ML20063D000

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Notice of Jc Finneran 820820 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Qa/Qc Control During Facility Const Activities.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence
ML20063D000
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 08/19/1982
From: Ellis J
Citizens Association for Sound Energy
To:
References
NUDOCS 8208270444
Download: ML20063D000 (4)
v • d • e


Text

il*@Yy:.! ' *;

.y 3.Qp;f%4 k

Tl'c.'

E$

Tp).,q&,

'T perm tojvosDENC8 a.,, i a.e ry.g

.s.

.y Q.

B/19/82:

S. 4 n,r(

'7.

UNITED ST ATES OF AMERICA 00CKETEO4.G,

,Y NUCLEAR REGULA10RY COMMISSION USMC "

S

. * [,.'.

I.

J t-, -

7 s

BEFORE THE AT0f11C SAFETY AH3 LICENSING BOARD q

I In the Matter of I

0FFICE OF set,8GA i

50- d $ $ ' DEL':

APPLICATION OF T EKAS tlT !!. ! T I E S Docket Nos.

GENERATING COMPANY, ET AL. FOR and 50-446 I

~

AN OPERATING LICENSE FOR I

~

COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC

.' 5 -

I (CPSES) f~

i '.

STATION UNITS #1 AND #2 3.x

~.

.a N_0TICE OF DEPOSITION

};.c TO:

Mr. John C. Finneran, Project Pipe Support Engineer Texas Utili ties Services, Inc.

~

P. O. Box 1002 Glen Rose, Texas 76043 You are hereby notified that CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy),

h._'v.

Intervenor in the above-captioned proceedings, will take your oral'depesition 9

!' ' 9. h comencing on Friday, August 20,1982 at 10:30* A.M. and continuing until 9A k. l....

completed. This confirms our telephone conversation yesterday afternoon with y+'-

,i,.

Applicants and the NRC Staff. The deposition will be taken at the offices of:

l-,.

o r.

.,n Carrington, Coleman, Sloman & Blumenthal

. t' n.Q

' ': /g.;

v 2500 S. Tower, Plaza of the Americas (f r,.c N~

Dallas, Texas The deposition will relate to all matters of which you have knowledge

's/-'-

in connection with CASE's Contention 5 relating to quality assurance / quality

}

e P,

control during construction activities at Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station -

4.:.

and 'the construction activities employed during the plant's construction.

I.

Y b.7 M'4 Specifically, you should be prepared to answer questions regarding the failure xo

. E

'of the Applicants to include proper analysis factors in their STRUDL (Structural av.

oo Qg Design Language) c.omputer calculations on pipe supports; problems with the s

J_

Oca use of Richmond Inserts (used to hang pipe supports); problems with constraint on]

of pipe thennal growth; suppurts which due to instability are actually non -

~

OO s

oco

,n owo

[:j W

. supports; the testimony of Mark Walsh and any rebuttal to his testimony of g-which you have knowledge, including all documents on which you will or plan

  • inmediately following the deposition of Kenneth L. Scheppele gg

b y

.j

. l 'R 3

,, m:. s

... a

  1. ~

{:(.

,; }- J a c, -,'

g s

bi-J, p

' L;

.e,.3

a t

to rely inQ' car Nbutnal _ testimony. You should also bring with you any of

'it

(/

y,-

the following 'which you ~have access t,o:; the mersonnel records of Mark Walsh j.,

insofar as they may be relied on 'for goar rebuttal testimony; the personnel t

records of Jack boyle, instfar as theA may be relied on.for your rebuttal (U' ' '

j 3

testimony; bN.k-up docments for the 14 arch 3,1982 meeting referred to in the r/,

)

3/8/82 TUSI Office Memorandum (CASE E3 ' bit 659E from the July hearings) discussed h

N 3

in the direct testimony and cross-exwiination.of CASE Witness Mark Walsh;

/

. n &,-.

[ ;-

t%dk-up documents which were referred to or ysed as.the_ oasis. for conclusions.

,. M

~.

(

(

' M.'W contained in the 6/25/82 TUSI Office Memorandum (CASE Exhibit; 659G) discussed -

. C N.

7-gy

,ss.'

in the direct tertimony and cross-examination of Mark Walsh; ahe NPSI Design M-

.;g Criteria for pipe supports (the official one issued in May 1981); all, documents which were used to define the method used to determine the tensile force,in the 4

~

c Richmond Inserts; the current Grinnell Design Criteria hcr;.p[p^e supports at.

w l

~:

U..,

l ', ~,

CPSES; a print-out of the criteria in the computer regarding STRUDL procedures'..

-./gg s

, j$fi) c.

program guides, and any other information relating to STRUDL; a print-out of' h.w :

.MQ'.hh the computer run in the file of the TUSI FAG (Frame Analysis Group); the Hilti i.

gu e;.

allowables' and the procedures' for the ana' lysis, a copy of FUB II and the instruc A lf)#~@

r tions of how to use the FUB II information; the current,:PSE (Pipe' Support Engineer W j

.)

t,.a ing) design criteria volume for pipe supportsj at CPSES; all the NCR's written g

by Mark Walsh; a copy of the American Weldirg Society Codei~ copies o.f any other-

'I H. j f

j

\\,'

_c documents of which you are anare or which you may use in your rebuttal testiimony;

  • g.

. Ef.j

+ '. d e

any any other documents hlating to the mattgrs referenced herein.

f

-! A.q h Documents should 'be considered in the droad sense, including but not fl3SI 1

.r'

'k i

limited to:

internal memoranfa; handwritten notes; drawings; sketches; models;

. m. I, r.

. r n. :.

/c,.

s

~ hotographs; etc.

/

p You should include, whereever possible, the dates, l'ocations and.circumst$nces;.'m i

of each docment.

P* , j[

+.4,:.

i j 'g j' .tn ,e .__n, p, ~,

u.p. sc.g, dg,m. n. k < ',[ '",{' ., a w. (.g.g;.,.. 3- <, s,u,.o 8 a;... '.t.t, f,.! ^,-?- ,stry ' : ..~ pt}, *. The" deposition will be taken before an Official Court Reporter. You e-. - si],^ will be sworn and your deposition will be taken under oath. [ t.- Respectfully submitted, 4 {lc;.: c (li".. '., . l) / 4 .,Let Aj / $j .,m,n.r. y y ' t,' f(Mrs.) Juanita Ellis, President CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy) 1426 S. Polk M.. '" '.";. ' A, Dallas, Texas 75224 ' ~ 214/946-9446 .. ' ~

l., ' ;)f.: '.,y. :

M., :r g. .? it, ! ' ~,..... 4 f. b 'I $'f 4 U,11.. q, l=, *.g i, ~.. y n... ' If[r, g, e$[;/.6Q ::l': s: ..,, g 1k-k.u '.. t s } .p; f s \\ i '7:. v? * '*' iQ *

  • iy t.;.*

I .a.

t..

T a s ) m. +. te

  • s I,?

4' g ! 4 34 9 . - p L' % 5 3i* 4 6 9 l# ',' '.fs es y.. L I. 'i '4 .u ','t' ..~ '..s e f' ', t *.' 'l

.5 '.
-". **Y91

...?.... ..\\',~v < c..m.... e -- }, %i ' *fgi eff; )*.-J C

' \\lQ.;j99.)&o yf. j r a y,,, a,;,$..,. v;.( *,yj., ; ,g. a'. 'd. / i, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 0%g [%. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Mfp, r,99.};3 i n m,;. " : ::Q.=h yp}',ki'.{,7 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARDQ $Q 23 P2 5g.:g>: i- .ff.. '. Iiis.[},In the Matter of .,.M. s 0FFggs SE,RVICE, ?d t I gm e J,d W ' F. $J6.4,l.?.b. { ' y f, GENERATING COMPANY, APPLICATION OF TEXAS UTILITIES I Docket Nos. 50-445 ' ' M t M' s.- ET AL. FOR AN I and 50-446 / n ],',OPERATINGLICENSEFORCOMANCHE I ^h h (' - l PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION -I '- h;, {j ' 7 UNITS #1 AND #2 (CPSES) I ' h., Q ' e-7.;k,.* G.?f '*'.J ,v 1 ,s ,.,&e :*7 '. b',s {..- s ::j' w. a p.-i[q,D!. .y y A.i,, F '.M' jOrar. h?I CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ' U. 9$.h. hhkmy. signature below, I hereby certify that true #and correct copies of, 7,,r.%..,. CASE's Notice of Deposition to John C. Finneran i Ar +- ..m,.. .es< ,4 'T/th6vepbcen.sent to the names lis ted below this 19th day of Aunnet A1982,rbt,;h M,[3 press Mail where indicated by

  • and First Class Mail elsewhere.

~ b %NMg

  1. o

]l'.,,g' 1 ' f**:=Handdelivered ' :je~ : {T *

z. -

.( w e,. g. .t... ~ g ~,h j?' ' ' bj $c Administrative Judge Marshall E. Miller David J. Preis te r, Esq. - r 2.UB Sb Nuclear Regulatory Commission Asnistant ~ Attorney Geh ral ', ej:i, ~l,9 Atomic; Safety:and Licensing Board Panel Environmental Protection Division .,k ; - fd;s. " 'q uhington, D..C. 20555 P. O. Box 12548, Capitol Station ,~, ', ",. ,.4 " , 0-e p; ;,9 r/!p" " Austin, TX 78711 -...."y.., v. [ kf4 .bk' 'Kenneth A.'McCollom, i,'f. Division.of Engineering, Architecture, Dean Ms. Lucinda Minton Panel Law Clerk l' : " * % - p.M.H.handTechnology Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U yfpoki$oma'StateUniversity V. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission j.'.'$ sti11waEer,' Oklahoma 74o74 Washington, D. C. 20555 '.c.T ?e p' K'.: ', ', ., n.e. v r.;;t: w g.4 Dr,, Richard Cole, Member t t mii c r,a fet'y and Licensing . :.:'8 , j -'. Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Board Panel

hb.$$

U.,S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commission !@hk Wachington, D. C. 20555 'T ' l 'J ],TM ' Lidalhington, D. C. 20555 i 'f $

    • Nicholas S.

Reynolds, Esq. Atomic Sa fet y and Licensing p,d Debe'voise & Liberman Appeal Panel J. i 7 f.;,l120.3 - 17th St., N. W. U. S. Nuclear Pegulatory Commission .,,s, rf *i. Washington, D. C. 20o36 Washington, D. C. 20555 ' y.g, .:?

  • i.:;.C 4 Marjorie Ulman Rothschild, Esq.

Docketing and Service Section ' i . 9'. g, ';i' pffic,e of Executive Iagal Director Office of the Secretary '. {' % d N j ;'UK' S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission V I.'y,. ;A. ~ f f '. iWashi.ngton., D. C. 20555 Wuhington, D. C. 20555 '? q %< -,,; g. y . p' lf i &.] s,- 'h' ,,i; * * : ' -. y' FnS f,, }i j,fy l r '. ~ 4': .?.WM, :e. 'M i. t s-y W. &..,,.. _rs.) Juanita E lis, President ., ;p.f-V ~ ' - ' uJ y

gi'.,Q;' /

5. d...., yiG. 4 'CASF (Ci tizens Association for Sound-Energ~y); ~'f .; r '~*s 9.g [

  • f e.

.:. i.C .e y.r[* h*(,ke,ad.gjAgj,gAyf 434,4,ggg s,g,,g,,,,,, 4,, m. zm m m m}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20063D000&oldid=4449863"