ML20009B172

Summary of 810618 Meeting W/Util,Fr Romano & M Lewis in Bethesda,Md Re Effects of Quarry Vibrations on Geologic Faults,Cured Concrete & Green Concrete & Concrete Voids

ML20009B172
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	06/30/1981
From:	Calkins G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8107150004
Download: ML20009B172 (7)

Text

_, _

'l

,h ye c..t>

(W 0

.f

[

a l

UUN 3 C ")B1 Docket Nos.: 50-352 and 50-353

-APPLICANT:

Phila.delphia Electric Company FACILITY:

Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 & 2

SUBJECT:

SUlHARY OF MEETING WITH FRANK R. RAMAN0 AND MARVIN LERIS DATE & TIME:

1:00 - 3:30 pm., June 18, 1981, at Bethesda, Maryland ATTENDEES:

Public NRC C.

I Frank R. Romano G. D. Calkins p

gf h ibJ g;

Marvin Lewes A. Schwencer A. K. Ibrahim

-i jul 0 g gggte J. R. Pearrigg

~{

p V,,,.g*$f, AS

($J PEEo R. B. McMullen Colleen Woodhead R. E. Lipinski (part-time) ' Q,/

'/

R. L. Fiske f

R. L. Tedesco (part-time) 4 AGENDA: _

2.

Effects of quarry vibrations on cured concrete l.

Effects of quarry vibrations on geologic faults 3.

Effects of quarry bibrations on green concrete 4.

Concrete bolds The purpose of tne meeting was to provide Messrs. Romano and Lewis an opportunity to question the technical staff on their conceres. The questions were the same as those they have raised in past correspondedce over the past couple of years.

-The responses by the staff were the same as they presented before by reference to the following documents:

1.

Directors Decision under 10 CFR 2.206 dated October 9,1989, relative to Mr. Romano's letters of April 12. May 14, and June 12,1979.

2.

" Comparison of Near - Site Quarry Blast Characteristics to the Seismic Design at Limerick Generating Station", Philadelphia Electric Company, July 1980.

3.

Letter from James F. Devine of USGS to Dr. Robert E. Jackson, NRC, JJuly 29001980, relative to a detailed review of poss5ble effects of quarry blasting on the Limerick Plc.r.t.

i 4.

" Blasting Vibrations Limits on Freshly Placed (Green) Concrete by United l

Engineers and Contrattors", October 29, 1980.

.y.{

} {....gl{...'.......

l

..... sto7150004 810630l

" '* 4 lcu:Naur)

PDR.ADOCK 05000352 A

PDR J

uo s.

our)..................l.....................

N:c ronu sie no soinacu o24o OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

. m m-a2,42.

u w

n W.

S.

n gy30 fggy

.z_

Messrs. Romano and Lewis questioned and discussed with the staff, characteristics of geologic strata at the Limerick site and the nearby quarry; vibratory motion from various blasting forces; and concrete at the liquid, initial set, add cured states. Also discusssed and examined were the date recorded over the past een years by the quaryy personnel and by PECo, and analyzed by USGS nad NRC personnel.

G. D. Calkins, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 2 Division of Licensing cc: See next page A

"'c ' >.DL:.LBA2...DL:

......S.W.

.... 0.5 B....... ).kg..................,,.........................

^

cro u co:nwe)..G..C.a..l..k.i..n. s : c2 A

encer RLipin i

Albrahim

" ^ " >. 6./.:.2 6. 81..... 6./. 5..//.8.1.......

.... 6AG /81

... 6. /.,2.'l/8].....

(unc e oru ain oo.coi wacu ono OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

• mo m-32 82.

=-

~,

Mr. Edward G. Bauer, Jr.

Vice President & General Counsel

' Philadelphia Electric _ Company.

2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania ; '19101 Mr.ior Vice President Vincent Boyer cc: _ Troy B.' Conner, Jr., Esq.

Sen Conner, Moore & Corber

- 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Nuclear Operations Washington, D.

C.-

20006-Philadelphia Electric Company 2301 Market Street Deputy Attorney General Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

-19101 Room 512, Main Capitol' Building Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Karl Abraham Public Affairs Officer Mr. Robert W. Adler-Region I, OIE

' Assistant' Attorney General U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,

Bureau of Regulatory Counsel 631 Park Avenue 505 Executive House King of Prussia, PA 19806 P. O. Box.2357 Harrisburg,-Pennsylvania 17120 Allan Kanner, Esq.

1622 Locust Street Honorable Lawrence Coughlin Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 5

House of Representatives Congress of the United States Ms. Phyllis Zitzer Washington, D. C.

20515

. Limerick Ecology Action P. O. Box 761 Roger B. Reynolds, Jr., Esq.

Pottstown, Pennsylvania 19464 324 Swede Street Norristown, Pennsylvania 19401 Lawrence Sager, Esq.

Sager & Sager Associates 45 High Street Pottstown, Pennsylvania 19464 Joseph A. Smyth Assistant County Solicitor County of Montgomery Courthouse Norristown, Pennsylvania 19404 Eugene J..Bradley Philadelphia Electric Company Associate General Counsel 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Mr. Jacque Durr Resident Reactor Inspector U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 47 Sanatoga, Pennsylvania 19464

3 s

pa neg g'o,,

UNITED STATES

+

[

"g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g

8 WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

'JUN 3 0 1981 Docket Nos.: 50-352 and 50-353 APPLICANT:

Philadelphia Electric Company FACILITY:

Limerick Generacing Station, Units 1 & 2

SUMMARY

OF MEETING WITH FRANK R. ROMAN 0 AND MARVIN LEWIS DATE & TIME:

1:00 - 3:30 pm., June 18, 1981, at Bethesda, Maryland ATTENDEES:

Public NRC Frank R. Romano G. D. Calkins Marvin Lewis A. Schwencer A. K. Ibrahim J. R. Pearring PECo R. B. McMullen Colleen Woodhead R. L. Fiske R. E. Lipinski (part-time)

R. L. Tedesco (part-time)

AGEiiDA:

1.

Effects of quarry vibrations on geologic faults 2.

Effects of quarry vibrations on cured concrete 3.

Effects of quarry vibrations on green concrete 4.

Concrete voids The purpose of the meeting was to provide Messrs. Romano and Lewis an opportunity to question the technical staff on their concerns.

The questions were the same as those they have raised in past correspondence over the past couple of yecrs.

The responses by the staff were the same as they presented before by reference to the following documents:

1.

Directors Decision under 10 CFR 2.206 dated October 9, 1979, relative to Mr. Romano's letters of April 12, May 14, and June 12, 1979.

2.

" Comparison of Near - Site Quarry Blast Characteristics to the Seismic Design at Limerick Generating Station", Philadelphia Electric Company, l

July 1980.

3.

Letter from James F. Devine of USGS to Dr. Robert E. Jackson, NRC, July 25, 1980, relative to a detailed review of possible effects of quarry blasting on the Limerick Plant.

4.

" Blasting Vibrations Limits on Freshly Placed (Green) Concrete by United Engineers and Contractors", October 29, 1980.

L

t e

to

. 2-Messrs. Romano and Lewis questioned and discussed with the staff, characteristics of geologic. strata at the Limerick site and the nearby quarry; vibratory motion

. from various blasting forces; and concrete at the liquid, initial set,' and cured-s tates. Also discusssed and examined were the data recorded over the past ten years by the quarry personnel and by PECo, and analyzed by USGS and NRC personnel.

h.y. k$/Ls:.

G. D. Calkins, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 2 Division of Licensing _

cc: See next page-i-

I

\\

il i

I I

i l

l I-I

m.

i. : l %

Mr. Edward G. Bauer, 'Jr..

Vice President & General Counsel Philadelphia Electric Company 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Vinc nt Boyer Mr.iorV$cePresident cc:' Troy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.

Sen Conner, Mnore-8 Corber

1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Nuclear Operations Washington, D. C.

20006 Philadelphia Electric Company 2301 Market Street Deputy Attorney General Philadelphia, Pennsylvania -

19101 Room 512, Main Capitol Building llarrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Karl Abraham Public Affairs Officer Mr. Robert W..Adler Region I, OIE Assistant' Attorney General.

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission;,

Bureau of Regulatory Counsel 631 Park Avenue 505 Executive llouse King of Prussia, PA 19806 P.' O. Box 2357 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Allan Kanner, Esq.

1622 Locust Street Honorable Lawrence Coughlin Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 s

llouse of Representatives Congress of the United States

-Ms. Phyllis Zitzer Washington, D. C.

20515 Limerick Ecology Action P. O. Box 761

. Roger B. Reynolds, Jr., Esq.

Pottstown, Pennsylvania 19464 324 Swede Street Norristown, Pennsylvania 19401 Lawrence Sager Esq.

Sager & Sager Associates 45 High Street Pottstown, Pennsylvania 19464 Joseph A. Smyth Assistant County Solicitor County-of Montgomery Courthouse Norristown, Pennsylvania 19404 Eugene J. Bradley Philadelphia Electric Company

-Associate General Counsel 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Mr. Jacque Durr Resident Reactor. Inspector U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 47 Sanatoga, Pennsylvania 19464 i

gev;nu--3 y

?-

x F

g

.4 *.

MEETING

SUMMARY

DISTRIBUTION JUN 3 0 1981 -

T..Speis.

W. Johnston

_4 cal:PDR-J. Stolz e

-NSIC.

S. Hanauer-

- TERA W. Gammill-TIC--

T. ' Mu rl ey.

LB#2 File F. Schroeder H. Denton D. Skovholt E. Case. _

O Mp,g M. Ernst

10. Eisenhut-Vg R. Baer R. Purple:

E g\\

C. Berlinger-B. J. Youngbloo '

K. Kniel

.D)$[@y

'A.'Schwencer f

pU G. Knighton c

F. Miraglia A. Thadani 4

- (b( 3*,,#p'o#

E. Adensam D. Tondi-G. Lainas

/f' J. Kramer R. Vollmer VA.

D. Vassallo J. P. Knight..

4 / _

P. Collins R. Bosnak D. Ziemann F. Schauer.

R. E. Jackson

.NRC

Participants:

Project Manager G. D. - Calkins Attorney, OELD R. E Lipinski A. K. Ibrahim M. Service

-C. Woodhead R. B. N Mullen R. Tedesco' G. Lear' J. R. Pearring S. Pawlicki V. Benaroya Z. Rosztoczy bec:

Applicant W. Haass Service List D. Nuller R. Ballard W. Regan R. Mattson P. Check

0. Parr F. Rosa W. Butler

-W. Kreger 1

r-R. Ho'uston T. Murphy L. Rubenstein f'

.--l.