ML20045D831
| ML20045D831 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 06/24/1993 |
| From: | Barth C NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| To: | GEORGIA POWER CO. |
| References | |
| CON-#293-14068 96-671-01-OLA-3, 96-671-1-OLA-3, OLA-3, NUDOCS 9306300105 | |
| Download: ML20045D831 (14) | |
Text
M a;r g q q p ggpgqggggg June 24,1993
'aine wu UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
'93 JUN 24 P 4 :01 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD a
In the Matter of
)
) Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY
)
50-425-OLA-3 etal.
)
) Re: License Amendment (Vogtle Electric Generating Plant,
)
(Transfer to Southern Nuclear)
Units 1 and 2)
)
) ASLBP No. 96-6M-01-OLA-3
)
NRC STAFF FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO GEORGIA POWER COMPANY'S FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS BY THE NRC STAFF On May 3,1993, Georgia Power Company ("GPC") served a request for NRC to produce documents. On June 18,1993, the Staff served its response to Georgia Power Company's request. The Staff's response was incomplete. This Supplemental Response will complete the Staff's response to GPC's request.
If other relevant disclosable documentation is discovered or if the Office of Investigation documents become disclosable, they will be provided. The Staff's supplemental response follows.
Reasons For Withholding:
A Statement of Policy: Investigations, Inspections, and Adjudicatory Proceedings,49 Fed. Reg. 36032 (September 13, 1984).
B 10 C.F.R. 6 2.790(a)-Footnote: Notes and Drafts Not Obtainable.
C 10 C.F.R. 6 2.790(5)-Intraagency Memoranda.
j 9306300105 930624
)T74 PDR ADOCK 05000424 O
)
D 10 C.F.R. 5 2.790(7)(i)-May Interfere With Enforcement Proceedings.
E 10 C.F.R. 6 2.790(7)(v)-May Jeopardize Ol's Investigation.
F 10 C.F.R. 5 2.744(b)(2)
Reasonably Obtainable Elsewhere, i.e., The Public Domain, The NRC Public Document Rooms, item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 99 3/20/90 Memo to distribution list from F
GPC Bockhold
Subject:
Site area emergency / Alert emergency followup report 100 3/22/90 Letter from GPC to NRC F
Subject:
Waiver of Compliance 101 3/23/90 Letter from NRC to GPC F
Subject:
Confirmation of Action Letter 102 3/23/90 Letter to GPC from F
2 S. Ebneter
Subject:
Regional Waiver of Compliance -
Vogtle Unit 1 103 4/9/90 Letter from GPC to NRC F
Subject:
Vogtle -
Confirmation of Action Lettet 104 4/12/90 Letter to GPC from F
S. Ebneter
Subject:
Completion of Confirmation 4
of Action Commitments 105 4/19/90 Letter to NRC containing F
LER 1990-06 106 5/14/90 Letter to GPC from L. Reyes F
Subject:
Meeting Summary
Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 107 5/14/90 Letter from GPC to NRC F
Subject:
Corrective Actions for Site Area Emergency j
108 5/29/90 Letter to GPC from G. Lainas F
Subject:
Temporary Waiver of Compliance - Vogtle 1 & 2 109 6/20/90 Memo to K. Brockman from A,B,C,E J. Rogge
Subject:
GPC Meeting with A. Mosbaugh 110 6/22/90 Copy of Vogtle DC 1-90-282 F
111 6/22/90 Copy of Vogtle DC 1-90-283 F
112 6/26/90 Inspectors personal notes A,B,C,E
Subject:
Allegation 90-A-0092 113 6/29/90 Letter to NRC containing F
LER 1990-06-01 114 7/2/90 Copy of an allegation (#2)
A,B,C,E with a memo to " Larry" from
" Allen" l
115 7/18/90 Transcript of interview with A,B,E A. Mosbaugh 116 7/20/90 Letter to GPC from F
S. Ebneter
Subject:
Completion of Confirmation of Action Letter Commitments 117 7/24/90 Memo to J. Vorse from C
S. Ebneter
Subject:
Change in request for investigation 118 8/14/90 Copy of Vogtle Record F
Correction Notice for record
- 18028-C-7-90-1, Rev. 7 119 8/16/90 Copy of GPC list of concerns F
identified by GC (position papers) (Draft Documents)
t item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 120 8/22/90 12tter to GPC from L. Reyes F
Subject:
Confirmation of Meeting - Enforcement Conference - Vogtle 121 8/30/90 letter to NRC from GPC F
Subject:
Clarification of response to CAL 122 8/31/90 Letter to NRC from GPC F
Subject:
Clarification of response to CAL.
i 123 9/4/90 Vogtle Emergency Planning C
Enforcement Conference briefing notes for pre-brief on 9/4/90 124 9/11/90 letter to Chairman Carr F
Subject:
2.206 request 125 9/17/90 Memo to various NRC C
addresses from S. Ebneter i
Subject:
Predecisional 4
meeting to review draft of Vogtle Special Team inspection findings 126 9/18/90 Press clipping - Atlanta F
Journal 127 9/19/90 Press clipping - Atlanta F
Journal 128 9/21/90 Letter to Chairman Carr F
Subject:
2.2% EXHIBil'S 129 10/1/90 Letter to Chairman Carr F
Subject:
Supplemental information to 9/11/90 2.2%
Petition (License transfer) 130 10/12/90 Press clipping - Atlanta F
Journal
l 1
Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding l
131 10/19/90 Letter to GPC from F
S. Ebneter
Subject:
Notice of Violation and Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty
($40,000) 132 5/9/91 DRAFT of Vogtle Special A,B,C,E i
j Team Inspection Report (90-xx) 133 5/10/91 Memo to J. Lieberman from C
S. Ebneter
Subject:
Vogtle Mid-loop Chemical Addition Demands for Information l
134 5/31/91 Allegation RII-91-A-0109 A,B,C,E 2 letters to the NRC from l
A. Mosbaugh dated 6/3/91 l
and 5/28/91
Subject:
GPC i
response to 2.2% is smoke, lies and mirrors l
135 6/4/91 Vogtle Special Report F
- 1-91 1 136 6/7/91 Press clipping - Augusta F
Chronicle 137 6/7/91 Press clipping - Atlanta F
Journal 138 6/10/91 Note to D. Hood from C
R. Hoefling
Subject:
Draft Vogtle 2.2% input comments 139 6/19/91 Memo to J. Vorse from A,B,C,E S. Ebneter
Subject:
Addendum to RII request for Investigation # RII-90-12 l
140 7/8/91 Letter to Chairman Selin F
Subject:
amendments to 2.206 9/11/90 Petition and Response to GPC's 4/1/91 submission
6-Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 141 7/10/91 Press clipping - Augusta F
Chronicle 142 7/10/91 Press clipping - Atlanta F
Constitution 143 8/15/91 Table of VEGP evidentiary A,B,C,E statements by issue created by 01 144 8/16/91 Memo a S. Ebneter from A,B,C,E J. Vorse
Subject:
Disposition of SONOPCO/GPC/Vogtle allegations I
145 8/22/91 Letter to GPC from S. Varga F
Subject:
Request for additional information re: amended 10 CFR 2.206 Petition 146 9/16/91 Memo to the Commissioners C
from J. Taylor
Subject:
Proposed directors decision re: material false statement during a commission meeting on Vogtle Unit 2 147 10/3/91 Letter from GPC to NRC F
Subject:
Petition of Mosbaugh and Hobby 148 10/23/91 Outline created by S. Vias on A,B,C,E Allegation RII-90-A-0092 149 10/23/91 Personal notes developed by A,B,C,E Vias on review of allegation RII-90-A-0092 150 10/29/91 Letter to Ms. Y. Washington F
Subject:
Referral of false testimony issue in DOL proceeding
_ - =
l
- l.
f Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 151 11/5/91 Allegation R1I-91-A4216 A,B,C,E letter from Mosbaugh to NRC accusing GPC personnel of lying in sworn testimony 152 11/19/91 GPC memo to department F
i l
managers from W. Shipman 153 11/21/91 Letter from NRC to F
Ms. Y. Washingtor
Subject:
Referral of false testimony issue in DOL proceeding 154 11/25/91 Letter to NRC from GPC F
Subject:
Reply to NOV.
155 11/25/91 Copy of Commitment /Open F
item tracking system control
- C00023580 156 12/10/93 Letter to GPC from NRC F
Subject:
Additional -
information RE: amended 10 CFR 2.206 petition 157 12/18/91 Memo to C. McCoy from F
W. Shipman
Subject:
l Temporary change to Procedure (TCP program broadness review 158 12/23/91 Letter to GPC from F
S. Ebneter
Subject:
Acknowledgement letter to NOV 159 3/31/92 Vogtle TS clarification 92-02 F
160 4/6/92 Memo to file from S. Vias A,B,C,E
Subject:
Vogtle special team inspection report 90-xx (3 sections) 161 4/15/92 GPC Commitment tracking F
system
.g.
Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 162 4/30/92 Memo to S. Ebneter from F
J. Vorse
Subject:
OI Case 2-90-012 163 7/7/92 Chronology of RII-90-A-0092 A,B,C,E 164 7/7/92 Chronology of RII-90-A-0092 F
TS Violations 165 7/17/92 Investigation matrix created A,B,C,E by DRP 3B 166 7/20/92 Allegation matrix created by A,B,C,E DRP 3B 167 7/20/92 Inspection matrix created by A,B,C,E DRP 3B 168 7/20/92 2.206 matrix created by DRP A,B,C,E 169 7/23/92 Memo to J. Johnson from A,B,C,E P. Skinner
Subject:
Assessment of Vogtle tape review w/ attachment i
170 10/6/92 Memo from P. Skinner to A,B,C,E S. Ebneter
Subject:
Analysis of EDG information provided to GPC in the original and revised responses to LER 90-06 and the CAL 171 10/22/92 Petition to intervene and F
request for hearing of A. Mosbaugh and M. Hobby 172 11/2/92 NRC staff response in F
opposition to Petition to Intervene filed by Mosbaugh and Hobby 173 12/4/93 Memo to J. Johnson from A,B,C,E P. Skinner
Subject:
Assessment of Vogtle tape review (with attachment) e
~
i
- l. l l
Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding 174 12/22/93 GPC answer to the 12/9/92 F
amended Petition of A. Mosbaugh 175 4/23/93 Letter to Mr. Kohn from F
NRC containing Partial Directors Decision 93-08 176 Undated Excerpt from IR 424, F
425/90-20 (Para.2.g) 177 Undated Copies of Personal Notes of A,B,C,E l
various personnel taken during i
meeting on 9/17/90 178 Undated Copy of Draft Document that A,B,C,E addressed closure of IFI 50-424, 425/90-19-14
" Potential Unreviewed Safety Question regarding spray down of the Alternate Radwaste Building" 179 Undated GPC DC 190377 F
180 Undated DC 1-90-0055 F
l 181 Undated GPC Calculation F
j
- X4C1901.855, Rev.1 182 Undated GPC Calculation F
- X4C1901.853, Rev.1 l
183 Undated Various GPC Documents F
l associated with FAVA System l
184 Undated Various documents provided F
by P. Skinner in response to l
FOIA 92-330 from GPC 185 Undated Draft of Partial Directors F
l Decision Pursuant to 10 CFR 2.2%
186 Undated Various Drafts of above 2.206 F
l l
1
, 4 9
l Item Number Date Description Reason For Withholding l
187 Undated J. Sniezaks' comments on F
Operational Safety Team Inspection Summary of Comments (4 pages) 188 Undated Document titled " Summary of A,B,C,E Additional Allegations from Confidential Source VEGP GPC" 189
' Jndated Personal Notes of J. Milhoan A,B,C,E concerning operational Safety Team Inspection i
190 Undated Personal Notes of J. Milhoan A,B,C,E concerning varioit: a!!c;;ations of Mr. Mosbaugh 191 Undated Handwritten pages (7) of A,B,C,E l
notes associated with Mosbaugh meeting with J.
Rogge l
NRC personnel read transcripts of the Mosbaugh tapes and listened to the tapes, and made notes and analysis. Following is a list, by last name, of who listened to which tape and made notes. These internal NRC personnel notes are not now j
disclosable for reasons A,B,C,E.
Items 198, 217, 223, and 224 are internal NRC notes, not disclosable due to reason D. They related to SONOPCO. Transcripts of these tapes have been provided l
to Georgia Power Company.
l Item Number NRC Reviewer (s)
Tape Number 192 Skinner / Vias 9
193 Brockman 10 l
\\
l
1.
Item Number NRC Reviewer (s)
Tape Number 194 Skinner, Merschoff 41 195 Vias 42 196 Brockman, Skinner, 57 Merschoff, Herdt 197 Brockman, Skinner, 58 Merschoff, Herdt 198 Skinner - relates to 74 SONOPCO 199 Skinner 75 200 Skinner 76 201 Skinner -
83 202 Brockman, Skinner, 95 Merschoff, Herdt 203 Skinner 98 204 Merschoff, Herdt, 99 Skinner l
205 SMnner 101 206 Brockman 155 207 Skinner 158 208' Skinner 159 209 Skinner 160 l
210 Skinner 167 211 Brockman 168 l
212 Skinner 183 l
l 213 Herdt, Merschoff, 184 Skinner 214 Skinner 186 215 Merschoff, Skinner, 187 Herdt 216-Skinner 199 l
i Item Number NRC Reviewer (s)
Tape Number 217 Skinner - relates to 201 SONOPCO 218 Vias 204 219 Vias 205 220 Brockman 216 221 Vias 217 222 Skinner
-220 223 Vias - relates to 226 SONOPCO 224 Vias - relates to 227 SONOPCO 225 Vias 234 226 Brockman 246 227
. Brockman -
248' 228 Vias 245 J
229 Skinner, Merschoff, 253 Herdt 230 Vias 258 231 Vias 260 l
232 Brockman 264 l
233 Vias 266 l
234-Vias 269 i
l l
l-l
i Item Number NRC Reviewer (s)
Tape Number 217 Skinner - relates to 201 SONOPCO 218 Vias 204 I
219 Vias 205 220 Brockman 216 221 Vias 217 1
222 Skinner 220-223 Vias - relates to 226 SONOPCO 224 Vias - relates to 227 SONOPCO 225 Vias 234 226 Brockman 246 227 Brockman 248 l
228 Vias 245 229 Skinner, Merschoff, 253 Herdt 230 Vias 258 231 Vias 260 i
232 Brockman 264 233 Vias 266 234 Vias 269 Respectfully submitted,
- $ W Charles A. Barth Counsel for NRC Staff Dated at Rockville, Maryland this 24th day of June 1993
i
}
L UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 93 JUN 24 P4.02
~
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, et al.
)
50-425-OLA-3
)
(Vogtle Electric Generating Plant
)
Re: License Amendment Units 1 and 2)
)
(Transfer to Southem Nuclear)
)
)
ASLBP No. 96-671-01-OLA-3
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of "NRC STAFF FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO GEORGIA POWER COMPANY'S FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS BY THE NRC STAFF" in the above-captioned proceeding have been served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class, or as indicated by an asterisk through deposit in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's internal mail system this 24th day of June 1993.
Peter B. Bloch, Chairman
- Thomas D. Murphy
- Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Mail Stop: EW-439 Mail Stop: EW-439 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 (301) 492-7285 (301) 492-7283 James H. Carpenter
- John Lamberski, Esq.
Administrative Judge Arthur H. Domby, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Troutman Sanders Mail Stop: EW-439 Nationsbank Building, Suite 5200 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 600 Peachtree Street, N. E.
Washington, D. C. 20555 Atlanta, Georgia 30308 I
(301) 492-7285 (404) 885-3949
-r
~.
r L.
, l David R. Lewis, Esq.
Adjudicatory File * (2)
Shaw, Pittman, Potts and Trowbridge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 2300 N Street, N. W.
Panel Washington, D. C. 20037 Mail Stop: EW-439 (202) 663-8007 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Michael D. Kohn, Esq.
Stephen M. Kohn, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Kohn, Kohn and Calapinto, P.C.
Panel
- 517 Florida Avenue, N. W.
Mail Stop: EW-439 Washington, D. C. 20001 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
]
(202) 462-4145 Washington, D. C. 20555 Office of Commission Appellate Office of the Secretary * (2)
Adjudication
- Attn: Docketing and Service Mail Stop: OWFN-16/G15 Mail Stop: OWFN-16/G15 U.F. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555
)
- #AfuM' Charles A. Barth Counsel for NRC Staff l
l l
l l
l l
_,_....,_.,.._,_._....__,._.,__,,,._...._,;