination is settling c.
and accumulating in the receiving. water or if it is being sufficiently dispersed.
d.
the optimal concentrations of Clan Trol CT-1 that are needed to control-adult and juvenile zebra mussels. Clam Trol CT-1 concentrations can, in all likelihood, be reduced in subsequent treatments to control juvenile mussels following the initial treatment to kill the established r1 ult population.
other viable alternative zebra mussel control methods that may be employed at e,
the plant. These alternative methods should consider the most cost effective (both financial and environmental) long-tern control of zebra mussels.
OH10 E.P.A.
l JijN 15 90 I certify this to be a true and accurate copy of the ENTERED OIRECTOR'S JOURNAL official document as filed in the records of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Byb A &Cate 6hs*/"h
Q8E33,_(Cont.)~
6., If construction is necessary to 1nstall chemical feed equipment,.a complete-
~
Permit-to-Install-(PTI) application must be submitted to the Ohio EPA District Office that serves your facility. The PTI must be approved prior to constrvstion of any equipment.'
1 7.
All reports required by these findings and orders shall!be submitteel to the Ohio EPA, Division of Water Pollution Control, Enforcement-and Compliance Section, P.O. Box 1049, 1900 Watermark Drive, Columbus, Ohio 43266-4149.
8.
The cooling water additive treatment program for rebra mussel control may only be' applied in accordance with the proposal approved by the Director.of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency. There any be no deviation from the approved
,voposal without the express, written approval of the Agency. Any deviation from-the proposal or the above conditions may lead to denial or revocation of these findings and orders or 'other. sanctions and per.alties provided under Ohio law..
Approval of this proposal does not constitute an assurance that-the cooling water additive treatment program will operate _ in compliance with all chio laws and regulations.
Additionally,.the teres and conditions of this approval do not relieve a permitted facility from complying with all monitoring requirements agnd effluent limitations that have been established in their lup0ES permit.
d
. Tune 15, 1990 Richard L. Shank, Ph.D.
Cate Director l'
)
OHIO E.P.A.
JUN 15 90 t certify this to be a true and accurato copy of tiv.' ENTERE0 0lRECTOR'S JOURNAL cfficial document as filed in the reenres of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency.
W s te 6//5/9d 1
BY' 1
s q
m, l
l OVERSIZE 1
DOCUMENT 1
PAGE PULLED L SEE APERTURE CARDS 1
.j
-NUMBER OF OVERSIZE PAGES FILMED--ON' APERTURE CARDS:
c
.I APERTURE CARD /HARD COPY AVAILABLE FROM-QECORDS AND REPORTS MAMAGEMENTT BRANCH i,
l^
c
.v...---.-
....~.~.. ----.......
....-.--J
. -....