ML20056B059
| ML20056B059 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 08/08/1990 |
| From: | Philips J NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Bradley Jones AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD (FORMERLY AKIN |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20055C265 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-90-333 NUDOCS 9008140069 | |
| Download: ML20056B059 (7) | |
Text
b
,,g.a.eg m---w.www.. ~
~.~m 7] Mf('$,.FOIA
_g3p yl s,-
t,-
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF
_P'm I **=
INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST
" ^ "
\\'a' AUG-8199p m. t t,,-i.,,._ e.e, at fW4 6t& A Bradley W. Jones PART 1.- AGENCY RECORDS Rett ASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checAed benes)
No agency records subrect to the esquest have teen located.
No addstional egency records subiect to the request have been located.
Reowested reco<ds are avadable throwgh another public dest'ibution prog'am See Comments $ection.
X Agency socords subiect to the esquest that die ident.f.ed ori Appendialest__A a,e si,ead, e,sa.bie to, pobhc ripect n and ceoving m ise NRC Pubisc Document Room 7170 L St>eet. N W~ Washington. DC 20$55 Agency 'eco'es svtsect to the eeq est it,at s'e ideatified on Append ules)-
U are bemo made avadable for pubhc mtpection and copying e' the NHC PubLc Document hoom, 2120 L Stieet, N W., Wa Angton. DC, e a folder undee this FOIA number and roovester name The nospeoprietary version of the peoposalisi that you opeed to accept m a telephone conversation with a member of my staff is now bemo rnade ave'able fos public inspection and copying at the NRC Public Document Room 2120 L Street. N W. Washmgton. DC. m a folder unde. this FOIA numbee and reovestes name Agency reco<c;s sub ect to the reovest that are edent fied on Arpend tiest
. may be inspected and cop ed at the NRC 4 ocal Public Document Room edentif.ed i
in the Commerts Secteon.
Enclosed is mformation on how you may obtain access to and the cha'ges foe copymg records placed m the NRC Pubsec Document Aoom. 2120 t Street NW.
wash.ngton. DC y Agency,eco,ds subte:i io ihe,eavest a,e encioned [ App. A, B, and releasable portion; of App. C docs are enclosed]
- n. cords sub.ci to the eavest have been refe. ed io anothe, rede,ai agencytesi fo, ievie and di,aci,esponse io you i
You wilt tw bIled by the NRC foi fees totalmg 8 in view of NRC 4,eiponse to this eav-. so fu th., acison is being ta6en o appesi ieite, daied No PART ft, A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC Ot$ CLOSURE Certain r/oemet.on m the reovested records is be,ng wit %eid from pubhc d sclosure puesvant to the esemptions desce bed e and to, t*e seasons stated m Pari ei.
s<:stions 6 c. and D Arv released portions of the docu 'ents for ahich oniv pa'i of the eeco<d 's bems withheid a'e being maoe asa lab.e fo< pubhc inspect.on end X
n copyirig m the NRC Pwbhc Document Room. 2120 L Street, N W, Washington. DC. m a folde' unde' this FOI A n mtne' and reQvester name w
COMMENis S
TU OtR CTOR nN OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PUBliC ATIONS SERVICES
/
b-V
~
4
\\
9000140069 900800 PDR FOIA JONES90-333 PDR s-
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION 'ACT RESPONSE FOiA wuustRsw F OlA
'90-333 DATE: [h@.p g
=c PART H B-APPLICABLE EXEMPTIONE
~
':s Recot ; subject tithe ' request that are described on the enclosed Appendants) _C an being withheld sn their enttr;ty or in part undet the
. (semptions and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to B U S.C 66?M and 10 CF R 9.17(a) of NRC Regulations.
1[ The withheld mformatton is property classified pursuant to Executrve Order IEXEMPT40N It i
2', The withheld minrmaten relates solely to the internal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. IEXEMPTION 2) 3 c The withheid mformaten as specifically exempted from public disclosure by statute mdicated IEXEMPTION 3) of the Atomic Energy Act which prohibits the disclosu e of Rettncted Data os Formerly Restncted Data 142 U S C 21612165L Sect *ons 141 145 r
Secten 147 of the Atormc Energy Act which prohibits the disclosure of Unclassified Safeguards Information 142 U S C. 2167) 4i The withheld informaton is a trade secret or commercial or fmancial mformaten that is being withheld for the reasonis) todicated; (EXEMPTION di The srdarenation 6s considered to be confide'ntial business (propnetary) information.
- ~, ~,
The informatrun is considered to be propnetary mformaten pursuant to 10 CFR 2.700tdH11 1
The informaten was submitted and received in conf dence pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790idH21.
i 5 The withheld mformation consists of interagency or rtraegency records that are not %eilable theciugh discovery 4MPilON 51 Apphcatae Pnvilege
' Deliberative Process: Disclosure of predecisional mformation would tend to inhibit the open and frank e ential to the delier"ative process e
ie _
Where records are withbeid in their entirety, the f acts are mentocably maertwir ed with the predecisional m, aster.nore a.su
' rio reasonably segregable f actual portions because the release of the f acts would permit an indirect mquiry mio the predectstonal process or the agency Attorney work product privilege (Documents prepared by an attomey in contemplation of litigation i Attorney -client privilege IConhdential communications between an attorney and his her cleent i
- 6. The withheld mformatron is esempted frorr pubhc disclosure because its disclosure would result m a clearty 6 arranted mvasion of personal pnvecv. IEXEMP",4N 61 -
7, The withbeid information consists of records compiled for law enforcement purposes and is being withheld for the reasontal it.dicated, IEXEMPTION 71
.i Disclosure could esasonably be espected to interfere with an enforcement proceeding because it could reveal the scope directiort and focus of en-forcement efforts and thus could poss.bly allow them to tak e action to wheeld potential wrongdoing o a violation of NRC requirements from mvestigators E kEMPTION 7 (An Disclosure would constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal pnvecy (EXEMPTION 7tCil X
The mformatron consists of names of mdividuais and other mformation the disclosu e of which could reasonabit be enoected to reveal identities of r
conhdental sources IE XEMPilON 71011 Other
~
l PART H. C-DENYING OFFICtALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 251bt and or 9 25 wi of the U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission regulations. it has been determmed that the ir formation withheld is esempt from production or disclosure. and that its production or desdosure is contrary to the public interest The persons responsible for the rienial are those of ficia!s identified -
3 below as denying of f cials and the Directors Division of Freedom of Information and Publications Services. Of fice of Administration and Resources Management, for any denids that may be appepled to the Executeve hrector for Operations itDOi r
DENYING OFFICIAL YlTLE'OF FICE RECORDS DEN!ED APPELLATE OFFICIAL SECRETARY EDO Ron R, Hayes-niroctnt Of fice of. Investigatinns App. C X
\\
')
1 PART H. D-APPEAL RIGHTS The derval by each denying officialidentihed in Part il C may be appealed te the Appellate Officialidentified in that section. Any such appeal must be m wnting and must be made within 3O days of receipt of this response. Appeals must be addressed as appropnate to the Executive Director for Operations or to the Secretary of the Comrmss on, U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commiss on, Washington. DC 20555. and should clearly state on the envelope and m the letter that it is an " Apoeai from an Initial FOIA Decision?
Mc Fonu ae4 cart a U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i"
FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION
I)\\ 4 7c-b i
1 A
[
Re FOIA-90-333 i:
APPE"ulX A g
DOCUMENTS ALREADY AVAILABLE IN idE PDR
\\
NUMESR DATE DESCRIPTION L
1.
4/14/89 Exhibit 4 to 01 Rpt..Ncn 1-89-006: Inspection E
yz Report No. 030-07022/89-001.
(10 pages)
PDR Accession No. 8905010045.
5f 2.
4/17/89 Exhibit 6 to OI Rpt. No. 1-89-006:
Letter b
from Malcolm Knapp to John Scandalios E
regarding, Inspection No. 030-07022/89-001.
E (2 pgs)
PDR Acc. No. 8905010040.-
p
[
.3.
8/16/89 Exhibit 7 to 01 Rpt. No. 1-89-006:
g Enforcement Conference Report No. 030-07022/89-002.
(8 pgs)
PDR Acc. No.
E 8909080072.
a K-
=
=
M K
M
=
~
.i i
Re FOIA-90-333 APPENDIX B DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN THE PDR~
.i NUMBER DATE-DESCRIPTION 1..
~7/24/89 Exhibit 2 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Amendment No.
26 of License number 29-13613-02.
(6 pgs) 2.
12/12/88 Exhibit 3 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Letter from John Rucaen to John White, enclosing application for an amendment to license 29-13613-02.
(3 pgs) 3.
2/14/89 Exhibit 8 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Letter from.
Paul Shapiro to John Russen, regarding I
Radiation Safety Audit.
(2 pgs) 4.
5/15/89 Exhibit 9 to OI.Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with Marlene J.
Taylor.
(3 pgs) 5..
4/11/89 Exhibit 10 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Handwritten notes-RTI Operator's' Log Entry.
(1 page) 6.
5/15/89 Exh1 bit 11 to OI Rpt.- 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with Malcolm R.
Knapp.
(16 pgs)
(NOTE:
The portions deleted are outside the scope of the request.)
- 7..
5/18/89 Exhibit 12 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with Daniel J.
Holody.
(2 pgs) 8.
5/5/89 Exhibit 13 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Examination-of RTI Records by Ernest Wilson, with attachment.
(2 pgs) 9.
5/5/89 Exhibit 14 to 0I Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Gnntact with John Singleton.
(1 page) 10.
7/8/80 Exhibit 17 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Kolakowski's word processor disk directory.
(1 page) 11.
6/1/89 Exhib-it 18 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with Brad Taylor.
(2 pages) 12.
Und-ated Exhibit 19 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
US Postal Service Return Receipt card from RTI, Inc.
(2 pgs)
,?.
L i
i i<
s n
Ret FOIA-90-333 APPENDIX-B DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN THE PDR (Continued)
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION
+ _.
13.
~2/13/89 Exhibit 24 to 01 Rpt. 1-89-006:
RTI Operator's log entry.
(1 page)
Oh 14.
6/22/89 Exhibit 28 to 01 Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of-
-Investigative Observations.
(2 pgs)
- 15.
Various' Exhibit 30 to OI Rpt.- 1-89-006:
R?I log entries.
(2 pgs) 16.
6/12/89 Exhibit 31 to 01 Rpt. 1-89-006:
Memo from-John Singletun to John Russen.
(1 page) w 17.
4/17/89 Exhibit 35 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Memo from John Russen to John Scandalios.
(2 pgs)
- 10,.
5/1/89 Exhibit 36 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Memo from John Russen to John Scandalios.
(1 page) f 19.
4/24/89 Exhibit 37 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Memo to All Operators from John Russen.
-(l'page) 20.
7/7/89
' Exhibit 39 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with Anastase Varaklis.
(7 pages) 21.
4/24/89 Exhibit 40 of OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Handwritten notes of Varaklis.
(7 pages) 22.
Undated Exhibit 44 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Telecopy.
cover letter, transmitting 5/5/89 memo from Robert Riley to Roy Lessy.
(12 pgs) 23.
4/17/89 Exhibit 2 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006S Memo from 1,,
John-Russen to John Scandalios.
(2 pge) 24.
4/24/89 Exhibit 3 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006S:
Memo from John Russen to All Operators. (1 page)
'l m
i
+
1 Ret FOIA-90-333 i
i
'I APPENDIX C j
DOCUMENTS BEING RELEASED IN PART NUMBER-DATE DESCRIPTION 1.
4/11/89 Exhibit 5 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Memorandum of Interview with individual.'
(4 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant.to Exemptions 6 ana 7(C).
2.
7/7/89 Exhibit 16 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with individual.e
-(5 pgs). Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
3.
6/8/89 Exhibit 20 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with individual.
(8 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
4.
6/1/89 Exhibit 21 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview with individual.
(6 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
l~
5.
6/1/89 Exhibit 22 t-al Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of Interview w/-
individual.
(5-pgs)
Portions withheld pu.
Jant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
p 6.
6/8/89 Exhibit 23 to OI_Rpt. 1-89-006:
ReportHof Interview with individual.
(7 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
7.
6/1/89 Exhibit 25 to OI'Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of H
Interview with indi'tidual.
(2 pgs) Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
8.
6/9/89 Exhibit 26 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of t
L Interview with individual.
(2 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
9.
6/21/89 Exhibit 27 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006. Report of Interview with individual.
(2 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
i r.
m -
9
[ !!(f ELLab Lc
. l6 i
W-l.;b i
Odkhb nw
,]UN,j m.
!?
- $eC ;-
v th, e
' JNR Re:
FOIA-99-333 mb, p Y@;, q APPENDIX C 4
fE gjf t.
DOCUMENTS BEING-RELEASED IN PART (Continued)
- Z-l/]
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION t
a L
I 1 w i
, mi
'10.
6/21/89 Exhibit 29 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Transcript L.[
of Investigative Interview with individual.
VD (59-pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to l
Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
.m 11.
C/21/89 Exhibit 32 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Transcript i
of Investigative Interview of individual.
(33 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and-7(C).
o o f
12.
6/21/89 Exhibit 33=to 01 Rpt. 1-89-206:
Transcrirt MW of. Investigative Interview with individual.
(32 pgs),
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
13, 6/22/89 Exhibit 34Lto,01 Rpt. '1-89-006:
Transcript of Investigative Interview with individual.
(110 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Euemptions 6'and 7(C).
j 14.
6/22/89' Exhibit 41 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Transcript i
of Investigative Interview with individual.
(15.pgs)
Portions' withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
,o
'I 15.-
7/7/89 Exhibit 42 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006:
Report of contact with individual.
(2 pgs)
Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and 7(C).
16.
2/7/90 Exhibit 4 to OI Rpt. 1-89-006S:
Report of h[a Interview with individual.
(10 pgs)
" " W' Portions withheld pursuant to Exemptions 6 and~7(C).
b y:
ki:l N
U
?
i
}
'b^
f