ML20028C048
| ML20028C048 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/22/1982 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 ALAB-687, NUDOCS 8301050386 | |
| Download: ML20028C048 (7) | |
Text
-
~
d
/
. #"'.'.sy'w *,* b..e( h h *o.
[y ?,.
'.pi{'
i ,' -* * *.'(#.4..# \\." ". [.. .[.,
h.c ( ~
- g S ip/Q'...[
- .'^I ' c... r 4 (._'_., }
- I.
,.c.'..
s
-.f' O_.
C..,'.'f.*,S.. 7%
..,.,1,'G.
1 s,..
Ys m
~
N C
x
. L %, %l g U
, s.S i lh, %*),i.b. [{s,'W-:.}..I'j ry c n . 4. W.Ed'D* ,' W W.%M *'e'/.T". 4 8 *tY.M #
W Ji'.
' / *.)F
'Ie P M M.C J.%!$ M9 d,r7.'u.,.R
,+j m
- e. #...@,,n h.s y n. n. n..
,"o,D
, w,~
s f.h
.n <. m p *jf.f),.,; #. _..
m e
n y%
.g w,
/ s.m.;, y. T 4
p*'
- h ;
.a.'...
. r i... n
.;R
. ~,.4 1.
m
.m..
-iM49.Ma %n%:@M.%M9
'[\\ 5 :l 9m w % w*;7.p;mpyy ::::.v. Am,yw:;9w%:3,y q
wm,, s.s.
,, c.
' - ': - k. m..t:- w w.t - +. M '
',.~y?.v >;, 5 M.
M.
4.. v, m... Wy e.
o,
4
+ ;;w c
r.m..
s
&mm.I;TPMSCRIPT mms.4ya m an m%wnd OFFICIA
~
mym$-w.de p.,,$,2 U t $wwj.;Y MM J LSa MRROC, EEDING I
... u lc hp y N'hh..v,g'n-NM MW8...h:;,:h6f$NM.N EN,.,h,,y$!N.Qt&&.v>'tw & y Ol iorar - %.'"P d.h;DMN:'a.A W WRhy!.'h?h.Sh.
xt,.Q.
3.... h..
%a?.p 3,
f gMn v n.u o t
d W
- ;tw ~ u.
2f k
- 9. g,-h 77,Q;$g$m$.Wm@m..+Ai'q.rm$.&n e
$$I55.h,h$pki h
f f/ NNsh Q 7. swywy. yOcg;wc.gii?.f:#qvy.M.,U-QY A QNUCLEAR, REGULATORY..COleiISSION W.2,.t.Q,.9%g.
Aph,>
4
%. w -& p% %
y
, g. ;,-.2. %w...w&. c N?<ill, &wu.q%..cQun,s'I&. #. 3.
I.K,g.a.j&%u..f..w%.e,q$p. l>W.q
. > 4. w &j. g e,+. w 9..Mf a.,.,, r,n %.s G
- ? > H
.x w%.
6 m.d,v% y.a m..%.,,,+.,,>
- n.. <g, ; 7 w, t.
. w.,.
t.
- r. -
4 PUBLIC MEETING
.~p,
~
e
". m. <
..n y
. v..c e..
. %.,,>y;
..c...
m f V ?r ;(.., u.,.y; ?. ' ; 3:gcv.?Qa. f.} f. :
. ' 2,,. '
S.,,'j 3.:,,, *l&.f._
- $ /5.Q.:h, ~ ' S ' %'
, l
.,;j M.:
.... p i.+).. +, g g zu.;.
,,5.w gw
/
"k. b, l'
^
- r. m 5 + v v + q,.;, % g...w[gs yhp.p.W.W, 5; W ' ',ryf#QfWWM M@t,W.$;; y%@*e(.s#
- h.. w y
%c p,a w
/.7
. t c.@m.y. y;< h.
.W n.Q [b3 D#4,.$ ygf f W: '. W.@,,.d. U L,[,y.c,. e,0 ? AFFIRMATION / DISCUSSION '
eg ;, Q 'JE. '.M.o
.U.M-V.
.W.Wl.ggN..,' g;p.p%g..M.,.a
,g ac t..a... s n
s
~Mm9
- q.
- -=SaINdTOE W e N m,#W.
m a *:
W PLACE
..vg
. 4 +.. '
t gw
,.,,s i.c
..s.
. A. /..
.,.,<o>s...
. a..-
rr 3m,
.a;.-
.c. M 4<,
1C,.E'] DECEMBER.22r1982~
M.' 7 O '..
,.d
.< u. w,>,h & i, ~ ?. w. a% p: ~.yd b:.~ a Q
~
M
.c.y. n.~Qc & +. '- *
. g.
r w
. *j
- v. =
- e. & e:.?#
~.,
ifQhf.fqf) ~.. ::v
.N'd' f5l y?Q&
. &.~.. m.f. f..,ta t
f ^ \\ %p<s..'. -.:.
va. t. s.. e ;-9. ;...
./ V.. a s.'
.0
.e%
"... w~.
as
- q.s; q,.; A % ;. %.... q., y.a q + py
.g t<>.s y j,Vb.. ~ a
.a
.~~r
> g ;h. '..J u.% -
s:
.~
- L g
- .y.
. ;m
.~ a A'
. h1
.s*
1% y;r c ( y Q., #
<. ;. ?
- 5.y nhMNA d- $
y 3
.. p 9;-
.t h. *' ',.dh. #d a.h.,y*i
[ h kl k.,.y us
. h vfy }b, c s.O;W ry;.,p,.,.,',p'
.. r b' c..
\\*
I.
/
]
',f
,p. Q,;g;*pv a j,3, s. %.,*...,,
,c,.
m>
st vr M.,. :..
.. u. 3..g 3
a y 4,g@,4,..
3(.v~ } w. $g, @;:
y Tp.
i g
, q\\. fe
.e 4
- 3An.,ww
. : c,;., ", ' e,, 2 ; %y;',o.,. w ~;~. G,.
. J.-?.$ '. s 4 '. R.:*,"a.f, f:;yt,s,1,v;.a :. g *(. f.,n:
. r; Of ;.w.t
. ]%
t.
q-e se'.q,
- ~ ~. -
nY %'W,g."., y., p.. v &.'. /I s,3,;,.4. -
.,s
..s
- a
, ",..c N,, e.. r> ;^.*
n., ',, c
..,,, g - }
mq
. r.,,.-
c eI %,
4.4p h e k
,t,
[pg
( [4
.e
- Q[A' $
... h %'I
. ' m[4 M ya.%. '.r. (. A w %
)4,
- .g g
$. i. :, /g, b" '., F!\\ &. g;>;,5 f
f g**
J &x,., MJ'iy..~ W ?.Q M
.A I
y4 s ('
~n 4.,qd.
4e,y u:+ v..g,.G.. a. ce'nl.*^ylW'$.y%n..,
t ea...mr er a.,&.., w.'; ! ','.:'f.. ;.,kQ.,.. <
- h. s & +& Y. Y '.;..
m.;.:t &w.i.s.,. y% 1 3 Q.,~..n;. y;'s*p.,
y.**,
aW p
'w,.
ss m,
, :::s..
a.
i-xyy 4) p.,
..w.
9. T,. n %); W e.?;e.Qm...n w.M.. s. %
-x 9.57.y~w &@t, %: @.
p
.; w : 9 ?n,,;a p;> y G,q e-4_:.v %w,,,g.v.
i,1
?c q
~
~. W' n q;5.s%, w.y. : s.
r h.m H.%:.m:e. w,1 c%o 1,.
.u. n y,.,
. y/,p. pct qs g%.g., >n g*
~.
n.
y
. m..- y, s.. s..
(* & % n ',%..
h q: y Mt p
ww a n~64..
y.% br 7(/...
- v. Jrr.*.ca
% w. s ?.i.t'c. :;6
<~
.'"..g~ % W M.;y. p, # Q # G. g yM'y;' g.!a N. yp(4.e,:..,v,n,.p s..
z, m.. G n* $.y @M. y n " %~:s.v.M.w ;p:
]* +
.a.g
/
i v ;m uw 3 (s.
51.9,r,f f37.C.:y!
,8yn;, 3:.. v~...
m.p i. n..;+.s ~_
e m.
... c,,. +..
. n.
,.,~.~e
.,.nray
.<v
.w s
s 0$
V
.f s.::1
- h. y. g t; g g e m s ) g. g g w s g f4 w, e, g % ge;.me.g,g e
om om swa w
&: w.c h
gyg.Q.s
,, gy n q non tecs, v
+!%lp$'hy$$m$%'iWa :m m.mw.%p,k, yg3, g3
.nw;9 ts.g
.M rT9 7 eon
- 4. t.,g g
7 M. w:h.S h [ %g _% u'Q y96 4$e ipwpg&. Q
.u.m w~.n w&4 Wc s.
a
% '*?Qf&,.%: p:?;p g.a. % r.q %y%
'.h 9 %.y<%%,,% m:Q,.Wa ir&%,n fy hf,,,p>.;am_j:..
~.%..
./h.n QQ
.w
<~Qs.e. 4,:
mis.h A&.%y?.K; {4'g:p;g'2, \\ R%. >.pc.k,.f.:
r 4
m 0
49f.g ty
'1 A,. r:.1.,* :
s.
a
% r %v m.q'., M.
p./n.,. g e. u. ~ + >
u,. w,h t, N.. t,;;mm s' m x.
v
- 4%g = r..g. b i-W p.. /. ~. " U '.. "Y.n*. n..;;. p' '.*.o. y sj
'
- l'.' # s d ',v ' f.. '.
v o
y Q
r
.f~,
J.
'N a,k, u, -[E 5 g
- . 3 4 A' $..h;.j %. 'e f.,b @. ,. o,- -.* e
.2
+ ;*- ( l *
[ '.'. '
- 5. V "^ %
- ,, i * * '
Q g
.:4.y,,.d q
. ~.
m
' ~ 1 ss.
7 7 *m *N'*1202) 628-9300
' '* ' ' ' M "Y W.j (T ' ' Y,.C a*' -
- 8
. ' ~.
..4
,W.*.
4'g "\\.
%.~ f T
- s. h i
- 4$
, '." > ^$ e c. !
td-i
<.-Mn. $.c %..h.440 FIRST STREET, N.W.$.% y wassiscTos. o.c zoooi. p. g Q v:m er.. m :w d m
..-y
3
{'.';
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
L
~
s 5
AFFIRHATION/ DISCUSSION AND VOTE I
6 7
8 PUBLIC MEETING 9
10 11 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Room 1130 12 1717 H Street, N. W.
Wa shington, D. C.
13 l
Wednesday, December 22, 1982 15 The Commission convened, pursuant to notice, at i
16 3s35 p.m.
17 COHNISSIONERS PRESENT:
18 NUNZIO PALLADINO, Chairman of the Commission JOHN AHEARNE, Commissioner 1g THOMAS ROBERTS, Commissioner JAMES ASSELSTINE, Commissioner 20 STAFF AND PRESENTERS SEATED AT COMMISSION TABLE:
21 S. CHILK 22 J. HOYLE l
J. ZERBE 23 N. MALSCH
'S 24 t
g I
ALDliRSCf} REPORTING COMPANY,INC, 400 VIRGINtA AVE., S.W, WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2345
I i
~
DISCLAIMER This is an ' unofficial transcript of a meeting of the United States
'y. Nuclear Regulatory Comission held on Decembei 22, 1982 in the Consission's offices at 1717 H 5treet, N. W., Wasnington, D. C.
The meeting was open to public attendance and observation.
This transcript has not been reviewed, corrected, or edited, and it may contain~ inaccuracies.
The transcHpt is intended solely for general infonnationai purposes.
As provided by 10 CFR 9.103, it is not part of the forinal or infonnal recorti of decision of the matters discussed.
iixpressions of opinion in 1this. transcript do not necessariTy reflect final determinations or beliefs. No pleading or other paper may be filed with the Connission fit
{-
any proceeding as the result of or addressed to any statement or argument contained herein, except as the Connission may auth'orf ze.
e 4
9 9
+
5 3.
~
=
/
2 o
{j 1
E E. 9. E E T D. I 1 9. 5.
j 2
CHAIRMAN PALLADIN0s This is an 3
affirmation / discussion session and I will ask the g,
(.
4 Secretary to walk us through the items on the agenda.
5
- 58. H0YLE:
Mr. Chairman, there are two 8
affirmation items for today.
7 The first is SECY-82-473.
This paper pertains 8
to a UCS notion to direct the staff to reschedule a 9
meeting.
The Commission is being asked to approve an 10 order that grants in part and denies in part this motion.
j 11 The Chairman, Commissioners Ahearne, Roberts 12 and Asselstine have approved the proposed order with the 13 modification by Commissioner Asselstine.
Commission
(,,
14 Gilinsky did not approve the order.
15 I ask you to affirm your votes.
16 CHAIRHAN PALLADIN0s Aye.
17 CORMISSIONER AHEARNE Aye.
18 COHNISSIONER ROBERTSs Aye.
19 CONHISCIONER ASSELSTINEa Aye.
20 NR. H0YLEs The second is SECY-82-457 21 regarding review of ALAB 687 in the Duke Power case.
1 22 The Commission is being asked to approve an order taking 23 partial review of this ALAB.
()
24 The Chairman, Commissioners Roberts and 25 Ahearne have approved the proposed order as modified in 5
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC.
400 VIRGINIA AVE, S.W., WASHINGTON. D.C. 20024 (202) 554 2345
s 3
(%
1 the one ve sent around to you today.
Commissioner has 2
disapproved taking review.
Consissioner Asselstine has 3
approved in part and dissen ted in part.
He vould not s
4 have sought review of the second issue specified on pago 5
2 of the order.
6 May I ask you to affirm your votes, please.
7 CHAIRNAN PALLADIN0s Aye.
8 COHNISSIONER AHEARNE4 Aye.
g CONHISSIONER ROBERTS:
Aye.
10 CORNISSIONER ASSELSTINE:
Aye.
11 HR. HOYLE 4 That is all, Mr. Chairman.
12 CHAIRMAN PALLADIN0s Thank you.
13 Anything more tha t should come before us.
14 ER. CHIL}C Nothing more for the affirmation 15 session.
16 Ihank you.
17 The meeting is adjourned.
18 (Whereupon, at 3 s38 p.m.,
the to affirmation / discussion session adjourned.)
20 21 22 23
()
24 25
(.i n.
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC.
400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2345
~
^
O O
4 NAR REGULL9. E CDMMISSICN
(
3 This is ec car.157 that the. attached preceedings cefces the
,~.
,-m
. COMMISSION MEETING is the 224447 of:.
PUBLIC MEETING - Affirmation / Discussion and Vote Date of Frcceeding:
December 22, 1982
@CC3CSC EQRher Place of Proceedist:
washington, D. C.
W o kalt as heret: appears., act chah thLs Ls the artzizaL : sasari; thereof ice che CLLe of the Cs~+ <sLaa.
Mary C. Simons Offf=ial Espertar (Typed)
MM Official Hagercer (514 accre) l l
e CC
~
,,-,.w-w--we,w
,_____m_
-- - --- g 1 2/81 P
.mp
- P TP.ANSMITTAL TO:
Document Control Desk,
[
016 Phillips
- p
.p
- 5:
ADVANCED COPY TO.
O The Public Document P,oom DATE:
//J//3 cc: GPS File ~
g From: SECY OPS Branch
<:=a=,
C&R (Natali.e-)
3:
. Attached.are l copies of a dor:: mission meeting N@=,
transcript /s/ and related meeting documan't/s/.
They are being forwa.rded for entry on the Daily Accession P:lii=>
List and placement in the Public Document Room.
No tll iip other distribution is requested or required.
Exist:t.ng DCS identification numbers are listed o_n the indiv.i, dual' documents wherever,known.'.
.p s;=>
Heeting
Title:
f/ b C //fi y J..
j A pt hML 8L lS '
6 pen X
/
~
h n NG DATE:
/.,2 /,:i'A/N2 Closed DOS COPIES:
~
Copies (1 of each checked!
ITEM DESCRIPTION:
Advanced To PDR:
May g
M M.
- Original be Duplicate S 1.
- Document Duo
- Copy
- f
/
/
5
$2
$i:
<=:
.g 2.*
,;5=
1 5:
3
<=:
~
3, 4.
5.
7=
~*
M S
C
- Verify if in DCS, and
- ~
(PDR is advanced one of ea'h document, two change to "PDR c
available."
of each SECX paper.)
!Y( JYiYi\\YYR\\ iYNJYbYYl Y YEYdo Y
,