ML20024E435
| ML20024E435 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 08/05/1983 |
| From: | Bordenick B NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD) |
| To: | Birkenheier J KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20024E436 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8308150047 | |
| Download: ML20024E435 (6) | |
Text
_
+-
' l,f Ht _,
s
2/
! h [qh NUCLE AR HEGULATORY COT.~. MISSION WASwi4G TON. D. C. DZ5 2.&#.y j
%,x M,/
a...'
August 5,1983 John E. Birkenheier, Esq.
Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill Christophes & Phillips 1900 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036 In the Matter of LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-322 (Emergency Planning)
Dear Mr. Birkenheier:
This is in reply to your letters of July 27, 1983, and August 2, 1983, which enclosed a list of sixteen informal discovery requests to the Staff.* Set out below are-the Staff's responses to your informal requests which have been provided to me. As to the first eight requests, with the exception of items 5 and 6 I gave you these responses over the telephone on July 29, 1983.
I
'gave you most of item 5 on' August 3, 1983.
I gave verbal responses to items 9-16 to you by telephone.on August 3, 1983.
~
1.
The Staff presently, expects to call the following named persons as witnesses during the Shoreham emergency planning hearings.
Witness Subject matter John R. Sears Onsite emergency preparedness as it interfaces with offsite planners Thomas Urbanik, II Evacuation Time Estimate Analysis In' order to expedite this proceeding and to continue the long standing spirit of cooperation between the Staff and Suffolk County with respect to discovery matters, the Staff agrees to treat the County letters as informal discovery requests. The Staff's voluntary response to the County's-requests should not, however, be construed as a Staff acknowledgement that the County discovery requests. in any way comply with the provisions.of 10 C.F.R. 5 2.720(h)(2)(ii) or 6 2.744 as regards discovery against the Staff.
DS01 8308150047 830005
- ljl g PDR ADOCK 05000322 o
]
. a t
2.
Thomas Urbanik, II, is a consultant retained by a Staff consultant (Battelle) to perform an Evacuation Time Estimate Analysis. Mr. Urbanik is from the Texas Transportation Institute of the ~ University of Texas (College Station, Texas). -See also 4 below.
3.
To date.there are no NRC staff evaluations etc. of the LILC0 Transition s.
~ Plan. The criteria which will be used to evaluate the Plan are set out in NUREG-0654, a copy of which I believe the County has in its possession, t
4.
Attached find copy of a letter dated December 2,1982 from Thomas Urbanik, II, identified above, to John Sears, also identified above.
(This was telecopied to you on August 3, 1983).
5.
The Staff presently expects to call the following named FEMA (or contractor) witnesses as a panel to testify to whatever contentions are admitted in the Shoreham proceeding which relate to FEMA.
A.
Roger P Kowieski - FEMA Region 2, Radiological Assistance Committee Chairman B.
Fred Sharrocks - FEMA, Washington, D.C.
Emergency Management Offices C.
Edward Tanzman
~
Argonne National Laboratory
+
i 6.
Argonne National Laboratory Personnel who reviewed the LILCO Transition Plan.
Edward Tanzman Chris Saricks Kenneth Lerner Phyllis Becherman James H. Opelka
. FEMA personnel who reviewed the LILC0 Transition Plan.
Headquarters Richard Krimm Jeffrey Bragg-George Jett Gary Johnson Fred Sharrocks Spence Perry-D
. Region II Roger Kowieski Stewart Glass Frank Petrone Phil McIntire 7 and 8.
The Staff is presently defining the scope of work for review of the recently submitted Shoreham PRA and expects to have this task completed by the end of August. This task is being performed by Edward Chow of the Staff. A schedule for completion of the review has not yet been finalized.
It is presently anticipated that the review will require six to twelve months to complete.
It has not yet been decided who the review contractor will be for the Staff. As you are no doubt aware, the Staff does not view the PRA as a prerequisite for the licensing of Shoreham.
(See generally the record compiled with regard to SC-SOC Contention 7EJT 9.
See 4 above.
In addition Battelle is preparing a comparison or the range of evacuation time estimates, including Shoreham, based on input-from Mr. Urbanik.
I will provide further information on this next week.
- 10.. John R. Sears
- 11. Mr. Urbanik is a subcontractor for Battelle who works independently.
His contact at Battelle is Art Desrusiers. -
- 12. See 14 below.
- 13. Mr. Urbanik is not under contract to the NRC.
(In any event I fail to see the relevance of this request to any potential County contention.)
- 14. Mr. Urbanik has testified' at hearings in Al. lens Creek, Indian Piont, Byron, Waterford, Diablo Canyon,-Zimmer, Three Mile Island, and Fermi.
9e also prefiled testimony at Comanche Peak. We are checking on the dates of such testimony.
In any event, this information may be obtained at the Commission's Public Document Room.
9
-4_
15 and 16. See attached Biographical Data for Mr. Urbanik which responds to your requests (Telecopy was sent to you on August 3, 1983).
Sincerely, Bernard M. Bordenick Counsel for NRC Staff
Enclosures:
As Stated 4
cc:
(w/enclosuresand incoming)
Janes N. Chrisman, Esq.
Stewart Glass DISTRIBUTION Bordenick Repka Dewey Mcdonald Rawson Reis Christenbury Murray Lieberman i
Olmstead OELD FF (2)
NRC Docket File: PDR/LPDR Chron(2)
R.Ca ruso 144 A.Schwencer 330 J.Norris AR5008 bXo'7
..... :... _ _. _ _ _f_fygh
- 0 E L D), /.)_ _ _ _.. _ _ : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.. _ _ _ _ _ :. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
0FC :0 ELD
[
.____:...._____.__...__:_J..js".
NAME :BBordenick/dkw
- RLds DATE:08/,f/83
- 08/
3
i '! $ '.,
- m. j i. liu'G cc, i t i e '.
c
.s,;
.t
- t i c. c r.
- b r ee r crt f r.;,r.
tecturer, Civil t regir.eering, T e > e r :< M 'O rrsity 1
Education Ph.D., Civil E ngineering,' fei.as At,M Uni versity,1982.
M.S., Civil Engineering, Purdue University,1971.
B.S., Civil E ngineeri ng, S.y racuse Uni versi ty,1969.
' B.S., Torest Engineering, State University of New York, 1968.
Experience Assistant Research Engineer, T exas T ransportation I nstitute, Texas A&M Uni versity, 1977-Present, tecturer, Civil Engineering, Texas A&M University,1982-Present.
Traf fic Engineer, City of Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1972-1976.
5 Transportation P1anning Engineer, City of Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, Michigan 1971-1972.
Research Assistant, Joint liighway Research Project, Purdue Uni versity.
-1970-1971.
j Professional Licenses Registered Professional Engineer, Texas and Michigan Memberships American Society of Civil Engineers Institute of Transportation Engineers Sigma Xi
^
Chi Epsilon Si mI FI CANT IEPORTS MD PUBLI CATI ONS _.
f
. 7mffic Engineering Priority Treatment of Buses at T raf fic Signais. T ransportation Engineering, l
. November 1977.
Priority Treatment of liigh-Occupancy Vehicles on Arterial Streets.
State Department of liighways and Public T ransportation, Report 205-5, 1977.
Evaluation of Alternative Concepts for Priority Use of Urban Freeways. in Texas, 1977.
l Dri ver Inf ormati on. Systems for liighway-Rail way Grade Crossings. Highway Re-search Record Number 414, 1972.
l 1
L 1
i l
.y.,
_ ~.
t
/s' 4
5..!_.: ;y I.
.:4.
h:'%r Wie.ory -
.r, Cli. A' (Chi cul ates Logi;al 1. c :.n ' en Aw : e r ;4 r :.. e ).
A L. crit irem port n ion r;;et *.:s ri: noce1 f or ihe Cal cui nion of E, ecunion Tir+ E s.n nes, U.S. riuc!e 6r kepul etory Conasi ssion, iiURE G/CR-2504, October 1981.
Analysis of Techniques f or. E stimating E vecuation T imes for Energency Planning 70nes, U.S. tiucl ear Regul.atory Commission, tiUREG/ CR-1745, 1980.
Analysis of E vocuation T imesr Around 52 riuc 1 ear Power P1 ant Sites.
U.S. tiuc1 ear Regul atory Commi ssion, tiURE G/CR-1856 Vol ume 1,1980.
Hur ricane.E vacuation Demand and Capacity E stimation.
Florida Sea Grant [. Col l eg Eeport th:mber 33, 1980.
Teias Hurricane Evacuation Study.
T he T exas Coastal and Marine Council',1978.
Public 7mneporintion Intercity Bus Riders in Texas. Transportation Research Record 887, 1982'.
The Intercity Bus Industry,in the U.S.
and Texas.
State Department of Highways and Public T ransportation, Technical Report 096 5-1 F,1981.
Bryan-Coll ege Station E nergy Contingency Study.
Metropolitan Planning Organization of Bryan-College Station, 1980.
B rya n-Col l e ge Station iT ransit ]mprovement Plan.
Metropolitan Pl anni ng Organi7ation, 1979.
Ann Arbor Dial-A-Ride Project Final Report, Ann Arbor Transportation Authority, 1973.
Ann Arbor Dial-A-Ride Operations, Highway Research Board Special Report 136, 1973.
i The Greater Lafayette Area Bus Transit Study.
Joint Highway Research Project,-
Purdue Uni versity, 1971.
E2dcr2y and Bandimpped.Tmrwporlation ^
E v a l uati on of Sel ected Human
- Se'r vi ces T ransportation Providers.
State Department of Highways and Public Transportation, 1980.
Cost-Ef fecti veness of Accessible fixed-Route - Buses in Texas. Jechnical Report 1051-1F, 1979.
Transportation of the Elderly and Handicapped in Texas: A Case Study. State Department of Highways and Public Transportation, Technical Report 1056-2F, 1979.
~
Total Accessibility Versus Equivalent Mobility of the Handicapped. Institute of Transportation Engineers, Compendium of Technical Papers, 49th Annual Meet-
.i n g, 197 9.
Survey of Vehicl es and E quipment f or El derly and Handicapped Transportation.
State Department of Highways and Public T ransportation, Technical Report 1055-1, 1978.
Corpus Christi El derly and Handicapped Transportation Study. City of Corpus Christi, Texas, 1978.
2 i
l l
~..- -, _ _
_ _ -,,