Response to ASLB 820604 Order Re Release of Photographs. Proposes Alternative to Order Wherein Univ Would Retake Photographs Excluding Objectionable Physical Security Sys Features.Certificate of Svc EnclML20054F319 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
05000142 |
---|
Issue date: |
06/11/1982 |
---|
From: |
Cormier W CALIFORNIA, UNIV. OF, LOS ANGELES, CA |
---|
To: |
|
---|
References |
---|
NUDOCS 8206160076 |
Download: ML20054F319 (5) |
|
|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20247Q7371989-07-28028 July 1989 Order Authorizing Dismantling of Facility & Disposition of Component Parts ML20211Q3021986-07-14014 July 1986 Order Authorizing Dismantling of Facility & Disposition of Components in Accordance W/Phase I of Dismantling Plan & NRC Rules & Regulations,Per 851029 Application ML20205G6071985-11-0808 November 1985 Order Terminating Proceeding Since Committee to Bridge the Gap Withdrew Petition for Leave to Intervene.No Other Petitions Remain.Served on 851112 ML20205G6551985-11-0808 November 1985 Memorandum & Order Approving Parties 851010 Stipulation to Dismantle & Dispose of All Reactor Components & Equipment Except for Biological Shield & Components Described in Stipulation.Served on 851112 ML20133Q2781985-10-30030 October 1985 Response to ASLB 851016 Memorandum & Order Re Settlement Agreement & Proposed Order on Matters in Dispute Concerning Proposed License Renewal & Dismantlement Proceedings. Paragraph 6 of Proposed Order Should Be Revised ML20133Q2941985-10-30030 October 1985 Affidavit of Dj Kasun Re Question 3 in ASLB 851016 Memorandum & Order Concerning Effect of Release of UCLA Security Plan to Public on Security of Other Nonpower Reactors W/Similar Plans.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20133J0691985-10-16016 October 1985 Memorandum & Order Requesting Parties to Respond by 851030 to Listed Questions Re 851010 Settlement Agreement & Proposed Order Terminating Proceeding.Served on 851017 ML20108A9601984-11-13013 November 1984 Answer Opposing Committee to Bridge the Gap 841024 Petition for Hearing & Leave to Intervene.Petition Fails to Satisfy Requirements & No Good Cause Exists for Deferment of Ruling on Petition.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20094A4741984-10-24024 October 1984 Petition of Committee to Bridge the Gap for Leave to Intervene & Request for Hearing Re Proposed Issuance of Orders Authorizing Disposition of Component Parts & Termination of License R-71.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20097A1271984-09-0707 September 1984 Response to ASLB 840806 Order Part B.Prompt Shipment of SNM, Removal of Metallic Core Components & Prompt Dissolution of Protective Order Required by Order,Regulations & Public Policy.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20097A0181984-09-0707 September 1984 Reply to Committee to Bridge the Gap 840801 Response Re Request to Withdraw Application.Aslb Should Approve Withdrawal of Application & Terminate Adjudicatory Proceedings.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20096G8791984-09-0707 September 1984 Response to ASLB 840806 Order Re Other Parties Responses to UCLA Motion for Withdrawal of Renewal Application. Clarification of Ambiguities in Proposals Progressing.W/Svc List ML20094C1371984-08-0101 August 1984 Response Opposing Staff Proposed Conditions for UCLA Withdrawal of License Renewal Application.Aslb Should Follow Required Practice Consistent W/Nrc Case Law.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20093H9281984-07-20020 July 1984 Reply Opposing Committee to Bridge the Gap (Cbg) 840703 Response to Univ Request to Withdraw Application.Cbg Not Established as Participant in License Termination Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20093G1541984-07-20020 July 1984 Withdrawal of 840622 Emergency Petition for off-shipment of Reactor Fuel Prior to Arrival of Olympic Athletes.Petition Moot.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20090C7851984-07-11011 July 1984 Response Opposing Committee to Bridge the Gap 840622 Petition for Commission Order to Remove SNM Prior to Olympics.Motion Lacks Factual Basis & Does Not Conform to Procedure.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20092P2431984-07-0303 July 1984 Response Supporting Univ 840614 Request to Withdraw Application for License Renewal.Proposed ASLB Order Accepting Withdrawal Request Encl.W/Certificate of Svc ML20151J9891984-06-25025 June 1984 Memorandum Explaining Reason Underlying 840622 Telegraphic Memorandum & Order Suspending All Further Proceeding. Licensee Has Shown No Desire to Retain Fuel Longer than Necessary.Served on 840626 ML20092G2821984-06-22022 June 1984 Emergency Petition for off-shipment of SNM from Site Before Olympics,Due to Withdrawal of Renewal Application & Security Risk Associated W/Olympics.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20140C6651984-06-18018 June 1984 Order Canceling Contention Xx Evidentiary Hearings Due to Licensee 840614 Request to Withdraw License Renewal Application & to Decommission Reactor.Served on 840619 ML20197H3831984-06-14014 June 1984 Request to Withdraw License Renewal Application on Condition That Application Be Made to Decommission ML20197H4051984-06-14014 June 1984 Motion to Suspend Proceedings Pending ASLB Action on Request to Withdraw Application.Hearing on Security Contention Should Be Canceled Immediately to Avoid Unnecessary Expense.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20197G7651984-06-11011 June 1984 Motion to Compel Further Written Response of B Ramberg or for Alternative Relief & Costs.Committee to Bridge the Gap Has Not Revealed Documents Per Interrogatory Requests. W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20091Q6071984-06-11011 June 1984 Objection to ASLB 840606 Notice of Evidentiary Hearing Specifying That Portions of Contention Xx Evidentiary Hearing Will Be Closed to Public.Only Portions Dealing W/Protected Info Should Be Closed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20091M8351984-06-0707 June 1984 Motion to Compel Committee to Bridge the Gap to Provide Further Written Answers to Questions 6 & 7 of Univ 840525 Interrogatories Re Security Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20091G8411984-05-30030 May 1984 Notice of T Taylor & D Hafemeister Depositions on 840604 & 05,respectively.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20091B3371984-05-25025 May 1984 Interrogatories Re Security Contention.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20090J6721984-05-0909 May 1984 Response to Applicant Request for Reversal of ASLB 840413 Finding of Matl False Statements.Requests Hearing in Which Questions Unanswered by Two UCLA Responses Can Be Thoroughly Explored.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20084H1991984-05-0404 May 1984 Notice of Disposition of Plotkin & Gt Cornwall on 840510 Re Physical Security & Request for Production of Documents. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20084F7061984-05-0101 May 1984 Estimate of Level of Threat Facing UCLA Reactor in Response to ASLB 840420 pre-hearing Conference Order.Facility Attractive Theft & Sabotage Target.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20084F1971984-05-0101 May 1984 Declaration of Wh Cormier in Response to ASLB 840413 Memorandum & Order Re Questions About Apparent Misrepresentations Made by Univ & NRC ML20084F1641984-05-0101 May 1984 Response to ASLB 840413 Order Directing Univ to Indicate Whether Any Representatives Had Reviewed Cormier 830825 Statements.No Representative of Regents Reviewed Statements Before or After Submittal ML20084F1881984-04-27027 April 1984 Declaration of Nc Ostrander Re Review of Cormier 830825 Statements.No Member of Staff Requested to Review Documents Before or After Submittal ML20084E7271984-04-27027 April 1984 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20084D0711984-04-25025 April 1984 Motion for Reconsideration & Clarification of Portions of ASLB 840420 Prehearing Conference Order Re Contention Xx. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20084C4001984-04-24024 April 1984 Reply Opposing Applicant Motion for Reconsideration of ASLB 840322 Order & Further Suppl to Rebuttal.Source Term Issue Under Investigation Should Not Be Litigated in Individual License Proceeding ML20084C4151984-04-23023 April 1984 Response to Committee to Bridge the Gap (Cbg) 840406 Motions for Reconsideration of ASLB 840322 Memorandum & Order Ruling on Cbg Objections to Rebuttal Testimony.Motions Should Be Denied.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20088A0551984-04-0606 April 1984 Motion to Reconsider Portions of ASLB 840322 Memorandum & Order,Overruling Objections to Untimely Filed Rebuttal Testimony.Aslb Has Placed Interest in Complete Record Above Statutory Interests of Proceedings.W/Certificate of Svc ML20088A1611984-04-0606 April 1984 Motion for Reconsideration of Certain Portions of ASLB 840322 Order.Only Penalty for Violation of ASLB Orders Is Further Delay & Continued License Possession,Precisely What Licensee Desires.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20088A2011984-04-0606 April 1984 Response to Applicant 840330 Rept Re Reactor Shutdown, Repair & Testing Schedule.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20088A6911984-04-0606 April 1984 Petition Per Reconsideration of ASLB Order Ruling on Committee to Bridge the Gap Objections to Rebuttal Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20087D7111984-03-0909 March 1984 Response to ASLB 840224 Order Indicating Concerns on Security Plan & Security Insp Repts Re Sabotage Matters Raised by Contention Xx & Directing Univ & Staff to Respond by 840309.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20235Z3661984-03-0606 March 1984 Affidavit of MD Schuster in Response to Question Raised by Aslp in UCLA Proceeding in Aslp 840224 Order Re Physical Security Insp Repts to UCLA & Every Licensee Inspected ML20080N2431984-02-16016 February 1984 Motion Denying Committee to Bridge the Gap 740109 Motion for Reactor Curtailment.No Factual or Legal Basis Exists to Support Extreme Remedy Sought.W/Certificate of Svc ML20080B7491984-02-0101 February 1984 Response Objecting to Applicant/Nrc Proposed Witnesses & Proposed Mod to Protected Order.Witnesses Do Not Qualify as Experts.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20080B6871984-01-31031 January 1984 Response Objecting to Release of Certain Protected Info. Proposed Sanitized Portions of Security Plan Should Be Released Only to Qualified Witnesses.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079H8501984-01-20020 January 1984 Reply Opposing Applicant 840117 Request for 24-day Extension to Respond to Committee to Bridge the Gap 840109 Motion for Curtailment.Reasonable Extension Not Opposed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079H4011984-01-17017 January 1984 Application for Extension of Time Until 840216 to Respond to Committee to Bridge the Gap 840109 Motion for Curtailment III (Irreparable Injury Associated W/Any Further Delay). Extension Will Not Delay Matters.W/Certificate of Svc ML20079H3751984-01-17017 January 1984 Response to Committee to Bridge the Gap Memorandum Clarifying Contention Xx,Paragraphs 1,2 & 3.Committee Should Be Made to Respond to NRC Motion Re 10CFR73.67. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079J1881984-01-16016 January 1984 Review of UCLA Analysis of Facility Shutdown Mechanism. Postulated Power Excursion Will Not self-terminate as Assumed by Expulsion of Water Out Top of Fuel Box Region Through Surrounding Brick Walls 1989-07-28
[Table view] Category:OTHER LEGAL DOCUMENT
MONTHYEARML20097A1271984-09-0707 September 1984 Response to ASLB 840806 Order Part B.Prompt Shipment of SNM, Removal of Metallic Core Components & Prompt Dissolution of Protective Order Required by Order,Regulations & Public Policy.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20096G8791984-09-0707 September 1984 Response to ASLB 840806 Order Re Other Parties Responses to UCLA Motion for Withdrawal of Renewal Application. Clarification of Ambiguities in Proposals Progressing.W/Svc List ML20093G1541984-07-20020 July 1984 Withdrawal of 840622 Emergency Petition for off-shipment of Reactor Fuel Prior to Arrival of Olympic Athletes.Petition Moot.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20151J9891984-06-25025 June 1984 Memorandum Explaining Reason Underlying 840622 Telegraphic Memorandum & Order Suspending All Further Proceeding. Licensee Has Shown No Desire to Retain Fuel Longer than Necessary.Served on 840626 ML20197H3831984-06-14014 June 1984 Request to Withdraw License Renewal Application on Condition That Application Be Made to Decommission ML20091Q6071984-06-11011 June 1984 Objection to ASLB 840606 Notice of Evidentiary Hearing Specifying That Portions of Contention Xx Evidentiary Hearing Will Be Closed to Public.Only Portions Dealing W/Protected Info Should Be Closed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20091G8411984-05-30030 May 1984 Notice of T Taylor & D Hafemeister Depositions on 840604 & 05,respectively.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20084H1991984-05-0404 May 1984 Notice of Disposition of Plotkin & Gt Cornwall on 840510 Re Physical Security & Request for Production of Documents. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20084F7061984-05-0101 May 1984 Estimate of Level of Threat Facing UCLA Reactor in Response to ASLB 840420 pre-hearing Conference Order.Facility Attractive Theft & Sabotage Target.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20084F1971984-05-0101 May 1984 Declaration of Wh Cormier in Response to ASLB 840413 Memorandum & Order Re Questions About Apparent Misrepresentations Made by Univ & NRC ML20084F1641984-05-0101 May 1984 Response to ASLB 840413 Order Directing Univ to Indicate Whether Any Representatives Had Reviewed Cormier 830825 Statements.No Representative of Regents Reviewed Statements Before or After Submittal ML20084E7271984-04-27027 April 1984 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20084F1881984-04-27027 April 1984 Declaration of Nc Ostrander Re Review of Cormier 830825 Statements.No Member of Staff Requested to Review Documents Before or After Submittal ML20084D0711984-04-25025 April 1984 Motion for Reconsideration & Clarification of Portions of ASLB 840420 Prehearing Conference Order Re Contention Xx. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20084C4001984-04-24024 April 1984 Reply Opposing Applicant Motion for Reconsideration of ASLB 840322 Order & Further Suppl to Rebuttal.Source Term Issue Under Investigation Should Not Be Litigated in Individual License Proceeding ML20084C4151984-04-23023 April 1984 Response to Committee to Bridge the Gap (Cbg) 840406 Motions for Reconsideration of ASLB 840322 Memorandum & Order Ruling on Cbg Objections to Rebuttal Testimony.Motions Should Be Denied.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20088A2011984-04-0606 April 1984 Response to Applicant 840330 Rept Re Reactor Shutdown, Repair & Testing Schedule.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20088A0551984-04-0606 April 1984 Motion to Reconsider Portions of ASLB 840322 Memorandum & Order,Overruling Objections to Untimely Filed Rebuttal Testimony.Aslb Has Placed Interest in Complete Record Above Statutory Interests of Proceedings.W/Certificate of Svc ML20088A1611984-04-0606 April 1984 Motion for Reconsideration of Certain Portions of ASLB 840322 Order.Only Penalty for Violation of ASLB Orders Is Further Delay & Continued License Possession,Precisely What Licensee Desires.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20088A6911984-04-0606 April 1984 Petition Per Reconsideration of ASLB Order Ruling on Committee to Bridge the Gap Objections to Rebuttal Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079J1881984-01-16016 January 1984 Review of UCLA Analysis of Facility Shutdown Mechanism. Postulated Power Excursion Will Not self-terminate as Assumed by Expulsion of Water Out Top of Fuel Box Region Through Surrounding Brick Walls ML20235Z3051983-12-23023 December 1983 Committee to Bridge the Gap Memorandum as to Status of Contention Xx (Security) Re UCLA Application for Renewal of Ol.Allegations of Three NRC Employees Made ML20083A6601983-12-13013 December 1983 Position on Contention Xx.Aslb Should Clarify Specific Factual Matters in NRC Motion for Summary Disposition. Whether Univ Must Provide Protection Against Sabotage Is Only Issue.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20082T4171983-12-13013 December 1983 Memorandum as to Status of Contention Xx (Security),Per ASLB 831123 Memorandum & Order.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20080G7511983-09-14014 September 1983 Memorandum as to Committee to Bridge the Gap Witness Panel Composition,Per ASLB 830902 Memorandum & Order.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20080L9551983-09-0909 September 1983 Response to Committee to Bridge the Gap 830830 Comments on IE Insp Rept on SNM Possession.Gap Alleged Discrepancies Based on Conjecture & Misinterpretation of Reported Info. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076H6481983-08-30030 August 1983 Response & Comment on IE SNM Inventory Insp Repts 50-142/83-02 & 70-0223/83-01.NRC Inventory Does Not Provide ASLB W/Sufficient Factual Basis to Establish Actual SNM Onsite.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20071H0431983-05-13013 May 1983 Response to Judge Laurenson 830422 Order Re Contention Ii. Parties Stipulated to Witnesses & Exhibits.Summarizes Witnesses Testimony.Ucla Case Will Be Presented in 4 H. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20073R2161983-04-29029 April 1983 Response to ASLB 830414 Order Detailing Licensee Legal Position Re Committee to Bridge the Gap Motion for Summary Disposition of Contention Xvii.Summary Disposition Should Not Be Granted.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20069K6291983-04-22022 April 1983 Answer to Applicant 830412 Reply to Committee to Bridge the Gap 830404 Comments on Sabotage Consideration.Regulation to Authorize Specific Contention Unnecessary.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20073C6841983-04-0707 April 1983 Memorandum Re Order of Presentation of Witnesses at Hearing. Objects to NRC Presenting Case Before Util.Proposal Would Be Improper Shifting of Burden of Proof from Util to Nrc. Declaration of Svc Encl ML20073B7631983-04-0707 April 1983 Objections to Certain Scheduling Matters Detailed in ASLB 830323 Memorandum & Order.Allowing NRC to Present Case First Creates Appearance of Improper Shift of Burden of Proof. Declaration of Svc Encl ML20072T5171983-04-0404 April 1983 Response to ASLB 830323 Memorandum & Order Memorializing 830223 Prehearing Conference.Motions for Summary Disposition of Contentions II & Xviii Should Be Dismissed.Burden to Show Absence of Genuine Dispute Not Met.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072U2171983-04-0404 April 1983 Memorandum Opposing UCLA & NRC Motions for Summary Disposition of Contentions II Re Class of License & Xviii Re Financial Qualifications & in Response to ASLB Concerns Re Contention Xix on Sabotage.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20066H4731982-11-16016 November 1982 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding.Declaration of Svc Encl ML20058J7971982-08-0606 August 1982 Response to NRC & UCLA Concerns Re 820712 Language Mods to Contention Viii Reflecting Proposed Application Amends.Basis for Contention Does Not Refer to 1982 Amended Application. Declaration of Svc Encl ML20071E6251982-06-29029 June 1982 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding ML20071E6391982-06-29029 June 1982 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding ML20054H7681982-06-22022 June 1982 Identification of Subjs Upon Which City of Santa Monica,Ca Intends to Participate,Per ASLB 820604 Memorandum & Order. Declaration of Svc Encl ML20054F3191982-06-11011 June 1982 Response to ASLB 820604 Order Re Release of Photographs. Proposes Alternative to Order Wherein Univ Would Retake Photographs Excluding Objectionable Physical Security Sys Features.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052F3801982-05-0606 May 1982 Notice of Intent to Participate as Interested Municipality Per 10CFR2.715(c).Santa Monica City Council Resolution & Declaration of Svc Encl ML20052F2461982-05-0303 May 1982 Memorandum Re Addl Discovery Matters Per ASLB 820416 Memorandum & Order.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052F2491982-05-0303 May 1982 Memorandum Re Disposition of Photographs,In Response to ASLB 820416 Memorandum & Order.No Compelling Interest Supports Committee to Bridge the Gap Proposal for Unconditional Release of Photos.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20052B6871982-04-26026 April 1982 Memorandum Re applicant-intervenor Disagreements Over Release of Intervenor Photographs,Per ASLB 820416 Memorandum & Order.Excerpts of Transcript of 820209 Discovery Conference Encl ML20042B7241982-03-12012 March 1982 Notice of J Bay Change of Address ML20009B8181981-07-0909 July 1981 Forwards Wh Comier Affidavit in Response to ASLB 810625 Order Re Article in Science ML19337B0391980-09-26026 September 1980 Notice of Appearance in Proposed Renewal of Ucla Research Reactor License Proceeding.Certification of Svc Encl ML19338D3611980-09-0909 September 1980 Certifies Svc of Response to Committee to Bridge the Gap Supplemental Petition to Intervene,On 800909 1984-09-07
[Table view] |
Text
_.-
_- 11
~
l 2 l 4
3I i . . n:
4 l
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 6
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 7 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD l
8 g In the Matter of ) Docket No. 50-142
) (Proposed Renewal of Facility
- 10, Tile REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY ) License Number R-71)
OF CALIFORNIA )
11 ) June 11, 1982
- ; (UCLA Research Reactor )
i 12 13 l UNIVERSITY'S RESPONSE TO BOARD'S JUNE 4th ORDER 1
14 l'
15 10 '
DONALD L. REIDHAAR
[-'
17 ll GLENN R. WOODS CHRISTINE HELWICK 18 l 590 University Hall 2200 University Avenue 19 j Berkeley, California 94720 1 Telephona: (415) 642-2822 20 I Attorneys for Applicant i
21 THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY
}{ .__
22 OF CALIFORNIA f 23,
' - 24 l,
>- 25h I
h 26 q
d 27
'l r
28 5 8206160076 820611 (I l PDR ADOCK 05000142
I 1 In an order dated June 4, 1982, and served June 7, 1982 2 the Board directed University to comply with para. 1 c) of the 3 Board's Order of April 16, 1982, within' forty-eight (48) hours 4 of the receipt of its June 4th Order. The Board also directed 5 University to preserve the photographs which are the subject of 6 para. 1 c) until further Order of the Board. The Board's June 4, 7 1982, Order was received by the University the afternoon of 8 June 10, 1982.
9 In the Board's April 16th memorandum and Order, 10 University was directed to " respond to CBG's suggestions as to possible means to overcome UCLA's security objections to the releaseto CBG of 20 photographs taken of the facility by CBG."
(Order, at paragraph 1. c).) Elsewhere in its Memorandum with reference to the same matter the Board directed University "to 15 indicate whether these suggestions would obviate its objections to the release of any of these photographs or whether it would be possible to depict the same scene in a second photograph while 8
excluding features of the physical security system." (Memorandum,
l 21 On page 14 of its April 8th pleading ("Intervenor's 22 Response to Applicant's Motion for a Protective Order; and 23 Intervenor's Motion to Compel"), CBG suggested that University l
24
" (1) . . . provide CBG with the photographs 25 and negatives in question with the objectionable j
' item in the photograph blocked out or otherwise 26 removed . . . .
27 28 ,
1 I
I " (2) . . . permit CBG to take t e questionable photographs again, this time with the questionable item 2 covered or outside the camera angle.
~
3 " (3) . . . (keep) any photographs for which i solution (1) or (2) is not possible . . . pending .
4 appropriate affidavits of non-disclosure and protective order conditions being in place which would permit 5, counsel for or representative of Intervenor to review the photographs in question under non-disclosure 6 conditions and participate in in camera argument as to whether the photographs should Te released with the bulk 7 of the photographs or whether they are rightfully to be included in security information provided only under 8 the security contention protective order."
9 Respecting suggestion (1) , while it is technically possible to " block out" on the negatives the objectionable items in the photographs, this alternative would not satisfy University's Isecurity objection. The exact placement or location of the objectionable item would be obvious on any blocked-out photograph.
University objects to any permanent record being made which would indicate the location of its security-related devices.
16 17 Suggestion (2) is objected to for the same reason and 18 for the additional reason that it is simply not practical. .
19 Photographs depicting covered objects represent a fairly obvious 20 permanent record of the exact placement or location of the 21 objectionable items. In addition, as a practical matter, certain 22 of the items cannot be covered. Also, unless University itself 1
23 retakes the photographs, University would have no way of ensuring 24 that the objectionable item was actually "outside the camera i 25' angle."
26 Suggestion (3) is in general acceptable. However, 27 .
i 28, University notes that on the basis of its May 25, 1982, letter to i
, l I
[
i 1 ithe Board, CBG apparently intends to argue that protective orders 2 and affidavits of non-disclosure are no longer necessary. As a l
3 l result, University is unsure of the status of CBG's suggestion (3).
4 University submits that there is a simpler solution to 5
lthismatter. At the Board's suggestion University has proposed (in its May 3,1982, ' Memorandum Concerning Release of the i Photographs") that it retake the photographs excluding the 8 j objectionable physical security system features. If so instructed g
by the Board, University will retake the photographs and present both the originals and the retaken photographs to the Board for l its examination and comparison at the upcoming prehearing 12 i t
With respect to the majority of the photographs l conference.
lUniversityexpectstobeabletoeasilydemonstratethatessentially 14 j
all of the pictorial content of the original has been preserved.
15 As to the remainder of the retaken photographs, questions may arise concerning whether University has recaptured the essential elements of the originals. As to these photographs and any others g
where the Board has questions, University is prepared to permit CBG's representative to view these photographs and engage in an 20 g in camera discussion with the Board concerning whether these r taken photographs adequately reproduce the originals. With the 22 B ard's assistance this matter can be resolved quite simply and 23 24 with little expense of time at the upcoming conference.
5 Dated: June 11, 1982.
26 DONALD L. REIDHAAR GLENN R. WOODS 27 CHRISTINE HELWICK By_ _
W1 lam . Cormier UCLA Representative
_3_
6 _____ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .
l 1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA I NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i 2 i BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD !
3 In the Matter of )
4 ) Docket No. 50-142 T!!E REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY ) (Proposed Renewal of Facility 5 OF CALIFORNIA ) License Number R-71)
-)
,6~ (UCLA Research Reactor) ) ,
)
7 8 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 9
- I hereby certify that copies of.the attached: UNIVERSITY'S 10 RESPONSE TO BOARD'S.l JUNE 4th ORDER 11 in the above-captioned proceeding have been served og the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class, 12 postage prepaid, addressed as indicated, on this date: June ll, 1982 .
13 14 John H. Frye, III, Chairman Mr. Daniel Hirsch Administrative Judge Cte. to Bridge the Gap 15 ATOMIQ SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 1637 Butler Avenue, #203 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Los Angeles, Calif, 90025 10 Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. John Bay, Esq.
17 Dr. Emmeth A. Luebke 3755 Divisadero #203 Administrative Judge San Francisco, CA 94123 18 ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD ,
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Co}mmission Mr. Daniel Hirsch 20555 Box 1186 19 Washington, D.C. -
Ben Lomond, CA 95005 20 Dr. Oscar H. Paris "
Administrative Judge 21 ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Nuclear Law Center 22 hushington, D.C. 20555 c/o Dorothy Thompson 6300 Wilshire Blvd. #1200 23 Counsel for the NRC Staff Los Angeles, CA 90048 OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR 24 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Sarah Shirley Washington, D.C. 20555 Deputy City Attorney 25 Cit; Hall Chief, Docketing and Service Section 1685 Main Street 26 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY Santa Monica, CA 90401 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 27 Washington, D.C. 20555 28 WILLIRM-8. CORMIER UCLA Representative 3 THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY
\ OF CALIFORNIA