ML20054H558

Requests Clarification of ASLB 820601 Special Prehearing Conference Order Admitting Large Number of Contentions W/ Direction for Future Spec.Board Should Set Time Limits & Should Outline Procedure for Spec.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20054H558
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	06/17/1982
From:	Dorsey J DORSEY, J.A., LIMERICK ECOLOGY ACTION, INC.
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8206240198
Download: ML20054H558 (5)

Text

-_

. . 6 L

, , .-.t ,.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA -

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION [

- + <v p j :77 g

'~ " "

BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING EOARD g c

E.

E In the Matter of  : .

PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY Docket Nos. 50-352 50-353

[

Limerick Generating Station,  : 3 1

Units 1 and 2  :

1 5

Y REQUEST OF LIMERICK ECOLOGY ACTION FOR CLARIFICATION OF SPECIAL PREHEARING CONFERENCE ORDER r 1

The Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (hereinafter _

" Board") for the Limerick plants, in its Special Prehearing Conference Order (hereinafter " Order") of June i, 1962,  ;

" conditionally" admitted a large number of Limerick Ecology i Action's (hereinaf ter " LEA") ' contentions , as well as those of other intervenors, with the direction that those contentions are  ;

i to be "made specific at the appropriate future time to be estab-  !

lished based on the information later supplied by the Applicant."

See Order, pp. 101-2. Intervenors are put on notice that failure to do so, or to explain why a contention cannot be further specified will result in automatic dismissal of the contention.

LEA requests that this aspect of the Board's Order be ,

clarified. j i'

First, LEA assumes that in its wording, "at the appropriate 8206240198 820617 PDR ADOCK 05000352 Q PDR e)h bb 'O3

- I 2.

=

L future time to be established" (Order at p. 102), the Board intends to set time limits for such specification so that intervenors will not inadvertently fail'to specify in a timely fashion. It is hoped that such time limits will be made clear in the near future, since the need to so specify could arise

- at any time as the Applicant continues to amend its application. l Is it the Board's intention that such specification in response ,

to new information will not begin until after informal discovery is completed September 30? ,

Second, LEA requests that the Board specify a procedure for the Applicant to follow in furnishing information responsive to conditionally admitted contentions. Particularly, LEA requests j 4

that the Applicant be required to state the point at which it has supplied all the information it intends to supply (as application amendments) concerning the subject matter of a particular con-tention. Such a procedure will avoid the confusion and excess

' paperwork of preparing and responding to prematurely filed new contentions.

Also, particularly for those intervenors with a limited number of contentions covering narrow subject matter (and generally without legal counsel) , it would be most helpful if the

! Applicant were to give notification that particular application  ;

amendments contain information relevant to particular contentions.  !

Very large quantities of information are being submitted by the Applicant as amendments to the application with increasing i

frequency. It is LEA's hope that intervenors, especially those l without counsel, will not be expected to engage in hunting expedi-

i

, 3.

tions through stacks-of material irrelevant to their contentions in order to avoid the risk of having their contentions d.s::issed for failure to specify.

LEA respectfully asks consideration of its requests.

1 Respectfully submitted,  !

Jp ITH A. DORSEY 1315 Walnut S t. , suite 1632 (.

Phila., PA 19107 i (215) 735-7200 g CHARLES W. ELLIOTT ."

123 North Fif th St. g Allentown, PA 18102  :

(215) 821-8100 j Counsel for Limerick Ecology Action 1

i 1

1-j 2

f i

5

L.

.. .e-CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE "f'- = E

- ' - e.

.ONY i 8

e. ,( c; u' l 3

• I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Req'Oesbn 22 2 i e

u of Limerick Ecology Action'for Clarification of Special . Prehearing . .

Ir

, ,1

p a ?. - _.

Conference Order have been served, by deposit in the U.S [ mail, I.

=

t.,

first-class postage prepaid, upon the following: E e

w I

t>

L T

b F

1.

L a

i Lawrence 3:enner, Chai =an A0mic Safety andlicensing 3 card '

.ga 4 .._43_. u dc,e .oa.a.a_ _' .

.,._.4v. .

U.S. NRC U.S. NRC Mashing:en, CC 2:555 i I

Washington, CC 20555 Atomic and Safety and L:. censing ~

C.. ' -

.._d."..=_-d -  :. . C o .t. a . .4 vc. e .= 1 ' =..a_ _1 ._

a a- 4 .._4a_____

.s _ , , _ 4 ye o n,.ec,e g.3. 3. :. .c. ~

U.S. NRC ' dashing:cn, CC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Dcchering and 5 err ~.ce 5ec:izn e -

.o_ .c.er_ _, f n.. O..__._. .g . . 4. - ._ _43

. .. c e_ e_ _4 c. _ - __

i Administrative Judc.e U.S. Nr.C -

C.5. NRC 'ias hington , CC 20535  :

a

..aswing: n, .,C

. 20:.22.

?.cber: Adier, Esc.  ;

~

Stechen .. Lewis, Esq. Cc==ctweal .; of PA, CER office of Executive agai 505 Executive Ecuse Direc: : PO Scx 2357 ' -

C . .C. . 7..C

.< ... =.. _ d_. a'." _ -, 3. .'s . 'i - ' O c 57 ash ngton , DC 20535 [

anen. :.s c .

na_3 ce:

u'.., 7- ^ #._.' d. ~ =. ~ '. .A . -. . e v, e " e..a _- = _i

.' . v. 2. C .- .. . . _a_ , _a. .

u...,..__ _..d .w.e _ . _ a. .,..s . .

C .e. .:_4 -- ._- . ., e C n s., - e _,..s , c..~ c.,_.

'.7 4 7 Pennsylvania Ave . , N?T 14 25 5 trawcerry Sq .

v.. a.. _ _d a .' . t._- ., , 3. .:. '"

_ a '_'_ O

'.i a s "s' .~. c. ..... , FC '0006 O. b. . 4. .i. .s . r.i.se.. J_

. . . P. . .

• =c

.s . .m. . .

r.a .w.a . e. a. -

sa ,_. ._ , s W and Generai Counsei .

. g i.

.t. .,.._. .'g_.s __ _ .

1 O. b.. 4.1. 3 . , 0.. *O*9_

., 7. 1 1

i l

_ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - __ _. J

r Di. rec:cr Thc=as Gensky, Director PIMA 3RP, CZ2 Basement, Transportatien Fule.== 3ar_i 31dg , 5th fl and 5adety 31dg.

• Thi.. d and *.ccus Sts.

Earrisburg, PA 17120 Ear-isburg, PA 17120 ij

=

2 Rober An henv .

303

. vernen .ane, u Box 136 W. Wilson Goode Mevlan, PA 19065 Mana.ging Di. ector City of Philadelphia

n. c n _:.2 2._. ....s _. e _4 ,. , .r.s c . Phila.delphia, PA 19137 1425 ~4ainu 5:., 3rd'f1 l Phila. , PA 19102 Jcse:h ~4hite , ~2: S Steven Hershey, Esc..

11 S. Meri:n Ave.

3 v. . "awr, PA 19010 f

. 9 Sylvania Ectse  !

Jcnicer and Lecus: Sts.  ?

3. .. _4 _3 ., . , ., A _3330

. . i Robers. :>ugirman , Esq.

Sugarman h Denwort.a -

n.

s . .* Ca s .,.. a Cn .s ...C

. Sui e 513 4

• 3, o.i...Cc .4v.. -

North American Bldg. .

State C:l'.ege, PA 16301 121 S. Brotd St. I Phlia. , PA 19107 .

Marrin *awis -

6504 3:2ddcrd Terrace

? hila., ?A 19149 -

Jar.es M. Neill, Esc. t 3cx 511 Oublin , PA 19 917 Alan J. Nogee Keyst ne Alliance 3700 Ches nu 5:.

Phila., ?A 19104 i

Frank R. Romano 61 Forest Ave.

Ambler, PA 19002

• e i:i

=

w

• 2 N

June 17, 1982 ,

/

m =d a . xi.s i

( r

?

_ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I