|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARDCL-99-123, Comment on Prs 10CFR50 & 72 Re Reporting Requirements for Nuclear Power Reactors & Draft NUREG-1022, Event Reporting Guidelines. Util Areas of Concern Includes ESF Actuations, Significantly Degraded Components & Historical Limitations1999-09-20020 September 1999 Comment on Prs 10CFR50 & 72 Re Reporting Requirements for Nuclear Power Reactors & Draft NUREG-1022, Event Reporting Guidelines. Util Areas of Concern Includes ESF Actuations, Significantly Degraded Components & Historical Limitations ML20205N4081999-04-14014 April 1999 Comments Opposing Proposed Rules 10CFR2,19 & 20 Re Proposed Repository at Yucca Mountain.Requests Information on How Much Radiation Being Released Now at Diablo & Hanford NPPs ML20205N4601999-03-21021 March 1999 Introduces K Schumann as Representative of Nuclear Waste Committee (Nuwic) of San Lius Obispo County.Informs That Nuwic & Nuclear Waste Management Committee Concerned with Transportation of Spent Nuclear Fuel Rods from Dcnpp ML20195E8841998-11-24024 November 1998 Petition for Mod to OLs to Require Plant Owner to Have Independent Contractor Evaluate Plant Safety Culture ML20236T3011998-07-24024 July 1998 Order Prohibiting Involvement in NRC Licensed Avtivities (Effective Immediately).Lh Brooks Prohibited for 5 Yrs from Date of Order from Engaging in NRC Licensed Activities ML20248C2261998-05-22022 May 1998 Comment Opposing Revised Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Protection & Safety Sys ML20129J4191996-10-18018 October 1996 Order Approving Application Re Corporate Restructuring of Pacific Gas & Electric Company by Establishment of Holding Company DCL-95-206, Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-61 Re Improving Fire Protection Regulations1995-10-0606 October 1995 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-61 Re Improving Fire Protection Regulations ML20091P8721995-08-23023 August 1995 Comment Opposing Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-61 Re Nuclear Energy Institute Proposed Amends on Fire Safety for All NPPs DCL-95-001, Comment on Proposed Changes to Reactor Pressure Vessel Integrity Rule 10CFR50.Endorses NEI Comments1995-01-0303 January 1995 Comment on Proposed Changes to Reactor Pressure Vessel Integrity Rule 10CFR50.Endorses NEI Comments ML20077M7521994-12-30030 December 1994 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Shutdown & Low Power Operation for Nuclear Power Reactors DCL-94-270, Comment on Proposed Rules 10CFR2,51 & 54 Re Rulemaking for NPP License Renewal.Endorses Comments & Changes Proposed by NEI 941208 Submittal1994-12-0808 December 1994 Comment on Proposed Rules 10CFR2,51 & 54 Re Rulemaking for NPP License Renewal.Endorses Comments & Changes Proposed by NEI 941208 Submittal ML20149H0851994-11-0404 November 1994 Initial Decision (Construction Period Recovery/Recapture).* Renewed Motion to Reopen Record 940808,denied.Served on 941104.W/Certificate of Svc ML20072L2651994-08-23023 August 1994 PG&E Opposition to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Renewed Motion to Reopen Record.* Util Opposes San Luis Obispo for Peace Motion Based on Affidavit Stating No Evidence Found in Motion Re Flaw in Program.W/Certificate of Svc ML20072F0291994-08-12012 August 1994 Erratum to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion to Reopen Record.* Intervenors Corrects Error in Renewed Motion to Reopen Record Re Application for License Amend to Extend Term of Operating License for Plant.W/Certificate of Svc ML20072B2651994-08-0909 August 1994 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re FFD Requirements Concerning Random Drug Testing ML20072A5821994-08-0808 August 1994 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Renewed Motion to Reopen Record Re PG&E Application for Amend to Extend Term of OL for Plant.* Motion to Reopen Record to Introduce Insp Rept Identifying Alleged Problems W/Plant.W/Certificate of Svc ML20071L2061994-07-26026 July 1994 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re Changing Current Drug Testing Policies to Exclude All Personnel in nonsafety-related Positions ML20072B8481994-07-26026 July 1994 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re Changes to FFD Requirements Concerning Random Drug Testing ML20071L1901994-07-20020 July 1994 Comments on Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re Relaxing Rule on Drug Testing of Employees Working at NPP DCL-94-134, Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-60 Re Amend to 10CFR50.54 by Changing Frequency W/Which Each Licensee Conducts Independent Reviews of Emergency Preparedness Program1994-06-27027 June 1994 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-60 Re Amend to 10CFR50.54 by Changing Frequency W/Which Each Licensee Conducts Independent Reviews of Emergency Preparedness Program DCL-94-135, Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-59 Re Proposed Amend to 10CFR50.54(p) Concerning Frequency W/Which Licensee Conducts Independent Reviews of Security Programs1994-06-27027 June 1994 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-59 Re Proposed Amend to 10CFR50.54(p) Concerning Frequency W/Which Licensee Conducts Independent Reviews of Security Programs ML20064D1791994-03-0707 March 1994 Pacific Gas and Electric Co Reply in Opposition to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion to Reopen Record.* Motion to Reopen Record Denied.W/Certificate of Svc ML20064D1961994-03-0404 March 1994 Affidavit of Mj Angus Re Motion to Reopen Record ML20063L5721994-02-25025 February 1994 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Re Util Application for License Amend to Extend Term of Operating License for Plant.* Advises That Record of Proceeding Should Be Reopened to Consider Insp 93-36 Re Util Surveillance of Asw Sys DCL-94-021, Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-21-2 Re Commercial Grade Item Dedication Facilitation1994-01-26026 January 1994 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-21-2 Re Commercial Grade Item Dedication Facilitation ML20059D2431994-01-0707 January 1994 Package of Intervenor Exhibits Consisting of Related Correspondence Not Admitted Into Evidence.Related Correspondence ML20062N0001993-12-30030 December 1993 PG&E Reply Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law.* Mothers for Peace Proposed Findings & Conclusions Do Not Provide Any Supportable Rationale to Change Findings & Conclusions Previously Proposed by Pg&E.W/Certificate of Svc ML20058P3931993-12-22022 December 1993 NRC Staff Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law in Form of Initial Decision.* Certificate of Svc ML20058K7491993-12-0202 December 1993 NRC Staff Motion for Extension of Time.* Board Has Extended Filing Time for Util Until 931230.W/Certificate of Svc. Served on 931206.Granted for Board on 931203 ML20058K8771993-12-0202 December 1993 NRC Staff Motion for Extension of Time.* Requests That Board Extend Date for Staff to File Findings Until 931222. W/Certificate of Svc ML20059M5291993-11-19019 November 1993 Applicant Exhibits A-21,A-22,A-24,A-25,A-26,A-29 & A-F1, Consisting of Related Correspondence Not Admitted Into Evidence.Related Correspondence ML20058E0741993-11-19019 November 1993 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law Re Licensee Application for License Amend to Extend Term of Operating License for Plant.* W/ Certificate of Svc ML20059E8931993-10-28028 October 1993 Memorandum & Order (Motion for Extension of Time).* San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace 931018 Request for two-wk Extension of Time to File Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law Granted.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 931029 ML20059E8531993-10-27027 October 1993 NRC Staff Response to Board Memorandum & Order Re Extension of Time.* Staff Believes That San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Has Shown No Good Cause for Requesting Extension to File Proposed Findings of Fact.W/Certificate of Svc ML20059E8631993-10-25025 October 1993 Pacific Gas & Electric Co Response to Motion for Extension of Time.* Util Does Not Agree W/Board Assessment That Mothers for Peace Request Appears to Be Reasonable But Will Not Oppose Request.W/Certificate of Svc ML20059B2191993-10-19019 October 1993 Memorandum & Order (Responses to Motion for Extension of Time).* Board Believes Intervenor Request for Extension of Time to File Proposed Findings of Fact Appears Reasonable. W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 931019 ML20059B1071993-10-18018 October 1993 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion for Extension of Time for Filing Proposing Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law.* Requests Extension of Two Wks or Until 931119 to File Proposed Findings of Fact.W/Certificate of Svc ML20057D0531993-09-23023 September 1993 Notice of Appearance.* Notice Given That Undersigned Attorney Enters Appearance in Listed Matter & Listed Info Provided.W/Certificate of Svc ML20057B0401993-09-14014 September 1993 NRC Staff Reply to PG&E Response to Staff Motion to Amend Protective Order.* NRC Staff Moves Board to Adopt Language Requested in 930817 Motion as Stated.W/Certificate of Svc ML20056G4891993-08-30030 August 1993 Pacific Gas & Electric Co Response to Motion to Amend Protective Order.* Staff Asks That Protective Order Be Clarified by Adding New Footnote to Paragraph 3 of Order. W/Certificate of Svc ML20059C7361993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-88,consisting of NRC Insp of Diablo Canyon Units 1 & 2 IR 05000275/19920161993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-137,consisting of Insp Rept Re Dockets 50-275/92-16 & 50-323/92-16,dtd 920707 IR 05000275/19930111993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-26,consisting of Re Insp Repts 50-275/93-11 & 50-323/93-11 ML20059M1381993-08-24024 August 1993 Staff Exhibit S-1,consisting of Re 920519 Enforcement Conference IR 05000275/19920131993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-140,consisting of 920416,mgt Meeting Repts 50-275/92-13 & 50-323/92-13 ML20059D0841993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-139,consisting of Insp Rept Re Dockets 50-275 & 50-323,dtd 920417 IR 05000275/19920261993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-118,consisting of Notice of Violation & Insp Rept Re Docket 50-275/92-26 & 50-323/93-26,dtd 921113 ML20059M5041993-08-24024 August 1993 Staff Exhibit S-2,consisting of Re Notice of Violation ML20059M8621993-08-24024 August 1993 Intervenor Exhibit I-MFP-35,consisting of Rept, Self- Evaluation of Diablo Canyon Power Plant, Dtd Jul 1993 1999-09-20
[Table view] Category:PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20195E8841998-11-24024 November 1998 Petition for Mod to OLs to Require Plant Owner to Have Independent Contractor Evaluate Plant Safety Culture ML20072L2651994-08-23023 August 1994 PG&E Opposition to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Renewed Motion to Reopen Record.* Util Opposes San Luis Obispo for Peace Motion Based on Affidavit Stating No Evidence Found in Motion Re Flaw in Program.W/Certificate of Svc ML20072F0291994-08-12012 August 1994 Erratum to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion to Reopen Record.* Intervenors Corrects Error in Renewed Motion to Reopen Record Re Application for License Amend to Extend Term of Operating License for Plant.W/Certificate of Svc ML20072A5821994-08-0808 August 1994 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Renewed Motion to Reopen Record Re PG&E Application for Amend to Extend Term of OL for Plant.* Motion to Reopen Record to Introduce Insp Rept Identifying Alleged Problems W/Plant.W/Certificate of Svc ML20064D1791994-03-0707 March 1994 Pacific Gas and Electric Co Reply in Opposition to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion to Reopen Record.* Motion to Reopen Record Denied.W/Certificate of Svc ML20063L5721994-02-25025 February 1994 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Re Util Application for License Amend to Extend Term of Operating License for Plant.* Advises That Record of Proceeding Should Be Reopened to Consider Insp 93-36 Re Util Surveillance of Asw Sys ML20058K8771993-12-0202 December 1993 NRC Staff Motion for Extension of Time.* Requests That Board Extend Date for Staff to File Findings Until 931222. W/Certificate of Svc ML20058K7491993-12-0202 December 1993 NRC Staff Motion for Extension of Time.* Board Has Extended Filing Time for Util Until 931230.W/Certificate of Svc. Served on 931206.Granted for Board on 931203 ML20059E8531993-10-27027 October 1993 NRC Staff Response to Board Memorandum & Order Re Extension of Time.* Staff Believes That San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Has Shown No Good Cause for Requesting Extension to File Proposed Findings of Fact.W/Certificate of Svc ML20059E8631993-10-25025 October 1993 Pacific Gas & Electric Co Response to Motion for Extension of Time.* Util Does Not Agree W/Board Assessment That Mothers for Peace Request Appears to Be Reasonable But Will Not Oppose Request.W/Certificate of Svc ML20059B1071993-10-18018 October 1993 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion for Extension of Time for Filing Proposing Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law.* Requests Extension of Two Wks or Until 931119 to File Proposed Findings of Fact.W/Certificate of Svc ML20057B0401993-09-14014 September 1993 NRC Staff Reply to PG&E Response to Staff Motion to Amend Protective Order.* NRC Staff Moves Board to Adopt Language Requested in 930817 Motion as Stated.W/Certificate of Svc ML20056G4891993-08-30030 August 1993 Pacific Gas & Electric Co Response to Motion to Amend Protective Order.* Staff Asks That Protective Order Be Clarified by Adding New Footnote to Paragraph 3 of Order. W/Certificate of Svc ML20056E8951993-08-17017 August 1993 Motion to Amend Protective Order (Governing non-disclosure of INPO Rept).* NRC Moves That Board Add Footnote to Paragraph 3.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20056E8021993-08-12012 August 1993 NRC Staff Opposition to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Leave to Conduct Discovery on NRC Inquiry Into Allegations Re Pressure to Falsify Fire Watch Logs Motion for Postponement of Hearing....* W/Certificate of Svc ML20056E7371993-08-12012 August 1993 PG&E Response to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion for Further Discovery & for Delay in Hearing Thermo-Lag Contention.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20046D1091993-08-11011 August 1993 San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Request for Leave to Conduct Discovery on NRC Inquiry Into Allegations Re Pressure to Falsify Fire Watch Logs,Motion for Postponement of Hearing on thermo-lag Contention.* ML20046B9181993-07-22022 July 1993 PG&E Request to Defer Briefing Schedule on Ref Ruling Re INPO Documents.* Board Erred as Matter of Law in Ordering Release of INPO Evaluation & Ref Ruling Should Be Reversed by Commission.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20046B9531993-07-22022 July 1993 Pacific Gas & Electric Co Motion to Require cross-exam Plans.* Requests That Board Require cross-examination Plans from Parties That Intend to Conduct cross-examination. W/Certificate of Svc ML20056C8721993-07-16016 July 1993 Pacific Gas & Electric Co Response to 930701 Motion to Compel.* Concludes That Motion to Compel Moot & Should Be Denied.W/Certificate of Svc ML20045G9691993-07-0202 July 1993 PG&E Response to Licensing Board Questions Re INPO Documents.* ML20045G9561993-07-0101 July 1993 Intervenor San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Motion to Compel PG&E to Respond to Third Set of Supplemental Interrogatories & Requests for Document Production,Filed by San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20045G9431993-07-0101 July 1993 Intervenor San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace (Slomfp) Response to Prehearing Conference Order Re INPO Documents.* Slomfp Cannot Provide Info by Affidavit Due to Lack of Info Re Content of INPO Documents.W/Certificate of Svc ML20045D7341993-06-21021 June 1993 Pge Motion for Schedule Change.* Util Moves That Licensing Board Adopt Listed Revised Schedule.W/Certificate of Svc ML20128P1821993-02-12012 February 1993 PG&E Preliminary Response to Discovery Request Filed Per 10CFR2.741(a)(2) & Motion for Protective Order.* Util Agrees to & Will Support Reasonable Discovery Into Issues within Scope of Contentions Admitted by Aslb.W/Certificate of Svc ML20128D8661993-02-0303 February 1993 Intervenor San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Request to PG&E for Entry Upon Facility,Per 10CFR2.741(a)(2) for Purposes of Insp,Measuring & Photographing.* W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20127D5461992-09-0808 September 1992 NRC Staff Response to San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Ltr Request for Hearing.* Presiding Officer Should Defer Ruling on Standing Pending Receipt of Any Amend Petitioners May File.W/Certificate of Svc & Notice of Appearance ML20006D7721990-02-0808 February 1990 PG&E Response in Opposition to Application for Stay.* Stay of Random Drug Testing Under NRC Fitness for Duty Rule Should Be Denied on Basis of Untimeliness & Challenge Having No Merit.W/Proof of Svc ML20247Q1531989-07-24024 July 1989 Sierra Club Request to Withdraw Contentions.* Requests That All Outstanding Contentions in Current Proceedings Be Withdrawn W/Understanding That Further Discussion Will Occur Between Sierra Club & NRC Re Nepa.W/Certificate of Svc ML20154E4281988-05-11011 May 1988 Motion to Terminate Proceeding.* Requests Termination of Pending Proceedings on Grounds of Mootness.Supporting Documentation & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20148L9531988-03-31031 March 1988 Response to NRC Staff to Petition for Leave to Intervene Filed by San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace.* Notice of Appearance & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20148L9301988-03-29029 March 1988 Answer of PG&E to Petition to Intervene in License Amend Proceedings of San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace.* San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Failed to Satisfy Technical Standing Requirements of 10CFR2.714.W/Certificate of Svc ML20237E5071987-12-15015 December 1987 Motion for Leave to File Response of NRC Staff to Appeal of Sierra Club from ASLB Memorandum & Order of 870902 & Initial Decision of 870911,1 Day Late.* W/Certificate of Svc ML20237E6891987-12-15015 December 1987 Motion for Leave to File Response of NRC Staff to Appeal of Sierra Club from Licensing Board Memorandum & Order of 870902 & Initial Decision of 870911,1 Day Late.* Motion Should Be Granted.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20237E8191987-12-11011 December 1987 Response of NRC Staff to Appeal of Sierra Club from Licensing Board Memorandum & Order of 870902 & Initial Decision of 870911.* Staff Opposes Sierra Club Appeal & Urges That Board Decisions Be Affirmed.W/Certificate of Svc ML20236E0031987-10-21021 October 1987 PG&E Answer in Opposition to Sierra Club Request for Stay.* Util Lists Four Arguments Opposing Request for Stay,Issued by ASLB on 870911,re Util Amends to Increase Spent Fuel Storage Capacity.Affidavit & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236C1831987-10-20020 October 1987 Intervenor Request for Stay.* Sierra Club Requests NRC to Stay Effectiveness of 870902 Order & 870911 Initial Decision of Licensing Board Until Sierra Club Has Had Opportunity to Participate in Proceeding Re Reracking.W/Proof of Svc ML20235T4071987-10-0505 October 1987 Response of NRC Staff to Intervenor Sierra Club Request for Stay.* Sierra Club Failed to Satisfy Requirements of 10CFR2.788 & Request for Stay Should Be Denied.W/Certificate of Svc ML20235R9611987-10-0202 October 1987 PG&E Answer in Opposition to Sierra Club Request for Stay.* Sierra Club 870924 Request for Stay of 870911 ASLB Initial Decision (LBP-87-25) Authorizing Spent Fuel Pool Reracking Amends Should Be Denied ML20235F2951987-09-24024 September 1987 Intevenors Request for Stay.* Seeks Stay of ASLB 870911 Initial Decision Authorizing NRR to Issue OL Amends, Permitting Reracking of Spent Fuel Storage Pools.W/Proof of Svc ML20234D3021987-09-16016 September 1987 Sierra Club Brief in Support of Appeal of ASLB 870902 Order.* Contention Contains Requisite Specificity to Be Admitted to Proceeding.Criteria for late-filed Contention Met.Proof of Svc Encl ML20238A5771987-08-14014 August 1987 Supplemental Brief Re Applicability of ALAB-869 to Inclusion of Zircalloy Cladding Fire Contention.* Sierra Club Believes Focus for Admission of Contentions Must Be Requirements of Atomic Energy Act & Nepa.Proof of Svc Encl ML20238A6521987-08-14014 August 1987 PG&E Supplemental Answer in Opposition to Intervenor Motion to Admit Late Filed Contention.* Sierra Club Motion to Admit Late Filed Contention & Direct Preparation of EIS Should Be Denied.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20238A6001987-08-13013 August 1987 Response of NRC Staff to ASLB Order of 870731 (Directing Parties to File Comments on Applicability of Aslab Decision in Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp,ALAB-869,to Proposed Contentions at Issue in Matter).* Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236B8541987-07-21021 July 1987 Motion on Notification of Meetings,Establishment of Seismic Review Committee & Govt Exam of Design Calculations.* Motion Undated ML20235J1541987-07-10010 July 1987 PG&E Answer in Opposition to Intervenor Motion to Admit late-filed Contention.* Board Requested to Direct NRC Staff to Prepare EIS Re Issues Discussed in Generic Issue 82. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20235J1791987-07-10010 July 1987 NRC Staff Answer to Sierra Club Motion to Admit Contention Re Generic Issue 82 & to Direct Preparation of an Eis.* Denial Urged.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20216J7911987-06-29029 June 1987 Motion to Include Issues Raised in Generic Issue 82 as Contentions in Proceeding & to Direct Preparation of Eis.* Board Requested to Direct Preparation of EIS Re Possibility & Impact of Zircalloy Cladding Fires ML20214A9391987-05-13013 May 1987 NRC Staff Comments on Proposed Order Re Electronic Storage & Retrieval.* ASLB Proposed Order Should Not Be Adopted.If ASLB Agrees,Staff & Parties Could Supply ASLB w/MS-DOS Disks of Prefiled Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20207P7081987-01-15015 January 1987 NRC Staff Answer in Opposition to Sierra Club/Mothers for Peace Motion for Summary Disposition.* Motion Devoid of Any Factual Support Which Warrants Granting of Summary Disposition Re Environ Claims.W/Certificate of Svc 1998-11-24
[Table view] |
Text
. Mz t l August 12,1993 I ~
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COhD4ISSION
'93 IG 16 T. '/ 2 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
) Docket Nos. 50-275 OLA-2 PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC CO. ) 50-323 OLA-2
)
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, ) (Construction Period Recovery)
Units 1 & 2) ) -
NRC STAFF'S OPPOSITION TO SAN LUIS OBISPO MOTHERS FOR PEACE LEAVE TO CONDUCT DISCOVERY ON NRC INQUIRY INTO ALLEGATIONS REGARDING PRESSURE TO FALSIFY FIRE WATCH LOGS, MOTION FOR POSTPONEMENT OF HEARING ON THERMO-LAG CONTENTION PENDING COh&LETION OF SAID DISCOVERY. AND REOUEST FOR EXPEDITED CONSIDERATION On August 11, 1993, San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace (SLOMFP), filed the above Motion for " Leave to Conduct Discovery on NRC Inquiry Into Allegations" and for a postponement of the hearing on the Thermo-Lag contention until that discovery is completed.' The Staff opposes this Motion.
DISCUSSION The NRC Staff opposes the Motion principally on the ground that SLOMFP is seeking to change this proceeding, which involves whether the periods spent in construction should be recaptured into the operating license terms, into an investigation 2 Notice of the allegation and the Staff's inquiry into this matter was given to the Licensing Board and the SLOMFP on July 15, 1993. SLOMFP waited until August 11, l 1993, on the eve of the August 17,1993, hearing to file this motion, and gives no reason l why it did not take this action in July. The fact that SLOMFP's attorney did not learn of this matter until she returned from vacation is no excuse for this delay.
9308250185 930812 5 l PDR ADOCK 0500 c
l 99
(
V of how the Staff conducted an inquiry into an anonymous allegation that pressure was put on an engineer to falsify fire watch records.' The contention for which postponement of the hearing is sought challenges the adequacy of the licensee's interim measures, principally fire watches, to compensate for Thermo-12g fire protection features declared inoperable. LBP-93-1, 37 NRC 5,26-28 (1993).
The licensee has offered as its witnesses on this contention David K. Cosgrove, whom it identifies as the Supervisor of the Safety and Fire Protection Group at Diablo Canyon, and Robert P. Powers, who was Manager of the Support Services Department at Diablo Canyon. The prefiled testimony of these witnesses explicates how fire watch activities at Diablo Canyon are documented:
The reving watch carries a portable electronic "bar code" reader wand I
(similar to those in use at retail markets) which scans bar codes installed in the fire areas along the tour route. At the end of the shift, the hand 1 wand (about the size of a personal calculator) is down-loaded to a personal computer and a printout of the watch activities is generated that documents the watchstander's name, badge number, the location of each area and the time the watch was in the area. The program also utihzes a results code, )
so that any special conditions identified during the hourly inspection can also be documented. The log of the watch activities is maintained on a computer disk and in hardcopy form for one year by the Fire Protection Specialist.
The continuous firewatch records are maintained by hand and consist of a logsheet that describes the location of the continuous watch to record the watchstander's name and time once each hour.
2 The allegation indicates that the engineer refused to falsify the record, and does not state that the records were falsified. For a discussion of the Staff's duty to evaluate the allegations before notifying a Board, see " Statement of Policy: Handling of Late Allegations," 50 Fed. Reg. I1,030,11,032 (July 19,1985), quoted in n.5 below.
,r
! l l
. l 1
l V j j Testimony of Pacific Gas & Electric Company Contention V: Thermo-Lag j I
l l i Compensatory Measures (filed August 2,1993), at 11. SLOMFP can fully inquire into l
any question of whether these electronically recorded bar code fire watch logs are accurate, whether any were falsified, and the ease or difficulty of falsifying them, by i
l directly examining those responsible for the fire watches and the fire watch records. To l l
l maintain that discovery should be had into how the Staff conducted an inquiry into the anonymous allegation would misdirect the hearing from examining the question of whether fire watches were properly conducted into the non-germane issue of whether the l Staffs inquiry into the anonymous allegation was sufficient.'
Although SLOMFP states that it "is entitled to a hearing on all matters that are j material to the license recapture," Motion at 4, there is no showing that the adequacy of l l
the Staff's inquiry is material to that issue, or that the material issue of the adequacy of l
fire watches cannot be examined in hearing.'
l 3
SLOMFP's attempt to redirect this proceeding to an investigation of the Staff is highlighted at 5-6 of Motion, where SLOMFP indicates it is mainly interested in how the i Staff conducted its inquiry rather than the accuracy of the records. Substantial questions l exist of whether SLOMFP may have discovery of the Staff on the conduct ofits inquiry.
As SLOMFP recognizes, Motion at 6, discovery against the Staff is governed by i 2.720(h). Under that provision, discovery against the Staff may only be had when
'necessary for a proper decision in the proceeding." The issue herein is not the Staff's inquiry, but the adequacy of the licensee's fire watches. Thus, discovery on the adequacy of the Staff's inquiry could not be had.
' The issue of pressure on Diablo Canyon employees absent changes in the logs, Motion at 5, is not the subject of a contention, and is not germane.
/
o
Y In sum, SLOMFP shows no reason to substitute discovery into how the Staff inquired into an anonymous allegation that an attempt was made to falsify records for a direct inquiry at hearing as to whether the records were falsified 5 5
SLOMFP claims that the Staff did not fulfill a duty to report the matter before the Staff " completed its evaluation" (Motion at 4), claims that inquiry into this matter is necessary "to remedy the NRC Staff's wrongful withholding of material information from the Board and the panies," (Motion at 6), and states that delay in completing this proceeding "will be far outweighed by the public interest in correcting the Staff's violation of well-established agency policy." Motion at 6-7. These statements are unsupported. Upon receipt of an anonymous and unsupported allegation that pressure was applied to change records, the Staff rightfully inquired into whether there was support for this statement before acquainting the Board and the parties (weeks in advance of hearing) with the fact that such an anonymous letter was received and upon inquiry was shown to be without basis. The Commission's " Statement of Policy: Handling of l2te Allegations," 50 Fed. Reg. 11,030,11,032 (March 19,1985), provides:
[I]n the future, staff board notifications of allegations will not be made until the staff has made at least an initial screening of the allegations.
Only those allegations which are found not to be frivolous, which are relevant and material to the decisionmaking process (as determined under existing board notification procedures) and which are determined to warrant further scrutiny will be submitted to the presiding tribunal. Board notifications should still be made promptly, consistent with the need and time required for screening.
Thus, although the Staff, perhaps, was not required by Commission policy to make the subject Board notification because it was not " determined to warrant further scrutiny,"
no harm was done by the Staff's notifying the Board and the panies that it looked into the matter to see if further scrutiny was required.
r
i i I
!9 l- '
l CONCLUSION i
For the above stated reasons, the subject Motion should be denied. ;
Respectfully submitted,
&M Edwin J. 's Deputy Assistart General Counsel for Reactor Ucensing Dated at Rockville, Maryland i this 12th day of August 1993 i !
! f r
l l
l l
I i
i I
I .
UNITED STATES OF AhERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION .g g. g BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD -
l r
l In the Matter of )
I
)
PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-275 OLA-2
) 50-323 OLA-2 ;
)
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, ) (Constructed Period Recovery) j Units 1 and 2) ) ;
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of "NRC STAFF'S OPPOSITION TO SAN LUIS OBISPO MOTHERS FOR PEACE LEAVE TO CONDUCT DISCOVERY ON NRC INQUIRY INTO ALLEG ATIONS REGARDING PRESSURE TO FALSIFY FIRE WATCH LOGS, MOTION FOR POSTPONEMENT OF HEARING ON THERMO-LAG CONTENTION '
PENDING COMPLETION OF SAID DISCOVERY, AND REQUEST FOR '
EXPEDITED CONSIDERATION" in the above captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class or, as indicated by an :
asterisk, by deposit in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's internal mail system, this l 13th day of August 1993 and, also, as indicated by a double asterisk, by facsimile on the j 12th day of August 1993:
" Charles Bechhoefer* Frederick J. Shon* l Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board ;
Mail Stop: EW-439 Mail Stop: EW-439 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission !
Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 )
Jerry R. Kline* Office of Commission Appellate '
Administrative Judge Adjudication
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Mail Stop: 16-G-15 OWFN' Mail Stop: EW-439 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 l Washington, DC 20555 l
l l
/
I
i a
Adjudicatory File * (2) Office of the Secretary * (2) l Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Attn: Docketing and Service l Panel Mail Stop: 16-G-15 OWFN j Mail Stop: EW-439 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ;
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 'l Washington, DC 20555 !
- Joseph B. Knotts, Jr., Esq. i Atomic Safety and Licensing Board ** David A. Repka, Esq. !
Panel
- Kathryn M. Kalowsky, Esq.
Mail Stop: EW-439 Winston & Strawn U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1400 L Street, N.W. l Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20005-3502 l 3
Nancy Culver, President Truman Burns l San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace Robert Kinosian !
l P.O. Box 164 California Public Utilities Commission l l Pismo Beach, CA 93448 505 Van Ness, Room 4103 [
San Francisco, CA 94102 l
" Christopher J. Warner i Richard F. Locke ** Diane Curran l Pacific Gas & Electric Co. IEER !
77 Beale Street 6935 I2urel Avenue, Suite 204 :
l San Francisco, CA 94106 Takoma Park, MD 20912 l l :
Greg Minor i MHB Technical Assoc. !
1723 Hamilton Avenue, Suite K !
San Jose, CA 95125 i i
't l Edwin . Reis l Dep Assistant General Counsel for Reactor Licensing l
t r
)
r - , .- - _ . - . , . . . . . . - _ _ , - . .- --.. ._ ,.-,..-_..m..-