ML20024B548
| ML20024B548 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 04/08/1979 |
| From: | Newton D BABCOCK & WILCOX CO. |
| To: | Womack E BABCOCK & WILCOX CO. |
| References | |
| TASK-02, TASK-07, TASK-2, TASK-7, TASK-GB GPU-0298, GPU-298, NUDOCS 8307090112 | |
| Download: ML20024B548 (4) | |
Text
___
i.,,
~ u -: 7.v a@ l.
n.N t~....
7*-
... * - ) ~ \\ 4,' ** '
.. ' * '.Z.nt%= %< Q.:;.h.j.&..m, A& ~ :f-.,,.,,.,,.
T.,..a,
---Q t
.!"-***~
--* y
- ~
. ~,._.... a.gg.t4*s.;;.3 E 4.~ a s w.
..w
.< w g.
i
,..e..
a.h.* r....; 7 -
y g.
."r....r&-i.'; :s'.*... f..;.. ;. ~. ~ ;-
W 4..
- O s..
.n,,,-.g. %s %.t >.',- j=* Q.=. S % g:
..,...at.^
'rXt, y.
.~..
i.:.;~;.
t -
r
.w..
.h,....
7*W*&cy. m -.p.~.yr,W " W gv-f F..
- . A
- 4 <.,;
.-Q3 s
..g.
'.W. a.
5**?
- m..,,..M =c:c..W.iak~d.
-n a.
-a t. -- -
- . y... m,M
- ?.j%c~ v.: n. m.--...,. -9..: r e.:?.~ ~.~--.= b = ;
- v. m.',5.i -
~
,~.. - ~ w. m,; -
^ '.
~.
. :. ~. r e : %. n,.,. :.p q &+.-Q. -
%.a..,.M
., x. e. ;g~k,
>ga
.m : w M.>.,.w..,-m.;. - '.
- w. -
-..~
~
a 3 w-NFD;UN '.Y.*.
-m m.--
N
.r. m. a Es J
, :M l d*2M4.*M>.'UEN@MEh..~m,.
E &[ c, M 2 G =W3.@9f$ [i 2 r + h y Q 2 - W "-
m
.n F
' i-
'~% F-5M&
?SjfkT q's
[.
'_.t -W h.
m.3.
N,'
- t. k k U
.;y_$". '
THE,AP. COCK & WILCOX COMM.NY
".r.-a 2 POWER GENERATION GROUP
.;;~ e l
{(.
.* ;;".- 2--, d
. ~
.w w e-i b
E. A. WGRAct
" P.'p4E. -m Fron 608 us 8 U
w ::- -
. s.m.. +.* an L
b :c ARW.
D. G. NEWTON Ce st.
" g'y*
{
Fi i e lio.
M e,
' 4;i.@4%:S 3
- -w':r p;@;.ms n*
.P A ce.
B&W OPERATING PLANT
-6
- .x.
Catt g,
- .. w 6 U w
$WD).
APRIL 8,1979-12:57 A.H.
.*q9C@j OPERATlHG INSTRUCT 10tts FOR STUCK OPEN PORY c
p ew 6
- e
!M b
r m :y m t :-,7.gd. g j
n...
V->.?a m. ::;.3 i
I PREPARED r%2F~$
ATTACHED 15 THE WRITE UP YOU REQUESTED SATLtAY EVEN!hs 4/7/79.
E, I'.
THE VRI'E UP FOLLOWIhG A DISCUSSION WITH B. M. DUMM, D. W. LAEILLE, G. Q.
p
.ss
- m; a
- .e.MW. c,
i-,
g,c. w EE155LER AND M. V. SOMACA. HOWEVER, THE WRITE UP HA5 x0T BEEN REVIEWED N-M 4
..'.,E.. d d..w.s,
w I WAS 60lHG TO HAVE J. D. CARLTON REVIEW IT SUT HE IS OFF TD-i r -
m-O."~A%N SY AM 600Y.
i.' =. %.
1 WOULD REC 0tNEND KAVihG THE RESP 0 tie REVIEWED SY SOEONE t
~:.-2 g
I.
.L.'. F..h A. fh..
.'GHT.
y. -y:dEE.
AKALYSIS Ax3 SAFETY AhALYSES. SWEONE FROM THESE UNITI SW.L'LD BE a::n n
~
d o
f.:,.*%..
-. - wi N2
- r.
TOMLRROW.
l i'.N'.5F;E-3 t.
.r. %
THE OPERATOR ACTINS ARE SPECIFIC BUT ARE EASED ON SuiE SUSJECTIVE REASONIM g
' 'h4 "W...
T' *.~iiQ'J.;s.y THEREFORE, YCU MY WANT TO NOlFY TK:M IN THE FUTURE EASED 0:f SOE SPECIFIC
- 9
~
i i ?.N.'ek&S AXALYSES TO IMPROVE PLAXi RELIASILITT. TESE OPERATOR ACTICES b -W.?.?..,:,o.2..
. d w
FRCH A SAFETY STANDPOINT.~
,2ste.
r M...13, 70%,.g m_ _,
Ex.
For ID
... ~.. -
fiO i P/
4..p:m-g Beft4
~
..*-TcM:s.O M i- !NTR000CT!ON J.R. Oanyo
. w.n c;:4:'s.:r
..N-NP.vg ITEM 3 0F I. E. BULLETIN kO. 79-05 REQUEST 3 UTILIT1f5 WIW B&W SUP
~:
i.
1 TK!$
[.J.TmdST<e m41:
K55 SYSTEXS TO REVIEW THE ACTIONS REQUIRED FOR COPING y'.H TRA*SIENTE.
p. Y.A'chJG. li 3.':2Q It tutLETIN WAS IKSTIGATED BY THE NUCLEAR IMCIDENT AT THREE
- h..S' "
CO' -b t - m,w-nrs tr.;RWG THIS IkCICEXT THE PoiER 0*ERATED RELIEF YALYE (PCEY) CM TEE Pm.I'E d?. -
.h-
.: 7. :. P'M CPiKED A.';3 FAILED TO RECLOSE. CCx51DERA!:.E TIME FASSED LEFORE TKE OP i M.-
- - -
- 'uc.g 1 TO IS LA Z I'.iY.e-E3$, (1 0" tem! AE0 THE PORY M3 FAILED GPEN Ar., it0K COPI.ECTiyE ACTIC:
s.J Q
TxE Fetttu:xc f,xFORMAtl0n 15 PeytoED FOR REvlEWiza THE ACTI~:s
[ 7 T i:J C.3 W
w E vALYt.
us a
s.r.
/ _
r
..C 7 d.~~@,
REgnRED FGA A STUCI CPEX PORY.
,..T.a u.
t ~~
8307090112 79040s t.
PDR ADOCK 05000289
[
P HOL
- a w m.m :.g 93 9 3
.;4 g
, g : @
.%..A y,@$. 3.,
r..
.. - o w..,.
7"
,,7.,
s.
.O.
.-...s..~1.
....a_
..y m.. u. 3. :
yr.
v t
z., _~.
-1 4-
..s 4.- y ~c'~ -~'.A.-@ w'.L: f. 4
- 9,
-.,.5 n' h.7'*". -%.,,T" ' PEW
.~
2
,a
...,,m
_ 3..
..,.,.+.":e. -.~ : av.c.-;s%-;-pL 44
.p...y.- m
.g u. ;.
%,,1
]
- f. Y:' -;-. t..._j&h 4
...~.r*'.L. j'y N. h.Ye*9.74 qs.. w;. w 4 E E. 35 h.,s...
4,. f.~; f 5,f
.-~
5 h*$
? f *f f-p[y 9
... + p 2.,
4 d y - Q., &
.... n g
- : :- +.
o'., u s
.w-n wn., a.r -+r,., : mv. -s:..,- +r.... 3;;
,3
.> r u c.-
tr
,t.c v.<-. j.m. 5,:, wre e
.,- a... +.;
. ;b M M EI N c Y-.
N N M Y'"I'M?aN.-Ifi-@ ibd qy m ~. : n. u.
['[
$r i.N-M4
,eu.d '._u
- 3.
..........N. E.V.T.O.N..T.O..W. '.N. A.C. K.....................P. A.G. E. 2...............
197. 9 W. %,'w 3
4 A
..,;;l n
- .)Q.r:+
y
.J 2.
DESIGN FUNCTION OF THE PORV
,. qy
' ;;.2._b -
R OVER PRESSURE PROTECTION OF lhE RCS IS PROVIDED SY TVO CODE SAFETY YALVES ON ES'Nd, nM THE ASME CODE REQUIRES THAT THESE VALVES CAN HOT BE ISOLATED.
Wv.-$
W THE PRESSURIZER.
f' @
yd -
CONSEQUENTLY. IF ONE OF THESE VALVES FAILED OPEM A LOCA WOULD RES
-3 k,.
r
.%'t:d LEAX COULD NOT BE ISOLATED. THEREFORE, IT 15 PRUDENT TO LIMIT THE M.H3ER OF
.N.'$h
,,.y w-
-i
.c m TIMES THE CODE SAFETY VALVES WILL BE OPENED. THIS IS ACCOMPLISHED ET h
PROVIDING A PORY WITH A LOWER OPENING SET POINT. HOWEVER. THE PORY M h
N BUT SINCE THE PORY 15 NOT REQUIRED FOR OVER PRESSURE PRCTECTICM y
M FAIL OPEN.
h THE ISOLATICH IS PROVIDED BY THE RELIEF ISOLATION VALVE M
E%S
-69 W
LOCATED UPSTREAM OF THE PORY.
-l
.:.z...e THE PORY ALSO KEEPS THE RC PRESSURE BELOW THE HIGM RC PRESSURE REA p
.W
.w d w...
=0
. -l M "M
SET POINT WEN AUTm*,TICALLY DECREASING TURBINE GENERATOR LOAL TO PJ' VTLg/;p%
Gm 4
LO FOLLOWING A LOSS OF OFFSITE POWER.
gg
- .Q
- < y Srm.:n
-t W. q-
' ' ~ ~ -
g r
3.
OPERATOR ACTION IF THE PORV FAILS OPEN
.{#M h
CLOS 1HG THE M370R OPERATED ISOLATIGt YALYE
-- 8
.I' THE VALVE SHOULD BE ISOLATED 3)
- m.a.
u d..
d.dT3-VKEMEVER THE 10RY FA:LS OPEM.
.-~O.~N ".3 5
~
s
.~g THE OPERATOR SHDULD ALWYS KEEP IN MIN 3 THAT THE PORY PROVIDES ggg
.(.
w FUNCTIDH AN3 THEREFOR 1 CNt BE ISOLATED AT ANY TIME WITHOUT JE pg53
.s e& mis
~-
5q u.aa SuETT Or THE et.AuT.
- _. m THE PLANT IS SAFE IF THE PORY FAILS E
4-W <
s[
THE PORY PRCVIDES PLANT RELIASILITY.
p c.m OPEx oR C:.0 SED OR rr THE C0x SAFETT vAtvES FAIL OPEx.
gg
%m e-m.
...e
' 'M5 g +.m
- 43 ACTIONS
,gg 3. g-,
M IF THE RC PRESSURE IMCREASIS TD THE PORY SWINT AW THEN DENS p
@n.m 1.
'.a=
'O..
ggtcw 2000 PSIG THE PORY SMD BE CLOSED.
M.t _W W
t
,.. y '
, " ~ * ' '
- y %g p --
u*$. 3.,,.
- ..W-en-4 g
- z =q ah iXXiE,&G[:fj&.fffjf.g 4.,
.. - > mh
. k[
~*
4'
$. !.. < } ^ M !.Q t
., s r., D M,#'hU. *+ 4:
,&w$$s.
h @-NN N f9 5 9 U p D a
.l. W *..
ggy
[. ' s. A Mjr.d
<.e'":,d?
4 g
u,c9s:.7gjm,%m,a%g,p, :w. m N *:.
'.' es-w
,w
' ' dA.C *:.q' -.,. w. s.t,,w.
~
M.-4 -= ?-*3E'e& %.;.i..
6,.e i ::..' 2 3
^'
- A% W u
.w.=j">o.W'.E.. Q,.
~"**
.3h k 5 n &*; ~'" ~$_.._..5%,i.iQ{
- .3 w
.r..d...?.w'.: - %. -
~
.. Nh. F'#u.:E' 4;};g * ::J}b
"~'u
'. 7
^*
vr4 g
s7:.
L p
6tk,. :n-.a....
~
- '-4:* Q g d '*957'.
%,4&:suwtf:-+
- T3 5
' ~ - ~
,,:w. w.%c.x,e.g.... e.
o-MO --
w m 4. x.-;, c.. ; w ~. g g m.;. g..:_Cu p =.+g.
g* Q :.g.s.y.;,.).y.y x-.
.Q' 4. a.k.*~;
,.s. m%*.g.e
'.e.
n s.
?.;Fi!.i M ?.-=.Ea... w n.n.~- m. 4.v..
.r..
m
~
~
e.
..x m'.s,w,~ ='M:4yw, q.- _ _ <.y wRt-qt n
Q- " -
APRIL 8,1979 T D E. M 5..--. ~.
... PAGE 3 f
.b..'a,
,. - ~
, s.
IF THE RC PRESSURE DECREASES TO THE HPI ACTUATION PRESSU g
- m. -
a BE CLOSED.
'Y$
Sa.,t, THE PORY POSITION INDICATOR LIGHTS 00 NOT PROVIDE DIR NOTE:
THE LIGHT INDICATES THE POSITION OF THE SOLINCID
- G.B VALVE POSITION.
THEREFORE. THE INDICATOR LIGHTS MIGN' NOT
-'3 OPERATOR ON THE PORV.
_4
, 1~
INDICATE A STUCK OPEM PORV.
Q 4.
SYMPTCMS OF A STUCK OPEN PORY_
D DECREASIMG RC PRESSURE OR PRESSURIZER LEVEL VITH g.9 m@
W-1.
',-g. f OR INCREASE IM LET DOWN FLOW.
TURE
,i
- P 3 6',
INCREASE IM THE RC DRAIM TAMK LEVEL AND/0R TD9ERATURE.
. S.*:T4 2.
I [-7$3
- indM, BASES FOR OPERATOR ACTION
-- m 5.
ll@--
arg THE PORY SH;ULD SE AVAILASLE FOR INCREASING RC PRESSURE TRAM T
M oM TRAMSIENTS WIOi HAVE AN IMITIAL DECREASE IM PRES l
l' : 9A ',Tt e
IM PRESS"RE F00 eLANT AVAILABILITY,
?Jc,$.
FOR INCREASING PCSSURE TRAMSIENTS THE RC PRES v.
- *:tW~
t ~ "i:7,.:M l,:,;5 O ui IF THE PRESSURE C5tCPS,.
I w '
LEYEL OFF BEFORE REACHING A 2000 PSIG RC PRESSURE.
l.".-
HOWEYER. THE NRY MS DCBE ITS
~~
)
cd5_
BELN 2000 PSIG THE PORY MY BE STUCK OPEN.
f ur;i JOB 81 MITIGATING TM IMITIAL RC PRESSURE INCREAS EM35ss i Qg=d NEEDED AGA!n 50 IT CAN BE ISOLATED WITHOUT AFF J
.'I9E INCREASIE PRESSURE TRAM 1!ENT IS INDICATED BT l
-~~LM M
E.Jd
.)
=
- M~A.2 TO OR A30"!E THE PORY SET PQ!NT FOLLOWED BY A RE lgusag
'W.!
[,,k,._1 FOR A TR,t.tS!tXT WHICH IRITIALLY DECREASES THE OPERATOR g._
- -e nWg
'Q5
,'j!,h.,4
- w.>.y x ecRv cxTIt w eRESSuRE uS muRMto Axa attM uufvEn I
. =. 4.1
.sw
..; -r.h N
f
- sulE
-5% j f
. w 9:
y
- .,J I, a f
h r
yc. 4..-- ;4
... _ b. w&.
'. & 3.<: b p g.sg ; q i e y :.-
c;;&.. i,m
.'. p-.:..= T.:;. @ m e2;..y;e.:...
.c.g.E g w.s. e _w = w %_.:.+. _.e.+ R.-. _ ' r3 -
. m.u
...c
_.2,
.<c.:.,..,..,..,.;-.w.
._%.:. p... n.,-.. s.
~a. _ _
.... y
- g - -
g_..m~.
_..g p w.._.-
" Y.
- y. ; h. w.<.>.. w: N f. 5., ~.
. 5 m....'
g
.p YN
',,?.Y,.b.$. 0...&.i:r~e.y~$. ~5.g-h.*.
k 5
. ~w. - :.
.. w a
a.
.. e. :. -.
c,.
c. w... :..,...... -.:
- e v,.
x..g; '. A
.p.. :.
- ,g. 6 oo....
- r.t:, u.m.u. ss
'!5'.5. V.E
?,;c#,=. - '.
JhYWL,...g[*5hhW$,._h-5*;jY.-'sih(h5.4. $;rywm;h
- %E h
e ih -v.
aw, g.,.,
s-------.-. b.N.E. M 5......
. _,,,,~.-..P AGE. 4..
- .A..P.R_I L.819 7 9 f_35;E @*~i
. m.: L~..
.4 k
4 M
)
g i
F
" s' FOR THIS TRANSIENT THE INITIAL PRESSURE REDUCTION USUALLY DOESN'T REACH lU THE HPI SET POINT. IF IT DOES. THE PORV MAY BE STUCK OPEN. THIS TYPE Or = x51 ext iS I m CATEO.T NO Ix! Tat,xESSu,E IsCaEASE.
I da I
+ M-i 3
- ss P_
R y
- i. x. QuNu a
. LABELLE
_ e gh 5
I E. O. GEISSLER e
- x. V. BONACA d
E. W. SWANSON e.-
.J b
na m
.4 6" - ~.
- 43:59 g.
=
I I
W b
.a=
E."
T k, e
- _b9
- 12!
i "t
2
--% 838
)
"~s"g
- . h e,at
~3 w
y.-w,ya,
- 3 e
v.-
k.U..'.
.cr r.
. )
.2 5
5_ oc 5
a n
--e y
. n.-
+.asa
.8 a
()1 N
W i
P..
I'.sgg'ig;%[--
!. ]*t WAW%q
- M h-
..:3 i,,
d L
y'
-m.
w '.bQ) u-48"..m.s
.W gp e*
1 F:. : :_ g -
.a f
M Lw *u.i. U..).s
..}
x wv% &
v
')
- 'h
% m w. m m w w w :w m m m e M k aK&tu
.