ML20032E788
| ML20032E788 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry, Fermi, Susquehanna, Columbia, River Bend, Clinton, LaSalle, Zimmer, 05000447, Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 11/10/1981 |
| From: | Faulkner H Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | John Miller Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8111230170 | |
| Download: ML20032E788 (29) | |
Text
.
~~
f NGi '
- Y O
,f' \\f '
c. DI V
]h,d Dacket flos. 50-322/341/358/3f3/387/397/4'
'58/461 MEMORAfiDUM FOR: James R. f! iller, Chief Standardization & Special Projects Branch, DL FR0!!:
H. J. Faulkner, Project Manager Standardization & Special Projects Branch, DL
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF ltEETIflG WITH LRG I AND LRG II ON OCTOBER 29, 1981 On October 29, 1981, a meeting was held in Bethesda, flaryland, between the flRC staff and representatives of LRG I, LRG II and their consultants to discuss in-core themocouples for BWR's. General Electric Co., as con-tractor to the LRG groups, discussed and presented results of a risk assessment study utilizing in-core themocouples. An attendance list is provided as Enclosure 1.
A copy of the view graphs highlighting the GE presentation is provided as Enclosure 2.
The conclusions of the risk assessment study perfomed by GE re:
'It will cost a minimum of $600,000 and 100 manrem per plant (assuming in:tallation after power operation) to install A
in-core themocouples. Subsequent maintenance will require
.C..d.L['/ N i
about 15 manrem per year.
/,M C/*
- There is minimal benefit arising from the negligible reduction
"(
in core melt probability and the negligible reduction in Im
'o NOVi3 D D #
radiation exposure to the public for incorporating in-core E!
u.s. 'ww#""^"" g themocouples.
cc
' Utilizing the safety goal cost-benefit criterion thatifs
_ @,/
Y[M~- g \\d/
currently being advocated by the ACRS, the cost-benefit consideration does not justify the use of in-core themo-couples in BWR's.
The staff indicated that they would like to receive a fomal submittal including details and resultsof this study. LRG indicated thht this could be provided in about 1 month. Additionally, LRG stated that the more general study of utilizing in-core themocouples in BWR's, that is being perfomed by S. Levy Associates, will be provided to the staff in about 1 month, omce >
8111230170 e1111o sunme >
PDR ADOCK 05000322 "" *"""
..P DR,,,
^
oars >
nac ronu ais oow nscu cao OFFICIAL RECORD COPY uscro: issi -333,eo
NOV 101981 Mr. Rubenstein indicated that there is a draft letter to applicants currently before the Commission for review requesting them to analyze numbers, location, etc., for placement of in-core thermocouples. He indicated that the industry will have an opportunity to present their case on this subject to the ACRS.
Currently, SER's are being written for BWR/4, /5 and /6 plants with a license condition to incorporate in-core themocouples into the ICC monitoring system prior to June 1983. LaSalle and Grand Gulf are the first plants of the BWR near term OLs scheduled for fuel loading. Both plants anticipate fuel loading early in 1982.
gBIGIELL SIGC 3Y
- 11. J. Faulkner, Project Manager Standardization & Special Projects Branch Division of Licensing
Enclosures:
1.
Attendance List 2.
Risk Analysis 0BWR In-core Thermocouples cc: See next page r
gh k
(L
~".SSPB' DL
..v..,.........
ome,,
aum. >...H,,,,,,,1,k,n,e,r,: k,a,b,,,J,Rgi,,,1,e,r
,L
........I9./81
....i,l l /....@..../. 81 11/
am>
OFFIClAL RECORD COPY
. usom asi-m-seo NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 0240
MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION LRG I AND LRG II Docket File
!&E Region I NRC PDR I&E Region II Local PDR I&E Region III SSPB Reading I&E Region IV TERA I&E Region V NSIC H. Faulkner TIC H. Williams E. Case i
D. Houston D. Eisenbr*
R. Perch R. Purple J. Miller E. Hughes SSPB LA/M. Service T. Novak S. Varga R. Boyd, KMC T. Ippolito R. Clark SERVICE LISTS FOR:
Clinton J. Stolz Perry R. Tedesco River Bend B. Youngblood GESSAR II A. Schwence.'
LaSalle F. Piraglia Fermi 2 E. Adensam Shoreham G. Lainas Susquehanna D. Crutchfield WNP-2 Zimmer B. Russell 4,
R. Vollmer A. Bournia R. Mattson L. Kintner S. Hanauer J. Wilson T. Murl ey R. Stark J. Knight R. Auluck W. Johnston I. Pel tier D. Muller M. Rushbrook P. Check C. Berlinger W. Kreger L. Phillips L. Rubenstein F. Schroeder M. Ernst ACRS (16)
I&E (3)
OSD (7)
OELD V. Moore
ENCLOSURE 1 LRG/NRC MEETING 0F OCTOBER 29, 1981 In-Core Thermocouple Risk Analysis I
i NAME REPRESENTING Pat Powell Washington Public Power Supply System John Rigert Long Island Lighting Company Roger S. Boyd KMC, Inc.
Eileen Buzzelli Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co.
Larry E. Schuerman Detroit Edison J. E. Slider NUS (Detroit Edison)
D. J. Cardinale PP&L Dale L. Holtzscher Illinois Power Company John Catlin Bechtel (Miss. Power & Light)
Lesley England Gulf States Utilities M. J. Anciaux GE (LRG II)
D. J. Robare GE (LRG I)
Carl H. Berlinger NRC/NRR/CPB H. Faulkner NRC/DL L. S. Rubenstein NRC/NRR Larry Phillips NRC/NRR/CPB Anthony Bournia NRC/DL 9
y-
,,-,.c.
_..,_,._,,m...m.m__,-,-,-
r._,
.,._=-,,,.._,_.,._,.-..-_w._,..--_,-..,
,,.,_y
ENCLOSURE 2 GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY RISK ANALYSIS BWR CORE THERMOCOUPLES DB: GGT: RF /105L1 10/15/81
OUTLINE o
BACKGROUND o
RISK ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY QUANTIFICATION RESULTS o
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS O
CONCLUSION l
l DB: GGT: RF /105L2 1C/14/81 l
t
i BACKGROUND o
TMI o
NUREG 0737/R.G. 1.97 o
LRG AND BWROG o
LRG APPEAL MEETING o
ACRS MEETINGS o
NRC LETTER o
ACRS LETTER o
GE RISK ANALYSIS DB: GGT : RF /105L3 10/14/81
-n
,yn y-+-m-
--r-n.-,,-
THERM 0 COUPLE RISK ASSESSMENT PURPOSE:
(1)
DETERMINE THE OVERALL BENEFIT DERIVED FROM THERMOCOUPLES AS INDICATED BY ANY REDUCTION IN RISK TO THE PUBLIC WHICH CAN BE ATTRIBUTED TO THERM 0 COUPLE OPERATION.
(2)
DETERMINE THE COST EFFECTIVENESS OF THERM 0 COUPLES BY COMPARING THEIR OVERALL COST WITH THEIR EVALUATED BENEFIT i
l l
DB: GGT /785 10/23/81 l
l l
BWR PROBABILISTIC RISK ASSESSMENT o
TYPICAL BWR/4 MK 11 PRA o
ACCIDENT SEQUENCE PROBABILITIES EVENT TREES (ET) - TOOL TO DISPLAY ACCIDENT SEQUENCES TO ESTIMATE PROBABILITIES FAULT TREES (FT) - DIAGRAMS TO SHOW OPERATOR AND EQUIPMENT FAULTS TO ESTIMATE SYSTEM FAILURE PROBABILITY CORE MELT PROBABILITY o
ACCIDENT SEQUENCE CONSEQUENCES CATEGORIZE ACCORDING TO CORE MELT / CONTAINMENT FAILURE SEQUENCES EARLY/ LATENT DEATHS o
RISK TO PUBLIC PROBABILITY OF ACCIDENT X CONSEQUENCE OF ACCIDENT DB: RF /105L11 10/15/81
METHODOLOGY o
DETERMINED BENEFIT EVALUATED ALL SEQUENCES INVOLVING OPERATOR ACTION QUANTIFIED CHANGE IN OPERATOR ERROR INPUT PROBABILITIES TAKES CREDIT FOR IMPROVED PERFORMANCE DUE TO THERMOCOUPLE INDICATION CALCULATED RESULTS OF CHANGE COMPARED TO TYPICAL BWR PRA RESULTS o
DETERMINED COST INITIAL INSTALLATION SUBSEQUENT TO INSTALLATION o
COMPARED TO SAFETY G0AL CRITERION l
DB: GGT : RF /105L4 10/15/81
QUANTIFICATION o
SINGLE FAILURE EVENTS (ECCS SYSTEMS)
CONTRADICTORY OR CONFUSING SIGNALS 1.0 x 10-3 CHANGED TO 2.0 x 10-4 OPERATOR INATTENTION 5.0 x 10-2 CHANGED TO 1.0 x 10-3 FAILURE TO FOLLOW PROCEDURE 5.0 x 10-2 STAYS 5.0 x 10-2 o
ADS (MANUAL INITIATION)
OPERATOR FAILS TO INITIATE 2 x 10 3 CHANGED TO 1 x 10-3 l
o COMMON MODE FAILURE EVENTS MISCALIBRATION OF WATER LEVEL INSTRUMENTATION MODERATE - 2 x 10-5 CHANGED TO 2 x 10-6 l
SMALL - 2 x 10-3 STAYS 2 x 10-3
~
l DB: GGT:RF/105LS 10/14/8.1 m
m
_s
=aAs-
- .see-mes-a sfs Es s
e_:
ir-
=E
==
t y
v
_a
- t.
e v!. *.
E *s 1 5 5. E *r f f I= E E g s i
E
=.e -
ag
= a s.ns s s s.s.s s.ms s..a -
'i I-r ein umuse num med m
man G
5 O uma sus man um m
um 2
a UN h
"i 3
d l
2 1
4 e
ee b
g4 F
_,-a 1
7 4
es.
sg
_x EYE.
'I 4
W i
g c'
sa e
g ;-
. 1 e
s e
)
., =
he baJ 5
{
Eg
,o ge 2
e.*
L 1.
Re
-3 s
4 g=
]'
3.t.
w W
WS z
5 6
m 2
c g
r-8 BM J31 M =a o
w
}
l 2
Ig 8i.
-1
- ii p:
..T Y
e 4
4 i
--~,er,-,
-w-.v-,--,y,,,_,,
g m -. c y o y,<
y
,..~.,-,---.,,-,yg-,,,y,.n
,+, q,w y-y,,,py.m,,-.,,-y,,
,,mwe-.,-,-,y,mv,+,ee-w,,
-p.,-.,y-, -, - -,
.%,---3,+w
EXAMPLE OF INPUT TO FAULT TREE MANUAL ACTUATION 0F SYSTEM FAILS N
OPERATOR OBTAINS OPERATOR FAILS OPERATOR CONTRADICTORY SIGNALS TO FOLLOW INATTENTION l
AND FAILS TO INITIATE PROCEDURE 1 x 10-3 5 x 10-2 5 x 10-2 2 x 10-4 5 x 10-2 1 x 10-3 i
l DB: GGT: RF /105L6 10/13/81
4 SIMPLIFIED FAULT TREE SHOWING THERM 0 COUPLE EFFECT (HPCI)
FAILURE OF HPCI 7.8 x 10"2 DURING INITIAL 7.8 x 10-2 START AND RUN FALSE SIGNALS FAILURE OF SIGNAL 1.0002 x 10-3 TO INITIATE 1.0001 x 10-3 LOSS OF POWER PUMP FAILURE, ETC.
HPCI L
NOT MECHANICALLY FAILURE TO GENERATE 2.N x 10-7 RESET & NOT INITIATION SIGNAL 1.3 x 10-7 RESET BY OPERATOR FOR HPCI AE FAILURE TO GENERATE MANUAL ACTUATION 9.8 x 10-2 SIGNAL AUTOMATICALLY OF HPCI FAILS 5.1 x 10-2 N NO INPUT CHANGES (OPERATOR ACTIONS WHICH MAY BE AFFECTED BY THERMO-COUPLES)
DB: GGT:RF /105L7 10/27/81 L
INPUT TO ADS TREE OPERATOR FAILS 2 x 10 3 TO INITIATE 1 x 10 3 OPERATOR OBTAINS OPERATOR FAILS OPERATOR CONTRADICTORY SIGNALS TO FOLLOW INATTENTION AND FAILS TO INITIATE PROCEDURE 3 x 10-4 1 x 10-3 1 x 10-3 3 x 10-5 1 x 10-3 1 x 10-4 DB: GGT: RF /105L6 10/15/81
1 SXMPLIFIED FAULT TREE FOR ADS FAILURE TO DEPRESSURIZE 1.05 x 10 3 i
WHEN NEEDED f.03 x 10 3 I
ADS VALVES ADS FAILS TO 9.5 x 10 5 FAIL TO OPEN INITIATE 7.7 x 10 5 i
9.7 x 10 4 FAILURE OF FAILURE OF ENERGIZED INITIATION 9.5 x 10 s PERMISSIVES SIGNAL (TRIP 7.7 x 10 5 SYSTEM A/C) 3.3 x 10 7 i
FAILURE OF AUTOMATIC 1.26 x 10 1 FAILURE OF MANUAL 4 x 10 3 INITIATION' 3 x 10 3 INITIATION 4
A A
I I
FAILURE OF FAILURE TO FAILURE OF FAILURE OF OPERATOR FAILURE OF LOW PRESSURE RECEIVE WATER LEVEL It!. fI ATION FAILS TO INITIATION PERMISSIVE HIGH TRIP LOGIC A/C INITIATE LOGIC E/G DRYWELL PRESSURE 2 x 10 4 1 x 10 1 2.3 x 10 2 2.1 x 10 4 2 x 10 3 1.9 x 10 3 1 x 10 3 i
t
~
DBB:sem/1132 4
10/14/81
.m.
--v 7
9 y-9r ewTrev-y m ew'q t-4-=~w*y*umsfe
- w13 9-gr ofre-6-ggggev---**gr-eyw't-vP-wa
- 9-' at r-r rber%eig r ~94e tw v,
9 m-ppa g g '
t,-y*g9-%*m p-p T-5=e+9>q9 ve+r-pp+y-t_-ne'
RESULTS 1
o EVALUATED ALL PRA SEQUENCES WITH OPERATOR ACTION NEGLIGIBLE OR NO EFFECT AT SYSTEM LEVEL o
HARDWARE FAILURE PATHWAYS MOST LIMITING OPERATOR IS BACKUP TO AUTOMATIC FUNCTIONS OPERATOR RELIABILITY IMPROVED THROUGH TRAINING AND EMERGENCY PROCEDURE GUIDELINES NEGLIGIBLEEFFECTONFINALCOREMELTPRbBABILITY o
9.5 x 10 6 WITHOUT THERMOCOUPLES 9.3 x 10 6 WITH THERM 0 COUPLES I
o NEGLIGIBLE EFFECT ON RADIATION EXPOSURE TO PUBLIC NO EFFECT ON EARLY FATALITIES 2% DECREASE IN LATENT FATALITIES (
01 LIFE) i j
DB: GGT: RF /105L9 10/14/81
==
.m.
-==ry-W"*7p
""+'y-e e4,t'-'yy-y bwm y
m M-99-Weiq-'++
?We>7g*,
g -N " 8 g y-is.-=,
7p-Pew Wysem3,_-e yg4t--r r w 4rW~p 4
%=PP=&tPP"
=*W-'"
PT*-=*
p V '
10*I I
- L "ND Alsg
,,.3 I
m
- AL NATURAL ggsg le.3 A
as M
Al
\\
A8 NSHES PERSONS
,I
\\
3 18.g ON GROUND g
4 4
10 Y
o-r CASH 1400 swr 7(\\
f SITT T
$PCCIFJC ~
, g.9 1-
,0 EMLY FATALITIES x gt f
10*3
^4 E
10 Stees ast R
~~,
j na
- g-w
\\
11
~
gg-4 1FIC1FIC fv4LuATIQis g
\\
l N
a la,
- =-
\\
1 10~8 kj 10*'
2 10 too 3.
W. W LAtart Fatalttist* Pee fear, 3
- Latu t Fatalltfes me to % agit aggg w g %,
e
E CONCLUSIONS o
BWR THERM 0 COUPLES COST INITIAL (GE MINIMUM ESTIMATES)
$600K 100 MANREM SUBSEQUENT MAINTENANCE FORCED OUTAGES 15 MANREM/ YEAR o
BWR THERMOCOUPLE BENEFIT NEGLIGIBLE EFFECT ON CORE MELT PROBABILITY NEGLIGIBLE EFFECT ON RADIATION EXPOSURE TO PUBLIC o
SAFETY G0AL COST BENEFIT CP.ITERION ACRS - $5 MILLION PER EARLY DEATH AVERTED
$1 MILLION PER LATENT DEATH AVERTED f
o COMPARIS0N l
l EARLY - $600K COST WITH N0 BENEFIT l
LATENT - $600K COST WITH LESS THAN.01 LIFE SAVED COST BENEFIT DOES NOT JUSTIFY THERM 0 COUPLES IN BWR i
DB: GGT:RF /105L10 10/15/81
Illinois Power Cbmpany cc w/ enclosure (s):
Mr. L. J. Koch, Vice President Hugh K. Clark, Esq. Chairman Illinais Power Company P. O. Box 127A 500.9auth 27th Street Kennedyville, Maryland 21645 Decatur, Illinois 62525 Dr. Oscar H. Paris Mr. Julius Geier Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Illinois Power Company U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 500 South 27th Street Washington, D. C.
20555 Decatur, Illinois 62525 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Peter V. Fazio, Jr., Esq.
Appeal Board Panel Schiff, Hardin & Waite U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7200 Sears Tower Washington, D. C.
20555 233 South Wacker Drive Chicago, Illinois 60606 Dr. George A. Ferguson School of Engineering Mr. H. H. Livermore, Resident Inspector Howard University U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2000 Sixth Street, N.W.
RR 3, Box 229A Washington, D. C.
20059 Clinton, Illinois 61727 Richard J. Goddard, Esq.
Mr. D. L. Foreman, Project Manager Office of the Executive Legal Director General Electric Company U.-S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 175 Curtner Avenue, M/C 682 Washington, D. C.
20555 San Jose, California 95125 Mr. R. C. Heider, Project Manager Mr. Charles Bacon Sargent & Lundy Engineers Prairie Alliance 55 East Monroe Street P. O. Box 2424 Chicago, Illinois 60603 Station A Champaign, Illinois 61820 Reed Neuman, Esq.
~
Assistant Attorney General Philip L. Willman, Esq.
500 South 2nd Street Assistant Attorney General Springfield, Illinois 62701 Environmental Control Division 188 West Randolph Street Suite 2315 i
Chicago, Illinois 60610 4
=
m D
pgggy Peter B.
Bloch, Chairman Robert.Alesander' Atomic Safety and Licensing Board OCRE Interim Representative U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2030 Portsrcouth.. Street $2 Washington, D.C.
20555 Houston, Tenas 77,098 Dr. Jerry R.
Kline Daniel D. Wilt, Esquire
. Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Wegman, Hessler & Vanderburg ---
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Suite 102 Washington, D. C. 20555 7301 Ch'ippewa Road 5
Brecksville, Ohio 44141 h-Mr. Frederick J.
Shon Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Terry Lodge, Esquire 7
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 915 Spitzer Building Washington,
D.C.
20555 Toledo, Ohio 43604 Atomic Safety and Licensing Mr. Tod J.
Kenney Board Panel 228 South College, Apt. A U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Bowling Green, Ohio 43402 Washington, D.C.
20555 Donald T.
E zone, Esquire Atomic Safety and Licensing Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Appeal Board Panel Lake County Administration Center U. S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission 105 Center Street' Washington, D.C.
20555 Painesville, Ohio 44077 Docketing and Service Section Office of the Secretary U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commissien Washing:On, D.C.
20555 James H.- Thessin, Esquire
~
Office of the Executive Legal Directer U. S. Nuclear Regulatcry Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 t
e
~
RIVER BEND Mr. William J. Cahill, Jr.
Senior Vice President River Bend Nuclear Group ATTN:
Mr. J. E. Booker Gulf States Utilities Company Post Office Box 2961 Beaumont, Texas 77704 Troy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.
Conner, Moorc & Corber 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20006 Mr. J. E. Booker, Safety &
Licensing Gulf States Utilities Company P. O. Box 2951 Beaumont, Texas 77704 i
Stanley Plettman, Esq.
Orgain, Bell & Tucker Beaumont Savings Building Beaumont, Texas 7770)
~
Lefin P. Sheldon, Esq.
Sheldon, Harmon & Wiess 1725 I Street, NW Washington, DC 20006
~
William J. Guste, Jr., Esq.
Attorney General State of Louisiana P. O. Box 44005 Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70804 Richard M. Troy, Jr., Esq.
Asst. Attorney General in Char State,of Louisiana Dept. of Justice 234 Loyola Avenue New Orl'eans, Louisiana 70112 S
e
GESSAR II General Electric Company ATTN: Glenn G. Sherwcod, Manager Safety & Licensing Operation Nuclear Power Systems Division
~
175 Curtner Avenue, Mail Code 682 San Jose, California 95125 cc.
Mr. Joseph F. Quirk, Manager BWR Standardization General Electric Company 175 Curtner Avenue San Jose, CA 95114 Mr. L. Gifford, Manager Regulatory Operations Unit General Electric Company 7910 Woodmont Avenue Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Director, Criteria & Standards Division Office of Radiation Programs l
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 401 M Street, S.W.
Washington, D.C.
20460 1
1 O
LaSalle o
Mr. J. S. Abel Director of Nuclear Licennng Commonwealth Edison Company Post Office Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 6C690 cc:
Philip P. Steptoe, Esq.
Suite 4200 One First National Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60603 Dean Hansell, Esquire Assistant Attorney General 188 West Randolph Street Suite 2315 Chicago, I.llinois 60601
.Mr. Roger Walker, Resident Inspector -
U. S. Nuclear Regulato'ry Commission Post Office Box 224 Marseilles, Illinois 61364 6
4 e p
)
m
-7 e
e s
=
9
[
e e
+
~
.....o-
.gp
- q3=.[3
~. _.. -
.~..
c
~"
Mr. Harry Tauber - e
'J
- ~~
' - Vice President Engineering & Construction Detroit Edison Company 2000 Second Avenue
-Detroit, Michigan 48226
^cc:
Eucene'B. Tnomas, Jr., Esq.
~
LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae 1333 New Hampshire Avenue, N. W.
Wa'shington, D. C.
20036 Peter A. Marquardt, Esq.
Co-Counsel The Detroit Edison Cgmpany 2000 Second Avenue
-Detroit, Michigan 48226,
Mr. William J. Farner Project Manager - Fermi 2 The Detroit Edison Company 2000 Second Avenue Detroit, Michigan 48226 Mr. Larry E. Schuerman Detroit Edison Company 3331 West Big Beaver Road Troy, Michigan 48084 David E. Howell, Esq.
'1;.
.:::.E : -ve.ue
.E-5-
-:: I 7
Mr. Eruce Little U. 5. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
.esic-.t inspector's Office f45; 4. Cis.ie Hic
-..Ey
,s.c o r t, "icnigan c5166
- c.
.-; =. n e J e n s 2;'_; Seccrc nvenue Detroit, nicnican 4s226 e
4
SHOREHAM "r. ". S. Pollock Vice President - Nuclear David Gilmartin, Esq.
Lono Island Linhtino Company Suffolk County Attorney-175 East Old Country Road County Executive / Legislative Bldg.
Hicksville, flew York 11801 Veteran's Memorial Highway hauppauce, New York 11788 CC:
Howard L. Blau, Esc.
IMB Technical Associates
- llau and Cohn, P. C.
1723 H w.ilton Avenue - Suite K 217 Mewbridae Road San Jose, California 95125 Hicksville, t!ew York 11801 Stephen Latham, Eso.,
Jeffrev Cohen, Esc.
iwomey, Latham & Schmitt nenuty Commissioner and Counsel New York State Energy Office 33 st Sec d Street Acency Buildino 2 Riverhead, New York 11901 Encire State Plaza Albany, New York 12223 Joel Blau, Esouire New York Public Service Commission Enerov Research Grouo, Inc.
The Governor Nelson A. Rockefeller Sidg.
Empire State Plaza 400-1 Totten Pond Road Albany, New York 12223 Walthan, "assachusetts 0215t-
~'
Ezra I. Bialik B. R. "cCaffrey Assistant Attorney General Shoreham L:1 ear Dower Station
., Environmental Protection Bureau
- c. n. Box 618 tTew York State Department of Law u dino River, f!ew York 11742 2 World Trade Center a
tiew York, New York 10047 N'. ivlor Oeveiev, III, Esc.
Hunten r vi, ians
- . n. ::x 15 %
- !c- :d. vircinia 23217 c lon Shaniro, Esc.
a Ca=er L Shaoiro o East F th Street
ee Yo rk, ':ew York 10n16
~
Je"rev r tter u
trr Ifian+ Lichtino Coroanv l
75" 'id Country : iced "ineola, "ew York 11501 Desident Insnector/Shoreham NPS c/o H.S. *!uclear Reculatory Cormission 0, G. Box B vork 11778 c int, New Occkv o
Fono rable Oeter Cohalan Su# folk Countv Executive
{nunty Executive /Lecislative Buildinc Vateran's "emorial Hichwav Hhnnauce, Mew York 117AR 3
I
$USQUEHAWNA Mr. Norman W. rurtis Vice President Engineering and Construction Pennsylvania Power & Light Company Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 ccs: Jay Silberg, Esquire Ms. Colleen Marsh Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge P. O. Box 538A, RD #4 1800 M Street, N. W.
Mountain Top, Pennsylvania 18707 Washington, D. C. 20036 Mr. Thomas J. Halligan Edward M. Nagel, Esquire Correspondent General Counsel and Secretary The Citizens Against Nuclear Dangers Pennsylvania Power & Light Company P. O. Box 5 2 North Ninth Street Scranton, Pennsylvania 18501 Allentown, Pennsylvania 1810i Mr. J. W. Millard Mr. William E. Barberich Project Manager Nuclear Licensing Group Supervisor Mail Code 395 Pennsylvania Power & Light Company General Electric Canpany 2 North Ninth Street 175 Curtner Avenue Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 San Jose, California 95125 Mr. G. Rhodes
- Robert W. Adler, Esquire Resident Inspector Office of Attorney General P. C. Box 52 505 Executive House Shickshinny, Pennsylvania 18655 P. O. Box 2357 Har.risburg, Pernsylvania 17120 Gerald R. Schultz, Esquire Susquehanna Environmental Advocates P. O. Box 1560 Wil kes-Barre, Pennsylvania 18703 Mr. E. B. Poser Project Engineer Bechtel Power Corporation P. O. Box 3965 San Francisco, California 94119 Dr'. Judith H. Johnsrud Co-Di recto r Environmental Coalition on Nuclear Power 433 Orlando Avenue State College, Pennsylvania 16801 Mr. Thomas, M. Gerusky, Director Bureau of Radiation Protection Resources Commonwealth of Pennsylvania P. O. Box 2063 Ha rri sburg, Pennsy ; v.
17120
WNP-2 Mr. R. L. Ferguson Managing Direefor Washington Public Power Supply System P. O. Box 968 3000 George Washington Way Richland, Washington 99352 ccs:
Nicholas Reynolds', Esq.
Debevoise '& Liberman 1200 Seventeenth Street, N. W.
Washington, D. C.
20036 Richard Q. Quigley, Esq. '
Washington Public Power Supply System P. O. Box 968 l
Richland, Washington 99352 Nicholas Lewis, Chairman Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council 820 East Fifth Avenue Olympis, Washington 98504 Mr. Albert D. Toth Resident I.isfector/WPPSS-2 NPS y
c/o U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 69 Richland, Washington 99352 Roger Nelson, Licensing Manager Washington Public Power Supply System P, 0. Box 968 Richland, Washington 99352 Mr. O. K. Earle, Project Licensing Supervisor
. Burns and Roe, Incorporated 601 Williams Boulevard P,ichl.and, Washington 99352 e
-h
i ZIMMER Mr. Earl A. Borgmann Senior Vice President
~
Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company Post Office Box 960 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 cc: Troy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.
Mrs. Mary Reder Conner, Moore & Corber Box 270, Rt. 2 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
California, Kentucky 41007 Washington, D. C.
20006 Andrew B. Dennison, Esq.
4 Mr. William J. Moran 200 Main Street General Counsel Batavia, Ohio 45103 Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company-Fost Offite Box 960 George E. Pattison, Esq.
Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 Clermont County Proscuting Attorney 462 Main Street
~
Mr. Samuel H. Porter Batavia, Ohio 45103 Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur 37 West Broad Street Resident Inspector /Zimmer Columbus, Ohio 43215 RFD 1, Post Office Box 2021 U. S. Route 52 Mr. James D. Flynn, Manager Moscow, Ohio 45153 Licensing Environmental Affairs Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company Mr..J_ohn Youkilis Post Office Box 960 Office of the Honorable William Gradison Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 United States House of Representatives Washington, D. C.
20515
?
David Martin, Esq.
Office of the Attorney General Timothy S. Hogan, Jr., Chairman 209 St. Clair Street Board of Commissioners First Floor 50 Market Street, Clermont County Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Batavia, 0.hio 45103 4
James H. Feldman,Jr., Esq.
Lawrence R. Fisse, Esq.
216 East 9th Street Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Cincinnati, Ohio 45220 462 Main Street Batavia, Ohio 45103 W., Peter Heile, Esq.
Assistant City Solicitor Rcom 214, City Hall C,intinnati, Ohio 45220 John D. Woliver, Esq.
Legal Aid Security Post Office Box #47 l
550 Kilgore Street Batavia, Ohio 45103 O
n f
.