ML20027D470
| ML20027D470 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry  |
| Issue date: | 11/01/1982 |
| From: | Hiatt S OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE ENERGY |
| To: | CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING CO. |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-OL, NUDOCS 8211040340 | |
| Download: ML20027D470 (5) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:- ~ ~ - - ~ ~ ' - .MTED CORRh .$, I( * !') Ah Novembtr 1, 1982 .' r UNITED STATES.OF AMERICA 79,,1 ; NUCLEAR-REGULATORY COMMISSION 00CNETED USNR } ], Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 3.
- 4 - % ;':y:.
) Mg3g ~ {T'7QIn the Matter of c } T 7.' [. ' CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING ) Docket Nos. 50-440 . e ; J, ~ ' ' l,C OMPANY, E_t, AJ_. ) TQ'Q4I SECRETAgy l ) (OperatingLic5n%~7fgfRM .::, s'% fg,j(:+" ';e ;; Perry -Nuclear Power Plant, ,) ..n . :. ' Units 1 and 2) ) ) 2-, OCRE SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO APPLICANTS' 2W SECOND SET OF INTEHh0GATORIES AND REQUEST ' ~ FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO INTERVENOR SUNFLOWER ALLIANCE, INC. ET AL. Intervenor Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy ("0CRE") hereby updates the responses made by Sunflower Alliance, Inc. et al. to Applicants' Second Set of Interrogatories to Sun-flower Alliance, dated May 3, 1982. These interrogatories 4 pertain to Issue #', for which OCRE is now lead intervenor (see September 17, 1982 Memorandum and Order, Concerning -Procedural Motions). 1. (e) OCRE would note that Applicants have now provided NED0-20566,. Amendment 3 to intervenors; this doc- ~ ument addresses the European core spray tests in ~' steam. However, OCRE does not change its conclusions methodology. regarding the adequacy of the NED0-24712 (n) It is never specifically stated in NEDO-24712 whether the SSTF simulated fuel bundles use an 8x8 fuel rod array. (1) The HEDO-24712 methodology does not satisfy the requirements listed in the " Request, for Additional 8211040340 821101 PDR ADDCK 05000440 O PDR ggg
- s.. 'n... f.
. * % :....:. w.'.. .u -
- ,. ~, gy
"*'?l %. :,..,_,q . y. p.~;... _ ' y;:. ws: 4, f '. 4 ' ~T Information" attached to the February 3, 1978 let'ter 3
- ?.
y *Q t ti. t 5~ ;, J:3..' ~.y from Eisenhut and Ross, NRC, to G. Sherwood, GE; J::.'QQ{M'.h;;d.W@5;f. - dc '-
- .Yk4..C>
8pecifically:- 2' wQygh't L;9drg: f '- 1 It is not stated why GE believes that the SSTF ' p ?5 Q.,. d.h.p- % *Ga"2,Qa%'%~Ri: h *(. ) + gmq ; 3 :. 2 ' g:.;@3 G.... n) %,,. ;g > u. - can accurately or conservatively represent the g.- V.,q.;; ' ;W .,,.. u. ' 'st "..ri M Q g,pfr conditions in a real BWR following a LOCA. ~ . :. ',';;i..:;;. ~ ..v. N.pr !"; (2) It is not stated how the SSTF is utilized to -r. ..yng,; ,.. y, - 1'nvestigate the closely coupled relationship , li'?..." O:(1p?.6 I.
- <-y,% y ~'
of core spray, distribution and counter-current-flow-limiting phenomena. (3) It is not stated.how the SSTF can investigate the effects of different steam qualities that might be present under realistic conditions; e.g., entrained water droplets in steam may inter-s act with the core spray. (4) There appears to be incomplete information re-garding the size of the steam condensing region around a nozzle; item 6 of the NRC's " Request for Additional Ini'ormation" states that 25% of the total steam condensation may occur in the " hydrodynamic" region; this information does not appear in NED0-24712, nor are,the references mentioned in item 2 of the request cited in NEDO-24712. i (5) NLDO-24712 does not justify the assumption that 1 1 of the Appendix K core spray heat transfer coefficients can be used when spray flow is celow the minimum design flow'(item 17 of the request). s
I. j,-{... * - T; ~,. 7 g..;. ; .[0.. y,',",.,'7. (d) OCRE'has now received the attachment to.the February .:.1. .7 :. .f..i..., f -i._;.M.N,S, - 3, 1978 letter and has no. objections to same, except ........ m..> 5 a.ew... -p,n,..... :; - y . s~. p 1.s <s,.T. +.;;.~ ~- g.p;,fd2'rt,4.:i;%. ic that.'~some of-the requi,r6ments appear not to.have been
- r<-
P ,r.. y-v e #g.d.b. e. 4 t%. g,s...;q$.,.,i.p.,.... ' - <i lj.y,e - met or. addressed, as. discussed in subpart --(i) of the .. y., yu,,,,.3. s...,. x . c g,.3,.=. <- ~ u$/.. g~.'h1.T.f.. I f ^ response to' Interrogatory 1. .e r f: P ;,u. r .- l.1 5,* i *,. 4
- Tse.,
e %> re.:t !Cs:y.<,..S.9
- n.t 3 ;.4 p.q u
~. - r., ..-. v.; c,:.rc yr.@. c Respeetfully submitted, q,.; a,,. 1 "E $, '. '.~. -t. ..,..,.;..,3... pu r. a Susan L. Hiatt U' ~. - OCRE Representative 8275 Munson Rd. j Mentor, OH 44060 (216) 255-3158 s ? Y e e i e h .I' \\ o = m
.~ ~,.. f; .g
- e.'
s.. .,~ a'
- ,,. z
- .
~ ~ - ~ - ' - ' ';~ ' "' ' ' AFFIDAVIT
- .-=.
Ct:',f; :...u. -::. i;~
- g..,.. Y.;'P[.
- = +~[~. t. -
alA$9 i[5:If Susan L. Hiatt,.having been duly sworn depose and say that ~ f/.. f*":.I'fE'. responsible for the foregoing supplemental responses to .f;;.
- ,'a,.. -C.
' ~. na. 7.. n,. . e....:.;. ~' interrogatories filed by Applicants and that these responses . a: n, .' ii . 1 .areitrue to the best of my knowledge and belief. ,. m n.. &n r.f.. Susan L. Hiatt /sP day of November, Sworn to and subscribed before me this 1982. h (' tf Notary ic MARLEY FORD EIGER. Attorney Atlaw Notuy Public. State of Ohio My commission has no empiration date, Section 147.03 R. C. I l
- ).;,~. ;.. [...,_. 7 m..,.. .t,;.;. : =. : ry.a,-g.,. g;o 1 @.:.0,1 *'9 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE gw DOLMETED fE- :. n 't. m,.: e USHRC - This is to certify that copies of the foregoing OCRE ,,;,gff.e. "*/$J.;..,4. SUPPLEMENTAL RESP 0 NEE, TO APPLICANTS 8 SECOND SET OF INTERW ~Tj3.';i > ROGATORIES AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO-IN'ggRM -3 20:28 Ya::.~.G:;VENOR SUNFLOWER ALLIANCE,. INC. ET. AL. were served by depos 3f5. M.;;. Yin.the U.S. Mail, first class, postage prepaid, this 1st da S$ifdM 0FFIC OF SECRETARY .bf November, 1982 to those on the service list below. 0005ETING & SERVICE
- 46 t
, j'.?' ~ BRANCH I f _....[. []:Sc[ g j Susan L. Hiatt i '4.J
- 6'?
' SERVICE LIST Peter B. Bloch, Chairman Daniel D. Wilt Esq* Atomic. Safety-and Licensing Board P.O. Bo'x 08159'.. U.S. Nuclcar Regulatory Comm'n Cleveland, OH 44108 Washington,.D.C. 20555 Dr. Jerry R. Kline Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, D.C. 20555 Frederic' J. Shon - Atomic S fety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commin Washington, D.C. 20555 Docketing and Service Section Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commtn Whshington, D.C. 20555 James M. Cutchin, IV, Esq'. Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, D.C. 20555 Jay Silberg, Esq. 1800 M Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20036 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Wachington, D.C. 20555 .}}