ML20045E334
| ML20045E334 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Sequoyah  |
| Issue date: | 06/21/1993 |
| From: | Gibson A NRC Office of Inspection & Enforcement (IE Region II) |
| To: | Medford M Tennessee Valley Authority |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9307020033 | |
| Download: ML20045E334 (15) | |
Text
1 June 21, 1993 Docket Nos. 50-327, 50-328 License Nos. DPR-77, DPR-79 Tennessee Valley Authority ATTN: Dr. Mark 0. Medford, Vice President i
Technical Support 3B Lookout Place 1101 Market Street Chattanooga, Tennessee 37402-2801 Gentlemen:
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- SEQUOYAH RESTART ISSUES This refers to the meeting conducted at our request at the Region II Office in Atlanta, Georgia, on June 14, 1993. The purpose of the meeting was for you to present to the NRC Restart Panel the status of your actions to identify items and/or programs to be corrected prior to restart of the Sequoyah Units.
A list of attendees, a meeting summary and a copy of your handouts are
~
enclosed.
It is our opinion that this meeting was_ beneficial to us in aiding our understanding of the actions that you are taking to prepare the Sequoyah Units for restart.
In accordance with Section 2.790 of the NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
Should you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact us.
Sincerely, (ORIGINAL SIGNED BY A. F. GIBSON) 010077 Albert F. Gibson, Director Division of Reactor Safety
Enclosures:
- 1. List of Attendees 2 Meeting Summary
- 3. License Handouts cc w/encls:
(See page 2) 9307020033 900621 l {l
'~
PDR-ADOCK 0S000327' P
PDR:
ZCOI e
Tennessee Valley Authority 2
cc w/encls:
W. H. Kennoy, Director Tennessee Valley Authority ET 12A 400 West Summit Hill Drive Knoxville, TN 37902 R. M. Eytchison, Vice President Nuclear Operations Tennessee Valiey Authority 3B Lookout Place 1101 Market Street Chattanooga, TN 37402-2801 B. S. Schofield, Manager Nuclear Licensing and Regulatory Affairs Tennessee Valley Authority 5B Lookout Place 1101 Market Street Chattanooga, TN 37402-2801 Robert Fenech, Vice President Sequoyah Nuclear Plant Tennessee Valley Authority P. O. Box 2000 Soddy-Daisy, TN 37379 TVA Representative Tennessee Valley Authority Rockville Office 11921 Rockville Pike Suite 402 Rockville, MD 20852 Mr. Ralph H. Shell Site Licensing Manger Sequoyah Nuclear Plant Tennessee Valley Authority P. O. Box 2000 Soddy-Daisy, TN 37379 Marci Cooper Restart Manager Sequoyah Nuclear Plant P. O. Box 2000 Soddy-Daisy, TN 37379 (cc w/encls - See page 3)
/
p Tennessee Valley. Authority 3
June'21,.1993 l
(cc w/encls)
L Michael H. Mobley, Director.
Division of Radiological 14ealth 3rd Floor, L and C Annex 401 Church Street
-i Nashville, TN 37243-1532
~ General Counsel Tennessee Valley Authority
- ET 11H 400 West Summit Hill Drive Knoxville, TN 37902 County Judge i
Hamilton County Courthouse i
Chattanooga, TN 37402 bec w/encls:
E. Merschoff, RII J. Johnson,.RII R. V. Crlenjak, RII S. E. Sparks, RII S. J.. Vias, RII
- B. Bordenick, OGC D. E. LaBarge, NRR Document Control Desk NRC Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2600 Igou Ferry Soddy-Daisy, TN 37379 i
DOCUMENT NAME:
B:\\ SEQ.MEE 3
D,RS
_R 7 P AG on u
r choff 6/p93 f/93
/
(
P s
e ENCLOSURE 1 LIST OF ATTENDEES 1
NRC A. F. Gibson, Director, Division of Reactor Safety E. W. Merschoff, Director, Division of Reactor Projects W. E. Holland, Senior Resident Inspector, DRP, RII F. J. Hebdon, Director, PDII-4, NRR D. E. LaBarge, Senior Project Manager, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation (NRR)
M. T. Markley, NRR, RPEB J. Jacobson, Inspection Team Leader, NRR/RSIB TVA R. Shell, Manager Site Licensing i
J. S. Baumstark, Operations Manager M. Starzinski, Manager Technical Programs P. G. Trudel, Engineering Manager-L. S. Bryant, Maintenance Manager M. A. Cooper, Restart _ Manger H. R. Rogers, Technical Support J. N. Ward, Engineering and Modifications Manager
'l 1
~
e v
e o
-. ~
ENCLOSURE 2 MEETING
SUMMARY
At the request of the NRC staff, TVA representatives met with members of the -
NRC Restart Panel for Sequoyah to describe the status of actions taken and planned prior to restart. of Sequoyah. The TVA representatives reaffirmed July 23, 1993, as the planned criticality date for Unit 2.
They described the processes used by TVA for identification of work to be completed prior to restart and the performance measures used to monitor the status of this work.
They reported that approximately 47 percent of identified hardware deficiencies would be corrected prior to restart.
NRC representatives questioned the bases and criteria used by TVA for the application of various backlog review processes. The NRC representatives said that they were considering rescheduling an Operational Readiness Team Inspection to an earlier date in order to provide about three weeks of evaluation time between the end of the inspection and an NRC decision on restart. The NRC and TVA representatives agreed to continue discussion of these issues during the status meeting scheduled for June 23, 1993, at the Sequoyah site.
l i
ENCLOSURE 3.'
AGENDA TVA/NRC RESTART PANEL MEETING JUNE 14,1993 Introduction and Purpose Ralph Shell Backlogs Marci Cooper Larry Bryant Jim Baumstark Jerry Ward' Ralph Shell Technical Programs and Performance Mark Skarzinski e
People / Organization / Culture Marci Cooper Closing Discussion Ralph Shell 1
WO WORKOFF UNIT 0/1/2 CORRECTIVE MAINTENANCE 2,500 E---
2,000 c)O3 1,500 to-O ASSUMPTIONS:
s u
Q)
- 1. Starting point 2008 WOs
- 2. Restart goal is less than O 1 E
,000 or equal to 722 WOs
- 3. Incoming rate is an U
average of 100/ week Z
- An avg. 29 WOs per week cance!!ed 500 4 Unit rate is 48 MH per WO
- 5. Dedicated Manpower-119 people per week 0
g_
,,,,,,,,,n N
E E 5
e N $
$ N
$ E n
n n
m m
m.
e
.o e
.n r-n a
e a
PLANNED POPULATION +
2,008 1.963 1.858 1,933 t.8SS 1,777 1,899 1.621 1.518 1.41 S 1,640 1,265 1,040 815 870 722 722 100 100 100 100
'100 100 100 75 325 79 75 FS 325 75 75 75 ADOED(PLANNED) 125 12S 126 178 178 178 170 178 200 350 300 300 270 223 75 75 PLAN TO COMPLETE ACTUAL POPULATION E
2.203 2.197 2,cos 1,e12 1.ess 1,80s 1.soe 107 112 Actual PER PERIOD 87 ACTUAL ADOED EKLGOSS/Bryant m
m.
O O
DELINQUENT PMs UNIT 0/1/2 MAINTENANCE 60 N'
k 50 o_
4-*
40 O
J CT C 30
=
ASSUMPTIONS:
Q 20
- 1. Starting point 48 PMs
- 2. Restart goal is less than b
5-
- 3. Incoming rate 10 per week
- 4. Unit rate is 12 MH per PM O to
- s. oedicated uanpower-Z 3 people per week
- 6. Interface organizations provide timely support 0
N N
(
k E,
E, k'N'
( k k e
( k k
.N 5 (
k N~N E' k k T
w a
v.
e e
a e
n n
n e
e e
n n
n FMNNED POPULATION
- 28 23 18 13 8
e S-S S-S S
S S
S S
S S
ADDED{ PLANNED) to, in to to to to.
10 to 10 to to to to to io io PLAN TO COMPLETE IS 15 15 13 11 to to 10 to to to to to -
to to to ACTUAL POPUL.',TtON E
40 23 31
'32 41 SS S4 41 34 29 21 14 14 14 3
BCTUAL PER PERICO if '
S-to l ' QCTUAL ADDED to S
to i
eCILGOSO/Treffenstedt
n-i' 4
._.4, o-m e--
1 g
gp; o- - eee C) y o-m e--
o-
- e--
/
a D-t/s e,
=8 y w: e--
01/2 m g
e-
,,,, s-e ne ez s-2 58 e s mc e-2
/
O&U S,O Z
08 t
cua 8"03 3
12 m
O 8s N
e-2;_
i P
- m a
1 O
H
= 7
- -""*~"
<C Og
,/o;
- wa-==
ain $ " D.y (T~
U m n es O_
//
e 1
O f
i
~ " "
a g
-ma es a/a aun g _
~
g e e-u u
sur s ee am D$
b n
/
m 2
ur e ee g
gily
~
~
m
- g wE m ac 3wSEQ O
.m
,uc-
.~.,,
{
l l
~
OE N
m m
.o o
o o
o
@@@m abljl C\\]
o to o
to
~
)
gl-lll@
S OM/SM dO 898WnN 3
I c-,
02/G 9G W
[]- 2716 9WW 95/R SNN g/g g.m o
/
t/9 ZW 9 l
l-l' wg~9 Ot/i QN 9 L L/l 7l W 9 l
-k p/2 g W 9'
/
Ii g
gg-m W e
-/
0719,"
- 9 3
O N'= x/
g !
5 0
ct/a 8a 9s ~
%)
- - x ~ er l /
V
<C m',
3[h-
=
00: 8 " E h '- o H
ad 9-o cm a-23 E
9t/? h"@3 6/9 DD 9D E
G O_
i 2*92 k
E O
79 I
O
/
se
~
~
~
e Y
jf G72> f*8f E
01/p 3. "
3 E
h
( t/P 9" -
Q-s E
g F/P hI h
l
- Th 972C m
j 12/C 5
o
~-
E[$ ' 6 b
up tr) tr - Q VllC O
>c a a
4 4 ed d M o
u oooooooooo eev m oeev m
?
689 q
r-.
r-r-
r-
.s--
Q
~
c, m
S,OM/BM 50 898PNnN 30F$$w W
2 2 O
e e
v
. i.,
o l
S 0 3 3 2
c-l G
0 3 3 2
m-I E
C 3 3 E
I 0'
3 3 F
E O
2 P3 NE O
O' S 2 m""
I 5
0 3 3 S
T 2
TMU" N
SOV'N 1
G 0 3 3 EUA E
2 E
E S
RER"N U
PC D l
g 3 3 6 EN 2
N'O R S A
HD"F E
C O
'l 5
M3 c MNT E"K T"E R
N A "" E i
5 t
m V
S^W 9 3 e 2
3 3 7 l
s 3
S N
i s
8 3 8 3
N m/
l 3 3 8 0 y
@s 4
0 1
/
O m
i 8 3 8 4 0 2 4
7 2
mN I
s 5
0 I
l 3 3 8 2 8 T
5 5
A 8 3 8 0'
~
R l
s 3 3 8 2 C
0 E
q i
S 6 O 5 8 C
0
~
P 0
s 2
1 S
0 O 2 0 7
7 o
O t
.m la l
G 4 O 4 4 u
7 7
s qe E
8 O 3 8 e
r i
7 7 ~
o
~
na 1
O 3 1
s" h
l E
8 8 '
t y
s t
4 s n
a 8 e3 O l
5 4
4 m
t: L :
8 8'
eg nl
.t iaan a
so o W
I G
4 4
r 8
8 np ggc o gt na 2
itpin r ir a nT 4
4 a
tsos l
E 3
6' r
mtr ut a ecp s S R i O.
~
n v
4 4
a s. 2a4 1
E 8
8 A1 4
4 n
1 M
8 8
8
.m 0
0 0
0 0
0 N
)
E N DD DT O
EOIOE 2
0 8
6 4
2 I
E D
v D
T N L T R A N P A AML WA 1
1 L
J J
L L D RR A PO P( O E
U C P P DOP T
L C N E T L A mhOoz_3u_o TWO23z L
DO A
N %U A P A ATL T C
C RC A A
W AD o.
W_
e o
a b
.N
=
y a - ~~
4
. n. ~_
g m _ ~.
n.
~..
O c3-va ~e 03 y w: ~c-f e-v s o:.oe
.,, e-
- ?tG "*
- Fr~
m 3
LU z
p
~
5 n
O 4
- " """"~"
Ya
g b
h g{
ac 0 0
i
\\
6 anea
, sc 0 0
$g $ $ Q w h '-
anggw E
" "E g
N
- /c 0
- 0 f}Ejs0 o
o o
o o
o
)
m v
o N
r s
gB
?
saaaso mos ao saannN lln k
]
.)
9 8
UNIT 12 TACFS TECH SUPPORT 25 R
20 A
en O 15
<C H
u_10 O
.,, u m,,,,,,;
~ 1. Starting point:-19
- 2. Restart gost: less than or equal to 7
- 3. Incoming rate: 1/wk for first
.g=
4 wks.
U
- 4. Unit rate: 24 mhr/TACF
- 5. Dedicated manpower:.9/wk avg.
- 6. Revised 6/7/93 to include all TACF's r
0s t
I l'
I l
i i1 I
i 1
f I
i t
f I
i t
i i
t i
t t
' I 4
e-CD 4 e
CO 10 N. CD - (D ' n O to M O.
N 4
- (o in.- c0 in N CD bC k D
~T ' C C ' D b LD C~D D b C DDs C C D. b b C' D D n n n ee e in to to m to e s -s s
m -m m.
rt Amuro PorUL Afrom o to it se to is se is is is is is e
a y
y 7
ADDED(Ptene.e 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 1
1 1:
1 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 2
=
0 3.
O 1
3 0
1 0
2 0
2 2
1 1
O O
O M AN TO COMMETE O
0 0
0.
O O
O.
e ACTUAL POPUL ATen E
22 to le is ACTUAL ADDED 2
9 0
0 0
ACTUAL M4 MRWD I
I 3
3 TSTACFS 3 00
, - -,,,.. =
a.
a,-
..a
.- - +
r-UNIT 112 CORRECTIVE ACTION
. DOCUMENTS LICENSING 400
=-.-.
NOTES:
- 1. Commitment is to be at 250 for
'E 2.
ur ent manpower is sufficient.
F.300 z
ne L1J Eao 200 O --
O u.
O im
_ Assuurrious:
I VL/
- 1. Starting point: 347
- 2. Restart goal is less than or equal to 250
- 3. Incoming rate: 22/wk
- 4. Unit rate: N/A
- 5. Dedicated Manpower: N/A t
i t
i I
t i
f f'
'I i
't i
I i
i 1
i
'l' t
i f
f I
f 0t5 4 e-CO 4~e-CD LO
'N' CD W - (*)
O e n O ra. v.
- c3 in - - co. in N c' -
bCDDT C'C D LO b C ~ D k. b C. D '. D ' $ C C D b !b C DD
.n n-n v ee in in to e-e o r-r-
8 m m
<o PL ANNED POPUL Af tom O 2e5 2e2 234 294 305 323 324 32e SM 347 333 329 320 311 302 253 284 2r5 206 255 250 245 240 235 230 225 ADDED 4 PLANNED) e s
7 le 17 22 e
12 13 11 25 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 33 13 13 13 13 13 13 PL AN TO COMPLETE O
O 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 21 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 24 to to to to te le
. ACTU AL POPUL A TION - 'E 2es 2e2 2e4 2+4 3o5 323 324 Sie 33e ser See 373 372 37.
ACTUAL PER PEntOD.
'S 12 4
e e
4
.E 10 3
0
-e e
22 3
-0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0-0
'O O
ACTUAL ADDED 21 e
'ttCCAC 1______z__
_.-._1______..
.n_
d j
c_
e
. ~
g, t
/
L C
N E
R A A A P A P L
L C C C D
T T T A D A u U U N E N
a A A D N T
l L
L E
O (P _D A P P ZWc Co
_Ozg
%O o <
D E O C L P
D R P O A O E
U M t*
U N P O P L P
E A L E
L R
T E )D A
1 I
I T
f O O E
t 4
6 8
0 D N O
N
[
0 0
0 0
E bb t
c 8
3 7 O 2 5 3
U 7
NET I
5 4 3 2.i A 8
2 O 8 5 9
I S
DUnRsS N
nDF I
enc et U F
9 s-2 O 0 di o r M 7
5 cit t
maiP e
r aair nT C
ntoI I
aND I
t t 9
7 O 5 6 9 5
eeg g O
d:
opoN T
r bT i
M 8aaiS 3 4 O 1
9 1
7 t l a:
1 5
a m :e i t s:
n h
eEe f
pr 5l 7 8
3 7 os i e7 9 O 5 5 s
w/i t t e s eemt r
1 8
C msh eED f
7 O
9 8 1
5
/ a 1
wn 1
eDm f
k 8
9 o
4 1
O 7 5 r
L
~
e bN f
q e
9 2 4 O 5 u
5 I
l C
2 a
>bm f
t 8
e 7 2
~
O 5 5 O
8 E
mE' W t
5 5 9 S
O 7 4
S mDM 1
N
.3 O 2 5 0
9 S
N 3
mkO I
,Nm 2 2 O 2 s
9
~
3 5
E I
bc i
N 7
8 3 S O 0 7
5 eEM f
G R
9 O 0 5
8 eDO f
=
O 0 5
n 9
eDN f
=
e 0 5
I T
e 54 f
=
oo 5 8
sE -
f
=
o0 5 E
e0 9 sE3 1
=
0 5
M og 8 nNm t
=
5 9
- b-1
=
oo S
5 o 0 e bD 1
(
5 mEm f
w 6,
e e0 5
o 0 e mDN i
s o 0 e mDm 1
m 5
J
]