ML20063D542
| ML20063D542 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 08/19/1982 |
| From: | Ellis J Citizens Association for Sound Energy |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8208270624 | |
| Download: ML20063D542 (4) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:'hb5k $Wj ewc. . di.x, ,.
.. . w - J. .
w, s,
% ,.tc .m
.M;$
WWM/* - 7L ' 8/19/82' UNI N N AN Y,'h [AikPkCA k" h D '
~
If;, gc 74 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION . 00CMETED US V,C NbW., ' ' s s J.l BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD -
- 4.h ..
T. E w AGO 23 P2 31~ T.9s 9' 7H ~In the Matter of I l
%dM.
' d'?$
en
'a . i' g 0FFICE CF SECRt'IM V J; y* APPLICATION OF TEXAS !!TILITIES Docke t RWDj50;t45vict .N GENERATING COMPANY, ET AL. FOR I I
and:50 W46
?'$
"Jr ' y.[,{
AN OPERATING LICENSE FOR -
/ COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC I
- k I
STATION UNITS #1 AND #2 b , . .' . ' .' (CPSES) I .. i.N y."1 . I
. -i ,
E :.3'
, .1 . ,' y -
- . - .Q .: ,l.-
k
&' ?c.* *l i .
W1.9 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION ,
. y'r 5:
hd#M~T0: ' L 'N
; . Peter S. Y. Chang .,
Tj . f < ' . Chief Engineer, Pipe Support Engineering D.%
- i. e '.;. Texas Utilities Services, Inc. 'y X),: .9 m;
P. O. Box 1002, Glen Rose, Texas 76043 T.M
~wa 3
h, ' b You are hereby notified that CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy),'^ . , . '. % Intervenor in the above-captioned proceedings, will take your oral depos-itio'n , . ((.i;(g { ..] -
.y, .
. .Nj
- ],4 commencing on Friday, August 20,1982 at 1:00 P.M.* and continuing until s . . . '.' % >
'l , g
.Qg.7
, y;, . W if:l,. ' completed. This confinns our telephone conversation yesterday afternoon with '
- ..&; .. p -
,- "$. Applicants and the NRC Staff. lhe depot.ition will be taken at the offices of:_ ", h wc . t..,..-
", Carrington, Coleman, Sloman & Blumenthal >f a .- 2500 S. Tower, Plaza of the Americas J.i W'.
Dallas, Texas 'V ? u , .% j S. 'c , . The deposition will relate to all matters 'of which you have knowledge ;,y
.. ., m yi.t
.$ .i
. in connection with CASE's Co.ntention 5 relating to quality assurance / quality 'y.%h : s. c
. . .r;
;s.. ~
control during. construction activities at Comanche Peak Steam Electric Stat; ion .w L. .
.n . g. t/[:
).c and 'the construction activities employed during the plant's construction. ,fp a .
#Y
)
. Sp'ecifically, you should be prepared to answer questions regarding the failure .
,,-/.t 3,- -
of the Applicants to include proper analysis factors in their STRUDL (Structural' .'v.rn;.$ - - e ex. * *,, x/m
~. O v Q . '
j7 Design Language) c.omputer calculations on pipe supports; problems with the,' -('; h. '.;, %.; oo use of Richmond Inserts (used to hang pipe supports); problems with const'raint [*hES o
, $,h.
a ~- , e s
- ..,;g.
.,onux of pipe thennal growth; supports which due to instabilily' are actuaMy non- 1..a.. .T.
. c. oo .
g supports; the testimony of Mark Walsh and any rebuttal to his testimony of' wijj@NJs N *'
.Q,c%A t '
'e
?j'. .mmo ox '*? l. which you have knowledae. including all documents op which you will or plan 4-
' : : 7 94
.'J '+
Mhmp: . 1 mediately following the deposition of John C. Finneran s [.[ ' ; '%. 7
% k*v <1 L '. -Q.G
~
s s ~*- , ~ . . <
'.7 to rely in , .ur rebuttal testimony. You should also bring' with you any of the following which you have access to: the personnel records of Mark Walsh insoiar as they may be relied on for your rebuttal testimony; the personnel, .
records o' Jack Doyle, insofar as they may be relied on for your rebuttal testimony; back-up documents for the March 3,1982 meeting referred to in the 3/8/82 TUSI Office Memorandtsn (CASE Exhibit 659E from the July hearings) discussed . - in the direct testimony and cross-examination of CASE Witness Mark Walsh; .
- i back-up documents which were referred to or used as the basis for conclusionsL ,'N r,
s.a contained in the 6/25/82 TUSI Office Memorandum (CASE E'xhibit 659G) discussed - C: J:fd. in the direct testimony and cross-examination of Mark Walsh; the NPSI Design. ] ji g:.J,.v; Criteria for pipe supports (the official one issued in May 1981); all documents;< . . JD-
*.59.,.
. which were used to define the method used to detennine the tensile force,in th'e m f9 )
Richmond Inserts; the current Grinnell Design Criteria for pipe supports-at. ~ l .@, N
, ,se
# CPSES; a print-out of the criteria in the computer regarding STRUDL procedures, , : [ .,-
.: . ; o ,~ -
program guides, and any'other information relating to STRUDL; a print-out df' ,
. ' y ' c. ?. .
~ ..y..~,;.
the computer run in the file of the TUS'I FAG (Frame Analysis Group); the Hilti , ". d.Pli? l allowables and the procedures for -the analysis; a copy of FUB II and the instruc-[- tions of how to use the FUB II information; the current PSE (Pipe Support Engineer-b &
^%%
ing) design criteria volume for pipe supports at CPSES; all the NCR's written . .
. ';c , ,.
,s l
by Mark Walsh; a copy of the American Welding Society Code; copies of any N.her '
. . . .' s-I documents of which you are aware or which you may use in your rebuttal testim'~ny; o b ';
l, .~ . any'any other documents relating to the matters referenced herein. [39I 'y .: l Documents should be considered in the broad sense, including but not -
- i L . ,
l . limited to: internal memoranda; handwritten notes; drawings; sketches; models; . l m photographs; etc. l ' You should include, whereever possible, the dates, locations and-circisnstances ~ - l l of each document. . l , l ' l.[ sy i h,
.: f:
.s? ~
_ . _ - . . _ . - . . _ ,_ t
;p . .
- q. .
. ::42 -
d *, * ' ' 3- , .,
. , J: .
e y..,
!.v.
The" deposition will- be taken before an Official Court Reporter. You 1,
.[
will be sworn and your deposition will be taken under oath. Respectfully submitted,
* ') '( , -; .. e. .
7;d4 7 ', . .
* ; . ">('
( >is Ac , D/. D '
- l. 6 ; AMrs.) Juanita Ellis, President .
i' CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy) 1426 S. Polk r.) ' Dallas, Texas 75224 - 214/946'-9446 - > P::yi i'is i m, . ' - t'% l ',
- -] k - a .,
m<. y !;'y , 1* f [. . p..... ,
.] f. I ,
{. :% .' '
.sg') *
- y. . *,
- 5. s ,
,' , t 'l D
')'
- _ ) *
.,* , \
%? 1 o
I.p* *
.'* f
- n,,,
- f.a.,),'+-:p
~
9 4*
.OgI: 'l i.4 h 5,*:.~ *;
. j. i :, ' *
.Nfll& -
- . + '
.e$. ,
- s Tf:
' , f
,-0 I
'4, l ,t t 9 5.
(
) ' ?. .
6 4 f;
- t: , ;. : ,
s 4:- 5 - k ', :,s u , e , h ' 4
. &.; .~ ,. ," u r 8 -
. u. -
' c,
' % d.
lp;Q; , 3.,. , , t a v
, M.:[!..khh
.. 4 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA '
O'h. 3 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
'wt
'rr.2 6 >L i .. h ,
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD x " l.),9 'i th] Matter of I N,'fM. j I m::s :m . l CATION OF TEXAS UTILITIES ATING COMPANY, ET AL. FOR AN I Docket Nos. 50-445 'i i]i-I and 50-446 :# - TING LICENSE FOR COMANCHE b .ei: %i? 3'.F.'M STEAM ELECTRIC STATION I
,~ ;.! . b'.d,hh
#1 AND #2 (CPSES)
I lF M I ~ - i? NY,$$^h " [
-po:
y ..
,pp :
,pr-b;,w.3 1.v,3g w -
CERTI FICATE OF SERVICE ' 8./F/M.:.-
+cc ;: - .r.m -.'
[ signature below, I hereby certify that trua 'and correct copies of ~_ ; U N iD g,g # -
. C..A..S E. 's Noti ce o.f. Deposi.t.i.on. .to. Pe.te r S . Y..
- . - - C.h.an.g .-.. -. _
...- - . _ - n--... - - - . . -
', s h,".;'
scen sent to the names lis ted below t his mt_ day of Aummt ,9982,7hy%gr$.g !s Mail where indicated by
- and Firs t_. Class Mail elsewhere. -
*C'
- =. Hand delivered '9 :
- 3/*9 g
^;m"' . i. 1
,. iv
' l , U,. . [,2W M j pctrLtiv; Judge Marshall E. Miller David J. Preister, Esq. %
i
,' J+Q. q,'qu' .M :
lNucldct Regulatory Commission Asnistant Attorney Geh ral N: .-
..g ' 'p# {
~ Saf0ty .and Licensing Board Panel Divironmental Protection Division eton, D.. C. 20555 P. O. Box 12548, Capitol Station 9 5
'#;.(i'"hff I 3~ ._
Austin, TX 78711 l?
' Y$,h ,
hnathA.'McCollom, Dean . !on cf Engineering, Architecture, Ms. Lucinda Minton ). " c; 3[y.f ' Panel Law Clerk ' 3N nd' Technology Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel ma Stats University l, f4'y$ t U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission . jg ,: $tsr, Oklahoma 74074 Washington,'D. C. 20555 hhtrdCole,
,' ' " ~
,,.NdMi. 1$
Member l Saf3ty and Licensing Board At m.i c Sa fety and Licensing Ivard Panel
,)hg:{
,'h'p'
%ucicerRegulatoryCommission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission , Jhp%
~
20555 gton, D. C. Washington, D. C. 20555 M@gfd Y S. Reynolds, Esq. O
- id/
Atomir- Sa fet y and Licensing ' N,;l f.' c2 5 Liberman Appeal Panel ll?th St., N. W. U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
'if 6 r
.2
, , q~1,h- 2:
irton, D. C. 20036
. .. j gyh :,3 washington, D. C. 20555
- hUlmanRothschild,Esq. . M" .q,.Q.; y Docketing and Service Section f
'Of Executive Legal Director Office of the Secretary
- P *'G
. -1.('g;.,p.,, l
{uclO2rRegulatoryCommission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .. '.M '
;t:n, D. C. 20555 Wishington, D. C. 20555 ,; -{.,,
, ,f.;, 3 pf
> U,']yWg. M
" ]Qj,1i :;
V R
.rs.$a anani ta 4 .11is, % President .
CASF (Citizens Association for Sound Er
,y
;p 't
' O.'~Q Nl'
. ; :t.. .v. . i ;a '.x,ei.e.,a.,aud%.~
E _
m m! HCL fr}}