ML20041D313

Summary of 820209 Meeting W/Utils,Snupps,Westinghouse & Bechtel Power Corp in Bethesda,Md Re Control Room Design

ML20041D313
Person / Time
Site:	Wolf Creek, Callaway, 05000000
Issue date:	02/16/1982
From:	Hopkins J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8203050200
Download: ML20041D313 (11)

Text

_

h

)

g,B 16 N 9

E g

4 Docket flos.:

STN 50-482 ifen and STN 50-483 Y/ gD P

g r,.,

APPLICANTS:

Union Electric Conpany q,hf > '

Kansas Gas and Electric Company a

FACILITIES: Callaway Plant Unit 1 4

Uolf Creek Generating Station, Unit 1

SUBJECT:

SU'ItARY OF MEETING HELD ON FEBRUARY 9, 1982 UITH Tile CALLAWAY AND WOLF CREEK APPLICANTS CONCERNING CONTROL R00*i DESIGN A neeting was held on February 9,1932 at the Offices of Nuclear Projects, Inc.

in Rockville, Maryland with reoresentatives of the Union Electric Cripany, Kansas Gas and Electric Conaany, SNUPPS Organization, Westinghouse, and Bechtel Power Corporation. The purpose of the neetinq was to discuss natters related to the control room design of the Callaway and Wolf Creek plants.

The agenda for the neeting is attached as Enclosure 1.

The neeting discussion focused on (a) the applicants' proposed responses to NRC findings as documented in applicant letter SLNRC 82-04, dated 1/19/82, and (b) reconnendations made by a consultant to the Wolf Creek applicant as docu9ented in K 1L'IRC 82-153, dated 1/15/82. The list of attendees at the neeting is attached as Enclosure 2.

Most of the meeting was concerned with the SNUPPS findings and the Callaway site-specific findings and these itels are addressed under part A below. Long-tern itens (called category 3) were not addressed during the neeting because they are of lower priority and because of time linitations; they will be addressed as required at a later time. Discussion of the Wolf Creek site-specific reco nenda-tions is sumarized under oart B below.

A.

Discussion of SNUPPS and Callaway Site Specific Control Roon Itens 1.0 Control Roon Workspace Iten fRC Evaluation of Applicants' Response NRC Finding 1 Callaway only.

Acceotable NRC Finding 3 Acceptable HRC Finding 5 Acceptable liRC Finding 6 Acceptable

!RC Finding 8 Applicant to further study - expect resolution in about 2 months 8203050200 820216 PDR ADOCK 05000482 A

PDR OFFICE )

cunNameb Dart )

Nnc ronu sia pow nncu eno OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usce mi-3359%

. FEB i s Me2 3.0 Annunciator Warnino Systen i

r l

Iten NRC Evaluation of Applica its' Response t

NRC Finding 1 5 13 Applicants stated they will establish adninistrative controls to prevent adjusting the alarm to time out in less than 10 seconds. Operators will be required to reset the alarras at the earliest reasonable time after response to previous alarms.

Hith this pro'.tision, the staff finds the responses acceptable.

NRC Finding 4 Callaway only. Acceptable NRC Finding 5 Acceptable NRC Finding 7 Acceptable NRC Finding 10 Further consideration required by NRC HRC Finding 11 Further consideration required by NRC NRC Finding 12 Further consideration required by HRC NRC Finding 14

-Accettab!e with ninor re-cording to change " eliminating" to " minimizing" inadvertant actuation.

4.0 Controls NRC Finding 2 Acceptable NRC Finding 3 Acceptable NRC Finding 4 Acceptable NRC Finding 5 Acceptable NRC Finding 6 Acceptable NRC Finding 7 Acceptable NRC Finding 8 Acceptable NRC Finding 9 Acceptable NRC Finding 13 Applicant to further study - expect response in 2 no.

NRC Finding 15 Acceptable NRC Finding 16 Acceptable 5.0 Displays NRC Finding 2 Acceptable NRC Finding 3 Callaway only. Acceptable NRC Finding 6 Acceptable NRC Finding 8 Acceptable NRC Finding 9 Acceptable NRC Finding 10 Acceptable NRC Finding 13 Acceptable NRC Finding 14 Acceptable

\\,

t N

CFFICe)

................... ~.

a.....a a.a..a u..a

...auaa*.a.aa.*

suRume) one)

.........au..~.a....

NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 024o OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usa m imi-m eeo

FEB 1 G 1982 3-

5. 0 Continued Iten NRC Evaluation of Applicants' Responso NRC Finding 18 Acceptable. Verification that the lights are energized will be nade at shift turnover.

NRC Finding 19 Acceotable

4RC Finding 21 Acceptable NRC Finding 22 Aoplicant to further study NRC Finding 23 Acceptable NRC Finding 24 Acceptable NRC Finding 25 Acceptable NRC Finding 26 Acceptable RRC Finding 27 Acceptable. The aoplicants deleted their response. The new response will indicate that covers will be changed from " red" to "cl ear".

6.0 L_abels and Location Aids NRC Finding 1-Callaway oniv.

Acceptable NRC Finding 2 Acceptable NRC Finding 3 Acceptabl e.

The indicator liqhts will not be labeled "open/ closed" because those that are labeled are pushbuttons.

NRC Finding 4 Acceptable N1C Finding 5 Acceptable NRC Finding 6 Acceptable NRC Finding 7 Acceptable NRC Finding 11 Reduce to Category 3 and stuiv further NRC Finding 12 Acceptable NRC Finding 13 Acceptable NRC Finding 14 Acceptable NRC Finding 15 Callaway only. Acceptable NRC Finding 16 Acceptable NRC Finding 17 Acceptable NRC Finding 18 Acceptable NRC Finding 19 Acceptable NRC Finding 20 Callaway only.

Acceptable NRC Finding 21 Acceptable NRC Finding 22 Acceptable NRC Finding 23 Acceptable with new response as folloss: The label relating Den color to displayed parameter will be relocated from the window to the bottom part of the door.

NRC Finding 24 Acceptable NRC Finding 26 Acceptable. The last sentence of applicants' response is deleted. Applicants will add the word " channel" in each naneplate to show selection of channels.

NRC Finding 27 Acceatable NRC Finding 28 Acceptable

!!nc rinain-an scrnne, sin CFFICE)

....a............

.....m.=~~~.a

-.~.aaaaaaaa

• a -a.- a a*..a a

• * ~ ~ ~. a a a a-a.

-a"

~"a""a"

~~~"a"a-a"**

SURNAME)

......................3

.....a......a..ama

-.-~~~~.aa..

a.a-aa=**-~~.

~~~~aaaaaaa" aaaaaaaaaaa" care p

.........a...........

.....a

~~a.

.-~~.-

--"~.-..-.

a---~~~~

- ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~

NRC F08M 318 (10 80) NRCM 0240

- OFFiC1AL RECORD COPY usceo:imi meo

}

Y l

I

. FEB 101982 l

6.0 Continued

(

i Item NRC Evaluation of Applicants' Response NRC Finding 31-Applicant to further study tRC Finding 32 Acceptable. Applicant will reword last sentence l'

to state " consistently applied."

NRC Finding 33 Applicant to further study HRC Finding 36 Acceptable NRC Finding 37 Acceptable NRC Finding 39 Acceptable. Aoolicant to reword last sentence as

'as follows:

Larger letters / numbers will be encraved.

l NRC Finding 40 Acceptable. Applicants will provide a yellow border around the red labels and change lettering to white.

'i NRC Finding 41 Acceptable NRC Findina 42 Acceptable i

NRC Finding 43 feceptabl e.

Aoplicants will perform a surveillance

~

to review board cleanliness and will clean as required.

l HRC Finding 44 Acceptable NRC Finding 46 Acceptable NRC Finding 47 Applicant to further study NRC Finding 48 Reduce to Category 3; applicant will further review.

IMC Finding 49 Applicant to further study HRC Finding 50 Aoplicant to further study NRC Finding 51 Acceptable i

tRC Finding 52 Acceptable NRC Finding 53 Acceptable i

NRC Finding 54 Applicant to further study NRC Fin _ ding 55 Acceptable HRC Finding 56 Acceptable Ni'C Finding 57 Acceptable flRC Finding 61 Acceptable. Applicant will add the following sentence to the response: This is nnt a safety concern with the SNUPPS design but nerely a delay in the boric acid response.

7.0 Process Connuter NRC Finding 1 Acceptable NRC Finding 2 Acceptable NRC Finding 3 Acceptable NRC Finding 4 Acceptable omcep suRmee>

04re ).............!.......

NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 024o OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usam mi.-m-m

-~

" FEB 151932 7.0 Continued Iten NRC Evaluation of Applicants' Response NRC Finding 7 This is nade a Category 3 item. The staff requested the apolicants to su5 nit a suquary of color-coding philosophy used in the control roon. The applicants white, green, others. This should include labels, should state which applications red is used for, keyboard buttons, mi,1cs, diagrams, etc. Applicants l

exoect to subait this in 2 or 3 nonths as part of j

additional information responding to currently unresolved findings.

URC Finding 9 The apolicants suggested a fast printer (300 lines /ninute) in the control roon proper would be a diversion with a large amount of paper. The staff indicated i

that NRC has the action to advise the applicants further i

of HRC require 7ents in this area. This was downgraded to a Category 3 iten.

NRC Findino 10 Acceptable i

HRC Finding 11 The applicant will further consider.

NRC Finding 12 Acceptable 8.0 Panel Layout NRC Finding 1 Acceptabl e.

The NRC Human Factors Branch will coordinate with the Procedures a Test Branch.

NRC Finding 3 Acceptable NRC Finding 4 Acceptable NRC Finding 5 Acceptable NRC Finding 6 Acceptable NRC Finding 9 Acceptable HRC Finding 11 Acceptable NRC Finding 12 Applicant to consider further.

MRC Finding 13 Acceptable NRC Finding 15 Callaway only. Acceptable MRC Finding 16 The applicant will consider panel RL014 controls further.

HRC Finding 17 Callaway only. Acceptable HRC Finding 19 The applicants and the staff disagree on the use of mirror-imaqing in the nimics. The staff will further consider this natter and advise the appl icants.

9.0 Control-Display Inteqration HRC Finding 4 Acceptable NRC Finding 6 Acceptabl e. The last sentence of the applicants' response is nodified to note that the lights for the second stage low load valves will be relocated to the left.

omer>

suaame >

me)

NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NOCM 02e OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usam e-mm

/

V

~"~

FEB 161982 9.0 Continued Iten 7RC Evaluation of Applicants' Response NRC Finding 7 Acceptabl e IRC Finding 8 Acceptable NRC Finding 9 Callaway Only. Acceptable HRC Finding 11 Aoplicants to consider further.

URC Finding 13 Acceptable. Apolicants stated their response is nodified to note " automatic" boration on RL002.

Applicants stated that boration and dilution are not fast response actions.

NRC Finding 14 Applicants to consider further B.

Discussion of Wolf Creek Site Specific Panels The staff briefly discussed with the applicant (Kansas Gas & Electric Comnany),

the preliminary assessment of the Wolf Creek site-specific control room panels, RL013 and RLO14, perfomed by the Essex Corporation. The staff inforned the applicant that at this time only an initial review of the assessment has been performed. Froa this, it ins deternined that the staff priority rating systea differs from that of Essex Corp. The staff will perform a complete review af ter receipt of the applicant's submittal of their response to the assessment.

The applicant stated that their response to this assessment is being fornulated and likely would be provided to the staff within 30 days.

The applicants indicated they expect to submit responses to remaining itens in 2 to 3 nonths.

In addition, to facilitate the Wolf Creek SER oreparation, they will provide a written commitment to the changes described in this neeting sumsry by about February 25, 1982.

Original signed by:

Original Ciccod By:

Gordon E. Edison J. B. I!cpkins gf>

G. E. Edison, Project Manager Jon B. Hopkins, Project Manaqer Licensing Dranch flo. 1 Licensing Branch Ho. 1 Division of Licensing Division of Licensing

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/encls.:

See next pa p l

l

/lb !b p

DL. :.L.B.#.1../...dD..L..:..L..B..e.l. /....

D..L...D.,.. \\

omce>

sumnet GEd. hon /.19.....@99.k.in.......NX yns.'.l.p.9.d

.../.... D.. 2 ".......

../..16/.82 2.././.[.f../. 82 2

2 om>

nac ronu ais oo-aomacu oua OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usoeoom-awm

1 I

l

~

Mr. D. F.- Schnell.

Mr. Glenn L. Koester I

Vice President - Nuclear Vice President - Nuclear Union Electric Company Kansas Gas and Electric Company P. O. Box 149

' 201 North Market Street St. Louis, Missouri 63166 P. O. Box 208

""S**

Gera'id Charnoff, Esq.

cc:

Thomas A. Baxter, Esq.

~~

Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Mayor Howard Steffen 1800 M Street,'N. W.

Chamois, Missouri 65024 Washingto'n, D. C.

20036 Kansas. City Power & Light Company Jay Silberg, Esquire ATTN: Mr. D. T. McPhee Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Vice President - Production.

1800 M Street, N. W.

1330 Baltimore Avenue Washington, D. C.

20036 Kansas City, Missouri 64141 Mr. Donald W. Capone Mr. Nicholas A. Petrick Manager - Nuclear Engineering Executive Director, SNUPPS Union Electric Company 5 Choke Cherry Road P. O. Box 149 Rockville, Maryland 20850 St. Louis, Missouri 63166 Mr. J. E. Birk Ms. Mary Ellen Salva Assistant to the General Counsel Route 1, Box 56 Union Electric Company Burlington, Kansas 66839 St. Louis, Missouri 63166 Eric A. Eisen, Esq.

Kansans for Sensible Energy Birch, Horton, Bittner & Moore P. 0. Box 3192 1140 Connecticut. Avenue, N. W.

Wichita, Kansas 67201 Washington, D. C.

20036 Mr. Tom Vandel Ms. Wanda Christy I

Resident Inspector / Wolf Creek NPS 515 N. 1st Street.

c/o USNRC Burlington, Kansas 66839 P. O. Box 311 Burlington, Kansas 66839 Ms. Marjorie Reilly Energy Chairman of the League of Women Voters of University i'r. Michael C. Keener City, M0 State Corporation Commission 7065 Pershing Avenue

. State of Kansas University City, Missouri 63130 Fourth Floor, State Office Building Topeka, Kansas 66612 Mr. Fred Luekey Presiding Judge, Montgomery County Mr. John Neisler Rural Route U. S. Nuclear Regulatory ommission Rhineland, Missou"; 65069 c

Resident Inspector Office RR #1 Professor William H.-Miller Steedman, Missouri 65077 Missouri Kansas Section, American Nuclear. Society

'Terri Sculley, Director Depart of Nuclear Engineering Special Projects Division 1026 Engineering Building Kansas Cooporation Commission University of Missouri State Office Building, 4th Floor Columbia, Missouri 65211 Topeka, Kansas 66612

~.

4

[,.

e Robert G. Wright Associate Judge, Eastern District County Court, Callaway County, Missouri Route #1 Fulton, Missouri 65251 Mr. James G. Keppler NRC, Region III Kenneth M. Chackes 799 Roosevelt Road Chackes and Hoare Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Attorney for Joint Intervenors 314 N. Broadway Mr. John T. Collins St. Louis, Missouri 63102 NRC Region IV 611 Ryan Plaza Mr. Earl Brown Suite 1000 School District Superintendent Arlington, Texas 76011 P. O. Box 9 Kingdom City, Missouri 65262 Mr. Joe Mulholland Manager of Power Supply & Engineering Mr. Samuel J. Birk Kansas Electric Power Cooperative,.Inc.

R. R. #1, Box 243 P. O. Box 4877 Morrison, Missouri 65061 Gage Center Station Topeka, Kansas 66604 Mr. Harold Lottman Presiding Judge, Dasconade County C. Edward Peterson, Esq.

Route 1 Legal Division Owensville, Missouri 65066 Kansas Corporation Commission Fourth Floor A. Scott Cauger, Esq.

State Office Building Assistant General Counsel Topeka, Kansas 66612 for the Missouri Public Service Commission P. O. Box 360 Jefferson City, Missouri 65101 Ms. Barbara Shull Ms. Lenore Loeb League of Woman Voters of Missouri 2138 Woodson Road St. Louis, Missouri 63114 Mr. John G. Reed Route #1 Kingdom City, Missouri 65262 Mr. Dan I. Bolef, President Kay Drey, Representative Board of Directors Coalition for the Environment St. Louis Region 6267 Delmar Boulevard University City, Missouri 63130 Mr. Donald Bollinaer. Member Missourians for Safe Energy 6267 Delmar Boulevard University City, Missouri 63130

.... =

~

a t

ENCLOSURE 1 AGENDA FOR 2/9/82 MEETING ON CALLAWAY AND WOLF CREEK CONTROL RCOM DESIGN REVIEW AUDIT i

1.-

. INTR 0/B ACKGROUND

'2.

DISCUSS ITEM-BY-ITEM SNUPPS PROPOSAL IN SLNRC 82-04 DATED 1/19/82 (90%) Make Decisions On:

.a) Acceptable 1

b) Clarification / Explanation Required i-c) Unaccept;ble. Identify future action and schedule 3.

DISCUSS WOLF CREEK PROPOSAL FOR SITE SPECIFIC ITEMS IN KMLkRC-82-153

-(101) DATED 1/15/82

)

b 4

i t

i i

i

. _ _.. ~... -.

s

~

e.

l ENCLOSURE 2 NRC - SNUPPS Meeting Feb. 9, 1982 Attendees NRC Staff Union Electric R. J. Eckenrode David Heinlein G. E. Edison Steve Miltenberger J. B. Hopkins Dave Shafer R. G. Ramirez M. H. Hellman SNUPPS Staff KCP &L R. L. Stright J. L. Miller Jim Riley Frank Schwoerer Jeff Klein Kansas Gas & Electric J. M. McKinstray L_awrence Livermore National Lab D. V. Kern J. M. Pippin D. A. Lappa Gene P. Rathbun F. Rhodes Biotechnology, Inc.

Bechtel G. R. Hatterick D. R. Quattrociocchi V. H. Orlovsky Westinghouse Patrick A. Ward Tony Diperna J. M. Gallagher

-Dennis Grove Richard Wu i

3 e