ML20062B165

Transcript of Commission 820722 Public Meeting/Affirmation Session in Washington,Dc Re SECY-82-270A on Alternative Commission Decision in Indian Point Special Proceeding

ML20062B165
Person / Time
Site:	Indian Point
Issue date:	07/22/1982
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8208040357
Download: ML20062B165 (10)

Text

_ _ . _ _ _ _ -

NU N U. PSGULATORT CCM!CSSICN

( ,

r, -

1 r -

6 Ju .. u ,. .r L, 3 0--

COMMISSION MEETING In de Ma m - cf:

i 1

i PUBLIC MEETING JEFIRMATION SESSION

^

l l

( DATI: .Tnly 22. 1992 PAGIS: 1 thru 6 AT: Washincton, D.C.

ALDR%X REPORTING C f .. ,

400 vi_TM a Ave., 5.W. ~4=*Hd"_p==, D. C. 20024 1

Ta.Lachc=e : (20 } 554-2345 8208040357 820722 PDR 10CFR PT9.7 PDR

. s 1

'~

1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3

4 AFFIRMATION SESSION' 5

6 PUBLIC MEETING 7

8 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Room 1130 -

9 1717 H Street, N.W.

Washington, D. C.

10 Thu rria y, July 22, 1982 11 The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 12 2:10 p.m.

13 BEFORE:

{~ 14 NUNZIO PALLADINO, Chairman of the Commission 15 JOHN AHEARNE, Commissioner IHOMAS ROBERTS, Commissioner 16 JAMES ASSELSTINE, Commissioner l 17 STAFF AND PRESENTERS SEATED AT COMMISSION TABLE 4 18 W. DIRCKS F. REMICK 19 J. HOYLE L. BICKWII l 20 s

~

21 22

, 23 -

l 24 25 AI.DERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC,

! 400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON. D.C. 20024 (202) 554 2345

?

?

4'

. ~.

DISCLAIMER This is an ' unofficial transcript of a meeting of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Comission held on July '22, 1982 in the

Comissi'on's offices at 1717 H Street, N. W. , Washington, D. C. The ineeting was open to public attendance and observation. Tnis transcript has not been reviewed, corrected, or edited, and it may contain inaccuracies.

The transcript is intended solely for general infomational purcoses.

As provided by 10 CFR 9.103, it is not part of the forinal or infomal l

' record of decision of the matters discussed. Expressions of opinien in ithis. transcript do not necessariTy reflect final deteminations or

- beliefs. No pleading or other paper may be filed with the Commission in

( . any proceeding as the result af or addressed to any statement or argument.

c'entained herein, except as the Commission may auth'orize.

e a

\

.J

~

2 1 EaoGIEEIagS 2 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: The meeting will come to 3 order.

4 This is an affirmation discussion session, and 5 I will ask the Saoretary to point to the items on the 6 agenda.

7 NB. HOYLE Mr. Chairman, we have one item for 8 affirmation today, all of the others have come off for 9 one reason or another, that item is 82-270A, Alternative 10 Commission Decision in Indian Point Special Proceeding.

11 That paper proposes an order, Mr. Chairman, that 12 responds to savarsi requests by parties to the Indian 13 Point proceeding, and provides additional guidance to

(. '

14 the Board.

15 Before I ask you to affirm the votes I have 16 received on that, I v'ould like to address another 17 matter.

18 You have received two submissions, one from 19 the Power Authority of the State of New York, and the 20 other from UCS-NYPIRG commenting 'on the Commission's 21 consideration of the draft order.

22 The question is, how do you wish to treat 23 those? The situation is, I now have three votes 24 suggesting that you do not want to entertain those 25 submissions.

ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC.

400 VIAGtNIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON. 0.C. 20024 (202) 554 2345

)

3 1 I would propose, as you have, sir, to put a l

2 f ootnote on the order, which you will affirm, saying, l l

c 3 "We have received letters from these groups, both dated i l

4 July 19, but' have not entertained either le tter." I 5 would suggest that this be.the approach that you take, 6 and to modify the order.

7 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: That is fine with me.

8 MR. HOILE We have agreement to do that, Mr.

9 Chairman. So the voting on the order is as follows:

10 the Chairman, Commissioners Ahearne and Rob erts approved 11 the version of the order circulated by Commissioners 12 Ahe,arne and Roberts on July 15th.

13 Commisssioners Gilinsky and Asselstine have

(~' ,

% 14 approved that order in part, and have disapproved it in 15 part, and indicated tha t they will provide separate 16 views.

17 I ask you to affirm your votes.

18 (Chorus of nyes.)

19 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: When will you have your 20 separate vievs?

21 COMEISSIONER ASSELSIIN E: I can have my 22 separate views tomorrow. I will not have them toda y , I 23 am running a little bit behind on them.

l 24 CHAIRMAN PALLADIN04 Usually we provide 24 l

25 hours for other Commissioners to look at th em .

i l

ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY. INC.

I 400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554 2345

4

/ 1 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: Yes.

2 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: This will delay the 3 issuance of the order until Monday.

(-

4 MR. H0YLE: Yes, sir, normally you would wait 5 until the separata' views are available and attach them.

6 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: Is there any problem 7 than?

8 MB. H0YLE: I don't see any.

9 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: You don't know when 10 Vic's views are going to be available.

11 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: Another approach we could 12 take is to publish the majority opinion tomorrow or 13 Monday, with a notation that other additional views, if

(' ,

14 any, would be issued separately.

15 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: I think to do that on 16 Monday would be fine.

17 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: Let's see if we can't get 18 word to Commissioner Gilinsky that we would appreciate 19 his comments by tomorrow, so that we act on Monday, and 20 give all the Commissioners a chance to see the 21 additional comments, and wait until Monday.

22 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: The order that we 23 affirmed actually was circulated almost a week ago.

24 COMMISSIONER ROBERTS: Let se see if I 25 understand. The separate views will not be attached to f ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY,INC, 400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON. D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2345.

5 1 the order?

2 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: Yes.

-s 3 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: They will be as long as t

4 they come in tomorrow.

5 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO When I heard that there 6 was a problem, I proposed another alternative.

7 Let's see if there is agreement on this -

8 approach. We will try to get Commissioner Gilinsky to 9 give us his separate views by tomorrow, and get 10 Commissionar Asselstine's separate views by tomorrow, 11 and allow until Monday for other Commissioners to review 12 them. If we have a problem on Monday, we will address 13 it.

14 COMMISSIONER ROBERTS: Fine.

15 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: I think that it is 16 important to get the order out.

17 MR. H0YLE: We will get the word to his 18 office, Mr. Chairman.

19 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO: Is there any more we need 20 to do in the affirmation session?

21 MR. H0YLE: No, sir.

22 CHAIRHAN PALLADIN0s Thank you.

23 We will stand adjourned.

24 25 ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY,INC, 400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2345

IE 4 %L

. - 6 a

( 1 .(Whereupon, at 3 35 p.m. , the Consission adjourned.)

2 3

(.,.

4 4

5 ,

0 i

7 8

1 1 9 i 10 i

11 i

i 12 13 14

15 i 16

~

17 l

l 18 19 20 21 22 23

'( , 24 25 ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC.

400 VIRGINIA AVE S.W., WASHINGTON. D.C. 20024 (202) 554 2345 l - - - . _ . . . _ . . - . . _. - - . . . _ _ , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ._._____._ . ___ _ ........ ,_.._ _ ,.__ _ ,. _ _ ______ _ _ ___ ,_.,_.___.__ __ __ _ _.. ._ _ _ __,

m NUCLEAR EGULATORT COMMISSION This is to certify that the attached pecceedings. before. the

, i l- COMMISSION MEETING l

in the matter of PUBLIC MEETING : AEFIIEATION SESSION Date of' Freceeding.: Juiv 22, 1982 Oceket llumber:-

l Flace cf Preceeding: Washington, D.C.

i were held as herein. appears,. and that this is the origina.L transcript therect for the file of the Cecnission , .

Patricia A. Minson Official Eeporter (Typed)

Y h W OfficiaJ Reporter (Signature)

G 1

e d

w.=

').

a k i

,I

P

_.. . . . , , , , 1. , r m~u mmmnnnnsnnrywmnumymwwmwwww h- -

1 2/81

~ - -

g,

$' _~E. .g N-9fp' TTAL TO *fu - @u Document Control Desk,4, f" ~ MM

~

_. Si

' ~

~

~ ~ '

. 016 Phillips h t

ADVANCED COPY TO: .

/~"7 The Public Document Room , -

b y

1D:'

y, DATE: - 7 @ cc: OPS File M c- From: SECY OPS Branch ,e g

/

, .::5.g C&R (Natali.e-)- E E

Attached .irejeopies of a do= mission meeting transcript /s/ and related meeting documen't/5/. They M are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession L:.st and placement in the Public Document Room. No other distribution is requested or required. Existing '

DOS cocuments identification wherever -known. numbers - are listec on the individual h

. . p Meeting

Title:

. ,o v .( is %w g

a p

M Cun y

/ w .

h M.

MZrTING DATE: hf '

/

M Cb.csed DOSCO?hES:

C Copies (1 cf each Checked) F7 I"TE DESC?lPTIO1h y

Advanced

• To PDR: .

• Original May be Duplicate F p

M 1. M

• Doccent DUP

• C0py*

Z \

• i k

hM . b

.y 2.

• W c

d h

h W

?$

• V d

• k

3.

• y b

~ .

g 4. -

p 5*

W

?

.. ^

• c

p y

C D

• Verify if in DCS, and ch'ange to "?DR

~ h 8

-h- (PDR is advanced one of each doce.ent, two

• available."

sd of each SECT paper.)

ry 3

M.IiMhiMMALMhhMMARBinunnnEWinnrdinhunndIMuuh- ~M="