ML20052C467

Response to Wi Environ Decade First Interrogatories & Request for Production of Documents Re full-scale Sleeving Program.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20052C467
Person / Time
Site:	Point Beach
Issue date:	04/30/1982
From:	Churchill B SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE, WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER CO.
To:	WISCONSIN'S ENVIRONMENTAL DECADE
Shared Package
ML20052C465	List: ML20052C464 ML20052C467
References
NUDOCS 8205050014
Download: ML20052C467 (12)

Text

4 April 30, 1982 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )

)

WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-266

) 50-301 (Point Beach Nuclear Plant, ) (OL Amendment)

Units 1 and 2) )

LICENSEE'S RESPONSE TO DECADE'S FIRST INTERROGATORIES AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS ON THE FULL-SCALE ]

SLEEVING PROGRAM, INTERROGATORIES 11, 15 AND 16 Licensee herein responds to Decade's above-captioned Interrogatories 11, 15 and 16.

Copies of identified documents are available for in-spection at the offices of David K. Porter, Wisconsin Electric Power Company, 231 West Michigan Street, Kilwaukee, Wisconsin.

11. State the names, last know address and job title of all parties who were employed by the Licensee or its con-tractors or subcontractors to perform the fall 1981 demonstra-tion sleeving program at Point Beach Nuclear Power Plant Unit 1.

RESPONSE

Licensee has been in contact with Decade, and is in the process of developing its response.

@205050014 820430 PDR ADOCK 05000266 G PDR

^ ,- .

y

15. Planea list all leaking plugs observed at Point Beach Nuclear-Plant by unit, steam generator, row, column,

,and date observed.

I

RESPONSE

A listing of leaking plugs or plugs which exhibited indications of potential leakage observed at the Point Beach Nuclear Plant is as follows:

A. Unit 1, A Steam Generator -

Date Plug Location Observed Referenced Document

R16C33 12/75 Field Service Re ort, Nov. 24-Dec. 11, 1975, MRS4.4, WEP7 (1)

R21C36 9/78 LER No. 78-014/OlT-0 R31C44 '3/79 LER No. 79-003/OlT-0 R31C44 7/80 LER No. 80-009/0lT-0 R29C54 7/80 LER No. 80-009/0lT-0 R24C37 7/80 LER No. 80-009/OlT-0 R21C49 (Wet End) 7/80 LER No. 80-009/01T-0 2 Plugs ,(Wet Ends) 11/80 LER No. 80-014/0lT-0 LER No. 80-014/OlT-0 R03C09 7/81 LER No. 81-008/0lT-0 i R19C33 7/81 LER No. 81-008/0lT-0

) R24C37 7/81 LER No. 81-008/OlT-0

R33CSO 7/81 LER No. 81-008/OlT i

l (Boric Acid Coated)

R21049 '(t456 End) 7/81 LER No. 81-008/OlT-0

R04C59 7/81 t'f I'

LER No. Sl-008/01T-0

(Boric Acid Coated)  !

i R08C50- 7/81 LER No. 81-008/OlT-0 l

(Boric Acid Coated)

L' nit.1, ^. St;r Cr:=:t;;-

R24C37 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 R21C49 3/82 i

LER No. 82-007/01T-0 R31C31 3/82 LER No.

R19C33 82-007/0lT-0 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 R03C09 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 R01C22 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 -

B. Unit 1, B Steam Generator Date Plug Location Observed Ref. Document R33C51 3/75 G. Reed memorandum, March 1975 R32C50 6/75 S. Eurstein letter to B. Rusche

, R22C28 10/76 Field Service Report, Oct. 3-26, 1976, MRS 4.4 WEP9 (1)

_ .-2__ ., _ _ . _ . . .

R23C28 10/76 Fiold Servico Report, Oct. 2-26, 1976, MRS 4.4 WEP9(1)

-R7C25 6/77 LER 50-266/77-06 R9C26 10/77 p. 57, 1977 Annual Operating Report R12C55 10/77 p. 57, 1977 Annual Operating Report R16C27 10/77 P. 57, 1977 Annual Operating Report R18C48 10/77 p. 57, 1977 Annual Operating Report R22C44 10/77 p. 57, 1977 Annual Operating Report R13C55 10/77 p. 57, 1977 Annual Operating Report R22C41 10/79 LER 79-017/0lT-0 R23C50 10/79 LER 79-017/OlT-0 R23C31 10/79 LER.79-017/OlT-0 R21C26 10/79 LER 79-017/OlT-0 R12C55 12/79 LER 79-021/OlT-0 R20C55 12/79 LER 79-021/OlT-0 R25C53 3/80 LER 80-002/OlT-0 R22C48 3/80 LER 80-002/OlT-0 R23C50 (Wet End) 3/80 LER 80-002/0lT-1 R29C41 3/80 LER 80-002/01T-1 R20C46 (Wet End) 3/80 LER 80-002/01T-1 R19C37 (Wet End) 3/80 ,

LER 80-002/0lT-1 R23C53 (Wet End) 7/80 LER 80-009/OlT-0 2 Plugs (Wet Ends) 11/80 LER 80-014/01T-0 R23C53 (Wet End) 7/81 LER 81-008/01T-0 R29C35 7/81 LER 81-008/0lT-0 R4C46 7/81 LER 81-008/OlT-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R29C41 7/81 LER 81-008/0lT-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R28C39 7/81 LER 81-008/0lT-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R29C37 7/81 LER 81-002/017-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R23C38 10/81 LER 81-017/OlT-0 R28C39 (Wet End) 10/81 LER 81-017/OlT-0 R23C53 (Wet End) '

10/81 [I LER 81-017/0lT-0 R29C34 10/81 LER 81-017/OlT-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R29C37 10/81 LER 81-017/0lT-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R24C37 10/81 LER 81-017/0lT-0 (Boric Acid Coated)

R13C61 10/81 LER 81-017/01T-0 Lu t 1, e Ster C= . me R23C38 3/82 LER No.

R24C37 82-007/01T-0 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 R29C35 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 -

R29C40 3/82 LER No. 82-007/01T-0 R13C61 3/82 LER No.

R29C37 82-007/017-0 3/82 LER No. 82-007/017-0 R24C50 3/82 LER No. 82-007/017-0

C. Unit 2, A Steam Generator Date Plug Location Observed Reference Document R32C15 4/81 LER 81-002/OlT-0 D. Unit 2, B Steam Generator Date Plug Location Observed Reference Document No Leaking Plugs Observed t

i i fl i

16. State any and all studies, analyses or consideration of any kind given to leaking plugs.

Response

A listing.of documents, including letters, memoranda, and reports regarding consideration of leaking tube plugs is provided below.

s Gi 7

4 5-

TYPE DATE SIGNER SUBJECT MATTER Memorandum 3/24/75 C. W. Fay Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Plugging Memorandum 3/25/75 G. A. Reed Repair of B Steam Generator Leaking Tube Plug Letter 6/17/75 G. A. Reed Explosive Tube Plugging of Steam Generators Letter 2/20/76 R. L. Kelly Seal Welding of Steam Generator Explosive Tube Plugs Letter 2/27/76 T. J. Rodgers Explosive Tube Plugging of Steam Generators Letter 5/13/76 R. L. Kelly Explosive Plugging of Steam Generator Tubes Letter 5/24/76 T. J. Rodgers Explosive Tube Plugging of Steam Generators Letter 9/29/76 G. A. Reed Explosive Tube Plugging of Steam Generators Letter 10/20/76 G. A. Reed Leaking Tube Plugs j Letter 12/8/76 T. R. Wilson Evaluation of Tube Plugging Remnants Letter 7/6/77 T. J. Rodgers Explosive Plug Failures Memorandum 7/18/77 G. A. Reed Steam Generator Tube Plugging Memorandum 8/9/77 F. A. Flentje Leaking Steam Generator Tube Plugs

~

Memorandum 8/16/77 G. A. Reed 10 CFR 21, Reportability of Failed Steam Generator Plugs Letter 8/29/77 R. L. Kelly Leaking Steam Generator Explosive Tube Plugs Memorandum 10/14/77 F. Zeman Steam Generator Leak Test Results Letter 10/15/77 S. Burstein Tube Plugging at Point Beach Nuclear Plant

TYPE DATE SIGNER SUBJECT MATTER Letter 10/24/77 G. A. Reed Unit 1 Refueling Outage No. 5 Steam Generator Tube Plugging Memorandum 10/29/77 G. A. Reed Testing and Repair of Steam Generators Letter 11/1/77 G. A. Reed Explosive Plugging Letter 11/1/77 D. B. Ralsten Tube Plugging at Point Beach Nuclear Plant Letter 11/2/77 T. J. Rodgers Steam Generator Weld Repairs Memorandum 11/4/77 T. J. Rodgers History of Defective Plugs Letter 8/18/78 S. Burstein Defective Explosive Plugs Letter 9/29/78 R. L. Kelly Steam Generator Tube Plugs Letter 10/20/78 T. J. Rodgers Steam Generator Tube and Explosive Plug Repairs Letter 3/19/79 G. A. Reed Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Plugging Outage Letter 4/18/79 C. J. Olson Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube and Plug Leakage ,

Verification Letter 11/9/79 G. A. Reed Use of Explosive Plugs Update Memorandum 1/22/80 C. J. Olson Unit 1 Refueling 7 Outage Steam Generator Inspection Letter 4/29/80 C. W. Fay Explosive Plugging Memorandum 5/7/80 C. J. Olson Unit 2 Refueling 6 Outage Steam Generator Work Letter 8/5/80 E. G. Case Results of Unit 1 Steam Generator Inspection Memorandum 4/21/81 J. Schweitzer "A" Steam Generator Leaking Plug l ,

t

\

\

TYPE DATE SIGNER SUBJECT MATTER Memorandum 7/10/81 J. Schweitzer Results of Primary-Secondary Leak Test Memorandum 9/11/81 Schweitzer Demonstration Sleeving Candidates Attachment to 7/16/81 S. Burstein Degraded Steam Generator Licensee Event Tubes Report Attachment to 11/13/81 C. W. Fay Degraded Steam Generator Licensee Event ' Tubes Report Report 11/24- T. E. Bowman W Field Service Report 12/11/75 TFSR) : MRS 4.4, WEP-7 Report 10/3- T. E. Bowman FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-9 10/26/76 Report 6/24- V. W. Doutt FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-10 6/30/77 Report 10/12- V. W. Doutt FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-ll 10/26/77 Report 3/13- V. W. Doutt FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-15 3/18/79 Report 10/6- V. W. Doutt FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-17 11/10/79 Report 12/12- V. W. Doutt FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-18 12/22/79 Report 3/10- T. E. Dunn FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-19 4/4/80 -

Report 7/27- T. E. Dunn FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-20 8/8/80 Report 12/1- T. E. Dunn FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-21 12/19/80 Report 4/17- T. E. Dunn FSR: MRS 4.4 WIS13 5/10/81 Report 10/16- D. T. Christiansen FSR: MRS 4.4 WEP-23 10/31/81 All References in Response to Interrogatory 15.

e l

i

. l l

U Respectfully submitted, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE f

By BMe W.

\

Churchill Delissa A. Ridgway 4

Counsel for Licensee 1800 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 822-1000 Dated: April 30, 1982 i

1 I

i

_g_

~

3- --, _m -. . , - - - , _ , - - , , . . - - - .

l .

l . ,

l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULAf0RY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board i In the Matter of )

)

WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-266

) 50-301 (Point Beach Nuclear Plant ) (OL Amendment)

Units 1 and 2) )

AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID K. PORTER County of Milwaukee )

ss State of Wisconsin )

DAVID K. PORTER, being duly sworn according to law, deposes and says:

1. I am Manager of the Nuclear Engineering Section of the Nuclear Power Department of Wisconsin Electric Power Company. I graduated from the University of Illinois with a bachelor of science degree in electrical engineering in 1965. I then spent four years in the U.S. Navy's Nuclear Power Program which included one year in training and three years of reactor ,

operator experience as an engineering officer aboard a nuclear powered cruiser. I joined the Nuclear Projects Office of Wisconsin Electric in 1969 and have been involved in various engin'eering assignments relating to the Point Beach Nuclear Plant and preconstruction nuclear projects since that time. As Manager of the Nuclear Engineering Section, I am responsible for providing technical, licensing, and engineering support to the Point Beach Nuclear Plant. These responsibilities include the technical review of plant equipment and repair specifications, and implementation of U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") licensing actions involving Wisconsin Elec-tric's operating nuclear facilities. I am personally familiar with Wisconsin

Electric's activities concerning inspection and repair of the Point Beach Nuclear Plant steam generators and our application before the NRC with respect to these activities.

2. I have prepared or participated in the preparation of " Licensee's Responses to Decade's First Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents on the Full-Scale Sleeving Program, Interrogatories 11, 15 and 16",

dated April 30, 1982. The information contained in those responses is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.

5 David K. Porter Subscrib and sworn efore me this) ayof/f:jto

/

/ 7)

/

y, U/k MNotary Public My commissio Expi,c=. A , #7 W e- d

//

i UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )

)

WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-266

) 50-301 (Point Beach Nuclear Plant, ) (OL Amendment)

Units 1 and 2) )

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This is to certify that copies of " Licensee's Supple-mental Resp 01ses to Decade's First Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents on the Full-Scale Sleeving Program" and " Licensee's Response to Decade's First Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents on the Full-Scale Sleeving Program, Interrogatories 11, 15 and 16," are being served to all those on the attached Service List by deposit in the U.S. Mail, first class, postage prepaid, this 30th day of April, 1982.

(5 cn wl Bruce W. Churchill Dated: April 30, 1982

~

l

~

j UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )

)

WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWET. 20MPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-266

) 50-301 (Point Beach Nuclear Plant, ) (OL Amendment)

Units 1 and 2) )

SERVICE LIST f

Peter B. Bloch, Chairman Stuart A. Treby, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Office of the Executive Board Pan,el Legal Direct 6r U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Wasington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Hugh C. Paxton Richard G. Bachmann, Esq.

1229 - 41st Street Office of the Executive Los Alamos, New Mexico 87544 Legal Director .

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Dr. Jerry R. Kline Wasington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Kathleen M. Falk, Esq.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Wisconsin's Environmental Decade Washington, D.C. 20555 114 North Carroll Street Suite 208 Atomic Safety and Licensing Madison, Wisconsin 53703 Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Francis X. Davis, Esq.

Washington, D.C. 20555 Monroeville Nuclear Center Westinghouse Electric Corporation '

Atomic Safety and Licensing P. O. Box 355 Appeal Board Panel Pittsburgh, PA 15230 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Barton Z. Cowan, Esq. l John R. Kenrick, Esq.

Docketing and Service Section Eckert, Seamans, Cherin'& Mellott Office of the Secretary ' Forty-Second Floor U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 600 Grant Street Washington, D.C. 20555 Pittsburgh, PA 15219 1

.l l

. .