ML20037A648

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Outlines Status of Discussions W/Doi Re Possibility of Need for Closed Cycle Cooling Sys.Current Studies Show No Severe Aquatic Impact from once-through Sys.Notifies of 730411 Meeting W/Util,Doi,Epa & Council on Environ Quality
ML20037A648
Person / Time
Site: Peach Bottom, Indian Point, Crystal River  
Issue date: 04/10/1973
From: Anthony Giambusso
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Muntzing L
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 8003250663
Download: ML20037A648 (2)


Text

-

_ = _ -,

y^

n - p.~-~< c - "- ;,- gy,~m

-w -m}.),4.J<

n

- x, ~$

W.iiSQ QQ y[,W

~

g* ?RK,

,t.

.L.*l~.c..&pf.,.;y[*'&,

N i'.jf.

_t

.M e * * "* Q r +

i f,y a,.." %'?r*

,,y

~. :., y..%.. ~.,.

.s n m~ m c y gw%'a :.5

  • P 9 s y k.

., A 4,

.s ;

s.;

nm wn y.p,.q1.

,m a.

m nn.,

wn -

u a

,m.s

..~,., w.

.. a

=g,

,, w.

s 6,4~.,a g mw q ~r m m;y[.

hu wwne ~%mqss.rw uw.*M.m W

- % ~ _ - n. x,fy 6..w w oc,;,pinc.e,.

A;.aW1.

r q %,w

,e, w v*

cy,9, m

. ; a m

~.w..,4.

,L. fl& QSfSEN^'Q&?,%.$dQ.W',Y.:.-00h',j,l5 *k'?NV"

&m $"

~. ~. ~

n.

w ~

, y.

ay w:.7'n:

, z" l

55T.

w

.~ T c w

^

.x. 1' w APR W '.973 y-m x

=

, z.s j

7g..

~..

a. +

+

.m q,

m m.

..,. ~_

T e

e.-

Docket No.'S0-302 u*.

w.~,

' 'y 5

.f

%Yd

,p

.m

., m.

L. Manning Misatsing. Director of.Bagulation

.g.] gu OWJE THEUs John F. O' Leary, Director of Licensing DEPARTMEET hF INTERICE CONCERNS REMTIVE TO CRTSTAL RIVER UNIT 3.,,

y %

, s :q

,, M )

1

.,V DOCIET N0.'50-301

.c',

,N ud

+

yP. t*

'?

.N.

e s.' * *

,t re-

- ' 1 [- +

a A. -

4

, a
  • t 1

6 This amme. is to spyrise' you of' the aset recent,developmaat in eur-s l

dealings with DOI relativa to the Crystal River Bait 3. 'In gr mano cf April 2 (sery enclosed) on this subject, I discussed the environ-1.

mental scudy programs that was under review which would be required i

before a firm ecuelusica could be disun relative to the nced for closed cycle coeling at this p1mnr. Further, I noted that we are carrying out studies which would define the best clesed cycle ecollag alternativa frca o coet/ benefit. standpoint if the ecriron--

aental studias reveel'a preblem that would require sn h r.casures.

Wa,axyce to twva the prefarable altornative definal prior to the.

com:plation 'oi the enviranunathi study program which is expected to take one year to casplata. In the IMn Point and ?cach rottom cassa, tha staff ccacia cd that sufficioac avide.ccc of. aquatic impact ess available to warrant a. decision an r*c mreed clos ~i gele ecoling 9Lth na need for sdJf/teml atudies. In contrast, th ataff has concluded, based on the 1-deraation that is e.n'rrnely attd thle on the nature of tb.e blots in th(area and the i@act fron W.it: l' sad "..that the cace-through systc= nt Cry::tal River, --ith ecas posotale minor moaifica.tsce, will cat result in a c.crora aqvatic inpac:. Severthelcrs, we do not dicagree that further studias would be useful.to corroborate our position and thus suoport the DOI in its desire to obtafa such studies.

I We have learned through discussions with the applicant, Florida Power l

T Cocperation, that Mr. Eat hid, Aset. Secretary of the Interior, has regnested that theyfattend a meeting la his office an April 11 to I

decide "What to de about Crystal River-thnit 3."

The applicant stated ~

a 'that' CIQ and EPA representatives were invited to attend.? Lata Friday ~

aftornoon (April 6,1973F D. RJ Muller' received 'a' call free

~

Mr. Cecrge Cerdaer's office hrriting him and c:har representatives of

_the AEC w o could waka policy decisions'.. Mr. liullar i. squired as to the h

nature of the meeting and policy decisinas but the secretary who wi relaying the message fror Mr. Gardner could not be specific. She-stated that Mr. Gazdmer would call MrO5:11er em April 9,1973 with

~

. farther ciarificatism.

.m n,u:

~

T

"~

c

,Q'^^.-

13 2.

wy

,_gi M' $ - pdFi h-.

8003250

}

- w.

- - ~.

- m.v - : - --

~., -

.,~

-1 ~:

<.~,,-s.,.r4,w M M m =pyc c - g; % y., @ @ ? p;p. W W. K.n. mMa,,,..,.,G,Miq;..w y

-. ~

n.,. b~, s,. u..~j.ec e f

,~..o_~x, #,, n c-m_e. w :w..,g %. g,.,+ ga.

.,g,,..,M, ig

- t yz.

,.mw

.y.

.g:,p:. -

w w..

- a.-.

m.; w.m. w w ax m p g.a wn.,w:.z,.s.nnm.c.tn -

.e w

.. =. h : ; 3 3. u.:.ne c. p. w w r,: : w.f r... w.. a..

..w :

- f.mp:; w.w.c, g..,

, 4.

~,

.p,p%v,,,.,.,,,~.~ :,. s _.. - 5,.

,v --e =. e s,,,. v~m. m.,m s

.t m,: > y...

,_.s:gy. -. sm.

.=:n.a

.- w

. w m..., w p,...

..m

,;y..

..w.

.a w

m

.c.

m ru..

... n.

2 w,

^.e-

~

.~

- ~.,, _

,L. Massing Xuntsir4.

. 2;..

pg i t s73.

f > _ 3. 327' y =.

[-

~

m.

.,e-4 y-g y

a.

+,.,..g.,,,

According 'to the applicant,'in discussion with Gardner[1t was- '

~

statedthatMr.Reidplanitodecideatthismeetingwhether,'*~[-

f

~

~

Florida Forer vill be required to start detailed engineering deafgn of a closed ' cycle cooling system inrcediately.

It was further stated tht Mr. Reid is prepared to approach the accomplishment of this requirement through' the Secretary Norton'- Chairman Ray-routere, if Mecessary.

e

-. [ - _ f.

6 3

/

t v

_,~

~

I will be pleased to discuss this situation with you at your convenience.

r Oridnd Signed By

~

A, Giambno

- A. Ciambusse, Decuty Director

.q for "maact.or Projects

. Directorate of Licensing g

o@ kW t.aclosure:

A.i stated o

u DISTRIETION s!ncket file (ENVIRON)

DSkovholt, OR g

"? Res. ding GKnighton, EP-1, L eD 4 v.s, r, Ja, e

v.

a RP huacing

. JYoungblood, EP-3, L EP-4 ?.eading WRegan, EP-4, L JF0' Leary, L DSells, EP 4) L Sim nauer SSheppard, EP-4, L BBuckley, PWR-4, L

- EGCase, L AGiambusso, DDRP, L ~

KDeYoung, ADFWR JHendrie, TR

~DRMuller, ADEP

, + ~

c.u,

'+.,

y s

4 f

=.

'y t '.i r

r i. ; L. ~

~^^",s

<, -y_

g r ~.,, +.

s

~

b*

  • w.,

i.,3 l.b* g', g e.'--)..'*. '.'n s ;-=.,

s, n,;c v.

4,,

-s 4 ;:;L i.

i s.

=,

h^%

e e,

,p-t ;u

- ' ; *,.a f,[ \\, ~ * -j l * -- Y < g *,.

~n,,

A: G.

rm...:,

e a

,~ 5,\\.

c'

>: s 4,

,,.p&.

'= - *.

n

u L,

u 1.

~..>

3%,

a w.e - p -.

.,,3,,.*

gea4%j '"

Yg, e.se e_

. 4.dima%g*I",,

es

    • 'v'-%.b o

map. *

.e on e a

+ sg

.e

.',g pr f

L(

4R

.,e' W*

b*

,2.;

.7p C v C& L.s,c;**.: n,.

T'a % 2 W""

'Q'.-'?*.YS~dQ @: *Yh -

N

, ? '. : jy.

...,a,-

,..A. n : n.~ m.a 1..y_S,

,.. _g - ay

.,y-a

~

-. ~

s

.mn.

~. ~

.f ~

p c'. z,...'.-. g x..,,

y

..a.

fr =;., g,

,c.

g u.-

m..,, \\{. ), s.

n,.

7.

i s.

,u m-q=;L -

.,r.,

1. e,..~.,.

..n q

e

-y

  • y' g y-t

.,8

. ;> -.. -. c;.

G f k...*,oQ'. ~

L 2.59

..gw.~ -

  • f g y' *4. f. ~. <

.4' are,ce

_ y,y$ 4. - _..fif g.. g.

a

y. _ - ~..,.m x",.

. - L, m.

._ f.' '...o

_... i.

n

.a; e.

{.

!p

$ n..:

..w.1 ; a i.,,

,{

f

^ r.

ft - ~

v

^

La y

a mg.&

J.;,.. g y.s q.d

,c.. p..

w:u..,....t>

z wa:r..

-g 3.y : y' Mg'V[r~ MEFt

.,,4:*~

1.pQ h-ler AGi.am sso' M JEO.' Lear 7 *.' @; Y ~

1.'_

,_:. ~

. 93 l6J73 n.g,,*7,7(. _.l} T.e,' ; 7 ~. 4l 73; x,4l.?l73:

1:

4

4..., -

W. -. #..~. ;., :.

-1'.n. u " w s.Ggr :. L L <.s h -

,.5, s.

E::

- ~ * ^

K.y1*2. *:?.

& N.M dnt > }.t.,:..h.i.4~*

7t 4'

N*

. w w-c.mm n wrw e.m. r

4,,u,.+.e.a.,.

uuses em.n%w%ues& ' M'M: '

ea m %:. At.s, a'i A %4 -n- ~...... s m %*: c- %.s m.o

--. ' A+-

OW b

p es ws v-p.