ML20008E252
| ML20008E252 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/16/1980 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 SECY-A-80-108, NUDOCS 8010240462 | |
| Download: ML20008E252 (5) | |
Text
1.r +
1 Issu i s'i j 4
.-*ORL. -
MSTON..T.
j MMyhgg hl i yl f g
..ir,g
- s&;;
..g-c.-t y
... p#;.s}.eh,y*
l r
-y, wmM w >- t M %l. *m 1?%g4nWMce..?iQN8h&Q.F i.s 3
4.{29 p h J W,. J..", -) h.M-A.~hy4 #a.,A
- M, g.. %. S. C Mr kp 9 N,9cM M
^
t.
t.e $ a g w y o..
m
- _.. g sn g.
q c.u w r, j, W M pt @ q p.e~w%T -,. - r
~:m vvQ., OM0;y y:< TrW A%4.m
- c. w.Q.5
- M m,
W h
4 w
>q 1
m.m w%xn pep p
mm.?:g-
- m:;. w%pr M
/
a w
y^ g.a e
v.my%
w
~
- h'C?"_W.,0. -Q M $ w@ &a;+x~.- -
m kt%
n m%;
&m 1
s
.a.
if WM
- O%
?Mnw.%s eN.Z.
J 9
- v..
bi@tn..y
~W r
1
. % m m~~ w sa~.- w ew-n % m,..
f.
Mw:;*;mm. '. peua wMmL.y
%*t
',,gd r%s
%ub 9 b 7 m. d..
",l?,k w. @l
. m. 9
@if*/-et<
!._r "P
4 g.. m u ty*N,;A.'*.. m ~. y..
- . p Am,,
r x
- ~,
4
- 'W l M@. #) a.5.
w 4 %.%-e,-u..s?.g.A AWh:.m.WP. +W',E4 %,
4'.4.
m
@4 $.-
.m.._va.
.w.e u..g.x.
$3 t
IRM. A. T,#.I,ON.c?SES.SI. O,N.>.80~-4 5 ?>
W N,o. m. E. w %. +.,,
M % sy* %~.. h, %,..%..a..,s m. %.
M*u~
.t.
w o,
q, a
~,z &p 9.y.y &, a,,L y g,. 4.,u.; W,,s p+ w. Q c,;2 x M %
a
> r.%.;.r.pw,*
L, {3..
W vC L
+M
.s I, -
%~,. t G*,R 3
nr w.....
z*.
^*t
- tm,,m
.X e
' s"a-yes.,,.
..y p
..u
- M,. q.,w,.>q,,w.g,,_C,'.
y mM R Wi&W<$2Y..M*..a,.,2..,2 ';.J;*-s %,,,.. #
W9
~
.W;+p3WN "
,p m ~. '
g*d
.Lp W:y ky 8,, J., e 2RW.,Z$ps g
(G:??$8
- $%nll y% m.
& g.
2<
NV #::@X,&W%# WiiW V
.wuQ s'mS Mg:. 2 &p%h,.n.:-.en' 2.:.;.p.w. 1:p,.m%M :' 8:. f.m
.+.nw n%
2b~ k.h.; wen.;. x..
-M -
n m..
u
.V7'w:t p n.h M.yMb &pc M.q..
.m a m W
.nt n
.;n S 3 ac,wpW-cw M W W-1 n
M Cu a:m.Q.,.w,g.%'.'M.e.M,4,h,w'Q s,,. v.c. T.%w.w.:gy&y., q;Q-y :.f. 3.~
. p.w:.- p W
g %u W <N q' %4.'et'..
j l3G;&Wgw NgM.$, w..g'
~ gs%,._,,. r.n.hi
_L.s.. v...?,.., #, t,4.;.
1.:-. 9 v
+-, y.;. a.ae x.
r,o.y.
- r. g.D
. m.q us..
.. w w. e;ar m x*
zg g
w.y s.p.,y.
. f W,,g,.
a
...y;
- r w.,y.my w._
y.y..,
,. m g._,
v i
i
> m. j' %,Jpnum. y.,,u, 7 7.w,.u
, o
- g,pg,w.q.s.,. gsg.;, y i
. y : <q.e.,' 7 '
c_
,.,~.,,-.w a
e s..
~..
n-
-; i
. y ni-ns,-m;~.;.u..m m.mun.w.-
y g^ &n>:;W..:n y d t~y.~. w g.7:
... ~.,
Mymuy;m@y?p.gog;.9 nww-p.
.. m. yo m
.w
..1 %.;,:.w.<.y m y
- c.. u w.: a,.;. m ; y;; m w }g,gg y 4,
e.,. s' q y &g. x.xQ; p ty.g g g,: m.p.rm..g.y..;.y 3:,c.;~;. y u ~.. m,.
g 3
9g.
g p
r.
m n
u p9 8 0 n s,.
@CQ >.:y n
m F M.,,@x.
j.DAT nggc erm n;
PAGES:1 thru 3 M V 92 ~
W 4
.~
. 41pg.Wy;.:
g y
y,
)W FA,;
' AT:N
. ;,,. ~~, W~ ~. 86 V.,
...'. s f':t e 4 :
w c. _; s u
s.-
'. M,g y*;i-* ; w f**-h;.
- + ami ". W,*
- s PMm. _< ), ;.. y :m.
s
.,.~'y...,..y.
o
's6 ~.;* p M.F.9.Op. N.ttp a.d.M e c.1...'-
~
- 5-e-WW:wr %,yy? ; *- g :.a y
- +
+
+
. - ; s.w(;eg,
. ~ n p wa.
., my,2
,7
.z.;,
' % Q,g,,7 _ ; -.
' '.+
a.f %;. "cs '.,p yw. y; T;'; w
,es;p.y....-
7; v
..'..E
- .avi m y
.,. ~.-:.
yw <
u.m-fYQ of*l
..r
-+c C.3g:.,, ~ 2 g p,3 L ;,;,~; '
' 1;.
,>y
- i. W
'j
. 'i'.
.f, a n
~~
- y,5*[':Y',
.? '
' 7&
I 3r ;,,A y., e _,,
. f.. L.,a.m,
,_.'N.*.,-.--~:
+
,. ~ q w:
-.?J,*i'....* 3. :/ -
(p 7
.t
)
s g
^.-
- 3,.h p Gm
.m '.., '.
p.?.
. T.t; } 9 - > -
f y ry - x -
s, m <
,, Jc C;;;
?tM.
> w g~ ;- W :, '.
y'. & m.,.:.4'+.p., w. m,.; b. y:,. y.,m'c..,.,
c
- x.ca s
.~
%.4,r:.:--Q'-
u : a.. 411 y.. e.J -
..n a..
..r.
..m s G W s ; s ' u
. r; ',
r:.
- ,. r
'y m, --
..-m a
$ok h;',rf, k U,
... '. h,
.. h :l 5 (.h. y;a. f,p wmm$+h&. n n&. w.k..,.,p$*$') gh f-h5.
k.
?.....
.Y.',
, ' (L. a ; ) % **
. m.w-
~
.n
..u.-...~
55AfthY,y
- ,; a.
w n lhh.Dm m m a?(n M c$M w:
w smlb b i~M @$ n$ w@ @2%n.w.n ?@.q N M N ! M C.~$ m w.h k.'W h x'lY ky'Y h
e m
3 M3~frM..m b.gh w
.e vv
.v,.
~
. w.g ST y$m,.
mm yu, g.s yv e
e p.
$ h&f. m;, knm$aBha.g+aizels*"MC'W$
v fv%~Y.m&Nmus?h.ffnf$5,
,2 m$$hb l.
?
&r we k
er M,.wm+RdWW.
- b*
~ yw
.e wv mm.
m c
WTT WM y M.w$.+g$._$$.Q::$$p@rlD M T M 7j{6ctibefleRE
~MhWM, s
.n_~.a.cmm n< ~ e& -&MWs}.@m+w. %n..n.A.t..n.. L. L,,,
- n. +. a., p :
~
a g ~<;yf,a m.. n. yCssnhu %s ; ?
.n.
? + *o,<. '- =a.p., [.v. a.r.:%.yW.v~.a, vy. s
,v.
w..,
s w..
-. y m x.e
,i n t @4. s. M w w y n
R
- ng
+
v.
M uWme -
a f.naSan n yve 7
w m y e ~w% wc;d;w H:aynm.rw n%.3 x sm w
sut.
cum-s.v. g n w a%sw%. 5%._Ap.m 400?m ;;r <.er, u&wp..m: ;.~w.v.gr+ e. -
.Ep m w
A-
.~
en g mw+
7 hJ' 6. E W W W M. w,.
wn a
Ave W m,cp:::n 4DvCW20024 i Mw A
'~
1%
% 9. %.)
l 7 M NC # N M?tS @M,G M~b @ _[Ta_a W.4'dOTd'*W _p M_
WBM.?
M_ew b**a' hf*flm myi8tWM'ME M D ~.d.#'h*T't'[.pr4*N @
D
=. W 2 0'2 M n;*j.4-2345 W p.wi W desty y M
- "'2N
- A'D'M e mm.emeg?W@n%pgWWMg,waw c.mmmg%m*p:W; gg!
M c
f R:
n
.ms.mm.3,_j. mss e
w~m.w. n e m..,., g. g -u
+
n 3,gge,sy.,gg y..
,w +.w ss g ygg.p.
- g..ggWhAMMNEW3Ml
- 8 010 ') 4 0WFWMMM ~ 7 am.megg%r, w
_w we.-w.%w,..A.9w%w. - m wwwe er
4 1
NRC I
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 1Q$6 dip r&t 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COliMISSION 3
!!h.
- E=
4 3
AFFIRMATION ~ SESSION 80 - 45 5
6 R
7 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Room 1130 "l
8
-1717 H Street, N. W.
9' 9
Washington, D. C.
20555 mio October 16, 1980
$ -10 z
The above-entitled matter came on for hearing, pursui.it g
11 to vote to hold a short notice meeting, at 11:37 a.m.
c 12 E
C BEFORE,:
_=_
E, 13 ms r.-
JOHN F. AHEARNE, Chairman g
14 w
15 JOSEPH HENDRIE, Commissioner 16 g
PETER BRADFORD, Commissioner d
17
- s 5
STAFF PRESENT:
en 18
=
SAMUEL J. CHILK, Secretary 19 8n 20 21 I
gg 22
==-
23!
..w_
24 E=-
25l l
l ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC.
2 1
_P _R _O _C _E _E _D _I _N _G _S 5.=55.3 2
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
The Commission now moves to an 3
affirmation session.
Anyone who wants to carry on conversations, 5E.
~#
4 would you mind moving outside to carry on the conversation.
g 5
MR. CHILK:
We need a couple of short notice votes.
E{
6 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
We need a short notice vote for 7
the affirmation session vote on SECY-A-80-108, Indian Point X
8 8
seismic action.
dd 9
I would like agreement to vote to hold that on icg 10 less than one week's notice.
E g
11 All in favor, say aye.
S y
12 (Chorus of ayes) h Ei E=
13 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
And then we will also move on to 14 a discussion and vote on A-80-73B, which is the order on E
15 psychological stress.
Well,,,that is a separate issue.
So don't 5
y 16 vote on that yet.
'A g
17 All right.
5 E
18 MR. CHILK:
Okay, the first item we have on the list 5"
19 I would like to defer on.
It is a revision to fracture toughness.
k 20 It is not ready.
It should be ready next week.
I I i 21 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
All right.
l 22 MR. CHILK:
The second one is A-80-148, motion of g.
23,
North Coast Intervenor.
The Commission has unanimously a
- j5) 24 approved the order which transfers the motion, a motion that the 25l North Coast Construction Permit Application be dismissed with i
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
3 1
prejudice to the licensing board for decision.
2 Please affirm your votes.
3 (Chorus of ayes) dh RF 4
MR. CHILK:
The next one is SECY-A-80-108, which is g
5 the review of ALAB-436 and 561, the matter of Consdidated 8
j 6
Edison and the Power Authority of the State of New York.
R R
7 The Commission here is divided on whether to grant K]
8 the petition of the New York State Energy Office and the dd 9
Citizen's Committee for Protection of the Environment to review
!'10 two decisions of the Licensing Appeal Board concerning seismic E
5 11 matters.
j 12 Chairman Ahearne and Commission Hendrie voted to deny 5
==
45 13 the petition.
Commission Gilinsky voted to extend the time for g
j 14 review to allow the Commission to consider the same issue in E
15 Seabrook, and Commission Bradford voted to grant the petitions.
s j
16 Since a majority of the Commission does not favor e
p 17 granting the petitions,
- hey are denied.
The Commission also 5
18 denied a motion by the New York State Energy Commission and the 5"
19 Citizeds Commission for Protection of the Environment to strike R
20 portions of the staff's answers to the petition.
21 Would you please affirm your votes.
th) 22 (Chorus of ayes) 23 (Thereupon, at 11:38 a.m.,
the hearing in the above-24 entitled matter was adjourned.)
.gg 25f b
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
MUCLEAR REGULATORY CNC!ISSION
~his is Oc certify -hat the a tachec proceedir.gs befcre the t -
in th e :n a t t e."
c f :
AFFIRMATION SESSION 80-45 Oate of Frecceding: October 16, 1980 Dccket Ilu='cer:
Place of ?receeding:
Washington, D.
C.
- 'e.a =. ".. e.i d.
'.a. e.* *. d.a.
-e 4 - - a. C *.e,
2.e..
.'a..=..
.."..'.e
.'.e
..".a.
..dg..a..=..'
-d
- - = - - - - d --
M dw 7y w
.&..w.
7
- e. e w e e..**.# m.p
. h. e
- 4.* a.
c*..W. a.
- * * * ' 3 3.' s- *..
w www..
David S.
Parker e r.r.a. a : -
.c.a.. c (. a
(..y., s..r y
.s
.y.
'a 1
l.J u
t.: - s. r ~.. =. =.
- e., v.
.= v.. e......,,,
n
.4 4%
=e E~Y.
6 n
--