ML20056E528

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Notation Vote W/Comments Approving in Part & Disapproving in part,SECY-93-087, Policy,Technical & Licensing Issues Pertaining to Evolutionary & Advanced Light-Water Reactor Designs
ML20056E528
Person / Time
Issue date: 07/14/1993
From: Selin I, The Chairman
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To: Chilk S
NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
References
NUDOCS 9308240194
Download: ML20056E528 (2)


Text

.~

,,e..ll...e............

1

^'

NOTATION VOTE!

.j[/i[f3 _ _._GbI RESPONSE SHEET

'a eb l

T0:

SAMUEL J. CHILK, SECRETARY OF THE COMMISSION FROM:

THE CHAIRMAN

SUBJECT:

SECY-93-087 - POLICY, TECHNICAL, AND LICENSING ISSUES PERTAINING TO EVOLUTIONARY-AND ADVANCED LIGHT-WATER REACTOR (ALWR) i DESIGNS APPROVED x (in part) DISAPPROVED x (in part) ABSTAIN I

NOT PARTICIPATING REQUEST DISCUSSION C0!41ENTS:

See comments attached.

i I

I l

j SIGNATURE I

RELEASE VOTE

///

July 14, 1993 DATE WITHHOLD VOTE

/

/

NO

ENTERED.ON "AS" YES i

,,-ww,,w w ea PDR COMMS NRCC 1

' CORRESPONDENCE PDR

i i

i THE CHAIRMAN'S COMMENTS ON SECY-93-087 I approve the staff's positions on I.E.

Fire Protection, I.F.

Intersystem Loss-of-Coolant Accident, I.G. Hydrogen Control, I.H.

Core Debris Coolability, I.I. High-Pressure Core Melt Ejection, I.J.

Containment Performance, I.K. Dedicated Containment Vent Penetration, I.L.

Equipment Survivability, I.M.

Elimination of r

Operating-Basis Earthquake, I.N.

Inservice Testing of Pumps and Valves, II.A. Industry Codes and Standards, II.D. Leak-Before,-

Break, II.E. Classification of Main Steamlines in Boiling Water Reactors, II.F. Tornado Design Basis, II.H. Containment Leak Rate Testing, II.R. Steam Generator Tube Ruptures, II.T. Control Room Annunciator (Alarm) Reliability, III. H. Role of the Passive Plant Control Room Operator.

I approve the staff's position on II.I. Post-Accident Sampling System, as clarified by Commissioner Remick's vote.

I approve the staff's position on II.N. Site-Specific l

Probabilistic Risk Assessments and Analysis of External Events, as modified by Commissioner Remick's vote.

I approve with the staff's position on II.Q. Defense Against Common-Mode Failures in Digital Instrumentation and Control Systems, as modified by Commissioners Remick and de Planque.

I also agree with Commissioner Remick's suggestion that the staff and industry representatives meet to ensure a common understanding of the requirements.

i i

l 1

I

.