ML20010H583

Transcript of 810918 Public Commission Meeting in Washington,Dc Re Revisions to Indian Point Order.Pp 1-6

ML20010H583
Person / Time
Site:	Indian Point
Issue date:	09/18/1981
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8109250505
Download: ML20010H583 (9)

Text

,

'^

. p.y;.. ;, - S,~. yy,.y.@n,..n,. gm>:. ':: 4.~_~ :.,:

(-Q,..;, v': 6 ;.

.. f.

. Y.

\\

.. a +

a.; m...

<. ;r...,.

- s.

w.

e. r.

y b ; p. 2;:: m + w :. m.

u..,....

n ~..

- s

~ :-

7 w~ -'

g.;f g 5c m z yg m y ggyegg3gy p.

a 1

.... m...

....,,,"h,sw3,<.,,,.y.,'.,-

7

sll.

' '.* *y'. f., o,*g ;* ~ ',_

'n i

...w; :,; : 4,.sga>.,a.

-.:c?..., a O.. e

., n g.-,,.ge.

e

e. + c

...g, l

O.,r

-,,x.~.

w r.

.w=

'...z: c. Q.C

'; :, y,, 4 ~ s.M.-

s 4

~*-

- w c

r.,.

r

~

,. r.

' c. -

s.

0

.. w n-g,

..a. ;u,.s ~;,-y :.

cw

, e'. m..

y.

cy

.....,..a.;m.. s %W;t, y; p :.; ::;u.c

~

. =. -

e;n ',

.w in r : - G :., '.

-..~

..., :.5

.,..c:: 9. v...,;.;.'r.;g:e v..

u

. ~.

m;..~ ;w

.,. - e,....,... t %. %,,v,%., q. q*',~.., u.4 g,;7.s... y-

.... _ ~ & ?

m.s:,

• .,, ~.

,7,,..g,..'._

5

- - a. -

m.,.s t

o.

u.,~

..,..a.

.t m

,.,,.. ~

n

....... m.

n

. c. u... ~.,-

.,,u y,,..a v..:

s,. %.ya.A.;;e c 3

.a o

. A s,p m..,,.,

2

.r.

.o s

,L

' :v. :. v

.... g. 4, y ;;;r. y,y:~;~.. w, %.,.. wt...v. w. m,..n. :.. m.. -

.v

. n.

.a'

,.x.. mA..X..t Q..

. r,, ; gl'y.'.%.:',.Ic..da. 'sX. lA o n. n:.q. '. Qf w'c, c ~~e

^.. m,

.. ~.,

. ';'s s

• ., u..

~

e.

4_s:d;v.'d

+

. y

., e P

- j'

.,_ 9.ls, o

.)y'*j Q..nz,..,: je:

, u %. w.,V;. -

.~

a

.c.

. }, h;

.',.,- y..

• ' -c '

2. d:a.W cf:. s.. jk:, [,&;y..

p ;p

.w -

2.

\\

.m. 9 u.

~,-.

/g....,i.G g l, S... ;4../. ; '.A :

I:

.,.~ w.

'.w.,.

'.:. a m.4 x. +v.3:,.

.r. ~...., ' ',, ',.- --

s v.=m. y %.-,..~r

- e p.p. J.,.

a..

.e g.

p.8+.

.. t.,L P. t.-~

,c

p...,,.; w*

.. +. -

c. v....

-ic a

m,. ;n, w. v.

9..._-v%.?,.C'~3

.g.,

R 4

e p

i.-.. Mg P UBLIC. MEETING :- O;s.m';E,,R.s%f y

~

~

w-

. : n.

Ts.

.v,~.

~y-

,u

- s

.m

%, a

• g;.,x

,v.p.m 4

, ',e(n a c~.. - > **m s <*:

i..

• .,;...-~-

a-

., $. 3

. c

. +

w. >

-.c.

- s

~ '

~

f,<

a R E V I S I O N S: T O_ T H E'.o.gINDIAN'. POINT', ORDER. #

m.

.r c.5 A A,.

T:%p... U

..o. -u;

.s

., ' ;*., -m '. -

..v,..

e v~n..,.,w'...$ N. ' m% :

~... -

m...

2-v n

e..

re.

.?.

,&.w.s,.8* * - 1:, s! E, %s*1.r S,,.

e r

sr-

.% W.

I"* *: '..;h.si*" :.

'd & -'

W

• ~- '.

% - m, e.. y u,

<4..:Q,.s<,,-.

n

. r.-

.+.o s

y

_y

![ n[. n :fkk '.L ~

• w....,.$k..).. ~

..., ',...gi

[

h

. -. t v.+. w,i.P. Y 60

. :[i.

i

.q

.i C

T

f a,p,c.~~ s-

i. 4.

A D:..c~

.. ~ -

..w.,a. b. v.?.y~.% @:n.+Q o w &..z W,p. :6.t : y ; s.. ~. - - =.w- ;-~ -

e-cr

~ m n " y:

h w.,, A 4-, e..v#

w-s.. : :.

n_

.f.

-~

a.

g.w y

... <e 3-s7.,. ;.n.---

4.4*'.#

'e-

' i wn s-m;v,a.

Se._ h_-- be #_ h.y.,

w n.~ :^.nw.-- n cATE:

?AC: 1 +-, 3 -

7_ R '. T 0. 9 7__

.. - - a

~.

. ; : ' z.%;&.w s'...n.@m3.

m

'AT:

Washincton', D '. C. ' ' "

~

s..

,,. y.

s

..m.,

.' '..y.,

4 9

. =,

4.f ek%

.e

..{.

, 7,.a

,,"g 1

s e

'g

.,g

..,. [ V ALDER 50X 3 REPORTIXG 4co n:p e a um., s.w. w e c=, c. c. 2c c:4 m?

':'a ' aphc=a : (200) 554-2345 0109250505 010918 PDR' ADOK 05000003 PDR T

l

a 1

-s

/~N.

-1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

,a 2

NUCLEAR-REGULATORY COMMISSION 3

PUBLIC MEETING

,.s O]

4 EEVISIONS TO THE INDIAN POINT CBDER 5

6 Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7

Room 1130 8

1717 H Street, N.W.

9 Washington, D.C.

to 11 Friday, September 18, 1981 12 13 The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 14 14:20 p.m.

15 BEFORE:

16 NUNZIO PALLADINO, Chairman of the Commisson 17' VICTOR GILINSKY, Commissioner 18 PETER 3RADFORD, Commissioner 19 JOHN AHEARNE, Commissioner 20 IHCMAS ROBERTS, Commissioner 21 22 23 (E) 24 25

(-)

[

ALDERSoN REPCRTING COMP ANY,INC,

r, 3

1 2

v lt

.]

1 NRC STAFF' PRESENT:.

2" SAMUEL CHILk 3

JOHN H0YLE 4'

LEONARD BICKWIT 5'

MARTIN MALSCH 6-FORREST REMICK 7

8 9

10' 11 12 10 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 23

.O 24

(.'

25

. '.'h.

i ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC.

s s

3

/-i-)

1 PR0CEEDINGS 2

CHAIRMAN ?ALLADINO:

This morning we had discussed D' Y 3 revisions to the Indian Point Order and I understand 4 everybody has had an opportunity to read it.

5 I got one ites from my own staff that says instead 8of "to only accept" to reverse the words and say "only to 7 accept."

8 I would even buy it the way it was.

9 COMMISSIONER BR ADFORD:

I was just going to say, I 10 am grateful to your staff.

The thought had crossed my mind 11 this morning but I did not dare at that point to throw out 12 an amendment.

13 (Laughter.)

0 14 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

I think that is the only 15 s 1ggested change.

Would you buy that change and vote "aye" 16for it?

17' COMMISSIONER ROBERTS:

I believe so.

18 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

My staff has come up with 19 two questions.

20 (Laughter.)

21 MR. BICKWITs Say it as it is.

22 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

That where we say, " focus 23 clearly upon the questions asked by the Commission" we would 24 probably want to go on to say something like, "However, 25 contentions based on allega tions in the UCS petition to h

ALOERSON AEPcRTINo COMPANY,INC,

4

-D I

s g

[])

1 affect some of our reguletions are not met - one or both -

2 and may ' be considered."

3 CHAIRMAN PALTADINO:

Where are you working from?

,,y U

4 MR. BICKWITs I did not follow you.

5 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

It is in the footnote.

6 CHAIRMAN PALLADINot In the footnote.

7 MR. BICKWIT:

Where-abouts?

8 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

Well, I wish I could find 9 it.

10 (Laughtar.)

11 COMMISSIONER AREARNE:

The point is that back in 12 the Order when we say, "The Boards focused clearly upon the 13 questions asked by the Commission."

t 14 MR. BICKWIT I anticipted that, and that is why 15 we said in the footnote that it does not make any difference 16whether it is within or outside those questions.

17 COMMISSIO N ER AHEARNE:

So, you feel that 18 clarification is not needed?

19 MR. BICXVIT:

No.

It says, "Without regard to 20 whether they fall within or outside the questions on pages.

21 v..d 10."

22 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE.

The other, which is 23 something that I thouqqt we had agreed to this corning - at

()

24 lea st the wording that I had - was in your phrase, in your 25 Order you say, " Contentions based on," I thought it was O

8 ALCERSoN REPCRTING COMPANY,INC,

n --

S f) 1 " Contentions based -on the allegations -in the UCS -- of

.sj 2 concerned scientists' petitions to the effect that certain --

3 CHAIRMAN PALLADI?TO:

You think it was based on the 7~

b 4 alleged --

5 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

Or the allegations.

8 OHAIRdAN PALLADINO:

You want me to co get it?

7 MR. BICKWIT:

All right.

8 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

Is that a problem, to say, 9 " Allegatiohs in the UCS petition to the eff ect that certain 10 Ccamission regulations are not met?"

11 MR. BICKWIT:

I do not see any problem with that.

12 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

Do you want to see if you can 13 get it?

It should be right on the desk.

14 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:

Do you see any diffe:ence?

15 MR. BICKWIT:

No.

16 inAARMAN PALLADINO:

Contentions based on the 17 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

Allegations in the petion.

18 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

I do not see much 19 dif ference.

I was reading it right from the document.

20 20MMISSIONER AHEARNE:

This is the old Order.

21 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

Yes, that is what I want, the 22 old O rd e r.. I was reading it from, let's see, " Contentions 23 based on the UCS petition to the eff ect tha t certain of our j[)

24 regulations are not in' --

25 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

We were discussing what I h

A1.DERSoN REPORTING COMPANY. ;NC.

400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTCN. O.C. 200 4(202) 554 2345

6 w

A.

.(

j 1 had said I would agree to put in, the allegations in the UCS 2 pe tition.

)

-3 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

Do you have any objection to i

4 putting in the word "allega tion ? "- Well, th en, we will have 5a vote to include that.

6 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE:

All right.

7 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

Do you have tha t, Sam?

8 MR. CHILK:

Ies, sir.

9 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

Any other comments on the 10 Order?

Yay we have s vote to approve it.as modified ?

11 (Chorus of ayes.)

12 CHAIRMAN PALLADINO:

All right, we will consider 13 t;te open portion of the meeting closed.

14 (Whereupon, at 4: 25 p.m.

the Commission proceeded 15 in closed session. )

f 16 i

17 18 19 20 21 22 23

,n.

25 i

j

)

A8.CERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC,

7_

~

.m MUCLEAR REGULATORY CO!?!ISSION (vg This is Oc certify that the attached proceedings befcre the 7

LJ 1:1 the =atter cf:

PUBLIC MEETING - REVISIONS TO THE INDIAN POINT ORDER Cate of ?: cceeding:

Seotember 18, 1981 Dccket Ilue:b er:

Place of Proceeding:

Washincton. D.

C.

wore held as herein appesrs, and that this is the Original transcrip the: scf fcr the file.'cf the Cec::lissien.

i M.

E. Hansen Official Reporter (Typed)

!f.

Official Reporter (Signature) t J

bLi

~.

((

(((({

(((( _({!((

ff((l

$ ( ( ( l lll ( ll ( (( !_1 ( (

(l P

TRANSMITTAL TO:

M Document Control Desk, 016 Phillips ADVANCED COPY TO:

O The Public Document Room g,

September 21, 1981

. l;DATE:

Attached are the PDR copies of a Commission meeting transcript /s/ and related meeting document /s/.

They are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession P

List and placement in the Public Document Room.

No P

other distribution is requested or required.

Existing h

DCS identification numbers are listed on the individual p

documents wherever possible.

,g-F 1.

Transcript of:

Revisions to the Indian Point Order!

2 (1 copy)

Sept. 18, 1981.

O ja

>wn

/g, 8 AQ7~ \\

Office of the Secretary e

/'

(w* e, 3

. e.

2, G

, e 's-

g '

ik b

5

/s

o ee r%p)X E

t.

?$HRR$NPNN0DW@bW69R3W6WN@$RR9RRN6DW9 1.