ML20009B103
| ML20009B103 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/29/1981 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8107140790 | |
| Download: ML20009B103 (9) | |
Text
v
-a l(}
(l
((
(h( (h(h(h{ L (f (h(h(h(f((h[h(fthhh(h(((([h(h[kf(f 5.
h TRANSMITTAL TO:
M Document Control Desk, 016 Phillips p
5 e
ADVANCED COPY TO:
O The Public Document Room h
cj=.-
DATE:
June 30, 1981 h
m P
Attached are the PDR copies of a Commission meeting P
transcript /s/ and related meeting document /s/.
They are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession "p
List and placement in the Public Document noom.
No l5 >
other distribution is requested or required.
Existing P
DCS identification numbers are listed on the individual documents wherever possible.
J 1.
Transcript of:
General Administrative Meeting, June 29, 1981.
(1 copy) l,_Off1 se 1 rown of the Secretary p
i par 7=noS2o
1 ec PT9.7 PDR Ah5ff}hl M
i J
ll 5
~
l
. n.. a -
,.,. e,.n.a.n. _.... wvm n.. m, n o...
~
ws,,.
.n.
n.
e.
l
,e.,
1
..: ~...,.
<~
a.,
c>
l l
-. NUCLEAR! REGULATORY COMMISSION 7
.(
w..
m..
D l
J, m
l 4
1 -
s i
w
,i i
i I
COMMISSION MEETING
.I a
I In *de Mat::s cf:
PUBLIC MEETING
?
~
I.
I GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE MEETING i
(
.\\
l l
1 1
I DATE.
June 29, 1981 pAczg:
1-8 AT:
Washincton, D.
C.
P M
4
.e I
/
',9' b
1 s
1 e
~
II 4
t
, m a.
4 s
c e
,, q e.
.y.
s -,s e. 33.% y.,, u;. c..
,m
~,[:"
+.2 f. ? ' $.b.4LD.+R..v.~%,i -
- 3.. REPORTING,., :.i...,.
f
,.}
n
-./.
.... 4
. n.
...an, u
..,... ~,,
.w
.,...,e e
a.
.x
..a. -
.u.......
... w.,.
n, y p
> m, u....mey 24p.y9, :. y :. n m,, :q..
w 7 l-g.
g, a u
-,y L1 p.y, c 7
- y;-
m b L.!,' ' '.9ll3.7. F.'40 0ivi$gisiifAie. i ~ 5.W. Washi..gi==,- D. C. ;20 0 2 4 ;;,
.n...
.r
. s.y J.+
- v
=,$--
l
._ g ~j.
'g-
. slt..
.s A
,4 n.g
- s. e,&
.4:. g,.:7 7.WM. -?'iTalachc=e : '(202) 534-2345 ',
mt.-
f M. -
4-
=Geb,
- e,moqd f d..:. nn. m_.,...,.
s.
.~,
,,sn.... m e.+4
.. s..
~. -. -.. -
.... +
.m' 1
u.e., [.,. %* ~",T et v.g*#,,,
3
,.: ?, ( 7 M-4 4','l ) $ *, t7;h.j 4. '.,,
.s i
J z.
.y 4
[le -
. w#"-.i
^
N.g,# I #...'!. [4}f4*(( Q ekjT, y f. g*'*"
mg k. #9, c_ _
, is Iag7[h f4- )l 5
y j h.Y,*.*j
^4 r
a 3
s
.+
n.
94sh.
m.
f* u.
.- i*
3 5.
yg g g e$t
. 'I. u -
,,*hi J t' * *,' ' ' -
.g
- 9%
4 5
)
- h N
..e(*
g g'
[ b *g _ 'k',. i,*M %,e [-b * * * 'M j. '?. s. f' ",.
='#.4 3 "", ~; k$.I
,8.JE. s k",h ** * $
=)
.4 4..
s
, ~.. %
- g5 w y ' v.,.
4 a '
=V
)
s-
- -, *i
- 1 /,9, s=
', f h4, - ; s f S'.a 9'M '$
- fb"[7
~,f f
I,,
[
s
, ~ #;,,, O E
.e,,.-
-a.o. $ &g.
<.s s
.w* > U
. u.,
. 37' ~ u.k s t 'W'I rfs'n..,,,.....k \\ 4 % 'u.'.M;*f B '?.
f S A~
. +k%.Ol4
'Mi k. + 4. ) " --
rf,g 'G' ' + l ~ *.,..
O. '.i Wr**Mf *M W'r *. l~*
4
.se-' 'l.
n
~ * * '
a.
,.. A s1 e M.* h s.*,+*i're %*A*,d '.t P
~
'?*
4 k, % w - - -. -
mm mmm m _, m m u.._ _
,a
v, 1
1 l
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
~
3 4
5 GENERAL ADMINISTRAhIVE MEETING 6
7 8
PUBLIC MEETING 9
10 Nuclear Regula tory Commission 11 Room 1130 12 1717 H Street, N.
W.
Washington, D.
C.
13 Monday, June 29, 1981 14 15 The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 16 2 : 20 p.m.
17 PRESENT4 18 JOSEPH M. HENDRIE, Chairman of the Commission 19 VICTOR GILINSKY, Commissioner PETER A.
BRADFORD, Commissioner 20 ALSO PRESENTS 21 S. CHILD 22 L. BICKWIT M. MALSCH 23 D. RATHBUN
- f. -
V. HARDING 24 J. FOUCHARD 25 ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC,
1 3
i y y 1 -,,-,
'd_.s ts a= u=c.dti a 2 5 P=a,.~ g-ta=
- s. c "' as4- ' s-s =- e - aa,, >: 2:sc-gp: e a,2,, 3 g,j g,,,7ei_,,
s_
za r,.u = =7 c.___,st== se u.=
3,.y,
- &n Cw
-d=4 sola17 f=r gn=arsi < e :=a:<.e=21
~
e E,*~r'8 *8-h 9T:P dad.by 10 C22. 9.103, i: 's :== pa:
of da
,c::a_ er i=d--=1 rucard of decis1:= ci de -.2: 3:3 13 -,3,s.
- .: grass 1=r.s et c?i:ic: 1: - " ' '
f"=al data -d_=a:1 =3 or haliefs.=s:sc:1:e de ::= cacassarily
- C No pleading er a:h--
Paper =ar be. filad..-1:h de C~usie= i= any :
ese of cr add:assed :c a=7 sta:a==== c a:h__a= ss 7as [2.~
ras g*:'
c= ca
- z:=9e as ce c-.__ ssiet. =s.7 au:3c:.
a.
/
G 4
g e
G e
S e
9 L
6 g.
+
a 8
1
- - - ' - ' - * * ' ' " - - ' ' ' ' ' ' ~1
2 (5.
1 EB9CEED1ES2 2
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE Now, there were a couple of 3 matters that I think it would be useful for us to look at 4 and see if by any chance we can sort them out.
Maybe we can 5 and maybe we can't.
6 In order to go forward with that discussion 1 will 7 ask you to join me in voting to hold a meeting on less than 8 one-week 's notice, a meeting which is titled a General 9 Administrative Meeting and at which I would hope to consider 10 in sequence the notes back and forth on a model hearing 11 schedule, that matter of incident response procedures and 12 finally I have got a letter I am trying to get out on the 13 Byron schedule.
- 4 So if you will join me in voting for this meeting 15 on short notice we can get on with it.
Those in favor?
17 (Chorus of Ayes.)
18 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE So orde red.
19 Peter, did you ever have a chance to scan through 20 that memo?
I haven't seen anything back.
21 COMMISSIONER BR ADFORD:
This is the one on the 22 hearing schedules?
23 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Yes.
Q..a 24 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
I would pref er to strike 25 the first and last paragraphs and just send the middle three.
ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY. INC,
uM i
3
[:
1 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
This was a draft I guess Peter 2 and I drafted on it.
Why don't we said a couple across the 3 table.
I am sorry the people in the audience won't have
~
4 it.
You can simply regard yoursel' =.: as reviewing what 5 would in more normal circumstances, be a set of internal 6 discussions between Commissioners taken two at a time rather e
7 than altogether at the table.
8 It needs some sort of an introduction.
We need a t 9 least a first sentence in the first paragra ph to sort of get 10 sta rted on it.
11 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Okay.
12 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
I would be inclined to take the 13 second as well and then strike the last one.
14 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
That is all right.
- Yes, 15 tha t is fine.
16 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Okay.
So in this thing we 17 would strike the last sentence of the first paragraph, the 18 n ex t three and then strike the last one.
19 How does that strike you?
20 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
You have the next three 21 paragraphs in, right?
22 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Yes.
23 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
And then strike the last
(;;
24 one.
25 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Yes.
h ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC,
r ~
li. _
4 1
COMMISSIONER BRADFORD4 That is right.
2 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs Okay.
If that is agreeable to 3 you why don't we vote Aye on that draft and I will give it 4 to the Secretary since its a Chilkogram.
5 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD Good.
6 (Chorus of Ayes.)
7 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
All righ t, Sam, we give you 8 that and I am not pleased to be able to junk that set of 9 papers.
We are making splendid progress here.
to The next item has to do with the incident response 11 plan and goes back to a memorandum John sent us back in 12 April recommending some language to go in the response plan 13 making clear the licensee's responsibility and putting in 14 somewhat clearer terms what we would do and would not do.
15 Now, I marked up his draft.
I tended to mark up 18 the backend of it.
Peter then had some markups and he 17 tended to mark up the frontend of it.
18 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD4 Yes.
I think our only 19 point of difference was over the business about even if the 20 act violates the NRC tech specs.
21 What I thought might suffice for me would just be 22 to strike that language entirely.
That is leave out my 23 various sta tements about not being able to guarantee 24 anything but also take out the phrase "even if that action 25 violates the NRC license technical specifications" from your g.y,
Lh. '
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC,
y 5
1and John 's previous circula tion.
2 It just doesn't seem to me to be right, for 3 example, if you had a situation in which the licensee 4 released a substantial quantity of radioactive material.
5 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs If he had to violate the 6 license condition because he felt it was necessary for 7 saf ety in the accident circumstance.
8 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD Right.
The fact is that 9 one certainly would ta k e that into consideration in deciding 10 what subsequent enforcement action is necessary, but there 11 may be situa tions in which even the mitigative action were 12 so severe from a public health point of view that it would 13 lead to a later enforcement action.
14 I can't think of all the possible contexts now so ISI would be happier taking out the language that appeared to 16 exonerate it in all Situations.
17 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs Okay.
Let's see, that would 18 leave the response plan, that paragraph 211.
Let's scan 19 through it and see how it would then read.
20 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD Just as you had it in your 21 version of June 8th only without the words beginning with 22 "even if" and ending with " technical specifications."
23 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs Okay.
You also wanted to
([
24 strike "or adverse publicity" up there.
25 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Oh, yes.
That is right.
h ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY,INC, J
==xw_
6 b.:"'
1 I am sorry.
I thought that had gotten done.
But you are 2 right, it hadn't.
3 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Yes.
That would also then 4 remove the insert.
5 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Yes.
6 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
I guess I hesitate to go 7 f orward with it, Peter, because John was anxious to make the 8 point that if you have to breach the license conditions in 9 some way in the interest of saf ety, you know, do it.
I 10 guess I am inclined to think, since he isn't here to defend i
11 it and carry it on, that maybe we ought not to make a 12 decision now and discussion ought to resune when he comes 13 back and can deal with it himself.
14 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
That is okay if it is okay 15 with you.
16 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
You didn't have great objection 17 to the comments I made on his draf t or on the draft 18 Chilkogram and I would hope you would continue to take those 191nto account when you do settle down sort the points out.
I 20 think this was for him a fairly significa nt part of the 21 approved guidance he was trying to provide and he ought to 22 be here to settle it out with you.
23 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Okay.
Now, let's see.
k5; There was a letter that has been kicking around for some 24 25 time.,
This was in response to a March 27th incoming letter ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC,
u a-7 1 commenting on our nominal schedule on the Byron Station and 2 I had some problems with it as finally rodrafted.
3 Peter, I think you had no objection to my redraft.
4 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
No, that is right.
5 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
John sent along a note that he 6 is not fond of, the changes and would like a sentence to go 7 in at the appropriate point saying that he thinks the 8 current schedule is too optimistic and so on which I would 9 propose simply to put in at the correct place and then get 10 the blasted letter out so that Dean Palladino doesn't find 11 him answering letters from March, although I certainly 12 wouldn ' t guarantee this is the only one that lies that far 13 back.
14 If that is okay with yoo, why let's us de that.
15 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
That is okay.
Why don't 16 ve just leave it to you to work it out.
17 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Well, I will stick it in some 18 place.
19 MS. HARDING:
John'is pretty flexible.
20 CHAIRMAN HENDRIEs Good.
21 Now, that takes me through the three items that I 22 wanted to bring up.
Was there anything else that occurred 23 to anybody else that this kind of a discussion would help?
24 (No response.)
25 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
All right.
In that case I find (4%
=-
1 ALDERSON REPORTING CGMPANY,INC,
6 1 ve have concluded 15 minutes ahead of time.
I am pleased to 2 note the public sessions this af ternoon.
3 The Commission vill move on after a one-minute 4 recess to continue its discussion on an operating license l
5 for McGuire.
So I will pause here and ask those who should 6 not be present.at a closed meeting of the Commission to 7 kindly absent themselves.
8 (Whereupon, at 2430 p.m.,
the general 9 administrative meeting concluded.)
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 (Ei 24 25
{!
-a c
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC, 400 VIRGINIA AVE, S.W., WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554 2345
- iUCLEAR REGULATORY CO!" MISSION This is tc certify that the attachec proceedings bef:re the cot @!ISSION MEETING in the ::tattar ef:
Public Meeting - General Administrative Meeting
" Cate of Proceecing:
June 29, 1901 Decket !! umber:
Place of PPCeeeding:
Washington, D.
C, wore held as herein appears, anc that this is the Original transcript thereof for the file of the Ccc=issi:n.,
Mary C.
Simons.
Official Reporter (Typec)
Wri I
Official Reporter (Signature)
I l
9 O