ML20034F670
Text
U S. NUCLE Ari RE GULATORY COMMISSION
,, q # w a o ss g r,
m%
,f,
.s$
FOIA 8 2_
v r
M SP3Nsi 1 vee c
i tj,.i RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF lmu MWmt (kq/ n[g0 -INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST m
NOV - 51992 Ont T Nuvbf R.5: 4 c, #c,
RE QUE ST E R
/
///g
-, ll -
d1 PART l.- AGENCY R E CORDS R'E L E ASE D OR NOT LOCAT E D iSee che. d ez Dam ed No agenc y records subject tc the request have been loca'ed No addit:ona' agunc y records subject to the request t, ave been loteted.
Recuested records are avadab'e throu;5 another put c d,stobut.on p o; ram See Comerti sect on.
i Arncy records subject to the request that are identified in Append {esi are amd, a.a tabie for pubhc inspect;or nd copyM; et the N RC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street. N W, Was%ngton. DC.
r' f
., ate bemg "ade s a4Ne f or pubhc insnect cn and copying Agency records sub,ect to the rep est that are ioerti ;ed m Append;itesi g
at the fiRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street. N.W., n ash ngton. DC, in a foWer under this F OI A number.
The nc,,ropnetar y sers.o, of the pic pow:si t at irou aa eed to acte;
.n a t*;h or t or verso on n.th a member of ms sta'f :s naa be,ng made a.-adable 00, in a fc w mdei t* s FOt A nu ber for pur c espect,on and copong at the N RC PXc Document Room. 2120 L Svert. N W. War ngtce c
Agency rec yds subyct to the reavest th',t are identiGed in Append m;es)_._
_ riaa y be msr ected and con ed at the N RC Loca' Put,hc Document Room ident hed in :5e Comments secM n.
E nc:osed f s riormy,on on hon you r.3 y obts n s cess to and t' e chc irs f or c opy'ng re:ords c; stt d et *e NRC Pubhc Docume-! Room,2120 L Street, Nh h as-pion DC Agency records suomt to the reavest re ermesed Records s.b ect *.o the te:;uest have been re ferre 4 '; another Federe' aiaency bt si for reven cinc o rei t t porne to you f
Fees Yo., C Deb 6edbi t' N RC 10 4es tetim;. E You wm recewe a,e'und from the NRC e N amount c' 5 in view o' N R C's response to tms rea..est. f.o ivi e* acdon,5 bo n; to o on o W r ner dMe? __
.No h
PART II.htNFOPMATION WITHHELD F ROM PltLIC DISCLCSUAL Cmam 6 meen W. t~e recuesteJ r.o
, oer g w e ne:d M - c ote : es;10sa c.v a s t"e c. - m descv ed rn nd +a i e rea sm.
f s.
m i art.t. i. C, and D. Amy r- % sed po tb, ce the o x ~er ts u <
- e n ca t c4 're re:--n a bei.
e:d sre bema r.aae s.eaue 6 put irsrector and ccoy M;; in the.RC Pubbc D3curnert Acom,212P i. Stree. N R. Was' Wgton, DC m a f c ter under tms F O l A n.3 %r r COWE f TS A
YON OF f Rf l DOM OF INF OF EATION AND PLEt CA? IONS LE R ME5 sinhT URE, D) AECTOR, DPld 4 i
/ Aa It i
9303040113 921105 PDR FOIA HUBBARD92-162 PDR
to A Nuuntysi Dait i
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF i
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST FOIA - 4 42-(CONTINUATION)
-- p~
NOV 0
PART lt B-APPLICABLE EXEMPUONS Records subject to the request that are described in the enclosed Append;={es) are teng wsthbeld in their eritiret y or in part under the Exempt;on No L 'nd for the reason (s) given betow pursuant to 5 U.S C. 552(b) and 10 CF R 9.1hal of N AC regulations.
4 1
1 The o rthbee.ntsmaten.s propem c'aW+c muant io Eucutae O der. (Ememm.on 1)
I 2 The w>tPheid ordorrr.aton teiates swelv te the inteerd pc'sunnel evies ar'd trot ecas of %AC d uempiton 2) m rd iMomat on 10 Cis< ; DS:se2, f
a 1
._ p 3 m.c. n.i q t4e, _ d nempt,oo EL App %,me PNaege i
I5 The
- tttee m?mmat=on rmsts v muw, u ce Pee m, reo as : e
,4
,.a sa., i.
i
[-t+ 3d l'ip'4 e s( *V. y t.9 +@ Pi s npht,p $ p the rie?ts,ept.ve p M t%
' dot..f * @t w e D'Oc eM DSCUS#t.cf Ptf '4 In O% 8 f f D *" rf s W U.)
8N 'l 1 f' a!. A "t
Whe e ert o~ts are nehod in thre enm the 4c u na eu tu 4
, et a r e ? a in += n edes i e s.n'.> re itn sc, a> c r.o w awnat,.g se ye po r f actue' lportrons t.ecause the ec+ai.e of the f mas awa r.emi ar r.caec t irm.am emo toe rece('smas cr.< en et tw apnc y j
A n m a p.,
p w i; s e.s Do -
m.n c e 4
.o a a: om ae atome,rwts' nem j Attm es-t p s cege :Cr'_omt i c-. m - _... _ _
.__ _ _ 4
__4 l
ne..t%e s W - et.y.3, em, f m :.a 1..
s e.s n..
c
-aw,,re m e..i m,ai.,,,
d.vrpt.on 0
/ {7 T he..i++ee s,f veat.on :o sats et <ec es urened 6 w a *"- n + me"t : w st:s r* " f 4 " *
- c m 10' " + " # C* 's 'f"1'c a'ec (E sc-nption 71 t
D-se esee M.caute, t.e ecc ed ic me+r e a, e *y -~en vcgredm brume a uv ma the scope. eet un and f atu of 6
e +mee-m e%.ms. m e o c% e em 9,(.o cet a m *
-9 ear - ?: e n went.a' n eens em e, a e.at e tu N A C rw e- -
o - %_ i w s. J.e__:-a y ?_i.A u_ _ _._ _
_~
, _... _. ~
~. _ _ _ _..
c j
f DWee n ovid ( m =st%te ar #a s"rtei ense t' pr s w g p'. ar y d a empi;cn 7(CH
,.e.,<-
,. m -
- e. m t., e e., % e,esn a ne e.m m.r o s. un -,+-n.4 q
j c o ' w > soucet (Ememon DH
_ - ~. -. _. - - - _ _ - - -
n%L t
I a'
. _. C - DEN..Y. ING. OF FICI AL S---
& iRT tl J 8' N 1 4 l"n Me'm i
he pe m m.pce". tue 4 'ned 164 the *?vmeitm * ;thbeht a enemm bom peo O ta. Regu:. yy Cmmm on se2 J
Pman To 10 Cf A 975@ at of ? M M c' tN - *
!hr em # re tha9 o'hc: sis rfrm # eri beca es rffwng l
duct on # C4t h'e eM P at M F me' cm m m 5 cm Pa g a the pec
."t "est cif c a-5 r*e tM C eccmr. D o :c. e4 r eec~ v
? m on ans Pat. w ms Lew,s. O* f u c + A* w %n - 6' ao de n e et re,a. 01:.,m.e ased to
- r E metstn e D-ecot i
fo O w aves 1EDOt l
idt!-OUICE FICORD5 DWf D 1
AWi t L AT f Of f!C:AL
[
a DENve% DmCLAL i
1 EDO
- LECRE'ADY G
_..__m
-M. M_ _ % r A
_p p
s' r
}
l
_--..--M
._,s
~ - - +
m-+-
g i
l t
f i
~#_.~M 4m._.._,-fe4--.
l l
l l
d 1
J bw I
l I
PART 11 D-APPEAL RIGHTS 1
i The cen;al by each denong officia: dent.f..d in Part II.C rney t>e appealed to the Appel. ate Otoc.ai. dent eed there. Any such aps. cat m, a be rnade m writ.ng nithn 3r., days of,eceipt of this response. Ap;wsis must be addressed, es appropnre to the E secstwe Dweetor for Ope'ations, to the Secre'a y of the Comm'nen, or to the faspector General, U.S. Octeer Regatatory Cenm.ssion, hh ngton, DC 70LM and shovid cies !y sts'e ori the enwesope and m the letter that rt <s en Appeal from an in tsal F Of A Decision."
t i
NRC FORM 464 (Part 2) (191)
U.S. NUCt LAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
~
.1 i
1
-e Re:
FOIA-92-162 O
)
APPENDIX C j
l RECORDS BE_ING PIACED INTO THE PDR UNDER THE' ABOVE REOUEST NUMBER 5
l' NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION I
i A11 ec a t i on_..No. 90-A-0044 j
1.
5/16/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 2.
4/4/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page).
3.
4/4/90 Allegation Management System l
Frintout (1 page)
A))egatjon No. 90-A-0106 4.
Undated Draft Inspection Report Writeup (2 pages) l 5.
5/15/91 Letter to E. J. Mroczka from E.
C.
l Wenzinger re: Acknowledgement Letter (1 page)
{
4 6.
2/22/91 Letter to E.
C. Mroczka from C. W.
Hehl re: Forwarding Concerns with enclosure (3 pages) 7.
12/5/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 8.
Undated Calibration Source Set Data, Set B (8 pages) 9.
8/1/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page)
]
10.
8/15/90 Allegation Management System Printout (1 page) l
{
Allegation No. 90-A-0107 11.
Undated Handwritten Note from S. Stewart (1 page) j f
12.
2/22/91 Letter to E.
C. Mroczka from C. W.
l Hehl re: Forwarding Concerns with j
enclosure (3 pages) l 13.
8/2/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page)
[
14.
8/15/90 Allegation Management System
[
Printout (1 page) t
~
f i
a
.. ~ -
.. ~.. -
h 9
9
-i Re:
FOIA-92-162
{
APPENDIX C (Continued)
[
RECORDS BEING PLACED INTO THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REOUEST NUMBER 1
UUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION i
i Allecation No. 90-A-0116 15.
3/31/92 Memo to File from G.
Kelly (1 page) 16.
3/29/91 Letter to E.
J.
Mroczka from E. C.
Wenzinger re: Acknowledgement Letter with enclosed 2/15/91 Letter I
2 to E.
C. Wenzinger from E. J.
l Mroczka re: A09302, 1/17/91 Letter to E.
C.
Wenzinger from E.
J.
l Mroczka re: A09189, 2/25/91 Letter I
to E.
C.
Wenzinger from E.
J.
[
Mroczka re: A09301 (9 pages) 17.
12/19/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 18.
12/06/90 Letter to E.
J.Mroczka from E. C.
l Wenzinger re: Forwarding Concerns i
with enclosure (3 pages) j 19.
8/2/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 20.
8/22/90 Allegation Management System Printout (1 page)
A11ecation_No. 90-A-0181 j
21.
2/24/92 Letter to J.
Opeka from E.
C.
Wenzinger re: Forwards excerpts l
from Inspection Report with i
enclosure (3 pages) 22.
10/17/92 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 23.
10/15/90 Allegation Management System Printout (1 page) 1 i
i 9
t
-i i
4 i
Re:
FOIA-92-162-j APPENDIX C (Continued) l l
BECORDS BEING PLACED INTO THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE-REOUEST NUMBER l
NUMBER DATE DESCBIPTION A11ecation No. 90-A-0187 24.
7/17/91 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 25.
5/15/91 Letter to E. ' J. Mroczka from E.
C.
Wenzir.ger re: Acknowledgement.
Letter (1 page) 26.
4/26/91 Letter to C. W. Hehl from E. J.
Mroczka re: A09352 (3 pages) i i
27.
4/26/91 Letter to C. W. Hehl from E. J.
Mroczka re: A09354 (5.pages) 28.
2/22/91 Letter to E.
C. Mroczka from C.
H.
Hehl re: Forwarding-Concerns.with j
enclosure (3 pages) 29.
10/24/90 Allegation Panel Decision l(1 page) j 30.
10/17/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) i 31.
11/6/90 Memo to File Documenting Drawing l
Discrepancies (1 page) 1 32.
10/22/90 Allegation Management System i
Printout (1 page) i l
1 Allegation No. 90-A-0221 33.
5/15/91 Letter to E. J. Mroczka from E.
C.
Wenzinger re: Acknowledgement Letter ( 1 page) i 34.
4/20/91 Letter to C. W. Hehl from E. J.
Mroczka re: A09352 (3 pages) l 35.
2/22/92 Letter to E.
C. Mroczka from C. W.
Hehl re: Forwarding Concern (3 l
Pages) i l
36.
12/20/90 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) t 37.
12/17/90 Allegation Management System Printout (1 page) l t
.,~
l l
Re:
FCTA-92-162 i
APPENDIX C i
(Continued) i RECORDS BEING PLACED INTO THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER i
FUMBER DATE DESCRIPTIQN i
Allegation No. 91-A-0010 l
t 38.
6/21/91 Letter to E. J.
Mroczka from E.
Wenzinger re:. Acknowledgement Letter with enclosed 5/6/91 Letter l
to C. W. Hehl from E. J. Mroczka re: A09449, 5/6/91 Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E. J. Mroczka re: A09453, 5/6/91 Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E.
j J. Mroczka re: A09448, and 5/6/91 i
Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E. J.
Mroczka re: A09447 (23 pages) j 4
i 3.
4/2/91 Letter to E. J. Mroczka from C.
W.
Hehl re: Forwarding Concern with
-l enclosure (3 pages) j 40.
Undated Handwritten Recommendations (1 page) 41.
1/16/91 Allegation Panel Decision (1 page) 42.
1/17/91 Allegation Management System l
Printout (1 page)
I l
r i
e r
i h
i
.. g..
..: : n.
I l
l Re:
FOIA-92-162 APPENDIX D l
RECORDS PARTIALLY _W_ITIIHFJLD 1
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION i
A11eaation No. 90-A-0044 1.
3/23/90 Allegation Receipt Report (1 page)
EX. 6 & 7C 1
Allecation No. 90-A-0106 2.
4/26/91 Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E. J.
Mroczka re: A09353 with attachments (4 pages) EX. 6 & 7C' 3.
5/13/91 Letter to An Individual re:
Closecut Letter (1 page) EX. 6 & 7C i
4.
12/6/90 Telephone Notes (1 page) EX. 6 & 7C-5.
8/2/90 Letter to An Individual re:
Allegation Status Update with enclosure (3 pages) EX. 6 & 7C
]
6.
4/19/90 Allegation Receipt Report with enclosure (3 pages) EX. 6 & 7C j
Allegation No. 90-A-0107
{
7.
5/13/91 Letter to An Individual re:
Closecut Letter with enclosed
(
4/16/91 Letter to C. W.
Hehl from E.
J.
Mroczka re: A09353 and Pages I
from Inspection Report 50-336/90-08 (6 pages) EX. 6 & 7C 8.
4/10/91 Letter to An Individual re*
r Closecut Letter with enclosed 4/8/91 Letter to E. J.
Mroczka from
+
l E.
W. Wenzinger and Inspection i
Report 50-336/90-08 (12 pages) EX.
I 6 & 7C j
9.
8/2/90 Letter to An Individual re:
Allegation Status Update with j
enclosure (3 pages) EX. 6 & 7C
~
10.
6/5/90 Allegatior eceipt Report (2 pages)
EX. 6 & 7C t
f
)
i Re:
FOIA-92-162 I
APPENDIX D i
I (Continued) t
-i RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD 1
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 11.
5/3/90 Letter to An Individual re:
]
Acknowledgement Letter (1 page) EX.
l 6 & 7C l
12.
6/22/90 Allegation Receipt Report (2 pages)-
l EX. 6 & 7C l
i 13.
4/2/90 Allegation Receipt Report with
]
attachments (3 pages) EX. 6 & 7C l
l
]
Allegation No. 90-h-Oll6 14.
9/5/91 Annotated Letter to An Individual l
from E.
Wenzinger re: Closecut Letter (2 pages) EX. 6 & 7C i
15.
9/5/91 Letter to An Individual'from E.
Wenzinger re: Closecut Letter (2 l
pages) EX. 6 & 7C j
1 16.
12/18/90 Handwritten Notes of Telephone.
Conversation by S.
Stewart (1 page)
EX. 6& 7C l
17.
9/5/90 Letter to An Individual from D.
R.
Haverkamp re: Acknowledgement l
a l
Letter (1 page) EX. 6 & 7C t
j Allecation No. 90-A-0181 i
18.
2/27/92 Letter to An Individual from E.
Wenzinger re: Closecut Letter (1
[
page) Ex. 6 & 7C 19.
10/9/90 Allegation Receipt Report (2 pages) j EX. 6 & 7C l
i C
l
-~+
I j
i
[
Re:
FOIA-92-162 1
i APPENDIX D i
(continued)
RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD i
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION i
Allecation No. 90-A-0187 f
20.
8/26/91 Memo to C.
W.
White from C.
W.
Hehl re: Materiality of Inaccurate Responses with enclosed 7/18/91
.{
i Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E.
J.
Mroczka re: B13883, Annotated Version of 7/18/91 Letter, 7/12/91
)
Allegation Receipt Report, 4/26/91 Letter to C.
W.
Hehl re: A09354, I
and 6/21/91 Memo from T. Arnett (12 pages) EX. 6 & 7C l
L 2
21.
7/12/91 Allegation Receipt Report (2 pages) j i
EX. 6 & 7C i
22.
5/14/91 Letter to An Individual from E.
Wenzinger re: Update Letter (1 I
page) EX. 6& 7C j
23.
10/12/90 Allegation Receipt Report (4 pages)-
EX. 6 & 7C Allegation No. 90-A-0121 l
24.
5/14/91 Letter to An Individual from E.
I Wenzinger re: Closecut Letter (1 page) EX. 6 & 7C 25.
12/7/90 Allegation Receipt Report (3 pages) f EX. 6 & 7C Allegation No. 91-A-0010 i
5 26.
7/3/91 Letter to An Individual from E.
l Wenzinger re; Closcout Letter with i
enclosures 5/6/91 Letter to C.
W.
l Hehl from E.
J. Mroczka re: A09449, t
5/6/91 Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E.
l 2
J. Mroczka re: A09453, and 5/6/91 Letter to C.
W.
Hehl from E. J.
Mroczka re: A09447 (18 pages) EX. 6
& 7C l
C i
t 1
i
Re:
FOIA-92-162 APPENDIX D (Continued)
BECORDS PARTIALLY WITIIIIELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 27.
Undated Markup of Letter (4 pages) EX. 6&
7C 28.
4/2/91 Letter to An Individual from G.
Kelly re: Acknowledgement Letter.
with enclosures (5 pages) EX. 6&
7C 29.
1/1/91 Allegation Receipt Report (2 pages)
EX. 6& 7C i