ML20062G878

Twelfth Set of Interrogatories & Request to Produce. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20062G878
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	08/09/1982
From:	Ellis J Citizens Association for Sound Energy
To:	TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
Shared Package
ML20062G868	List: ML20062G867 ML20062G878
References
NUDOCS 8208130216
Download: ML20062G878 (10)

Text

n .7. f A , cyc. c oco m m' " "" -))

8/9/82 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA .

d}'

NUCLEAR REbulATORY COMMISSION 00, ED g

.{

BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD ,

.A I EGOJgN ..I'07!-

In the Matter of APPLICATION OF TEXAS UTILITIES Docket Nos. 50i Th and 50-4463 Rb . - '~ '

GENERATING COMPANY, ET AL. FOR I I

AN. OPERATING LICENSE FOR  :

I COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC I  !

STATION UNITS #1 AND #2 (CPSES)

CASE'S TWELFTH SET OF INTERR0GATORIES TO APPLICANTS AND REQUESTS TO PRODUCE ,

Pursuant to 10 CFR 2.740b and 2.741, CASE (Citizens Association for Sound ,'

Energy), Intervenor herein, hereby files this, its Twelfth Set of Interrogatories to Applicants and Requests to Produce.

Please answer the following interrogatories in the' manner set forth' herewith:

1. Each interrogatory should be answered fully in writing, under oath or affi nnation.

2. Each interrogatory or document response should include all pertinent infonnation known to Applicants, their officers, directors or employees, -

their agents , advisors or counsel . Employees is to be construed in the l broad sense of the word, including specifically Brown and Root, any .

consultants, sub-contractors, and anyone else performing work or services on behalf of the Applicants or their agents or sub-contractors.

3. Each doctanent provided should include a sworn statement of its authenticity.

4. Answer each interrogatory in the order in which it is asked, numbered .

to correspond to the num-er of the interrogatory. Do not combine answers. .

5. Identify the person providing each answer, response, or document.

6. These interrugatories and requests for documents shall be continuing in nature, pursuant to 10 CFR 2.740(e) and the directives of the Board.

8208130216 820809 PDR ADOCK 05000445

. _ 3 5}

Because of the time mstrictions under which we are presently operating, we mquest that supplementation be made on an expedited basis.

7. For each item supplied in response to a request for documents, ide'ntify it by the specific question number to which it is in response. If the item is excerpted from a document, identify it also by the name of the document. Please also provide the copies in the co rect order (rather ,

than in reverse order).

CASE'S INTERR0GATORIES TO APPLICANTS AND REQUESTS TO PRODUCE

1. Provide the names of the rebuttal witnesses Applicants plan to present in the September hearings. Include in your answer a brief summary of each witness' qualifications and what his or her testimony is expected to cover.

2. Are any of the rebuttal witnesses referenced in question 1 above purported to be experts on STRUDL (Structural Design Language)?

3. If t' eh answer to 2 is yes, for each witness who purports to be an expert on STRUDL, provide full and specific details mgarding such person's qualifications and training, including specific details of work background, 1

training (including when, where, and by whom trained, length of time train- .

ing occurred, etc.), and any other pertinent details.

4. Provide for inspection and copying all documents on which the rebuttal l

witnesses referenced in question 1 above will rely in their testimony.

5. CASE has been informed that some of our witnesses have had some problems in obtaining their personnel records from Comanche Peak. We may want to question Applicants' witnesses regarding some of the information in our witnesses' files during cross-examination of Applicants' rebuttal witnesses.

4

_.9- . - m., . - -

. . $.;Y,.}

1 1 .

5. (continued): -

We understand that there may be a problem as to whether or not Applicants 4 j

would supply personnel records direct to CASE. We therefore equest that c you send the following information direct to the witnesses themselves- 'f immediately:

l u

(a) Charles A. Atchison 'i 744 Timber Oak Azle, Texas 76020 -

il Mr. Atchison advises that he has now received his QC Personnel .i records and his certifications. Hovlever, he has not yet received his jobsite personnel file from the timekeeping office. Please \[f send it direct to him at the above address. '};

(b) Mark A. Walsh

'f\ '

2309 0xley Drive

• Pontiac, Michigan 48055 As stated in the attached copy of the letter from Mr..Walsh to

}i i

TUSI on July 30,1982 (CASE Attachment 1), Mr. Walsh has requested f

a photocopy of each and every item in his personnel file: including I (but not limited to) evaluations, salary reviews, attendance records, etc. Please send these direct to him at the above address.- 4

. (c) Henry A. Stiner i P. O. Box 1441 Glen Rose, Texas 76043 . i and  ;

Darlene Stiner '

t P. O. Box 1441 -

[

Glen Rose, Texas 76043 , j i

As stated in the attached copy of the ' letter from Mr. and Mrs.-

Stiner to Brown & Root (CASE Attachment 2), Mr. and Mrs. Stiner - I have requested copies of everything in the personnel files of each of them and documentation on the qualifications and certi-fications on each of them. This should include everything in D

i

j q -

l 5.(c) (continued):  ;

their QC Personnel records and in the jobsite personnel files from the timekeeping office. Please send these direct to them at the above address.

6.- Provide for inspection and copying the Cold Form Institute (CFI) Catalogue

- 1971.

7. The March 8,1982, TUSI Office Memorandum (CASE Exhibit 659E) refers to a March 3, 1982, meeting. Provide for inspection and copying all documents (in the broad sense of the word, including but not limited to: internal memoranda, papers, letters, handwritten notes, etc.) which were used during  ;

the 3/3/82 meeting, referred to during the 3/3/82 meeting, used as the basis for conclusions drawn during the 3/3/82 ineeting or as the bas.is for conclusions contained in the 3/8/82 Office Memorandum.

8. The June 25, 1982 TUSI Office Memorandum (CASE Exhibit 659G) contains further clarification of the 3/8/82 Office Memorandum referenced in question 7 above. Provide for inspection and copying all documents (in th'e broad

! sense of the word, including but not limited to: internal memoranda, papers, letters, handwritten notes, etc.) which were referred to or used as the

~

l .

basis for conclusions contained in the 6/25/82 Office Memorandum.

9. Provide for inspection and copying tile NPSI Design Criteria for pipe supports (the official one issued in May,1981). f

10. ' Provide for inspection and copying all documents (in the broad sense of the word, including but not limited to: internal memoranda, papers, letters, handwritten notes, etc.) which were used to define the method used to determine the tensile force in the Richmond Inserts.

11. Provide for inspection and copying the Richmond (Insert) Screw Anchor Catalogue (the one which Applicants began to cross examine Mark Walsh i

about just before lunch on Thursday, July 29, 1982 - should be in the

- 1

. ll

~

11.(continued): :j transcript) . We believe it was Bulletin 6 dated 1971. At that time, (

Applicants indicated that you had not yet been able to get a copy from .

9 ,

the site but that you intended to introduce it on rebuttal. ij 0

12. Provide for inspection and copying the current Grinnell Design Criteria j

.f for pipe supports at CPSES. p i

13. Provide a copy of the print-out of all the criteria in the. computer regard- .

ing STRUDL procedures, pmgram guides, and any other information relating If I

to STRUDL.

-[

14. Provide a copy of the print-out of the entire computer run in the file

't of the TUSI FAG (Frame Analysis Group). '

15. Provide for inspection and copying the entire volume of the current,PSE h t

, design criteria for pipe supports at CPSES. - -

3 Y

4

16. Provide for inspection and copying a copy of the Hilti allowables and the [

procedures for the analysis.

'I

e

17. Provide for inspection and copying a copy of FUB II and the instructions t of how to use the FUB II information (i.e., the entire procedure for using ,I all of the information off of FUB II) to determine the capacity of the Hilti h

bol t. E.

g.

18. Provide for inspection and copying the criteria for rejectable porosity h liy and gas pockets in welds. (Believe this is D.I.1-81, but not certain.)

N If this criteria has been changed, provide both the old and new criteria. p Depending upon the answer from Applicants as to who their rebuttal witnesses - [L are, we may wish to take depositions from some utility witnesses. Also, if -

Applicants wish to take deposition (s) from any of our witnesses, we will need -

r the preceding infonnation prior to the taking of such depositions. -

I I

t i

?.

We themfore ask that the preceding information be provided at least two full days prior to the taking of such depositions, if any of the information contained -

l in the documents requested will be referred to directly or indirectly during such depositions if taken by the Applicants. In mgard to depositions taken by CASE, we will advise as soon as we have been provided the infomation in question 1 the names of Applicants' witnesses from whom.we may wish to take ~

depositions and the documents which we will need to uss in such depositions.-

Respectfully submitted, '

> J n b6.J f} J D - -

M4'r's.') Juanita Ellis, President 6tASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy) .'

1426 S. Polk Dallas, Texas 75224 ,

, f, 214/946-9446 .

.3d

.y.

Y g

3 E

I h

I;.

m b.

s

,=

~

CASE ATTACHMENT _1 Mark A. Walsh 2309 0xley Drive Pontiac, Michigan 48055 Richard Baker TUSI, Personnel Department Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station P. O. Box 1002 Glen Rose, Texas 76043 July 30, 19_82

Dear Mr. Baker:

I terminated my employment on June 18, 1982. I was an employee of PDS and assigned to the Comanche Peak site in the site stress analysis group.

I would like a photocopy of each and every item in my personnel file: in-cluding (but not limited to) evaluations, salary reviews, attendance re-cords, etc.

Please mail these requested papers, etc. to my new address:

Mark Walsh -

2309 0xley Drive Pontiac, Michigan 48055 Please provide these documents innediately. -

Thank you for your prompt reponse. -

Cordially, 4 d. 1___

Mark A. Walsh e

4 D

w.f, u Qi 1 ~

l CASE ATTACHMENT 2 -

l Page 1 of 2 :I l

, il August 9, 1982 3

Mr. Ray Yockey .h

,4 Personnel Manager Brown & Root, Inc.

T

'l Box 1001 ,

Glen Rose, Texas 76043

.[.

Dear Mr. Yockey:

i This is to confirm our request of August 6,1982, sent certified mail to you (see' attached receipt) for copies of everything in the personnel files ,

on me and my wife and documentation on the qualifications and certifications ,.3 -

on both of us. '

.k As indicated in our August 6 letter, we expect that this will be supplied e promptly and that there will be no omissions or deletions.

4 As indicated in our letter, I have tried on numerous occasions to clarify . $

certain information contained in my personnel files, by certified letter -

and also by telephonic communication. ~

This is to escin request th3it you immediately sup' ply 'us with these records . .

and documents.

~ ~

y/

. bl We will appreciate your prompt response. '

, py Sincerely, d .

4 & m = - -- - l;p 9 T k g.. ..~ 4 % v -Q H'nry e Stiner if Darlene Stiner .]

P. O. Box 1441 J Glen Rose, Texas 76043 j

\

.L P. S. By copy of this letter, we are authorizing Mrs. Juanita Ellis, President 1 of CASE (Citizens Association for Sound Energy), to include this request i as part of her request for documents in CASE's next request for documents i in the operating license proceedings for Comanche Peak. L a - s..o

/$w tL

. = ..

9 I

e 1.

- . . m _. .. ., ..

yyw- g , . , . . _ . _.

. ,, .g u.. . .

pxgp.  %,w. 4.: ~ . . :p:4..

. .o;. a)n . .. .J;,,,, , .:,n v.,

. ,. 3 m'-e 4. v . .,. ;

., . 4 . . . -

. o.

p

e , .

. .j.< :p j.f.t,k .,. Q.

p. ,t.-c * . .- ,,

1 e' . .-

,. , , j. . ct O: . v, .;r yk .

i';%

Uly?'.);{w

-),q& . L -, . f V.?: * . , . ' ,

.~. . M-

., . s... . ~ t- *

.c . . g:.n, :.a.s8.,.gf ~;,.

.? ; . . 6' . ' -

c, ,

,, M. n. ,. C.'Mg.yy,id)

.i. . ...),' .

<,.g. . . .

p.,. g

.q :, . " ' - -

• CASE ATTACHMENT.2 . .1 .tgM,f: .4 .

glT:ia S

.- Page. 2 of'a  ; .::.;;%..

. ' ,v

. 2 y.W.. k 4.g:

L 'r9.: ,. p *

. - ll .

, n.;;

, . ' ..eg!NJ..y%g ^

u..< . . .Q W:.. .qv.,. j.', ..

-..' . : g. . ,rp .. .

, .s ; , .,,y.

y-

.;;;.e4:a..u.p,j&

.,p. y . hy;

, . .;s,' .e

. .,e  :-- J ..,i n y:; .z.n. ..,. . ; . .

.m...  :.. .

m.

M  ;;~ - t-R 327. 51.8 537 "T' y@y@v'f.h -

q g;W %.

" L

./? RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL .*

.. @.,.. .:;'. ~ .

.f.hg.f,,.*/@.

..m.n.uffn',,u.,

-i.

. (*j J'}';

N0 INSURANCt COVEAAGE PROVIDED-

~ k ;, .'. .;;k.;. ] .-

NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL M All 71.

4 egiqi,'

T b,7.

/) (See Reverse) /) * '

, . ' 4' .' . n:1.WrbY'k';

f. ' l f" p /-

M,1f4

/'

4N a;7.'mb .

.. .; yi  %

l

• I

-b o?. ,. ...s.

l . , ,

%W

' . i: ' %.%

%l.W'*

y ',f' g/< f, . '.

POSTAGE & #F ,

]

',' g ,

hc)f [

O Cf selifit nt Fr s,..

_((e **

.Wi N

r i as n t Ivt i+ < i f.-),$f. {; Uf+. 4 -

l li f m er nc .. ., .. '-

'. b 9...y.

c'f%Q.

hp *l

• y ;;, . I. s.;YNi-' * \ ', O .j(

h .f '

$ $- 0

E@ '

3{ : ... . .

Ai ..r u .

O[h:. A:x T*s.g' . '.-O - ' M

.. . ;m?* .

$ . c. l . .

.ll ;*  ? .ky/,.g

• ..n, r ~

a :: . r.. . . A,. .u. .s . . .

l&y;'

&, .n";~. ., ; .; , - f g <a-g c*

5 'n

.v.a. s. .t *

• s .*

..a pl ?" .

. . ~ , M.Ne.D.;;y,w

(

O

. . ' . . - 4JJ. g ',t,['d.-%E*cc,

- 'i etie.AW.* s ti Aewn

{g,q,. 4,(c.uJ.,,'. f !*;i, fU I -

,c N u e .1.

M i,...

,o ^

Wa tite twvW- *

• - . ff t.'; . *( <;.  :.,' P-n:

, r g -- y - , *.;$ f, ,

'# g... ,; l;[ts.f. y.'

TOTAL POSTAGE AND FEES < S /h 7

'f . ' i Vi & y.Q .S s"?! -1 . \?%

,. : ,,A POSild ARK OR DAlp,s" . .'

= #- <g J . '" -

j.A *". . M.y:X'$'

fL..S.yJ i 8

/j'@%;yi.y -

$., i . . d *

.'.J8,hW[y)e 1

s .

I m':n

'N-h,h

.9 .h.y,n.

.l. 2 .

m. i.;V E . -

v. ; a w+

' e. ..~,

~,. . . ,; A: . m i.

a

~.:, . t.

.%. {.yi'. -

. -l^ .

[g.:s:5.' ;.

.; k_. . a . S

. !. + :9 ;.... ., a . .

,,.. a n ,,... .:G .

fM w ,$'h;(h:a}l. ". ;.

d. -

v-w e.8 .. ww.' y .

- . :d:q.Q%.

z:-.

f

^hy H v.u:':n  : $.6%: . . . - .,..'.'?

s '

.W ,

hy,p ' ):';L$.iKQl?n[?l l:

!.i. -

.;.?.T'f.r.g.h.',* 5 .Yw+

i

. o. D : , .

M;p... --

Y

• $ W lQ ,', . ..' - ,

, e. .r .

?4.E a-

. .a _

=

., , . .  ;*[

- s l'

.. 1

1. i ..

4 i \

'.k s ,;

..I' p'$. .

m... .

l.~.:: .

, , l

.d. f$

l -. .

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA .'. g;g#.E E! 'r.[js' '

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSTON t,

,G' BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BO.RD , 3 .g ;

In the Matter of I ......... . e. ,

I (JY&$ EWsh.'& 'S APPLICATION OF TEXAS UTILITIES I DocketNos".,0$OWMSygg Ql GENERATING COMPANY, ET AL. FOR AN I and 50-848 '

OPERATING LICENSE FOR COMANCHE I , {' d 1

PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION I f UNITS #1 AND #2 (CPSES) I

.[ll O .

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE -k *

.d By my 1 h low Ih certify that true and correct copies of ptuhelfth s set ofreb[errogatories In to". Applicants..a.n_d. Requests to Produce cI .

~,I-have been sent to the names listed below this 9th day of Auaust , 1982, by: r Express Mail where indicated by

• and First Class Mail elsewhere. -

.___ .i

• • = Hand Delivered  ?,

o Administrative Judge Marshall E. Miller David J. Preis te r, Esq. - .

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Asnistant Attorney Geheral *f;,

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Y:nvironmental Protection Division 3'"

W:mhington, D. C. 20555 P. O. Box 12548, Capitol Station y, N Austin, TX 78711 -[h 0Dr. Kenneth A.~ McCollom, Dean Ms. Lucinda Minton

3. r r. ,

Division of Engineering, Architecture, Panel Law Clerk J.h and Technology U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .* q#

Okichoma State University Stillwater, Oklahoma 74074 Atomic Safety &. Licensing Board Panel Washington, D. C. 20555 4

'.?

.e

• Dr. Richard Cole, Member Atomic Safety and Licensing -'

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Board Panel

.U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission -

Wa:hington, D. C.- 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 lC Nicholas S. Reynolds, Er q . At omid Sa fety and Licensing .

Debevoise & Liberman Appeal Panel I

1200 - 17th St., N. W. U. S. Nucitar Pegulatory Commission

}

l ,

t Wa"hington, D. C. 20036 Wa s hi ng t.on , D. C. 20555 M,1 l0 Marj rie Ulman Rothschild, Esq. Docketing and Service Section - el

~-

l Office of Executive Legal Director Office of the Secretary T' U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ,[ ,

Washington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 ..

. .u, i p '-. ,

1 .

na se D Qk,i,,

+ s. Uuanita El is, President EF (Citizens Association for Sound Energy)

-b

4. f

.a . . . ...

n :+ u%.