ML20040C114
| ML20040C114 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 01/19/1982 |
| From: | Adler R PENNSYLVANIA, COMMONWEALTH OF |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8201270281 | |
| Download: ML20040C114 (4) | |
Text
.
PA 1/19/82
,s UNITED STATES OF NfRICA NUCLEAR REGlRAIORY 00I11ISS10N 00cKETEr ny-BEFORE 111E A'IDIllC SAFEIY NO LICEtSII!G BOARD
'82 JAN 22 P4:29 In the lhtter of
)
)
CF% ; u.y METROPOLITAN EDISON 00t1PM N,
)
00CKr.im:; a 1.E to w
)
Docket No. 50-289 BiM p
(Three title Island Nuclear
)
(Restart)
Station, Unit Ib.1)
)
f,
,RE. Oj!!VED Q
JAN 2M982* C ERRATUI 10 "00t-LOWEAL1110F PENNSYLVANIA'S I
g Y Ye "tnnemmY PROPOSED FItOIIUS OF FACT NO CONCLUSI0tB 0F IAW ON ISSUES RAISED IN REOPENED HEARING ON OPERATOR CIIEA (!q JSC u
/
The errors in the Connunwealth's proposing findings and concluswm G have been brought to my attention:
(1) Paragraph 52 - Delete the penultinnte sentence in the paragraph.
(" Professor Trunk detennined... minor variations.")
The corrected paragraph should read:
52.
Professor Trunk's first analysis uncovered eleven sets of parallel answers by Ifr. G and tir. H on three separate sets of Category T tmke-up enmis.
Trunk, ff. Tr. 24, 831, at 6.
These parallelisms included identical answers, sequences, form, wording, and unique errors.
Licensee Ex. 70a, at App. B.
-Based on this evidence, Professor Trunk suggested possible cooperation between lir. G and tir. H.
Id.
Another set of two parallel answers was discovered by Professor Trunk during a different review. These included one case of " identical short answer responses uniquely worded" and a second case of "the same basic wording in a long paragraph response with minor variations." Professor Trunk s
3 determined that "These two incidents appear to O
indicate that sone cooperative effort did take place y
between these two examinees, particularly in the second incident." Licensee Ex. 70e, at 1-2.
See also Trunk, ff. Tr. 24, 831, at 11.
(2) Paragraph 56 - The first sentence should be corrected to read: " Based on the inforvation discussed in Part I, above, the Board believes that it is necessary to review the adequacy of the
~'
8201270281 820119 PDR ADOCK 05000289 G
Staff's investigation of the various cheating incidents involving operators who have not been terminated."
I regret any inconvenience these errors may have caused.
Respectfully submitted, O.
1 aj
\\m, 3
r
,$.CY
._ (?.-j l
?(U(f !A l
}iilil3tT W. NDR 1
R
/
Assistant Counsel Commnwealth of Pennsylvarda
[
.s 1.
UNITED STATES OF RERICA NUCIJAR RFEUIAIORY 001-IIISS10N BEFORE 11E 61DlIIC SAFE'IY AND LICEtElt1G BONO In the Matter of
)
)
IMOPOLITAN EDISON CDMPAtW,
)
)
Docket ib. 50-289
('Ihree !!ile Island Ibclear
)
(Restart)
Station, Unit Ib.1)
)
1 l
CERTIFICNIE OF SERVICE
'Ihis is to certify that copies of the foregoing " Erratum to
'Cormiotwealth of Pennsylvania's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of law on Issues Raised in Reopened llearitig on Operator Cheating'" were served on the persons on the attached service list this 19th day of Jarntary,1982, by deposit in the U.S. nail, first class, postage prepaid.
3 [j C1;L /\\
i
.i.
njkj s
tj
-(j
,I 4 % w s - C.
j IloiiERT W. ADIBt
~~
'~ /
l l
1
m l
12TITED STATES CF #L~tICA 21:CINI FICvT.AICiG C2!ESSICN EU'OPI "SE A*t2HC SAFE'IY MD 11CE'MIC F/MPS In the Patter of
)
)
MEIPCPOLITN1 IDISQI C27R.Y,
)
)
Docket Ib. 50-239 (Three Mile Island :bclear
)
(Pastart)
Station, Ihit !b.1)
)
S'iR7 ICE IlST Docketing and Service Secticn it. Sterm C. Sbolly Office of the Secretar/
Union of Ccncerned Scientists U.S. :bclear Pagalaterf C:cc:ission 1725 I Street, N.W., Suite 601 Washington, D.C.
20535 Washingten, D.C.
20006 Ivan W. Scith, Esqaire, Cair:nn P.s. Iouise Bradford Atcx:ic Safety ani Licensing Board Panel
- R Alert U.S. :bclear Pagalatory Cocc:ission 315 Peffer Street Wshington, D.C.
20555 Parrisburg, Pemsylvania 17102 Dr. W lter H. Jordan Ellyn R. Weiss Atocdc Safety ard Ilcensing Board Panel-Sbolden. Ilar on, Poisran & Weiss SSL West Outer Drive 1725 I Street, N.W., Suite 506 Cak Ridge, Tc= cssee 37830 Washingten. D.C. 20006 Dr.1.inda W. Little Karin P. Shelden, Esquire (PM;E)
Atocie Safety ard Licensing Board Panel Sb41 den, Har:r1, Poisran & Weiss 5000 He=itage Drive 1725 I Street, N.W., Suite 506 Paleigh, : brth Carolira 27612 Wshingten. D.C.
20006 George F. to tridge, Esqaire James A. Tcurtellotte, Esqaire Shaw, Pit an, Potts & tcs.tridge Office of the Executive legal Director 1800 M Street, N.W.
U.S. !bclear Regulator / Cdx:ission Washington,'D.C. 20CC6 Washington, D.C.
20555 Pa. Parjorie lL Arodt John A. Ievin. Esqaire R.D. :)5 Assistant Counsel Coatesville, Pemsylvania 19320 Pem sylvania Public Utilief Cccc:ission
~
P.O. Box 3265 Pa. Gail Bradford Rurisburg, Pemsylvania 17120 Anti-bclear Group Pepresenting York (M G l)
Petert L. Fm.~.p, Esqaire '
245 W. Ihiladelphia Street Assistant Solicitor, Counef of Ibuchin York, Pennsylvania 174%
P.O. Sex P. 407 l brth Fren Street Parrisburg, Pemsyharia 17108 Pa. Frieda Be:ryhill, Cairan Coaliticn for Nuclear Power John E. :tirnich, Oairan Plant Postper.mmt Dauphin County Ecard of Cxcissicners 2610 Gred:n Drive Dauphin County Ccurthouse
'a'il=:ingten, Delaware 19808 Frent and Marxet Streets Harrisburg, Pemsylvania 17101 Mr. Rcbert Q. Pollard 609 dir.tpelier Street Jordan D. Cuminda:, Esquire Baltirure, Parf and 21210 Atter.ey for l'e terrf Temship l
T.M.I. Steering Cccrittee Walter W. Cahen, Esquire 2320 ! brth Second Street Consu:mr Aiwcate Rtrris'xrg, Pemsyhania 17110 Departemt of Justice Stra terr / Square, 14th Flocr Pariin I. Isis Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17127 6504 3radford Terrace P..iladelphia, Pennsylvania 19149 Dr. Cauncey Keeferd Judith H. Jctrerad Jane tre Enviremmtal Coalitien en !bclear R.D. 3, "cx 3521 433 Orlando Avelue Etters, Pemsylvania 17319 Pcur State College, Pennsyhania 16301 dras J. Ger.d.ne, Esqaire Depurf Attorny Gterral Division of law P:ofessor Ctry Milhollin Pocrs 316. 1100 Pay cnd 3culevard 1915 Jefferson Street 3, ark, New Jersey 07102 Padiscn, Visec-. sin 53711
.