Letter Sequence Draft Approval |
---|
|
|
MONTHYEARML20059E5031994-01-0606 January 1994 Forwards Results of on-site EQ Review of Related Info at Plant in Support of Staff Task Action to Identify & Address Existing EQ Issues & Concerns.Encl 1 Provides Results of Staff Review.Encl 2 Provides Draft Ltr to Transmit Info Project stage: Draft Approval ML20059L3411994-01-28028 January 1994 Forwards Results of on-site EQ Review at Plant,During Period 931213-17 Project stage: Other 1994-01-28
[Table View] |
Similar Documents at Perry |
---|
Category:INTERNAL OR EXTERNAL MEMORANDUM
MONTHYEARML20212C0761999-09-15015 September 1999 Notification of 990930 Meeting with Firstenergy Nuclear Operating Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensee Recent Submittal Requesting Five Percent Power Uprate ML20212J3201999-06-23023 June 1999 Forwards Proposed Change to STSs for Review & Comment.Change Would Remove TS Requirements for ESF Features to Be Operable After Sufficient Radioactive Decay Has Occurred to Ensure Off Site Doses Remain Below SRP Limits DD-99-05, Forwards Monthly Rept on Status of 10CFR2.206 Petition as of 990331.During March,Director'S Decision (DD-99-06) on Browns Ferry & DD on Army Corps of Engineers Was Issued & (DD-99-05) on Diablo Canyon Became Final Agency Action1999-04-20020 April 1999 Forwards Monthly Rept on Status of 10CFR2.206 Petition as of 990331.During March,Director'S Decision (DD-99-06) on Browns Ferry & DD on Army Corps of Engineers Was Issued & (DD-99-05) on Diablo Canyon Became Final Agency Action ML20205P6271999-04-14014 April 1999 Notification of 990428 Meeting with Util to Discuss Proposed Asset Transfer Between Duquesne Light Co & First Energy Nuclear Operating Co & Associated License Transfer of Beaver Valley Power Station Per 10CFR50.80 ML20205B8871999-03-26026 March 1999 Notification of 990415 Meeting with Utils in Knoxville,Tn to Visit Test Site & Discuss Test Program for ECCS Suppression Pool Suction Strainer.Context of Meeting Considered Entirely Proprietary ML20199L0511999-01-21021 January 1999 Notification of 990222 Meeting with Util in Rockville,Md for Ucs to Present Addl Info & Clarify Issues Raised in Two 10CFR2.206 Petitions Re River Bend Station & Perry Nuclear Power Plant ML20198R8831999-01-0707 January 1999 Forwards SER Accepting Licensee 971015 Request to Amend Perry Nuclear Power Plant TSs 5.2.2.e to Remove Reference to GL 82-12 & Require Administrative Controls Be Established Which Will Ensure Adequate Shift Coverage ML20196D9451998-11-30030 November 1998 Notification of 981204 Meeting with Centerior Svc Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Revs to Licensing Basis for Feedwater Containment Isolation Valves ML20195B8551998-11-0909 November 1998 Notification of 981119 Meeting with Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Revisions to Licensing Basis for Feedwater Containment Isolation Valves ML20238F8661998-09-0101 September 1998 Forwards Licensee Revs to Svc List for Placing in PDR ML20238F3341998-08-31031 August 1998 Notification of 980915 Meeting W/Centerior Service Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensing Submittal Based Upon Revised Accident Source Term That Deletes MSIV Leakage Control Sys & Relaxes MSIV Leakage Limits ML20238F1861998-08-28028 August 1998 Notification of 980910 Meeting W/Centerior Service Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Revs to Licensing Basis for Feedwater Containment Isolation Valves ML20238F5861998-08-28028 August 1998 Notification of 980909 Meeting w/BWR/6S:EOI & Listed Utils in Rockville,Md to Discuss W/Nrc Planned Applications by Licensees to Reduce Operability Requirements During Refueling Outages ML20248F4571998-06-0202 June 1998 Notification of 980625 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Analytical Testing Bases for Mark III ECCS Suction Strainer ML20216D8551998-04-14014 April 1998 Forwards Signed Original of Order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty.Addl 5 Copies & Disk Encl,For Use.W/O Encl ML20217B8441998-03-0606 March 1998 Notification of Cancellation of 980331 Meeting in Rockville, MD to Discuss Proposed Testing Program for ECCS Suction Strainer ML20197B7831998-03-0606 March 1998 Notification of 980331 Meeting W/Ceic in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Testing Program for ECCS Suction Strainer. (Proprietary Info Will Be Discussed) ML20199A3291997-11-13013 November 1997 Forwards NRC Operator Licensing Exam Rept 50-440/97-309OL on 970825-30 w/as-given Written Exam ML20199A3071997-11-13013 November 1997 Forwards NRC Operator Licensing Exam Rept (Included Completed & Graded Tests) for Tests Administered During Wk of 970825 ML20138D8451997-04-29029 April 1997 Notification of 970508 Meeting W/Clei in Rockville,Md to Discuss Priorities & Schedules of Licensing Issues for Plant ML20147J2271997-04-10010 April 1997 Forwards for Transmittal Notice of Proposed Merger for Perry Nuclear Power Plant,Unit 1 ML20136F9741997-03-13013 March 1997 Notification of 970324 Meeting W/Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Emergency Core Cooling Sys Suction Strainer 1/4 Scale Test Rept & to Discuss Acoustic Methodology Applied to Upper Lift Load ML20135E4781997-03-0505 March 1997 Notification of 970306 Meeting W/Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co in Rockville,Md to Review Emergency Core Cooling Sys Suction Strainer 1/4 Scale Test Rept.Meeting Cancelled ML20134Q1271997-02-25025 February 1997 Notification of 970306 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Review Emergency Core Cooling Sys Suction Strainer 1/4 Scale Test Rept & to Discuss Acoustic Methodology Applied to Upper Lift Load Reduction ML20138J7671997-02-0505 February 1997 Informs That NRC Plans to Administer Generic Fundamentals Exam Section of Written Operator Licenseing Exam on 970409. Ltr W/Copy to Chief,Operator Licensing Branch Must Be Submitted to Listed Address in Order to Register Personnel ML20134P9011996-11-26026 November 1996 Notification of 961204 Meeting W/Clei & Teco in Rockville,Md to Discuss Potential Submittals Concerning Proposed Merger of Centerior Energy Co & Oec ML20134E9191996-10-29029 October 1996 Forwards Rationale for Inital Plants Selected for Design Insps & for Plants Considered for Second Quarter FY97 Design Insps ML20149E8161994-08-0202 August 1994 Forwards Fr Notice of License Amend Requests Proposed Merger of Toledo Edison Co & Cleveland Electric Illumianting Co Antitrust Determination NUREG-1299, Forwards Continuation of Curtiss Papers to Be Filed Under Commission Correspondence in Pdr.Advanced Copy Sent to Pdr. List of Documents Included in Four Boxes Encl1994-06-29029 June 1994 Forwards Continuation of Curtiss Papers to Be Filed Under Commission Correspondence in Pdr.Advanced Copy Sent to Pdr. List of Documents Included in Four Boxes Encl ML20059E5031994-01-0606 January 1994 Forwards Results of on-site EQ Review of Related Info at Plant in Support of Staff Task Action to Identify & Address Existing EQ Issues & Concerns.Encl 1 Provides Results of Staff Review.Encl 2 Provides Draft Ltr to Transmit Info ML20058N4811993-12-15015 December 1993 Informs of Decision to Expand Senior Mgt Oversight of Selected Plants,Per Recent Meeting W/J Martin & H Miller. Lists Assignment of Managers,Effective Immediately ML20058M0351993-12-13013 December 1993 Notification of 931214 Meeting W/Licensee in Rockville,Md to Discuss Plant Fuel Failure Root Cause Analysis ML20057G3001993-10-15015 October 1993 Notification of 931028 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Plant Course of Action Plan to Improve Performance of Plant Over Next Several Yrs ML20057D5251993-09-0101 September 1993 Forwards 2.206 Petition Submitted by Capella,Wene & O'Connell Re Poor Performance of Plant.W/O Encl ML20056G0181993-08-26026 August 1993 Notification of 930902 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Facility IST ML20056E7141993-08-19019 August 1993 Notification of 930831 Meeting w/BWR-6 Owners Group in Rockville,Md to Discuss Pending Amend Submittals to Adopt Improved Standardized TS ML20062C2851990-10-18018 October 1990 Forwards Stipulation of Agreed Facts Between Licensee,Nrc Staff & Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy, Signed by Three Parties.Original Stipulation Returned to Silberg. W/O Encl ML20059M0271990-09-17017 September 1990 Forwards Amend to Facility License,Removing cycle-specific Parameters from Tech Specs.W/O Encl ML20059H2091990-09-0505 September 1990 Provides Recipients & Hiatt W/Util Proposed Amend to Delete Values of cycle-specific Parameters of Each Core from Tech Specs ML20056A3641990-07-24024 July 1990 Requests Addition of Listed Name to Svc List for Plant Proceeding.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 900726 ML20248D1391989-09-25025 September 1989 Forwards AEOD/T915, Ground Fault Detection & Trip Circuit at Perry Unit 1, Technical Review Rept.No Further AEOD Action Recommended,Based on Merits of Alarm Scheme for Resolution of Issue ML20248B5631989-06-0606 June 1989 Forwards,For Info,Aeod Diagnostic Evaluation Team Rept for Plant.Evaluation Initiated Following Discussions Held During Senior Managers Meeting in Dec 1988 ML20247E5711989-05-22022 May 1989 Notification of 890531 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Monthly Performance Rept ML20246L2701989-05-0909 May 1989 Forwards SALP Inputs for SALP 9 Rept,Including Info Obtained During Exams Reported in Exam Repts 50-440/OL-88-01 & 50-440/OL-88-02.Deficiencies Noted Re Failure to Provide Training on Auxiliary & Emergency Sys ML20246A2771989-05-0303 May 1989 Forwards SALP Input for May 1988 - May 1989,in Accordance W/ 890401 Memo ML20236E3261989-03-20020 March 1989 Forwards Assessment & Tech Spec Clarification Re 881212 Loss of 5-volt Dc Power Supply & Loss of Rod Display & Operator Control Modules.Restoration of Normal Rod Position Indication,Rather than rod-by-rod Indication,Proper ML20235S6271989-02-28028 February 1989 Notification of 890307 Meeting W/Bwr Owners Group in Rockville,Md to Discuss Items of Current Interest.Agenda Encl ML20206C6041988-11-0808 November 1988 Discusses Review of 870227 Significant Precursor Event Re Two Inoperable Diesel Generators,Per R Dudley 881013 Note. Util Corrective Actions Appear Thorough & Comprehensive ML20205T5821988-11-0707 November 1988 Notification of 881115 Meeting W/Devonrue & Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Std Alternate AC Design to Meet Station Blackout Rule ML20155J3931988-10-20020 October 1988 Notification of 881102 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Unit 1 Operating Performance.Proposed Agenda Encl 1999-09-15
[Table view] Category:MEMORANDUMS-CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20212C0761999-09-15015 September 1999 Notification of 990930 Meeting with Firstenergy Nuclear Operating Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensee Recent Submittal Requesting Five Percent Power Uprate ML20212J3201999-06-23023 June 1999 Forwards Proposed Change to STSs for Review & Comment.Change Would Remove TS Requirements for ESF Features to Be Operable After Sufficient Radioactive Decay Has Occurred to Ensure Off Site Doses Remain Below SRP Limits DD-99-05, Forwards Monthly Rept on Status of 10CFR2.206 Petition as of 990331.During March,Director'S Decision (DD-99-06) on Browns Ferry & DD on Army Corps of Engineers Was Issued & (DD-99-05) on Diablo Canyon Became Final Agency Action1999-04-20020 April 1999 Forwards Monthly Rept on Status of 10CFR2.206 Petition as of 990331.During March,Director'S Decision (DD-99-06) on Browns Ferry & DD on Army Corps of Engineers Was Issued & (DD-99-05) on Diablo Canyon Became Final Agency Action ML20205P6271999-04-14014 April 1999 Notification of 990428 Meeting with Util to Discuss Proposed Asset Transfer Between Duquesne Light Co & First Energy Nuclear Operating Co & Associated License Transfer of Beaver Valley Power Station Per 10CFR50.80 ML20205B8871999-03-26026 March 1999 Notification of 990415 Meeting with Utils in Knoxville,Tn to Visit Test Site & Discuss Test Program for ECCS Suppression Pool Suction Strainer.Context of Meeting Considered Entirely Proprietary ML20199L0511999-01-21021 January 1999 Notification of 990222 Meeting with Util in Rockville,Md for Ucs to Present Addl Info & Clarify Issues Raised in Two 10CFR2.206 Petitions Re River Bend Station & Perry Nuclear Power Plant ML20198R8831999-01-0707 January 1999 Forwards SER Accepting Licensee 971015 Request to Amend Perry Nuclear Power Plant TSs 5.2.2.e to Remove Reference to GL 82-12 & Require Administrative Controls Be Established Which Will Ensure Adequate Shift Coverage ML20196D9451998-11-30030 November 1998 Notification of 981204 Meeting with Centerior Svc Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Revs to Licensing Basis for Feedwater Containment Isolation Valves ML20195B8551998-11-0909 November 1998 Notification of 981119 Meeting with Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Revisions to Licensing Basis for Feedwater Containment Isolation Valves ML20238F8661998-09-0101 September 1998 Forwards Licensee Revs to Svc List for Placing in PDR ML20238F3341998-08-31031 August 1998 Notification of 980915 Meeting W/Centerior Service Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensing Submittal Based Upon Revised Accident Source Term That Deletes MSIV Leakage Control Sys & Relaxes MSIV Leakage Limits ML20238F1861998-08-28028 August 1998 Notification of 980910 Meeting W/Centerior Service Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Revs to Licensing Basis for Feedwater Containment Isolation Valves ML20238F5861998-08-28028 August 1998 Notification of 980909 Meeting w/BWR/6S:EOI & Listed Utils in Rockville,Md to Discuss W/Nrc Planned Applications by Licensees to Reduce Operability Requirements During Refueling Outages ML20248F4571998-06-0202 June 1998 Notification of 980625 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Analytical Testing Bases for Mark III ECCS Suction Strainer ML20216D8551998-04-14014 April 1998 Forwards Signed Original of Order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty.Addl 5 Copies & Disk Encl,For Use.W/O Encl ML20217B8441998-03-0606 March 1998 Notification of Cancellation of 980331 Meeting in Rockville, MD to Discuss Proposed Testing Program for ECCS Suction Strainer ML20197B7831998-03-0606 March 1998 Notification of 980331 Meeting W/Ceic in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Testing Program for ECCS Suction Strainer. (Proprietary Info Will Be Discussed) ML20199A3071997-11-13013 November 1997 Forwards NRC Operator Licensing Exam Rept (Included Completed & Graded Tests) for Tests Administered During Wk of 970825 ML20199A3291997-11-13013 November 1997 Forwards NRC Operator Licensing Exam Rept 50-440/97-309OL on 970825-30 w/as-given Written Exam ML20138D8451997-04-29029 April 1997 Notification of 970508 Meeting W/Clei in Rockville,Md to Discuss Priorities & Schedules of Licensing Issues for Plant ML20147J2271997-04-10010 April 1997 Forwards for Transmittal Notice of Proposed Merger for Perry Nuclear Power Plant,Unit 1 ML20136F9741997-03-13013 March 1997 Notification of 970324 Meeting W/Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co in Rockville,Md to Discuss Emergency Core Cooling Sys Suction Strainer 1/4 Scale Test Rept & to Discuss Acoustic Methodology Applied to Upper Lift Load ML20135E4781997-03-0505 March 1997 Notification of 970306 Meeting W/Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co in Rockville,Md to Review Emergency Core Cooling Sys Suction Strainer 1/4 Scale Test Rept.Meeting Cancelled ML20134Q1271997-02-25025 February 1997 Notification of 970306 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Review Emergency Core Cooling Sys Suction Strainer 1/4 Scale Test Rept & to Discuss Acoustic Methodology Applied to Upper Lift Load Reduction ML20138J7671997-02-0505 February 1997 Informs That NRC Plans to Administer Generic Fundamentals Exam Section of Written Operator Licenseing Exam on 970409. Ltr W/Copy to Chief,Operator Licensing Branch Must Be Submitted to Listed Address in Order to Register Personnel ML20134P9011996-11-26026 November 1996 Notification of 961204 Meeting W/Clei & Teco in Rockville,Md to Discuss Potential Submittals Concerning Proposed Merger of Centerior Energy Co & Oec ML20134E9191996-10-29029 October 1996 Forwards Rationale for Inital Plants Selected for Design Insps & for Plants Considered for Second Quarter FY97 Design Insps ML20149E8161994-08-0202 August 1994 Forwards Fr Notice of License Amend Requests Proposed Merger of Toledo Edison Co & Cleveland Electric Illumianting Co Antitrust Determination NUREG-1299, Forwards Continuation of Curtiss Papers to Be Filed Under Commission Correspondence in Pdr.Advanced Copy Sent to Pdr. List of Documents Included in Four Boxes Encl1994-06-29029 June 1994 Forwards Continuation of Curtiss Papers to Be Filed Under Commission Correspondence in Pdr.Advanced Copy Sent to Pdr. List of Documents Included in Four Boxes Encl ML20059E5031994-01-0606 January 1994 Forwards Results of on-site EQ Review of Related Info at Plant in Support of Staff Task Action to Identify & Address Existing EQ Issues & Concerns.Encl 1 Provides Results of Staff Review.Encl 2 Provides Draft Ltr to Transmit Info ML20058N4811993-12-15015 December 1993 Informs of Decision to Expand Senior Mgt Oversight of Selected Plants,Per Recent Meeting W/J Martin & H Miller. Lists Assignment of Managers,Effective Immediately ML20058M0351993-12-13013 December 1993 Notification of 931214 Meeting W/Licensee in Rockville,Md to Discuss Plant Fuel Failure Root Cause Analysis ML20057G3001993-10-15015 October 1993 Notification of 931028 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Plant Course of Action Plan to Improve Performance of Plant Over Next Several Yrs ML20057D5251993-09-0101 September 1993 Forwards 2.206 Petition Submitted by Capella,Wene & O'Connell Re Poor Performance of Plant.W/O Encl ML20056G0181993-08-26026 August 1993 Notification of 930902 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Facility IST ML20056E7141993-08-19019 August 1993 Notification of 930831 Meeting w/BWR-6 Owners Group in Rockville,Md to Discuss Pending Amend Submittals to Adopt Improved Standardized TS ML20062C2851990-10-18018 October 1990 Forwards Stipulation of Agreed Facts Between Licensee,Nrc Staff & Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy, Signed by Three Parties.Original Stipulation Returned to Silberg. W/O Encl ML20059M0271990-09-17017 September 1990 Forwards Amend to Facility License,Removing cycle-specific Parameters from Tech Specs.W/O Encl ML20059H2091990-09-0505 September 1990 Provides Recipients & Hiatt W/Util Proposed Amend to Delete Values of cycle-specific Parameters of Each Core from Tech Specs ML20056A3641990-07-24024 July 1990 Requests Addition of Listed Name to Svc List for Plant Proceeding.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 900726 ML20248D1391989-09-25025 September 1989 Forwards AEOD/T915, Ground Fault Detection & Trip Circuit at Perry Unit 1, Technical Review Rept.No Further AEOD Action Recommended,Based on Merits of Alarm Scheme for Resolution of Issue ML20248B5631989-06-0606 June 1989 Forwards,For Info,Aeod Diagnostic Evaluation Team Rept for Plant.Evaluation Initiated Following Discussions Held During Senior Managers Meeting in Dec 1988 ML20247E5711989-05-22022 May 1989 Notification of 890531 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Monthly Performance Rept ML20246L2701989-05-0909 May 1989 Forwards SALP Inputs for SALP 9 Rept,Including Info Obtained During Exams Reported in Exam Repts 50-440/OL-88-01 & 50-440/OL-88-02.Deficiencies Noted Re Failure to Provide Training on Auxiliary & Emergency Sys ML20246A2771989-05-0303 May 1989 Forwards SALP Input for May 1988 - May 1989,in Accordance W/ 890401 Memo ML20236E3261989-03-20020 March 1989 Forwards Assessment & Tech Spec Clarification Re 881212 Loss of 5-volt Dc Power Supply & Loss of Rod Display & Operator Control Modules.Restoration of Normal Rod Position Indication,Rather than rod-by-rod Indication,Proper ML20235S6271989-02-28028 February 1989 Notification of 890307 Meeting W/Bwr Owners Group in Rockville,Md to Discuss Items of Current Interest.Agenda Encl ML20206C6041988-11-0808 November 1988 Discusses Review of 870227 Significant Precursor Event Re Two Inoperable Diesel Generators,Per R Dudley 881013 Note. Util Corrective Actions Appear Thorough & Comprehensive ML20205T5821988-11-0707 November 1988 Notification of 881115 Meeting W/Devonrue & Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Std Alternate AC Design to Meet Station Blackout Rule ML20155J3931988-10-20020 October 1988 Notification of 881102 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Unit 1 Operating Performance.Proposed Agenda Encl 1999-09-15
[Table view] |
Text
1
. L January 6, 1994 Docket No. 50-440 MEMORANDUM FOR: John N. Hannon, Director Project Directorate III-3 Division of Reactor Projects III/IV/V FROM: Conrad E. McCracken, Chief Plant Systems Branch Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
SUBJECT:
RESULTS OF THE ON-SITE EQ REVIEW AT THE PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT (TAC M85648)
During the period from December 13 through December 17, 1993, James Tatum and Christopher Gratton of my staff, along with Frank Quinn of SCIENTECH (an NRC contractor), performed an on-site review of EQ-related information at the Perry Nuclear Power Plant in support of the staff's task action plan to :
identify and address existing EQ issues and concerns. The purpose of this review was to gather information and not to assess licensee compliance with NRC regulations. The results of the staff's review is included as Enclosure 1, and Enclosure 2 provides the contents of a draft letter that may '
be used for transmitting this information to the licensee.
If you should have any questions regarding the review that was conducted at Perry, please contact Chris Gratton of my staff at 504-1055.
NdSi9!10dby Conrad E. McCracken, Chief Plant Systems Branch Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Enclosure:
l As stated Distribution:
See next page 1 h 9401110223 940106 PDR ADOCK 05000440 i P PDR._ '
I
[./ f<( ;
l SPLB: DSS h S LB:DSSA CGratton;cf ( 'S'LB:DSSA JTatum CMcCracken 1/ 6/94 1/ f/94 1/p/94
[G:\ REPORT.PER] f 1000'O 1
)$
A D
Enclosure 1 NRC STAFF ON-SITE REVIEW 0F EQ INFORMATION AT THE PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT 1.0 INTRODUClION As a result of the staff's activities related to license renewal, environmental qualification (EQ) was identified as an area that required further review. A major concern in this regard was whether the EQ .
requirements for older plants (i.e., those with EQ programs developed under 00R Guidelines or NUREG-0588, Category II, requirements) were adequate to support license renewal. Consequently, the staff concluded that differences in EQ requirements between older and newer plants constituted a potential generic issue which should be evaluated for backfit independent of the license ,
renewal activities.
Separate from the activities supporting license renewal and in response to issues that were raised by the Office of the Inspector General (0lG) in a report dated August 12, 1992, the NRC staff conducted an assessment of fire protection requirements. The staff's report dated February 27, 1993, 1 identified a number of weaknesses and made wcific recommendations for improving the NRC fire protection program. ln view of the weaknesses that were identified, the staff concluded that other NRC programs such as EQ should also be reviewed to identify and correct any programmatic weaknesses that may exist.
Consequently, the NRC established a task action plan for identifying and addressing 1: sues and concerns that currently exist in the area of EQ. One element of this task action plan involves a number of site visits by the staff -
to gather first-hand information on EQ and to discuss current issues, problems and trends with nuclear power plant personnel. It is emphasized that the purpose of these site visits is not to assess licensee compliance with NRC
+
regulatioas.
The Perry Nuclear Power Plant (PNPP) was the first plant selected for the staff's on-site EQ review activity. The review was performed from December 13-through December 17, 1993, by James Tatum and Christopher Gratton of the NRC, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, and by Frank Quinn of SCIENTECH, an NRC contractor. This report is a brief summary of the on-site review activity .
1 that was conducted. and serves to document the results of the staff's efforts in this regard.
2.0 BACKGROUND
INFORMATION RELATIVE TO THE PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT l The PNPP is operated by the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company et al (CEI or the licensee), and the plant began ccmmercial operation on November 18, 1987. The power source is a boiling water reactor (GE type 6) rated for 3579 Megawatts Thermal, which is enclosed by a Mark 3 containment. PPNP's construction permit was issued on May 3, 1977; therefore, the more recent EQ guidance of IEEE Standard 323-74 and NUREG-0588 (Category I), are~ applicable ;
to Perry.
?
3.0 REVIEW DETAILS The staff's on-site review activity is directed toward gathering EQ-related I information in support of a generic programmatic review, and it is the staff's desire to promote an atmosphere of cooperation and support during each of the site visits. The staff's review plan calls for gathering information through licensee presentations, discussions with plant personnel, and document review.
3.1 Licensee Presentations As part of the review team's orientation to the Perry EQ program, the licensee 4 presented specific information relevant to Perry and provided a tour of EQ components located in accessible areas inside containment. The licensee's presentations covered the results of an EQ audit, EQ-related problems that :
were uncovered during a recent walkdown of harsh environments, involvement with industry groups, administrative procedures, training programs related to >
EQ, and a discussion of a cable condition monitoring program that was established as a commitment at the time when Perry was licensed. ,
fhe licensee's tour of accessible areas of containment concentrated on those areas with safety-related electrical equipment that was qualified for harsh ,
environmental conditions. Equipment that was specifically highlighted during the tour included, for example, Target Rock valves, motor operated valves '
(Limitorques), temperature detectors, ASCO solenoid valves, Rosemount transmitters, and associated electrical cables.
3.2 Discussions with Plant Personnel Over a three day period, the EQ review team participated in group discussions about EQ issues with station personnel from the engineering, maintenance, ,
operations, and training organizations (see Table 1). The purpose of these !
discussions was to learn about programs that had been established for Table 1 Discussion Groups Number of Functional Area:
Participants:
Quality Control 3 ,
Probabilitistic Risk Assessment 2 i Operations 3 Electrical and Mechcnical Design Engineering 4 Systematic Maintenance Optimization 3 Field Engineers (Plant Maintenance) 2 Systems Engineering Section 4 Control Room Personnel - Shift Technical Advisors 2 MOV Group 4 Maintenance and I&C Planners 4 Site Training 2
i i
implementing and maintaining equipment qualification, and to learn about -
specific problems and concerns that existed as a result of EQ requirements and how those problems and concerns were being addressed. In general, station -
personnel appeared to be very aware of EQ requirements and appeared to be sensitive and inquisitive about conditions in the plant that could impact the '
environmental qualification of safety-related electric equipment. ;
3.3 Document Review :
The review team examined the Perry EQ Master List, procedures applicable to ;
EQ, and 70 Auditable File Packages (AFPs) for safety-related electric ,
equipment. The AFPs were well organized and maintained, and listed information such as the equipment type, manufact er, model number, qualified life, and maintenance interval. The AFPs also ontained specific vendor ,
information and any notices that were applicable to each item.
3.4 Results i Based on the information that was obtained at Perry during the on-site EQ review, the staff found that a number of program elements and practices seemed j to be important for establishing and maintaining equipment qualification. The ,
staff also learned about some of the EQ-related problems and concerns that currently exist. .j Noteworthy EQ-Related Program Elements and Practices:
- Periodic EQ training for engineers, craft personnel, and managers / supervisors (the existing program at Perry was being updated at i the time of the site visit). ;
Well organized and maintained qualification file packages. The licensee !
maintains a complete Auditable File Package for each equipment type, which contains equipment qualification information, including vendor information and notices; and the packages are kept up-to-date. ]
Cable monitoring program in harsh environments (this program is a Perry licensing commitment). During construction, representative samples of spare cables were installed for future monitoring / testing at five-year. ;
intervals. . Sufficient spare cable was installed to allow testing to be performed over the entire 40-year life of the plant. The cable i monitoring program includes provisions for trending temperature and j radiation conditions in the vicinity of the spare cables.
- Harsh and mild environment temperature and radiation monitoring. As a .I result of hotter-than-expected conditions in the upper drywell, the l licensee recognized a neeri to monitor actual plant conditions and to j adjust equipment qualified life accordingly. Although the upper drywell o problem indicated a need to shorten qualified life, with sufficient l supporting data it may be possible to extend qualified life in other areas where environments are not as severe ar initially expected.
i j.
'j 1
l m~- -
- Pre-startup walkov -s of EQ equipment in harsh environments. Areas that are typically not accessible during plant operation are specifically flagged for this walkdown by the licensee.
- Use of training aids for the maintenance and inspection of EQ equipment.
The licensee maintains a collection of EQ components for use as training aids. These training aids are easily accessible to QC inspectors and maintenance workers to assist them in their duties.
- Steam leak checklist geared to evaluating EQ concerns. The licensee has established a steam leak check list as a vehicle for evaluating the effects that steam leaks may have on EQ.
- Administrative practices that highlight EQ-related maintenance and testing activities. For example, the repetitive maintenance task cards distinguish between EQ and non-EQ equipment.
Centrally locating the various sealing requirements for EQ equipment.
The licensee has developed two specifications that state the sealing requirements for all EQ equipment used in the plant. One of the specifications is for Limitorque motor operators and the other specification is for all other EQ equipment.
Use of experts outside the Perry organization to participate in the biannual EQ review. The use of other experts outside the Perry organization can be very helpful in getting a fresh, independent review of programs and practices.
- Use of industry data and site-specific data in evaluating the performance of EQ equipment. Various reports in this regard are reviewed by the licensee on a quarterly basis and prior to plant startup from an outage, such as the Component failure Analysis Report (industry report) and the High Frequency Failure Report (site-specific).
Maintenance optimization program. The licensee has established a program to determine the appropriate intervals for performing maintenance on components. While it is important to ensure that EQ equipment is receiving the periodic maintenance that is needed, it is also important to realize that maintenance that is performed too frequently can have some adverse effects on plant operational cafety.
For example, an increased burden is placed on operations and maintenance personnel, there are more opportunities for errors to occur, and equipment availability can be reduced. This program is currently on hold at Perry while actions are being taken to implement the requirements of the maintenance rule.
Periodic maintenance activities classified as " required" vs. "related" to alleviate potential scheduling problems. The licensee attempts to distinguish between maintenance activities that are specifically required for maintaining EQ equipment in an operable status from those activities that are not specifically required to maintain the ,
equipment's qualification; for example, " good practices" that are cited
3 in vendor's manuals. For maintenance requirements that are not specifically required for EQ, the licensee allows some flexibility in scheduling the repetitive maintenance task.
Use of a Preventative Maintenance Feedback Form designed to document the condition of parts replaced during repetitive maintenance. This provides a mechanism for periodically documenting the condition of equipment that may be important for future EQ considerations.
Integration of risk analysis results into maintenance programs. The licensee is currently ranking the importance of systems based on PRA results so that this information can be used in implementing the maintenance rule requirements. This information can also be helpful in identifying and sensitizing people to the really risk-significant EQ equipment that is installed in the plant.
Problem Areas / Areas of Concern Expressed by Plant Personnel:
Extension of maintenance intervals (similar to what is typically allowed for Technical Specification surveillance requirements) is not allowed for EQ repetitive maintenance, even though the " qualified life" that has been established is speculative. This can create a hardship for -
licensees in scheduling repetitive maintenance too often in order to avoid mid-cycle shutdowns or by requiring specific evaluations for each component on a case-by-case basis as the situation arises.
Commercial grade dedication of components was identified as a problem for some EQ equipment; especially individual pieces of vendor-supplied, skid-mounted equipment. Digital equipment upgrade was also cited as a potential problem for EQ equipment. Although these are specific areas that are currently under review by both the NRC and the industry, it is important to recognize that there may be some specific needs with regard to EQ in resolving these issues.
Lack of cooperation from vendors of qualified equipment was cited as a potential operational hardship. Station personnel indicated that some vendors no longer supply " qualified equipment," and others have tightened maintenanco requirements and restricted the type of maintenance that licensees may perform without voiding EQ warranty provisions.
4.0 CONCLUSION
S The review team found that plant personnel at Perry were very open and receptive to the NRC visit, and expressed no reservations in sharing plant practices and experiences. Consequently, the on-site EQ review at Perry was very worthwhile and productive, helping the NRC staff to better understand and appreciate the programs and practices being implemented in order to satisfy EQ requirements, and also highlighting some of the problems and concerns that '
currently exist. The information obtained during the Perry site visit is v3ry useful and will be factored into the staff's generic programmatic review of EQ.
i Enclosure Boiler Plate Letter - Contents !
During the period from December 13 through December 17, 1993, the NRC performed an on-site review of EQ-related information at- the Perry Nuclear Power Plant in support of the staff's task action plan to identify and address existing EQ issues and concerns. The purpose of this review was not to assess compliance with NRC regulations, but rather to gather information that is critical to the staff's ongoing EQ review. Due to the support and cooperation that was afforded by plant personnel at all levels, the time spent by the NRC staff at Perry was very productive and worthwhile. We appreciate very much the time and effort that was spent by your staff in assisting us in this :
effort. The results of the staff's EQ review is enclosed for your )
information. ;
l!
In addition to the standard distribution for Perry, please include the following addressees on the cc list:
George Wu, NUMARC :
1776 Eye St. NW Suite 300 -
Washington DC 20006-3706 William Horin Winston and Strawn, NUGEQ 1400 L Street, NW r Washington DC-20005-3502 Timothy Boss Perry Nuclear Power Plant, W-245 10 Center Rd.
Perry, OH 44081 ,
Hugh Geiston Nuclear Electrical \l&C Florida Power Corporation -
P.O. Box 219 Crystal River, FL 34429 Bob Smith Duke Power Corp. l 422 South Church St.
Charlotte, NC 28201-1006 i
Gary Eldridge !
Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation i 301 Plainfield Rd.
Syracuse, NY 13212 1
i
. y, DISTRIBUTION:
TMurley/FMiraglia MRubin, SPSB WRussell AEl-Bassioni, SPSB AThadani NSaltos, SPSB MVirgilio TSpeis, RES CMcCracken LShao, RES GHubbard JCraig, RES JTatum MVagins, RES CGratton JVora, RES ADummer SAggarwal, RES CRossi, DRIL ASerkis, RES JHopkins, PDIII-2 CAntonescu, RES L01shan, PDIII-l HRathbun, RES PShemanski, PDLR CBerlinger, EELB -
EWeiss, EELB FBurrows, EELB JWermiel, HICB AMarinos, HICB '
HGarg, HICB ,
Docket File SPLB EQ File NRC PDR ,.
' Central Files-Frank Quinn, Scientech Inc.
11821 Parklawn Dr. Suite 100 Rockville MD 20B52 l
1 I
l I
.