ML20049J649
| ML20049J649 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 03/02/1982 |
| From: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUREG-0886, NUREG-0886-ERR, NUREG-886, NUREG-886-ERR, NUDOCS 8203180563 | |
| Download: ML20049J649 (4) | |
Text
..
?
3 p* *
- G or.
UNITED STATES
,o,
,8,' -
'.,g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
,j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
\\.,,,,/
1 1
t t
N MARCH 2, 1982 ERRATA SHEET for
" STEAM GENERATOR TUBE EXPERIENCE" NUREG-0886 Please make the following chsnges:
1.
Replace the second page of Table I with the attached page so that,the entire table can be read across pages 18 and 19.
Replace all of, Table 4 with the revised
- 2..
version that is attached.
DIVISION OF TECHNICAL INFORMATION AND DOCUMENT CONTROL t
)
h 4
3203180563 820302 POR'NURE9 0866 R PDR
l Ttble 1 (Cont.)
Primary side Secondary init. SCC in No. of No. (%)
Steam side init.
small radius leaking of tubes Sleeve generator g
IGA / SCC U-bends.
Denting (e)
-tubes plugged repairs replacement X
116(1.8%)
l X
X-Extensive-31 948(8.4%)
X-6508 tubes X
X-Minor 4
69(0.5%)
X X-Minor 6
237(4%)
X-21 tubes X
X-Minor 1068(11%)
Under consideration X
X-Moderate 51 827(13%)
X-12 tubes X
X-Moderate 4
117(2%)
Planned X-Extensive 14 (21%)
In progress X-Extensive 5
477(3.7%)
X-Extensive 40 1593(25.4%)
X-Completed X
X-Extensive 27 2187(21.5%)
X-Completed X-Extensive 36 (24.8%)
Planned X
X-Minor-1 27 X
2-34(1%)
X-Minor 0
0 X-Minor 1
15 X
1 61(<2%)
0 21(<1%)
X 12 368 X-Extensive 1
801(6.1%)
Planned 0
0 0
30(0.9%)
X 8
8 X
X-Minor 1
284(2.8%)
X 3
24(<1%)
i 0
282(2.8%)
l l
X-Minor 0
0 I
I 5
5 X
f
)
l 19 1
L.
~
Foreign operating experience with PWR steam generators *I I
Table 4.
Previous Wastage SCC Secondary operation or other SCC /lGA initiated SG model Tubing Start-up water chem.
with P0 wall initiated from 10 NSSS Plant name (country) no.
material date.
control control thinning from 0D in U-Bends Fretting Denting W
BR-3 (Belgium)
NI SS 10/62 AVT Yes W
Trino Vercellese (Italy) - NI NI 6/64 AVT No X (b)
W SENA (Fran.e) 14.
SS 4/67 AVT No X (b)
K Obrigheim (W. Germany)
NI Inco 600 3/69 AVT No X
X X
W Zirota (Spain) 24 Inco 600 8/69 P0 Yes X
X (b)
W Beznau 1 (Switzerland) 33 Inco 600 12/69 AVT Yes X
X
- CE Mihama 1 (Japan)
CE Inco 600 11/70 AVT Yes X
W Beznau 2 (Switzerland) 33 Inco 600 3/72 AVT Yes X
X Very minor (b)
K Stade (W. Germany)
NI Inco 800 5/72 P0 Yes X
X M
Mihama 2 (Japan) 44 Inco 600 7/72 AVT Yes X
X K
Borssele (Netherlands)
NI Inco 800 10/73 P0 Yes X
+
K Biblis A (W. Germany)
NI Inco 800 8/74 P0 Yes X
W Takahama 1 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 11/74 AVT Yes X
X X
W Doel 1 (Belgium) 44 Inco 600 2/75 AVT Yes X
W Ringhals 2 (Sweden)
SIC Inco 600 5/75 AVT Yes X
X W
Tihange 1 (Belgium) 51 Inco 600 9/75 AVT No X
X X
N M
Genkai 1 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 10/75 AVT No X
N W
Doel 2 (Belgium) 44 Inco 600 11/75 AVT No X
X M
Takahama 2 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 11/75 AVT No K
Biblis B (W. Germany)
NI Inco 800 4/76
.PO Yes X
4 K
Neckarwestheim NI Inco 800 10/76 P0 Yes X
(W. Germany)
W Mihama 3 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 12/76 AVT No W
Ko-Ri 1 (Korea) 51 Inco 600 6/77 AVT No X (3-12 mil).
M Ikata 1 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 9/77 AVT No X (b)
F/C Fessenheim 1 (France) 51A Inco 600 10/77 AVT No F/C Fessenheim 2 (France) 51A Inco 600 3/78 AVT No K
Unterweser (W. Germany)
NI Inco 800 10/78 P0 Yes F/C Bugey 2 (France) 51A Inco 600 2/79 AVT No F/C Bugey 3 (France) 51A Inco 600 2/79 AVT No X (b)
W Ohi 1 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 3/79 AVT No X
F/C Bugey 4 (France) 51A Inco 600 5/79 AVT No F/C Bugey 5 (France) 51A Inco 600 11/79 AVT No K
Goesgen (Switzerland)
NI Inco 800 12/79 P0 Yes X-(minor)
M Ohi 2 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 12/79 AVT No W
Almaraz 1 (Spain)
D3
.Inco 600 12/79 AVT No X (c)
F/C Gravelines 1 (France) 51M Inco 600 7/80 AVT No W
Tricastin 1 (France)
SIM Inco 600 7/80 AVT No W
Ringhals 3 (Sweden) 03 Inco 600 7/80 AVT No X (c)
F/C Dampierre 1 (France)
SIM Inco 600- 10/80 AVT No See footnotes on last page of table.
Table 4. '(Cont.)
Previous Wastage SCC Secondary operation or other SCC /lGA initiated SG model Tubing Start up water chem.
with P0 wall initiated from ID N555 P' ant name (country) no.
. material date control control thinning from OD in U-8 ends Fretting Denting F/C Tricastin 2 (France) 51M Inco 600 11/80 AVT No F/C Gravelines 2 (France)
- SIM Inco 600 12/80 AVT-No F/C Gravelines 3 (France)
SIM Inco 600 1/81 AVT No F/C Dampierre 2 (France)
SIM Inco 600 2/81 AVT No M
Genkal 2 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 3/81 AV1 No F/C Dampierre 3 (France)
SIM Inco 600 4/81 AVT No 2
F/C Gravelines 4 (France)
SIM Inco 600: 8/81 AVT No
-F/C Blayais.1 (France)
SIM Inc 600 8/81 AVT No F/C Tricastin 3 (France)
SIM Inco 600 9/81 AVT No F/C Tricastin 4 (France)
SIM Inco 600 10/81' AVT ha F/C Dampierre 4 (France)
SIM Inco 600 10/81 AVT No F/C St. Laurent 2 (France)
SIM Inco 600 10/81 AVT No M
Ikata 2 (Japan) 51 Inco 600 3/82 AVT No (a) This summary is based upon information available to the NRC staf f (b) Fretting at anti-vibration bar supports.
(c) Fretting in preheater section.
U Key:
W - Westinghouse K - KWU-F/C - Framatome/Crevsot-Loire H - Hitachi M - Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd.
CE - Combustion Engineering e
__