ML20043H927
| ML20043H927 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/15/1990 |
| From: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 9006270089 | |
| Download: ML20043H927 (8) | |
Text
- - - - - - - - - - - -...
+
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR :REGUL ATORYLCOMMIS S ION w.
4 4
dil '
AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION AND VOTE h00ati0nl-a0cxvIttE, xiaytxNo
- {.([ '
O0
. JUNE'15, 1990
-I i
g -7 a
, ages:.
g y t
4 victS co p q
' I,,
,a; gr EAL R. GROSS AND CO., INC.
COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCR1BIRS 1323 Rhode Island Avenue, Northwest Washington, D.C.
20005 (202) 234-4433 9006270089 900615 PDR 10CFR
^
4
'PT9.7 PDC s
o --
' N. '.
.g
,1 f
'g,
[.
~
DISCLAIMER
+
o 4
This is an unofficial transcript of a meeting.of
.the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission ' held on June 15, 1990, in the Commission's office at One I
White Flint North, Rockville, - Maryland.
The meeting was l
open to public attendance and observation.
This transcript i
l' has not been reviewed, corrected or edited, and-it may 1>
contain inaccuracies.
1>
l' The transcript is intended solely for general
~
l.
informational purposes.
As provided by 10 CFR 9.103, it is not part of the formal or informal record of decision of l
the matters discussed.
Exprer? ions of opinion in this transcript do not necessarily reflect final determination
[
or' beliefs.
No pleading or other paper may.be filed with l
m-t f.
the Commission in any proceeding as the result of, or 1
u addressed to, any statement or argument contained herein, f
1; h
except as the Commission may authorize.
k, 3 -9 1..
i j i-
}ll b
\\
HEAL R. GROSS COURT RtPoRTER$ AND TRANSCRtBER$
1323 RHoDI 15 LAND AYtHUE, H.W.
id...;
(202) 234-4433 WASHINGToH. D.C.
20005 (202) 232 6600
- s u^
i.{
'nh
's5.
i
,4
s
.i o
i 4
\\-
.-6
-UNITED STATES-OF AMERICA c
' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 1
AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION'AND VOTE PUBLIC MEETING Nuclear. Regulatory Commission One White Flint' North Rockville, Maryland Friday,' June 15, 1990 1
?-'
- 6..
The Commission met in open
- session, pursuant to.nntice, at 13 : 32 a. m., Kenneth M.
- Carr, Chairman, presiding.
li ~;<
COMMISS10NEffS PHESENT:
KENNETil M.
CARR, Chairman of the Commission EENNETil C.
ROGERS, Commissioner JAMES R.
CURTISS, Commiss'ioner
'I NEAL R.
CHOSS 1323 Ithode 1sland Avenue, N.W.
Was hi rig t on,
D.C.
20005
- y
/202) P34-4433
.e
nn n
$ %', dnn Uv n =Dw -.
c ~ W,&~% %QM Qs c. '8
- H
,% ]' % qf f ' ".u"n '.? ?KiX.Wf O W ;
N m
u vm &:y},Q%-[Q=&.
M & P ' mls:? n):
Q V
- ky 5: T_i wwd, y.,4 \\ YMf;w-pyw w mm Qnn m :p -r>un.
. y a
J g A u w %w: w; >w w.n.m w %c~e-ww* w s
&w%nmmp-,.
p p.
sWj a'er w wp+
e*m w
. J.wAv ts gym,h. 4
. =
- M P % B _o4. 5 7 9. *p a
- 4. w -
- hv % m%n,ze.v 4 i.N,:.s,-
t e3 www - w n %-t 4
2:e
, e m,
v u+.
t.
- s. g
_ kc=c.FN ' ^N.
qC U' p[ q',-
w /. bv-
- c -- + t p.
\\
sw w ign 8 n,o,
.,8 u
4Ft 1
+F j 'b m
i ~^ r l-n 1
W~C, A'. - p ". '
4 yj e w y-
- s
= m -
C #m ' '+_
- " M,' V, A
kN.WgD,a p
3 e w wm.g /
MM N' !
- N h-Mr g
k
$w w% Q M y &n g &U N ^
M N E-M [ $ e% w.
= :
-MD
~. M Nc N:31,
- M n.
m.-
s%cMwmW w
c
> =
e u
W
',w,-W www&Mmkn,
\\wmmw., a.
4
- a.. &.4.,
s K'
c
+
~. n -
4 e.
vv.
e o
?,
w ~ b.u,:1 w. ; +m.,.,.
%n, ~,-,en a.
v eo
- w s,i..
.nv. =.
.c,c.
-x v
u.
m,. s 4
~vw.
- e. v -
3, u.
w m,m.m, - --. n, r1.<.n
,w -
%e m
yw9 h;WA nw ' ' e y, m ; ~ wM M.
m 4t v.
%nW %as sa gw c
,1
~n y c'
. ': s wc W*, - x, ',u W
p1 wp
~
rw
- y :>
nc n
wm-n-
2 -.
s rm' e < _ k '^. ' p ) a,.;l~'D_ y'. ~-
4
-9 s
l'*
kbEATEDM, TETHE COM.MISS10N TAB $Ei:
e, _
w r, ",
w me e
a 4
s, MNmMbdN.9
% M.
M f
-;1.
m:
- x,o.p m.
.a,
" w i.
c
+
7-.. gnu n p=u t,
-t r
r
+
3,4g M, %a
. -r'.
,-?:.xy,.
._3,
- c. 2
,,-f.-.
p
-..,.y p _s 2
E nyMs_ _. J_ ic >,lE. _ W. s l., KSAMUNIA M CHTLX USeWet'ary' - M,; Jm..-
.r[,,9')-
I
$m n
c r
'v" Y _. ?_ o % Y. A
~e a
37
. : 9,_ ~
w^v r sia pd.w,s, a w s.
= c a
~
1
( i
=
' $l/ME$.m s7, d~d's sye
@ILLI AMfC,i E P ARLE R; fGen,e ral?,Couns el.5x,. p'. ! N -N
,. o V
P %g 9.
A 'm WL o'
.14 - rq E--
' ir_*
y a,
, & L ts M. p%~F' y& SG. -
t W;h
~
G 1
_ j.
f y-J 4
s cv^
, 9 I
_'t p'+
atmu,-.
i m:
, i 5
4' r u 2,.
%QWf ;W4 v Q M:,Vf2 r p-i M
W f* f
- c n" W 6 y ', it. MM mw a W'
.n
_,,w n..
w, s+n~%@.s ww.
w
~;m
%mw~,...-
m, V,
hQ*',;n
,p p..
n s
Ri i
" Y ', ' " b m%
bhn
~,
r w~
c.
a
.m n y L.a.:
ws v
. 'j
- g &,lqAt
->,t W@;Eg Vi,
,A,
- y miu' J e
wr a
9
.1 3"
f 7
' + <
M 3
73 n
AM s
-- P '. t o.0 R
u
.@m s
d'
- t;i
, '7 6 %, -w '+ W h.;..y/ 9q ms_ A i
en ox m_n [1 -
>t KMm s u g.,
..=.,; ly "w' -.
j
.u' 3
s *,
a.
gt=
3 u :. x1u-J4 g
A ;1 h ?v; s
_. - en :F n,
w,.,a.
y
- gn v_
1
,Ar-I x;
n-1 m q
ry s.
o.- l..
ey ca g/x, u m )p~%g h Q> gb_
_ :Qg j
+
e y
_q,','"
4, -
o yir_-
m e o'.x
> w !i(-
y 4, pt.
w..
q ~ ; m.. ;-
. i.
j j
h.du c. d--1 a
&lpW4yng cg > s's'
~4 m
v 9
J+y. -. /; M f.a ( a v.me y*,,
y yp
,+
i 4
g i i
!g. 3 y;
J-i'ghI!$,
u
,h y 4. '1, j $',q *- _,
+5 p%p#.
.'5 o.
4 j j
._1.
j 4,
- ay 2r e
s a n r 1
m 1
f, t
t s.
W m m. w w
w" " m~ m m%,c m,,,o iA c
s ww ~ '
+, w a
un u m :: ~
a A.
^,
+
y
't ;, *,
n
=s
's..
y.q.,.V + k.
r y(
s
't,. =.
~-
s r:=a
- ? 9
- b
- ) y, i '.
AW tb v
a w:j fp 4 t =s i.:/
p\\+
s
- g pr '
aw 5.
, y\\. i y[ ;g,
g a, h-.,(
.,.g i
6
-Avi j4 Qj[1 ;* 9 J%
't J
. ;3 g-fg;
-y' '1,c f
's gy'.4--Qs] n r" - 'i.'
q t
"l 8
f c
., gut'8d'
~ ;t,
<s
..st
. -g - g
.'. [
z1.
- f'a(.. g ts;
- f..
r.t c i/M(c
~% e u %
?'4Cf-V f5
=--%'
W:f:,
N.g -
, '14 Q
r s
W:yG o; W i
5-J..
w 1
cw s.g ?
{hy t) gn ? W'1,,p T
J.! {
?
s e
u iGL
,,M LW 4
t gMy )Me a2-q ~
k
);1 y
a.
3 L' f:
4
,Jgeh r
4.1 j.
-w,.
--- V
..: a pdgm +-g 4 s
a e
1 7
'N x ;.,
1
. par m :.4 g c w
4 g-w+g 1,,
s 3
w-q%m/n u e:m a
o n.4 <,
.+-
una' m
n
- - r k
n)ca-c n-w jM %
sL M W~p, I:
g> -
- 2 4 L ga s
s p.
ca ybur
-+.
n-
+t y
y
- 3.,
, yg g-p - -
..fW g Wm u.t~
s 4
~:
s g (y'?y@jF-' ig' %.W9 e 3 L, A'i 3v
~
m, s
n
=
n w: n..
qtx,.
- ':x:
-%y-R M'y c
r um
. hin m
7,j
-p-A N.m s i-6 (3s
,j,,)g;g g;
gJpM.. a :- ;+:< - -@ ;dem
..41 7
we
, w
- 4
+
m
,g 1i.
t> e w g ge
.c-
@m e m p.. e _ - ~ -J:t p m4-g r mg s.
-. r,
7:
- !,'h~
m.
1 4
4 4
s-+
N5, ?:!lM '
9' I
wg -
s N_i'i,W v i "
i -
j 0
-,Y'-
M N '?\\ ?h ^
7 I-
-Sk f
\\
I
,l
, s. j(,d.i f #
' g.M,'
t y
% E GQ i
+
i
-4. q -
's %>; d ' ' b 6, 3 p.%e x*_ --%[-
, (
, m.
_ um
.L 5
gw, o
i u
-4 s
, ~.
> y-
- 2 m
m t
d gM. a,
2 4;
.m. umy.,
m -
m i m,,
' o., a, f q' e
sa uh -
s s
s..
w
.a m
m
?c@'.,. - ~, _
y s
x N=2 M. s.bWL2
- i. L :n
am3
., =
- u '.
'k, C
[. h Y
I i
- ; ' 5 ir d
+
- .+
s.-
"J ij
- - u'
- Q{:-v yv, m.:
e r1
~> -
3
.a<
H -; p.- p,,. e,v:,
g,1,
- L,
r n'
f
, W-d at pm ge s
. -. Jr yis. g.,.
r
.. +
1,
g.c 4
1 i
_p f
- (s tm = 2W My d ' Y.b.i W 1--
/%. b i
s
,wn N g4.-
,3,
,: r+ ~
g h
t, Q
y
, g QQ g p"w%pi.-
a
_q gMw+ m -.
m
. p b 4;. M,'.
x::
~
A:
wi-
.)__
~~(.,
t.
<.p:
gn~1..pe-
-u
- one, m.
-+
shpg ~,@m!y1.W.pQyi; 7
' ^.
m:
8
~
k; 0+
t
>/
Lt ws
-1/
e(
- ...[f.Q.N " \\'$
17 i
s 3
g-y m, dml u, a, h i g.
,r y
d W:
1
-, w.
to%:
e4
'i 4 Ry@ Ag M-p; %op
.,m y
a WK J
, ; 'tT: $y;d. r m
.R G
Y %'
v
- m,3pf,on a
W. N.7 iQh -
t J*"
4 nnan 't s~
t Mni Jk
- $1Qu 4 phW h_.
m
'1 d
s yn,
y VM*
5.
M,J:
9 1
L.fl; h s s 1) s i. :
i p
i 6"
+H f s ;.a : _-
DWh s Tr NEAl.Ei GHOSS
.)
MB$$oT,
)323 Rhode Is1and Avenue >
N.W.
- l.,
u n kh.h h, h km',
Nf f a i n r, L, o n,. S. C, 20005 i
J b.Nh -
4
.# m[Nk Y MVd.4 d202) '234 M4 33
.l
^
H. m A w &h,, el b;\\,wg>t (n x,..e is* %
6 re' v.
5 or h[ y i.l " -
, d e-4
,.' h '+ M N e e.
':mq :s1 y
s j
l-t,-
h we r,, (,e,.---
y ap,-ar~'
i49+YE y i y
(
-w W, -
wm s.r. 9 - wm u,s
, m.,.,
o
-v 1 -
ab t
<t
- m y
~w ss n
.c w
,~-
u e.
,'C'-
S k '-
+'-4Y-W" r.d.
s w,g,,
-l.[,
'i e
i.
%- ";m W..-
,~
,it a
p.y
.A y
--r
- ~
f U. s y j
x T
)
.. s 3 p' /
'l
'(
s
{'
3.
7('
1:.
p.g.0-C-E-E-D-I-N-G-S.
~i
?
t O
=2
- 11 r 3 2 a'. a.,
1
-3)
CHAIRMAN. CARR:
Go'odi morning, ladies -- and!
.y
- 41
/ gentlemen.
p, iS.
-This. is an affirmationc session.- ~ We.havel l,
t 4
0.-
,one itemato:come before us this morning, w 1
lc, 7-
.Before J-ask :the~ Secretary to-lead Jis
~
q t
w 8
-tbrough the i tem - for af firmat ion, do:any of;my fell 6w.
'j c'
r 9
Commissionern shavc = any opening commen t s - 1t hey; would 4
10 11ke.>,to.make?
(
- . 1 ill Commissioner Hemick andi Commissioner t
.12
' Roberts'are not with us this morning.
f 4..
,13.:
.Mr.: Secretary, you may. proceed.-
,7
.14 -
SECRETARY CilILK:
The paper before-the-j
~
w o
- 15; iC o mnii s n i o n, - Mr.
- Chntrman, is SECY-90-178..
It's n{
A
,4
-IfD f i n o la.. r u l e entitled, " Storage of Spent' Nuclear Fuel in F
17 NRC-Approved SIorage-Caskn-at Nuclear Power. Reactor ~
'l it
'Siten-and Other"Conformin'fAmendments-to 10 CFR Parts'.
j g
192
-50.and-170."
- 20; Th(LCommission is being asked to.actTon ' n L '
L
.i ll y final rule' which would allow power reactor licensees
.j pf 21-n 22<
-t o s tore spon*
nuclear fuel 'on their reactor sites
'1 4
r r
2 3.'
undeb o, general.1icense.
The rule wi11 require that i
W ;[
'24 11connees notify th-c NRC, the only NRC-certified cask's N
,1 l'e us ed for s t orage, and that the spent fuel be stored p
25:
O.:
g_
NEAL R.
GROSS 1323 Rhode Island Avenue, N.W.
W a r. h i n c t o n,
D.C.
20005 7
1 (202) 234-4433
'N f
[
a
h.#
'N' N,;
9; s
, gg,.
.0-V,,a :,5
~
y t
4 3,5 4
y f-jy j f.
- U-J 'N >
,W f,,
f'"
_ _4 4
, 1.;
g
' wN ;
y,-:
l'
~
q y
under conditio~ns specified in theEcosk,certificaterof n'
M >;y 3 2-compliance.1 l.
a,c 3
The rule ( also -pravides procedures'> and;
~
- {
- b,
,4;
' cri t e r l'a i ' f o r. ob t a i n i n g.. NRl. approval' lof' spent fuell
~
^
- ;f
'}'.
- 5; storage _Lenskj designs.-
t.
8-9 K.
6
> Chairman C$. r r,
C o mmi s s i_o n e rs.
Rogers,-
q, d 7)
- l. Curt iss c and Remick. have approved ;t he rule: with thet
.,.w
- 02. y ; _ ;
+
.8 modi fications indicated -in our at t achment ofEJune'the
~
+
V l9_
_1 3 t h ',,
10-Commissioner Roberts did -nott par!ticipat'c-
-9 11)
'in this action.-
4 4
- 12
'Would you please affirm your-votes?
ll'
+-
13:
CHAIRMAN CARR:
Aye.
9 e
+
- (
x 14L
- COMMISSIONER ROGERS:
.Aye.
4
-15 COMMISSTONER _ CURTISS:: zAye.
' t I G --
CilAIRMAN CARD:
.ls 'there. anything: olce to, s
a
~ 17 -
come be fo re ' tis t oday?.'
y,
[k
-!D
-18' SECRETARY ClllLK:.
1-hnve nothing'further.-
!= 19 ~
~
C il A I RM A N - CARR:
All right.
We
=s tand'
.]
g, '
li L20 adjourned.
~
r.
9 T
L 21 -.
<(Whereupon, at 11:34
.a.m.,.
the above-.
J.
n e,
- 22 entitled matter was adjourned.)
=
0
)'
23
,tr, Q
.24
.j
=h h
, 25 4
m' E.
1 d
(
- C_-
t F
1 NI: A I, R. GROSS I
1333 Rhode Island Avenue, N.W.
Wy Wus.h.inyIon, D.C.
20000 (202) 234-4433 s
s
W
}
4
- .f.,<.,.
- ,:M(
j; p;.i
- 3. -
4.
+
m >;
,3 ;
CERTIFICATE OF TRANSCRIBER y
This is to certify that the attached events of.a meeting, e
s
^
of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission entitled:
m F'#8 TITLE OF MEETING: AFFI'RMATION/ DISCUSSION AND VOTE e-PLACE.0F MEETING: ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND DATE.OF MEETING: -JUNE.15,'1990 u.?
3 were transcribed'by me' I further certify that said. transcription.
0
'\\
is accurate and-complete, to the best of my ability, and that the transcript is a true and accurate record of the foregoing events.
1 s
(/ J
- (
'_1.15%.~k wV. j
(
r 0
~
.t
.y sr Reporter's.name:
Peter Lynch 3
s
- )
7 i
i f
)
. q r
\\
NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRAH5ChittR$
1323 RHODI 15 LAND AYlHUE, N.W.
- (202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON. D.C.
20005 (202) 232-6600 j
p
WW M WWWWd%%WWWWWWWWWWWdiWWfggg i
TPAHSMITTAL TO:.
Docurcent Control Desk, 016 Phillips r
\\
l ADVANCE 0 COPY TO:
The Public Document Room I(
L DATE:
8/As19 0 hgi j
FROM:
SECY Correspondence & Records Branch g
1 ll Attached are copies of a Comission meeting transcript and related meeting document (s). They are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession List and y
placement in the Public Document Room.
No other distribution is requested or required.
s Meeting
Title:
8A M
h ' O d E D 4DL-
~
j
//F
+
l l
Meeting Date:
6 // f 9 d -
Open Y Closed I
h
- h L
- l Item Description *:
Copies Advanced DCS s
- 8 L
to POR Cg li
- 1. TRANSCRIPT-1-
1X I'
i is
~
y l
l-
):
2, & # VO - /7 ?
e$
l b
?
~
-f ll t
('
3.-
j 4.-
fe i
5.
E 6-
-2 1
'5
- POR is advanced ons copy of each document, two of each SECY paper.
}
3 C&R Branch files the original transcript, with attachments, without SECY 8h papers.
o: p-A/MA _
j M