ML20024E831
| ML20024E831 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 08/30/1983 |
| From: | Bell M NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| To: | Browning R NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| References | |
| REF-WM-1 NUDOCS 8309070119 | |
| Download: ML20024E831 (2) | |
Text
F o
g.
l Al1G 3 01983 Distribution L
3109.6/MJB/83/08/29/0 vWR file:
109.6 3001.4 WMHL r/f MJBell & r/f NMSS r/f HJMiller MEMORANDUM FOR:
Robert E. Browning, Acting Director J0 Bunting Division of Waste Management PDR FROM:
Michael J. Bell, Chief High-Level Waste Licensing Management Branch Division of Waste Management
~
SUBJECT:
MEETING 0F DATA RELEASE PANEL OF MATERIALS REVIEW BOARD, JUNE 13, 1983 l
L On the above date, I attended a one-day meeting of the Data Release Panel
[
'of the' Materials Review Board in Chicago, Illinois.
The purpose of the meeting was to review the first data package prepared by the Materials l
Characterization Center for inclusion in the DOE Materials Handbook.
The data package was for leaching of PNL.76-68 borosilicate glass for temperatures up to 90*C and for leach times up to one year.
A list of-attendees at the meeting is enclosed.
There was extensive discussion of the format for presentation of the data l
and numerous suggestions were made to improve the clarity of the presentation of the information.
An important point was that the tests were run while the MCC-1 static leach test-was still evolving,'so that i
the data were not obtained under the test procedure as it now exists.
A i
further. important point is that' the MCC-1 test itself is recognized to have several limitations and there are unresolved questions about the applicability of the data to repository conditions.
The position I took l-with regard to the data was that NRC would not object.to any reasonable format for presentation so long as the uses and limitations of the test.
1 l
method and any deviations from the test procedure were clearly identified
[
so that the user or reviewer could see whether the data were being i
properly applied.
I
[
It'was agreed that the MCC should revise the data package to take into account the comments of the Panel and that it would be submitted to the i.
.. M Record $61 MRB foy,jggjg at its next meeting.
W 1
I lO % 6 Docket No.
- l
/
LPCil Michael J. Bell, Chief
- c. Distribution; High-Level Waste Licensing Management Branch Division of Waste Management (Return to WM, G23 SS) g2.
Enclosure:
List of Attendeer
".p:_---_______-.___________-:__________--:__--_____
0FC
_ _ _ _ _. _ _' W_MH L NAME :MJBell: led :
8309070119 0'20830 DATE : 8/'30/83 PDR WASTE wpg_.1 PDR
I
, Enclosure 1 Attendees at Meeting of the Data Release Panel Materials Review Board Ramada-O' Hare Inn, Des Plaines, Illinois June 13, 1983 Present:
Panel Members:
Visitors:
l-M. Bell, NRC L. Daniel, MCC l
J. Berreth, Exxon M. Bowen, MCC R. Clayton, U of Chicago J. Haugen, DOE-Cll/MIO S. Coburn, U. S. Steel, ret.
C. Mcpheeters, ANL/MIO L. Dole, ORNL (alternate for W. Lackey)
H. Frederikse, NBS (alternate for T. Negas)
W. Gerberick, U of Minn.
D. Isherwood, NNWSI G. Maczura, Alcoa J. Mendel, MCC D. Moak, ONWI M. Steindler, ANL, Chairman l
Executive Secretary:
l l
W. Seefeldt, ANL l
Panel Member Not Present:
J. Burke, Consultant l
T y
y,
.m._
y
-