ML20009E138
| ML20009E138 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Point Beach  |
| Issue date: | 07/17/1981 |
| From: | Fay C WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER CO. |
| To: | Clark R, Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20009E139 | List:
|
| References | |
| IEB-80-11, NUDOCS 8107270156 | |
| Download: ML20009E138 (19) | |
Text
/
O WISCONSIN Electnc eona couesur 231 WEST MICHIGAN, MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN 53201 July 17
$pN b
5 0(9g
/~
t Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director p
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation 4
gC U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
/
Washington, D.C.
20555 ra Attenticn: Mr. Robert Clark, Chief Operating Reactors Branch No. 3 Gentlemen:
DOCKET NOS. 50-266 AND 50-301 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING MASONRY WALL IE BULLETIN 80-11 POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT, UNIT N05. 1 AND 2 On June 9-11, 1981, members of your Staff met with Wisconsin Electric and our consultants at the Point Beach Nuclear Plant to conduct an onsite review and audit of our responses to IE Bulletin 80-11, Mascary Walls.
Discussions were neld during this meeting to resolve differences between the NRC Staff's design criteria and the criteria used by Wisconsin Electric in evaluating the Point Beach masonry walls.
An end result of these discussions was the formulation of 21 action items which would resolve the NRC's concerns regarding the analysis of masonry walls at the Point Beach Nuclear Plant.
These action items were formally
~
transmitted to us with Mr. Colburn's summary of meeting minutes dated July 1, 1981.
A number of these action items requested that information be provided to your Staff by July 15, 1981.
The attachments and enclosures to this letter provide our responses to those items.
These attachments include responses to items 2, 3, 10, 12, 14, and 17 and that portion of the response to item 1 requested by July 15.
Please notify us if you have any questions regarding this information.
Very truly yours, g
Y
$, u.,- t$
., +,
\\
C. W. Fay, Dire'ctor i) f /
Nuclear Power Department h
Enclosure v
Copy to:
NRC Resident Inspectpr (less encl.)
JP./
Point Beach Nuclear Plant P p's Blind copies to Messrs. McNeer, Burstein, Gorske/Finke, Porter, 8107270156 810717
~
Reed, Charnoff, Stevens gDRADOCK05000 y q % (.)) M
\\
180034 D
o 0
a _._
i! '
j i
i I
n-
.f
_ l.
2o 3,.
,4i pw a
bb RO f
E~
C U
/
/--T S'
/
H
-s s g
2 x
~
- ^
e f
g U
W l
s 6
U. n' 8
I i 1
I III N
8 a
e c :;; =
c$
cc w e m
H n5 r
M O uo 0
O W Nd 0- Ea O.
o o'z.
4 l
xo v
W D
nm C
z
- di
'O r
o u s!
5
{.-
z a.
o_
~C D E
O Lu C
I...
Q W
CC On
~
E zo o
s 84 W
u tu W
E l
o cc a
lW E
'z 3
(
W m b
O k
o o
O 4
4 a
g g
(S 01 NOI189373330
Me9f 0
0 1
j s
1 H 0 i
.u
.I C8
.w E/ 7 T
1 U/
l P 0 1
M O
C R
\\
\\
\\
\\-
0 KI lI k
\\
1
\\
\\
\\
\\
TO/
/
E i
iill/
T
/
E
)
F Z
\\
H 8
\\
(
Kl i
\\_\\N N
I
\\
\\
Y N
\\
\\
\\
C O
\\
\\_\\
\\
N I
i
\\
T
\\
E R
\\~\\
U V
Q E
i
_1 l
E I
1 E i./[/l[j/
L li A
F 4
R 5G S
P 1I Iv N
_)
T T I 3
C CD 3
)
E L 9
a
~
E J I 1
O U s,
0 0
P RB t
1 M
o f
?c C 0 I(
E S
P C A
7_<~I R 8 S E U
B L G
N O
N T R O
I N T I N P
P O O M
f 0
E R
0%
M N0 U
E.
x R
D G4 T
E C
E E
L T
P S
A R
L A
E N
I N
- G E
S I 1
O R G
J C 0
5 0
5 0
5 0
2 0
7 5
2 0
1 1
0 0
0 O
i so E5"08
^
GENERATED RESPONSE SPECTBA CDMPUTECH JOS:
POINT BERCH PROJECT 541 10/17/80 ORIGINAL SPECTRUM:
CONTROL 800M BUILDING ELEVATION: 26.0 FEET LEGEND 2.0% ORMPING i
2.50 I
I
]
_ 11 2.00
!\\
G
\\
g 1.50 1
t z
-q o
a g.
g I--
L g 1.00 g
cr 3
p
\\((_._g-OD A
l 0.50 O
(EG'7'0.4o)
/
N I
/
\\
6' 3
W-I
- (0.2(
(
72,js,
,,I t i
Ii D.00 _
0.1
- 1. 0 10 100 FREQUENCY (HZ) f
p@ C's
. ~
0 0
(E_ _ _
L u
1 ij H
h 0
C8 W
E/
O 7
(
T 1
U/
P 0 1
M D
C N
0 1
T E
0 E
F 0
)
Z 6
2 H
(
\\1ah
\\
Y M
\\
C O
(
N I
^
T E
A U
V Q
E E
L R
1)
A 1 E F
4 R 5 G N
)
/
T 0
)
T I C C D 4
9 E L 0
1 E
J I SU p,
0, 0
P AB gi 1
S P 4
M 7
c HO 6
2 L i
C O E
2 R R
?.
(
S E
((I i
B L G
N O
N T R O
I N T I N P
P O O M
S P C A
O E
R 0%
M N0 U
E R
I D
G4 T
E C
E E
L T
P S
A R
LA E
N I
N
- G E
BI
- 1 G JO O R 0
0 0
0 0
e 5
0 5
e 0
0
@Cgo 2
2 1
Eg
awOQ 0
0 j~
1 Il Q H 0 a
C8 E /7 T
1' U/
P 0 1
M O
C 0
~
1
(
E
^
T
}_
E F
0
)
4 ZH 4
(
i\\i
-i I{
N I
Y ll O
C
\\
l I
N T
E
_ - _ ~
R e
U V
Q E
m
_ _ - 6 _ _ ^ _ _ - _. ~ - -
/
R L
E A
1 E t1 J
4
/
F R 5G g
N
)
T T I
)e C C D z9 EL i
E J I OU 0
o.
P R B 0
p, S P p,
HO l
yIe M
1 7
C O Z
E R R u.
C S E I
S L G
N O
N T R O
I NT I N P
P O O M
S PC AO E
R D%
N N0 U
E.
E C
E R
D G2 T
E L
T PS A
71 R
LA E
N I
N G
E S I O R G J O 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
5 0
5 0
5 0
2 2
1 1
0 0
g i:2 Wg8.
g t,
GENERATED RESPONSE SPECTRR COMPUTECH JOS:
POINT BERCH PROJECT 541 10/17/80 ORIGINAL SPECTRUN CONTROL ROOM BUILDING ELEVRTION: 44.0 FEET LEGEN0 4.0% ORMPING 2.50 2.00
\\
L
\\
a j
\\
l o 1.50
._ _____k
~
1 U
\\
3 E
I L
f I
U 1. 00 E
1
\\
l N
I
\\
\\
~
~
p l
~
GD nA'
.50 ym,,_n)
- g Y
cokspis l1 w
0-h 6) 0.00 0.1
- 1. 0 10 100 Ff1EQUENCY (HZ)
- o3 0
0 T
1 e
H 0 C8
.o E/
c 7
T 1
U/
I P 0 1
M O
C m
~
~
\\
x 0
n'
\\
1
\\
\\\\
\\
l
/
IW T
A I
E
}
E V
"\\
)
F n
ZH 8
\\
(
\\
g
\\
\\
)
Y N
O 9
C n
h I
N 2
l T
11
)
E 1
o R
IlI
\\
U V
l 1
Q E
L t\\
y E
i li g
Tl R
A 1 E
.3 4
(\\
c.
t F
R 5 G r
If 1/I c
N T
T I C CD A/
jC E L E J I O U P
D 0
R B S P T
1 HR C A E
4l R P S
E S L G
N R
N T R O
I NT I N P
P O E M
S PC A
D E
R D%
M N0 U
E.
R l
D G2 T
E C
E E
L T
P A
7 S
R L
R E
N I
N G
nE 8 I 0 R 1
G J O 0
5 0
s 0
5 0
2 0
7 5
2 0
1 1
0 0
0 0
= e E g5dt"
GENERATED RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPUTECH JOBS POINT BEACH PROJECT 541 10/17/80 ORIGINAL SPECTRUM:
CENTRAL PRRT BUILDING ELEVRTION: B FtET LEGEND 4.07. ORMPING 1.25 1.00 G
g 0. 75 r
g i
z
'l _ R _ \\
/
N\\
\\
U 0. 50
/
\\
\\
l 5
N\\
e f
\\\\
\\
\\
7Y - J\\
n\\
w W /y/ II \\
0.25 l
\\ \\
l o j
L cc.17) a
^
~
E "# Pr0E) 0.00
-i 0.1
- 1. 0 10 100 FREQUENCY (NZ)
0 gmD3f i 0 1
H 0
)
C8 9
E/
2 T
0 7
(
1 U/
P 0 1
M O
C h
\\
\\
\\
\\'
0 1
\\
\\
A
\\
1 T
/'
E
,A E
\\
F U
Y,/
0
)
Z 6
H 2
\\
(
N
)
Y O
C 2
)
I N
2 T
bk O
E R
o
/.
U V
t O
Q p,
E
\\
E L
(
n l
A 1 E f
4 s
o F
,l c
R 2 G S
t.
N f
T c
T I f
C C D
}
(
E L
/ /
E J I P
)
O U R B 0
Q~
S P
ll 1 T
HR C R E
- l R P S
E B l N
i G
F N
T R O
I NT I N P
P OE M
S P C A
D E
R 0%
M 40 f
U E.
R D
G2 T
E C
E E
L T
P S
A R
L A
E N
I N
G E
BI O R 1
G J O 0
s 0
5 o
5 2
0 7
s 2
1 1
0 0
O gg 5 gy8"
sZoOMh U
U I
)
o H 0 I.
p C8
(
E/ 7 T
1 U/
P 0 1
M O
C
\\g 0
\\\\
1 bN#
T E
\\
E V
F 0
)
Z 6
H 2
(
N j
Y g
N O
\\-
u.
C N
I
\\
T
\\
\\
o
)o E
A
\\
U t.
Q V
E g
7 0
E L
g, p,
R
\\
1 E l
A 9
4 F
4 e
R 5 G S
f N
T r
g t.
T I t
J c
C C D E L E
J I N
O U 0
P RB S
P r
T 1
H R C R E
A P S
E B L G
N A
N T R O
I N T I N P
P OE M
S P C R
O E
R D%
M N0 U
E.
R D
G4 T
E C
E E
L T
P S
A R
L A
E N
I N
G 7
E B I G
J O O R 9
5 0
5 0
5 0
2 0
7 5
2 0
1 1
0 0
0 0
g =;E"g8G
GENERATED RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPUTECH JOB:
POINT BERCH PROJECT 541 10/17/80 ORIGINAL SPECTRUM:
CENTRAL PART BUILOING ELEVRTION: 44.3 FEET LEGEND 2.0% ORMPING jf i;_
- 1. 25 T_
- '}
l
__l l
5f 1.00
\\i
\\L h-us e 0.75 t
~
)
5 4
.\\
E
] 0.50 o
W(
E E
/t-~\\
t
\\
aa 0.25
\\
\\
ES)s J_
U 5 ep, v-
'r O. zz )_-,
y3
,A ~.M7
')
.Z
- _. /
O 2 T<e). 0 M O. On l
0.1
- 1. 0 10 100 FREQUENCY (HZ)
m 0
s
,,OGn 1
0 H
0 i
C8 2
E/
2 7
0 T
1 U/
P 0 1
M O
C
\\
0 1
\\
1
. L T
E E
,n_
F
' \\_,
\\
3
)
Z 4
H 4
(
N Y
)
O
.)
C
\\
S_
N I
T
\\
,1 2
2 E
A
-o 1
U A
V 0
Q p,
E E
0,,
L R
c 1 E S
A e
F 4
S R
5 G T
(
T I 2
N 1
C CD C
E L E
J I O U 0
P RB S
P
_YI 1
T HR C A E
R P S
E B L G
7 N
R N
T R O
I N T I N P
P T
C OE M
S P C R
D E
R D%
M N0 U
E.
R D
G4 T
E C
E E
L T
PS A
R LR E
N I
N G
E B I 1
O R G J O m
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 2
0 7
5 2
0 1
1 0
O 0
0
-( o
- Eyee 3/
j 1
1i, L_
I
- L i
,f;1Ml
~ ~
f ilII l41_L; g.
3 L_
s.
- 1I Li i.. i.
_. i C8 lIl i!
i j ; i,.
i i-1!
o E /
g T1 l
I i
' i I
! i i
i 9
U/
l l
I i
!i ji i L_
i p
P 0 M
i
- i i
l e
i 1
!~
i i
i e_.
l[
O U
C lT Ii i
I t
i ii f
c
" lQ_
I' 0
T E
l j-l i
i l ljI I
I i
1 i.
i
{
E l i I i li I
.li gj I.
l' F
l
.i I
,i !
8 1
I1 i ! I
} gl i i-
-l l.ti
!lI !
I Il il:
I
- )
I a:
N
!l I !
. !i
!]_
)
O l
I
- 2
,l II c
Z ll
- !i H
T Jg
,;I!
I
~
(
R E
i i im i!
l i
i j
.,I V
L 1;
Y s_,
, 1 I
N C
E G
i !I
.i
- L i b1i
/
! e; E
lI U
N l
i i
~.l3J o
Q I
D g
E R
L l_l 2-iy U.
I F
l 1 U i! l l
A
,F.
4 B lj; R S G
T T N C
CI EH
-_ u' I
E J
0 O H
.;h l
P RT 1
S P
J'
- 1 I i
!i.
l I
1
- i.,
HS
.1 I i lf
- 1. [e
,ii_
iqi.l O
E AY
.1 Il l
.!g
- nl.
]
C S
E R t
T L
-L.'
i p
- h. :
i I
BR G
N I
N l
I I
O NI P
M I
iI.l!1 l;Ii7 i
l
- l P
I X OU S PR R
E iT.I!
l i]< I i;
!c O
R D7 M
N0
- y U
E.
i.il iIj l!
R G2 II D
T E
C E
E L
S T
P A
i I
{ ; L_.
1:
~
R L
- 1 R
E N
I N
- G E
G JO 0
0 5
0 5
0 2
5 5
7 2
0 U
0 O
0 1
1
_, g o;
ug' s
180034 OO
_ _.d _
i.
.d-
- l. _
...l..
.J..__j E
O U CO l
d gw
.}
t CD i
j f
3N IL O
w
.. !.. [...
D U
i
. 'l..._,,_
/_ [
0 O
w
__..J
.-...... 2...
d E
._. l 4.
.t I
e
__.L.
.a_4._.l l
n
...?. -. _.f.
i 2
..J.
q_
I.
g l
I.
_... +_
O
. i i g
!j__-
.._4 z
I i
w
.._ L.
_4
._4 q._
J l'
i
/
\\
\\
I w
u E
1
/
Z sv) i u.J
/
Y I
l
~
\\
O l
l
)
I o
.J.
N)
W I i c
g,* D I
v m
co N
4 u.
C m o
b
>z l
L) u~
wx LJ iox O
C-c-
O 3._
' r -- - l ------ q _.. t -- j - - j-- I' - - '
i l -- J 1
l 07 LD 1
7 b ' - --b--'
u d
_.. - ___ L E>
so e e
._q _
_p _..
i 73
- _..-I gQ y d_
i i
m i
eo r
i,,
l}
m
@ LE C
- l j
-4_{_..
.._. L
.l.
!l l - i Q
i LIJ l
'l j
ON i
C ZC l
ly t
i
$y
_l__j
_g.
v.
C O
l I
(.J U
W t
w J
b Ln g
l l
,e l!]
Z m
2 a 0 (gj mm d
O C
(
O
"") O O
W O
W O
W O
l l
N O
t'-
Ln N
O O
O O
O (S 01 NOI1BW373338 l
p02o 0
00 1
g _
H 0 C8 E/
l>
9 T
1 U/
P 0 M
M 1
f O
D
)
C
'9 40
^
N N
T E
0 E
.(_
1 F
62
-I N
y.
O I
T
)
\\\\i![
Z R
H V
C E
L
.l\\
I E
\\
\\
\\
_\\
)
Y h
\\
S C
G N
\\
t3y_
N
(
0 E
I U
D l
s Q
L
\\
ji y
e E
I A
U m
G R
e 4 B F
R 5 4!
w
,l, (1-G T
T N
\\
C CI E J f
E H O H P
RT 0
S P U
/
O 1
HS C
E RY S
E R B R G
N I
N T L O
I N I I X P
P O U M
S PR R
O E
/#
R D%
M N0 U
E.
7 R
D G2 T
E C
E E
L T
P
~
S A
R LR E
N I
N
- G E
B I O R 1
G JO 0
5 0
5 0
5 0
2 0
7 5
2 0
1 1
0 0
0 0
a e E C=i5.
0 b C $ 7$
h oh 0
e
~
1
~
~
~ ~
~
N H 0 1
C8 E/
9 T
1 U/
P 0 1.
M O
C
)s
\\'j e
4
/
\\
f T
\\ ]h {_
E o
E t
F t
AI 82 N
O l
I
)
T Z
R
\\,
H
(\\
V
(
E L
\\
Y E
\\
(\\
A.
\\
)f C
G N
d
\\s_\\
(_
0.,
N
.E I
U D
L s
Q y
E
._. \\_\\
I 1
4 1 U i
R F
(L R 5 r_
~
4 B i
~
G J
T ll T N C
CI E H E J O H 0
P RT j
1 S
P U HS
'd!
O C
E RY Y
S E R B R G
l N
I N
T L O
I NI I X P
P S
P R R
O U H
O E
R D%
M N0 U
M E.
R D
G4 T
E C
E E
L T
PS R
R LR E
N I
N G
E BI 1
G JOO R 0
5 0
5 0
5 0
2 0
7 5
2 0
1 L
0 0
0 0
_m o
$30oC
dm AA 0
0 l
[
.. )Q A
o H 0 c
l C8 E/
0 i
T 2 U/
P 0 1
M O
C
>y r
vu k
T E
\\ \\'
0 E
1 F
\\
8
!i
\\
k M
4 I
\\
(\\
I N
/
\\
\\
O
\\IA%
Z I
)
T A
H V
(
E
\\
L
\\
)
Y E
\\
4
~
C
)
N i
I L
Jl '
N G
/
E D
_I i
e I
U l
o.
Q y
L E
s I
i R
f 1 U c
A F
i 1[
,/
4 B 3
~
I L
R 5 t
G T
c y/
T N j
C CI
/
J EH E
JOH V'
0 P
RT S
P U 1
O S ER mf I
HS I
C E
AY B A G
i
-II l
N I
N T L O
NI S
PA R
i pi I
I X P
P O U M
O E
I R
D%
M N0 U
E R
D G2
{,
T E
C E
E L
T P
S A
i
,I R
L A
E N
I N
- G E
BI 1
O R G
J O
~
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 2
0 7
5 2
0 1
1 0
0 0
O Eg zS $ Uwl" i
GENERATED RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPUTECH JOB:
POINT BEACH PROJECT 541 10/20/80 ORIGINRL SPECTRUM:
RUXILIRRY S3UTH MING BUILDING ELEVRTION: 48 FEET LEGEN0 i
i I
l, t
! l l
4.0% ORMPING l
l t
i i
1.25 s
j 1.00 l'
h' F
\\
11
\\
_/
l
\\
\\A k
G
-.f
___YI
\\
o 0.75 E
\\
\\
~
H
\\
c
\\
\\
g
\\
\\
U 0. 50 I
\\
u
\\
n
\\
y
) l\\
\\
i N/\\
\\
v 7
m
~
C0
\\ \\
- -q.)
0.25
> c3 u.c.a p, 0 u)
<n j
n
/
M
] (t.%n. c.n )
CP--Y
[
I I
i l
I i
0.00 O.1
- 1. 0 10 100 FREQUENCY (HZ)
,