ML20028B523
| ML20028B523 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 11/22/1982 |
| From: | Hood D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| ISSUANCE-OL, ISSUANCE-OM, ISSUANCES-OL, ISSUANCES-OM, NUDOCS 8212020210 | |
| Download: ML20028B523 (12) | |
Text
l
.c Novemb:r 22, 1982 Docket Nos: 50-329 OM, OL and 50-330 OM, OL APPLICANT:
Consumers Power Company FACILITY:
Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF NOVEMBER 5, 1982, MEETING ON INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDEP' INNING On November 5,1982, the NRC staff met in Bethesda, Maryland with Consumers Power Company (CPCo); Stone and Webster Engineering Corp. (S&W); and Parsons, Brinkerhoff, Quade and Douglas, Inc. (PBQD) to discuss the qualifications and charter of S&W and PBQD regarding the independent assessment of the implementation of the auxiliary building underpioning work.
Representatives of the Government Accountability Pro-ject (GAP), a public interest group, also attended and provided questions and com-ments.
Meeting attendees are listed by Enclosure 1.
Handouts (Enclosure 2) were provided during CPCo's presentation.
Mr. J. Mooney of CPCo reviewed relevant portions of CPCo's letter of September 17, 1982, which announced that S&W and PBQD would conduct a third party assessment of the initial phase of the construction of the auxiliary building underpinning.
The assessnent team, which consists of eight people, is reviewing the soils design documents and construction plans, and will review construction itself, to assure that the design intent is being impleanted and that construction is consistent with industry standards.
The assessment will also assure that the quality assur-ance (QA) program is being implemented satisfactorily and that construction is being implemented in accordance with the construction documents.
Mr. Mooney also reviewed a previous meeting between CPCo and NRC Region III per-sonnel which provided copies and discussed the associated Project Quality Plan and the professional qualifications of the team members.
Professional qualifications of team members were reviewed by Mr. Stan Lucks of S&W, the team project manager, and by Mr. Louis Silano of PBQD, Messrs Lucks and Silano stated that all members of the review team met the independency criteria specified in Chairman Palladino's letter of February 1,1982, to Representative John Dingell.
S&W experience with independent assessments was noted to include the Summer and Diablo Canyon plants.
Underpinning experience of PDQB was noted to include numerous structures and activities associated with construction of the San Francisco and Atlanta transit systems.
Mr. Mooney noted that any nonconformance report, weekly progress reports, and a written final report would be suomitted to the NRC with copies to CPCo.
The duration of the program is targeted for 90 days from start of underpinning con-struction (which will encompass installation of the grillage beam for pier 8 as identified in SSER #2, Appendix I), but the duration will be detemined by the L -
a w d or ssiw b u tz W
" " ~ " " " " " " " "
-" e212o20mio e21122 sunwAus)
PDR ADOCK 05000329
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " - ~ ~
" - ~ ~ ~ - " -
" - - - ~ ~ ~ -
~ ~ ~ " " - - - " "
A PDR
- - ~ ~ ~ ~ -
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ " - ~ ~ "
oAre )
l-l---
OFFICI AL R E' CORD COPY usaro:mi-smoo unc rosu sia tio-ao> nacu ouo
. Mr. Wayne Kilker of S&W discussed the activities of the assessment team since arrival at the site six weeks ago.
These have included review of the vertical access shaft, material storage area, test facility, and the offsite concrete facility. The team has also reviewed QA documents, inspection instructions and SSER J2. Daily meetings are held with site engineering and construction person-nel.
At the conclusion of the meeting, the GAP representative provided comments and questions.
GAP emphasized that the professional qualifications of the assess-ment members, the Project Quality Plan, and the raw data for the summary reports should be part of the public record.
GAP questioned whether 90 days was a suf-ficient duration to assess an underpinning project projected to require in excess of 18 mnths to complate.
GAP encouraged that public meetings be held by the assessment team and plans to documents its comments on the assessment team's methodology in the near future.
/
DA 1 Hood, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
As stated cc: See next page i
I s
k 1
W omer >.DL:LB..J.L
...QL$,.;B..f 4..
SURNAME >.MO.0.QMC...
...WP, ( G.,.
..l.llhf8,2,,,,,
,,,1,1/,p 04n >
unc ronu sia oo-so uncu oao OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usam mi-aw.so
I MIDLAND Mr. J. W. Cook Vice President Lee L. Bishop Consuners Power Company Harmon & Weiss 1945 West Parnall Road 1725 I Street, N.W., Suite 506 Jackson, Michigan 49201 Washington, D. C.
20006 cc: Michael I. Miller, Esq.
Mr. Don van Farrowe, Chief Ronald G. Zamarin, Esq.
Division of Radiological Health Alan S. Farnell, Esq.
Department of Public Health Isham, Lincoln & Beale P.O. Box 33035 Three First National Plaza, Lansing, Michigan 48909, Sist floor l
- Chicago, Illinois 60602 Mr. Steve Gadler 2120 Carter Avenue James E. Brunner, Esq.
St. Paul, Minnesota 55108 Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Jackson, Michigan 49201 Resident Inspectors Office Route 7 Ms. Ma ry Si ncl ai r Midland, Michigan 48640 5711 Summerset Drive Midland, Michigan 48640 Ms. Barbara Stamiris 5795 N. River Stewart H. Freeman Freeland, Michigan 48623 Assistant Attorney General State of Michigan Environmental Mr. Paul A. Perry, Secretary Protection Division Consumers Power Company 720 Law Building 212 W. Michigan Avenue Lansing, Michigan 48913 Jackson, Michigan 49201 Mr. Wendell Marshall Mr. Walt Apley Route 10 c/o Mr. Max Clausen Midland, Michigan 48640 Battelle Pacific North West Labs (PNWL)
Battelle Blvd.
Mr. Roger W. Huston SIGMA IV Building Suite 220 Richl and,' Washington 99352 7910 Woodmont Avenue Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Mr. I. Charak, Manager NRC Assistance Project Mr. R. B. Borsum Argonne National Laboratory Nuclear Power Generation Division 9700 South Cass Avenue Babcock & Wilcox Argonne, Illinois 60439 7910 Woodmont Avenue, Suite 220 Bethesda, Maryland 20814 James G. Keppler, Regional Administrator U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Cherry & Flynn Region III Suite 3700 799 Roosevelt Road Three First National Plaza Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Chicago, Illinois 60602 Mr. Ron Callen Mr. Paul Rau Michigan Public Service Commission Midland Daily News 6545 Mercantile Way 124 Mcdonald Street P.O. Box 30221 Midland, Michigan 48640 Lansing, Michigan 48909
Mr. J. F. Cook cc: Commander, Naval Surface Weapons Center ATTN:
P. C. Huang White Oak Silver Spring, Maryland 20910 Mr. L. J. Auge, Manager Facility Design Engineering Energy Technology Engineering Center P.O. Box 1449 Canoga Park, California 91304 Mr. Neil Gehring U.S. Corps of Engineers NCEED - T 7th Floor 477 Michigan Avenue Detroit, Michigan 48226 Charl]s Bechhoefer, Esq.
Atomic Safety & Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 Dr. Frederick P. Cowan Apt. B-125 6125 N. Verde Trail Boca Raton, Florida 33433 Jerry Harbour, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 o
Geotechnical Engineers, Inc.
ATTN: Dr. Steve J. Poulos 1017 Main Street Winchester, Massachusetts 01890 a
1 l
ENCLOSURE 1 ATTENDEES 11/5/82 NAME ORGANIZATION Darl S. Hood LB #4/DL/NRR W. D. Shafer DCS Rill J. A. Mooney CPCo John Schaub CPCo A. S. Lucks Stone & Webster Wayne E. Kilker Stone & Webster Louis Silano Parsons, Brinckerhoff Jim Brunner CPCo, legal George Lear HGEB-DE-NRR Joseph Kane NRR:DE:HGEB E. J. Sullivan, Jr.
NRC:DE Melanie A. Miller NRR:DL:LB #4 P. T. Kuo NRR:DE:SES Frank Rinaldi NRR:DE:SEP William Paton OELD Walter Haass NRR/QAB E. G. Adensam NRR:DL:LB #4 J. P. Knight NRR:DE T. H. Novak NRC:DL Billie Garde GAP Lyman Heller NRR/HGEB Roger Houston CPCo Charles Ader Stone & Webster S. Holuy GAP OFFICE) sunuAme>
DOTE)
NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 024o OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usam mi-m-m
///S/ tr z.
X%
% /,
v MIDLAND PROJECT SOILS REMEDIAL WORK INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT 4
1
~
1 l
COMMITMENT (LETTER OF SEPTEMBER 17, 1982)
RETAIN THIRD PARTY
- INDEPENDErlT APPRAISAL
- IllITIAL PHASES OF CONSTRUCTION
- AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING PROVISICil TO EXPM!D BOTH SCOPE AND DURATI0tl ASSESS."ENT TEAM
- CONSTRUCT!0il EXPERTS
- QA EXPERTS
- SUPPLEMENTED BY UNDERPINNING CONSULTANT REVIEW TO INCLUDE
- S0ILS DESIGN DOCUMENTS,
- CONSTRUCTION PLANS
- CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES ASSESSMENT TO' INSURE-
- SATISFACTORY QA PROGRAM I'MPLEMENTATION
- CONSTRUCTION CONSISTENT WITH DESIGN INTENT
- CONSTRUCTION CONSISTENT WITH INDUSTRY STANDARDS i
~ -,
... ~..
SELECTION OF ASSESSMENT TEAM t
SELECTION CRITERIA
- INDEPENDENT l
- EXPERIEi!CED Design Review Construction Underpinning Nuclear QA/0C 1
ASSESSMENT TEAM REQUIRED JOINT EFFORT j-i
- NUCLEAR AE/ CONSTRUCTOR i
- UNDERPINNING SPECIALIST i
i h
i
ASSESSMENT TEAM STONE 8 WEBSTER
- INDEPEilDEilT
- EXPERIENCEE '.'UCLEAR AE/ CONSTRUCTOR
- EXPERIENCED Ill THIRD PARTY INSPECTIONS PARSONS, BRINCKERHOFF, QUADE 8 DOUGLAS
- INDEPENDENT
- EXPERIENCED IN S0lLS/ UNDERPINNING
- EXPERIENCED IN THIRD PARTY INSPECTIONS 4
1
,,,,i%
i ASSESSMENT TEAM MEMBERS NAME PREVIOUS POSITION EXPERIENCE STAN LUCKS CHIEF GE0 TECHNICAL 20 YEARS AS CIVIL AND ENGINEER - BOSTON S0ILS ENGINEER.
PhD IN CIVIL ENGINEERING (S0ILS)
WAYNE KILKER SENIOR SOILS ENGINEER 18 YEARS AS CIVIL
- BOSTON ENGINEER.
MS S0IL MECHANICS LARRY ROUEN SENIOR QUALITY 8 YEARS AS QUALITY ASSURANCE ENGINEER INSPECTOR IN NUCLEAR
- CLINCH RIVER POWER INDUSTRY.
ACI/ASME LEVEL III INSPECTION ENGINEER AL SCOTT CHIEF CONSTRUCTION
~ 34 YEARS'AS CONSTRUCTION ENGINEER
ENGINEER
- RIVER BEND
'd
__.,.m
~
7
,_,pp Y-ASSESSMENT TEAM MEMBERS (CONTD)
NAME PREVIOUS POSITION EXPERIENCE PAUL BARRY STRUCTURAL ENGINEER 11 YEARS AS CIVIL
- BOSTON ENGINEER BARRY HOLSINGER QUALITY ASSURANCE 13 YEARS AS QUALITY ENGINEER INSPECTOR
- NINE MILE WALT PARRISH CIVIL / STRUCTURAL 25 YEARS EXPERIENCE ENGINEER - PITTSBURGH IN CIVIL / STRUCTURAL SUBWAY INSTALLATION, ENGINEERING JERRY RATNER CONSTRUCTION EN3INEER, 20 YEARS CONSTRUCTION
- NEW YORK CITY
l SCOPE OF ASSESSMENT
\\
,s e
~~
DEVELOPMENT OF ASSESSMENT PROGRAM COVERING AUXILIARY BUILDING UNDERPINNING PREPARATION OF PROJECT QUALITY PLAN
..e
,{'
OVERVIEW DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS
(
EVALUATE ADEQUACY OF. TECHNICAL, CONSTRUCTION, AND QUALITY PROCEDURES 4
EVALUATE PROCEDURAL IMPLEMENTATION SUBMITTAL OF ANY NONCONFORMANCE REPORTS TO THE NRC WITH COPY TO CPC0
?
i SUBMITTALOFWEEKLYPROGRESSREPdRTSTOTHE NRC WITH COPY TO CPC0 SUBMITTAL OF FINAL REPORT TO NRC WITH COP'Y TO CPC0 DURATION OF ASSESSMENT WILL BE DETERMINED BY ASSESSMENT TEAM NO LIMIT ON NUMBER OF ASSIGNED PERSONNEL
o November 22, 1982 EETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION T
"DocketNo(s): 50-329/330 C N OLl NRC/PDR
~
N: -
Local PDR NSIC PRC System LB #4 r/f Attorney, CELD E. Mensam Project Manager n unnri Licensing Assistant M-nuncan NRC Participant 3:
D. Hood '
W. Shafer, PIII G. Lear J. Kane E. Sullivan M. Miller P. T. Luo F. Rinaldi W. Paton W. Haass E. Adensam J. P. Knight T. Novak L. Heller l
o bec: Applicant & Service List l
l