ML20058K316

Comments on Correction/Suppl to Comment on Proposed NSHC Determination,Request for Hearing,Notice of Intent to Intervene & Opposition to Issuance of Amend by & on Behalf of Shoreham-Wading River Central School District

ML20058K316
Person / Time
Site:	Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date:	11/29/1990
From:	Mcgranery J DOW, LOHNES & ALBERTSON, SCIENTISTS & ENGINEERS FOR SECURE ENERGY, SHOREHAM-WADING RIVER CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, NY
To:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
References
NUDOCS 9012170136
Download: ML20058K316 (4)

Text

. .

. Il0U l

e 29 #90'!?!la F fgti D . L .d. O ASN I NGTOti- DC : JP A G E '. 001 g.. ,-

' ~ '

• pp #lfg4 SLJ MS

. DOW. LOHNES & ALBERTSON monum u Gw p h igail9o

_ .5 labs TWE NTY-T HIRD 51 R E CT . 3 - 4 WAS HINGTO N. D. C. 2 0037 f e<ilq nemspctper

,etc. om aou m.noa vettcoma non esneoco 1

o. . m."

J AM(B P. ht(C H A N E HY, J H. ~

e- , n. ,-

i November 29,'1990 "  !

l i

TELECOP'Y COVER SHEET {

4 Total number of pages 4 . including cover page, j t

To: . Regulatory Publication Branch i

Agency: U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.  !

ATfN: Betty Golden (Ext. 24268):

Room P 216 l From: James P. hkCiranery,'Jr.

Re: Please see the attached.

Telecopy No.: 301-492 8110 To Confirm:

Client No.: 10342.0001 If you do not receive all of the_ pages, please call (202) 857-2681 as soon as possible.  !

Timnk you.

Sent and Confirmed: Date: -____ Time:

By:

gg217o1369021a9 e <

p ADOCK 000003gy ,

PDR

(

, e * '

h[hUlh-Py

,e t>'

• j ,g.g

[.

O p,, , , .', g , ;

.+ 1-l'

/

h f

T

• ,k,-

~5 i

I,

't.

k t

6 V

k

=

~~-s n

'HQU 29 '90 !? 15 FROM D.L.A. lJAEHlHGTON DC- PAGE.002 ,

(.> .

DEFORE THE UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION t In the Mattor of )-

)

long Island Lighting Company. _

)

Docket No. 50-322, Shoreham Nuclear ) _

Power Station, Unit.l. ) USNRC Docket No.

Suffolk County, New York ) 50-322 (Application to Amend Operating License ) License No. NPF-82 Under Exigent Circumstances to Allow ) ,

Shipment of Reactor Internals to the )  !

Low-Level Radioactivo Waste Disposal )

Ropository at Barnwell, South Carolina) )_

)  !

l CORRECTION OF AND SUPPLEMENT TO COMMENT ON PROX) SED NO SIGNIFICANT HAZARDS CONSIDERATIONS DETERMTNATION, REQUEST'FOR HEARING, NOTICE OF INTENT TO INTERVENE, AND OPPOSITION TO ISSUANCE OF' AMENDMENT' BY AND ON BEHALF OF;

• SHOREHAM-WADING RIVER CENTRAL SCHOOL-' DISTRICT AND i SCTENTTSTgLA.jiD_ENG.IXCJ;BS FOR SECURE ENERGY. TNC S ,

Yosterday, the Shoreham-Wading River Central-School ]

District (" School District") andScientintsandEngincors-qdh Securo Energy, Inc. ("SE2") furninhed,~bycounsel,thereqgsted-comments, a requent for hearing on the proposed amondment $$ior to its issuance, gave notice of their intent to intervene $ any-hearing, and opposed the issuance.of the abovo-captioned $S I amendment. i 1

The School District and SE2 horeby correct the last  !

line of Section 7 of that submittal on page 18 by deleting i

"U.S.C. 5 709" and substituting "U.S.C. 5 706".

Purther, the School District and SE2, recognizing that the Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 is currently a

_ e j)

-4 g....  :

.k, ,,h i hk r,

m gdl; MS #s t>. .

u

.4

. ,,j:,

%ff i

m@g bfh m?.

lG5

A ,

N, ,.

g. 4

>%-;f

' 3 56,n ic

<:f@[l(}C

W

.IIhfy'j!5 iU$

l$I

Yh a

.! U.

gi

{

Mf e

$f w

. ' .I

. il(

r '[is E

ticli 2 9 '90 17: 15 F PO fi D.L.A. WAEH!IMTott I.C FAGE.003 utilization facility licensed under the Atomic Energy Act, and that it will remain such a facility (at ) east until a possesulon-only licenso io issuod and curviven judicial review), state that the chipment of' the 137 fuel nupport bearings and 12 peripheral pieces of the reactor vessel for burial an vanto would constitute intentione.1 and willful destruction of, and/or the causing of phycical damago to, a utilization facility licensed under the Atomic Energy Act in violation of 42 U.S.C. I 2284(a). And such unnecessary disposal at this time, given the ponsibility (regardloon of how remoto the Staff or LlLCO may consider that popolbility) of future operation of Shoreham, would be ca intentional and willful attempt to cause an interruptior r,f normal operation of the facility in furthur violation o't 42 i

U.S.C.  % 2284(b).

Finally, given the statement by LILCO in SNRC-1774 3 (November 16, 1990) that thouc reactor internals are " currently being ctored in boxes on the South separator / Reheater Roof above the turbine deck," thoro is a serious question as to whether L1LCO is in violation of the confirmatory Order of March 29, 1990. That is, there is a question whether the current mode and site of storage constitutes continued maintenance of components nocousary for full power operation consistent with NRC regulations and LILCO'o lico. iso obligations. If NRC investigation reveals the mode and/or site of storage for those  ;

reactor internals is not in accordance with appropriate standards, it would constitute " tampering with the . . .

i 2-  !

c. . . . _ . . . . . . . . _ . _ ,

140V 29 '90 !?: 16 F F C l1 D . L. . A . t&EHINGTOtt DC FAGE.004

, .re W g' F couponents , . . of any such facility" also in violation of' 42 U.S.C. 5 2284(b).

Tho forogoing violations, or imponding violations, of 42 U.S.C. 5 2284 also (a) demonstrato that the current and proposed activities of LILCo with respect those reactor interna 1n cannot be the nubject of a no significant hazards considerations dotermination and (b) form more than an adequate basis for the denial of the license application and enforcement actions purnuant to Appnndix c of Part 2 of the comminnion's Regulationn.

Finally, the School District and SE2 contend that, due to the speed with which irreversible actions can and would be accomplished under the proponod amondmont, the granting of a hearing subcoquent to issuance of the amondment would be a violation of their rights to a hearing under the Atomic Energy  ;

Act, the Adminintrativo Proceduro Act, and the Duo Process Clause of the Constitution.

Respectfully submitted, i i s f November 29, 1990 W + / Ac -

. wh -

J s P. McGranery, J Counsel for the Petitioners l~

Shoreham-Wading River Central School Dictrict and Scientists and Engincors for Secure Energy, Inc.  !

e W -w. . _ -