ML20040H245

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of 811202 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Geology Issues Per SER Section 2.5
ML20040H245
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 02/04/1982
From: Hernan R
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8202170498
Download: ML20040H245 (32)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:r__ i Q M00 UNITED STATES ,og [ g NUCLEAR HEGULATORY COMMISSION g .j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 ,o p' b 4 EE2 s Docket Nos: 50-329 3 UEGiEG gL and 50-330 FEB S-u amu eturamg31ggg 0 APPLICANT: Consumers Power Company $Pu / FACILITY: Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 fG

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF MEETING HELD WITH CONSUMERS POWER ON GE0 LOGY - DECEMBER 2, 1981 On December 2,1988, the NRC staff met in Bethesda, Maryland with Consumers Power Company, Weston Geophysical and Dow Chemica'llo discuss ~ geology issues which must be addressed as part of the Midland OL safety evaluation. This subject relates to section 2.5 of the Midland SER. A list of meeting attendees is attached as. is a co@ilation of the handouts and visual aids used in the course of the meeting. is a listing of questions that the staff raised during the course of the meeting.

SUMMARY

On behalf of the applicant, Weston summarized the results of their investigation dealing with recent geologic investigations relating to the Midland Plant site. This information is to be ultimately incorporated into the FSAR by amendment. A formal report will also be issued to the NRC early in 1982 to document the details and methodology of the investigation. The investigation utilized information developed by various other companies and government agencies involved in dry or abandoned oil wells, coal test holes and water wells. The investigation, however, did not address all of the staff's concerns to the depth required and the appli-cant was given several questions to address prior to issuance of a revised FSAR section on geology (see Enclosure 3). A presentation was made by Dow Chemical Cogany (whose Midland Plant is adjacent to the Consumers Nuclear Plant site) regarding past Dow subsurface mineral recovery operations in the general area. No open questions resulted from this presentation. The meeting concluded with a presentation and discussion of the applicant's proposed subsidence monitoring program. I Mv Ronald W. Hernan, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing

Enclosure:

As stated l cc: See next page i l 8202170498 820204 l PDR ADOCK 05000329 {E PDR

[ }p ' a$ W G W (? Q 4' Docket Nos: 50-329 and 50-330 ~ APPLICANT: Consumers Power Coapany FACILITY: Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF MEETING HELD WITH CONSUMERS POWER ON GE0 LOGY - DECEMBER 2, 1982 On December 2,1982, the NRC staff met in Bethesda, Maryland with Consumers Power Conpany, Weston Geophysical and Dow Chemical to discuss geology issues which must be addressed as part of the Midland OL safety evaluation. This subject relates to section 2.5 of the Midland SER. A list of meeting attendees is attached as. is a compilation of the handouts and visual aids used in the course of the meeting. Enclosure 3 is a listing of questions that the staff raised during the course of the meeting.

SUMMARY

On behalf of the applicant, Weston summarized the results of their investigation dealing with recent geologic investigations relating to the Midland Plant site. This information is to be ultimately incorporated into the FSAR by amendment. A formal report will also be issued to the NRC early in 1982 to document the details and methodology of the investigation. The investigation utilized information developed by various other corrpanies and government agencies involved in dry or abondoned oil wells, coal test holes and water wells. The investigation, however, did not address all of the staff's concerns to the depth required and the appli-cant was given several questions to address prior to issuance of a revised FSAR section on geology (see Enclosure 3). A presentation was made by Dow Chemical Conpany (whose Midland Plant is adjacent to the Consumers Huclear Plant site) regarding past Dow subsurface mineral recovery operations in the general area. No open questions resulted from this presentation. The meeting concluded with a presentation and discussion of the applicant's proposed subsidence monitoring program. Ronald W. Hernan, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing

Enclosure:

As stated

  • NOTE: SEE PREVIOUS WHITE FOR CONCURRENCE ec.

"'c'>. bee next pagL4LB#4-. DL:L8#4.... DL4L8#4...... D b ~~~> .*.RHernanf,hmc , D H,m d,,,,, *,,, MDuncan,,* .E A, ,s,am,,,, 1BR8 2..........1.l.27.(82,,,,,,,1g8/,8,2,,,,,,,,1/g,,g2 une rouw ais.io, eon wacu eno OFFICIAL RECORD COPY . - m-32n 41

S. k. k M + m m o 1 Docket !!os: 50-329 and 50-330 APPLICAtlT: Consumers Power Conpany FACILITY:. Midland Plant Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF MEETING HELD WITH CONSUNERS F0KER ON GEOLOGY - DECEMBER 2, 1982 On Decer.-ber 2,1982, the NRC staff cet in Bethesda, Maryland with Consucers Power i. Coupany, Weston Geophysical and Dow Chemical to discuss geology issues which nest be addressed as part of the Midland OL safety evaluation. This subject relates to section 2.5 of the Midland SER. A list of meeting-attendees is attached as. is a coapilation of the handouts and visual aids used in the course of the meeting. Enclosure 3 is a listing of questions that the staff raised during the course of the meeting. St201ARY On behalf of the. applicant, Weston presented the staff with a draft copy of their ~ report dealing with recent geologic investigations relating to-the Midland Plant site. This information is to be ultimtely incorporated into the FSAR by amendment. The investigation utilized information developed by various other coapanies and government agencies involved in dry or abandoned oil wells, coal' test holes and water wells. The investigation, however, did not address all of the staff's con-cerns to the depth required and the applicant was given several questions to address prior to issuance of a revised FSAR section on geology (see Enclosure 3). A presentation was made by Dow Chemical Conpany (whose Midland Plant is adjacent to the Consumers Nuclear Plant site) regarding the Dow subsurface mineral recovery. operations in the general area. Ho open questions resulted from this presentation. .The meeting concluded with a presentation and discussion of the applicant's proposed subsidence monitoring program. ..t Ronald W. Hernan, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing

Enclosure:

As stated cc: See next page omes >.#.L;LB../.4bNL;L..#.4.hh..L.A.;.0.L,;hB,,ff,4,..... 0.(;.(B...f.4 a suaNaus >.RHe.raanAmc .MDuncan...............EAdensam nare >..llM.82.........llMlB2.......1/3.!/B2................ll...../.R.. OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usem u-m-m {NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 024o

MEETING

SUMMARY

DISTRIBUTION Docket File G. Lear NRC/PDR S. Pawlicki Local PDR V. Benaroya TIC /NS7C/ TERA Z. Rosztoczy LB #4 r/f W. Haass l H. Denton D. Muller E. Case R. Ballard D. Eisenhut W. Regan R. Purple R. Mattson B. J. Youngblood P. Check A. Schwencer

0. Parr F. Miraglia F. Rosa J. Miller W. Butler G. Lainas W. Kreger R. Vollmer R. Houston J. P. Knight W. Gammill R. Bosnak L. Rubenstein F. Schauer T. Speis R. E. Jackson W. Johnston Attorney, OELD S. Hanauer 01E (3)

ACRS (16) F. Schroeder R. Tedesco D. Skovholt M. Ernst K. Kniel NRC

Participants:

G. Knighton A. Thadani A. Cardone D. Tondi H. Planner (LASL) J. Kramer S. Brocoum D. Vassallo J. Kimball P. Collins R. Hernan D. Ziemann F. Congel J. Stolz M. Srinivasan R. Baer bec: Applicant & Service List C. Berlinger E. Adensam Project Manager R. Hernan/D. Hood Licensing Assistant M. Duncan-

t -I 4 v \\ l j ./ f. ENCLOSURE 1 LIST OF ATTENDEES } ,/ / + NRC Consumers Power A. Cardone D.' Budzik

11. Planner (LASL)

T. Thiruvengadam S. Brocoum R. Oliver i J. Kimball \\R.Ilernan Dow Chemical' ' ~ ~ ~ Neston Geophysical R. Nagel L. Schultz l S. Tedesco i P. Turner 1 R. Teifke s-r R. Holt l ~ ~. -. 4 I 1 1 i x i l l l l OFFICE) ..~.a..-a.aa..a.* sua=A E6 I j' DATE) OFFiClAL RECORD COPY usom mi+.co ,'.Ned FORM 315 (10-80) NRCM 024o

n j 4 i EtJCLOStlRE 3 'It is felt that evidence for a pre-Early Pennsylvanian age for the youngest displace-ment along faults identified in Devonian and Missippica strata has not been concluded from this presentation. The following questions and requests for additional infor-mation should help the staff nate its decision as to the validity of thie interpre-tation.

1) Can it be shown, by use of locally continuous beds or coal seans, that the Pennsylvanian Saginaw Fomation has not suffered faulting over those fault traces identified from structure contour naps of the Dundee Foma-tion. Traverse Group, or Marshall Fomation?

s i

2) In cross-section E-E' (Figure 15), which traverses the southeast corner of Porter township,12 miles southwest of the plant site, a vertical fault is interpreted as extending fra below the top of the Dundee Formation upwards into the flichigan romation. Give a reason to why this fault could not be interpreted as extending vertically upward to cause the observed flexure in the Bayport limestone (labeled Pama sandstone) and the offset of the thin shale unit within the Pennsylvania Saginaw Fomation.
3) Reprocess the data presented in your cross-sections by projecting critical stratigraphic horizons from other close drill-holes into the l

plane of the cross-section and by incorporating structures delineated in structure contour naps. l

4) Supply the scimic reflection line available for an east-west traverse south of the plant site. Also provide an interpretation of what structural information can be obtained from this reflection line and how such structures relate to or do not show geologic data previously presented.

N

5) tise whatever " reliable" water well data is available to fomulate cross-j sections over areas containing the identified Paleozoic faults to show that locally continuous beds in Pennsylvanian strata are not sinilarly displaced by these faults. Again, incorporate and project whatever bore hole data you can to present all your geologic data in a consistent and coherent fashion.

omce> SURNAME) - DATE ) ... +...... OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usa m eo - a eo Nac ronu myo-soi nncu oao. _

P I y, ENCLOSURE 2 't %*.e.,-,, 2 ... q%... hesuaract I muc w c m, m. 9 g

  • =.. car.

g uc-tw ek..,.,. "-e,,,c Q j j ,s h :' .=*g,;',' c '6-.-Q,.-. -fT s ~,o..... u

    • * '" *-~..

q q,;,,>. N M l t.'- b,a%,,d,sh't-t';pd_+h., l $, 3 s, , ' Yf 5 r ,ee,5,r., n g-t.,,g,, e,,s.s,s i '\\., W", *N b,,'$*q d5X *~aEi-]c{ ~ ss ( WA y G j& ~-R.k'.e. =.: ~- ~ o -..~*0C*0 ;-~ ! m-::p:s< :n=-a -3.,M, s ~" *E-OSC ,-fr/o:g~ '$ 5 $ 5 0,!'s~$" h 5./. 3 e% w; 2:.:h w d '.?.'*$T A:?;~ =.*w'a , e% t1. b</f,.G9,0 s w** ,1-i- s r =- ~4 '" #% w aV.> i ss gg ,,, : ; f,,. c, i - --. c -s. 2 fr i t.t s'y4's ,w's,, p' ~matpegwNph m - e e e,.,,, ,y i.e. m w,.4kh n,, \\ i'i.c.h'N.,Nh?hkh:r%,' <

  • n,.

scw di 4' d'55k t-r',e Wg ddffAsM.'xwbsw' %,w'Tf?F('LA,t '9,f, i' i\\%m'.f, oM <'*, \\ ' s0 i e J ! w ' ". -h i.s S A:* \\ -- $\\ sPSs' d t' j C - ec si 'W%---W ihW[Ni b /., s b'f P e SM dN'#YN[,$!h, / D h_l./ [fr,.4YEY hhkS)]f{Yh.!'

.i, /

r /iR'e s rk.. '[ h

  1. Y[Os$N'5' N

A,.n$'w%J 'u'M%py... 1 i ,'p.- p ~r G ", 6 g4 ,~%: -(;.a'::s+h v'-Q'4,4','.y'r;<4. &c~ p.w:gse. c ,s rs, n,,:&n:n.s,pi,,,.,':.M, :: %+r. n 9% wg,.,., y a< ,. -.,c.n J ~4/k*k,) w g.#- h M' ~~, .. p.- ,y n,i,. y r 5' g -%p,y'syY'tg m~%-[':'&p*h % 't 7 .5 I't I N ' s'

  1. t D

h$0'..** < s. C 'I, w. 6Hv '5 d.v'ij,

~,5'Od""

[-[:,, m,(,,,h'&$f[ * #d'$.,,#N..l,s,,'s.y. u,.s ,w*, ** O -,/,@g[;D .u? - w,, ~:

n. -

A > L hhp @.c.c.. t M I:P<,I. t O- =. ,is, e, # s -4 e, ^ ' b - \\,p e,,,Isem,,,1,L tv gr,,',. ' *7:j,[p' ;' l o T .% I,.4.d*. c, * * % * * - t-s L,1~!}., j-),.*s%a ey 't,,y[. Io'm?O-^ ~~~ ~ 2 ~, /.a,.,.---- .s' w* 5:;: * ~.'.T: t, g q,

  • /

.s s n j - -.e -s =. b- 'o i,.., *4'*,,& '- ~}S,\\ ~1 's'c.s,.sh t ' - s , -4 ) s f..-e%..\\. '*N.,.,. -t -i cG% * *',g, ~e# j

  • ~,c, a N.. igl,a es.rM--,o%.,',,R,~&,,.

s. n ,:: < *.a '4 ~ ~Q ~, % ' -, l,. 'i'ss s',

'd,,,,, >,*,WM W-sca..;L.',1?

f. r s , F.,q. A.- N

  • g 7, c w D v,.s

,' M,- s,,,.u,P~/.. ..~ ~ - t~ @d _-). ' ' }','b'I,,s,.h..s,t* f.,'$,.. -L:,,,c .s y es,- WCW,, j'ml%{~~.I',k.p] q'., s cAq.< -,'a , *O'&u.:.w:&p. ]; - }, ---. u .T. } ~ = = -t - rJ>,-}c::-e ~ o~&. '. (-l; n> Lm r r s '.'.W;-43 sr g L. ~. - t t ~~- t t S 8 Y 1 f CESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF BEDROCK STRUCTURE L STRUCTURE CONTOUR MAP OF MIDL AND PLANT-UNITS I 82 MICHIGAN -TOP OF TRAVERSE for f CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY a WESTCN GEOPHYSICAL CORP FIGURE 6

s

  • a l.

l l r I l =j i h i _. _.,_i _.. _.. __. + L._.yJ j i i l J ._._.p.._._4__._._. r ( i I i l . -._L. _._1._.._ J _.. _.lj__.._., I. I i. r e I i i ._L. - i. _L. . L- - i 4 i .. -.._.i _. _ ..)

  • p*'

l j ._.7._.- uso6amo i 1 h i p.___. _L..,.._ll"' _.J j 'I t _J._1_1 ,_ -/.-L, i

p. _._.

J ~ _. _. J _. _. _ H. _. -{ j I l l l 1 I i 7 . _i_.J __._i_l._1.___L. l tarrb i k l l g L J . r.i_. _. .._. 5.._._.._ i I l i. i i i.- . __. _. b _. _._.1_ -.,_... y I I. I. i. l .l l l l -a._.J._.l , L,. __,,.i_., _.. __. g 80 20 30 40 50 Maes a e a 1 DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF BEDROCK STRUCTURE MIDLAND PLANT-UNITS 182 MIDLAND StTE LOCATION for CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY wESTON GEOPHYslCAL CORP FIGURE, ,/

(

  • -.. _..,. L$

7 s. 't, y i i s. 13 ,0 13_' i__ N.___ N !'.D g,A h,,,, ' h... i '.c N j, R. 2 ' E. i j g. L' - -- - - Q 8,,,neleus [p N-,1 i. en * 'ess th ( -- - l qJ;.,c.g gme, p ;,; 3,,;,y y . r..r. t., ' .. f [ 'MID ND i vi,'. E. _R _ _

p. 7'y I

e 9.. ..t _ _ _ J., R.L @ '4MQ '8 .h L* *,,h.

,
7 g -t a-)p.

79 ---.o._~~_._...,.o t 9 d_., _ E.... O' - I , %[, A m '\\ ,e.(Q *,,} n' ,i mfn ~ ~ n s - ' ~ ~ ~ --= - l 3 s. 3 56. 34

  • f 33~j t

,,4 35 f

  1. i' r

s Sm.ths Crosu. E7s b'i L _ J f76 i ng s 4 3 4 N4 h/ \\ 0N \\ [ Q ' t 3 5 ,1 '\\

o7b,

^[~ /* d a___ _ ir e o C^ LJ L' e)p;' ) L',, T i.3 N. p.-...__.. _'. _ _. .;._N G F- } R. 2.. __. 1 w.. i l 3 N l T, I.0 C k_p o r i... L-- 1 ~- 7 ggd~.- 3 3/.. _.-[ # ' N,,.4. -. s ,9 3 /)b[ h,g. fR. I _....,Ef . 3,... g--.- NOT E Submitted by Geospectro Consultants to Consumers Power Compa ny,1984. DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF BEDROCK STr<UCTURE STRUCTURE CONTOUR MAP-MIDL AND PLANT - UNITS I 82 TOP OF TRAVERSE for CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY

  • ESTON GEOPHYSICAL CORP FIGURE 2

(

F' -A I A 4-e e 4 e e E a g e e e

    • ^'
  • ee

~w.-** wo- .4_.. / / e / / / / / ,mi i Q's w. <i,$, y.,i.,, --,e m _..m e....o.a ,i,,. ..m {' -= M'~ / / / /c +, /s. $,=: ~- n;::,- a> wA .... ~, s v M4 pg a a.at t w eamsc go y, y .. _ s e=== i 5lE8 7___ 5._5 I g g __ =-m = 3 a g -C-C-l l E ~=M- ~ _-=_-=-C = C--C-C -C-C-b-i-I-- M= -P. -G- =r__=_ 3 - =$5UU A b =~ Tv51 98 00oe 0 Z-.;,..: { h3,_. ,= g-_- gaRT g $DDb % M-*^e ~ sas aca. Ei5eEiEE ss 3 MN

9"""" 45"-

a on b ? *. : MM Owe 0EE k i 1 2 nt DESC88PTKpe ase gwRueT.Kun OF.Honeta 9tedTW.E Vf tfCR SC ALE .eLass Pta 1 ev sf3 0 63 ST94f e4e&Put COLue. 3 a,...:.er . ec, o e,_,,__ aj "~ g ---,e e- - - -

en iiU :, f **5 5 ?"., r~ ! 1 Y: t %$h T * '! '" ' & ~; sf&& e Em S e I '2D !, j s' # I U lIh!f fj{}, D d }D 1 3 g tl !! + ' b !;b Id !i IS ! a h' }ly l[fl}$Ift j !! I ~. [ik, ~ N '-O $:h J g., ..;I.,,,3lk, ..Q# 7 b 'l', ' b4/ h. I I ? I D d a ss.vi il3 m p c;y1 ! i: =)! i rdy .o - >. w +. i

[ o'} al3 ww l

ND E .i-19N l g gi p. 3 ,:g p < 9.:q ,Q.,; i % w._m, a a 'h. T@% ....'t ue c~:r.,@ b~ 'O 4 n*3 o W. ' j M*t'?*l j;;p +Q.9Y[j lj [ t: gr. ~.. l. .m., -. 2l 1 N M a 4, '" g $ q.-.f.74 La t; t I \\l i t i km p,y l! I M l ---4 W; b MQ~4;c[r.i. i l l 1., j la1 l l l l 5

qq i

t l i t k,2 L i -c g -s -w. ..r ] !y ld_ h@kh .s. s l' I ' h.-[I $}

  • 'i V j ga o

s r&y , %)fI;' l{. U__."__._ [7~h 2 T,' { /I .D o

d id%

![ If 4 g#cg:.asg y r g _+ .q .7 y rs. 4. \\~~ cc i I s w _ j'l 6( \\ , yr:*,! p

r e

i m. 4

e e 7.Ws

_Q/ 6 i[! J,, '/ '-r*'- -m3 rb (g U h i: N 'I Nh -"'- f / _a ~ i _1 _ _j sqeg l's K l n -! m P ?n 3C ,.,..m, s- , - ses 3 fI l 'h ' )T! - l z l-i l. ,bl 1 1; '$ I I: Mi it .{6,I pC W. I,13. j <, !,l.1f.i,i,,,t7, ir d~. e$.* 7 l'. 71-I?,di8 f

-?

i ' 'a i

  1. _ p' lI_9 f

k, l =,. i* 'i <i l [ . e.. A 0 f 'C-d'*_a~ ,-J< b}, I 3-i r/;: ,o b l }?A s 2 \\ l 1 1 c I

4 t F6r-"E
M

? l\\ i i E..i !I\\ [,U'[ k l qA ;)I 7 4 1 g I !/ g4 !]jj,!*=ll v m 2]fI! 1 I j h; > " # h j/1h l I l\\I \\.l a h.m ) fj, j. I s.i B.s E' .q 9 c l t, t ~q-N I lI-h. 'j d ! l.

  • k Is g.!

~ [ w j. (N I.., \\ 4 fii pD$ ',' l -i-l l [>,~~^hh ,~ Y f !.' @, i4u $s'c h E@gN i !bd! M i i / n;n .i .n I k khI{$ k f hh. hjf j. .gg mm, !. -, a f b. _I. Ic G,lt rl w ~ ~ ~. ~. ll . L':

n v CN 1

A I L t '** N Q

--p . g..;, 7 3;pa y ;.;,.3, g.g,;. g;.. p.,;.,, - .. s \\ ;. -~.y;y.p91g. c. -9 cc; ;;.w w,o.;, nig;,;,q4 s,4.;.,p: g; w,,y.. c w y;.... : _.,, y m;. ;,,;,..p.,;y;; p'. q,qqq._,, -z,,, p sg.,;, p. ; m t.... g. _ :. c.

g.a* ** ; v_';3+p e n 1;* y ide.tl f j-$ e ; r} y.3\\ i.l,*yp,.

E,

g) y,, r,,

g.;s ., y q, s*;; ~ s ., v...q. :.-av.:.;.wg.m:.,:.A.-..y.;...;,..,, ; c.,g.p.;';_Q;n._g;e, s.. n ., w t c.., - . :) e. Q d.; :.. % u w: v v.*1pl:+: ;. ;~ q.l M..; a ryp ~;7 e::. c. !; ;. yip;u.y._, . y _. .._ o L a,. m _. v. - -- .. _. ' q. i. .a w..w, a,9 pp.g:.. b. ;;;.., s;;p.p.. r w. .u

,
v,a.,

~7,, /, / s. ~ i >/ e9. i / / ,s ./,- , '!/ / ^ 'N[' ] p 'ly, 'Q \\; / N i //' l. , w i s . N,O / \\ % 7, .I s-3 s //, i \\4 i \\ .e,, A p %,. J A ' % : ~ Q( Q,A.! " f ~b W,Y 'l 0 i \\ 3 i ' / }.1 t / ( 's,. - Q% h i - ),- x / i 9 s r_ ! [l ,/', d ,,),) [xg'\\( ?Q. =. =,; ./ l _m '* ~ ~ t \\ l l

2. '

~ m ) k'( $f \\ I /. ,/ h f ( m. 2 /' y \\ .... l i. s s, s s s g. 3 .s g) / al g('

y. N 4;,1. y. C <-

s ti ) j - qt s% N . 'A

r ef

,.\\ .32,y7 ,s 3 s ,f u i ,b .J ~9 ~ pl.

, J a.

r s) s / e 7 e 3's p / \\ \\,. f' 3 ./ /' /

n.

r N. >/ % (I. d' 't 1 [ w% ( ~' a[\\ 4 / /,/ % \\ v.( s

t. '

,/ \\- ...........n l f. ,() h\\Ef l h \\ W' l h \\ ~. \\- \\ { / \\;. 5 \\ r, n. y & ,) j p /' /+ ,e ' s ?! D 4 1 ( t Q, ', \\. 8 l 'I I ,t'~" j-n t ( i ~. { l, + rl \\, g I s 1 .. k.\\ O b g j 3 ',\\ \\ / /~. ' / T ' k. \\ . i. I O g 8 e y\\ i N " j) j i bl / / ) T h.- l' l }l l { f( l /'.s) g 'h . ail 1r 4 w .n-

e I r I i i i g l _. _.. t.. _ l L_.,J j i l ~ * = ~ - s . \\y l .N i o 1.. _. . A. A ---- N \\ I \\ }s \\s \\{w% \\ 'N \\ j lg\\ j s' gi s V g '7 ~ 's \\ N Is \\ / s s s s g !s 3._g. . _\\.-_s \\ 1. q_. g. LA..d j'/ N \\! \\ \\

  • sN s

[ [s N\\\\\\ \\ \\ \\ s s s I. $'. N g %g ( gss Nj s \\ s'N'%s r--t,'s. s s Y N i \\ \\I\\ l\\ b \\ \\ \\ [ N, 1 \\ \\'N h k_4_Ns J-NTDs l '..! s N \\ Ny L W L.b. $ ~s g i \\ IN N t\\ g g g lk \\ \\ gug N .b _. b-NN - \\ N N i

  • st N

8 s N N g*s g i g Ni IN j s i- -*r -g7 s I \\ l \\i s t) l . _.. _.J. __.. ! \\ al..__...___. u.. __.. NOTEe 0 10 20 30 40 50 M.ies COMPANY, M 0 AN PLANT UNITS I 8 2 FIN AL SAF ETY ANALYSIS REPORT FIG URE 2. 5-7, ( REVISCN f,11/ 77 ). DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF BEDROCK STRUCTURE MIDL AND PL ANT - UNITS I 82 TREND OF ANTICLINAL FOLDING for CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY wESTON GEoPHY$1 CAL CORP FIGURE 4

.., ;,.g.w,; g..g.. y..,. ;; ; ....c- . m.. t.(, ., u,., u a r.... w..;. v.u'.n -:.cv t. w~..,"[.,,... m M...% g5,. w,r x.;e :.-.., , :- g, ;1 p., ns.5,;,y -:yp: v.. .c.:,._;w<f:g;_.z;9 ;-;;g,,. - ; - a y n n.< 9 :<:~,u s: a.a:.:. n.,.u..s in.::.-v w :-y wp pp. h..y~T.;. a v c,l.:y9q.;a..; : : < :

e. : =..

@ w.;a; ;. v.m.2.n :g.mgw... i.sw a. u.u.. w p. m.. + i.,, s..a :. c c.e: n -w. ;, :. c.,.. a -s.. .m.. .1 . -l,*. L. l .a r w. w:.x w.;.uda .:n.a na.:as n ::n;.w w':.w.%'*. ..a. s w.~: > :... t. ; %'c ij f.) *. -:. s.'... .r ' ' i '

  • r... + 'O 4

, 4 *. ,a ,, ',; ;. h i 1'd1%)@ #d f:

  • t y
  • f,. -.4t e,-

+?,'4 b./;J L s o..nn.vrie<

m. s u t t 'r'
    • t A im u_s

_ e 8 '2 _.r. s. . - u, / / 's / "l,l,,, ./ o c/;i/- \\ ij' j,49,,' \\\\ f 8 , u xV f_. 7N(//, vh q "i 7//[ Qu,7 M -/ // 4 / = 77 =,, N -~ / ~ J .,p ~ - / e ~ x. - t a C \\ I m & \\. j h r , t&' '>ys%M L TQ %y/, N' x s _\\ ,1iL %gg'7-> A < ' q,. . @. %. A, N. -r i i ~ ks 's J d* 7.'s (s \\ ~ .+ x c / \\i C ' m\\ ^ se t, \\s ' 's N / '

j. j'

[,,, /.

  • Qe

% d' <* 'N,.h.j/ \\ i-r s an io 9 ./ 1 g. .p % ~ w (. X - 's W,, N.'N il ( / - ^ y9 j. q. ~ l. ,' f,! '\\ ' A 'st /, i - i f

~,'N

&~+(/ f g '/ ,,. K y. \\ <' y / 4 'j (\\- i \\ 1 N 's \\ \\ m s ( / \\ \\\\ c / g-s ) g / \\

s. s\\s, l

i f. i f ~ x ys . - ~ x. N. m ,. s -( .'N l '{ g s' [. ) s! \\ / / ) J \\ i / r ~ s ,/ \\ 1 ( l /. / i 3 3 / V: ~ ) \\ k,- N \\ i, a i>: \\ 9, I 9 5 /.. J

v..,

./ ...L I /. /. 1, = 1 7 \\ g i+. / /, n ' N,i. ; \\ wgwentmmenwww+:wMmMcmmaxwwcTwf l l l l

e .m - a.n oe .- m ee e.e +. -m--

  • ^ ' * " " " '
  • ~

/ mw ao. o lh p$ I ~j%(, l 7.nr&.-@% cl .; d . i ;'q' : %g - - s t 1 ^ ., } Mg: - g;;)4-- -.n., ~F i ) j i,, s. \\ . l) f Gunt e r i e. r. i i i t I g s Y l l l/c ,/ ', i t i, --- d,!

  • f..... n.

_'a!* t.. ~= auc hg,

lcoes,
  • a" i

// i j .y ', / - / t i i .u. a k i l

h d,i I i h

kl 2 i u-S p itY ll

=

1 f I i t. I .m o -y j i i moest I g f } f. e mac 2n-3,,.., _i I ? i i t I m.t3e se4_;e,c_a aanw=u3e on, vaso; 4 esov

== see e { tus seu ,,g= I m., i k e ---^- .--.___.-._m___.

c. ._2 _ + n a e e 4 eo, +- 8 i

  1. ~

h Q> /- a s e I ), 7./. ,q. / n ../ 'o q. / ,o /.. s. .~ /... ' t ..d l y s i~ \\, /s,' /.. s 'q .,et e /. . \\.. N + i M YE!L s.. 4 55-F

tra.

1, - y- .,4 ~ [. /- / 4 /x i a - m.. s... aa ges. ass.uf N w_ = _ _ A 1 2 2 a i '==== gr;; = g,g.' 4= 7 = *. = = * * *. * * ' = = ' 1, i + I 6- -=.,--#- 4.~ -,,,--,_wy r-+,- -#m --y,c. ..g_, -,,-,,.--n--r,r*=-<*--rrm+rrw+-w

  • r'+1--re-----et

+ e c w * - t r.w e - e e- - r

(8cl'35c.I?N2h35515f$$$$iSMdNIN$5MMU5!s$$$f$35$sd$M ~ ..mm::wycpa-- mmm w mnwnumtwwm mmwsm n.wp n v%nu3MC'GMM'agnWinfe4;yy%2uS 4: h k @b5 h c:x ig.?;w ey&h Eh

lm erw cggs3 mm.nwe. i.#p sumqqvtywx magney
.v.

-n , - ~ x'AMlJ,'t.'.g.Q ;;:h&;9',l[ ~ y:.y:{Q $k.jn i f; 2 ;':q ;'4

  • L 1

c

c. :-'. :=: Wr.cj imme?; m 7:

= : = g :; c '.r. y ; W +;iL.. ;. -aa-a A s.--.-. --f- - --k.. ~_ H 3 / - u /,' L.WJ ,/ y w i I // ~ ~ 't.d. Nm ~ ? -W /- ,_u - s,.w_ ) 4 \\ A7 i

g,

'\\y s \\; l l f g ~, hl e -i t a ' )_ ' b RI . ; :;.s } / ! J \\. L ' 4 .,/ ..' t j a y = i. .i l i l 2 o ( ,p! J. t 7 ~ x.. y .,/ ./ \\ ,= 8, 7 + =. u,\\ .= y _ _ ~ ( 2,x .= + = X, s _., . a/ i. 1 .x .s ,..a j p L 'Y Y N ? er

l l ' t W-u -u:-m -n p.i oprr.. . rq. ~..w\\lbiNA*&,.. % M.

  1. .L.~ ',1.W$.~(%

s? nm L s I ' &Y? :"K@**9%fyk Y "? **n.~'W.1;? Z Ay>W>rw?< g I {.6F

gw-

! !! l !.l..!.l! [ ! I I lilIl l ! l I,I e ~ #! e +de W M y.-wen l I .l l l 3-4: -44 ,= 3 w, N,M,d.M;k-M I I Tk@-[k[N !: y.t. a.;. L_,

c. L,I lp.n.. -

b1. M 8 - 1,1. - C - --;.p?.. qn r t 2-

m. v.; y<.m.,c:

y.-. v. . g-l s y

.. n

) ) ..xc.M@..>..r~.h.,. h,l l gl l!!! i! i MI.M.,.,.-k+. I I .,s. el i g.. t,; ris y s... a..y, .e w...QM...g 3, .-.s 4

,U. t.

6, -@ ..4 cm% . s qd*q% c M f;.;.w * -- C.Q,.C..j M,

s..

a : - w /J-.r M. F%,s - ' \\y: ln; /g,. 5:i.%. ..m za',,,9; aR_. - t i:, i ' a..g;.&a;. t v. r m =m y t

  • w.Wh.'. :j : gfl.$

) g# j *- j~n*. p y y Jf'ph g 'i l ./ -[M47.A . #a ' p.

  • ,; sv eis O. *.yMY@f$Q mv e
-d

?N %M .',hli. N @Q MM f,)# Ii s }a l C#%1Anghj; p,. / t *y ' I' w 3 S' er. 6 31 .< vc.. %:L.*7 . f Agg g +:h Ie ; e,w,/ .ii a < E52s "4 1 .n: '.,, " >. mW 5:rM3h iti

  • " ac.A s.

[wgm. l 4 ?.M4%,7 :- .wpua .m y .: :...%,3,,; a g,, p OMMYihN% h

N3

. T. hit W,idal._ D.QiL j p- A. ' j. >/ h, 6 i 3.: I. k. fn :. <... c. ,t s -s .s NW Ms-vNaw -., - ~ Wp.M..,M,qs, g,,.

  • + * * ' }; * * ; %g.:.,J3. -@k@g$;qh.WW@W n

9:+q 'v .. ;wM 9 My~f;.; p; j?y b, Q;,Gyfg i.E

    • f-Y STU'
  • A v? N.7, D., f'b x.($ }
  • W ylli," <;&R kOh' * &g,qh
'h f ' W R;.

s ' "$j ; i. t

  • /. / '.

h',. .s. s -- " u,.. :%. g.l?.6 - -._ p

5 Wo g%,

..,,}.. >,e 7 y;;ig,y, :il?y a L p;m .g.. Q.y.. p %9 r ~-w-.W '.> {. 0 <n- - qL;^7s 4 i >in > W.g 5:"..gg 4

l

'r ,r . AM .u yyw%y4'M";,v

  1. ri
3 m;.p
.w.; gyp 3M 1, ' n M s. ', 4 7gIM,.,<n % o.;. y;nj b

.N ~.ha-9 M g la 8s 1%-;. A 'Wh

Qi
i s ',"a

.JAh Sd" I , I, r:: d ~* W 5-;; N;., h h % n 3 Y< V'i?v, 3n r? M% s l Ng e-t .:+.. o S, .l l e s .. m x.,. .-, r -r. (.

  • I l 7, ;k

, n:d:,v!JW tr-n.:. p::,, :y-t "" [M ccar#- O. m@;w x.i.; i .]. ~ ,I J; m e e.;.> twaan. 8~ .e N ...h j Q 'pW'h., ,,Myl pg.%: k. 4. 5 -I r

.a a

g& _.,. es..$. l. q.y, Wl'# y, ~% 1,Z 9 \\~~ . M;;'$.4;$. 3?$ j W' e

  • .s,..' c

.1. 'b M. p* e.c. es N;-d i %.,y; .,a v M 4 1

e..w

.g ',y $ L' f:r%. {m:$:- u eg+.mse Q g y p .s t..;.vu w .-"*) 'Yr. Q !4 AMg - ] j' h ' iy V; i3 '$$3

'q^F;,,.

L./ ^ M g-4 c:-- l -.4 g Q% g ., i 1.J..

.s ;*' ge

.,c- %,.gf,f,g.p . ?. G. gJ,.,-*e -*@..; -- ' lv ~ !- + % ~ q % y/*; .? - y

.
f.m [.

J:e ~ 1'

}*

7. .-.y.f 3

l'qby. M]
ige w

Q j' s i,a k ^ ~ \\ \\. r.,+f*i? Q's ' >:,j, - Q \\ pW:f';.' ] j [ r[@k_ h g: l ;y s'y ' .- s a q":.. s a nt v; -w n

  • [-'

{drl } !, s: t 4 m: ' + 1, Zli J n:. g ;':: mcp*a s I+% , %y l .% )., i . ).; e. ,. sg ' r.g , y~ k g... .N

J C.Q

'JM.. Op. N .c %. V F:3 e+n' TT ,e y e rgMit N ' ^. ' d, ' r fr N .. n;-. .Y.e i - ,6 +-. ' n+282 y 'pk,.7 y (', t - N' L 1 'X ' iiif. Qf:fy V. - :gpg ,J "y n p. q l jh,. .,:35 f4* s :, n ht f, 6 Y l' I'*1.~5au Dhh. m-,'.l ' $w $ $@ Y ' : % y m. r,ww.. n ww

m i &

n' W r>g I,P ww $:LM%y.rl&c t

  • y

- ?.s6: f 8 9 l. '. ' K9.A2:^) ~ gl r.* M f .M.Wwh: M m,p yg I '.. f s4."'. & %.'.'-li.' O.7,>:l8 i ? ll l ~ y p -;>'.. ',' c n.: y24%% eW. ,.e.. t , ~;

,.,...m&;
&.

'e. >.u,s.s a.y . f. i, nc04. ?.,, iN., $ $ ,h.b 5.hT ,k!h,Nkhk'N[f[b6'N-I j_ .'* l {Md.- e' ,, ' r .w w n w,oa-w i 4.... a -m i l >;y.g.

  • .C*q W,*,M wI,

e u_tu.

i 1 +,5_?.--$QQ %.~ '. l. n' $:..,.M a,L,v,. w. %g t.;; .W k. i !. . 9.,'* %'"* W ly MWf WP ' } , ' We.p.. :e ..e _ f .*-d d.i.%,. - g.x I 5 4--W.b.- . 'o c. 2.='n$u @ , [ CM !r (v I I 1. 9p,',jj[Iglg'I.ti j l . wgr#c. 6 ,w i i .i-a . : wm.x - ,a3: ..u, i t a. 1 i i ? i.' ! . i y ,e uo. . lft'g gg e?- ii1 p :J2:Q -- y [s . G?K,'{.g 1 m. e 2

---l.
h

>t - iv.Q W. ,-~ M . W h_. @.s'.

jl I. I ;

llll i! ii I g U M W M.C O.. .i! 1 6 =,..., ?.* i y... f,4 . ~..

.$f 83I

~ '. l %q,h. fy 3 / \\ ' p h'.s-g;;... ,j;, R (

3

. n.= v - % m.c:Ac> g1 w,y 9<-.w. w : ? f, f f N i,4' j.e ibl ~'. ,a. ...g. II N g, ,'y' s 2 ij

  • ii-c_-f
l.,j' x.g n-mw;YQ**MMA__ _

I p ' k::'::s.1 - i =j N 'M.- s "i-h i W ,. r J-r 4 d%@id4>c'Skd.;L.. ' i S: ' e', ci31.';i', d .C J. % rJ.$,$

2 siip*9$

Ig 3,sk$jg's 1-d i 4 a i ~ %, M..:-g tr y. . sii;e 3.:.. i , v.;.d,.f..qp<.g WW;:y~ n$*N'.. y % g! n \\ ,u L.-. + 1,t' i ,. gi, s * ;-:p.7 7 i i xwy J'a-h ed Q Q Q J:j. ) :.3y. s ,;p .cqm n:.y,Q g,' a; - ~. ', - .. r:;s.;;,.; c. s;g y %::. ;, n.a. Y i;;i r 8 a *.m w.rwr w ? - ^ : s. ..,. _. w.. ~ is.., p. b r ,v i :.. 5 N+?. 7.p.* wQ *-.'*e,m ?.'p W )!. b g.. 7 "^ ,.. 4 b+ f. ts.;'_.if. i [~ )lp, .x.g .) -w. -pr-g ,",,f,- 1* ,g ,.h] I

  • f J
. = ' -

.} .m c%,, A b s kyk h bib g }' . f . ', h ir 2 . s. A4hy,) ji N "5' .:. ~p. h e.r s U ..,q w..w;o w -w ,i 'l g- [ ..q..-:t., b': ;if %*.4 '.s U;:1 Id r^ sg;'%,", I ~.-.*m i ly.5. I (- .+ 4 .a.a.. *>. '- f $,.4g !

6 g. <.

W .p?, C:.cc -~?.:. !-y @" ! {y @ha' ',4 ? g fM:is:d -1 '%.;3 )>e $if a. '"' yV y g { MM g.t'i E .0 p i3,.O' AMf -. j - l 1 t Os. l ~.. - WM c -R.%k N' % &~~, >y y*. 3 M., $ *n -d -i,si.

y.p,yW.-

+ a..:,y :m.4.s [ .,. e s, a.:. .,kl - ' i ,l.;.m=Y '.+.: > j,,

  • %. ~ WA g

i - l l-A s. .a a ee t '.2.

- :x xt M

g4 - 4 g- '5555 9 h

i e

I- . :-t .r, ',n . !,i . s 45g i h-I (:h;: IiS r l I masw.- _,.- bi - -nW"M*MN .'1 .M R$ [ '~ l i ~s s.3

e. e. "

.~ 4 i.Ot W C g j e, W s s.* m, 4$tsb.: ,,':g B.. = n-g 4, h.)i '5 ..[ N, Nb$ M9.,.. L. -.c 18 f e&v'&.v s 4- '~p m ^:' 1 om...g. erd,.4.n5yl$; Aj]

. i, a

%ewm w g &- h md T11ea s - v%. I nl e ( u -.. ..;.[m.5 :!Q s;+;f>- +-O 1 1 l ,. _.y, %._;.G.2,.V t - ;

  • l Aq7 i*

.. \\.,' id, O,,,' w? I I-2 g i i i i

4

  • e 9

m 98'*==megh.gaw ,,mq,,,,,,,,,,, 'e ? v e ~~" 5 0 Z 3 5 !5 1 6 f A i !, ~f ? g g

8 3

e s e w J s s a 3 o m =og: ;!Esj7l @ H 5. 3 g,5 g a jll a f a g ! )s ! I i ! I If a s. !

I, ;;, y -

g -e r -3

  • l'

= 8siaaIs i a i s-g ! $ 2 2 2 5 M 0 0 S 0 1 !0 0 0 M O Ip " " l i j 8 E i m lg5 = = = 5 33 ~ W l 1hl52 5

5. $

8 ~1 .j gg ,,,,:*,{h 3 15 1ii i jE E j [i [ 55 ga w es a i W=e# 2 v.t ?3 M,! 4 'x. p q p,p-I. ig,ir g i p m : r c e qn,n +3 jI u ! :^ ' :5 'yy j, ! g $[f,d. 7!(; $n, d I X M>#. u s i,i il,! p I '9 +3555I f 3x o. F,, l 1 r'! l i t 4 w h,:.{I 4j ,1 n]h df,,,,, 'i

9:
-:+:-

5 a5'E 25 : 6Eo a

x L

n a 74 x 7.#Q. /,\\ jt'W 25555.i f -:Q:j s [!I s u $c ,t!) ;lllihl li $i t 3 o-e p%,4),t t?55$_ g&g $. e : g3 a '3 3: Q) k' - @I;,ln,l/ e ?Z y c/ fi r t y +x-K g9 i g,, 4. I T

i ky m

I "fC 4 4{aima. . pyngm' it g M* f z l g' SI p r .rv.o 4 vr% ve -&wde.- g g 0 t w!'::ing(,';M!k" _ oi m. pow:+:-w% E gyn NbE: EbbMMN l 3 W g a b U N M. k ;! M;!d j 2.l w % mig h @li kl@n$l 3@@:5 g .=r e- = M%t ggy w e::.e+.e:=X-h-m -. = -l>e., o M q'". a il7 gl n'.,; h l ]!,8[i shg -p yIl;4 u e 5555$$j)!k[4 FX yn a

  • .. -u.-=:
25 2 ? ? 3 I 8

i gn

"spil p 4 : m.-=

I m! ql!;ij pp3$ Y=,;M 4 it f rj T ii f

u$

$R9 Y '.y.h} l[ gNMnQlk[j'gi @ i n M 3Eseta M3 + m HmjS Esr- : t ( # f= 6g 'u%. Jy' j> sat =- i

l s p' M3:55 g p 'b':3:i E-g.c : eA 4y

=2:555514 i d;,; ui n E 4 hq $ s c 1ji1 w .v9 'l,?. 3 Yi'/hahFEEVEEein i ?:523: W 9~ 6yji,d,!pj'DM Vp 7 2-Mh IM, d.d j%.r.;g li ill t ,t :+:+:+ 1, r 1 . p, o.a vu),Q pgI"p:u y, c5: pp >N.e i

ggs g], ;q ggggg
,

,%r... g! T;m,jl(e w$ m-]4 %[j@ i 0 3-i f g ,f ,h,o 4]ghh!?Ik h ii w.g

$$$?:p@I f fl I

1:fUyW.I &j ciG D.h f w ] j, I' t g N s:pa ,,[. N. I $.lbgk hdhp..,kib w e. c R I i R ~ -m

a 4 I

m'. Ig' r"-

7 i FG +**.- ~mw I .<r :_ y. W.;, lg

'.%. i.,m,.qc

.. n,. w ^ b o: g .e tv 3 4 . "w 5 m i = e'?;" v-@.u/, I I., ! i12

  • ,I

.a l j l M g J s.i lx g,.. v s s 3 I l9jj g [ s I.g::sa15 3 g s s 0,- e.ll!.gs! 11gg*!!iri 32 N W.. N. ' e.e, ~ 3: u .i !, n s s r.:, 2 _ m I s 7 0 < >. ::. T,ip g m m g .A.,*e., ,. -'ei' wpe y.1 s4--4 .- 5 J NJ f. g. { w') e d ' y, i w.

k. W8[h.m% i?7 %n.

N:,l le i. 4.I t .8 -5 d M,c%. . A.o } j g g 8 mje h, 1

I I

i Ir gs m

  1. Jh-Nihg

. 'I, ss s a e M*-I e .4:55/ l,,, l }* ,*;w M.bWp.8 3i J u '* 2 .s <-: /. -:,/ a i M.f_ e 4-c. _v v o,, t.-e.. g w%a 2.9 ~ _ _ f) r %r n. m,,.,,w e-u > ~ /.C-c .v-3 e v. z 3 4#~gWA ' _-/g B? 5 t $m m b: r .fif.I h,..l*dT 67 *a l t h i 1* d'. a #.'rbi [ -Q.ff~ <l. ,?, t 4 ^N 2 q ,a [. h*. % N }h? ek5 E $. ${ a., o 23 g y vf. + et-

x.

N , ~. ~,. sm: '*1.'>

  • kt 552,

$d g JM[,a%g'-IQQ p$ 55 5 f h-%

  • /l ig g'

M,, _._y_,t.d.,, :7:s g e e %,,-a

:.z...

w 8 e, w ,. %.. - e wap p .w. f -g gefh,3 -=.a ,6 s w ..m g V,4V . h' ' g 4a.3 A,[4. e .h. m '4*Xd$ -.* KM 7.t,p* Tamp 6;-,Wp,3 G. :f:4,_

.2 [gi r>

y i W. qv-*

  1. t** j y

_e::=:. v,

n 3

It -y ,b, s.b.k. % i,, ' h -1 . g _ : _ :e- - $. -Z > g f 1 i s %ee,., % **I '" a4 i,

~..

---.b 'y (**j}f_- s g,, h.. L,, 52 d - Q'il".p= y%Y ~- t i. c ..u.;'.., -jg.M t -n _

'.44[
--:k

~,'" . D'. f. ' ?52'- D.., ;d",,' N [. .e s N:3 . ty .a ( i g.@rWid. 9) 1: W 's:si:i a.d,i.:J:S 5,;gi 37,.5 %m%j @r m

$ ' -Q*1 '* - } ~k Ja W
1) p...--

p sv-kv?., q e . ;x; <: fMit .',i. -- _-P'

f;.e 4

a.A W }- -:4

n.

".a. n: .y 2:5y[

  • zt xX
  • Jy pi

'M'd '5 f '1 $t ; N'- v.q*p' 4*arb ,e.'g* X.:OXs .M, i .y a c - g~ - -g *. -x fg; " 34 y. r

r..x v4[.m Wev.' l e-l

-e-: ~ v. f. 4g , -f*

  • 7 lf*'~;s p g,,.;1

's-r,..f e-(:1).,. ' /} ' ' ' ' ~, -:-tv ~4 .. b j . %Y. f,$;w. ';g_%. : 1 'I \\ -v- -g

  • y *,..,.n. ;

e.r Ui .r p-C+) e i!- i t I e ._ x f T- :[ .-x-!:., R.: ff CW "J.:P 8 -:-X- . *y? ^;;m.Q.7 #.!;< -u 4, L z , t i, y,.. fyp 4 p. i s ikg_9_;:1,44 4,i _;g_,_,. (_,, _ _ _- ; f,f;.g } ei ;f 324My '.3 agi n'#*Q @$ggx gg ?p, ??:$s sM. :: -i --E pd W' O e. '.I'= E-; :,ib5it$ r7At" wTi' 'S b a. e g%dP M'?(;.I' C 'i. E .. ' I i t 'E v :

  • r.4d d'

i ~ t , d[4d +. L , g,l + {_ _ ~ ;Z * : ': :. ' esvece. f,1.'C;

%.R - 4,q

-6 ^ e ^ gi.

  • ! >j

^ ! Ley l., ~ v_: yn M, M -[-6f ' ' ' 5;I. s ~f52Y3h 3,-..s%, .e p'**. .g g -f I E ..W M,m? < 1 I l{"*i d f> .... w i, 6- 'I

-)

e' 4 / fl .9 .s, l . s'8 -

M'3
:

5Y_iiii$ji:3 E-M ? .v y . x.f :c :42+., nv M-p b 4, J e' Z-E+ -- 9X- ,.g 4 f A '[' (~g-k ',. *;* h1 g ,p g. 4 '.{, %. g i 4 f ' *.- ' N { -5( ' [.{$2 ~d ~-(- 3[h> iN eios, @I ( + .s hb [ jjgl[O -$h[2i[bk(k{b[:[5f 5 ,N. ^' x.-:..g e -e. : :.:: -X U %d' h/f.., e l . %. e-:+:x:-y;//e O.f A

3. '

m f S.., L. p.s t 6 ,.__ex-: i >-4,.,,; f .. :.vr. . :-X - ::. e.g >n t

4. '.c U.f.

I I 44 .. y ;*. : J "_:. I\\, Lei _5 ~N M

    • l. 4
  • 1,-

A. se+ , jA. W;.4 6 g.- - l ;;}fyy' r5 5h .-N .Y.I p 4. ,h. S. [I'

X[,F

't. G. ?

y

q n-6 g. W k:5 4 h-

  • *. ' i- -.

1 g tl 'y

  • $,.h.e...

i. -'.$( -q' N. y 1 3 <4. j W I e,

- ' p

.-y. 4 4 - y t l g' p ', ;N, e~ ";; ~, ; :+ F!.

  • ??

5.v. l~.4 ? t'.', i { e .l ^w W.. ) -.', t

  • 9.
    :$

- '25u. N 3,-,4 W .z..o y.- ~ c r.,u ,r-y !. & g'ek % -

  • y.

gl g

f

.:6, y.' a .s,

N
g. a.:

-1 ~~ ? V**a., WW(l1eW. h% st I' ..if-.[ ,,,-$nho.PMi

  • l.

gi I l h M 9Ng kS 7 M.~ .U d $w-Q + m a a-3: m;* ww t 4.tyge U - m 9 I i ,,J n,J c. i d'; Y:2::+P-_ 6' il e M A n .f;fc L -O :- g~. p:. e. g.p'M r v; 4'@ t 14 0 "i.*

r..,
a. y O.*W.e W

l,'h p,- 4'.. gzi - ;L E '; m. J T N ely:_ '.J ' la ?% - Qb i N 4.,., xf .gfA % y.l, b'll a 7.. ? W - s. 7,w n m,. m w 4

g. g a my...v

= 3 l 'm y y y:. <+ I I I I I' Wy i d.~ ~. i;r-?.h mes 1.m$rfy & Q". } I 'd g p> g-

.Q O 29. Ow m e 8,, E i 8 6 5 2 s 3

s 9,

$z M, ?,l 1 3 I 5 i 3s o 2 Y ,I 'f, {s}$s.!,,,, g j, 2 J' .e ~ <or c s E 2 3 g: o _ 5 _2 > 1 -g s g *I rf 4. : - $. 3 9 i - 8 . 9 aa! 1* I w I* 9 c.). 1 j*s *! a g j s.y e g a a o rn i @ g m m n a p!J U q s1 b:- ti

n

+. 58 3 9 3 E W ic. Lq l!j L\\J m n c := e m r, c y b b U ue 2 v s E-m x E. c e f",- a on s1 a s a .s

  • a i

s.= aa m- . g.s m = a 4 D. 3 iu 3 I a, sW !r 3 "s j 8 a T r ss su 1 o. p. .O laa N..-.d$ p +f,,,,.fffff; mdl,!ll. $D M ',d.i.,h 4. HOE *(hhO) N.E Yh*( Z [4Y l 1 , !)2 M[ hihl )l[h,%gg }l'.y:p,', r aA.M, I

+x+:+:#

<+:<.:C, p;;s w,. c. <, m,yL,(gO + e -: .~wri p? :xx:=:: %.3 q0,,s [ ,r=faf., 3, o v y ,, y m.I.1 1r -; t e-Vh 4 L t. v:- 4CI q p, ;t.'; n i,, s i y -:i: 9. . p:.IH

  • l ; h. $

f f ),N.D q --- y$ u.,.i,e4 i 'i y.d c..Ff (e .'e d .b $ h " h hN i hh-" 2 -s.

4h1, 5

I [: 4..,* .=n M, ^ v v_ve.r. - @..., tv=.r ,a <s g' 46..!n v:a:a:. a..n1 .s J d; M,

c. DM ij 7,'l,, e:

i ,a. ,.r ~ - - - - -. 1r oo e,- ' <.c. s,a, fty =ve.r.it 4.' N. 1,.#.g 'fG,J 1..i. ;*;,,;. a vf.v, of

  • c
p.., rn.,, c E z-

-. y m..a i s.. lY I " #A"I.O " N 14 $

  1. 5'*)

4I 4 ' kr 'd bl.h' lv.. sy G. o : g I, i :,;%,4'-* Ypi, Uth/NT I'd. I l fe i1,M N } l, Qy;y'f'$s. - y.s,$I,, hr.c=~4 i Q e,.-f.rf.; 2 .M i, l,( y. q l I Q. %yg .f = o r.:0&y., . m .n ? Y.ip~ %-

-: ~. " if.h '4-::X

.,v:: -- - w' -i. 4,o %. *:' 5.q a.+3,., w,,. :cu_ _=_,_. -

p 8

1 ,1, C-:W 8. 8 W.' g :,. 4 6 __ x.,e_ a_ g<.,, = <,s..,pa..,:,, ,\\ 5 ., da ' .,f_-~, ,,1 fu .c 3,

  • ~=,

d. 3, .as.i l_ ::: 5 _ ~i:,.,f 9 ' ,e U s, n, m 8 4p4 }1 ...r 4 9%' t. i.,w,W,'16.%. ff_- - e g ',-2.y y I h. :a p.1,& % - u 'mi(1sf. ir W K *.t,D y i 7. ,g 9:-Z9,."*,

-Z-:-C C

e O 1 j$,m 29X .,s,,

  • -:-Z

-f p i.n. :Mts; 5 .. -) y.di'i,X. .d, l -,j,, ' '"r 6 [ ~y - f,M t,ph;,1,! i s.m s

  • i. J. W, p.r

--[- .M.'" i '.i, V' { # *} l,. Td, 9n [#O2 m a. Lt. ;,N.l hih Z-C #C a L,g h,. t . i ,91 t Q,MP.Ei,5 N,J4j/fid,.l 4 ? -E ~ "p M I PV q 355. $ ? '4Jy; :0 h, ; !~X Sim ', -dph@ph~; i,if,,,pi vih! ip ',,b???: 3p4,, '~-C~555 N M .' ;.., t P., n. 'h ','?,L q I Q. 55 '(jly,, MS i 6. i,i,@h,1,h ' I !.?pMi d' "o j-, q 555 i ; @hl QW.Ad#' s,h.; W h 5::2 ' ' q, l W S i R W,t'$ ', Rp f?:S,i.j,T,i /M 5 ,. h't. (u' :55555:@A.,hp.i< 55 p J",' -==e. z N w 4. i. 4. / ',nl-f- 8 -= u . e.' pi l My4 ,2 aff. y.ph f 6 i r , ' d. j, g-.,p g.. g....r.r r ..d.- W,l U urm$- M+ el,t r. A> 3 e- [: DIM.. N ev v= t,; $. Ci$;! o I M. j-5ff$ 2 3 US -25 DN,"; M. .5555 355 a ,' r' m.! iw, g. ? p,w.gm,Il,i W s < n.;,n,t ra i .. y. g., eu x - Q,,4,A m,- + - w dy,r a ve

- n &c. 1.i, w.

(r

  1. $i f!b5-$,333-Eh.,, y'q.ve/y i

r m -{A:p).ib'Any!ghth,I,,j:%.0 i,. gi %, ii . vJ4s e ,,m - $ mms j

i!,Ld,,r D.

ar= v i m .l W . w ',, y, 4. 1h lI, b+ermm,,.,,.=.- ,, u/ o a 9,,,,,,)J pr,pe u,g,y,9 l,I qi. n >m.. H.,yQ v v=3 4.. ,,.v s t s -..y; a,h.. w, e p v=-up,., r .c + , i JI 4, q .-e-3 c s. 4 9,.pi!$)'Q.cfry v,g & . Ng,: ga l%p,.,,,*

.r., :0. a y..

.r. w1,.. y ,- r.. g p. l. h y ~y 4 ,, s p: z

s.

@m,4,/ h %.,, :C 's mWr e+i-:-:-e [9 b,' m p,Jpe i,,,..,t.yc'.:t m he s,: -vm Ap u c't+' pg y k] mj N u!;s v.[q, g 9":' M, W i 3-Y,-;-i g9 % 9,- 9 e'S', , ' 'j,f.h, ,.h DYl,'. mt% h M ;t..m%..,,n.i. 3 a g-3 q! h3 p d.d; ~ I ?.nM

+:s. W :s y

c w yJ m.m a WJ:TbA /

n ;ti i.

la-

-: ' 4. r,

.,y * .ix {t 1 r,

.m sp$.)

) Pc, :p 7 l' ?,'(. u e.:...w. 4 a:p/Y -9,. , I j v ,ff.. ' " l1 1 " J' $ ,J !, 6 f,u,', q -re.p - ( C r g O R E k { b S S S S S ? 9 a sectua ala

N. CROSS-SECTION E-E' CROSS-SECTIC': F-F' CONSOUDATED SEDIME NTS 3 g M SILISTONE g :f f a e &ee g$ f h 7

2e=

N ""I' '" 3" t m l - 't 3,y,,ri,3 i h, P##.!!' ' m.,megw o pg;,'a%,,,,,, ry) s=ov t. esio e l'! \\ g,g V.]b L'*E5M s ,Y stonuters 500 4s, C%g~s,? _ -- MsCM&a8B _i% w GYP 5uMe aseMvf.dhf f 'N. gggg 8'. QQ Q tamtv snatt E W-Ki;e. mfit%Y O== o _w s uw g. a g .aa.a +2 ,74-Q M

  • b

'b'$ b 54 a.3-%% t Macacam tfC_r5 iUM-4' cm . -s.A $ ^_i~ ~M.i;32 ? i ="r~+": E*r C..- } l- .m.'- 8 umos.ana p _ b ' 3[ an cesit e ~ - - Ukt -N I N D EIZ b preshsvivasinaniPLEssfocthE E +:^{3+ L- ~2-Q-E econosov P_-Q_~~5-ir 'M i-f-'~_#- N ~' .,m. uNCONSOUDATED SE0tWENTS ~ is: dDE15 U

+-f.3 "-1

- 'IC 5~:r-35 _'~E. - _O. EG ctav Yh&W -- h 8 ?Q =227 4=E-E 3 Pi _"cid GT C3 ?2":_ E= 6. M_ 6 _ C 58"8' C G M tD.y.'~ * : _T--- 1 w---=~ ~ = - =c==- 5 O 3FMN55 3 Y*$ $$7a" U "'"""" .. s v- _m-E phMi wNd Ea 5~ <' ~~ '"~

  • <a" a Q- ] samu a saavtt

@6ar d@%3.M77-U-EJWlE -...n 4~ aminiu G3 r-$ -C-.n_ _Fr ~=W%I-SSW YLN'O' 05"*O

Y-- WHYZ.

LM4$- YFW % -1 %2 ?L @ ett:5 oct= staava O

5 y g
-ghg; s -o-y

-w4 > svuino 4 00 cc ,"fc_-%5MC .isoa j i aus a_. _m t 'll 2T$9~G$ l l hi-d w s::E ~.-.- g. e 43

!E a,.

== = = = = = = - _. A to.g. O(=- )[Tdh

  • 2000

[:[$ Y.~, _y_ {-Q,.~g_-g in avt N5t / out n z g,_.- =ygg g [dN .b I[N Q',i."" ' y frwd "'"*" } l j' l '[ % Juy

==.,,, -~ ua - y.= =n -+= n 1)l' .m. DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF BEOROCK STRUCTURE CROSS SECTION E -C' end F - F* MIDL AND PLANT - UNITS I 82 for lrasungis CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY wtsfoN GEoec$icAL coPP

.p. 8 F W-4; -rn. u. m-w i ..m , t % u.m. r m S = ._- y = .8 O {

  • l vA:.w:4

.J../.g, ~ ( e' 4 5' s , c.? se 3 4 2 . y.+.-cb '...,o J ,... f.y r.-f 3 1 - 3 .s-g

. r * *, *

-y 9 ( ; g- .w,x.o ~V "'.- cm t O .G.* y e .:e 3,

u. 4 G

3 .w.. < g y% p g s. w:.%.,. g u w w y,,. _ sc;;,. -o { .o.

4.
--c_

_-c _.A w s-=;m _ f.. :. _. _ = _ - -. .y

  1. ' g..

~,9 r i WM.f.-P.*M avutt avonon i .=t%w '.<.4 + .'J: %@.. =,2.-i -M E- [. } 3.; 9"h

y

?i v.h. j J e,e,, a 1 c.g 3 M? w.,6w .ial. g' g'.w. aM c ::% o. ?.pg we< - mi ry .M M*r - =. - _ - xg : k"w.s4:,3 4v-@. _ -..-g gI f m 7Orp ~ -. wp w g ".p. w - r_ % g.; g .q a 1.m r);r %g ,'..s w*Q 5:MLj a .]. R e.+c}^it,1% - - -. = g s p '..t 7 F *~ ' 2=cisian =.aus Q:#k... w_ _m_. coa . %.n. , -. s..o K p -.~ =. _.n x Q'" = N? -:-c 2-E IN

<v:Re,N

= t*f ".M=&5 e ' a g%.j 3 . C, " 2.=-ra-= a %.%.g a.1, y. e -WM y.'24:.g... ~ :N. ;c ..........n...n.n........n.......n..o.. ansco r=-f : e_ _n g .n.n....... n.i o. ...,..n.. n q .ax ......n...........n..r wa...y ,.r;. Ugg- .. 4 .W s ,e ......n.. .-.e.. 3.- w%; y; ._c ..o........n..n...n .... m...i ..gg;- .i.. ,2, n g fm n J *:n_,q.7 ..,...,n.u....u..n..n....o...... 83

!er.

.m 1...... .n..........n....... ,vg-p; 7 a.w,,_ -n n............

m..

.m ' %r,d M ~ .n n . in,n 1 g %., p...A en .h ....n... - e 1- - .,~,.%., n.3 ~.~ n........a.......a.n........ .=-ym, >g.c s .....n... ............ni..n....n......... w m .n...,.....no............n........n...

. -a

,uJ. . e, ~+.;.m c. .i ,gy .m ..n. ,n . ;.3. ..n a. g~*- -; n.a... a.a...n..n.. n......m..n

d...

p/ ~&w n n u.- w. 3Amn. n m- .4. g%a- ?>.; _ r n,% .lO ..,y. '<. - _F-f'.-.- g. y ' M 2- '.. i a g t; l

  • -d p%

-::p+.. .. 5=.-+:. .r.e j ~ R '.', , s m,.y 4 i $g %.p - 7 '-__. - g ; S; hY e.-- ..e cf. -.,. t. h.N ...m.,r.,,,,,,,..u a, ;; _ -.'. ~ a.=. u 4,46 o... ....u-.....en.. .n.......n. . me } ni,..u.............s .n. ,. Ji i i ,... n...a.s n.n n ,1,,,n,: -3. ..i _.. = o. .i. a n%.g .n w J W.a -;'. g " -.,,, h. - _m $4 ' m W +. R br M+ J E r-m'. _ a a .,.n u.. o ie. r. > ...n....n..en... - c _ : --: a n. u a =- m" =f. g g .u....s..... u i. ei. ...u" n g4-e Ainn. I

3., _.' __=. O,~ r_

WC.~,' ?, m .a 7 n , cog

h. NU'7.=-J
1 m

..3_ ~. Q__ 7-1 f Q s 3 t 2.~Y.;$'s ..m &c'l.' -*~". -7. G. - 't. ..h; .*nl'yh.. M d, vi%h.,/

2 n 7<,w,** C,

-em >' W,M..h n _..u .N""".-r.~~. a. ~~ 4. ...,.g*..' ,..,,.n1...a...s....e.g m. r p(2-p i ,............, 3 1,.,,.....m n e %.. 44^,) ;;. W H. tsp,a,p~.g ; gW'4.5.dJ,). x-

    • j s.

'f..._, ;

  • 008 3""'

ut.*y! m, W.,;.,,, I.,0 W 1 wf. t s* H. 1 ','/,t i i,'. I',,: y 9 E,"W*y s%#.g :- f sI. g, ) a,. i .w-[._L,.,. b,vpi e t m / oh. G M /.' I [ I 'M **- &.= % y L. g

NhfD A

8.. osm " ~.ng i I

4 e f94 p.,, ,5?e 5*9E'h$9*'$'N,WA B ?@a --: term., n.m:.wwr%n't r n,.e.M,

m, gxM;M;asr-W-:.1c-~s;i. 4

,. s r, .%. w ru s e 1 r agl 't ~,. ygk;., ~ - gfa,;* ci.:,eJQ;;p: e 's 9.,4.unu .:s:m 3 y ep. -. :p.y w-e ~... e(.~.1. g ..-t ,,, $ u 2 y ' -' - *. 'g . %,..w v 4,,, 3 ' f,# 5 g,s $ .Y + t. 8 G i5 3

  1. , ' //N.'.-;.N.,w..'n

.;;, 7 ,,. J.7 '. o,, - g .. _e . 4s47.?<M.WG

I$ [

} .c ........ c. c.z... ~ ' r8 ag3 ; . Ar, s. 7U$!}.5$f$',$7 Y Y ,Jj O 35 1 '[O'N Y.Y%&hN$b@&f Y $25&& WJ -n-a..+MW u+4M.'.X.?pF.5.e &m% 1 $3 2 . nun.

v.. h?d t-a'

\\ yy ,;. a,e..z: ; ,%y,

a,. ~
. % p w S.c

- 1 i na c . 4

m. e af

.,4,. =3 .p a. o

  • M N L 4,9-M 'gu.,. n...a:

y,..aa.m s, dr* : 3 y G. I 6y Q W)'pg 4 . : p Q l R 4.'i:f %p M 4r I = - nr. fawn %-hs.r,y 5

r. a.:~

e e c . ~& fM.b2C

m 5

T'MN3 M yy$&% $I l (?f 3 e. e [&$$ dss $ P$ 85 6 MM.Q...SR_iAi%.. - a-x. .. ~. N~ ry;w. -.;:. a.c m a..a,q-4;i %.%.i eM s ,r q; $, $

x. *. Am'

= ~ g

r - *-- ;

'ln'W.s.,.:r e-. ^* I tt s t G.0.,,

n.,.

' Nfhr . :N?f7 - :n: m~ w. w.- % -ese & 5 M.u.g c. Q .e .,rc ,. S-~Q**4 L* &5 ;l,,*gbY,h a y. ] { y)5 e. c,, W Q: y w

- v.1,t

-g .)O(0 ,. t t;wv* Q x*es. ,,V;. .t ...:~ * - o -- g ). - .3Nb ' -

  • ,,, %py---gx s-
    • J.>

g n a

s

,I g-geMg' o a= I {c @[ l '..[.ghe =-_I. W. .,,g,', s,- e, Im. 1 .w , e 5 e6m4) y L '6 .

  • A.-Qs 9 j

k'},,, i 5 V a'7. 6t #, J !I !. .4%- c '~ ~As z .,%s,+r.:9,- n&:s -P .t. t % - ', :. n.< a =

c wQ,

..g. L .<.,1lC'*)?:,1y{ F *f ;2 %a, 1.. m.c ,... Y.. '. ;v,, ~ + N 5 "* ' i 4 -*. [ T g.T ,ac.t. h g g J t 2l c 1 2 6 '? G l 05^N .C~' ..n Ly \\ s'.w;p. it*;. .c a w,, 12.Y.cwfr r w.,YM's my l k+ 2; - "Nf4M, s I*O-- e

  • +Y 'm'no:,Vgs'w..# _....

i -3., ( .. m to w,= .. ~ , 3 y L'.*. e ne p , -4.. 'y,. I,t. 9,% k3 l 1 .=* Y.A s~,l ~ ~4 i }g f: lf.Q~.si.N-y.~ .h o-k U V M 4ww*m'*em: g.jf -AD-al . a&. k= A qlT m $e s e a# M W 7 d id -e M: = PdQ@$Y. ib a. d S - en gi axi w?. ' %.n.t.%, g... -,. ~<--a.e..- *i w%y' ya . x ;-,. '-7,~ 3.5 K; ~ ,,r,, ,m ; N.-.Rr s N [;*f *p s.:d O NY.A".D**- ?'A dI.$ / I eN t i d@y% Mii.EfBfAM@5C 9 49, 7 ,s T... 'g M,. f. .x_ '_ i ,, a 4 %v Y;g5*e1mJm / JG t ii j i.'& b. ^J*

4 ,A**.. l p '? &*f 4 e l .e n a t am 7 I - -y/G ,A y - a r, O!, j s C t E a E i 1 i ,-:h,3) i t = l f g ~, e n e s v 2 ,I 3 !. ! I I ! js 3 ! . j u e j M N I E g *: $ $

  • k I

df f IIg lI.t [ f ^4 i . : I I a a ! 1 33

  • 1 1 In i !1

. M. r..,... y F 8 [ t 1e a ;;,. b o,. 2. ,-, -.,g -. e- -'*' h {t-a - -.C 3 - J.! [ gygi;.. (- -s 4 u h i ein "D 33 'd a ,..r.,,e~

r. y

,6 C 3 T 6,.- w => - A'.g*I ,s3 2- .-\\ *i-. nQ .s

  • , + ' *.

du, diW .. M; (5@f"**- b P 4 4.

  • .a, e

l;; p Ls, tw. Qi,.+. p. :- f ,f ".,.j vi

  • c h'r-J p

WJM py b j ,i w 7 j, j ~-WWr?' 7,',.; [D T.- a [ i., fq,~ W4 I~ K 'Q dy g g M' 8 .y EN. .) % V % @c. -z w.m . t }. .\\' og u g. m. g2 u m-ON. ~. --W3 R'/h4(4-A Q 7 6E *k II -2' YD - w;fg D:q I kW U 45V4 6 u%gnk kN 7 M% G Cf =,,

  • h
  • il k]tsy'g
y y~

% ;,vd g 3 Wh-t.~ g -Q4 h.ds*y . % M e g: %'

vg ;

'4 I N y e s m. ~ ,m n +- x a ' J.-.T

  • q.,-

w4 edm., 5 N *h o g N b v' a. p.,;.r- . :a%, s. o.m..

  • @w,.#,*

\\p . A.</J. -e W h vm,., -Q, '! F. : < ic.,4 4Q "1 - A.. v.- b ~1 v2 o r.? p e, s .;f. k k

[?f,.

.n:4:. ? -* I ~n .'d,34 ~e ~4 q:: ,n '*TS:: Lo Y ~,

..,gs,

.Q tw d].i,-- J t g, .cW t .; j. i- . G P, R", .U %{ k,i

  • U ~ r w,5,.n.o V,

,~ :me .a, - i., r-y#.'M< s w a

Q:

'D :.:,' k+.- me - O:

.eg,Y

-f -' ' / 3 V-L'$.. sh J P@N1sjf[a 7 s g*,i pocW', 9 ks g s ~~ <x t.w wa, - r. wQ-2 f '.~~,- - f.Q( %C (m 'g N'v[,;;.,-] 't I 'Mf' $6 A E

f. e

\\ q.' ! J ,q\\ H p,c f<. 'll Q'? g' @m f i t \\ I / / \\N1 l .a,,- , '. e, - s %e.i a e de dla 2 n 3 er r _w. ^ w* ,.,n. Q go - l l /

  • p*,

(( & { '(.. # ~.", C [ .J w

.y u.

c n

c. s va

+: a ) ;. ] [3' d(] v. h l]_-, &[' 8 f: :n Q: 4 fi M. MpKM,., 'y Q ~~ ' Y.,%.I. u..$;).

... w a

r%. g.

  1. x a

m

  • 1 T_M M 4.4.:,,

I-i. g 5ft Y* . * *A*f'f g -d. L p< 6'O Mt Js$p,;A> ? ~ sv. f.& ~- p:g*.t'.'. n -Q t.. bQ"vp .- l 1 )r .p -~ ;

o. ~f, c

y y. . n-w

-t.w l.gj a

-~. ~~ - g a ss n 1 ,W si yw

gfi 3

y"a a e I P' g,. ;pj d f' E

.Gk

,Y.ST 1 i i t @$ g 9*.( -.. m

4 6 4.e;, +

  • s5s. -

r - y )s-*y j l %? .o W,

  • - ws,.n M.

cr c. vive

  • ~ +

'b d s A e,e g _.2 ~ G t m~.

1. i 5

.~

g

%f .* r. +h ? E g _i,i e s E k 5 ./-' ':J < 1 I i z -,W s.j ! e i 1.: Gma = : - I[;3 a

.. "I a jd g

I a

  • I 3

- e; - a g.)3 z 4 ! $ ' 'I I g I rl h amslI{,IgI l j i I '. . ~. i. WapfM1 ~ r M NBfa f i. / ".p s'n j 3sI f r; r* n 7.. m m ".. !e,,) " " r "*-1 ( $ r, p 4 g-e r' g U.9 " m I t u u u a s 'u m. c

d'Ji;

, -~ "h - sc a n s si-u i a. l h $; f.U A W.; E N: dhk"_&.e ~ g f.p" r&M

s. w&m.

. +p$. ? ? Ge',

' '.p;;tA

~ i u w,, - _ 4. #r p e y. [ s ..g.

g.,%;1

+ wy J og 3 ena y o

~. w.. g

=y u

  • - e

.g a ~, r..=: &r. g;2 -.v ax r- ., x i- ? 4.Wp %

  • 2 h" C. @W@%

(QyM'-O93 3, bu ' r '..LPyh--

W3 4

W'.' { & g'< .;s-2..u'fe;e. t(y,. Jc W N.y 3I ..v-! 1.W:h:.+.' pa.%%..ymy, s-s' d- <g y j . :s ~.

  • . h (Q-G

= e %c. .m e '! ~* fM I' ?cQ 's ]g g c' g c y,,,. - .i9 6 - I, * - ,.U,):.a. *. .y s ,4 - stA

  • (j.W' m

8 M $n 7 .-w S. 13 m;r g s; j. ,,., 43,. 4 " -. y,,',%..,g s.- g, , g" ,w ,. o e -s) -.we&$

7. ', %

t

  • '*',N r.g

} - ( ,..,,h =n s 3 .N a 3#$ E9 @)'m A<, I '%I ..mm e .4 n Sp-is N:3 $ g_ (h'; b. '/ q,?. l ._p_ s ...,4

  • I t

j .l - f y y (4 ...["#q

3

[fM,a l 'i ~. m --.r ' 8 l-nW( w:w me,L 5 w%w< 5 v.m~ g.) e% % :m. 1 i} }g %,b; b.,, e. s e h r

pm

,s. 7 y-e.. n w. m . r. 4 V.T 9 y wp g, .s n-T4 = h '. bit, 3 f .m

a..

i i :- -.n a nl x ~: a >. $. ! ' 'f)1 M,M g; m l# 'Q\\ .-1, p. 4%

r. j k c

s _ s - [k

  • w hq#

m, i I I t a 4.W .i g- - a : ?.r T;< [ x

t r-i g(,

~ 4: mh..3 r; .m... p %.4%. - p @d'ht i }?,%,

,9 =

[ Q;.mir L.s Y b u w r4 s., g-Mc~ ; n;q m n ..l$*^ i 'Il r i' Mh.y, 7' '[ # d l@4 hf*t% 4,, -E s I I I

  • 'M M['-

w m.u. ,:p, %

  • ~4 s

.~ ~'

1 1 .,[gb {.' ~e m S 20'r'& e m - Ms' > e ) .I a !. i, i l @i, i $m' [I y , :i i.i3,ii 15? l l l i t i I l ! ! !s!i l ! l l ! !,! ! l-I 5 j p.. t ..., 2.,3

s -, n n e e r - - - - - - f.-- r r = rgar.sssse.JLlui p auss
p -

l , g:

t. _

. e..%. g s A ;;. s m.T,,;g g g ):%rM W .. :v;.v.m n-w 7E Eh, R "MFS - E m; wegy u.nss g, epJ.. M wm. e .c e ch. ig W1 w-w ,Q't ' k' - > if f f. f , ZrJ _ l'. f,)m,,.-) ge;M o. 8 a y ; m :. - . s.e w r.s

  1. .i-w 3 "

s iNA@M h d'h ( (s',, ~ 'b/Ob ' bh.h.Ims. thus h d wr+m 1 _5 W 3 iM@M. I id!.m#.e Q.j E!.. m%! b' t f.[Ilf- "1 g h [j;;; tm Y.Y,$'N jb7 a B m.:, w:n . A. c., _.~ ;gJ.S p'ql \\. ri,. 5 I f? e .','M i --Q 4E7, m.i t l '.J: }

  • ,J,.

h.. W,W N .8- .q' h llC g ,y.;,\\ l % ff.C+.&

~d-Y{

ll'. ;- u z a a. -. f:. ::y&.:. m .G:% 5-LV . I' y s. ,, : w yA p, 'I. ' f,, y(' ! g -m p Llg ..;$9 8 t-- r a k 'Y.,\\ 4 $~ -i l-g \\ C~ W I. ( ' L:- O' ., m:A'. ? W', *.... sj f.: i I-g'r.- q f-Ql4 ' 4..;*M* 4gi s, p g, 9 x s, 5l N&: y}. - ' (J. ] ??.f.'," Y $. :W: ,t.-b.. r.g .: ld g w e, s - ,: m. /. r.; . m. p- .N r-.- ia q-; g., 3$ 1 e M gi.Q - m [ F, k..., ~ 9.. '3*' s ? 'l [ Nb NN.I.L $ i-3sn 1e.: b, t -. .:x x. c y .y*.-.- I~ / s~

    • *r -

i 3 $.': ' s m &,,b: "4 'Ll ? I5b 6@M@W:K ' % (- Q.- ? pc . y.~ --u 6 W %s :4 W-1 M: 1- }Gsi %h TjQ 9 g. M s-s- w x M. f." 'N = g-3 b ' {; \\, M n9,'~ l', ?)

f,:,:,[

Q 6a i, I, c n py,x w)u.- s i..., l f 4 ( , n: 1-o,O .[.', 7,h, y.-: m [.*,* D, fDE.Ud.,, ' ~' 3

-- me,

3 .l 'l.. ^ .* i S. w" w, L.m g_ 3w m< ig .p~

  • ~q., &

t

~

s ( g g. y,1 ,,* W Q p-QiW; ' g y un A L; 1< , f

,k y,'.1 (k 3.-

W*1 ) \\ , 3 gye. f'- Wt ? 7(. .yg gA Es* f, g ~) e '6 i g L >::4 ' !G- . eg.fl. =h.u;., s.s. v.t-, x s -

3

.,,nd no.u ra .:. i:., g,zR k ,t s ~ ..,,.g. p. m s' w' 3. f,m:- w ?1 k k_

  • /4' f, hio

. *,, E i E i g l~l &'J;W u -m W

e t

.;.Q

~ i

  • n '% -

i." ~' ' ? Q 3*,'Q 2 y i: 5 i /Gd[. l - d.i, i ?, ,, Q h, t y y j jg 8'l $ = t ' ;' E= l j l }l *]' .A a 3 IL -Q !,ig l~y $f'(

L2 g )i S

U $$y j355ik's$.A! I I ! I O $3 I l $ $ $ 5 i ' 'q j i s. 1G3 r : s e ys!

w. N~

r-a s + r e - -- i L W I. - j.: A E h h J., _ _ 1,,JJ s ~. " ' '. - Wh,.' c-a f.12 e e c 1 , -O C ,'iu 5 .;h , :: c N2f > k*g.h.u h. I.,., %tet - 2yc9 i.. %. r W iis1 su I ~ W -4 3.s p.g w #;k, A.,, ( N - A.U a YMj b, l . 4 ** M, ~ wd 4 h M,- [*' ([ 3 '2 Y 5 6 [ L~T i.% A4h W' f'v %. I y.'qQ M " MMM r ., I '.' / ' k-. ' .Q : Q.h) Q .g w ' -d;%,9 K-- li.ttr _. h,Ag 8e z u g e 6: e s ' 7f:*.? G ' p i., ; eg j e. ,, -A c e-f at

.i-s

,, )[' Y ..e -e q, m g.j e.' 4 = j+ ]., $' D' ';' '.] {- ~ +f h: ' 3} 'g'.' s, g g = hE 8 P,$ak_ 2 n. .b' N * 4 ?,.h t @o'ar [- f 9,%g@eni-M, 'th.1 D?S 0 3 <L g -Ws .s q* g h. E , d. kj 5 b.[;f d ..qh. w

i.h

.,, d.

  • 9 si A e

d,M ,WF 4 d' ' -; 42 0 4 ',.., *. + s q.

'd 5

b's h.. %.vg E 77,*-7W 4 e' y., % ~ _.s -G7N si. h ..h

e~ m y* W, 9 x+

<o, g .. g . 7 7' A [.. .I N l;( A-f. r y'*- g i 8 / d. l-I.h o. ,, a, \\ y ..<w. .~ 'I

  • l 4

[r- , *.. 4Q -4 - j l-: ,,.,;*yf %p,- .'. W p'

  • g.

f- .'.d.d..b $.J' .is es ~ o -u g$1 h,h . o e ~~ bh] D, h.? Jy l i:j I t; N Jy.g lli ~ p-W. -rh tD i ~.Y ,N h (* *. * .a y o-

a v;

.y-1 - N ' :: l

g

\\, w.%m h $ 5 b ( ., f {"* 1 g,.f'#e.. Y ~., ~<w .. m s ,55 \\ Q' (,;;sv %-.,m -> w m .t. i ',*, e f::- ' q A '+ * -=7f i ~ A. 8'** g s' b? ? l A~ kl% ^. 5 .:[ - r u . 4%s W@y 4 Q */ J \\. ~< - ; [ : i.&. l-r-r rp* s i Lysw %. i

s..t

. w:, -.3. g %4 1-y.Q)

  • U 4

I q ON [* g 1") w#. A. t N.V; _/'* 'j r_ - -l ch -.= %C. i a i s 3j-, J%:p, s.wa. 1 r# e ['d l*h t s, s m- = m .: n M* 4pb , $c;

  • f

$ bk.! i y\\ '* *.

  • V. $

l i d -h Ek & t> v r 'r o? - hL*,(( N.'.

  • NY D.m?-..,

D. g ,1 r . h;, g.. byr y vE t-f1 'y

m [k.w I

V.[a

  • W' p

M. h [f?'L.my s ..',.n.J., pi. n K3 .m & ^ k.a 4

M ir 2

AT g-6' 1 T hj a9 aw Ng j$ . *g4 b* ' i h. t h; Q.t.;e ^ J . ~; M M ~ ti f c.- ,wn. g.3 - pw p E3) : ^ c.d g.D gk [.St-hk f:Y v, g:.v: ' /t { F4k.w.@; 'd} ; 1 ,aw m&e pmyxs"J.)%4 A M 6 MApR' M TS r;9 m t-nw e M n?&g. x; < m.c t a.ym. [/@c khd . ;r, '!- M k... $$yM if /// f ' j%'h.j Mvh ,k YM N.Vb I i i i i i i sur g1ss wt ..m

4 9 no.~- c +..' ?'.5.e'u'cohwh t',h'5'5 50 A

  • A -

l. 55 5&h

  • N ~-4a..

,4:1w,, s .X',,h ' % NW ,G"Y,'N Y&Yf*?'e* W y ~ - - ca u Al a keyae;wyM.yuw,w.pr')- e/. . * *2 gt r.ge e e

z. aq ymr

.r c.- v ' s_ y f / f, kl%'i'## h ' h h'#, 'I *k j' m'#fGr."5N,,r;: - P? ' -J s .. 's c?ft*

  • ' ;c ; '. R '

y Q L 'f '~-w-b _y,'..;^~**.'-_".-+3; y y 3

t g

.--.~+..'ep',..' e. g-W:s' -.~,..;.

a 3

- j'

^.
    • a

.. * %~ t t E C Y s U S f*' f$ f8!*g - E

....,s. h i.*;i d.f3,'

-54 k-b h 5.f..F.iti 3 i j i ;; ; i:.! . i 1. N 3

    • ?

..... ~

v. #

m. 3 g - -- *j e v s acufp.g';q:<. w y,f.... v y 3,. -,l,! I i,; y; j- ~ J. Es/

  • h,:. l 4

[ j i j ra o -./. 4 > ;; i 44',,yp.4,gy s _ ~ ,,_..y . 4% A E ' !. N+Nh @ M N _Eb. l-i$$ mm e, m@ .ci %WeMWMGeis%W /;s A* Sa f 2 ' S ^ imiM0WM:n.dai;.4G%+,"Vi%~~ W:n &j:p !: A n.%. jn m <; g .7.:.y M w %aw3Q h+n.C T n ta h'yl k. k E .n-5%.-m%w%.-u,.,4,,g%.--m;;N@u.mai%b M<%.u% i .,. y i M.,; . 1..f, [2 -E 7 4 g f 3 q e g. 1 -.~v' g-Q,,. s.s %....KW v S~ .q s 3.;:: ~. ,., w. .g. hJ W.s, --9

  • > v

';*24.ki8.M@,g &lM*5 N > h'o M$5 M l' ins d*dt?..

w w-%.u-w g,.~n ;y D / 'f l

( 3 w,r r ' f.U fN 3.,M .h$h Y { Y.5 $ 5 5 ,f 'iL ~ ?iiiY -M 5 3 M M M h s @m er: 4. '}w[L - c ^ f s- .l ~ :a.w,,p-: w w w3 y.-\\' .c ~ ...g,. v .+^.Fsi - 9& t ,~ ~ i 9, Q.[y'ddh. Q e.) Q T"7*%~f a f: l$k,p)[l? 0

g. -yce -

.?fgE k plx

4. -

e.,. w.. q. _w._nm e ,%n., m,.u e %a-i 1 teq.,7] wd i sgaj.. _.. o I o, ( 33. 0 g

. i_

s e

..~ y u y U tl N f ~,,, & p,

& e- $ ',g T m -' '._ O I',S:Y. y T h., ' Y"'* '4 j-4 I- E ? U .. 2.< 7. v. 3.- ag., :.- ,o g " [<;Mi' g.J.D:-C *.s;3,... c i T ' b-d 5= =* Q.f;.* N b. y 33 q W in i. c.E,, ' 't3 E# h 8 p jM O. e .i i _n e-ms 8y . ;T g r MQ iQ, I. (.M I- 'n y 2.'fTk=c 5 Yd? ? @ d 3 I ed t 5 _t 6 l Q(J m.Rh ?l$,{} 4M ' *g. m m- ~r 4 g;.yg (/ L:: W I

F

/. k' MN'1-i h; Fg%-- ' y(o yf, ey k'#N lY W 97 < l L me.+.6;.6. c_. m--- 5-q.A: %e1 r a h y[>% i [W Y;;?le s, t, h%:f2 ?r Y hMh T --)I 'I I~ [wsgg.,[.,,.fi%5m,?*thN@N,AQ. Q 1 7A ] E3 ha$e{4-

iWWE, i.eum e

i-0 m m' ~w'e W.,$y9 MPk'% f@:@* ' ' ' h F .W F $,6{MWEinm9.;( M( {c MW8 ".p @nwJ .; b v.*M; 7 Mk #. . Q *. I 1 I

4..:

S;y.yMy ^ ' ' 'g su.4m. ~~ p e ... 9, - c --m, c.: e f. n spre gs&p' f %.a J Tb h. 'jg,nL i

D .*a s I T r ^, - 700 A .m ^_ A A........ A n y'. ::9. v.':.r.c; u.;:.:.: .. m...;..... w ;!' M..:,... g ,..;.. :.;... a. b...:;. ::::. :\\ t. e.M ... e.:.c..;.c :.7;-l,-- (.:.:.:.*: :i.;:;. s. ....a....; ; .i.* : 1. y.v. e. ". - :.. *;:... 7.a,.,: : ::...:::.' :: :.: t. :..

1..
., W.. U.....C: *,..: i A. y....

.. Y.. 600

s... <......... <,.,..

,.'e...... -..,...t..... ;.: .l? :.. .: *.. '......:.. '... i t*.. ?.l.';..C:.. '. ; _.. ; :...:.'.....,.. ;... .s..~',- .. ;. p < - ~..,_..-.,...>.L.a-... ' --. ~. '. l

  • ^... y-

- _. =. - _.... -.. - S00 ...,..;.,...................y

l..

..3. - - - - m. LX.~,..- -, o. g.. 3 -.. - -. &##. -.syW.. h 7; .~ /- ni:i-8 q' wi.....e r - 400 .*S Q..fQ i.? ?.);9 L':.. .,g. .t. ~.w. m yi.. -.....z,' w =u. w... o' p. - ..;.a. ., p:: r '~ n

x.....

~ ..~ ~. ~.. + .....,.,.e g &. ,a .s t- ..s..-..t-...?

;l.:

~ - 300

J. n p,

j.. ., ;., % g<.3'.,., . g t.f; .g;.<' :,g ne 3ay,; ,a .?c. <4...s.. <.~.... p. a.:f.,.. t.:.. e ~ ~:...;,

g. g. g..
  • v
"
v.xd x.

un..;: s

c.

=- .".~ H:: w.... :::...vi.:. ~ - t.. w.. 7.,,.:u. a. e <~.;.. mm:, s. ..._.w. N-,.__..-..._.. ~.:,. ......_..-.,n...._,.:y..>. -200 -= ...m....-....-.- ., n. n._. ,..u.s.,,,.y..--*..*.. - * * * = - - -. e y -- t JM.... M y.-. . i %...,.5 en

m. ei.

N .y, r. . 100 Mississippian ' t. - aca level ~ ...,: t Drift Sandstone Dry or abandoned oil well J

  • eet v,..

r .'r m U Ccal test hole Shale 1 O 1/2 Ifater well I 411cs l i Ho-izonte.1 scale Cross Section C-C' through Dry er Abandoned Oil Wells 3 s i i h l l DESCRIPTION AND EVALUATION OF BEOROCK STRUCTURE MIDL AND PLANT - UNITS I 82 GARFIELD CROSS SECTION . r l for 00NSUMERS POWER COMPANY WESToN GEOPHY$lCAL CORP reGURC 3 !l <l

ENCLOSURE 3 It is felt ti.at evidence for a pre-Early Pennsylvanian age for the youngest displace-ment along faults identified in Devonian and ' Mississippian strata has 'not been concluded from this presentation. The following questions and requests for addit 1onal infor-mation should help the staff make its decision as to the validity of this interpre-tation.

1) Can it be shown, by use of locally continuous beds or coal seams, that the Pennsylvanian Saginaw Formation has not suffered faulting over those fault traces identified from structure contour maps of the Dundee Forma-tion, Traverse Group, or Marshall Fonnation?
2) In cross-section E-E' (Figure 15), which traverses the southeast corner of Porter township,12 miles southwest of the plant site, a vertical fault is interpreted as extending from below the top of the Dundee Formation upwards into the Michigan Formation. Give a reason to why this fault could not be interpreted as extending vertically upward to cause the observed flexure in the Bayport limestone (labeled Parma sandstone) and the offset of the thin shale unit within the Pennsylvania Saginaw Formation.
3) Reprocess the data presented in your cross-sections by projecting critical stratigraphic horizons from other close drill-holes into the plane of the cross-section and by incorporating structures delineated in structure contour maps.
4) Supply the seismic reflection line available for an east-west traverse south of the plant site. Also provide an interpretation of what structural information can be obtained from this reflection line and how such structures relate to or do not show geologic data previously presented.
5) Use whatever " reliable" water well data is available to formulate cross-sections over areas containing the identified Paleozoic faults to show that locally continuous beds in Pennsylvanian strata are not similarly displaced by these faults. Again, incorporate and project whatever bore hole data you can to present all your geologic cata in a consistent and coherent fashion.

L -. T-~ ~}}

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20040H245&oldid=4551647"