ML20052F302
| ML20052F302 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Fermi  |
| Issue date: | 05/11/1982 |
| From: | Michollin G Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8205120329 | |
| Download: ML20052F302 (4) | |
Text
1 u)
DxxETED s
U 7, v, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA g
RECENgg
]
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- 02 UY ll P2 21 WA21%
~
7 ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative Judges Gary L. Milhollin, Chairman Dr. David R. Schink
~
i Dr. Peter A. Morris In the Matter of
)
)
THE DETROIT EDISON COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-341
)
(Operating License)
(Enrico Fermi Atomic Power Plant,
)
Unit 2)
)
May 11, 1982 ORDER CORRECTING TRANSCRIPT The transcript of the evidentiary hearing in this proceeding is hereby corrected as follows:
Page Line Correction 214 12 Delete "l-C" 18 Change "in" to "on" 236 1
Change "Wilhollin" to "Milhollin" 2
Change "othe" to "other" 248 3
Delete " entire" 21 Change " Contingent" to " Contention" 255 2
Change "sholds" to "should" 3
Change " evident " to "evidenti "
9 Change " Bloom" to "Bluhm" 381 5
Change " alternate" to " ultimate" 5
Change " operation to" to " operation of" 6
Change "has" to "is" gCS 60 \\
t
?$Rb$0CK05ooo34,
- '
- 0511 T
s s
. Page Line Correction 448 3
Change "Ms. Woodhead" to " Chairman Milhollin" 4
Change " Chairman Milhollin" to "Ms. Woodhead" 462 11 Change "now" to "that" 471 25 Change "greated" to " greater" 25 Change " number of" to " numbers for" 476 17 Delete "get" 25 Change the second "have" to "have you" 478 14 Change "you're back to" to "your back of" 14 Change "at" to "of" 478 24 Change "the evacuation" to " evacuation,"
479 21 Change "Lagoona" to " Pointe Aux Peaux" 481 15 Change " Chairman Milhollin" to " Judge Schink" 487 15 Delete "By Judge Schink" 489 16 Delete "by Judge Schink" 491 16 492 13
" "A (WITNESS HUNGERFORD)"
493 7
Delete the first "the" 495 1
Change "be postulated for" to "could be postulated for a" 504 7
Change " liberated" to "at liberty" 506 8
Change "Just a moment" to " Chairman Milhol'. in: Just a moment" 519 25 Change " differ" to " defer" 522 9
Change "and" to "on" 10 Delete ","
l Page Line Correction 522 21 Change "is" to "is it" 524 2
Change " applicants" to " applicant" 7
Change " lean" to " glean" 10 Delete "it" 1
16 Change "whether" to "what are" 525 16 Change "of" to "to" 25 change "in" to "on" 25 Change "and" to "and an" 4
526 3
Change "rather" to "rather.than" 527 4
Change "It's" to "It's a" 549 9
Change "in route" to "and routes" 22 Change "on" to ","
l 23 Change " to get" to "with a given" 4
550 4
Change "a" to "the" 6
Change "it's" to "a" 23 Change " reduce" to " redo" 551 1
Change "7" to "70" 3
Change "." to ","
j 4
Change "You" to "you" 552 2
Change " site" to " site?"
2 Change "you've" to "You've" i
2 Delete "and" i
556 3
Insert "for" after "then" i
i l
_4_
P_ age Line Correction 561 20 Delete "from" 21 Change "for" to "from" 570 11 Change " Calvin" to " Kelvin" 571 10 Change " meeting" to " hearing" Attached hereto are transcript corrections proposed by the Licensee, Detroit Edison Company, et al., and by the NRC Staff. Parties may object to the transcript corrections proposed by the Licensee and the NRC Staff within 20 days of the date of this order. Absent such objections, the transcript is deemed to be corrected as the Licensee and the NRC Staff have proposed.
FOR THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD i
$s i
b t
Gary L. Milhollin ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE Dated at Bethesda, Maryland this lith day of May,1982 d
I
\\
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
THE DETROIT EDISON COMPANY,
)
Docket No. 50-341 et al. (Enrico Fermi Atomic
)
(Operating License)
Power Plant, Unit No. 2)
)
APPLICANTS' PROPOSED TRANSCRIPT CORRECTIONS The Detroit Edison Company, Northern Michigan Electric Cooperative, Inc., and Wolverine Electric Cooper-ative, Inc.
(" Applicants") request that this Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, pursuant to S2.750(b) of the Commission's Rule of Practice, adopt the following proposed corrections to the transcript of the prehearing conferences held December 18, 1978, and July 22, 1981 and the hearing sessions held March 31 -
April 2, 1982 in the above-captioned matter:
PAGE LINE DELETE INSERT 15 25 the a
16 1
with Detroit Edison.
l 39 8
names named 98 11 be overly be not overly 98 16 leisurly leisurely 147 4
remediate remedy 190 14 the that i
(
C f r3
~
PAGE LINE DELETE INSERT 194 15 beliee believe 221 19 Massett Madsen 245 23 4A 4
263 15 Walter M. Street Wayne H. Jens 264 20 William Wayne 291 16 A (WITNESS ALESSI)
(nothing]
295 23-dimension diameter 24 297 3
under onto 302 4
scope probe 303 15 clippings clip angles 309 23 to through 323 2
Floorings Borings 325 15 concrete.
They concrete, they 325 16 placed with replaced with noneffective non-de fe ctive 325 16 clip angles where clip angles.
Where 325 17 accessible by a accessible, a 331 23 raise the level
[nothing]
332 12 weep holes 333 1
falsifications false indications 339 3
common time and 344 5
They conceded He went beyond 352 15 sec. in snap inspection PAGE LINE DELETE INSERT 353 17 paces places 403 25 not now 406 9
testimony on page 211, testimony beginning on page 11, 407 13 Eckhardt Eckert 408 5
Eckhardt Eckert 408 13 Eckhardt Eckert 408 18 national disaster natural disasters 409 25 and next annex 411 25 Mr.
Mrs.
412 22 towns counts 415 6
draw up send 419 4
Maybe the system The emergency broadcast system 428 12 phone foam 432 3
designed designated 436 19 pass 437 18
' regime area regime in the area 437 19 document.
documented.
447 9
Eckhardt Eckert the population 449 12 450 23 thirty minutes, i
452 4
Sustained by a standby 456 2
Let's A (WITNESS MADSEN) Let's l j
PAGE LINE DELETE INSERT 463 11 react.
Immediately, react immediately.
he He 464 23 ethylene effluent 465 15 ethylene effluent 465 17 protective protected 465 18 projectory trajectory 468 3
State state of 468 4
State state of 468 21 KANEN HUNGERFORD 469 1
KANEN HUNGERFORD 469 10 KANEN HUNGERFORD 469 16 KANEN HUNGERFORD 469 21 place plate 470 3
KANEN HUNGERFORD 471 6
plan were really plan really i
473 2
to 50 473 8
70 7
475 19 plant plan 478 3
pass path 478 9
pass path t
479 15 HUNGERFORD KANEN 479 22 HUNGERFORD KANEN l
480 3
HUNGERFORD KANEN 481 16 Eckhardt Eckert i
l l
PAGE LINE DELETE INSERT 482 5
are determined are not determined 483 10 have halve 486 13 latteral lateral 487 1
- decrease, 487 8
by underworks under works 491 14 in and 491 15 particular.
particulates.
492 4
energy are inventory is 492 13 A (WITNESS
[nothing]
HUNGERFORD )
498 13 shouldering sheltering 498 25 cryptography cartography 499 1
7.5 7.5 minute 500 4
datum meant datum.
The average 502 12 do all two stall 504 7
liberated at liberty 508 9
weld weight i
508 16 INE I and E l
508 17 INE I and E 508 17 7902 79-02 508 17 extension expansion 509 8
7902 79-02 1
509 14 eighth base l l 1
PAGE LINE DELETE INSERT 509 18 7902 79-02 547 15 licensing any licensing.
547 16 particular Particular 547 16 or are 547 16 and understand and I understand 554 13 accuracy adequacy 554 21 truck's position juxtaposition of to 569 13 an and 571 13 the two 574 4
route.
You route, then Respectfuly submitted, LeBOEUF, LAMB, LEIBY & MacRAE By M
a 5
Suite 11HO 1333 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036 Attorneys for Applicants April 19, 1982.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
THE DETROIT EDISION COMPANY,
)
Docket No. 50-341 et al.
)
(Operating License)
(Enrico Fermi Atomic Power
)
Plant, Unit No. 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have this 19th day of April, 1982, served the foregoing document, entitled " Applicants' Proposed Transcript Corrections" by mailing copies thereof,first class mail, postage prepaid, and properly addressed, or by personal delivery as indicated, to the following persons:
Gary L. Milhollin, Esq.,
Dr. Peter A. Morris, Chairman Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Board 1815 Jefferson Street U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Madison, WI 53711 Commission Washington, DC 20555 (personal delivery)
Dr. David R.
Schink Administrative Judge Chairman, Atomic Safety and Department of Oceanography Licensing Board Panel Texas A & M University U.S. Nuclear Regulatory College Station, TX 77840 Commission Washington, DC 20555 (personal delivery)
Chairman, Atomic Safety and Monroe County Library System Licensing Appeal Board Panel Reference Department U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory 3700 South Custer Road Commission Monroe, Michigan 48161 Washington, DC 20555 (personal delivery)
David E.
Howell, Esq.
Colleen Woodhead, Esq.
3239 Woodward Avenue Office of the Executive Berkley, Michigan 48072 Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Daniel Swanson, Esq.
Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Mr. Robert J.
Norwood Commission Supervisor Washington, DC 20555 Frenchtown Charter TO'.;nship 2744 Vivian Road Monroe, Michigan 48161 Secretary Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Attn:
Docket and Service Section (orig. plus 20)
(personal delivery) j j
L.
Charles Landgraf
/r jV LeBOEUF, LAMB, LEIBY & MacRAE Attorneys for Applicants l
l 4
l
e UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
DETROIT EDIS0N COMPANY Docket Nos. 50-341
)
(Enrico Fermi Atomic Power Plant, Unit 2)
NRC STAFF TRANSCRIPT CORRECTIONS The NRC Staff hereby submits the following corrections to be made to the transcript of the hearing held in this docket in Monroe, Michigan March 31 through April 2,1982.
On the second introductory page of the March 31, April 1 and April 2,1982 transcripts, " Office of Executive Legal Director, United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C." should appear immediately below the names of Ms. Woodhead and Mr. Swanson.
Page Line Correction i
216 4
Insert "the" after "is" 4-5 Change "for the Division" to "from the Division" 6
Change " Regulatory Commission" to " Regulation of the Commission" 9
Delete "tae" 10 Change " pre-trial" to " pre-filed" 218 18 Insert " Fermi-2" af ter "the"
-b Uj
'l v i Y]$
. 1 Page Line Correction 218 24 Insert "at" before "the" 219 11 Insert " Reactor" af ter " Nuclear" 220 3
Insert "the" after " considers" 5
Change "have" to "has" 8
Add "s" to " impact" 9
Delete "s" from " Plants" 11 Change " addenda" to " addendum" 11 Change "This" to "These" 251 4
Change " presentation, the" to " presentation. The" 8
Change "now" to " putting" 12 Change "there is" to "it" 13 Change " throw out" to " throw it out" 17 Change "4, we" to "4.
We" 18 Delete "we" 19 Change " convention" to " contention" 253 16 Change "put into" to "put testiony into" 17 Change "if" to "and" 269 2
Change "showed" to "show" 8
Change "50-341/7904" to "50-341/79-04" i
j 270 2
Change "a" to "as" Staff testimony following 270 omits the last two pages (27 & 28) of Appendix A, Report No. 50-341/79-04 by the U.S.N.R.C. Office of Inspection and Enforcement, Region III.
These missing two pages are attached to these transcript corrections.
i
}
- Page Line Correction 271 10 Change " testimony. The" to " testimony, the" 387 4
Delete "in" 388 11 Change answer to "I was not" 394 4
insert " Judge" before " Morris" 438 14 Change "and" to "before" 18 Delete "in the path" 440 21 Insert "in" after "And" 23 Delete "of"; insert "on" after "both" 441 8
Change " time; that" to " time. That" 442 1
Change "per" to "by"; "to" to "do"; " worse" to
" worst" 443 5
Add commas after " duties" and "briefly" 448 7
Change "--does" to " dose" 450 15 Change " accident, at" to " accident. At" 16 Change " plant; is" to " plant?
Is" 453 6
Change " postulates" to " postulate" 454 5
Change "can" to "have" and " consider" to " considered" 456 2
Insert "A." before "Let's" 520 23 Insert "who" after "of course,"
24 Insert a comma after " plans" 25 Add " answers" after " provide."
521 22 Delete "just" 3
24 Change "and those" to "on doses" 522 1
Change " voiced" to " versed" 7
Change "for" to "more" 8
change "would" to "could"
e i Page Line Correction 525 3
Change " caucus" to " focus" 526 8
Add " regulations" after " plans" and add a period 9
Delete "and"; capitalize "the" 9
Change "that further" to "further that" I
527 7
Change " kind of" to "like to" 530 5
Change "woulr" to " work" 16 Change "a" to "the" 17 Change "whicn" to "which" 531 1
Change "doucment" to " document" 5
Delete "page five" 6
Change " Anthony, are" to " Anthony. Are" 25 Change "IWTNESS" to " WITNESS" 532 16 Change ""1125," that" to ""1125."
That" 3
1 j
534 1
Change " Courts" to " Boards" 2
Change "?"
to "."
5 change "and" to "an" j
11 Insert "not" after "was" i
534 16 Insert "from" af ter "be" 16 Change "is" to "if" 538 8
Insert "in" before " testimony" 8
Add a comma after " testimony",
9 Change " read" to " ready" 539 6
Change " concern.--is" to " concern.
That is,"
540 22 Delete "--are" 1
4
+ - + -
e-m e
-.4
+
y
.y,-
m
--m--
. Page Line Correction 541 3
Change "emeregency" to " emergency" 5
Change "in " to "re "
542 7
Change " questions- " to " questions."
14 Change "ments, in" to "ments.
In" 15 Change " evaluation" to " evaluating" 23 Change "NRC- " to "NRC."
544 2
Insert "as" after "early" 5
Change "- " to "they" 9
Delete "is" 16 Change "--than" to "and then" 545 7
Delete the comma between " source" and " term" 546 3
Change "didn't" to " don't" 8
Change "out" to "our" 14 Change "to" to "on" 15 Change " supplement of" to " supplement reference to" 547 1
Delete " plant" add";" after " system", add " " af ter
" temperature" 2
Add ";" after " tion" l
2 Add ";" after " equipment" 2
Change " equal" to " fluid" l
l 6
Add "it" after "but" 7
Change "we had made" to "had been made" 8
Delete "them" 15 Change " licensing any" to " licensing.
Any" 16 Change "or" to "are" and insert "I" before
" understand" l
4 e
- i. '
4 3
Page Line Correction 548 16 Add "is" after " plume" 17 Add "are" before " told" 19 Add "rather" af ter " plant" 21 Change " limited" to " limiting" 549 4
Change " develops, the" to " develops. The" 5
Add a comma after " determine" 551 7
Change "right, there" to "right.
That" l
9 Delete "on" 20 Change "from" to "of" 554 13 Change " accuracy" to " adequacy" 21 Change "the truck's po ition to" to "the proximate position of" 555 5
Add "is" after " planning" 557 9
change " nearest" to " distance" 10 Change " point, do" to " point. Do" 13 Add "at" af ter "down" l
14 Add a comma after " question" j
15 Change " plant are" to " plant? Are" i
15 Change "it is" to "it?
Is" 558 9
Change the comma to a period after " point" 4
10 Capitalize "is"; add a question mark after
" distance"; capitalize "are" 22 Change "1.9" to "1 or.9" 559 5
Insert a period af ter closer. Capitalize "is" 12 Insert a question mark after " Dixie Highway" and insert "It" before "is"
-e-,m.---,,-,---,,,,y---.-
,.,,-,,e.~~v,,-e,-
er....
-w--
Page Line Correction 559 15 Change " travel, a" to " travel?
A" 16 Change " difference" to " distance" 24 Change " based, is" to " based? Is" 560 1
Change " analysis, risk analysis" to " analysis, and risk analysis" 2
Add "a" after "of" 2
Add "of" after " spectrum" 2
Change " Wash 14 hundred" to " WASH 1400" 4
Add "a" after "was" 22 Delete "I thought" 25 Change "beknownst" to " applied" 561 1
Delete "and" 564 1
Change "Pinte" to " Pointe" 566 2
Insert "to a" after "six hundred" 574 10 Change "it believes- " to " include" 11 Change " routs" to " routes" 12 change "also there" to "also."
19 Change " dosage" to " doses" 23 Change " occasion" to " occurrence" 575 1
Change "that" to "when" 5
Change "radialogical" to " radiological" 12 Change "at" to "in" Resppctfully sub 'tted,
/
hg40
/
Colleen P. Woodhead Counsel for NRC Staff Dated at Bethesda, Maryland this i
Tha investigstien soccciatcd eith this allsgetica did e.st revaal cny evidence that would lead to the conclusion that reinforcing steel was omitted from the RHR Building. No items of noncompliance or deviations were identified.
Allegation No. 20:
Cracks in the concret's base sat of the Reactor Building.
Mr. Euron expressed his concern of the concrete cracks which developed in the reactor building base sat at elevation 540'.
He felt that the cracking might " allow radiation to leak out of the reactor building" and that the structural integrity of the base sat may have been impaired.
Findina: DECO had previously identified the cracks in the reactor building base slab in accordance with 10 CFR 50, Paragraph 50.55(e)(3).
The final technical report from Deco was dated November 3, 1974, No.
EFZ-29,537.
Deco summarized the reactor building base sat cracking problem as being one of ground water, which was seeping through the radial and circumferential cracks present in the base slab. Evaluation and disposition of the cracking problem by the licensee included the
~
following actions:
4 Building Outleakage - In the case of a pipe rupture in the Reactor Building, there would be no outward leakage of radioactive water through the cracks in the floor of the building unless the basement areas became flooded to such a depth that the head of water inside was equal to or higher than that of the ground water outside. Under normal plant operation conditions, this would require flooding in the basement to a depth of approximately 30 feet before reaching the same head at the normal external ground water.
If this flooding began to occur, the reactor would be brought to a safe shutdown and the water contained within the building would be processed through the radwaste system.
It should be noted that this case is only valid if the cracks were not repaired.
i l
Sargent and Lundy, the structural designers for the reactor building, performed a thorough anlysis and concluded that the l
observed cracks did not impair.the structural strength of the base slab.
A program was initiated to monitor the width and length of l
selected cracks for an increase in length or width and to identify any new cracks which might develop.
Crack width and the penetration into the base slab was determined by taking random concrete cores at various specified locations. i i
e Dev21cpad, cyprevsd end exscut2 peccadurss for the drilling, pressure testing and grouting of all cracks present in the base mat.
As of the date of this investigation, Deco personnel indicated that they felt the grouting program had effectively sealed the cracks in the base slab due to the lack of infiltrating ground water. The NRC team toured the elevation 540 base slab on February 22, 1979, and found no evidence of continued water seepage. No items of noncompliance or deviations were noted.
6.
Unresolved Items Unresolved items are matters about which more information is required in order to ascertain whether they are acceptable items, items of noncompliance, or deviations. Unresolved items disclosed during the investigation are discussed on pages 12 and 13 (Allegations 2 and 3),
and on page 22 (Allegation No. 15) of this report.
7.
Exit Interview The investigators met with site staff representatives (denoted in the Persons Contacted paragraph) at the conclusion of the investigation on March 2, 1979. The investigators summarized the scope and findings of the investigation, including the apparent items of noncompliance identified in the Results section of this report. The licensee acknowledged the findings.
G 4
m..
e' UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
DETROIT EDISON COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-341
)
(Enrico Fermi Atomic Power Plant,
)
Unit 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of "NRC STAFF TRANSCRIPT CORRECTIONS" in the above captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class or, as indicated by an asterisk, through deposit in the Nuclear Regulatory Comission's t
internal mail system, this 28th day of April,1982.
Gary L. Milhollin, Esq., Chairman Peter A. Marquardt, Esq.
Administrative Judge The Detroit Edison Company Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 2000 Second Avenue 1815 Jefferson Street Detroit, MI 48226 Madison, WI 53711 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Dr. Peter A. Morris, Administrative Panel
- Judge
- U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Washington, DC 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Panel (5)*
Dr. David R. Schink U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Department of Oceanography Washington, DC 20555 Texas A & M University College Station, TX 77840 Docketing and Service Section*
Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Harry Voigt, Esq.
Washington, DC 20555 LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae 1333 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W.
Suite 1100 Washington, DC 20036 Mr. David E. Howell 3239 Woodward Avenue
[
Berkley, MI 48072 f
~
Colleen P. Woodhead Counsel for NRC Staff
_____