ML20033A850

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Amended & Supplemental Answers to Issue 17 & Issue 26 Interrogatories.Affidavits & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence
ML20033A850
Person / Time
Site: Waterford 
Issue date: 11/20/1981
From: Larry Jones
JOINT INTERVENORS - WATERFORD, JONES, L.L.
To:
LOUISIANA POWER & LIGHT CO.
References
NUDOCS 8111300026
Download: ML20033A850 (8)
v • d • e


Text

,

_- =

RELATED C0KRESF0"DENCE t

-e 00CMETED U%RC UNITED STATES OF AMERICA -

NUCLEAR REGULA'IURY COMMISSION -

  • 81 NOV 23 P5:08

' ^ ' ? CF SECRETARY ONG & SERVICE MANCH BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of LOUSIANA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY Docket No. 50-382

!Dj (Waterford Steam Electric Station Dh(

Hl.

Unit 3)

N f' hon new l

wn w JOINT INTERVENORS' AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO ISSUE 17 AND ISSUE 26 INTERROGATORIES

{

Interrogatory 17-2:

h Hearings held before the Joint Legislative Committee on Natural Resources on May 14, 1981 pointed up the inadequacy of present evacuatic. plans. The hearings featured Thomas Creaghan, management coordinator for the Office of Emergency Preparedness, and Joe Colson, also of the preparedness office. A copy of the newspaper article on the hearing is included, as Exhibit 1.

I Particulars of criticism of the present evacuation plan are as follows:

(1) Inadequate Roads.

Joint Intervenors believe that a 2.5 mile road is necessary from the new Misissippi River bridge at Luling to the Airline Highway. Also, Joint 1

Intervenors believe that the two lane route Louisiana 3127 should be four SO3 Q

laned.

g 4

8111300026 811120 '

PDR ADOCK 05000382 C

PDR'

c In St. John the Baptist Parish, Joint Intervenors believe that six new i

roads' are necessary. One road between Highway 61 and I-10, and five roads making the evacuation of Laplace subdiviusions to Highway 51 (see 4

newspaper article, attached as Exhibit 2).

(2) Inadequate Procedures Joint Intervenors believe that ir. adequate procedures have been set up for the evacuation of the following types of people:

(a) all people without vehicles 6

(b) schoolchildren (c) aged or crippled (d) sick and hospitalized (e) imprisoned (3) Inadtvluate Testing Joint IAtervenon believe that inadequate testing has been made in the following particulars:

(a) No testing of warning system that has to contact 90% of the population in 15 minutes.

(b) No testing of evacuation times.

1 l

Inte;Togatory 17-4:

Peter Cleary, Citizens for a Better Environment, Staff Physicist --

Richard Pollack, Director of Critical Mass Energy Project -- Ron Lanoue, i

Critical Mas Energy Project -- Bertram Madere, Civil Defense Director of S*. John the Baptist Parish -- Warren Landry, St. Charles Parish 4

Councilman-at-large -- Joel Chaisson, St. Charles Parish Representative

-- John Lucas, Civil Defense Director of St. Charles Parish.

i i

Interrogatory 26-2:

Refer to 17.2 '3)(a) and (b). Since inadequate testing has been done, there is no way 1 tudge the adequacy of decision making capabilities.

Interrogatory 26-4:

Re' ts 17-4.

m Interrogatory 26-6:

Refer to 17-2 (3) (a). Since there has been no testing of the system under emergency conditions, there is no way for Joint Intervenors to judge.

Joint Intervenors request that we be given official notification of any testing procedure and be allowed to participate as observer.

Interrogatory 26-8:

See 17-4.

Interrogatory 26-10:

Refer to 17-2 (3)(b). Since there has been no testing, it is impossible to judge the adequacy of the communication system. Joint Intervenors request that we be allowed to participate in any testing procedure as observer.

Interrogatory 26-12:

Refer to 17-4.

Respectfull bmit GILLESP

& JON I

O/

BY w

/At LYM N L/JON

, JR.

rney for rvenor.

114 Richelake rive Metairie, Loutsiana 7 001 (504)835-6458

o

_y

,, m,,,,,,,,

..,,.. l d ;, '

e ;[gx33rhj[r lyj,y]Q[;. C'g r, O N f ' h(, Q f j,," '[.

.y,

'f[],h..

[

,,,;[.

1

,=

s c... ",.

.. x.

.. g.

f.

' )!.M..: ! -lt -St !Et&n.m

..,. m

.:...o, y

}

.S

, ;*... N-.

]~

. SW-"[1. P. ~ 24..

  • 4

~.. ~; s.'..V:..'.v.f 'The Times-Picayuhe/The States-f tem' r ; * +k-

. FrMay, May 15.198I 7 '&

  • ~. N

~

w'

' N. - i

. g.-

??~.

... < ;1. ~.t a

l (Ub.C L.

.M. b, -

C,.s m 4

v-,

.. r. _., a r c;

. t;.

22 i

x.

y

$b.._bbiMNh1.t N Cf M

5 m.m E n. J M.-

3h 1

....:, y - - a -

f Ey [ '"m 4 HA..

?I'

' ; Ca;;.m,e=

"G ;ODER But ColsooIassured the coS:nitte' e

^

i-fnee a w' rung'toward closer

~ ' Je. -Terp G,,,,,,

c.

ae o

' -I - BATON ROUCE O Evacuation commueleadon with local Ciru

'e j

q

  1. ureates in the conce.ted area around, Defe=* duci* 5 ^"d **er* '"8 M

.. _ /

C.veekthe Phee Mthe j'e"j

'.Waterferd III. Loclsla':a Power 3,: opbg a plan tw a catral,.molce LIC:t Cc:ny..y's nuclear power phnt authority to advise the public.how to the Hc!pbl &n*.xare Man"1_

( OfDee bf Emergency Preparednesstt Tr.fi, La., cre not a:':quate, a state,'**

I*

-;g ber 'of the h

T n m

ge,,,y C,,g3,,. ethat investigated I'J.

i gWE khomas C:eaghan, ma'nagement v

the Thru Mlle Island, Pa., nuclear coordinator for the preparedness disaster, told the comm!ttee that a lack

/

d a dfW w d WMn k

ogency,, told a acelear power. study _ that incident eansed the greatest dam-

~

- CM

[

n 9

'.. subecmmittee of the Joint Legisistive

, Committee on Natural Resources that

  • I,

.sn evaccation plan has been devisd New reporting was terrible,,.;

])

. l Trunk said. "We depended on the i

e_:

9 m

k

' However, he said, "We work with media to tell us the bonest truth. None

~

I p kN what we have. I think we did the best of the stories were the same. They)

C gC'z

~~

job with the routes we had."

were not putting it correctly.

r. ;

l q

Creaghan;did not elaborate on the "The (utility) company was not set j

p

~ @)

present roadway system near the up for this accident" and had no pre-y,

nuclear plant, situated adjacent to the pared information, no public relations

..l MOissippi River in St. Charles Parish. representative, and as a result the

}

g9

( 20000 /

200s )

H Tb{ only access to the plant is a road information to the pub!1e was not accu-1 r,

\\

, [s par:llel to the river. Many industries rate, she said.

g"3,

+

l l

c.re, situated in the area, and the river Trunk said a small town of 15,000 road is the only means of evacuation.

was overrun by 750 news representa.

3/8": Cordless,2-Spd;-

19 Pc;3 Rep. Joel Chaisson. D.Destrehan, lives who exaggerated the problem and i Reversing Drill Soeket i ahs has been critical of safety precau. frfghtened local residents.

j h operam W & 3M RPM W" to 3/d tions and possible problems connected "It was safe for them, but not for with operations of the new power us, she said.

both forward and reverse.

oilonset.tj p plant, declared "We need goed roads,.

.As for the fMeral Nuclear ' egula.

[e 1

R es in on 3 W s.

M Pe. %

.6 good plans, and Waterford IH la get. tory CommiW:, "I s sated it reor-1

.", ting ready to open."

ganized from top to betwm," The com-

'W Chalsson and Sen. Ron Landry. D-missJon is now dom; a better job cf Laplace, both took the Office of Emer-inspection of plants under construction hh p gp

, gency Preparedness to task for not and those in operation, she said.

L,

.j having made recommendations con-Earlier. Dr. Gordon R. Thompson, I

eerning a lack of adequate plans to staff selentist of the Union of Con.

r#

L prq!ect the public frem possible acci. cerned Scientists, charged that nuclear b-gk%

j ' dents at the nuclear power plant.

, plants have the potential for severe d

3 "We haven't been doing anything in accidents, but that the Noelear Regula.

./

the past," agreed Joe Colson, new tory Commission has been unable to

]

/

[j director of the offlee. "It was much state the consequences of a major jerse t!.an I eipacted."

disaster.

l I-1 b

(3, 1

6 CS. honors La right W

m.

to veto 3-waste dump 4

. a,, g

& Air C By DEORGE HAGER blanket right to veto any repositorr.

Flood Light M. nsi

  • W shihgten bureas the other one gave the state the right h gn,,p,ng;,, way to pmtect 3weP WASHINGTON - The Energy to veto-only a repository for "lonz Y"r home fyn intruders.

y cord.2

Department will stand by feuinlan="s term" storage of nuclear waste. Both blanket rfgha Om cxm crdbrr waste arrrrmenta_ bore the awnstar = at E a

Il

M; ~~ %; ~. -~.-u-L,-
=a;- -~~... &,.u.

. ;: ~ ~ ~ -' ~

^

r n, 6.,4. g~. m}i&

m 1~

{

~e.~.w m ;y w(

.. _. ww

~ m :. a w ; p _- m 'we <

s.o=

m. s..

s-

- m. v,).

  • y..y

~, i 9

p w~

[h 31 ~ys r.y:>

o

- [* c., b, ^ r ' } 5,. lll: 7.a.,,,, A'E C, ' '

V.':f. h %,Q2h;, '.* &.n&w l};;

0 ^- '

' ' ^ '

% ~.

. - ~

.n Q

.c,.r.

go b

Ni b ~ 7:..

\\

D,r.,n ; j $ ;,W w:m'* -m r

a;.pra.mm%

w.

_ n+#m "l' N W 5-M +GW >;[. j-W p we,.

n ew1 m^.

=

A M k M

  • M L.U. $: }n c s

4

'I j^

(D

' ~

O*M;~k.;

~~

b R.

r _..f]w*h; ^

k.

i n -

+

QM,%%C j.

h }

&sNht;.w ~ N W"'

~

~

r j w'~~~.hb.5? eh,*

h

,;p'"w p'

,:p4 ~

~

- ~+- A w a

., )'

W

' g.

q. 2' &.. - '_

u

(*~

~

n%-

, gs.%,y,

Mr. @ g y

+

?,',,.4%m]4.< bI

>[

MY '

dWS d

,ycl~xm:8m@e;y.'

O1,A ;.,.

m m:

s m: pn u

m_

(

.&c l

}yg f

@!e.ydj$dM M Q h W lu ~ #~M3hW'f4a3 h @rm.g-

-y M

lRO.$*$e+-WP d

V v %cy "N

yC

$?$5$D??r$, &:,rk

?$%*"?r,my:m2 &

W"w h:58

)-

e.:,p% f+ s,

~ *E

.C

%3 e, s ~w' A -%c.s

~

%"'j,,,, 3 j ; y F-h.,

<f&%

Qb*L 4,

'*%.O W ^ *T Y T 'K.'

'~ L,

"M 1.--

  1. c

_e my V,

s, f

MMM. Jy$%

' N. e

} % t W.

V p3 i

WW%$-

Q Nh?.

Q_

l lhS f

f))

o. u..

a

- ( n th; m

%p g@og y& 4 C'2= K m='Me.;

. wm.y=m am -

v w"

$ [$ $ $S f( N $ k h D b,W W b~

kN sEEt F

M. p m#"1:mawkmAwW m v.%

=

,~

n-m mm

~

. m m u m nQ, a

3

. A.,+u.w..'.'<_,, MTs-u _-

~

m,, c v %

o _ II]ll{

em 4

c - =

a' yn.

o jGMi

) y u

-s Wh M.wv:r -- - - -

,,r cs,.y a r. - c '-

,.y m

=

,~

_x

_ r - 7 7 r -- s t ~ 1 1 h ECW 7 1

mm namm,.g,.

y-g,",,

[

- n E n-. '~mp

,Mj= -, f_ 'Ib w

- T r-'-

T A ' '17".- W u,.; a.T N-

^

v mrS*d'b.:

@. ~' id ' T.U 'n Sc r ri a 1. _.

- N~

GW

,
tp

. Y.

m[,,$'.Q',- }e5 T i' NI g,N w&W, W i

c q.

x, c-

_a h:In f

F

@M.h? W M --r; &, f.. m' g ;?. W

+

n.-

+

m 3i$N.(

WF41

-- r-- rr rr, -y 3 W.

p 4:

--- s i,,

fc T

-C n ' _

79 '

~, m.,.

m.

n-

.1..um, u

- -. - - g.

ms.

3,,n y -

r hr -,, r

,a w en1 r,

i i - m v-H 7 fr.

6.

...u, 1

i a 31

1..

u--

SWnD geWmW'+W 'm%-. 2&

. rm

=

s,_.

9 2, M, M g;c--'u

!='M.?

T W 4 G "' F W "Q ;s" IS%T-EfR, w' i MM N

's

[. 3((- h, -- [,

1,__

4* ' ig

'w

,g s,=. m, r.

., n f'QS]-- M'k 1IiT-6 s'

3

-' 1_

i r-y

. " ft f 4 _.. 7 ') -

=t_

  1. gW

-H-g - p' y. --- a.7_

m '- a < ~i 4.,,.--

g@ k 5 O Ti.9 ' O iUeu

"% ~

Aqg--

_;., 4 '1 ; g - - g g y 1_'

k l

~_

. fa

  • ' l.Nj'T. ff-O ff* $Qf, Whk_,)fflf[ ~ '

M'

~

^

' ' ~ ' '

-!. jh(____ _

- 7

.r, u_3.t-r.>y-4

,e G

1 Nw

r_i, f,_

-n.an

.it_

s Ef.1._

7 i.

7 1 - i --J'i :'.s'I a.

a

,d m,

WB_e a m

Q

.t y'.W.

4 x F Y a_

ri.

.e 1

,,%k -

Fe-a '-' ~ j

--('E l I -' l im e

  • tjv. W T j

T' rr.-

t.

,8

  • v s.

n

- a2 1 m-s :- s -.w77

'4

.a_r-a1Tu-t y-

)

.1-,.,----,_-,n,

,a r -'

,u s -

-' r -

~

%*T1---a n r s '1-1 rm mu yd

.xn..

--s,

~s n 1 fT T' T' l iD[ _Ti1F

^

t 1E1T A~~*~'~

'E'T m zu-ww

',7 T 'A73hy_g'-~S;ig fg g

r-a _ -

a. -- i-

_t cr<

.3v LXHIBIT s

~

s

STATE OF LOUISIANA PARISH OF JEFFERSON BEFORE ME, the undersigned, did appear GARY L. GROESCII, a person of the full age of majority and a resident of the Parish of Orleans, who did declare on oath that Joint Intervenors' Amended and Supp:emental Answers to Issue 17 and Issue 26 Interrogatories filed herein are true and corrcet to the best of his knowledge, information and belief.

'GN4Y.MIROESC11 "

/

Swo to and subscribed before me, Notary, this O'd of uf

_,1981 1

l I

l o-CP v

NOTA IfUBLIC/

1 I

/

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of LOUISIANA POWER & LIGIIT COMPANY Docket No. 50-382 (Waterford Steam Electric Station Unit 3)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on November 20, 1981, I mailed copies of Save Our Wetlands, Inc. and Oystershell Alliance, Inc.'s, JOINT INTERVENORS AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO ISSUE 17 AND ISSUE 26 INTERROGATORIES to all individuals or entities appearing on the attached Service List, postagk; d, first c th United States Mail 7

,N LYS N L. JORES, 5

2

~

SERVICE LIST Sheldon J. Wolfe, Esquire U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Washington, D. C.

20555 Dr. Ilarry Foreman Box 395, Mayo University of Minnesota Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455 Dr. Walter H. Jordan 881 West Outer Drive Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Docketing and Service Section (three copies)

Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.

20555 Sherwin E. Turk, Esquire Office of Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.

20555 George F. Trowbri.1;e, Esquire and E. Blake, Esquire Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1800 M Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C.

20036 W. Malcolm Stevenson, Esquire Montce & Lemann Whitney Building 625 Gravier Street New Orleans, Louisiana 70112 6

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20033A850&oldid=4589929"