ML20039D093
| ML20039D093 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 12/28/1981 |
| From: | Arndt E, Finch L, Lietman D, Lietman P, Lorhingbill D AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| To: | Palladino N NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8112310308 | |
| Download: ML20039D093 (6) | |
Text
]. _ _.,
v '* *Wy.fyg,. Q. j;'
{g g,J,
kiQpjyQ y H g :.; g g% @ j g g g g. g g g g g d
YlSfs'j@l$5??@-v,y9M ShiRNn wpp;w~:wnje$$??
i mt M
k'w*W.g.c.,,.+x,2.j;&..,,,v. :
B uewMia A
Yb'N*k'"E hh, t :~L E$
-g
.t.
~-
,g.
7]{t,3.C O/te bh fh H
A 4 9 # "hj,as,A. a nkST.js, Ef 28&', W
,h$
c
}
?
f fan $$rtu 0% < DE t :5'j '
7 l
~ " "
P JJ[esi$
is7 F
i ;s'pERATEa "~,.,,.,.-s e %
17///
~
QygPh w:nre 7
"" ~ "~.T !!UT;1D ER fROC. & UTIL FAC.h.a
'~s' &o %g N. R.C.
w104 v :p l
W.e Q,g,
.~
y D.C-
~
7 AGES $
r e ::s=1 :sm v.
.i 45 F
av-M.,.
" SL 3
-4 a,.
o!q-j k. _I W
^
&p U E'iWfc!
1 h
y-
,O ggplsM>W@!j g
-yiss
-54 j~
g 9,
~
ON
'3 g{
0 193
-u K
f f
M
-m
...: s n
-*?
/p k').
N
~
b 4
Gs
'73 7 3. a G 71 c
6 l
?
z 1
,.za j
&)P d )@ % -
y$lQ l]}ll h
L' g
a
[;;
h..
~
n si P
. - - - - ~
p
- ~
.e L
W 5, :
9 G
y^
c,
- yy
.a.
~l
'.i o-P!w. o 8112310308 811228 MtM Y
PDR ADOCK 05000289
'M y ew,P. p$~r.:
'_c
. g H
P DR ""
a y Il If
. i h',*.
Sh=::.
U.#A 20 /fT/
???_
m
"!$=7 hi t
So,% DEC 28 A8:[6 b_;.,,,9Js.h$2L.JEM EW
,n--.--
,. ~
n=v==.
. gm.m ilspsdnd oflE daa X#N" jau dadk 2$ps b
b
' h
? [t G SE
-=
h j
fN w.
-~
u tr>zM5et-ozu Amwa9, $atu-adh/w & N -.
9N5!f MM.-*
/,_
_
hdAC
)(
A[G
^
=- - :=-
.Al$
h l
S'M Wu' w
n L........
W.4 N4ntfd Y
% d h ff f h et2 (d?>w?-
I a..._
s...-..
- ^ ~
7 i_-,'1,,:..
_ iCa as A 3
~
j llO e=..-..=
4
\\1
../.
LA Y
- f..
~
,7._.
6 m
/
t-w in p.,a a.AL &
L a_
m.....
- -=. -
. 2D "a 8 Wd&.3rr g,ygg
- 5;
-_.--._[
- 7...
a.,..7 m s.mt
~,
o c
+
4: e.
t
..;. +
3.
s
k' D.v.".T ':':M r.1 Pi.GG. 3, tri!'.. FA3.....,,..p o==.nc j
DXQIEP
/
((s II.
LY0h L.& f L
i D LO JG.<}/d l L
'.v.C!: OF SECP,E i. v
- iE d i:NG i SEr<VICE IYY.IY -
[Lf
/
dCO kt
' fk a /u y -
x.
J,a <x c / u s w,, a u s xx u
/uy(f Actstcc/ -fL+pic bcu/icj X/s M&dcaf.
haL' 4ap& /ud heuesxy.usato A e-jaw su f
L kj.2 C w fl p K 4 U D A A L &L>
'funcub2/J G-ub d
f]Lt (tua. Aay,att Act' Aumcf &
. f h u n a t k a g g a i w s 4. w 's e u A u j h
- in n Avesas w a asaw fAOLCby fLL CL4RMLcl #^'2A Mdss) y&a)6&x}'
~
'N&scd u' j%s 4ttw,Lbj Wx4?
fasxwchw tAaf a/uJAw t!h wcada x)/M
.blhLL- /F L}&) jus vjGuf2Ae, /)'d luxncbdtlafx-fha.
& <1 h cyaq u Rz. itceom -
i OfudL a (%y udsakncy 6 TAU wt' dhicfitZu
/
op apn uhuua w b u @ t z e c/ / w ' 2/c e Cb b Y
etdA-) IGA /WW 3
})
uajchel dsin ht0L(chiQ IO~[d D,0 4 [(uXI S
tu>1'-
1/s M2eAak 7 an r-s jaa y cawn s wia r p
s ee As6g
,va
~
/-
j.
'E
-J,, e :
- ,7
. I J 1
A V
V
./
JCbd AL Pi. TM /
ac L..c*
_.......s
. _....__.. f.
W Mv'.
Lud/
c ',.
-e 2m.m a
.e
.ap,*
W
~.... _
./
-'* = = * *
- e.
000huis
/- 6. M 3 2 0...
~
C 373-/d./.
.T
~
= * * * - *
- 8.
wi.
i...weh.**p*=m*****
- '**********"8*-*
- -*w
-..a
.we e.
w =
,4 4..,
.J
..=.._._t_._.
I f*
9 4
e e
I 8
e.p
-
- eetg*
,,,,m,
.p w...........
'U3n i 3 s-1 rpea jle 7Fve 7
m m-ata,' A
.gf g i pa s c
.g P3:09L t Dr o i ort DOCIfi
- gri.,, y i
- ' f'nVlCt Y.
Nu/>zto 0 {l;J :,,
t OGt<~o, (d. S.
/V-t le < +
/f
, I. {e l". m,;S,-
%> k, F~.
- 0. c.
d SY i ROD.'& UTIL h..
~
CRes Mt)
L A.
I'&e,.
b W #7"M M
gi M s
rn r
- i m
fa y
nuwa a,s s y L Al J.ADLL, 514.",A y
4~4 A
zz A J L ~
p a uM.
A.
A um mp M
de A~~;
m A
g,~
LLb4 qw) l O +y ',
y fg ok M
W" A <-
y ' Al H,
)
gp usa M.
Y~
Ny, q Q NP M.
k 4
e D},O5 Co-y ns,.,.,
A.,e-h(
d/.
~ N[
fo:
C ytes a. +. - w c. a. - m,(anJ
/t a
g3 r.i.,
n ~g
\\;
y u>
%~~~.
./'
u m r. - m m m m-umu vmmua m ;ui,mmax -
- ' vestigation, analysis and tschnological reviews into
' hought applied to a given gibberish and a reactor into
%' g b t
,y i h
m 1:
4x 7'a oroblem could be measured - radioactive mush. We have a A r-gp h
{
d h
by the time' consumed. In~
right to ask why thelicensing doing it and the weight of the board's judgment will be i
f inal report, then the accom-- right this time when it was il
[
f plisfiment of the Atomic wrong the last time.
U11%>,{'
lf h{l]h; Safety mtd Licensing Board 9 'O 3
f j-.
_ Unit I nuclear teactor at issue of restarting Unit I than 3__
Jooking into the restart of the THERE IS MORE to the s
.Three Mile Island merits a a technological evaluation 3
I thigh ranking. Atter spending made by a panel dedicated to
- inany months taking testimo-isolating nuclear power deci-j ny on the fitness of the un-sion-making from the influ-
~
.: damaged nuclear plant and ence of the host community.
Ag'^
- the competen'y of the man-It is.an indication of how de-c
. agement of.. General Public. void the process is of sensitiv-(Utilities to operate it, the ity to its mistakes and a mea-3three-member boar'd has re-sure^ of its lack of social-
. b~ 5 ipage report. Its predictable. tior. of Unit I can be consid-
~
.' leased its findings in an _800 - accountability that the opera.
~
,.g
' conclusion: The Nuclear Reg-cred while.only yards'away-p ulatory Commission should its. sister plant sits in. ruin, RS/J,
grant-GPU permission to t'ontaminated by radioactivi.
commence operation of the ty, an acknowledged heallh
. by.w.~c:
reactor.
'and safety hazard which con-
'But if the licensing board tinues unresolved.
,. was " exhaustive" in, its in-The system has failed to 1
. quiry it surely was not thor,come to grips'with this nucle-
._w
. ough; if it asked many ques-ar stepchild. No one wants to
-[
~'-
E
_. g W
, ;tions, it failed to ask the right admit paternity, so the easi-y
- 1. questions; if it looked at eve-est thing to do is to ignore it, e.r
~E
..ry sciew,' it could not grasp let it. sit there. The govern-'
MN1 5
- . the entirety of th'e problem. It ment licenses them,'the utili
~
II.
/did, e:,sentially, what a previ ties operate them and the
$.}
' 'ous licensing board had done Good Lord cleans them up.
N d:
,.in~ certifying the safety and The system never was pre-N it j
1., soundness of ' Unit 2,.which, pared to deal with a $1 billion in a shorter time than it took nuclear accident and it is no
.h Ajl to pass the NRC's rigorous more, prepared today, yet it pmg
.g l
Mreview, became a world sym-proceeds with licensing of g
4
',' bol of a technology that not n clear plants as if TMI nev--
e y
Q
.'Conly failed, but, threatened er happened, as if it didn't ex -
=
- the lives and fortunes of ist, as if there wasn't an all h h1]
]
i ousands of people..
too~ real risk' of radioactive th p
It is possible to separate contamination of._ down-o the technical connections be; stream. community water tween the two reactors at-systems and the irreplaceable i TM1 -- as is being done -- but Chesapeake Bay fishery.
/6@--
p)
J it is even beyond the ~ power
'Only a system that is
.'[of the NRC to alter;their morhlly bankrupt would car-physical proximity or to ex-ry on its ritual of attesting to tinguish the trauma inflicted the innocuousness of nuclear
)gk o
, from there on a public trust _ power plants across the ashes m.pg
.. ing of the judgment, integrity _ of one that says it im't. The
' LM'El -
. 'and technical competence of final decision on the recom-
. the utility and its nuclear mendations of the licensing overseer. The licensing board board rests with the full com-could deal with the myriad of mission of the NRC and it e
technical questions, it could will be less of a judgment en
- 1. -
.J
'o -
. not -- it would.not -- address Unit I than it is a judgment
.S
.'g[
8 the psychological result on itself and the morality of t
' when a nuclear accident ren-the$olicies it Intrsues.
,